0:04I'll call the meeting to order.
0:07If the uh clerk will please read the roll or take the roll.
0:11Chair person, councilman Clark.
0:16Councilmember Scipio, President, and Councilmember Taylor.
0:22Mayor Pro Tim Adams is under the weather today, but is look watching us on TV.
0:27And I don't think the Zoom is working.
0:31So she said if I do anything she wants to say, she'll email me or text me.
0:38See if I want to recognize her or not.
0:41See what's going on here.
0:43Okay, we will now get going on our monthly meeting.
0:50We have three consent items.
0:52Is there any item anyone would want to pull?
0:59I make a motion to approve the balance.
1:01We have a motion to second approve the ballots.
1:03All in favor say aye.
1:13Item C one report from the Film Partnership of North Carolina on use of city grant funds to support intern.
1:26Should I should I make a comment before this?
1:29Oh yeah, hang on a minute.
1:31Hippie will pull if she'd like to make a comment.
1:35Um I just wanted to say this is just uh one of those emerging industries that we have been uh supporting for many many years in Weston Salem, and it really started as I can recall when the school yards film school came to town, and that was somewhere back in the 90s, I believe.
1:57And to see where we are today is just another testament of how our community underwrites uh unique initiative.
2:06Raoult, just an overview of what we've done, what we're doing, and how this has impacted us so far.
2:16Good afternoon, Chairman Clark, mayor joins members of City Council.
2:19So back in uh September of 2022, uh the City Council authorized a grant of a hundred thousand dollars to the film partnership of North Carolina to support an intern program to help uh really grow the production workforce here in the triad.
2:36Um the uh more union-based workforce exists in Wilmington and and Charlotte, and there's been efforts you know to try to help uh you know bolster the production workforce here so that more film and television and even streaming uh productions could could locate here.
2:54Um so it's been a couple years since that grant was awarded.
3:00Uh they have provided us a report on the their use of the grant, and that was included in the uh item uh on the finance committee agenda.
3:09Just very briefly, uh they were able to place 70 interns uh in 10 productions, and if you see there on the report, the uh the interns come from various zip codes throughout the city.
3:22They've also established a number of partnerships uh locally with uh once the same state university for site technical community college.
3:31Uh so uh I think we've really have seen the you know the productions here lately uh continue to grow.
3:38Uh a couple you know recent ones, uh a little prayer, which is actually I think playing right now at Aperture, and then uh the most recent production that wrapped up was the Bard.
3:48They have another production.
3:50There's another production that's scheduled to start uh at the end of this month.
3:54So uh I would like to just recognize Lauren Vilchik, who's a uh professor on the faculty at the School of Filmmaking, and also a producer who is involved in these projects.
4:03Uh she's here as well as Rebecca Clark with the PMO Triad Film Commission, Bernice Miller, and I'm sorry, sir.
4:09I've uh all folks who are involved with our local uh film industry.
4:16Uh so they're they're here if you have any questions you'd like to ask of them.
4:20Clark, would you like to come up and say anything?
4:23Um come up that wasn't a question.
4:31I was in the I was in the other group.
4:34It felt very very lonely, didn't you?
4:37I thought I was early, but I'm like sorry.
4:42Um just general comment, how's the film industry doing?
4:45So it's it's actually doing great.
4:48Uh a lot of you have heard that for the last 10 years since the film incentive changed at the state level.
5:00Um, you know, most of the projects are going to just Wilmington and Charlotte because those are the two union crew bases.
5:04And so to film here, it actually costs productions more money because they have to house out of town union crew and uh pay per DM for them, you know, travel them in, you know, pay for housing.
5:21So with all that being said, I'm really pleased that Lauren with the film partnership, she um has been working as a producer on the bard and this current film that's getting ready to start, and um and has asked me to help make sure that they find everything they need here, and we've done that.
5:47So for this for the second film, this is the second film in 10 years that has benefited from the state film grant.
5:54So I am over the moon because I want to see this industry grow, I want to see it continue.
6:00We have everything to offer, nothing to lose, and um, so we're on an upward trajectory, definitely, and I want to appreciate I appreciate all you're doing to support film to support the Piedmont Tribe Film Commission to support what Lauren and Bernice are doing with North Carolina Film Partnership and the Tri-City Film Consortium.
6:24Um, it's just we're building such a strong community right now, and it's it's very exciting.
6:31So is there anything we could do to get around this disunion issue?
6:36Well, I have talked a lot to the city managers about some sort of local incentive, but I think even if we worked with through economic development to get some sort of local incentive, there has to be some sort of buy-in from the state legislators, it's something about the bill.
7:01Maybe Ben can talk more about that, but that's one thing I was gonna say because if we could get a local incentive, um it would it would definitely change change things and level the playing field a lot and get us more of the television projects too, like television series that spend a longer time here.
