Public Meetings - Phoenix, Arizona

The Phoenix City Council’s Community Services and Education Subcommittee met on June 24, 2026, at approximately 6:15 PM (transcribed as morning session). The subcommittee approved routine items, received updates on the Cultural Pass program, eviction legal services, social work internships, the city’s naloxone distribution and overdose alert system, and the third annual 602 Day celebration. No public comments were made. Consent Calendar - Item 1: Approval of Minutes – The subcommittee unanimously approved the minutes from the May 27, 2026 meeting (motioned and seconded; all in favor). - Items 2 & 3: Head Start Actions – The subcommittee approved Item 2 (authorizing the Human Services Department Head Start Birth to Five program to apply for a non-federal share waiver from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of Head Start) and received the March 2026 monthly report (Item 3) by consent. Chair clarified Item 2 was for action; motion carried unanimously. Discussion Items - Cultural Pass Program (Item 4) – A presentation was given on the library’s Culture Pass program, launched in 2013 in partnership with Act One. The program provides free passes to over 20 cultural institutions across the state, available at all 17 library locations and the bookmobile. Key statistics: over 18,000 passes checked out in 2025, and nearly 8,000 through May 30, 2026. Councilmember Fernandez expressed interest in expanding the program. Chair Hodge Washington noted the program’s value for accessible education and plugged the concurrent “Quick Read-in Challenge” running through July 20, 2026. - Eviction Legal Services and Housing Stability (Item 5) – Human Services Director Jacqueline Edwards presented eviction filing trends (from Maricopa County Justice Courts) and updates on the city’s Eviction Legal Services program (launched January 2025). From program start through March 2026, 766 applications were received; 436 were eligible and referred to providers; 67% of referrals were for legal representation; 25% of closed cases ended in negotiated settlement. Upcoming programs: Maricopa County Eviction Diversion Pilot ($800,000, targeting high-eviction zip codes, launch expected by end of August 2026) and the city’s Stability Assistance Program (up to $2,500 per household, projected to help 360 households, starting July 2026, focused on stabilization goals in housing, finance, education/employment). Three potential future strategies were discussed: a Preferred Landlord Program, a Landlord Risk Mitigation Fund, and a One-Stop Stabilization Appointment post-eviction. Chair Hodge Washington emphasized the need to identify funding for the eviction legal services program beyond the current ARPA interest funding (through June 2027). Councilmember Hernandez praised the prevention-focused approach. Councilmember Stark commended the collaboration with Maricopa County. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington thanked county partners and noted her priority on housing stability. - Social Work Internship Partnerships (Item 6) – Presented by Housing Director Titus Matthews, Assistant Director Aubrey Gonzalez, and Deputy Director Zona Pacheco. The city has partnered for over 20 years with Arizona State University and Grand Canyon University to provide accredited social work field placements (BSW and MSW). Interns work across Human Services, Library, Fire, and Housing departments. Key outcomes: Since 2024, 9 interns in Human Services; Library interns launched Teen Connect program (73 youth attended) and connected 146 residents to services; Housing interns supported 592 households, conducted 107 community events, and assisted 3,620 households through food distributions. The Housing Department employs 10 former interns. Councilmember Hernandez asked about program costs (none for housing) and expressed interest in expanding to other departments. Councilmember Stark praised the program, noting his chief of staff is a social work graduate. - Naloxone Program and Overdose Alert System (Item 7) – Public Health Advisor Yanitsa Soto and Special Project Administrator Kelly Kozada presented. Naloxone kit distribution in Q3 (February–April 2026): over 5,200 kits distributed, a 65% increase over Q2 and 68% increase over same quarter last year. Over 54 sites now have kits; four new housing department sites added. Since program inception (August 2023), 38,785 kits distributed. The Phoenix Opioid Overdose Alert System launched May 1, 2026. It uses daily overdose data from Phoenix Fire EMS to detect spikes (statistical deviations from historical predictions). On May 23, 2026, the system triggered a “red” (highest) alert with 29 suspected opioid overdoses in 24 hours. Alerts are sent to the Office of Homeless Solutions and Community Assistance Program, which are developing response plans (e.g., targeted outreach, naloxone distribution, linking to treatment). The system will be evaluated for effectiveness. No questions from subcommittee. Chair Hodge Washington praised the data-driven approach. - 602 Day Celebration Recap (Item 8) – Presented by Deputy Communications Director Ashley Patton, Senior PIO Athena Sanchez, and Management Assistant Chanel Hooks. The third annual 602 Day (June 2, 2026) saw record participation: over 450 businesses/organizations (up from 100 in 2024 and 250 in 2025). Major destinations reported attendance: 16,000 at Phoenix Zoo, 26,000 tickets purchased for Arizona State Fair, 22,000 tickets for Diamondbacks game. TV/radio coverage reached an estimated 10 million viewers/listeners; social media posts earned approximately 11 million views. Positive online sentiment was 75%, described as “established civic fixture.” The city’s 602 Day website had over 130,000 page views. Employee engagement included a wellness step challenge (won by team with Vice Mayor, Councilman Waring, and Councilman Stark), peer recognition, and swag sales. Future goal: at least 602 participants in 2027. Councilmember Hernandez suggested earlier distribution of sticker packets, uniform branding templates for businesses, and adding filters to the interactive map (e.g., light rail-accessible businesses). Councilmember Stark highlighted the initiative’s origin with Vice Mayor’s chief of staff Zach Wallace (dubbed “Mr. 602”). Chair Hodge Washington commended the growth and community pride. Key Outcomes - Approved: Minutes from May 27, 2026; Item 2 (Head Start waiver application) on consent. - Received and Discussed: Culture Pass update (Item 4), eviction legal services and housing stability update (Item 5), social work internship program update (Item 6), naloxone/overdose alert system update (Item 7), and 602 Day recap (Item 8). No votes required for these items; all were informational. - Directives and Next Steps: Chair Hodge Washington requested staff to identify potential funding sources to continue eviction legal services beyond June 2027. The Maricopa County Eviction Diversion Pilot is expected to launch by end of August 2026. The city’s Stability Assistance Program will open in July 2026. The Overdose Alert System will be monitored and evaluated, with plans to expand partner involvement. Planning for the 2027 602 Day is underway, with targets to exceed 602 participating organizations. - No Public Comments or Future Agenda Items Requested.

