Public Meetings - St Petersburg, Florida
Public Meetings - St Petersburg, FloridaThe St. Petersburg City Council met on December 14, 2023, at 6:45 PM (start of meeting). The agenda included awards, proclamations, public comment, new business items, and approvals of several ordinances and resolutions. Key topics included a request to consider renaming the Tampa Bay Rays, a referral to name a baseball field after a local volunteer, and approval of the South St. Pete CRA budget for FY2024. Consent Calendar - Approved the agenda and consent agenda unanimously. - Item E1: Ordinance granting a utility easement to People's Gas System for the St. Pete Pier (passed 7-0). - Item F2: A report item passed unanimously. - Item J2: Annual update to the Capital Improvements Element for FY2024-2028 (passed unanimously). - Item J3: Amendments to land development regulations for large multi-phase projects and civic uses (passed unanimously). Public Comments & Testimony - Pamela Adams (resident, 767 54th Ave S) voiced frustration with the St. Petersburg home development program, alleging incomplete repairs and discrimination. City Administrator Rob Gurdis assured follow-up. - Vince Cox (resident, 2950 63rd Ave S, PSTA board member) expressed support for Commissioner Renee Flowers and opposed the proposed PSTA bill, urging the council to pass the resolution. - Christian Hardegree (Regional Chancellor, USF St. Pete) spoke in favor of the historic Gas Plant development, the EOS building, and the Veterans Success Center, urging leadership. - Domenico Pontoriero (resident, 670 10th Ave S) supported the resolution opposing the PSTA bill, citing that the bill reduces St. Pete's board representation and is fueled by misinformation. - Second Open Forum: Franklin Perez was not a resident, so he was not allowed to speak. Cindy Shepard (City Council staff) thanked Chair Gabbard for her leadership. Discussion Items - D1 – Distinguished Citizen Award: Councilmember Mohammed presented the award to Roosevelt “Bubba” Swinton for 50 years of coaching and mentoring youth through the Wildwood Dodgers. Speakers encouraged naming the baseball field after him. - D2 – Proclamation: Mayor Welch proclaimed December 15, 2023 as Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority, Zeta Upsilon Omega Chapter Day, celebrating 68 years of service. President Janae Skipper noted over half a million dollars in community donations. - Special Announcement: Suzy Ahawk announced the 2023 CareFest results; District 1 won the Care Cup with 25 projects. - G1 – Team Name Discussion: Councilmember Driscoll requested administration to include a team name change to “St. Petersburg Rays” in stadium negotiations and report by January 4, 2024. Mayor Welch and Rays President Brian Auld opposed, stating the name is not in the term sheet and a change would jeopardize the deal. Public speakers were divided. The motion was amended to request a report on “options to elevate St. Petersburg’s profile” rather than specific name change. Passed 6-2 (Fix Sanders and Gabbard dissenting). - G2 – Baseball Field Naming: Councilmember Mohammed’s resolution to refer naming the field at Thomas “Jet” Jackson Recreation Center after Roosevelt Swinton to the appropriate committee passed unanimously. - H1 – Legislative Agenda: Councilmember Hanowitz requested approval of the 2024 state legislative agenda with amendments (added homeownership language, broadened water systems language). Passed unanimously. - H1B – PSTA Resolution: Councilmember Driscoll’s resolution opposing the proposed bill altering the Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority’s special act. Passed 7-1 (Montanari dissenting). - CRA2 – South St. Pete CRA Budget FY2024: Brian Caper and George Smith presented a $18.9 million budget (66% housing, 23% business development, 6% workforce education). Highlights include new ADU construction program ($500,000), additional staff for housing processing and engineering, and cleanup funding for the Sancofa site. Councilmembers discussed measuring poverty reduction and workforce readiness. Approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - G1 (Amended): The administration will provide a report by January 4, 2024, on discussions with the Rays about elevating St. Petersburg’s presence in the stadium deal. Vote: 6-2. - G2: Referred to committee for naming the baseball field after Roosevelt Swinton. Unanimous. - H1B: Adopted resolution opposing the PSTA special act changes. Vote: 7-1. - CRA2: Approved the FY2024 South St. Pete CRA budget. Unanimous. - All consent items and ordinances passed unanimously.
