OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Ukiah, California/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Ukiah City Council Regular Meeting – November 4, 2026

City Council — Wednesday, November 4, 2026
BodyUkiah, California
SessionCity Council
DateWednesday, November 4, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
Meeting Thumbnail
⇩ GET FROM SOURCE

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Original source
Transcript — Verbatim

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

0:06

If I could have uh everybody come in uh grab a seat or stand in the back, we'll get the program going.

0:13

If I could have the fire district board and the city council please joining me up at the front

Unassigned speaker

0:20

here,

Speaker 1

0:43

Chief Jennings.

1:04

I

Speaker 2

1:04

do, but she's definitely always what time you ever do, which is here.

Speaker 3

1:13

Director Graham, just

Speaker 1

1:26

evening everyone, Chief Buckingham.

1:28

Please join me up at the front.

1:32

We'll have we'll have you stand over there in front of the flags.

1:35

So we're just gonna talk about you, so from afar.

Unassigned speaker

1:40

Uh

Speaker 1

1:40

I want to welcome everybody here this evening, our team members, uh, community, family, friends.

1:45

This is truly a um exciting evening to be able to uh do the formal oath of office and swearing in and badge pinning for uh Chief uh Justin Buckingham.

1:56

So big round of applause for the chief here tonight.

2:09

It's it's almost like a reunion.

2:11

I'm seeing people, past directors here, past chiefs, past team members, um, both old and current.

2:18

And uh it's really nice to have you all here today to uh support the chief and taking this next step in his professional career.

2:26

Um when I was meeting with Chief Buckingham, you know, it almost feels like the weight of the world is placed on you as you take on these offices.

2:35

And uh there is there's a lot of responsibility, um, there's a lot that comes with it, a lot of accountability, and um, and there's a lot that you want to do.

2:45

And uh it's not a race, it's a it's a journey, as one council member often tells me.

2:51

And uh part of that journey is um with all of you here and uh those that couldn't be here this evening because the only way that we truly in these positions are successful is by working with all of you and having the support of each other, and that's what's so special about our community is that uh people here are not just numbers.

3:14

We are friends, family, neighbors, um, and all part of that community.

3:19

And I know that um all of you will contribute to this success of Chief Buckingham by being there and being supportive, both from a knowledge perspective and um and and otherwise.

3:34

So with that, I also have the city council and the Ukaya Valley Fire Protection District Board of Directors here with me this evening um for the oath of office, and uh I'm gonna ask uh

Unassigned speaker

3:47

uh

Speaker 1

3:47

President Bushby um to say a few words at this

Unassigned speaker

3:50

time.

Speaker 1

3:56

I'm gonna I'll just hold on to the mic, right?

3:58

You know, I have

Speaker 3

4:00

pictures here.

4:03

Um, you know, I didn't write anything down because I just shoot from the hip, and sometimes it makes sense, sometimes it doesn't, right?

Unassigned speaker

4:12

Uh

Speaker 3

4:12

I love this guy.

4:14

We worked together.

Unassigned speaker

4:15

He

Speaker 3

4:15

was North Station, I was South Station, a couple of captains showing up at the same time.

4:20

He'd take over the scenes.

4:22

I'm kidding.

4:24

Um, so Buck.

4:27

First off, thank you everybody for being here.

4:30

He appreciates it, the fire department appreciates

Unassigned speaker

4:33

it.

Unassigned speaker

4:34

The

Speaker 3

4:34

police department appreciates it.

4:36

They're part of the they're part of the family and the people that work here at the city.

4:40

You all do a really, really good job.

4:43

City Council, thank you for being here.

4:45

Um,

Unassigned speaker

4:48

I

Speaker 3

4:48

don't think that you uh throughout your career ever thought that you were going to be a fire chief somewhere.

Unassigned speaker

4:56

You

Speaker 3

4:56

didn't plan on doing

Unassigned speaker

4:57

it.

Speaker 3

4:58

I did tell him two months ago when you're just a little bit, you know, thinking, what am I doing here?

5:04

I said, Buck, hold out, you'll be chief one day.

5:08

Did I not say

Unassigned speaker

5:09

that?

Unassigned speaker

5:10

About three months ago.

Speaker 3

5:12

And it came true.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Engineering And Infrastructure██████████████████████22%
Historic Preservation████████████12%
Energy Management████████████12%
Public Safety███████████11%
Technology and Innovation█████████9%
Procedural████████8%
Pending Litigation████████8%
Personnel Matters███████7%
Economic Development██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Ukiah City Council Regular Meeting – November 4, 2026

The City Council met at 5:35 PM on November 4, 2026, following a Fire Chief Oath of Office ceremony for Chief Justin Buckingham. The meeting covered a consent calendar, public comments, council and city manager reports, unfinished business on the Palace Hotel, emergency contracts, distributed generation policies, and new business on a hotels ordinance and city manager contract amendment.