On May 12, 2026, the Phoenix City Council held a special meeting to interview three finalists for the position of Chief Presiding Judge of the Phoenix Municipal Court. The council interviewed each candidate for up to 45 minutes, followed by public comments and an executive session. The meeting concluded with a unanimous vote to appoint a candidate (name not publicly disclosed in the transcript). Public Comments & Testimony - Valerie Boyer Wells spoke in support of Judge Michelle Lu Sang, citing her intellect, integrity, and leadership experience, including her role in transitioning Mesa Court to electronic files. - Adriana Jenko (Assistant U.S. Attorney, President of Los Abogados Foundation) spoke in support of Judge Wilbur Hudson, emphasizing his breadth of experience, community involvement, and ability to foster trust. - Terry Marks spoke in support of Judge Hudson, highlighting his integrity, community presence, and long-standing service. - Joshua Fisher (shareholder at Gallagher & Kennedy) spoke in support of Judge Tina Solomon, praising her diligence and deep ties to the Phoenix court system. - Chris McBride spoke in support of Judge Hudson, recalling his work with indigent clients and specialty courts, including the first veterans stand down. - Alicia Skupin (Presiding Judge, Chandler Municipal Court) spoke in support of Judge Lu Sang, citing her experience as a presiding judge in Apache Junction, her leadership in transitioning to electronic files, and her relationships with the Arizona Supreme Court. - Chuck Whitehead spoke in support of Judge Hudson, noting his mentorship and leadership among judges. Discussion Items Candidate Interviews: - Judge Wilbur Hudson – Approximately 30 years of experience with the Phoenix court system as a public defender, prosecutor, private attorney, and judge. Currently presides over Veterans Court, which has served over 3,000 veterans with 1,500 graduations. He emphasized procedural justice, leading by example, and community outreach. He identified budget, accessibility (expanding court hours), and technology (virtual hearings, electronic filing) as key challenges. He supports expanding specialty courts and using data to track recidivism. - Judge Michelle Lu Sang – 28 years of judicial experience, currently on the Chandler Municipal Court bench. Previously a Mesa judge and chaired the AJC committee on leadership and workforce excellence. She stressed commitment to justice, rule of law, and treating court users with respect. Her biggest challenge identified was transitioning to digital files. She supports virtual hearings to reduce failure-to-appear rates and emphasized community trust and specialty court evaluation through recidivism. - Judge Tina Solomon – Phoenix Municipal Court judge since 2018, previously a prosecutor for 19 years. Presides over an in-custody docket with many domestic violence cases. She emphasized the golden rule, procedural justice, and leading by example. Her pressing issues include the court management system (CMS) project and photo safety. She proposes a domestic violence specialty court and improved training. She supports virtual hearings selectively, noting in-person hearings promote compliance. Key Outcomes - The council voted unanimously to enter executive session to discuss the personnel matter. - Following executive session, the council returned and voted unanimously to appoint a candidate. The transcript does not specify who was appointed, but the meeting was adjourned with congratulations.

