Smithtown Town Board Regular Meeting - February 19, 2026
Smithtown Town Board Regular Meeting - February 19, 2026
The Smithtown Town Board held a regular meeting on Thursday, February 19, 2026, at 2:00 PM in the Victor T. Liss Board Room. The board heard a public hearing and unanimously adopted Local Law #1-2026 implementing four state-mandated tax exemptions for seniors, disabled veterans, active duty service members, and surviving spouses of police officers killed in the line of duty. The board also approved numerous administrative items, site plans, personnel actions, and a $2,100,000 bond for drainage improvements.
Consent Calendar
- Approved meeting minutes from February 3, 2026.
- Approved eight comptroller transfers (e.g., $850 for plant maintenance to dues, $3,500 for hazardous waste disposal to striping, $379,527.68 for capital vehicle leases, etc.).
- Approved five resolutions including training for the town assessor ($120), disposal of computers/phones, auction of Western V Plows, and training for two School Age Department employees ($400 and $85, respectively).
Public Comments & Testimony
- Public Hearing on Local Law #1-2026 (Tax Exemptions):
- Klas Johnsson (106 Fulton Boulevard): Expressed concern that the law requires a 100% service-connected disability rating, while he is rated 90% but paid at 100% due to individual unemployability (IU). He argued that New York State should include IU in the 100% rating, as done in Cape May County, New Jersey. Recommended contacting state representatives to amend the law.
- Greg Cibernhardt (12 Tall Tree Lane, Smithtown): Supported the 100% disabled veterans exemption, noting few Smithtown veterans currently qualify but more may develop disabilities (e.g., from burn pits) in the future. Urged the board to pass the bill.
- Brian Pacella (4 Fireplace Drive, Kings Park): Stated he is 100% disabled, served in Iraq, and asked the board to honor the sacrifice of combat veterans by passing the tax exemption.
- Jeanette Walsh (1 Mars Court, Smithtown): Expressed respect for eligible groups but voiced concern about the financial burden shifted to non-exempt homeowners. Requested a transparent breakdown of the estimated tax impact on ineligible residents and urged income-based criteria for relief.
- Anita Castorina (3 Spruce Street, Smithtown): Attempted to speak about general taxes but was redirected; her comments were taken during the public portion later.
- Public Portion (after agenda):
- Anita Castorina: Criticized the board for raising taxes by 10% and piercing the 2% cap, new hires (including a Public Information Assistant), and spending $500,000 on the Senior Center. Suggested posting meeting dates on a sign outside the municipal building.
- Elizabeth Mafe (16 Old Road, Kings Park): Objected to overdevelopment, citing traffic and potholes. Alleges the board slipped through a 288-unit planned residential development without proper notice or a promised meeting with council members.
Discussion Items
- Public Hearing and Adoption of Local Law #1-2026:
- Presented by Assistant Town Attorney Rachel Lenberger. The law creates four new articles in Chapter 256 (Taxation):
- Senior Citizens (Age 65+): Up to 65% reduction in assessed value for town taxes, based on income limits.
- Fully Disabled Veterans: 100% exemption from town property taxes and special district charges for veterans with a 100% service-connected disability who are individually unemployable.
- Active Duty Service Members: Up to 25% exemption (capped at $20,000 assessed value) for those deployed to a combat zone in the taxable year, with permanent duty station in New York State. Must reapply annually.
- Surviving Spouses of Police Officers Killed in Line of Duty: 50% exemption on primary residence.
- The board heard testimony (see above), then closed the hearing and voted unanimously to adopt the law.
- Presented by Assistant Town Attorney Rachel Lenberger. The law creates four new articles in Chapter 256 (Taxation):
- Site Plan Reviews (presented by Liam Trotta, Planning Department):
- Mason Technologies (25-15): New 89,320 sq. ft. two-story warehouse/office building on Oser Avenue, Hauppauge, replacing a previously approved larger building. Five conditions of approval.
- Insignia Steakhouse (25-20): 3,308 sq. ft. of additions including a solarium, freezer, and enclosed walkway at the NE corner of Route 347 and Mount Pleasant Road. Four conditions of approval.
- Both received SEQRA Negative Declarations (no EIS required).
- Advertise for Public Hearings (three items):
- March 3, 2026: Amendments to Chapter 101 (Parks, Buildings and Grounds) regarding parking permit registrations.
- March 19, 2026: Local Law #4-2026 (Traffic Code §TC 4-2) parking permit registrations.
- March 19, 2026: Local Law #5-2026 (Traffic Code §TC5-1) truck exclusions.
- Bids and RFP Awards:
- Bid #26-016 (Black Polyethylene Bags) – to be opened March 12, 2026.
- Bid #26-018 (Bamboo Removal and Drainage Improvements at Oakside Drive) – to be opened March 26, 2026; pre-bid walkthrough March 11.