Consent Calendar

  • Report of Disbursements for September 2026 approved.
  • Authorization for sole-source purchase of specialized irrigation equipment for Phase 1 of the Ukiah Valley Golf Course Recycled Water Connection Project, with a budget amendment increasing an internal loan from $200,000 to $250,000, approved.
  • Acceptance of a $1,000,000 grant from the County of Sonoma, on behalf of the Russian River Watershed Association, for watershed-wide governance solutions; the city will act as fiscal agent. Approved.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Helen Sizemore urged the council to waive historic preservation requirements for the old post office, noting non-historic additions (e.g., plywood) and the desire for viable reuse.
  • Palace Hotel discussion (13a): Multiple speakers addressed the building's condition and future:
    • Jim Werner called the scaffolding inadequate and urged street closures or a shoring plan.
    • Karen Rifkin cited her book, providing historical cost estimates for seismic retrofitting (initially $2.32–$3 million, later $7 million).
    • August Temple (from Lake County) opposed demolition, proposing a cannabis dispensary to fund restoration.
    • Anne Marie Borges, a real estate agent, expressed confidence in finding outside investors and praised owner Tom Carter's work.
    • Kevin Murphy encouraged the council to define "stabilization" and work cooperatively with Carter.
    • Steven Johnson, former attorney for a previous owner, criticized the city's antagonistic approach and urged collaboration.
    • Dennis Crane echoed calls for cooperation and noted the city's general plan goal to assist owners of unreinforced masonry buildings.
    • Quinn Ellis questioned the focus on nostalgia, suggesting repurposing the building for housing and businesses.
    • Chad Holch noted that Carter's work may have prevented damage during the June earthquake.
    • O'Rein Walker cited a successful historic building reuse in Salem, Oregon.
    • Other speakers (including a family historian, a neighbor, and a worker) supported Carter's craftsmanship and commitment.
  • City Manager contract (14b): Julie Golden requested more transparency and a two-week delay for public review of the proposed amendment; council proceeded to vote.

Discussion Items

  • Proclamation: Recognized November as Native American Heritage Month.
  • Council Reports:
    • Councilmember reported on MCOG field trip along Highway 101 rehab and the Great Redwood Trail in Hopland.
    • Vice Mayor attended the Russian River Confluence meeting, highlighting coordination among watershed organizations.
    • Councilmember noted a successful downtown community event.
    • Mayor attended a ribbon cutting for the first stage of the city-owned fiber optic high-speed internet project.
  • City Manager Reports:
    • Opportunity Zone 2.0: Community Development Director Craig Schlauter announced that census tract 116 (covering Ukiah's commercial area) was certified by the U.S. Treasury as an Opportunity Zone, effective January 1, 2027, for 10 years. The city's resolution and community support were credited. 2,479 tracts were initially eligible; 620 were selected.
    • Flock Camera Policy: Acting Police Chief Max Brazil reported new safeguards: data sharing revoked for all but neighboring counties (Sonoma, Napa, Lake, Humboldt, Marin, and CHP), requiring signed MOUs; weekly internal audits; mandatory training. The changes respond to community concerns.
    • County Core 2.0 Program: City Manager noted the county's updated program to assist individuals in crisis, with activities starting at the public health office on Dora Street; a building purchase on Dora Street is pending.
    • Deputy City Clerk Recognition: City Clerk Christine Lawler recognized Araceli Sandoval for earning the Certified Municipal Clerk (CMC) designation.
  • Palace Hotel (13a):
    • Chief Building Official Matt Kaiser reported the building remains deemed unstable per a 2024 ZFA engineering report. Owner Tom Carter provided a letter from architect Richard Ruff (Ruffin Associates) stating safety measures (fencing, scaffolding) were in place, allowing entry for consultants and workers. Council and staff found the letter insufficient, requesting a more detailed structural engineer report or a plan to refute the ZFA findings. Councilmember Crane noted the need for a clear definition of "stabilization." The city manager emphasized the city's fiduciary duty to public safety. After public comment, council directed Carter to provide a timeline for obtaining a professional report or a phased stabilization plan. Carter agreed to work with Ruff and possibly ZFA. No vote was taken; the item will return at a future meeting.
  • Emergency Contract: Landslide Mitigation (13b): The contract with Diamond D Construction for work at the Pressure Zone 1 water storage tank was reviewed. Materials are mobilizing; work expected in two weeks, weather permitting. Council determined emergency conditions continue and authorized continuation. Approved 5-0.
  • Emergency Contract: Oak Manor Underground Infrastructure (13c): Electric Utility Director Cindy Sowers reported that a failed conductor and three transformers were replaced; conduit installed; final costs to be reported at next meeting. Council authorized continuation. Approved 5-0.
  • Distributed Generation Policies (13d):
    • Sowers and Intercon engineer Trisha Swain presented a hosting capacity study and policy review. The study found aggregate DER (6.5 MW existing) is constrained by reverse power flow limits to PG&E; after adding the city's planned 3 MW solar at the wastewater plant, only 1.2 MW additional capacity remains. The policy limits solar to a customer's 12-month usage, requires technical screening, and addresses plug-in solar (SB 868) effective January 2027. Batteries can complicate grid stability. Council received the report and affirmed the Electric Utility's administrative policies on distributed generation. Approved 5-0.
  • Hotels and Lodging Ordinance (14a): Deputy City Manager Shannon Riley and Building Official Kaiser presented an ordinance limiting hotel stays to 30 days in transient occupancies not built to residential code. The ordinance aims to prevent safety hazards (overloaded circuits, pests) and TOT revenue loss. Properties can change use via permit. Introduced by title only; second reading will follow. Passed 5-0.
  • City Manager Contract Amendment (14b): City Manager Sage Sangiacomo announced his intention to retire in 2028 after 32 years. The amendment sets a fixed term ending December 9, 2028, increases severance from 9 to 12 months (with an 18-month post-election provision), and adds accrued leave payout. No salary change. Council adopted the resolution. Approved 5-0.
  • Committee Assignments (14c): Council received updates; no modifications requested.

