OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Tacoma City Council Meeting Summary - November 12, 2025

City CouncilWednesday, November 12, 2025
BodyTacoma, Washington
SessionCity Council
DateWednesday, November 12, 2025
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
0:00

Now we're gonna gavel back in.

0:02

I'd like to call to order the city council meeting of November 12th, 2025.

0:07

Clerk, will you please call a roll?

0:09

Councilmember Bushnell?

0:10

Present.

0:10

Deputy Mayor Daniels.

0:12

Aye.

0:13

Here Councilmember Diaz.

0:17

Councilmember Hines.

0:19

Councilmember Remba, absent.

0:20

Councilmember Sidalgay?

0:21

Here.

0:22

Councilmember Scott?

0:23

Here.

0:23

Councilmember Walker?

0:24

Here.

0:25

Mayor Woodards?

0:26

Here.

0:27

Please join me in listening to the land of law land acknowledgement and flag salute led by Councilmember Bush now, followed by a moment of silence.

0:34

We gratefully honor it, acknowledge that we rest on the traditional lands of the Puola people where they make their home and speak the Lashutsi language.

0:40

Please stand for the flag salute and remain standing for a moment of silence.

1:39

Are there any modifications to the agenda?

1:42

Seeing none, we'll move on to the consent agenda.

1:44

I move to adopt the consent agenda, including resolution number 41792.

1:49

Second.

1:50

Are there any council questions or comments?

1:53

All right, seeing none, all those in favor of adopting the consent agenda, please signify by saying aye.

1:58

Aye.

1:58

All those opposed.

2:00

Consent agenda is declared adopted.

2:02

There are no proclamations, uh recognitions, or presentations this afternoon.

2:07

Um now we're gonna move on to public comment.

2:09

On tonight's agenda, there is one opportunity for people to comment.

2:13

As a reminder, community reform was removed from the agenda by the council motion at last week's study session.

2:18

The next regular community form is scheduled on December 9th, 2025.

2:23

Under public comment, you can speak about motions, resolutions, or ordinances on tonight's agenda.

2:27

This form is intended to give speakers the opportunity to share their viewpoints and feedback with the city council to aid in our decision making, and it is not meant to be a back and forth dialogue.

2:36

Your remarks should be directed to the city council and not at individual staff members.

2:41

If you wish to speak under the public comment period, please press the raise your hand button near the bottom of your Zoom window or star nine on your phone now, so we can see the number of people wishing to testify this afternoon.

2:52

If you're speaking in person, please sign up at the back of the room if you have not done so already.

2:56

Your name or the last four digits of your phone number will be called out when it is your turn to speak.

3:01

Clerk, will you please read?

3:03

This is a time set aside for public comment.

3:05

Speakers are asked to identify the specific legislation they wish to address.

3:09

All right, I would like to remind everyone to please keep your comments respectful, relevant, focused, and on topic.

3:15

We strive to provide a comment period where people can feel respected while sharing a wide variety of viewpoints and acknowledge that we may hear comments that conflict with our values.

3:24

To ensure all speakers can express their first amendment constitutional rights, we ask that you refrain from clapping, cheering, booing, or otherwise being disruptive.

3:33

You will have 90 seconds to make your remarks.

3:35

Please be mindful of the time frame.

3:37

As always, you are not required to use all of your time to make your point.

3:40

If you cannot remain on topic, you will be given two warnings.

3:43

If you remain off topic, we will have to move on and we'll end your time.

3:47

Clerk, have we received any written public comment for tonight's meeting?

3:50

We've received one regarding ordinance two nine zero seven five.

3:54

All right.

3:55

Um with that, I'm gonna start by calling the person who has their hand raised online, and we'll start with Serenity Staub or Strob.

4:15

Hello.

4:19

Oh we lost serenity.

4:22

Okay.

4:22

Well, um, I will start calling those who are.

4:25

Oh, we've got another person who raised their hand, so I'll go to Kathy Irwin.

4:34

Hi.

4:35

Um, I wanted to.

4:36

I I have already fit um furnished or submitted written um statements on this two nine zero seven five ordinance.

4:46

Hello.

4:50

But I also wanted to um certainly express the frustration with which the pace of some of these updates and sub-area plans have gone, which has included um a very much of a delay from the time that residents are first involved to the very end.

5:07

When things have drastically changed as it has with this ordinance coming up.

5:12

I feel sorry for anybody who is living near the port at this point in time because I do not see this as a positive place to live with the environment.

5:20

Give the amount of industry, commercial uses, et cetera, that are planned for this area, with very little area devoted to anything environmentally based.

5:31

It is a shame that not more.

5:33

We couldn't see more in the way of green space or other uses for this area of the tide flats.

5:38

And I feel that we also need to remember that this area is also supposed to be known for um the Northwest known for recreation and other tourism-related events, which will not be as much fun for anybody visiting the area, given what's proposed in the future for the industry in this area.

5:57

So I do not agree with approval of this um tight flat sub-area plan.

6:02

And really, the planning department needs to move the show along on a quicker road with these subplant areas plans.

6:09

Thank you thank you, Kathy.

6:11

Thank you for being here, and thank you for your comments.

6:13

Okay, I don't see anybody else who has their hand raised online.

6:17

So I will go to those who have signed in, and we'll start with Michelle Reich, followed by Kit Burns.

6:25

Michelle Risham.

6:27

I'll speak into the EMS levy.

6:29

Uh it's a tax.

6:31

Uh nine million dollars annually.

6:34

And that's directly related to the homeless issue, because that really taxes the EMS services for calls, repeat calls, and and it's related to the encampment issue and everything, and taxes in general.

6:51

And I'm opposed to wasting the city funds and your um President, yes, just making problems worse by spreading the people around from the 172 sites.

7:04

Um then you're gonna spend money for a low barrier drug use center.

7:12

And if you have a low barrier drug use center, you need dealers to supply the drug users.

7:18

So your city council would approve that.

7:20

That's a bad idea.

7:22

And I rather you uh spend the money for a veteran's center shelter instead of a low barrier drug user or center for drug dealers, because there's there's gonna be always some drug dealers within the group there to supply the drugs because they they and you need to take care of business there in the city with all the population partners.

7:47

Um a hundred and twenty people that were evicted from this uh thing on 112th street, and only one of them took shelter.

7:56

Think about it.