The St. Petersburg City Council met on December 7, 2023, at 20:00:00+00:00. The meeting included a settlement approval, ordinances modifying procurement thresholds and small business enterprise programs, a contract for consulting services related to the Gas Plant redevelopment, and appointments to the Community Benefits Advisory Council (CBAC). All eight council members were present. Consent Calendar - The agenda and consent agenda were approved unanimously. - Legal Item I1: Approved a $150,000 settlement for an auto accident lawsuit (Rhonda Gary Jackson case) where a city vehicle ran a stop sign. The plaintiff incurred over $400,000 in medical bills. The settlement is within the sovereign immunity cap and was recommended by the assistant city attorney. Unanimous approval. Public Comments & Testimony - Item H1 (CBAC Appointments): Three speakers addressed the council in support of Karen Mueller's appointment: - Wendy Snyder (6407 Sandpiper Way South) spoke in favor of both recommended appointees, particularly Karen Mueller, citing her lack of vested interest and focus on the city's best interest. - Karen Mueller (12th and James, Campbell Park) described her community outreach efforts in Campbell Park, including housing resource promotion, equity initiatives, and neighborhood awards. She expressed enthusiasm for continuing to serve. - Robin Davida (4830 Osprey Drive South) praised Mueller's volunteer leadership, listening skills, and ability to navigate complex housing systems, urging her appointment. Discussion Items - New Ordinances E1A and E1B: - E1A (Ordinance 568-H): Amends the procurement code to raise the threshold requiring council approval from $75,000 to $100,000. Procurement Director Stephanie Swinson and Assistant City Administrator Tom Green presented, citing workload and alignment with other agencies. Councilmember Driscoll opposed, stating her reasons for preferring $75,000 had not changed. Councilmember Montaneri supported due to changed circumstances and inflation. Vote: 7-1 (Driscoll no). - E1B (Ordinance 569-H): Modifies the Small Business Enterprise Assistance Program, raising thresholds from $50,000 to $100,000 for bid discounts, sheltered market, and participation percentages. A public hearing is set for January 4, 2024. Vote: 7-1 (Montaneri no). - Agreement with Inner Circle Sports LLC: Assistant City Administrator Tom Green presented the contract to fund consulting services for the Gas Plant redevelopment, using $274,000 from the general fund contingency. Councilmembers met with David Abrams, principal of Inner Circle Sports, to address concerns about a related entity (Stadco LLC). Councilmember Floyd noted potential liability shielding but understood the business rationale; he remained opposed. Councilmember Hanowitz and Montaneri expressed support after the meetings. Vote: 7-1 (Floyd no). - CBAC Appointments (Item H1): The council considered appointing two ad hoc members (Karen Mueller and Councilmember Fig Sanders) to the Community Benefits Advisory Council. Councilmember Mohammed raised process concerns about requiring a simple majority vote in committee before advancing nominees. The council agreed to discuss appointment procedures in a future joint meeting. Administration explained that Gypsy Gillardo, a standing CBAC member, resigned to avoid a potential conflict of interest related to a Sankofa business incubator; Esther Matthews was appointed to complete her term. The appointments passed unanimously. - Land Use and Zoning Changes (Items J1A and J1B): Proposed future land use map amendment to Plan Redevelopment Mixed Use (PR-MU) and zoning change to Corridor Residential Traditional (CRT-1) for a 0.41-acre parcel at 266th Street North. The change would allow up to 10 townhomes instead of the current 6. Staff recommended approval, citing consistency with the comprehensive plan and the Sunrunner Development Study. Two public comments opposed the increase in density. Councilmember Gurtis opposed, noting the area is mostly single-family homes and the density increase from 6 to 10 was an overreach. Vote: 7-1 (Gurtis no). Key Outcomes - Votes and Decisions: - Legal settlement approved unanimously. - Ordinance E1A (procurement threshold increase) passed 7-1. - Ordinance E1B (SBE program changes) passed 7-1. - Agreement with Inner Circle Sports passed 7-1. - CBAC ad hoc appointments approved unanimously. - Land use and zoning changes (J1A and J1B) passed 7-1. - Next Steps: A public hearing for E1B is scheduled for January 4, 2024. The council will discuss appointment procedures for future committees. The CBAC ad hoc members will participate in an orientation on sunshine law and conflicts of interest before the committee's first meeting on December 13, 2023. - Announcements: Councilmember Gurtis recognized birthdays of staff members. Councilmember Montaneri noted Hanukkah and Pearl Harbor Remembrance Day. The city received awards for water resources management.
