6:07Okay, glad to have you here.
6:09So if you would you can give us an overview of what you're presenting today.
6:14You want to say with the start, I'll just briefly say with the start of the new administration, we've taken a look at the API team, so it looks a little bit different than I then uh in terms of structure and org chart than it did last year.
6:30So we basically um have you know what is you know traditionally API um are folks that that are um working on process improvement and you know uh innovation um and so those folks are here and they're reflected here in the green.
6:53I am sitting at the table because you know there's been a leadership change with that team, so I'm here kind of in an interim basis.
6:59Um Jason is here to represent um data, the data team, and then Vinny, as you know, at the beginning of this year was named our chief um information officer, and so his portfolio includes digital services, which is part of the API team and IT, which comes next.
7:15So um so that's why I'm here, but I'm gonna toss it over to Vinny to and Jason to talk about um you know their teams, what they do it and what we're here to present for today.
7:27Uh so um just again introduction overview.
7:31Uh I think you'll see on the first handout with the York chart that uh we provided you.
7:37There's uh distinction between a couple different teams, there's different functions that each of them provide, but we all work in concert to execute on the uh you know shared mission of uh services or augmented services, I would say for our uh city departments uh uh naturally uh we interface both internally with uh different departments, every department, and then also uh externally with constituents in certain uh certain circumstances.
8:03So um the digital services team as uh the deputy mayor said uh works closely with these teams but also with the IT team uh which uh we'll be talking about in about a half hour.
8:14So um Jason, any overview from your team you want to go around?
8:18Uh no, I mean I think you all addressed it.
8:20Um I have a couple of questions.
8:26How many of your employees are on the Sura payroll?
8:29Certainly so if you flip over on the back side of that uh org chart, there's a copy from the budget book of the uh position details and they're color coded accordingly.
8:39So there's uh to answer your question directly.
8:41There's uh it shows five listings under Surah here.
8:46Um one of them is not highlighted because it doesn't necessarily sit directly in the API department, but is funded through a grant that is uh more or less uh overseen by the API department and uh works closely with the budget team.
9:01So um those are those positions there are going to be color coded and matching the org chart on the front that shows uh what teams they sit on.
9:08So everything except those two.
9:16Um the program manager that you see down there uh is the one that does not sit directly on the digital services team.
9:24And then I'm gonna ask you another question.
9:29Uh the director of innovation that you see on there uh has been moved to uh it's not highlighted because it's been moved to zero for this upcoming year, just given uh some of the structural changes that the deputy mayor alluded to.
9:43So the sort of funding is not in there.
9:45Uh not for a director of innovation, correct?
9:50So we're gonna go over the you talked about a direct of innovation.
10:00Your management analysis.
10:03Are you looking for one?
10:05Oh, the sorry, the positions uh there's management analysts, is that what you're referring to?
10:11Do you want to speak to that?
10:14So there's been an ongoing effort with um innovation to take a look at the positions that exist.
10:21And I know the previous um chief innovation officer was trying to determine whether or not the positions reflect the uh job responsibilities, you know, which have evolved over time, and so management analysts was one of the positions identified to add to the roster that uh we thought might better fit the needs for the team.
10:43But it would be you know, the intent would not be to bring on a new employee be an existing employee.
10:55Okay, so let me um ask this question data project manager, your data analysts.
11:02Those are vacant positions as of now, correct?
11:07So is that are the funded positions funded?
11:10They are in the budget.
11:11Um the data analyst role has been vacant for uh around a month now.
11:15Uh we had an individual move into a new role within the city.
11:18Um the data program manager role.
11:20Um we hired um we hired uh individual to fill one of those roles um a few months ago.
11:27So it's been an ongoing process to to fill roles.
11:30Um I think it was four or five months ago.
11:34But uh the other role is still vacant, yes.
11:37Okay, but it's funded.
11:39And the information system is coordinator as well.
11:41It's funded but vacant or already.