Key Outcomes

  • Approved Consent Calendar items (disbursements, irrigation equipment, RRWA grant) unanimously.
  • Authorized continuation of emergency contracts for Diamond D Construction (landslide mitigation) and Wipf Construction (Oak Manor infrastructure) by 5-0 votes.
  • Affirmed Electric Utility's distributed generation policies, including limits on solar sizing and technical review requirements.
  • Introduced a new ordinance prohibiting stays over 30 days in transient hotels; second reading pending.
  • Adopted a resolution amending the City Manager's employment agreement to a fixed term through December 9, 2028, with enhanced severance provisions.
  • Directed Palace Hotel owner Tom Carter to provide a timeline and structural engineering report or plan to demonstrate building stabilization; no vote taken.

Meeting Transcript

If I could have uh everybody come in uh grab a seat or stand in the back, we'll get the program going. If I could have the fire district board and the city council please joining me up at the front here, Chief Jennings. I do, but she's definitely always what time you ever do, which is here. Director Graham, just evening everyone, Chief Buckingham. Please join me up at the front. We'll have we'll have you stand over there in front of the flags. So we're just gonna talk about you, so from afar. Uh I want to welcome everybody here this evening, our team members, uh, community, family, friends. This is truly a um exciting evening to be able to uh do the formal oath of office and swearing in and badge pinning for uh Chief uh Justin Buckingham. So big round of applause for the chief here tonight. It's it's almost like a reunion. I'm seeing people, past directors here, past chiefs, past team members, um, both old and current. And uh it's really nice to have you all here today to uh support the chief and taking this next step in his professional career. Um when I was meeting with Chief Buckingham, you know, it almost feels like the weight of the world is placed on you as you take on these offices. And uh there is there's a lot of responsibility, um, there's a lot that comes with it, a lot of accountability, and um, and there's a lot that you want to do. And uh it's not a race, it's a it's a journey, as one council member often tells me. And uh part of that journey is um with all of you here and uh those that couldn't be here this evening because the only way that we truly in these positions are successful is by working with all of you and having the support of each other, and that's what's so special about our community is that uh people here are not just numbers. We are friends, family, neighbors, um, and all part of that community. And I know that um all of you will contribute to this success of Chief Buckingham by being there and being supportive, both from a knowledge perspective and um and and otherwise. So with that, I also have the city council and the Ukaya Valley Fire Protection District Board of Directors here with me this evening um for the oath of office, and uh I'm gonna ask uh uh President Bushby um to say a few words at this time. I'm gonna I'll just hold on to the mic, right? You know, I have pictures here. Um, you know, I didn't write anything down because I just shoot from the hip, and sometimes it makes sense, sometimes it doesn't, right? Uh I love this guy. We worked together. He was North Station, I was South Station, a couple of captains showing up at the same time. He'd take over the scenes. I'm kidding. Um, so Buck. First off, thank you everybody for being here. He appreciates it, the fire department appreciates it. The police department appreciates it. They're part of the they're part of the family and the people that work here at the city. You all do a really, really good job. City Council, thank you for being here. Um, I

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com