The St. Petersburg City Council met on Thursday, November 30, 2023, beginning with an invocation by Imam Abdul Ali of the Tampa Bay Muslim Association and the Pledge of Allegiance. The council considered consent items, public hearings on affordable housing and zoning, legal retainers, a PSTA update, two affordable housing resolutions, a city-owned land policy, and multiple committee referrals. The council also convened as the Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) for two development approvals. Most votes were unanimous, with Councilmember Mohammed absent; notable split votes occurred on legal retainers and the domestic equipment parking ordinance. Consent Calendar - The consent agenda was approved unanimously without discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - William Herman, a resident of the Historic Kenwood area, stated he initially doubted claims of systemic bias but after reviewing the water/wastewater rate structure concluded that the poorest residents are subsidizing the wealthiest. He urged the council to pass a resolution requesting the city's chief equity officer to investigate the utility rates for systemic bias. - Carrie Mueller, a resident, expressed concern about the Rays/Hines financing deal. She detailed what she characterized as a net land subsidy and large public costs, including city and county bonds and foregone property tax revenue, and asked for clarification meetings with council. - Ann Pollock, a commercial real estate attorney, expressed strong support for the Rays/Hines project, describing it as a once-in-a-generation opportunity to raise St. Petersburg's national profile and attract business investment. - Jeremy Tolberg, a resident, opposed the stadium deal, citing an academic study of Atlanta's Truist Park. He argued that stadium deals generally produce lower property values and fiscal shortfalls, and called the proposal a cash transfer from residents to wealthy team owners. - Nick Bell, president of the Old Northeast Neighborhood Association, spoke in support of the proposed domestic/commercial equipment parking ordinance, saying van-lifers have been using city streets and public rights-of-way as permanent campsites, and urging the council to adopt the ordinance. - During the city-owned land policy discussion, Joe Farrell of the Pinellas Realtor Organization and Jason Mathis of the St. Petersburg Downtown Partnership both expressed support for the policy, with Mathis noting that developer feedback led to technical improvements. Discussion Items - D1 – Police Volunteer Road Patrol Recognition: Councilmember Girdis introduced Lyndell Bright, CAPPY staff liaison, who presented certificates of appreciation to Road Patrol volunteers. The council also recognized Officer Wolfson for his 32 years with the St. Petersburg Police Department, including 12 years as Road Patrol Coordinator, and presented him the Sunshine Ambassador Award. Council members thanked the volunteers and Officer Wolfson for their service. - E1A/E1B – Affordable Housing Amendments (Senate Bill 102): Housing Administrator Amy Foster presented amendments implementing Senate Bill 102, which requires administrative approval of multifamily rental developments that include at least 40% affordable units at or below 120% of area median income (AMI), subject to local compatibility review. The ordinance also changes the city's 30% affordable process: it eliminates the five-acre minimum for industrial projects, reduces the 60-unit minimum to 10 units, and replaces the public hearing with a 30-day notice and comment period. Both ordinances passed unanimously, with Councilmember Mohammed absent. - E2 – Land Development Regulations for Civic Uses and Sports Stadiums: Planning Director Elizabeth Abernathy presented amendments adding sports stadiums, convention centers, performing arts venues, and microbreweries to zoning and parking matrices. The proposal sets tiered parking requirements: one space per 20 seats in downtown, one per 10 in traditional districts, and one per 5 in suburban districts, with bicycle parking and off-site parking allowances. It also exempts large civic buildings from downtown floor-plate limits and adjusts CRA submittal rules for large multiphase projects. Councilmembers questioned whether the downtown parking ratio was adequate for large events, but the ordinance passed unanimously. - J1/J2 – Legal Retainers for Stadium Project: Assistant City Attorney McCall Dyer requested approval to increase the Faegre Drinker outside counsel retainer from $250,000 to $550,000 for drafting stadium and gas plant project