The Public Safety and Justice Subcommittee met on May 6, 2026, starting at approximately 9:00 AM and adjourning at 11:09 AM. The meeting covered approval of prior minutes, consent agenda items, a detailed presentation on proposed fireworks ordinance revisions, and an update on police and fire recruitment and hiring. Unanimous votes were taken on consent items and to recommend the fireworks code changes to the full city council. No public comments were received. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: The subcommittee unanimously approved the minutes from the April 1, 2026, meeting. - Block Watch Grant Awards: Councilwoman O'Brien moved to add two grants to the recommended list: item 26-155 for $15,000 and item 26-058 for $2,277 covering specific line items. The motion passed unanimously. Discussion Items Fireworks Ordinance Revision - Assistant Chief Justin Alexander, Police Lieutenant Brian Rimza, Deputy Parks Director Jared Rogers, and Deputy Communications Director Ashley Patton presented proposed revisions to Phoenix City Code Chapter 23, Article 2, Division 5. The new language would prohibit the sale and use of permissible consumer fireworks to the full extent allowed by state law (ARS 36-1606), which currently permits fireworks only around certain holidays. - Prohibited Areas: Permissible consumer fireworks will not be allowed within one mile of mountain preserves (shown in red on a map) and, during stage one fire restrictions, within one mile of other park properties (green and yellow areas). The city is developing an online tool to help residents determine if their address falls within these restricted zones, expected to be ready before July 4th. - Enforcement: Civil fines up to $2,500 and criminal penalties (class 1 misdemeanor, up to 6 months jail, $2,500 fine). The department intends to use civil fines for first-time violations and escalate for repeat offenders. Cost recovery provisions allow the city to charge for emergency response, storage, and destruction of illegal fireworks. - Public Awareness: The "Celebrate Safely" campaign will begin in early June using newsletters, social media, billboards, and community outreach. Subcommittee members asked about communication with neighborhood groups and park signage. - Outcome: The subcommittee unanimously voted to recommend the ordinance revision to the full city council for consideration at the May 20, 2026, meeting. Police and Fire Hiring and Recruitment Update - Fire Department (Assistant Chief Rita Riddle Bigler): Authorized sworn positions are 2,059, including 134 funded by the TPT increase. Thirty-four of those are already in operations. Sixty-one recruits are on track to graduate May 15, and 50 new hires are on-boarding for a June start. Online testing in August 2025 and January 2026 yielded 134 out-of-state applicants from 24 states with a 74% completion rate. The cadet program (55–75 active cadets) continues to supply roughly 25 candidates per hiring cycle. - Police Department (Assistant Director Kurt Courthood): Authorized positions are 3,125; as of February 2026, filled sworn positions totaled 2,460, with 126 recruits in the academy (the most in any February for at least three years). In the first two months of 2026, 933 applications were received. Of the 26 recruits hired in 2026, 19 remain in the academy and 7 have separated. Recruitment efforts include national outreach, online testing, partnerships with universities, and events targeting women. A joint Police-Fire Career Experience on March 7 attracted over 500 attendees and resulted in 16 on-site police recruit applications. - Discussion: Councilmember Waring expressed concern about the declining number of sworn officers (2,460), noting it is far below the authorized target and has not improved significantly. Councilwoman O'Brien pointed to the hiring freeze from 2007–2012 as a contributing factor to a gap in mid-career officers. Subcommittee members requested future reports on attrition rates, applicant pipeline data, the effectiveness of the $2,500 referral bonus, and longer-term staffing trends. The police department highlighted ongoing process improvements to speed up hiring, including using online interviews for out-of-state candidates. Key Outcomes - Unanimous approval of consent calendar items including block watch grants with Councilwoman O'Brien's additions. - Unanimous vote to recommend the fireworks ordinance revision to the full city council for the May 20, 2026, meeting. - Presentations on hiring and recruitment were received for information. No formal action was taken, but the subcommittee directed staff to provide follow-up data on police academy attrition, retention rates, applicant funnel analysis, referral bonus usage, and historical staffing levels in future briefings.

The Phoenix City Council met on May 6, 2026, to consider a range of agenda items, including liquor license transfers, election conduct, labor union MOUs, a controversial ordinance regulating medical treatment and food distribution in city parks, and updates on opportunity zones and airport infrastructure. The meeting drew extensive public testimony, particularly on the parks ordinance, which passed 6-3 after a substitute motion to reject it failed. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (Meeting Minutes): Approved unanimously. - Item 2 (Boards and Commissions): Approved unanimously; two new village planning commissioners were sworn in. - Items 3–26 (Liquor Licenses): Approved unanimously, with item 22 continued to May 20, 2026, and item 26 revised. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 26 (Barracks Bar liquor license): Three speakers: Matthew Moody (applicant, in support) described the bar as a safe space for the LGBTQ+ community. Andrea Lukowitz (attorney for applicant) noted the applicant worked with neighbors and zoning staff. Matt Wolf did not speak. Councilwoman Pastor gave no recommendation, citing neighborhood protests despite the police department's revised approval. Passed 9-0. - Item 37 (Election conduct): Leonard Clark expressed concern about ICE presence at polling stations, urging contingency plans. Passed 9-0. - Item 42 (MOU with Labor's International): Leonard Clark spoke in support, noting the importance of unions. Passed 9-0. - Item 45 (MOU with Phoenix Law Enforcement Association): Councilwoman Hernandez spoke against, citing lack of transparency, police accountability concerns, and the contract's protections for officers. Councilman O'Brien spoke in support, thanking officers for their service. Vote 8-1 (Hernandez no). - Item 49 (Parks ordinance – medical treatment and food distribution): Extensive public testimony (over 50 speakers) with sharply divided positions: - Supporters: Residents, neighborhood association leaders, youth sports representatives (e.g., Cactus Youth Baseball League), and park employees' union representatives (Unit 7, LIUNA) cited safety concerns, discarded needles, trash, and the need for regulation. They argued parks are for families and recreation, not social services. Some supported the ordinance as a balanced compromise. - Opponents: Medical providers (Circle the City, Street Medicine Phoenix, Venn Centers), harm reduction groups (Shot in the Dark, Southwest Recovery Alliance), faith-based ministries (St. Herman's Table, Food Not Bombs), and advocacy organizations (ACLU of Arizona, National Homelessness Law Center, Black Lives Matter Phoenix Metro) argued the ordinance is unconstitutional, punitive, and will lead to deaths. They emphasized that syringe service programs reduce needle litter, and that restricting care will increase emergency room visits and 911 calls. Many speakers shared personal stories of needle sticks, homelessness, and the life-saving role of outreach. The ACLU attorney warned the ordinance violates First Amendment, religious freedom, ADA, and due process rights. Discussion Items - Item 49 (Parks ordinance): City staff (Cynthia, Deputy City Manager; Brandy Barrett, Assistant Parks Director; Rachel, Office of Homeless Solutions) presented the ordinance, showing photos of needle litter, trash, and unsanitary conditions from parks. Key components: bans needle exchange and intramuscular naloxone distribution; requires permits for medical treatment (enclosed tent or mobile vehicle, supervised by licensed professional, max 2 per park per month) and food distribution (max 2 total service permits per park per month); exceptions for first responders, emergencies, and already permitted events. Eligible parks: 105 neighborhood, community, and regional parks (excluding sports complexes). Staff will track permits, violations, and park conditions. Council members raised questions about enforcement, data collection, liability, and partnership with OHS. Councilwoman O'Brien emphasized tracking unintended consequences. Councilwoman Pastor noted the addition of food distribution was not part of her original motion. Councilwoman Stark and Guardado highlighted constituent concerns about safety and equity. Councilwoman Hernandez questioned the lack of empirical evidence and the punitive nature (class 1 misdemeanor, up to 6 months jail). - Item 57 (Opportunity zones): Councilwoman Pastor explained her strategy for selecting zones to create impact across districts. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington emphasized using zones for housing, healthcare, and food access. Passed 8-0. - Item 65 (Sky Harbor Land Reuse Cultural Corridor): Vice Mayor Hodge Washington thanked staff and community for the BAIS grant-funded corridor along Buckeye Road. Passed 8-0. - Item 67 (Deer Valley Airport terminal modernization): Councilwoman O'Brien highlighted the airport's economic role and the new terminal features (patio, observation area, Barrio Brewing). Passed 9-0. Key Outcomes - Item 49 (Parks ordinance): Approved 6-3 (Councilmembers Guardado, Pastor, Hernandez, and Waring voted no). The motion included a six-month implementation review by the appropriate subcommittee. A substitute motion by Councilwoman Hernandez to reject the amended ordinance, repeal the December 17, 2025 original, and start a new process failed for lack of a second. - Item 45 (PLEA MOU): Approved 8-1 (Councilwoman Hernandez opposed). - Other items: All approved as noted (unanimous or 9-0, 8-0). - Citizen Comments: Three speakers addressed air quality, the parks ordinance, and ethics concerns about staff distributing stickers. The meeting adjourned after citizen comments.

This meeting began with council information updates and then focused on the presentation of the City Manager's proposed $2.3 billion general fund operating budget for fiscal year 2026-27. The city manager and budget director outlined a $162.5 million surplus, new investments in child care, homelessness services, teen programs, and emergency assistance, and a $75 million set-aside to ensure balance in FY2027-28. After extensive public comment – with many speakers urging an increase in crisis relief funds to $5 million – council members discussed and praised the budget but took no final vote; a budget decision vote is scheduled for May 19, 2026. A separate agenda item on the food action plan was continued to a future policy session. Public Comments & Testimony - Over 20 members of the public spoke, the majority requesting that the council increase the client services line item for crisis relief funds by an additional $5 million (to a total of at least $6.5 million) and expand access to all Phoenix residents regardless of immigration status. Speakers cited federal SNAP cuts (affecting over 400,000 Arizonans, including 181,000 children), increased ICE enforcement, and rising housing and food costs. Many emphasized the need to subgrant funds to culturally competent community organizations and to create an oversight committee. - Several speakers expressed strong support for the $5 million child care affordability set-aside, including Dr. Katie Spruit (First Things First) and Robert