11:44Um yeah, one of those is currently filled.
11:48Uh there is uh a second one that is vacant that we're uh looking to fill as well.
11:52Will you fill it one?
11:57Councilor Montel, do you have any questions?
12:12No, no, you're fine.
12:13You have to morning.
12:16Blessings to everyone here.
12:17Good morning, and we're joined by counselor Caldwell.
12:21Um I was a few seconds a few minutes late, so I'm not sure.
12:28How many positions, Sarah, do you have?
12:30Yeah, on the uh back side of the org chart that you have there, there's a copy of the position details page from the budget.
12:36Uh you can see at the bottom the Surah positions uh that are funded through the API department.
12:42They're color coded uh according to the org chart on the front, so you can determine which team that they uh are on within the or which division and team within the API department that they are they are they're existing, these are all existing.
12:56So there's one new one though, right?
12:59From what I mean the it's on it has sorry, uh in 2526, you know, you can see that there was one position and it continues in 2627.
13:11So there haven't been the total number is was five last year and it's five this year, also.
13:16So there haven't been any added.
13:18So these all these positions were there all last year.
13:26Um I noticed two positions are being eliminated.
13:30Innovation project leader.
13:32So are those funds going into these new positions, chief innovation data official deputy chief?
13:39Are we switching funds limiting this position and creating these two positions?
13:45So the intention is to eliminate the innovation project leader and have those two employees move into positions that um more closely aligned with the work that they are doing now.
13:58Okay, now you have system analysts information.
14:01Are any of these positions are they frozen?
14:04Their pay scale are any of them frozen.
14:07No, I mean uh all positions.
14:09Uh I'm not sure if I understand the question, but all positions would be eligible for you know, well, no, my my question is if they reach a certain rate, they reach a certain rate.
14:21Does that mean the city says, well, we can't you you're maxed out.
14:26You're you're maxed out.
14:28Now you have some employees there that are union employees.
14:32No, uh, there are no union employees.
14:34So there's no one who's the one.
14:37Okay, so there's no one.
14:38Oh who's the oh Craig?
14:43Sorry, yes, of course.
14:44I know you're a union employee.
14:47So what I'm saying is so we have some union employees or employee.
14:52If any employee has a problem, anything, who do they go to?
15:00Do they go to the union rep or do we go to you?
15:02So if Craig is a good idea.
15:07Hey, Council Rick Alsever, Director of Human Resources.
15:10For any folks in the union, they have the right to their union representation, but they also have access to us.
15:17So if there is any issues, they can go directly to the union related or union leadership, they'll bring it to us, or they can come directly to us and we work with the union leadership.
15:26If they have any grievances, okay.
15:28And there's never ever any recaliation or any charge.
15:36That's what I want to know.
15:37So Vinny or Corey, so the I see the asterisk on the bottom of this, and forgive me because I'm using Corey's glasses because mine are lost somewhere in the building.
15:47But uh what's the the can you explain the $900,000 jump in the in the supplies?
15:52I see it says co-terming efforts, but for my own confusion, what is co-terming?
15:56Happy, happy to elaborate on that.
15:58So to promote best practices in fiscal management of the software budget.
16:06It is in our best interest and the city's best interest to align the contract dates with our fiscal year.
16:13So what that means is we uh worked over the past year to uh adjust the terms, and I've I've come to you all on a number of occasions throughout this past fiscal year to uh um modify the terms of certain agreements, the the lengths of them to make sure that they align with our fiscal year.
16:34So we incurred less dollars uh in this current fiscal year, which is why you see us uh uh in order to accommodate the adopted budget last year, we're coming in right around where that uh is and then next year we'll be incurring uh since we've kind of reset that start date for a lot of those contracts, be incurring those expenses.
16:57That 900 would be about in half next year, probably.
17:00So I would not or the 900 specifically.
17:03So it would be around 2.4 next year in that line or um I'd have to look at specific terms of individual ones.
17:09I can't I don't want to.