7:58

Thank you for your comments tonight, Michelle.

8:00

Kit Burns, followed by Kyle Jolly Boys and Barb Church.

8:07

Good evening, Mayor and City Council.

8:09

My name is Kit Burns.

8:10

I live on Hilltop.

8:11

I want to speak on two issues tonight.

8:13

First of all, I want to bring to your attention item 25-1004.

8:17

Uh, this item actually came before the council less than a month ago, and it said that the property that was being vacated by UW Tacoma for 2.9 million dollars.

8:26

And yet this or this item tonight reduces it to 600,000.

8:30

So I'd like to know uh what happened to the 2.3 million dollars it appears to have missed.

8:36

Now I may have misread that, but there's not sufficient information here um in the agenda for me to figure that out.

8:43

So I uh expect it'll be explained tonight.

8:46

Um the second thing I want to bring to your attention.

8:49

10 years ago, Mayor Strickland did a really fantastic job of going around the community and raising funds.

8:56

This is regarding the tax.

8:58

She did a great job on street initiative uh one, and I thought it wouldn't pass, but it did.

9:04

She went and it was part A and part B, and they both passed.

9:07

I thought, well, maybe one might pass, but she got them both to pass.

9:10

So 10 years later, here we are with Street Initiative 2.

9:13

What I would like to know from the council, and you've got my email.

9:17

I'd like to know what the discussion was not to run the streets initiative two again.

9:23

As an architect, I worked on school districts, and we'd put the bond issue up, it would fail, we'd run it out again.

9:29

Do you know how much this one failed by at the last election?

9:32

Everybody on the council should know.

9:34

1,600 votes.

9:37

This was poorly presented, and it needs a lot more attention.

9:42

Thank you.

9:44

Thank you, Kit, for your comments.

9:46

Kyle.

9:54

Mayor, this is one of our last meetings together after 15 years.

10:01

It's been a pleasure.

10:04

I've been standing up against the Port of Tacoma for nine years now.

10:10

You guys want to expand it and do a lot of terrible things out there.

10:14

Like that previous caller said, you don't want to live by it.

10:18

I can see it out my window.

10:20

I live 2.2 miles away from that L and G plant.

10:24

I want to know what the city is going to do if there's a Lahar hitting the ported Tacoma.

10:30

I want meetings on that.

10:32

I want meetings on earthquakes.

10:34

We had over 200 earthquakes on Mount Rainier last summer.

10:39

What's going to happen if the mountain blows, Mayor?

10:43

And the Lahar hits the port of Tacoma and hits that 8 million gallons of L and G.

10:50

You guys once told us it's 3.5 mile radius.

10:54

That was a lie.

10:56

It's 15 miles.

10:59

And if you want to know more, I think you should follow me, Mayor.

11:05

It's been an honor.

11:08

Thank you, Kyle.

11:09

It has been mine.

11:10

Barbara Barb Church speaking on 29075.

11:24

Residents in this city were catalysts in making the sub-area plan happen because we were tired of the polluting and dangerous industry coming into our already overburdened neighborhoods.

11:34

So while some of you worked on the sub-area plan process for a few years and mayor seven years, uh I respectfully want to thank many of the other community members who worked on it for over eight years.

11:48

Thank you, POLUP Tribe.

11:50

Thank you, Yvonne McCarty of the Northeast Neighborhood Council.

11:53

Thank you, Aaron Dilworth, for your health impact assessment.

11:58

And thank you, environmental and social justice groups.

12:00

The conversation 253, Onita Arnold, Les Pogue, Norma Ramirez, Calista and Sid, Advocates for Cleaner Tacoma, Steve Storms, Communities for Healthy Bay.

12:14

Thank you, Claudia Reitner, for all your research.

12:17

John Carlton, Kyle Jolly Boys here, Kathy Lahan, Steve Storms, and thank you to all the thousands of others who pack the halls to say that Tacoma needs to do a better job to protect the people's health and safety.

12:30

Council, please say yes to support the planning commission's amendments one, two, and three to the sub-area plan.

12:37

Use this vote as an opportunity to make up for the lack of meaningful inclusion that local residents were promised early and often as part of the overarching sub-area planning process.

12:51

Thank you.

12:52

That was the first time I was on time.

12:58

You ended right on time.

13:02

That's I don't have oh, looks like that person came back.

13:05

Barb, I do want to say thank you for reading that long list of names.

13:08

You mentioned people I haven't seen in such a long time because this has been going on for so long.

13:14

I'm not gonna make formal comments at today's meeting, but I will on the second.

13:18

But thank you for bringing send a copy of that list because they they they they there are a lot of people who help make this happen, and I appreciate some of the names that you brought up from some time ago, especially Claudia.

13:29

So thank you.

13:30

All right, I'm gonna um that's all I have.

13:32

That's all who signed in.

13:34

I'll go.

13:34

Oh, and we lost her again.

13:36

What happened to Serenity?

13:40

Serenity, if you are still online.

13:44

We lost her again.

13:48

Well, she's not online.

13:49

I'm gonna have to declare the public comment period closed, and we'll have to get her um next week.

13:57

All right, we're gonna move on to um.

14:03

All right, let me back up here.

14:05

I got I I lost my pages.

14:06

Okay, now we're gonna move on to the regular agenda.

14:09

Um, we now have a motion before us for consideration.

14:13

I move in conjunction with the ordinance numbers 291 29061 and 29062 to reduce the associated street vacation fees to a total of 600,000 for both street vacations in the best interest of the city.

14:25

Mayor second.

14:27

All right, um, I will take this.

14:30

Um, and we'll when it gets presented, we'll have staff um, we'll have staff present the actual numbers.

14:36

But what um what you have before you, what this particular um uh change is is that council member Rumba and I were able to talk with the University of Washington Tacoma um uh to to be able to partner with them in a way that um they could make the they could both pay for some of the land, but we could also make sure that they're actually able to develop the property into um the park and to the usage that they want to have developed, not just for their campus, but for the city.

15:06

Um they have been um an incredible partner.

15:08

UWT has been a credible partner um to the city on countless different initiatives and programs, and again, it's not just what they do in the four walls of their campus in providing education, but it's the way that their campus really is an urban-setting campus that reaches out far beyond the four walls of their campus.

