OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Whitehall, Ohio/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Whitehall City Council Meeting - May 19, 2026: Recall Resolutions and Community Testimony

City Council — Tuesday, May 19, 2026
BodyWhitehall, Ohio
SessionCity Council
DateTuesday, May 19, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 1:48:06

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

0:06

Mayor no

Speaker 2

0:07

just

Speaker 1

0:07

came up.

Unassigned speaker

0:08

Oh, there.

Unassigned speaker

0:09

Okay.

Speaker 2

0:11

Good evening, everyone.

0:12

Welcome to the White Hall City Council agenda meeting for Tuesday, May 19th, 2026.

0:17

We will start with a moment of silence, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:21

We'll then go into our roll call.

0:24

Then that'll be followed by the approval of the May 6th, 2026 agenda and regular meeting minutes.

0:28

I'll need someone to make a motion.

Speaker 3

0:29

I'll make a motion.

Speaker 2

0:30

Thank you, Mr.

0:31

Dixon.

Unassigned speaker

0:33

One

Speaker 3

0:33

second.

Speaker 2

0:34

Thank you, Mr.

0:35

Atkins.

Speaker 3

0:36

Is everyone going to be here on the roll call?

0:39

Yes.

Speaker 2

0:39

Mr.

0:41

Devin is running a little bit late.

0:42

Mr.

0:42

Brown is running a little bit late due to uh traffic situation.

Speaker 3

0:46

Thank

Unassigned speaker

0:47

you.

Speaker 2

0:49

We'll then have a presentation by the director of Franklin County Board of Elections, Anton White.

0:54

So appreciate him coming.

0:56

We'll then move into our standing committee reports, officials reports.

1:01

And then since our last meeting, there have been no official reports filed in the council council office under communications, petitions, and claims.

1:09

There have been no communications, petitions, and claims have been filed since our last meeting.

1:13

We'll then have our first poll public and uh folks will have up to three minutes to speak.

1:19

And they can speak on any topic they like, and they just are required to uh state their name and city of residence.

1:26

Then have our verification of copies, and then we'll get into our legislation.

1:30

Uh there is no legislation for third reading.

1:33

Um under second reading, which will go by title only.

1:37

We have orders 34, 2026, allowing a special permit under 1125.04 to allow drive-through facilities that are properly located at 46 out of East Broad Street, parcel number 090 008 427-000, and 090-008249-00.

Unassigned speaker

1:57

Uh

Speaker 2

1:57

property owned by Meyer Foods Management Company and declaring emergency.

2:01

Again, that's title only.

2:03

Under first reading, we have several items.

2:05

First is resolution 16, 2026, a resolution providing for the submission of the question of the recall of Mayor Michael Bibbis, the electors of the city, and the declaration of an emergency.

2:16

I will need somebody to introduce.

2:19

Mr.

2:20

Morrison.

2:22

Looking for a second.

2:24

Second.

2:24

Thank you.

Unassigned speaker

2:26

Mr.

Speaker 2

2:26

McCann.

2:30

We then have resolution 17, 2026.

2:33

A resolution providing for the submission of the question of the recall of Councilmember Gloria Elmore, the electors of the city, and the declaration of an emergency.

2:41

This will also need somebody to introduce.

2:43

I'll introduce

Speaker 4

2:45

Dixon.

Speaker 2

2:47

And somebody to second.

2:49

Yes, I'll second.

2:50

Dr.

2:50

Mr.

2:50

Atkins.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Procedural██████████████████████22%
Community Engagement██████████████████████22%
Racial Equity████████████12%
Public Safety███████████11%
Government Structure██████████10%
Public Engagement██████6%
Elections███3%
Fiscal Sustainability███3%
Parks and Recreation███3%
Summary of Proceedings

Whitehall City Council Meeting - May 19, 2026

During the May 19, 2026 meeting, the Whitehall City Council heard from Franklin County Board of Elections Director Antone White, who recommended June 23, 2026, as the date for a special recall election. After extensive public testimony and council debate, the council adopted three resolutions to place the recall of Mayor Michael Bivens, Councilmember Lori Elmore, and Councilmember Amy Harcar on the ballot. The council also received updates on the Yearling Road construction project, city finances, and community events.

Special Presentation

  • Antone White, Director of the Franklin County Board of Elections, requested that the special recall election be set for June 23, 2026 (a Tuesday). He cited operational advantages, including the ability to offer a full early and absentee voting schedule, avoidance of conflicts with the July 4th holiday, and the need to complete the election before statewide signature validation work begins on July 1. The council accepted this recommendation.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • First Poll Public: Multiple residents spoke, most expressing support for Mayor Bivens, Councilmember Elmore, and Councilmember Harcar, and criticizing the recall effort.
    • Michael Spicer (Whitehall resident) stated that recall organizers do not speak for the majority and urged a "yes" vote for continued progress.
    • Glenn Henson (Whitehall resident) complained about a neighbor running a construction business from his residence and said he had not received a return call from the mayor’s office or the police chief.
    • Fred Malar (on behalf of the Baptist Pastors Conference) voiced support for the mayor and quoted scripture.
    • Rob Herbert (Whitehall resident) praised the changes under the current administration and said he moved to Whitehall because of the mayor’s leadership.
    • Tony Wilborn (Whitehall resident) called for the community to operate in love and expressed sadness that some residents feel pushed out of the city.
    • Chelsea Johnson (owner of Columbus Chaos Women’s Football team) thanked Mayor Bivens for supporting women’s sports and endorsed his leadership.
    • Harper Blake (Whitehall resident) encouraged everyone to do their own research and support the recall targets.
    • Michael Young (lead pastor of City of Grace Church, Columbus) called Elmore (first Black councilmember) and Bivens (first Black mayor) history makers, accused the FOP Lodge No. 9 of financing the recall, and questioned the motivation behind it.
  • Second Poll Public: Additional testimony focused on support for Police Chief Mike Crispin and condemnation of the recall’s divisiveness.
    • Diane Peters (Whitehall resident) thanked the administration for community conversations but said the recall has changed her view of Whitehall. She criticized FOP Lodge 9 for funding the recall.
    • Joel Harcar (Whitehall resident) urged a "yes" vote for proven leadership and highlighted the accomplishments of the three recall targets.