agreements. Councilmember Hanowitz questioned the magnitude and timing of the increase. The motion passed 5–2, with Councilmembers Floyd and Hanowitz voting no. The council also approved confirming Bryant Miller Olive as special legal counsel for finance-related matters (not to exceed $100,000) and increasing the bond counsel fee cap from $125,000 to $250,000 for publicly issued stadium debt. That motion passed 6–1, with Councilmember Hanowitz voting no. Councilmember Mohammed was absent. - F4 – Inner Circle Sports Agreement: Assistant City Administrator Tom Green presented a $1.248 million consulting agreement with Inner Circle Sports for the Rays/Hines stadium and gas plant negotiation. Compensation includes $700,000 contingent on bond issuance, $274,000 from the FY24 contingency, and $274,000 from Pinellas County under an interlocal agreement. Green also provided a summary of $756,725 in prior professional-services expenses. Councilmembers raised concerns about the scope, the future Stadco entity, and requested financial information, including net present value and revenue streams. Following debate, the council voted to defer action to the December 7, 2023 meeting. - F1 – PSTA Update: PSTA CEO Brad Miller reported on the agency's national APTA award, Sunrunner ridership (over 1 million in its first year), unchanged traffic speeds and reduced crashes on the corridor, a planned First Street station, fare capping at $5 per day, subsidized passes for low-income St. Petersburg residents, free rides for veterans, and zero-emission bus progress. He also detailed a local bill passed 6–3 by the Pinellas legislative delegation that would reduce the PSTA board from 15 to 12 members, cut St. Petersburg's representation from three seats to one, and shift citizen appointments to state legislative leaders. Councilmember Driscoll moved to refer a discussion on a resolution supporting PSTA and opposing the bill to the Legislative and Intergovernmental Relations Committee; the motion passed unanimously. - F2 – Bayou Court Apartments: Housing Program Specialist Mark Van Lew presented a new 60-unit, 100% affordable and workforce housing project near Lake Maggiore. The unit mix includes 12 units at 50% AMI or below, 9 at 80%, 15 at 100%, and 24 at 120% AMI. Total cost per unit is $287,717, and the city's per-unit subsidy is $45,667. Developer Tyler Herbert of Gravel Road Partners spoke in support, noting the project is shovel-ready, includes on-site bus access, and prioritizes municipal and school employees. Council approved resolutions F2A and F2B unanimously, with Councilmember Mohammed absent. - F3 – Repetitive Loss Area Analysis: Floodplain Manager Hannah Rebhholz presented the 2023 annual repetitive loss report. There are 969 repetitive loss structures in four sub-areas, with the highest concentration in Shoreacres. The city is implementing drainage, backflow prevention, and living shoreline projects. Councilmembers learned that the stormwater master plan totals roughly $760 million and would take about 76 years at current funding levels. A deeper discussion was scheduled for March. No vote was required. - G1 – Capital Improvements Element: The council approved the capital improvements element amendment updating the five-year capital improvement schedule and adopting FDOT's work program. The motion passed unanimously, with Councilmembers Montanari and Mohammed absent. - G2 – Parking Enforcement for Domestic and Commercial Equipment: The council heard a first reading of an ordinance updating definitions of "domestic equipment" and "passenger motor vehicle" to restrict live-in vehicles parked in residential areas. Nick Bell spoke in support on behalf of the Old Northeast Neighborhood Association. Councilmembers discussed enforcement discretion and potential unintended effects on people living in vehicles. The ordinance passed 5–2, with Councilmembers Floyd and Gabbard voting no. A second public hearing is scheduled for January 18, 2024. - CRA2 – Old Police Station Mixed-Use Project: Reconvening as the CRA, staff presented a revised $120 million site plan for the old police station property at 1300 First Avenue North. The project includes a 12-story office building with 154,000 square feet of office space, a 7-story building with 42 workforce housing units, a 168-room hotel, a 1-story commercial building, a 629-space parking garage, and a public plaza. The CRA approved the project unanimously, with Councilmember Mohammed absent. - CRA3 – 18th Street North Apartments: The CRA approved a $72.9 million project at the northeast corner of 18th Street North and 2nd Avenue North: an 18-story, 279-unit multifamily building with a 383-space parking garage. Existing tenants remain in place until construction. Councilmember Driscoll raised concerns about the proposed dog run location adjacent to neighboring properties; the applicant said they would explore design improvements. The vote was unanimous, with Councilmember Mohammed absent. - New Business H1–H4 – Committee Referrals: Council approved four referrals: H1 (public art code changes) to the Budget, Finance, and Taxation Committee; H2 (affordable housing lot disposition program) to the Housing, Land Use, and Transportation Committee; H3 (2018 Penny for Pinellas affordable housing guidelines resolution) to HLUT; and H4 (2022 census data and child poverty) to the Youth and Family Services Committee. All referrals passed unanimously. - I1 – 2024 Federal Legislative Agenda: Councilmember Hanowitz moved to approve a resolution confirming the 2024 federal legislative agenda. The motion passed unanimously. - I2 – City-Owned Land Policy: Council approved a resolution supporting the city-owned land disposition policy after public comment and discussion. Staff noted the policy clarifies the city's RFP process and housing goals and incorporates feedback from developers. The motion passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - The agenda and consent calendar were approved unanimously. - E1A, E1B, E2, F1, F2A, F2B, G1, H1–H4, I1, and I2 passed unanimously; Councilmember Mohammed was absent for most of these votes, and Councilmember Montanari was also absent for G1. - J1 (Faegre Drinker retainer increase) passed 5–2, with Councilmembers Floyd and Hanowitz voting no. - J2 (Bryant Miller Olive finance counsel and bond fee cap) passed 6–1, with Councilmember Hanowitz voting no. - G2 (domestic/commercial equipment parking) passed 5–2, with Councilmembers Floyd and Gabbard voting no. - F4 (Inner Circle Sports) was deferred to the December 7, 2023 council meeting. - CRA2 and CRA3 were approved unanimously. Note: The clerk announced the initial agenda vote as passing unanimously with both Councilmembers Mohammed and Driscoll absent, though Driscoll had responded to roll call and later participated in voting; subsequent vote announcements listed only Mohammed absent. This appears to be a transcript discrepancy.
The St. Petersburg City Council met on November 27, 2023, at 10:00 AM. The meeting included an invocation, pledge of allegiance, roll call, and approval of the agenda. The main item was the second reading and public hearing of Ordinance 562H, which addressed budget adjustments for fiscal years 2023 and 2024. A significant discussion centered on reallocating $300,000 from an Albert Whitted Airport economic impact study to an urban tree planting program. Discussion Items - Budget Cleanup Ordinance (562H): Budget Director Liz Mikovsky presented an overview of the FY23 cleanup and FY24 budget reconciliation. Key highlights included: - Estimated FY23 general fund beginning balance of $57.631 million, with an estimated $13.735 million added to fund balance. - FY24 budget entries will use $8.611 million in general fund balance, resulting in an estimated net increase of $5.124 million in fund balance (ending at $62.756 million). - Detailed changes from first reading: revenues increased by $1.865 million, expenditures increased by $431,000, and various fund adjustments were noted. - Debate on $300,000 Transfer: Councilmember Montanari proposed moving $300,000 appropriated for an Albert Whitted Airport economic impact study to the urban tree planting program. Councilmember Driscoll supported the move, citing benefits citywide. Councilmember Gabbard initially made a motion but withdrew it to allow separate consideration. Councilmember Floyd expressed concern about the readiness to spend the money, suggesting alternatives like the contingency fund. Councilmember Fix Sanders recalled previous issues with tree planting. After discussion, a motion to transfer to the urban tree planting program was made by Councilmember Montanari and seconded. Key Outcomes - Vote on Transfer: The motion to transfer $300,000 from the Albert Whitted Airport economic impact study to the urban tree planting program passed 4–3 (Councilmembers Driscoll, Gurtis, Hanowitz, and Montanari voting yes; Councilmembers Fix Sanders, Floyd, and Gabbard voting no; Councilmember Mohammed absent). - Vote on Ordinance as Amended: The amended Ordinance 562H (including the $300,000 transfer) passed unanimously (7–0, with Councilmember Mohammed absent). - The meeting concluded with no other public comments or announcements.