7:24Okay, well, you and band keep talking.
7:28I sent them an article just earlier today about Jacksonville, Florida offering um uh I think a 20% additional incentive, but they have a pot of money that they use to help.
7:42And I I know there's some ways that we can we could work together to make sure it goes to a good project that's gonna provide longer-term job opportunities.
7:53Um, so I I definitely will keep y'all posted and keep talking to Ben.
7:58Okay, thank you very much.
8:00You're welcome, thank you.
8:02Um, just another question.
8:05The new the production that's going to be coming and starting here.
8:09Is there anything you would like from our residents in how they can get connected to that production or not?
8:17Well, I would like maybe Lauren to come up and speak to that as the producer of this film, but I would say on the Piedmont Triad Film Commission Facebook page, I have listed um where crew members can get work on that, and they have lots of opportunities for extras, uh, paid extras.
8:37So please like my Facebook page.
8:41And and your is your Facebook page, give us the identity.
8:46It's Piedmont Film, uh, the Piedmont Triad Film Commission, but my website and the Facebook page is Piedmont Film.
8:58She can give you more information about the partnership specifically.
9:04Uh thank you all for having.
9:07Lauren Lauren Vilchick and 2524 Walker Avenue.
9:14Um, so I am the producer of A Little Prayer.
9:17I'm the producer of the Bard, and I'm a I'm producer of widow.
9:20Also an educator in the area.
9:23So I'm committed to the area.
9:25Also the treasurer of the film partnership.
9:27So the goal is to grow the crew base statewide, but specifically, I'm partial to this area.
9:34So this program has been instrumental.
9:37I did want to make the comment that the way the funds are utilized, we pay directly.
9:43The interns are paid to train.
9:46So the money goes directly to them, it doesn't go to the production.
9:50So I think that that's that's an important nuance.
10:00As far as how the community can get involved with casting, we've taken over Metropolitan Village as our housing, and they are really thrilled about facilitating space where we can conduct casting from that area.
10:12Not only housing, they're talking about building on and having it be a partnership and in more creative involvement in the area.
10:21So we're really seriously considering that.
10:23They're talking about a podcast center in those buildings.
10:27So those kinds of conversations are starting.
10:30And we just held a workshop through uh our partnership with Tri-City Consortium just this weekend where we pulled in another 20 interns.
10:40Some of our crew members are so committed to the training that they were donating their services, pulled out all the equipment, trained more and more people in the community.
10:48And I think we have another 20% of the participants who are interested in actually their first placement.
10:56Thank you very much.
10:57Thank you very much.
11:07I just wanted to uh thank you for that and thank and and congratulate Rebecca for her perseverance.
11:14We had a film that was coming here uh early this summer and uh they needed historic site, and she was they were turned down twice for at two locations, but Rebecca instead of giving up had a brainstorm and said, Let's just film it at yesterday village at the fairgrounds, which turned out to be a double good use for that for that facility.
11:33So, Rebecca, thank you for continuing to push on.
11:37I'm happy to do that.
11:39Thank you, everybody.
11:43We might go to the general agenda to see the current three G1.
11:52Item G1 resolution authorizing the purchase of 29 2026 Ford Maverick compact hybrid pickup trucks.
12:01Good evening, Chair Clark, members of the committee, mayor, members of the council at large.
12:05Uh the item before you is uh a motion to approve a resolution to award um a purchase order for 29 compact pickup trucks.
12:13These are going to be pool vehicles that are used by our fleet.
12:17Um we did a competitive bid for this, received five bids, which you can see on your item here.
12:24Um the low bidder is parks Ford.
12:28Their delivery date is 180 days, and we do need to award to the lowest bidder who's responsive, meaning they submitted all the proper bid forms and they meet our specifications, which they do.
12:39So we're asking for uh an award in the total cost of 866,404 dollars to Parks Ford.
12:48Any questions or comments?
12:51Well uh this versus second item is also trust.
12:59We'll vote on this now.
13:00Can I get a motion to approve G1?
13:03So motion and a second approve G1.
13:06Are we voting orally?
13:08Okay, all in favor say aye.
13:14If the city clerk will read G2 item G2 resolution authorizing the purchase of 83 2026 Ford Interceptor PPVs, good.
13:27Uh the item before you is to purchase off of state contract, um 83 total um PPV uh police pursuit vehicles.
13:36There are 52 gas-powered V6 vehicles and 31 hybrid vehicles on this.
13:44The total cost is 3,547, 64905.
13:49Uh Deacon Jones is the state contract holder.
13:52So any questions or comments?
13:56Can I get a motion to approve?
14:02I have a motion second approve.