17:10I'm just guessing it would be around half if this is just half this is just a one-time deal.
17:15I wouldn't necessarily say it's going to uh um co-term would be a one-time deal.
17:21Yeah, okay, okay, okay, okay, okay.
17:23So does it cut it in half for right now?
17:26Uh that's yes, that's why we've gotten to the point where uh our FY26 projected is right around where the adopted budget was.
17:34Uh is because we were able to uh uh reduce the costs we were going to incur this year uh to again accommodate what was approved there.
17:42So um I don't have any questions right now.
17:56How do we look how do we look like overall as far as our new systems?
18:02A lot going on in the city right now.
18:06Yeah, we have a lot of systems.
18:08I would say yeah, a lot.
18:10Um we the digital services team and uh in collaboration with the uh innovation and data teams work to identify when you say where are we at with systems?
18:20I I want to make sure we don't necessarily just uh exclusively talk about it in terms of technology and that we're not just here buying systems because you know we think technology is the latest and greatest and need and we want to adopt it.
18:33Uh we take a look with our innovation and data teams to understand the processes behind uh the platforms that we utilize and uh make informed decisions based on whether or not uh a platform is going to be uh effective in our day-to-day operations.
18:50So the innovation team does a really great job of meeting with uh departments understanding on a person level, you know, a systems made up of people, process, and technology, right?
18:59So they they focus a lot on that people and process component, make sure that we're adequately uh uh equipping our departments and teams with the appropriate solution.
19:09So DPW system, right?
19:14Are we like where we need to be with that?
19:16Is that specific to payroll counselor?
19:19Because I know that was a major issue.
19:22I know a lot of uh employees had a lot of concerns about that.
19:27So where are we with that?
19:29So I mean I think it's I think it's safe to say, you know, it's an iterative process, so we're continuing to roll it out.
19:36I think some of the concerns that we saw specific to DPW in terms of congestion at the clock and and things um of that nature, I think we've been able to work out.
19:45Um, but it's uh it's an ongoing process, but I think given the success that we had in water, which I think arguably has the most complicated schedule, we don't anticipate any major hurdles um with DPW so far, things have been going smoothly.
20:00Where are we like getting it to where we could say we're ready to go?
20:02I know this has been like five years going that I know of.
20:10Yeah, go ahead, Josh.
20:12Counselor's Josh Syerson on the innovation team.
20:15Um so where we are in the project overall, we're just past the 50% milestone of rolling it out citywide.
20:22Uh we should be close, actually, and we expect to have everyone done by the end of summer.
20:26Um as we've mentioned a couple of times when asking you for the um to authorize the UKG uh next phase of the project and the mosaic legislation that happened earlier this spring.
20:36Um those are additional phases that will bring it all under one roof essentially and make it easier for everyone.
20:43So um the goal is that we'll have all of our current rollout done before we really kick off that next phase of the project.
20:49But if that you know ends up getting delayed at all, these future phases are going to simplify it across the board.
20:54Um our goal is still to get it 100% done by the end of the summer, though.
20:58That answers your question.
21:02These are the systems we have.
21:04So yes, this is this list here is what was used to derive that 2.9 million dollar budget there.
21:10So it's uh itemized as you can see by application name, spender, the description, and all the way down at the very bottom.
21:17You can see that total number and how it was derived.
21:22Thank you for this, because I think this is the most comprehensive list we've ever had.
21:27Uh I will give a shout out to Craig Olmsted on our team who is a uh Rockstar when it comes to maintaining and a union employee.
21:39Um can we go over personal services?
21:42Um I'm looking at uh salaries of a title pay, how is how it has gone up?
21:49Can you go into detail?
21:53Um so this kind of gets to your earlier question, counselor, in terms of um right sizing the job responsibilities for some of the employees.
22:02You know, they were being asked to do things that were not necessarily within the existing job responsibilities, which caused the out-of-title pay, but by right sizing them, we think we should be able to eliminate any out-of-title pay going forward.