Wolenzine (Christown YMCA), who noted that 72,000 children have working parents but only 47,000 licensed slots exist. - Two speakers (Brent Stockball, Phoenix Community Alliance; Leah Friglia, Hance Park Conservancy) requested dedicated funding for park rangers at Margaret T. Hance Park, modeled on the Civic Space Park arrangement, to address safety and encampment issues. - One speaker (Ben) criticized the police budget increase of $59 million while asking for more crisis relief, arguing that keeping people housed is more cost-effective. Discussion Items - Budget Presentation (City Manager Ed Zuercher and Budget Director Aaron Mertz): The proposed budget ends six years of federal stimulus funding and allocates a $162.5 million surplus ($100 million one-time, $62 million ongoing) across several priority areas. Key additions from the trial budget include: - Flexible Emergency Financial Assistance: Increased from $1.5M to $3.15M (one-time). - Teen Services Programming: Increased from $500,000 to $937,000 (ongoing). - Park Services Permit Staffing: $379,000 and 3 positions (contingent on council approval of a new park ordinance). - SNAP Navigation Services: $5 million child care set-aside partially used in FY26-27 for SNAP navigation. - Other investments: $1.6M for community health and safety (lighting, park enhancements), $9.4M for children/youth/families (including child care), $18.4M homeless service continuity (shelter operations, master leasing), $6.6M housing trust fund, $1.5M planning and development customer service, $50M employee compensation, $75M set-aside for FY27-28 balance. - Council Questions and Comments: - Vice Mayor Hodge Washington highlighted the increase in flexible assistance and teen programs, clarified that the Shade Phoenix plan ($60M investment for 24,000 trees and 500+ structures) remains intact, and noted that eviction legal assistance is funded through June 2027. He requested more information on transportation funding (bike lanes, traffic calming) via the transportation sales tax. - Councilwoman O'Brien praised the housing trust fund and fee waivers for affordable housing. - Councilwoman Hernandez thanked staff but pushed for additional funding: she asked about increasing flexible assistance to $5M, teen programming to $1.5M (including $500K for literacy hubs), and more shade near schools. She expressed concern about the park ordinance enforcement budget ($379K) and questioned the fiscal impact. She also called for improved community engagement and a more accessible budget video. - Councilwoman Stark emphasized employee compensation and planning and development improvements. - Councilman Waring noted that 38% of the general fund goes to police, 25% to fire, and about 77% is personnel costs, with 72% of that for police and fire staffing. He stated that public safety is the core purpose of city government. - Councilwoman Pastor thanked the community, supported child care and teen programming, and asked about the one-time nature of SNAP navigation funding. She raised concerns about the accessibility of city assistance programs (the Monday call-in process) and asked staff to improve emergency procedures. - Councilman Robinson praised the budget as a result of good work by city staff, noting that during lean years budget hearings draw larger crowds. He committed to supporting the budget. - Agenda Item 2 (Food Action Plan): Council agreed to continue this item to a future policy session (June 9, 2026) without discussion, given the extensive slide deck. Key Outcomes - No vote on the 2026-27 budget: The budget decision vote is set for May 19, 2026, followed by tentative adoption on June 3 and final adoption on June 17. - Council direction: Staff were asked to explore additional funding for crisis relief and teen programming before the May 19th vote (Councilwoman Hernandez) and to review the accessibility of human services intake processes (Councilwoman Pastor). - Agenda Item 2 continued: The food action plan was continued to the council policy session on June 9, 2026. - Council information updates: Vice Mayor reported new stop signs and shade canopy at New Ashroe Park (first from 2023 Go Bond). Councilwoman Pastor announced an FAA study on flight path changes (virtual meeting May 13) and celebrated the Moon Village Garden Association's new community garden.

The Phoenix City Council convened on May 4, 2026, at 10:45 AM. The meeting opened with an invocation by Rabbi Levratov, the Pledge of Allegiance, and memorials for two prominent community members: Michael Peterson, a former city staff member, and Dr. Gene Blue, a civil rights leader and educator. The council then proceeded through a lengthy agenda, including a significant discussion and vote on a residential solid waste rate increase, approval of a K9 services contract with PetSmart, multiple affordable housing projects, and a contract for accessible visual inclusion services at Sky Harbor Airport. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes (Item 1): Approved unanimously. - Boards and Commissions (Item 2): Approved unanimously; new commissioners sworn in. - Liquor Licenses (Items 3–10): Approved unanimously. - Bulk Approvals (Items 11–63): Vice Mayor Hodge Washington moved to approve items 11–63 with the exception of items 11, 12, 15–21, 28, 32–34, 43, 48, 49, 51, 55, and 58, which were considered individually. The remaining items were passed 9-0 by roll call. Public Comments & Testimony - MOU with Phoenix Law Enforcement Association (Item 19): Leonard Clark expressed concern about officer interactions with citizens and requested transparency. The vote was deferred to a later meeting. - Election Materials (Item 21): Leonard Clark voiced concerns about ballot security and federal interference. The item passed 9-0. - Civil Service Board Hearing Officer (Item 28): Leonard Clark spoke in support, calling for public education on the board’s role. The item passed 9-0. - Accessible Visual Inclusion Services (Item 43): Rebecca