14:03All in favor say aye.
14:08Thank you very much.
14:09We will now go to G3.
14:11If the clerk will read that, please.
14:13Item G3 resolution awarding construction contract for Helen Nichols Park walking trail.
14:20I'll start it off again.
14:24This is a resolution asking to award a construction contract for Helen Nichols walking trail.
14:29Uh, this is to create a loop around the Carl Russell uh community center.
14:34Um you can see pieces of that on the colored exhibit there.
14:37Um there's gonna be a fitness station under a shade structure expanding the asphalt to allow better access back to the rentable picnic shelter.
14:45Uh we did bid this back in early 2024, but we had a failed effort.
14:50Our low bidder failed their good faith effort, and the next bid was over the budget that we had at the time.
14:56So um parks look worked to get some more funding.
15:00We put this back out for bid.
15:01We received only one bid from Hodgin Construction Company.
15:07They were actually our number three better the first time, and their price is very close to what they gave us the previous year.
15:13So it was very happy about that number there.
15:15However, that was still over the funds we had available.
15:18So we did um staff worked with the uh contractor and and as well as the consultant to uh remove part of the project in order to get down to the budgeted funds.
15:29So I'll I don't know what details William wants to speak to about that.
15:32But let me ask you a question first.
15:35I'm surprised looking at the drawing why we didn't get more bids.
15:39That doesn't look to be the most complicated thing in the world.
15:43Any thoughts on that?
15:44No, uh, we super received four bids the first time that we bidd.
15:48I'm not sure why we didn't get more the second go-round.
15:51It may have been just a timing issue.
15:53It was bid late, late in 23.
15:57You want to come up, please?
16:00And offer any comments you'd like.
16:03Uh good afternoon, Chair, uh, mayor joins members of the committee.
16:06No, we uh, as Darren mentioned, um went through several bid processes.
16:11Um there'll be the motion in front of you is sort of uh approve and not to exceed amount of 992,000 dollars.
16:18Uh we feel confident through um use of the using the contractor as well as using some government uh contract uh purchasing options to purchase some of the equipment that will be um able to get this within budget and get this bill.
16:33Has this a particular uh vendor done other work for us in the past?
16:40Yes, we've worked with Hodgins on several several projects, in particular recreations uh projects, and they've been very good to work with.
16:46We develop a great relationship with them over the years, so we feel confident uh working with them.
16:52So because you you've had to reduce your cost, does that mean you had to change the design as well?
17:01The design was altered slightly.
17:04The wood originally the path that you see on the east side of the site went up through the uh paved asphalt area, which is just north of the recreation center.
17:14Um that was a little over a tenth of a mile.
17:16Uh that portion of it was eliminated as well as we're buying some things ourselves as opposed to having the contract to buy them and then just charge us a markup on them.
17:25So that's how we were able to get it within budget.
17:28And then what happens with change orders?
17:31The change orders have to stay within the budget.
17:34Yes, change orders typically have to stay within the budget.
17:37Um, but we work with the contractor, um, any engineers, landscape architects, uh, to kind of figure out the best uh in field solution, um, the best most efficient way to move forward.
17:50Um they don't always necessarily uh require a large dollar amount to be successful, but we feel more than confident that we'll be to complete this project based on the information that we already have about this particular site.
18:09Royston, thanks for the presentation.
18:10The trail to the southeast of the property leading over to Carver High School, does that currently exist or is that new a new trail or path that needs to be established?
18:19The one that's just south?
18:21Yes, sir, south uh east.
18:23So that that trail goes down to um we have a ball field uh that the city owns, which is down at the base of that hill.
18:32Um that trail goes down there, provide us maintenance access to that hill.
18:35There's also a set of stairs that um goes down there, but the school's field is right adjacent to it to ours.
18:46We have a motion second.
18:48All in favor, say aye.
18:53We will now go to the last item.
18:56G4, if the city clerk will please read this one.
18:59Item G4 update on the funding status of the city's defined benefit pension plans.
19:04Winston-Salem police officers retirement system and the Winston-Salem police officers separation allowance.
19:12I'm I'm gonna give a a brief sermon here.
19:16Um other folks in the community have not done a good job of stewarding their financial responsibilities.
19:24I consider this a very important presentation.
19:28Uh that will cover both to a certain degree, both pension plans that ensure all are not sure cover all our employees.
19:36The police one, which uh we we actively run, uh, is what Ms.
19:42Latham is going to talk about mostly, but she's gonna comment a little bit on the state pension plan that covers the other employees.
19:51Latham, with that introduction, you have the floor.
19:54Good afternoon, Chair Clark, mayor joins members of committee and council.
20:00Um, this is just an information item to bring you up to speed on the financial status of our two pension plans that we fund.