15:28

Um so to the city is considering this action today to really put a fine point on our continued partnership in and and the work that the university is doing to create a downtown campus core that is vibrant, vibrant, thriving, and colorful, not just again for the students, but for everyone who lives on the campus.

15:50

And I hope that you all will join me in supporting this action in support of the immense value that UWT brings to our city.

15:57

Normally, when we do projects like this, um even if it's a street vacation, someone would come back to us and ask us for funding to be able to support the project.

16:08

Well, everybody knows the budget issue that we're reflecting, which is kit probably exactly why you said why aren't we collecting the full amount?

16:14

Well, we also see this as an opportunity as a way that we can participate um in in the cap in this capital project by reducing um the actual amount um that they would have to pay for the street vacations and considering that also our contribution um to their capital campaign and all the work that they will do in the future.

16:36

So that is my explanation for the number.

16:39

We'll get a short staff presentation um when it actually comes up to talk about the street vacation, but I wanted to um get this motion taken care of before we actually vote on the ordinances this evening.

16:51

So um are there any additional council questions or comments?

16:55

All right, seeing none, all those in favor signify by saying aye.

16:59

Aye.

16:59

All those opposed.

17:01

The motion is declared adopted.

17:02

Moving on to purchase resolutions.

17:04

Item nine, Clerk, will you please read Resolution 41793?

17:12

A resolution ratifying a contract with multicare health systems and the amount of 3,900,000 plus applicable taxes budgeted from various funds for occupational medical services for an initial contract term of four years retroactive to January 1st, 2025.

17:27

I move to adopt resolution number 41793.

17:30

Second.

17:32

All right, are there any council questions or comments at this time?

17:35

Seeing none, all those in favor of adopting resolution number 41793 signify by saying aye.

17:40

Aye.

17:41

All those opposed, the resolution is declared adopted.

17:44

Moving on to item 10.

17:45

This presentation will also cover items 11 and 16.

17:48

Clerk, will you please read?

17:50

Resolution 41794, a resolution authorizing the execution of a collective bargaining agreement with district lodge number 160 on behalf of local lodge number 297 of the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Aerospace Workers Track Workers Unit Effective January 1st, 2026 through December 31st, 2028.

18:08

I move to adopt resolution number 41794.

18:12

Second.

18:12

All right, I'd like to call on Mark Johnson.

18:21

Is Mark online?

18:22

Is Mark here?

18:26

Maybe Mark the two meeting at five.

18:30

Um City Manager, I don't see or can hear from Mark Johnson.

18:38

Would you like us to postpone this?

18:40

Or is there another staff person we can turn to?

18:43

Can we come back to this man mayor if it's we certainly can.

18:47

Um city attorney, we are in the middle of a motion.

18:58

We've made the motion.

18:59

There is a second.

19:00

Now we want to postpone the presentation and not take a vote on it.

19:04

Do we need to rescind the motion?

19:06

Do we leave the motion hanging out there?

19:08

Help me understand how we pull this back until we can find um till we can find Mark.

19:14

So the council member that made the motion can withdraw the motion.

19:17

And then you can move to modify the agenda to push the uh item to a different portion of the agenda.

19:24

Okay.

19:25

All right.

19:26

I'm um I just moved to the you just want to remove the motion.

19:30

You just want to move it to review.

19:32

No, she can just remove it, right?

19:34

Yeah, just withdraw your motion.

19:36

Well, I'd like to withdraw the motion to adopt resolution number 41794.

19:40

Um, and I'd like to move to um move this resolution to the end of the agenda.

19:50

The end of the agenda.

19:51

Second.

19:52

All right.

19:52

All those in favor signify by saying aye.

19:55

Aye.

19:55

Are those opposed?

19:56

The ayes have it.

19:57

Okay.

20:00

The motion has been removed and um the uh item has been rem the item has been moved.

20:04

Um Chris, just to make sure if for some reason um we are not able to catch up with Mark and we can't bring this back, then by the end of the meeting we do need to vote to remove it from the agenda tonight, correct?

20:16

Correct, Mayor.

20:17

Okay, great.

20:17

Thank you.

20:18

All right, we're gonna move on to final reading of ordinances, and we're gonna go to item 12.

20:22

Clerk, will you please read ordinance 29069 and ordinance authorizing no increase in the ad valorum general property tax revenue collection in terms of both dollars and percentage for the general property tax levy for 2026?

20:39

All right.

20:40

This item was presented on October 28th.

20:42

Are there any additional council questions or comments?

20:45

All right, seeing none, Clerk, will you please call the roll?

20:48

Councilmember Bushnell?

20:50

Aye.

20:50

Deputy Mayor Daniels?

20:51

Aye.

20:52

Councilmember Diaz?

20:53

Aye.

20:53

Councilmember Heinz?

20:54

Aye.

20:55

Councilmember Rumba?

20:57

Absent?

20:57

Councilmember Sidalgay?

20:58

Aye.

20:59

Councilmember Scott?

21:00

Aye.

21:00

Councilmember Walker?

21:01

Aye.

21:02

Mayor Woodards?

21:03

Aye.

21:03

The ordinance is declared passed.

21:05

Moving on to item 13.

21:06

Clerk, will you please read?

21:08

Ordinance 29070, an ordinance fixing the amount of ad valorum tax levies necessary to identify the amount of the estimated revenues from property tax levies to match estimated expenditures for debt services and other funding requirements.

21:23

All right, this item was presented on October 28th.

21:25

Are there any additional council questions or comments?

21:28

All right.

21:29

Seeing none, Clerk, will you please call the roll?

21:32

Deputy Mayor Daniels?

21:33

Aye.

21:34

Councilmember Diaz?

21:35

Aye.

21:35

Councilmember Hines.

21:36

Aye.

21:37

Councilmember Rumba, absent.

21:38

Councilmember Sidalga?

21:39

Aye.

21:40

Councilmember Scott?

21:41

Aye.

21:41

Councilmember Walker?

21:42

Aye.

21:43

Councilmember Bushnell?

21:44

Aye.

21:44

Mayor Woodards?

21:45

Aye.

21:46

This ordinance is declared passed.

21:48

Moving on to item 14.

21:50

Um Jeff, while she reads this, I'm going to ask you to come forward because I've got a question for you.

21:55

So this item was presented on October 28th.

21:58

Are there any additional council questions or comments?

22:00

I'll start with Councilmember Sidalgay, Jeff, and I have one for you too.

22:04

Okay.