22:14Is then the director of innovation uh to be determined in the numbers or not?
22:23Yeah, so the director of innovation was in last year's budget, but is going to zero in this year's budget.
22:29And just given the changes that we've had in the innovation team, we're we're taking a look with the entire team to see what we want that leadership structure to look like going forward.
22:37So it's just you have an S DVD, so I thought it was not determined.
22:41All right, sorry, yes, I can see it now.
22:44And I have one more question for you because we talk about the Sura a lot and we talk about how how do you propose that you're going to move, are you are are you going to move these employees out of Sura?
22:57Yeah, so that is the intention is to move the existing employees off of Sura.
23:00There are some personnel related issues that we need to navigate, but that's at least my goal is to um to get these folks off of Sura and back onto the general fund.
23:18So let me ask this last question, I guess.
23:20And so you were talking about the having a system that is a complete whole, like, you know, across departments, right?
23:29But then also each departments would most of them have their own specific needs to of IT for different services, I guess.
23:39So but those systems speak to the bigger system.
23:43I mean, is that the goal?
23:46So we've got enterprise systems, which you're referring to in terms of that overarching umbrella of like what everybody has access to, and then there's department specific systems.
23:54And uh throughout our evaluation process, when we identify new platforms uh that are necessary for individual departments, we look at interoperability, right, to make sure that they do communicate with our broader enterprise systems, or if uh you know, the codes department has a platform that they use, but uh maybe BAA needs to communicate with or get that data as well.
24:17Yes, they we we take that into consideration when selecting platforms to make sure that we're serving the needs of while there might be a primary user such as codes, there's secondary users maybe such as BAA who need data from that, and we make sure that those communicate with each other.
24:34And I'm looking at this is gonna be my last question.
24:37Um I'm looking at all of these systems we have is over us almost 70.
24:42How do we actually manage all of those?
24:52The uh uh Craig Olmsted and uh our team does a uh phenomenal job of uh ensuring that we stay current with all of these, right?
25:02We when it comes time for a renewal, for example, on a you know arguably yearly basis, uh, some of these, uh, we take a look and say, hey, uh are the is it being utilized?
25:11We have which, if I gave you the entire entirety of this, you'd have like a million more pages, but we have contacts with each department and who is the department kind of business owner, if you will.
25:22And so we touch base with them, we say, hey, is this platform still being used?
25:26Is it being used to the degree that we initially anticipated?
25:29Meaning some platforms are licensed based.
25:32If there's only 10 licenses or 20 licenses for a given department, uh, we we check in on that and say, do you need all of those licenses still?
25:40Can we reduce these licenses?
25:42So these are part of uh the the process that we do for every single one of these.
25:46So we can go from 70 to 50.
25:48Yeah, for essentially, yeah, and and uh ideally reduce our overall cost that we're incurring.
25:53So we go through that process, we evaluate all the different components as as we can.
25:59Actually, another question, just a blanket question.
26:04Uh this is a whole nother world, IT technology, all these different this whole packet of stuff is team.
26:12Um, but I know you know, a couple years ago we were as we were processing and changing and we were trying to figure out what makes sense and payroll and all these all this the new technology.
26:24One of the biggest things was making sure other people knew each other's jobs, right?
26:28Crossing, because as people leave, then someone doesn't know, right?
26:32So we got this phenomenal young man right here who was doing all this work, right?
26:36Putting in all this time, but who else knows what he's doing?
26:41That's gonna be important because we just should.
26:44It should be somebody else knowing because that happened, you know, in the previous there was a situation nobody knew, and then we were stuck.
26:53We uh the digital services team in particular when it comes to these software systems, uh maintain internal documentation, and that's a shared resource for the entire team to review and have access to.
27:05Uh that way, uh, if there's an event where somebody who was what we would call a product manager or someone who's overseeing the day-to-day operations of a platform uh was to depart, we have documentation to understand again the business use case and needs around it, the decisions that have been made in the past, uh, any uh special configurations, the way it's been implemented, et cetera.