Rosenberg, CEO of Reboca, described the technology’s benefits for travelers with low vision. The item passed 9-0. - Solid Waste Rate Increase (Item 48): Two speakers addressed the item: - Jennifer Scheipe, President of Keep Phoenix Beautiful, expressed support, citing the need for infrastructure sustainability. - Mike Rellis, representative of LiUNA Local 777, supported the increase, highlighting equipment delays and workforce dedication. - Citizen Comment Session (30 minutes): - Jack and Lexi (LDS Church) thanked council for supporting the Giving Machine Initiative (Dec 2025), which raised funds for local charities. - David (SOS shelter resident) described being threatened with exit for noncompliance due to disability status and inability to work. - Frank Urban (Fund for Empowerment) criticized the proposed park ordinance limiting food sharing to twice per month, calling it harmful to homeless individuals. - Faith Kearns (Fund for Empowerment) argued the park feeding restrictions violate compassion and First Amendment rights. - Lee opposed nutrition assistance work requirements while filing for disability. - Rhonda Savage (SOS) thanked council for soap and paper towels but reported black mold and flooding at the shelter, urging remediation. - Tony Harris (Fund for Empowerment) proposed allowing food drop-offs without permits as a compromise. - Leonard praised unions and Senator Mark Kelly, and requested a monument for Senator John McCain. - Elizabeth Fenable (Fund for Empowerment) echoed concerns about black mold at SOS and argued the food-sharing ordinance would infringe on religious and free speech rights. - Randy reiterated health issues at SOS (mold, flooding, dog pen sanitation). - Clarissa (SOS) criticized poor food quality and staff inaction. - Sue recalled 72 heat deaths in 2023 and opposed the park permit requirement. - Stuart Tanner described being wrongfully discharged from SOS and accused the shelter of insurance fraud. Discussion Items - Contract with PetSmart for Canine Units (Item 11): - Councilwoman Hernandez asked about the K9 unit breakdown (36 dogs total across bureaus) and the public comment period for canine policy updates (through May 31, 2026). - She noted she would vote yes (dogs need food) but expressed personal concerns about canine units as dog abuse and their use as weapons against the community. - The item passed 9-0. - Motel Conversion to Senior Affordable Housing (Item 12): - Councilwoman Guardado highlighted the La Perla project (126 units for seniors 55+, at 25% completion, opening early 2027), funded via ARPA, NSP, and a congressional earmark. She called it a model for combating homelessness. - Passed 9-0. - Special Meeting for Presiding Judge Appointment (Item 15): - Councilwoman Hernandez explained the process: interviews will be held May 12, 2026, with the council selecting the chief presiding judge, who serves as the court’s administrative officer. - Passed 9-0. - Federal Home Funds for Affordable Housing (Items 32 & 33): - Item 32 (Second & Roosevelt): 60 units for families. Passed 9-0. - Item 33 (Wood Street): 45 units for seniors at or below 60% AMI (some at 40%). Vice Mayor commended the city’s strategic use of funds. Passed 9-0. - Rio Fresco Emergency Shelter Operations (Item 34): - Vice Mayor Hodge Washington shared success stories from the shelter and emphasized the need for the full continuum of care. Mayor Gallego noted funding via CDBG and expressed concern over the president’s proposal to eliminate such programs. - Passed 9-0. - Solid Waste Service Rate Increase (Item 48): - Deputy City Manager Stevenson and Public Works Director Felipe presented the revised fee schedule: a three-year tiered increase of $5 (July 2026), $5 (2027), $4 (2028), plus an inflationary adjustment (max 5%) from 2029–2033. The original proposal of $6–$6–$5 was reduced after community feedback. - Additional features: increased discount for 60-gallon containers (from $3 to $5/month), doubled contribution to Project Assist (to $440,000/year, total cap $1.5 million), and commitment to future efficiency studies. - Council discussion highlighted affordability concerns, recycling/compost improvements, and the need for multilingual outreach about assistance programs. - Several council members (Hernandez, Vice Mayor, O’Brien, Stark, Guardado) acknowledged the difficulty but emphasized necessity due to inflation (labor +32%, trucks +52%, construction +40%) and the fund’s enterprise status. - Councilwoman Guardado voted no, citing the burden on residents amid inflation and federal benefit cuts. - Vote: 8-1 (Guardado opposed). Passed. - SRP Street Light Installation (Item 51): - Vice Mayor highlighted 30 new lights on Broadway Corridor (24th St to 32nd St), improving safety and equity. Passed 9-0. - Phoenix Connected Active Neighborhood Program (Item 55): - Vice Mayor noted resident engagement in Levine and Estrella for transportation connectivity. Passed 9-0. Key Outcomes - Solid Waste Rate Increase Approved (8-1): Monthly residential rate will rise $5 in July 2026, $5 in 2027, $4 in 2028, with subsequent inflationary caps. Green organics subscription fee set at one-fourth the residential rate. Low-income assistance (Project Assist) doubled to $440,000. - K9 Contract with PetSmart Approved (9-0): Food and supplies for 36 police dogs across multiple bureaus. - Senior Affordable Housing Projects Approved (9-0): La Perla (126 units) and Wood Street (45 units) moving forward. - Presiding Judge Interviews Scheduled: May 12, 2026 special meeting for selection. - Accessibility Tech at Sky Harbor Approved (9-0): Contract with Reboca for low-vision navigation aids. - Multiple Infrastructure Contracts Approved: Street lights (SRP), active transportation planning, wastewater treatment, and civil service board hearing officer. - Public Comment Recorded: Multiple citizens raised concerns about SOS shelter conditions (mold, sanitation) and opposed the new park food-sharing ordinance (to be voted on at a later date).