22:05

I just have a clarifying question based on comments that I received.

22:09

This number of the six percent, where does that come from?

22:12

Is that something we decided as a city, or is that come from uh the voters?

22:19

Uh Jeff Upton, office management and budget.

22:21

Thank you for the question, Councilmember.

22:23

So that six percent comes from uh proposition one, which was passed by the voters in August of 2023, which authorized uh the restoring of this EMS levy up to the 50 cents per 1,000 of assessed value and further a annual increase up to six percent year year over year.

22:42

Okay, great.

22:43

I just wanted to clarify that we are uh just doing what voters have asked us to do, just you know uh you know, logistically.

22:53

That is correct, yes.

22:57

I shouldn't let council member Sidalgay go for first, but I guess I do there were some comments made about um what this EMS uh property tax levy is for, and um there was a comment made earlier that that we're increasing taxes just to um fund our homeless outreach services.

23:19

And so Jeff, can you just talk about um the EMS tax levy, what it is used for?

23:25

Um, and I think Councilmember Sidalgay asked the exact question I was also going to get to, which is this is just a part of the requirement to continue the levy.

23:36

This is not a new levy that we are um putting on voters, it's just something we have to do every single year as a part of the process, or as a part of the budget, I should say.

23:48

Yes, thank you, Mayor.

23:49

Um, so the EMS levy funds um medical response services, mostly performed by the fire department.

23:57

And yes, you're correct.

23:58

The uh action that this ordinance would take is something that's required by the state.

24:04

The state requires us to uh notify the amount that we as a city intend to collect from uh to set the property tax levy for each year.

24:14

So and it is consistent with the language that was approved in proposition one with the six percent um increase year over year thank you.

24:23

Thank you very much for that.

24:24

I just always want to make sure that we're educating voters on um there are things that sometimes we say um that that people will actually say in their comments during public comment um that may or may not um that they may or may not understand the implications of what they've said, and I just want to make sure that we're correcting the record so that the public clearly understands um that this is not a new tax that that we are um that we are putting upon voters, but this is something that we always collect.

24:52

So Jeff, thank you so much for that.

24:54

Um with that explanation and seeing no other hands raised, clerk, will you please call the roll?

24:59

Thank you, Jeff.

25:02

Councilmember Diaz.

25:04

Aye.

25:04

Councilmember Heinz.

25:05

Aye.

25:06

Councilmember Rumba absent.

25:07

Councilmember Sidalgay?

25:08

Aye.

25:08

Councilmember Scott.

25:09

Aye.

25:10

Councilmember Walker.

25:11

Aye.

25:11

Councilmember Bushnell?

25:12

Aye.

25:13

Deputy Mayor Daniels.

25:14

Aye.

25:14

Mayor Woodards.

25:16

Aye.

25:16

This ordinance has declared passed.

25:18

Moving on to item 14.

25:19

Clerk, will you please read?

25:22

Madam Mayor, I think we're on item 15.

25:26

I'm sorry.

25:27

That was item 14.

25:29

Yeah.

25:29

I'm sorry, item 15.

25:30

Clerk, will you please read?

25:32

Ordinance 29072, an ordinance fixing the amount of emergency medical service levy necessary to identify the amount of estimated revenues from the property tax levy to match estimated expenditures for debt service and other funding requirements.

25:46

All right.

25:46

This item was also presented on October 28th.

25:48

Are there any additional council questions or comments?

25:51

Seeing none, will clerk please call a roll.

25:55

Councilmember Heinz.

25:56

Aye.

25:56

Councilmember Rumba, absent.

25:58

Councilmember Sidalga?

25:59

Aye.

25:59

Councilmember Scott?

26:00

Aye.

26:01

Councilmember Walker.

26:02

Aye.

26:03

Councilmember Bushnell?

26:04

Aye.

26:04

Deputy Mayor Daniels.

26:06

Aye.

26:06

Councilmember Diaz.

26:07

Aye.

26:08

Mayor Woodards.

26:09

Aye.

26:09

This ordinance is declared passed.

26:11

Moving on to item 16.

26:12

Clerk, will you please read?

26:17

An ordinance amending chapter 1.12 of the municipal code relating to the compensation plan to implement rates of pay and compensation for employees represented by District Lodge No.

26:28

297 of the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, Rail Track Workers, and General Units.

26:36

All right.

26:38

This item was presented early.

26:39

Oh no, it hasn't been presented early in the meeting.

26:42

Okay, wait a second.

26:44

Now let's go back to thank you for reading that into the record.

26:50

We can't take a vote on it yet because we haven't.

26:52

You know what?

26:52

Here's what I'll do.

26:53

I'm I'm huh?

26:56

Oh, gotcha.

26:57

In that case, we'll come back to it.

27:00

Um Madam Mayor Mark is here.

27:02

Yeah, I was gonna say, Mark, why don't you come on up and make your presentation?

27:06

That's what I that's what I was just thinking of.

27:07

Why don't you make your presentation on the whole package?

27:10

And then we will set this ordinance over.

27:13

We'll set the other one ordinance over, and then we'll come back and pass the ordinance.

27:17

So, Mark, come on up and present on the resolution and the two ordinances.

27:24

All right.

27:24

And sorry, sorry for the no the changing of the time.

27:28

Oh, no, no, no worries.

27:30

I good evening, Mayor uh Woodards and members of the city council.

27:33

I'm Mark Johnson, labor negotiator for the city of Tacoma.

27:36

I have two resolutions, an ordinance, and an ordinance to present this evening, and my apologies for being here a little bit late to do this.

27:44

But resolution 41794, authorized execution of accessor collective bargaining agreement with the district lodge 160 on behalf of local uh 297 of the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, the track unit, uh track workers unit.

28:01

This agreement is three years, covers approximately seven full-time equivalent positions, and was adopted by the utility board uh uh as a resolution on October 22nd.

28:12

Um of January 1 of 2026, the rates for the rail track maintenance worker um will receive a general wage increase of three percent and a market base increase of six point five percent.

28:28

Effective January 1, 2027, the rates for the railroad railway track maintenance worker will receive a general uh wage increase of three percent and a market-based increase of two percent.

28:40

Effective January 1, 2028, the rates for the railway track maintenance worker will receive a general wage increase of 3% and a market based increase of 2%.