- RFP #26-003 (Parking Violation Software) awarded to Fundamental Business Service, Inc.
- Bond: $2,100,000 for drainage improvements to the town parking lot north of Main Street between Bank and Landing Avenues (40-year term).
- Other Approvals:
- Rescinded Resolution 2025-1243.
- Reappointed Kenneth G. Dolan to Board of Assessment.
- Authorized permit applications for drainage repair on Gardiner Road and wildlife monitoring at Hunts Pond.
- Extended multiple bids and agreements (road marking materials, steel stock, fuel, recyclable processing, bearings, athletic field clay, etc.).
- Approved change orders for Short Beach exterior alterations.
- Appointing Robert E. Draffin as hearing officer for disciplinary charges against Employee #005130 (suspended without pay up to 30 days).
- Approved modifications to Marine Law Permits for maintenance dredging at Stony Brook Harbor (extension to Feb. 28, 2026) and Nissequogue River (extension to March 22, 2026).
- Issued four Local Waterfront Revitalization Plan consistency determinations.
- Authorized grant application for Burrwinkle Park Renovation, voluntary transfer of leave time to a Parks employee, and software use agreement for Over 65/Disability Limited Income Calculator with other townships.
- Approved two legal settlements: Laura Buonaiuto v. Town ($3,329.63) and William Arteca v. Town ($10,000.00).
- Personnel Actions (21 items A–U):
- New hires, promotions (e.g., Jonathan Giuglianotti to Labor Crew Leader II at $53.58/hr), status changes, medical leaves, terminations, and stipulation of settlement agreements for two employees.
Key Outcomes
- Closed the public hearing and unanimously adopted Local Law #1-2026 (Tax Exemptions).
- SEQRA Negative Declarations issued for Mason Technologies and Insignia Steakhouse.
- Site plans conditionally approved for both projects.
- Authorized advertising for three public hearings on parking and truck exclusions (March 3 and 19, 2026).
- Approved $2,100,000 bond for drainage improvements.
- Awarded bid extensions and RFP as noted.
- Approved all personnel actions including a disciplinary suspension and hearing officer appointment.
- Honored Parks employees Bob Zidane and Jake Barrett for assisting a resident during the February 2 snowstorm.
- Public comments heard on tax concerns, development, and town finances.
Meeting Transcript
Roll call. Supervisor Wellhard. Here, Councilman McCarthy. Councilwoman Noah. Councilwoman and Zoroah. Councilman Loman. Okay, before we begin the board meeting today. We have uh some parks department employees here. Um we're going to recognize their public service. Once a month we begin a town board meeting by honoring an employee whose dedication, talent, and character have made a meaningful impact on the community. Today it is my privilege to recognize Smithtown Parks Department groundskeeper Bob Zidane and laborer Jake Barrett. On February 2nd, during a severe winter weather snowstorm. An older resident fell near the street and was unable to get up. While his wife was unable to assist him, fortunately, a parks department vehicle observed the situation and immediately pulled over without hesitation. Bob Zidane and Jake Barrett sprang into action, assisting the gentleman to his feet and ensuring he returned safely to his home. Mr. Zidane, Groundskeeper 2, who has proudly served since 2010, and Mr. Barrett, a laborer, who joined the town in 2023. Both work under the supervision of Marcel Calais, town maintenance crew leader, caring for the grounds at all of the town facilities with dedication and pride. Their quick response and willingness to help a resident in need reflect the same care and commitment they bring to their daily responsibilities. Their actions exemplify professionalism, teamwork, and a genuine concern for the well-being of our community on behalf of the town board and the entire Smithtown community. Thank you for being a shining example of what public service is all about. Gentlemen, congratulations. Great work and uh and keep up the good work for us. Zedan. They might be clutching the backballs. You know what? We'll give it to them after the Jake Barrett. I don't see him. They might be in the role. We'll give him to them at the animal. Okay. Okay. Very good. Congratulations to both of those gentlemen. Thanks for beginning. If I may, how many folks are here, which I believe there are quite a few, in regard to the tax exemptions that were passed by the state of New York? Almost the whole crowd. So let me explain what we're going to do before we start. On the agenda today, you'll see a public hearing, which will be presented by one of our town assistant town attorneys. She's going to explain the local law that we have to produce to make these exemptions eligible to you folks that are here and anybody else that is eligible for them. So our intention today, this board, is to hear the public hearing, close the hearing, and adopt the local laws, which gives everybody the right then to access to these tax exemptions if you're eligible. There is a deadline. So it has we have time for you folks to apply. Mr. DeCoto, our tax assessor will stay after the meeting for any questions or anything you have on how you proceed to do that. We have our attorneys here as well. And they can explain the procedures on how you go forth and get uh your your um requests in and make your applications before the deadline. And if there's any extensions, I think Mr. Ricordo will be able to help you with that.
openpublica.com