The subcommittee met to discuss several items including approval of minutes, consent agenda, withdrawal of the Downtown Phoenix Entertainment District implementation plan, an update on Opportunity Zone 2.0 guidance, presentations from cultural organizations, and an economic overview focusing on land and real estate. Consent Calendar - Minutes approved unanimously. - Consent agenda item approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - No general call to the public; however, a speaker was registered for item 3 (Entertainment District) but the item was withdrawn, so the speaker was not heard. Discussion Items - Downtown Phoenix Entertainment District Implementation Plan: Staff requested withdrawal to allow additional stakeholder engagement and coordination with sister departments and full city council. Councilwoman Pastor moved to withdraw but requested it come back in May. Staff indicated they needed more time, but after discussion, the motion to withdraw passed unanimously. Councilwoman Pastor expressed disappointment about delays, noting it is a high priority and only two meetings remain. - Opportunity Zone 2.0 Guidance Update: Presentation by Ryan Tuhill and Jasmine Lombrera. New federal guidance requires a new map; the city can designate up to 33 qualified census tracts from eligible tracts based on stricter criteria (median family income ≤70% of MSA). Staff identified eligible tracts, then recommended eligible tracts based on development potential, now engaging council districts, and will bring a final map for council approval on April 22 to meet the May 8 state deadline. Council members discussed community engagement; Councilwoman Pastor noted she has many districts and may need more time, but staff emphasized the hard deadline. Council members expressed support for the tool, citing success like Paradise Valley Mall and IKEA. - Upcoming Events and Programs at Cultural Organizations: Presentations from Ballet Arizona, Children's Museum of Phoenix, Phoenix Art Museum, Pueblo Grande Museum, and Shemer Art Center. Each highlighted upcoming events, visitor statistics, community programs, expansion plans, and economic impact. Council members praised the presentations and discussed future items, including a request to hear from the Science Center in September. - Phoenix Economic Overview and Update (Part 3: Land, Real Estate, and Economic Geography): Presentation by Ryan Tuhill and Zandon Keating. Discussed Phoenix's advantage of available developable land, greenfield vs. infill development strategies, examples of mall redevelopments (Park Central, Paradise Valley Mall, Metro Center), and the importance of infrastructure. Highlighted that construction sales tax has increased 168% since 2017. No questions from committee; chair praised the series. Key Outcomes - Minutes and consent agenda approved unanimously. - Item 3 (Entertainment District) withdrawn unanimously; direction to bring back at a future meeting. - Opportunity Zone update received; staff to continue council district outreach and bring final map for approval on April 22. - Cultural organizations' presentations received; future agenda items: request for entertainment plan by June (Councilwoman Pastor), and request for Science Center presentation in September (Councilwoman Stark). - Meeting adjourned.

The Phoenix City Council met on April 8, 2026, beginning at 10:45 AM. The meeting opened with an invocation and the Pledge of Allegiance, followed by roll call (all nine members present). The council approved a series of consent items, heard public testimony, debated a youth crime prevention contract, recognized a retiring accelerant detection dog, and voted on several land-use and grant items. Key outcomes included canceling a competitive solicitation for youth violence prevention services and directing staff to rework the RFP with greater council input. Consent Calendar - Unanimous approvals: Items 2–12 (liquor licenses, except item 12 which was disapproved 9–0), items 13–74 (ordinances, resolutions, and planning/zoning items) with several exclusions, and items 72–73 (rezoning near 64th Street and Mayo Boulevard) were approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 25 – Youth Crime Prevention Contract: Mr. Harris (Jacob Harris Foundation) testified in opposition, stating that the recommended awardee, Father Matters Incorporated, lacked capacity and commitment to serve youth. He shared his personal story of losing his son Jacob to a police shooting and emphasized the need for a 100% dedicated organization. He urged the council to vote no and instead directly fund his foundation. - Item 74 – Rezoning near 11th Avenue and Michigan Avenue: Kimberly Sisk (resident of Michigan Avenue) opposed the site plan design, arguing it would create unsafe traffic conflicts, diminish property rights, and that the city’s traffic impact study was flawed. Cheyenne and Adrian (residents of Rosemary Lane) opposed the two-story homes that would block mountain views and privacy. The applicant, Bill Allison, defended the project as infill housing with traffic calming measures. - Citizen Comment: Diane Barker commented on the recent Final Four event and requested action on noisy vehicles. Bonnie Nichols raised concerns about safety and management at the city’s Safe Outdoor Space (SOS) program. Noah James spoke about ICE, police representation, and the need for a female city manager. Discussion Items - Item 25 – Authorization to Contract with Father Matters for Youth Crime Prevention: The item proposed a $1.5 million, three-year contract using Neighborhood Block Watch funds. Staff reported that the RFP received 20 applications, scored by a three-member panel; Father Matters scored 883 out of 1000. Council members expressed concerns about the lack of an interview process, the organization’s limited youth experience (last youth program in 2008), and the fit for the program. Councilwoman Hernandez and others questioned the selection process and performance metrics. Staff noted that the program would serve 425 youth over three years using evidence-based tools (Botvin Life Skills, Triple P). After extensive debate, Councilwoman Hernandez moved to cancel the RFP and direct staff to rework it with council input, with a goal of launching by January 2027. The motion passed 9–0. - Item 35 – Recognition of Sonny the Accelerant Detection Dog: Captain Robbie Simpson described Sonny’s seven years of service, responding to over 40 fire scenes per year, reducing investigation time from days to minutes. The council unanimously approved a resolution honoring his retirement. - Item 41 – Fixed Wing Pilot Training: Approved 8–1 (Councilwoman Hernandez voted no, citing concerns about the program’s scope). - Item 43 – Homeland Security Grant Funds: Councilwoman Hernandez asked about definitions of terrorism, monitoring of hate groups, and ties to ICE. The assistant chief clarified that grants are for planning and equipment, not immigration enforcement, and that the department does not investigate groups based on ideology alone. The item passed 8–1 (Hernandez voted no). - Item 50 – Martin L. Schultz Way Ceremonial Signage: The council unanimously approved a ceremonial street sign honoring Martin Schultz for his contributions to downtown development, transportation, and human services. Multiple council members spoke in support. - Item 54 – Consolidated Rail Infrastructure and Safety Improvements: Approved 9–0 after public comment from Diane Barker urging a holistic view of BNSF rail safety. - Item 74 – Rezoning at 11th Avenue and Michigan Avenue: The applicant sought to rezone from R1-8 to R2 to build 19 single-family homes. Staff confirmed that the cul-de-sac would need completion regardless of rezoning, and that two-story homes are allowed under current zoning. Councilwoman Stark noted the project provides middle housing needed in the city. Councilwoman Hernandez clarified that the street is public, property value impacts are not a zoning factor, and backing into traffic is standard on local streets. The motion to approve passed 9–0. Key Outcomes - Item 25 – Canceled RFP for Youth Crime Prevention: The council voted 9–0 to cancel the contract with Father Matters, direct staff to work with council on a new RFP, and discuss goals at the May 5, 2026 policy meeting, aiming for a January 2027 start. - Item 35 – Sonny’s Retirement: Resolution honoring Sonny passed unanimously. - Item 41 – Fixed Wing Pilot Training: Approved 8–1. - Item 43 – Homeland Security Grant Funds: Approved 8–1. - Item 50 – Martin L. Schultz Way: Approved unanimously. - Item 54 – Rail Infrastructure Safety Improvements: Approved unanimously. - Items 72, 73, and 74 – Rezoning Applications: All approved unanimously.