28:51

Uh in each of the agreement each year of the agreement, the rates for the all other classifications are calculated at 10% above the railway track maintenance worker rates of pay.

29:01

Uh other changes to the agreement include a change for providing a reimbursement for leather work grubs to the employer furnishing uh replacement work gloves for those that are worn out, an increase from 250 dollars to 300 dollars uh for an allowance uh the provided every two years for reindeer, um, an increase of from 200 to 300 dollars for an annual allowance uh to provide for work clothing, uh adding June 19 or Juneteenth as a paid city holiday, uh adding an employer provided match to the 457 deferred uh compensation uh plan for employees covered by the agreement up to a maximum of 3% of base salary uh resolution 41 uh 795 recommends the approval of a letter of agreement with District Lodge 160 on behalf of local lodge uh 297 of the associate international association machinists and aerospace workers, the general unit, and was adopted by the public utility board as a resolution on October 22nd, uh, 2025.

30:09

Letter agreement provides for the creation of a new classification titled machine and fabrication welder lead.

30:16

Classification will be represented by District Lodge 160 on behalf of local lodge 297 of the association, International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers General Unit for the purposes of collective bargaining.

30:29

Classification will be created as a classified, designated as overtime uh, and the pay rate will be set at 10% over the rate of pay for the classification of machinist as established in the collective bargaining agreement for 2025 and 2026.

30:47

All that the terms and conditions of uh for the classification will be consistent with the current collective bargaining agreement.

30:54

Uh ordinate or ordinance 29074 provides for the implementation of the provisions of the agreements as negotiated with district lodge 160 on behalf of Lodge, Local Lodge 297 uh of the International Association, Machinists and Aerospace Workers, the track units, uh workers unit, and the general unit.

31:14

Be happy to answer any questions you might have.

31:18

Thank you very much for that presentation.

31:22

Um we have any questions?

31:24

And again, this is for this is for resolution.

31:28

This is for item resolution number 10, number 11, and ordinance number 16.

31:33

Councilmember Walker.

31:35

Thank you, Mayor.

31:36

Um, are these employees primarily or entirely uh with TPU?

31:41

Tacoma Rail?

31:43

Or is this are they mixed between General Government and TPU?

31:46

They're TPU.

31:47

They are on the first resolution.

31:50

That's rail.

31:51

Okay, thank you.

31:52

Great.

31:53

Thank you very much, Councilmember Walker.

31:54

Are there any other questions?

31:57

All right, seeing none, this ordinance will be set over for final reading next week.

32:03

That is the ordinance.

32:04

Now I'm gonna move back to item 10.

32:08

Um, and this presentation um was just given, and as I said, also covers uh items number 11 and 16 that we just took care of.

32:16

Clerk, will you please read?

32:19

Resolution 41794, a resolution authorizing the execution of a collective bargaining agreement with district lodge number 160 on behalf of local lodge number 297, track workers' unit effective January 1st, 2026 through December 31st, 2028.

32:34

I move to adopt resolution number 41794.

32:37

Second.

32:38

All right, it's already been presented unless we have additional questions for Mark.

32:41

All those in favor of adopting resolution number 41794 signify by saying aye.

32:46

Aye.

32:47

All those opposed, the ayes have it.

32:49

The resolution is declared adopted.

32:51

Moving on to item 11.

32:52

Clerk, will you please read?

32:54

Resolution 41795, a resolution authorizing the execution of the letter of agreement with District Lodge number 160 on behalf of local lodge number 297, General Ludical Unit regarding a new classification of machine and fabrication welder lead.

33:08

I move to adopt resolution number 41795.

33:11

Second.

33:12

All right, this item was just presented.

33:14

Are there any additional council questions or comments?

33:16

Seeing none, all those in favor of adopting resolution number 41795.

33:21

Signify by saying aye.

33:22

Aye.

33:23

All those opposed, the ayes have it.

33:26

The um the resolution is adopted.

33:29

Okay, I think we got it all taken care of.

33:31

Thank you so much for coming down.

33:34

All right, we're gonna move back to our regular agenda.

33:36

We'll go back to first meeting of ordinances, and we will move on to item 17.

33:40

And this item will have a PowerPoint presentation and will also cover items 18 and 19.

33:46

Clark, will you please read?

33:48

Ordinance 29075, an ordinance adopting the Tide Flat Sub-area Plan as an element of the one Tacoma Comprehensive Plan by replacing the container port element and revising the future land use map and land use designations as recommended by the Tide Flat Steering Committee and Planning Commission effective January 5th, 2026.

34:07

All right.

34:09

Steve.

34:11

Good afternoon.

34:12

I'd like to call on you, Steve.

34:15

But I can't tell you how excited I am.

34:19

This this may be one of two times that I will call your name from this dais about this plan.

34:30

So Steve Atkinson, I turn it to you.

34:33

Great.

34:34

Thank you, Mayor.

34:35

Uh, and good afternoon.

34:36

Uh, Mayor Woodards, Deputy Mayor Daniels, members of the council.

34:39

I'm Stephen Atkinson, Principal Planner with Planning and Development Services.

34:42

Um, and here this evening uh to introduce the first reading of ordinances, uh, ordinances plural associated with the Tide Flat sub-area plan.

34:52

Let's see.

34:55

I can change slides.

35:03

All right, Alison, are you able to go to the next slide?

35:07

All right.

35:08

It is it may be frozen.

35:10

We will continue with the presentation.

35:12

Okay, let me be really clear.

35:14

The PowerPoint may not work.

35:17

We'll get that out to everybody.

35:19

This is not gonna delay us.

35:22

Go ahead.

35:24

Okay, we'll give it to the Stephen, why don't you go ahead and talk on the first slide and we'll keep working on it.

35:29

Absolutely.

35:30

So uh thank you, Mayor, and uh sorry for that inconvenience for everyone following uh from home tonight.

35:35

Um the tide flat subway plan, uh, first ring of ordinances this evening.

35:39

Uh I just wanted to uh provide an overview of the ordinance package that's before the city council uh this evening.

35:46

Uh the first ordinance, number 29075 uh would adopt the tide flat sub area plan, uh replacing the container port element of the comprehensive plan and revise the future land use map of the comprehensive plan.

35:59

So the first ordinance uh would revise the city's uh comprehensive plan.