Discussion Items

  • Mayor’s Report: Mayor Michael Bivens delivered an emotional address beginning with Rudyard Kipling’s poem “If.” He defended his administration’s fiscal management and transparency, criticized the recall effort as divisive, and stated the recall is being financed by the Fraternal Order of Police (FOP) Lodge 9. He addressed concerns that he is pushing certain residents out of the city, declaring that he serves all residents regardless of race, gender, or orientation. He expressed confusion over claims that Whitehall is becoming a “black and white” issue.
  • Treasurer’s Report: Treasurer Trevel Balser reported that the city is in a strong financial position with a robust investment portfolio yielding approximately 3.5–3.7% return. He noted he is working to update outdated financial reports on the city website, some of which had not been updated since before COVID.
  • Public Service Report: Director Casey Rowlands updated that the Yearling Road project is nearing completion. Brick pavers in crosswalks will be removed this week, asphalt will be laid next week, and the August 1 finish date remains on track. He clarified that donated dedication bricks in sidewalks will not be removed.
  • Legislation – Second Reading: ORDINANCE NO. 034-2026, allowing a special permit for drive-through facilities at 4600 E Broad Street (property owned by Meyer Foods Management Company), was read by title only. No vote was taken; it will be considered at a future meeting.
  • Legislation – First Reading:
    • RESOLUTION NO. 016-2026 (Providing for submission of recall of Mayor Michael Bivens): Introduced by Councilmember Morrison, seconded by McCann. After suspension of rules, councilmembers spoke in support of the mayor. A motion to adopt passed 7-0 (Elmore, Morrison, Harcar, Adkins, McCann, Dixon, Brown all voting yes).
    • RESOLUTION NO. 017-2026 (Recall of Councilmember Lori Elmore): Introduced by Dixon, seconded by Adkins. Suspension of rules and adoption passed 7-0. Councilmembers delivered statements defending Elmore’s integrity and record.
    • RESOLUTION NO. 018-2026 (Recall of Councilmember Amy Harcar): Introduced by Morrison, seconded by Dixon. Suspension and adoption passed 7-0. Harcar addressed the reasons for her recall, connecting it to her advocacy for immigrants, refugees, and LGBTQ residents. She and supporters argued the recall is a political effort to remove voices for inclusion.
    • RESOLUTION NO. 019-2026 (Authorizing a plan with the Whitehall Community Improvement Corporation): Read by title only. Economic Development Director Jackie Russell gave a brief overview, explaining it formalizes the CIC’s cooperative agreement. Discussion was postponed to the next committee meeting.

Key Outcomes

  • The council voted 7-0 to adopt each of the three recall resolutions (016, 017, 018), formally placing the recall of Mayor Michael Bivens, Councilmember Lori Elmore, and Councilmember Amy Harcar on the June 23, 2026 special election ballot.
  • The council accepted the Franklin County Board of Elections’ recommendation to set the special election for June 23, 2026.
  • The council postponed detailed consideration of RESOLUTION NO. 019-2026 (CIC agreement) to the next committee meeting.
  • The council approved the minutes of the May 6, 2026 meeting by a unanimous vote.
  • Community events were announced: Big Summer Kickoff on June 5, Juneteenth celebration on June 20, and a Memorial Day ceremony on May 25 at 10 a.m. at City Hall.

Meeting Transcript

Mayor no just came up. Oh, there. Okay. Good evening, everyone. Welcome to the White Hall City Council agenda meeting for Tuesday, May 19th, 2026. We will start with a moment of silence, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. We'll then go into our roll call. Then that'll be followed by the approval of the May 6th, 2026 agenda and regular meeting minutes. I'll need someone to make a motion. I'll make a motion. Thank you, Mr. Dixon. One second. Thank you, Mr. Atkins. Is everyone going to be here on the roll call? Yes. Mr. Devin is running a little bit late. Mr. Brown is running a little bit late due to uh traffic situation. Thank you. We'll then have a presentation by the director of Franklin County Board of Elections, Anton White. So appreciate him coming. We'll then move into our standing committee reports, officials reports. And then since our last meeting, there have been no official reports filed in the council council office under communications, petitions, and claims. There have been no communications, petitions, and claims have been filed since our last meeting. We'll then have our first poll public and uh folks will have up to three minutes to speak. And they can speak on any topic they like, and they just are required to uh state their name and city of residence. Then have our verification of copies, and then we'll get into our legislation. Uh there is no legislation for third reading. Um under second reading, which will go by title only. We have orders 34, 2026, allowing a special permit under 1125.04 to allow drive-through facilities that are properly located at 46 out of East Broad Street, parcel number 090 008 427-000, and 090-008249-00. Uh property owned by Meyer Foods Management Company and declaring emergency. Again, that's title only. Under first reading, we have several items. First is resolution 16, 2026, a resolution providing for the submission of the question of the recall of Mayor Michael Bibbis, the electors of the city, and the declaration of an emergency. I will need somebody to introduce. Mr. Morrison. Looking for a second. Second. Thank you. Mr. McCann.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com