27:26So yeah, we uh certainly hear that and make sure that we uh you know make as much documentation as possible for that that case.
27:34And I think to your point, Councilor Caldwell, I think that's where the opportunity is to restructure these teams so that you know um instead of Josh having all this information, for example, resting in his head that we have a team working on it, and so that that he has a partner in that process, and so I think that's why this gives us a real opportunity as we're taking a fresh look at these teams to structure them so that their actual teams working on projects, not everything's living in one person's mind.
28:00To build a little bit on that, those like Camino, for example, I'm just looking at your list that are that are public-facing.
28:09Um not everybody has the same skill when it comes to technology.
28:14Um so do we have trained folks to train, or how do we train our residents to be able to use our systems?
28:23Yeah, I think uh the the thing to highlight is that these technical systems are you know, they augment our current services, and I don't know, or I see Jess is over here, and Jess can probably speak to it uh a little bit, but also uh just to highlight that their office is still open, you know, on the first floor of OPP, where residents can still come in, get the the person-to-person guidance they may need in that uh instance.
28:47Uh you know, it's not exclusively online or nothing, right?
28:50So uh for those that are capable, certainly have technical skills uh and can leverage it, and I think there's a uh uh large uh portion of the community that is seeking modern engagement experiences with local government, really that uh but then also uh to your point, we're not leaving anyone behind in the sense of.
29:15But still do want to do this.
29:17So could there's um how do they engage with somebody to I'll let Jess speak to you know the uh you know permits department and counselor Jessica Brandt, um director of the central permit office?
29:28So we do have the kiosk.
29:29Um, but yeah, we work one-on-one with anybody if they if they need an application or they're having trouble, they don't understand.
29:36Um we provide uh assistance over the phone, we do have computer right downstairs on the first floor, they can come in.
29:43Um so we have many different ways that we can help folks out if they need something.
29:47How many of your staff work from home?
29:50Or from home, we don't have uh work from home.
29:56And how close are we to payroll modernization across the city?
30:09Kind of related to the timekeeping project, and that's what you see.
30:12Uh just began as as the authorization came in for the mosaic contract this spring.
30:18That kicked off an 18 month effort to get payroll done.
30:21That's kind of the next phase once timekeeping is done is to start payroll.
30:24The goal of that is still to get done sooner than 18 months.
30:28So our target right now is January 1 of 27.
30:31But as we've seen in the past, sometimes there is delays that you encounter in these projects.
30:34So the last thing we want to do is no delays, the last thing we would want to do is uh rush ahead and risk you know jeopardizing people's pay.
30:41Um, but you know, that's our optimistic target right now is January.
30:45Um the the agreement lasts for for 18 months, though.
30:47So if not January, perhaps next July, but that's generally the the time frame we're talking about.
30:58Counselor Monto, do you have anything else?
31:00I'm off that thing also.
31:02Let me ask this question.
31:03Is everybody out there part of your team?
31:07There's a lot on the yeah, there's a lot of stakeholders too, because I know sometimes they're, you know, in the grand scheme of the city, API is a relatively new department, and I understand that sometimes there are questions about what does API do.
31:19And so I appreciate that so many of the departments that we work that this team works with have showed up to you know demonstrate the value that they have in working with APIs.
31:29So permits, parks, HR, VAAs back there.
31:33I know they work with the fire department, and that's why um finance, yes.
31:38Um so and that's why I just appreciate the team putting together kind of the project highlights to to give some information as to what exactly it is that API works on.
31:48So each one of them they have specific duties with specific departments.
31:54You all look very smart.
32:03That's part of my job.
32:04No, I appreciate it.
32:06All righty, we have three minutes left before we transfer to our next meeting.
32:11Thank you for this overview.
32:12I will have more questions, so I will talk to you, Vinny.
32:17I look forward to it.