36:04

Ordinance number 29076 uh would amend Title 13 of the land use regulatory code to revise the zoning map, incorporate the new proposed zoning districts, land use tables, and associated development standards as recommended in the Tide Flat Sub-area Plan.

36:19

Um and then the third ordinance, number 29077 would amend Title 19, our Shoreline Master Program again to revise the shoreline environment designations, the allowed land uses and prohibited uses within the shoreline environment, um, and it integrates development standards for consistency with Title 13.

36:36

Um the brief overview of the three ordinances uh that are before the city council for first reading, all associated with the Tide Flat subway plan.

36:45

On September 9th, the City Council adopted a resolution uh establishing a public hearing for the sub area plan.

36:52

Uh that hearing was conducted on October 28th.

36:55

Uh that time period represents uh a 45-day public comment period, uh, which is one of the city commitments as part of our intergovernmental work plan.

37:04

Um and that was a commitment to both our broader community and governmental partners to ensure adequate time to consider uh the recommendations and any potential amendments that were under consideration uh in these ordinances.

37:16

Uh in support of the city council's public hearing, uh staff conducted an informational meeting on October 16th.

37:23

Uh, we presented the public review documents, so each of those ordinances uh was uh presented to uh interested parties and members of our community, um, and we uh answered community questions at that time.

37:36

Um in addition, uh we issued a variety of public notices to support just broad awareness of these uh ordinances and the consideration by council.

37:45

And this went out to approximately 6,500 to 7,000 uh direct mailings to taxpayers and occupants both within the tide flats and surrounding communities, uh social media advertisements.

37:56

We have a significant listserv of interested parties have been getting email notifications throughout the process, um, as well as some of the legally required advertisements, legal notices, public notice signs, um, as well as notification to the state, joint base Lewis McCord and Pialp tribe of Indians.

38:13

Um the City Council public hearing was the fourth public hearing.

38:17

Um formal public hearing and comment period conducted throughout this process uh following the planning commission's public hearing and comment period uh again uh earlier this year that they conducted on the draft plan and code amendments.

38:30

Uh prior to that, we conducted a public hearing on the draft environmental impact statement to get comments uh on that body of work and the responses to those public public comments were incorporated into the final environmental impact statement.

38:44

Um and then uh the city council also conducted a public hearing earlier on in the process in the kind of affirmation of the range of land use alternatives and scenarios uh that was considered by the council that really helped structure the scope of work for this process and the range of development alternatives that were considered through both the plan and EIS.

39:05

Um and I will just note that the notifications we provided for the city council process were similar to the same notifications that we provided uh in support of all of those prior public hearings.

39:16

Uh at the city council's public hearing on October 28th.

39:20

Um, by the time of the public hearing, uh the council had received 19 written comments.

39:25

Um and during the public hearing itself, uh the council heard from 20 individuals providing testimony directly to the city council.

39:32

Um, in staff's assessment of both the written and oral testimony provided to the city council.

39:37

Um we felt that the comments that were shared with the city council were generally within the scope of comments that were previously considered by both the planning commission and city council.

39:46

Um the comments uh in staff's review were generally supportive, not unanimously.

39:52

There were some concerns, uh, but generally supportive of adoption of the plan.

40:00

And there were some requests from individuals for further requests for consideration for amendments to the plan or the supportive code amendments.

40:06

So in general, I think what we'd characterize is while many of the parties that had requests for uh changes were still highly supportive of the direction that the plan is taking in council adoption of the plan overall.

40:20

Uh the comments that we received were generally reflective of the broad community interests that have been part of this process from the beginning.

40:27

Uh many of the individuals that commented have been involved in the planning process or uh were directly involved in the Tide Flats advisory group.

40:34

So we heard from representatives from the Economic Development Board for Pierce County, uh communities for Healthy Bay, the Manufacturing and Industrial Council, uh Chamber of Commerce, as well as uh former uh member of the board for Northeast Tacoma Neighborhood Council, um, all of whom had previously been involved directly in the Tide Flats Advisory Group and sharing uh their perspectives and helping review and provide comment to the steering committee throughout the process.

41:00

Um and um generally just a note here again uh that any new material amendments would require an additional 45 day public comment period uh to ensure adequate review and input from our partner governments uh prior to any city council action.

41:17

And next slide.

41:22

Uh there we go.

41:24

Uh thank you.

41:25

Um and then uh the slide just shows the tentative schedule.

41:28

So following uh this first reading of ordinance this evening.

41:31

Um this would be coming back uh on December 2nd for consideration for final reading of ordinances.

41:37

Um and then upon council action, um there are two uh final steps that we will be taking.

41:43

First would be to submit the plan to the Puget Sound Regional Council for consideration for certification.

41:48

Um, as we've informed the council before, that certification uh is critical to ensure prioritization uh for the Tide Flat sub area for future grant funding through the Puget Sound Regional Council.

41:59

Um and then, secondly, any amendments in the Shoreline Master Program must be submitted to the Department of Ecology.

42:05

There is an additional state review process to ensure consistency with state laws.

42:09

Um and the Title 19 amendments do not take effect until finally approved by the Department of Ecology.

42:16

Um with that, I'm happy to answer any questions that the council may have.

42:23

Thank you, Steve, for that presentation.

42:25

Um are there any council questions or comments on this item or items 18 and 19?

42:32

I think I'm gonna reserve um my comments, and I take it because she didn't jump up and press the button that council member walker is going to join me and will reserve our comments for December 2nd on the final reading of this.

42:46

But again, I do want to thank um Barb Church again for bringing up all those names, and I can't wait to Barbara.

42:52

I'm gonna reread your list.

42:54

Um kids already got it.

42:55

I'm gonna reread your list, Barb, um, next week because there are a lot of people who've been really invested in this.

43:01

This was a lot of work.

43:03

Um, and there are a couple of people in these chambers right now, one of them standing in front of me, who I'm just thinking, I don't know what you're gonna do after December 2nd.

43:14

Um Steve, you may actually get to do something other than sub-area plan in the planning department.

43:19

But um seeing no questions or comments at this time, we'll move on to item 18, and Steve will save our long-winded comments for December 2nd.

43:29

All right, moving on to item 18, Clerk, will you please read?

43:33

Ordinance 29076 and ordinance amending title 13 of the municipal code relating to the land use regulatory code by amending various chapters to implement the tide flat sub-area plan, including updates to land use, zoning, and death development standards as recommended by the Tide Flat Steering Committee and Planning Commission effective January 5th, 2026.