The St. Petersburg City Council met on November 9, 2023, at 6:30 PM to consider proclamations, a police department report, a presentation from the Palladium Theater, and a CRA funding agreement for an affordable housing project. The meeting included a roll call, invocation, and Pledge of Allegiance. All council members were present, with Councilmember Driscoll absent for one vote. The council approved all consent items unanimously and passed a resolution for the Fairfield Avenue Apartments project. Proclamations and Awards - Transgender Day of Remembrance: Mayor Kenneth T. Welch proclaimed November 20, 2023 as Transgender Day of Remembrance in St. Petersburg. Community representatives Tristan Burns, RJ Leschinski, and Rashida Johnson spoke about the vigil to be held at City Hall steps and the importance of supporting transgender residents. They cited statistics on anti-transgender legislation and violence. - USF St. Pete Student Government Day: Mayor Welch proclaimed November 9, 2023 as USF St. Pete Student Government Day. Chancellor Christine Hardigree and Campus Governor Abdul Mukit Kwaja spoke about the student government's role and the partnership with the city. - Hospice and Palliative Care Awareness Month: Vice Chair Deborah Fig Sanders proclaimed November 2023 as Hospice and Palliative Care Awareness Month. Karen Davis Pritchett and colleagues from Suncoast Hospice accepted the proclamation and spoke about their services. - Veterans Day: Councilmember Ed Montaneri proclaimed November 11, 2023 as Veterans Day. Helen Rhymes, social service planning manager, accepted the proclamation. Montaneri encouraged residents to pause at 11 a.m. on November 11 for a moment of silence. Consent Calendar - Approved the meeting agenda unanimously. - Approved Ordinance 562H (year-end appropriation adjustments for FY2023 and FY2024) unanimously; public hearing scheduled for November 27, 2023. - Approved Ordinances 756L and 788Z (future land use and zoning changes for a 0.41-acre parcel at 266th Street North) unanimously; public hearing scheduled for December 7, 2023. Councilmember Driscoll was absent for this vote. - Approved item F3 (unspecified) unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Open Forum: Carrie Mueller (address: 12th and James Avenue) spoke against the proposed new stadium project, arguing that the total cost exceeds $1.2 billion and that the city would contribute approximately 77% of the cost without receiving naming rights or other revenues. She advocated for alternative development of the area. - CRA Public Comment: Brian Unk, attorney for the applicant, spoke in favor of the Fairfield Avenue Apartments project, describing it as the first project in Florida to utilize HB 1339 and highlighting its 100% affordable units and permanent affordability through a land trust. Discussion Items - Police Department Quarterly Report: Chief Anthony Holloway reported that overall crime increased 3.8% compared to the same quarter last year, but the five-year trend is down 6.1%. Violent crime decreased 2.2% (five-year trend down 5%), while property crime increased 5.3% (five-year trend down 4.6%). Auto thefts account for 25% of property crime. There were no homicides in the quarter. The department reported 136 stolen guns (the chief initially said "36" but the breakdown totals 136). The department has 88 applicants in the hiring queue and 25 vacancies. The C.A.L.L. program has exceeded 10,000 calls with no incidents. Council members discussed traffic enforcement on Gandy Boulevard, scooter safety, mental health call responses, and a recent shooting incident downtown. - Palladium Theater: Executive Director Paul Wilburne presented the theater's 25th anniversary and a capital campaign to renovate the facility. The project costs an estimated $10 million. A private donor has committed $5 million (including a $2 million challenge grant), and the state has provided $850,000 for design. Wilburne requested a one-time appropriation from the city, noting the theater has operated in the black since 2012 and does not seek ongoing support. Council members expressed support and discussed possible funding models. - CRA Item – Fairfield Avenue Apartments: The CRA considered a resolution to provide $9.7 million in TIF funding to the Fairfield Avenue Apartments project, a 264-unit 100% affordable housing development. The project will include units at 50%, 80%, and 120% of AMI. The per-unit subsidy is $36,742, lower than recent similar projects. Pinellas County approved $12.4 million in funding. The project will be permanently affordable via a land trust. Construction is expected to begin in Q1 2024. Councilmember Mohammed requested reporting on local business participation; the administration agreed to add reporting requirements. The resolution passed unanimously. - Referral to HERSC: Councilmember Driscoll requested a referral to the Health, Energy, Resilience and Sustainability Committee to discuss updates on Healthy St. Pete and the St. Pete Healthy Food Action Plan. The request was approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - All votes were unanimous. - Agenda approved. - E1, E2, F3, G1 approved unanimously. - CRA resolution for Fairfield Avenue Apartments approved unanimously. - Proclamations presented. - The council will consider funding for the Palladium Theater in future meetings.