This meeting of the Public Safety and Justice Subcommittee, chaired by Councilmember Robinson, included updates on the Phoenix Police Department's Downtown Operations Unit, the two-year anniversary of the Phoenix Community Court, and other informational items. The subcommittee approved consent items and the minutes from the previous meeting. Consent Calendar - Item 1: Motion to direct staff to develop an updated ordinance to return to the subcommittee at a later month for action. Approved unanimously. - Item 4: Approval of the subcommittee meeting minutes from March 4, 2026. Approved unanimously. Discussion Items - Item 2 — Update on Police Department's Downtown Public Safety Efforts: Assistant Chief Brian Lee and Commander David Cedar presented an overview of the Downtown Operations Unit (DOU). The unit covers the approximately one square mile downtown core. A crime suppression pilot program (Shift 3 squad) began June 1, 2025, and went permanent on August 20, 2025, operating Wednesdays–Saturday 6 p.m. to 4 a.m. with one sergeant and four officers. From August 1, 2025 to March 23, 2026, the squad produced 96 arrests, 259 incident reports, 61 citations, 22 notices of violation, 6 traffic accidents, and recovered 5 firearms. In August 2025, responsibility for the downtown shelter area was transferred from DOU to the Central City Precinct for more efficient resource alignment. DOU also contributed to updating policy for the Public Safety Response Team (PSRT) and First Amendment demonstrations, including smaller squads, a layered deployment approach, and new less-lethal systems. An e-bike patrol program launched in February 2026 with 10 bikes donated by partners. DOU managed 434 special events in 2025 and is on track to support over 260 in 2026, including the 2026 NCAA Women's Final Four (March 30–April 5). Councilmembers O'Brien and Gordado commended the unit's work and professionalism. Councilwoman O'Brien inquired about expanding the Shift 3 squad to 24/7 coverage; the department noted that full 24/7 coverage would require a second shift 3 squad but current staffing allows enhanced coverage. - Item 3 — Update on Phoenix Community Court Two-Year Anniversary: Presenters included Sarah DeYoung (Chief Assistant City Prosecutor), David Ward (Director of Public Defender's Office), and Scott Hall (Office of Homeless Solutions). The court launched in January 2024 through Councilwoman O'Brien's leadership. It operates as a transformative justice initiative for people experiencing homelessness, with a collaborative team including Municipal Court, Prosecutor's Office, Public Defender's Office, Office of Homeless Solutions, and Community Bridges Inc. (CBI). Key statistics: 554 participants have concluded their cases; 214 graduations; 32 cases dismissed before graduation; 11 pleaded guilty to a reduced sentence; 29 placed in other specialty courts; 43 returned to regular court for noncompliance; 225 opted out. Of the 214 graduates, only 18 recidivated (8% recidivism rate). Services provided: 234 individuals received identification documents; 358 were placed into shelter or housing; 172 received mental health/substance use treatment; 98 participated in employment services. The court achieves a 72% appearance rate compared to single digits in regular court for homeless defendants. Councilwoman O'Brien asked about reasons for opt-outs and returns to regular court. The panel explained that some participants are skeptical of the process or prefer the speed of regular court, and that the program requires commitment to case management and court appearances. Councilwoman O'Brien requested long-term recidivism data (3-5 years). Both councilmembers expressed strong support for the program. - Items 5-8 — Information Only Reports: These included updates on the Levine Tower, fire staffing and response times, community assistance program, and implementation reports. Councilman Waring asked about the fire department's new 24-hour medical response vehicle at Station 45 (expected by end of fiscal year) and the potential for a new fire station (Station 71) on Mayo Clinic property. The fire department stated they are working with Community and Economic Development on the property acquisition. No action was taken on these items. Key Outcomes - Approved consent item directing staff to develop an updated ordinance (Item 1) — unanimous. - Approved subcommittee minutes from March 4, 2026 (Item 4) — unanimous. - No formal votes on other items; updates and discussions were received as information. - Councilwoman O'Brien requested that the Community Court team provide longer-term recidivism data (3-5 years) in future reports.