43:51

All right, just real quickly before I um before I say anything about this.

43:55

I want to remind everybody of the ordinance that 29075 will be set over a final reading on December 2nd.

44:02

All right, we um this item was just presented on item 18.

44:06

Are there any additional council questions or comments?

44:09

All right, seeing none, this ordinance will be set over for final reading on December 2nd, 2025.

44:13

Item 19, Clerk, will you please read?

44:16

Ordinance 29077, an ordinance amending Title 19 of the municipal code relating to the Shoreline Master Plan by amending various sections to implement the Tide Flat Sub-area Plan, including updates to shoreline environment designations and land use zoning and development standards as recommended by the Tide Flat Steering Committee and Planning Commission, effective upon approval by the Washington State Department of Ecology.

44:39

All right, this item was just presented.

44:41

Are there any additional council questions or comments?

44:43

All right, seeing none, this ordinance will be set over for final reading on December 2nd, 2025.

44:49

Moving on to unfinished business.

44:50

Is there any unfinished business?

44:52

Seeing none, moving on to reports by the city manager.

44:55

City manager, do you have a report this evening?

44:57

Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of council, deputy mayor.

45:00

It's actually a continuation from your special meeting that we uh did close up.

45:04

It's uh a celebration for the city of Tacoma.

45:06

I'm pleased tonight to share with the City of Tacoma that we have been officially recognized as the Vision Zero as a Vision Zero community by the Vision Zero Network, a national honor that reflects our strong commitment to eliminating traffic fatalities and serious injuries by 2035.

45:22

This recognition fulfills a key goal in resolution 40559 and highlights the hard work of our public works transportation team.

45:29

Uh while the network emphasized our uh the network and this recognition emphasized our vehicle safety efforts.

45:35

Our vision zero work is much broader, encompassing street design, speed reduction, education, and equitable enforcement.

45:42

Congratulations to the Vision Zero team for this well-earned recognition and for the continuing um efforts to make Tacoma Streets safer for all.

45:51

Thank you, Mayor.

45:52

That is my brief report to you.

45:55

Um thank you very very much.

45:57

And um, I'm gonna go ahead and just put uh you can this is I'm gonna do this, and this is for the staff and everybody who works to make this possible, but I'm gonna do it to the leader over here, our policy leader in Councilmember Walker, who has been a Vision Zero champion since day one, and to all the staff who've been working so hard on this.

46:17

Thank you so much.

46:17

This is great recognition.

46:19

Um now we just got to keep doing the work.

46:21

All right.

46:22

With that, I would uh move on to comments and committee reports of the council, and I'm gonna call on Councilmember Heinz, Chair of the Government Performance and Finance Committee.

46:30

Uh thank you, Madam Mayor.

46:31

The government performance and finance committee has convened twice since the last update on October 21st.

46:36

The agenda contained three briefing items.

46:38

Staff provided an insurance one-on-one overview of the city's insurance policies, and the second and third briefing items were presented by staff to discuss an ordinance for two telecommunication franchise agreements with Fat Beam, LLC, and Forge Fibers 37 LLC.

46:52

The committee met again on November 4th uh to discuss three briefing items.

46:56

The staff proposed amending to COM Municipal Code Title 12, Section 12.10.310 to revise Tacoma Water System Development Charge for new water service connections effective February 1st, 2026.

47:08

Second briefing item was by staff with recommendations to amend to coal municipal code to expand solid waste the solid waste pilot project, allowing collection and safe disposal of hazardous materials from certain customers.

47:19

And the final briefing item was a follow-up on the December 2024 adoption of the Tacoma Municipal Code on special permits and tax deductions for recyclable material hauling.

47:28

The next GPFC meeting is November 18th at 10 a.m.

47:32

in room 248 of the Tacoma Missicial Building.

47:34

The public is also invited to attend virtually.

47:51

Madam Mayor, that concludes my report.

47:53

Thank you very much, Councilmember Hines.

47:55

Are there any additional council cork council comments this evening?

47:59

All right, I just want to make one.

48:01

Um sometimes fun things happen, and something fun happened to me today, and I don't always do this, but I I'm feeling like I want this young person to be able to turn on the TV and um and watch this portion of the meeting.

48:15

So I want to show this to everyone.

48:19

Um it is a panda, and this is this was given to me uh by Penny.

48:26

And Penny created for me in here an advent.

48:29

I'm calling it an advent calendar because it has candy in it of my last of my last four meetings, and inside each piece of paper is a laffy taffy, which is my favorite um candy.

48:41

So um, Penny, I want to thank you for this incredible gift, and I want your mom to turn on the TV for you so you can see that I thanked you on camera.

48:49

It was very sweet, and I'm gonna enjoy eating all of the laffy taffy and maybe sharing it with my colleagues.

48:54

Um with that, I will move on to the second to the final um uh motion tonight, and I will turn to the deputy mayor.

49:02

I moved to excuse council member Rumbach from the meeting tonight.

49:06

Second.

49:06

All right, all those in favor signify by saying aye.

49:09

Aye.

49:09

All those opposed.

49:10

The motion is declared adopted.

49:12

Final motion.

49:14

I move to adjourn.

49:15

Second.

49:15

All those in favor signify by saying aye.

49:18

Aye.

49:18

All those opposed.

49:19

The ayes have it.

49:20

We stand adjourned.

49:21

See everybody tonight at the 150th anniversary celebration.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Procedural███████████████████████████████31%
Public Comment██████████████████18%
Engineering And Infrastructure█████████████████17%
Personnel Matters████████████12%
Transportation Safety█████5%
Parks and Recreation████4%
Public Engagement████4%
Affordable Housing███3%
Environmental Protection███3%
Summary of Proceedings

Tacoma City Council Meeting Summary - November 12, 2025

The City Council convened on November 12, 2025, following a land acknowledgement and a moment of silence. The Council adopted the Consent Agenda unanimously and proceeded through Public Comments, where residents addressed the Tide Flat Sub-area Plan (Ordinance 29075), the EMS Property Tax Levy, and the Street Initiative. Regular agenda items, including resolutions regarding street vacation fees, vendor contracts, and labor agreements, were reviewed, with several items postponed for staff presentation before final voting. The meeting concluded with reports on the city's Vision Zero recognition and committee updates.