20:04Um we have the um the WISPers, which is for our sworn officers who were hired before January 1, 2014.
20:13So this is a closed plan.
20:15Um it is meant to replace Social Security because our sworn officers are not eligible for Social Security as this plan replaces that.
20:23Um for those hired after 2014, um, we have a defined contribution plan, which is a little bit different than the WISPers plan.
20:31The WISPers plan is structured very similarly to the state, the local government retirement system plan for our general employees, and um it has been the WISPers plan has been in act of active since 197.
20:45Um we do um bring to you as part of the benefits rate every year to fund this plan as well as the separation allowance plan.
20:54The separation allowance plan is also for sworn officers and it is um required by the state, it's a statutory requirement.
21:02So we have to um ensure that both of these plans are funded adequately so that we can pay the future benefits when our when our employees, when our sworn officers retire.
21:11Um I wanted to mention that our WISPers plan as of January is 84 percent funded, and as of June, um we just got the June report this week is 90 percent funded.
21:23The um the national average for state and local pension plans is 77.7 percent.
21:28So there we are doing better than the average plan.
21:32Um the elders plan, which is structured very similarly to our WISPers plan.
21:38Um, the most recent data I have there is from June of 2024, where it was 83 percent funded, and on that date we were 87 percent funded.
21:47So that's favorable in that we are we are keeping up with the the pension funding and the plan as we should be to make sure that we're we're well funded.
21:57On the separation allowance side, we are 45 percent funded, which means we have 45 percent of the funds we'll need over the years to to make all those payments, and that may seem low, however, it's important to note that most of our peers are funding that just yearly on a pay as you go basis, and the city has made the decision to set aside funds for that to make sure that we are we are planning for that proactively.
22:22Um at any rate, we are um we are looking very good.
22:28The actuary comes and does a study.
22:30Um he does the study every year in January, and then they also look at it again in June.
22:35So we're keeping a close eye on that.
22:37Um the the funded rates are um are component of several factors, so different things affect that, such as our investment earnings, how many people are retiring, what age they're retiring.
22:50Um so it can fluctuate up and down, especially um as the market fluctuates.
22:55We may have a strong year and we may have a year that's not quite as strong.
22:58So you will see that go up and down at any point in time, but over the years we've been very consistent with our funding ratio.
23:06Um the second page in your packet does show kind of a graphical representation of the funding.
23:14So the top graph there is our WISPers plan.
23:17So that shows that our total our total actuarial liability.
23:22So what the actuaries would say that we need over time is 250 million, whereas we have set aside 210 million.
23:29So that's where the 84 percent funded amount comes from.
23:33So our unfunded amount, which is that red line.
23:36So you see that dropping over time, and they're projecting that we'll be fully funded by 2038.
23:43And then on the separation allowance, similarly, we will be fully funded around 2038 or 2039 as well, and that just shows that our total liability we have is 32 million.
23:58We have about 15 million in assets currently set aside.
24:02Um, so we'll need an additional 17 and a half million.
24:05But we have a plan to continue to fund these plans each year so that we can achieve that status of being fully funded.
24:14If you look at your graphs, the top one is the red numbers going up the left side.
24:20What those numbers don't look that's the unfunded amount.
24:24So that 40 million, that's currently as of January.
24:30What the money that we don't have in the bank that we're gonna need in the future.
24:33That's the unfunded because the 84 percent is what 180 million or something like that.
24:45With these funds, they are assumed first those who've already retired, and they're in here, and it anticipates current staff members or employees.
25:01And going forward, is there a projection for an a certain number of employees that we would need to fund, or is this representing where we are with our current retirees and our current staff?
25:17Is this a projection of that?
25:20So the number as of January is based on our current numbers.
25:23So for instance, right now in Whispers, we have 780 in total, but 508 of those are retired.
25:31Around 185 are current employees, and then we have about 87% who are vested but are no longer with the city, so they'll draw in the future.
25:40Since that's a closed plan, the actuary can more accurately determine how much we're going to need over time because there's no new employees coming into the plan.
25:50So when a person say they expire as opposed to retiring, it it how does it impact this?
26:02Um well it's it's structured similarly to the elders plan.
26:07So the employees name a beneficiary who who received their funds, and then there's a number of different funding um when they retire.
26:14There's there's different options they can choose from in terms of beneficiary and um like what percentage they want to make sure that their beneficiary receives after their death.
26:26Correct, which the folks in this will not leave the plan until they expire.
26:31Yeah, but but their beneficiaries receive the funds that were set aside.
26:39Okay, thank you very much.
26:41Any questions from this other member?
26:54All right, we will stand adjourned.
26:56Thank y'all very much.
26:59I did not hear that.