Consent Calendar

  • Resolution 41792 and associated routine measures were adopted by unanimous vote (Aye).

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Kathy Irwin expressed strong opposition to the Tide Flat Sub-area Plan (Ordinance 29075); she argued the pace of the plan has been too slow, resulting in significant changes before final approval, and criticized the proposed lack of green space and environmental amenities in the Port area.
  • Michelle Reich expressed opposition to the EMS Property Tax Levy (Ordinance 29072); she described the $9 million annual tax as wasteful funding that exacerbates homelessness and argued that funds should be allocated to a veterans' center rather than a low-barrier drug use center.
  • Kit Burns questioned the rationale behind reducing the valuation of a street vacation item (Item 25-1004) from $2.9 million to $600,000 without sufficient clarification in the agenda, implying a potential discrepancy in the funds.
  • Kit Burns questioned the Council's decision not to run the Street Initiative 2 as a bond issue again, noting it failed by only 1,600 votes previously and was poorly presented.
  • Kyle Jolly Boys expressed concern regarding Port of Tacoma expansion; he challenged the safety radius regarding a potential Lahar event, stating his position that the risk radius is 15 miles, not the previously cited 3.5 miles, and requested city meetings on earthquake and disaster preparedness.
  • Barb Church explicitly stated a position in support of the Planning Commission's amendments to the Tide Flat Sub-area Plan; she thanked the Puola Tribe, community members, and advocacy groups for their long-term involvement and urged the Council to adopt the plan to honor the inclusive process.

Discussion Items

  • Street Vacation Fees (Items 10 & 11 context): Mayor Woodards explained that reducing fees to $600,000 was a strategic move to foster a partnership with the University of Washington Tacoma (UWT) and support their capital projects, rather than collecting standard market fees due to current budget constraints.
  • Collective Bargaining Agreements (Items 10, 11, 16): The presentation for Resolutions 41794 and 41795 and Ordinance 29074 was initially postponed because Mark Johnson (Labor Negotiator) was not present. Upon his arrival, he presented details regarding a three-year collective bargaining agreement with District Lodge No. 160/Lodge No. 297 of the IAM (Track Workers and General Units). The agreement includes wage increases (3% general + market adjustments), new classifications (Machine and Fabrication Welder Lead), and holiday additions (Juneteenth).
  • Tide Flat Sub-area Plan (Items 17, 18, 19): Planner Stephen Atkinson presented Ordinance 29075 (adopting the plan), Ordinance 29076 (amending the Land Use Regulatory Code), and Ordinance 29077 (amending the Shoreline Master Program). Atkinson noted that while the City Council public hearing received 19 written and 20 oral comments, the overall feedback was supportive with some requests for amendments. Council members Walker, Woodards, and others reserved final comments for the December 2nd reading.

Key Outcomes

  • Adopted: Resolution 41792 (Consent Agenda).
  • Adopted: Resolution 41793 (Multicare Health Systems contract for $3.9 million).
  • Passed: Ordinance 29069 (No increase in ad valorum general property tax for 2026).
  • Passed: Ordinance 29070 (Fixing ad valorum tax levies for debt services).
  • Passed: Ordinance 29071 (Clarifying EMS levy requirements per Proposition 1; clarifying it is an existing levy, not a new tax).
  • Passed: Ordinance 29072 (Fixing the specific amount of EMS levy for 2026).
  • Postponed: Resolution 41794 (Track Workers CBA), Resolution 41795 (General Unit Letter of Agreement), and Ordinance 29074 were voted upon and adopted after the presentation was completed (Items 10, 11, 16).
  • Set Over: Ordinances 29075, 29076, and 29077 (Tide Flat Sub-area Plan) for final reading on December 2, 2025.
  • Recognized: The City of Tacoma officially received Vision Zero Community recognition from the Vision Zero Network.
  • Adjourned: The meeting was adjourned with a reference to the 150th Anniversary celebration.

Meeting Transcript

Now we're gonna gavel back in. I'd like to call to order the city council meeting of November 12th, 2025. Clerk, will you please call a roll? Councilmember Bushnell? Present. Deputy Mayor Daniels. Aye. Here Councilmember Diaz. Councilmember Hines. Councilmember Remba, absent. Councilmember Sidalgay? Here. Councilmember Scott? Here. Councilmember Walker? Here. Mayor Woodards? Here. Please join me in listening to the land of law land acknowledgement and flag salute led by Councilmember Bush now, followed by a moment of silence. We gratefully honor it, acknowledge that we rest on the traditional lands of the Puola people where they make their home and speak the Lashutsi language. Please stand for the flag salute and remain standing for a moment of silence. Are there any modifications to the agenda? Seeing none, we'll move on to the consent agenda. I move to adopt the consent agenda, including resolution number 41792. Second. Are there any council questions or comments? All right, seeing none, all those in favor of adopting the consent agenda, please signify by saying aye. Aye. All those opposed. Consent agenda is declared adopted. There are no proclamations, uh recognitions, or presentations this afternoon. Um now we're gonna move on to public comment. On tonight's agenda, there is one opportunity for people to comment. As a reminder, community reform was removed from the agenda by the council motion at last week's study session. The next regular community form is scheduled on December 9th, 2025. Under public comment, you can speak about motions, resolutions, or ordinances on tonight's agenda. This form is intended to give speakers the opportunity to share their viewpoints and feedback with the city council to aid in our decision making, and it is not meant to be a back and forth dialogue. Your remarks should be directed to the city council and not at individual staff members. If you wish to speak under the public comment period, please press the raise your hand button near the bottom of your Zoom window or star nine on your phone now, so we can see the number of people wishing to testify this afternoon. If you're speaking in person, please sign up at the back of the room if you have not done so already. Your name or the last four digits of your phone number will be called out when it is your turn to speak. Clerk, will you please read? This is a time set aside for public comment. Speakers are asked to identify the specific legislation they wish to address. All right, I would like to remind everyone to please keep your comments respectful, relevant, focused, and on topic. We strive to provide a comment period where people can feel respected while sharing a wide variety of viewpoints and acknowledge that we may hear comments that conflict with our values. To ensure all speakers can express their first amendment constitutional rights, we ask that you refrain from clapping, cheering, booing, or otherwise being disruptive. You will have 90 seconds to make your remarks. Please be mindful of the time frame. As always, you are not required to use all of your time to make your point.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com