The St. Petersburg City Council met on November 2, 2023, beginning at 2:00 PM UTC, with all eight members present. The meeting included approval of consent items, multiple public hearings, and new business items concerning affordable housing, community development, and a proposed straw poll on the Tampa Bay Rays stadium development. Key speakers included council members, staff, and members of the public. The meeting lasted approximately several hours, concluding with announcements and adjournment. Consent Calendar - Agenda Approval: Added item CB20; approved unanimously. - Consent Agenda: Routine approvals and unanimous actions approved without discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - Street Flooding: George Cassidy (3130 10th St N) and Sean Gretsch (921 32nd Ave N) described chronic flooding in Magnolia Heights and called for improved stormwater infrastructure. Cassidy stated pipes are inadequate, and Gretsch cited a city supervisor confirming pipes are too small. - Stadium Straw Poll: Multiple residents spoke in favor of placing a non-binding straw poll on the March 2024 ballot regarding the Tampa Bay Rays stadium deal. Speakers included John Stewart (who cited economic studies showing subsidies do not benefit communities), William Kilgore (St. Pete Tenants Union), Peter Kent (detailed cost breakdown of $1.3 billion taxpayer burden), Andy Oliver (asked for the straw poll as a data point), James TriMarco, and Carrie Mueller (raised concerns about developer concessions). All urged the council to let the public vote. - Israel-Gaza Resolution: Marella Setkick (4200 25th Ave N) expressed disappointment with the council's October 12 resolution supporting Israel, asking for a resolution supporting Palestinians and advocating peace. She noted over 8,800 Palestinian deaths, including 3,600 children. - Final Open Forum: Gerald Broadbent (715 64th Ave S) complained about overnight campers at Maximo Park and requested better enforcement from police. Discussion Items - F3 - Good News: Tree Planting Grant: Councilmember Mohammed presented a $49,000+ grant for tree planting in Child's Park, with city match. Councilmember Driscoll and others praised the initiative but questioned the need for a proposed $850,000 tree mapping study. Staff (Alison [last name]) said alternatives are being explored. The item passed unanimously. - E4 - Affordable Housing Tax Abatement (Liv eLocal Act): Administrator Amy Foster presented an ordinance creating Chapter 28 to provide tax relief for developments with 50+ units where at least 20% are affordable at 60% AMI or below. The exemption applies only to city taxes and sunsets in 2026. Councilmember Gabbard thanked staff for rapid implementation. Passed unanimously. - F2 - St. Petersburg College Property Acquisition: Director Aaron Fish described the purchase of 5.23 acres at 7045 Burlington Ave N for $4.2 million, to be rezoned for up to 105 townhomes at or below 120% AMI, with 30% first right of refusal for SPC employees/students. Councilmembers expressed support and discussed affordability targets. Passed unanimously. - F4 - Final Plat for YMCA/Mangrove Middle School: Elizabeth Abernathy presented the final plat for the joint campus on 62nd Ave N. The project, substantially constructed, includes a 600-student health/wellness magnet middle school and a YMCA. Councilmembers praised the collaboration. Passed unanimously. - G1 - Affordable Housing Ordinances: Two ordinances related to Live Local Act implementing regulations for administrative approval of affordable housing. Passed unanimously. - H1 - Straw Poll on Rays Stadium Agreement: Councilmember Floyd requested a referral to the Committee of the Whole (COW) to discuss a non-binding straw poll on the March 19, 2024 ballot. After debate, the motion failed 5-3 (yes: Driscoll, Fix Sanders, Floyd, Hanowitz, Mohammed; no: Gabbard, Gerdes, Montanari). Opponents cited complexity of the deal, low turnout in a presidential primary (72% of St. Pete voters are Democratic/NPA/other), and the advisory nature of a straw poll on a non-binding term sheet. - H2 - Joint CBAC/City Council Meeting: Council Vice Chair Fix Sanders requested a COW meeting with the Community Benefits Advisory Committee to discuss the community benefit program. Passed unanimously. - H3 - Flood Mitigation Strategies: Chair Gabbard requested a COW by Q1 2024 to discuss flood strategies, including permitting, FEMA grants, community rating, and a climate-informed zoning study. Passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Approved Unanimously: Consent agenda, E1-E3 (preliminary assessments), E4 (affordable housing tax abatement), F2 (SPC property acquisition), F4 (YMCA/school plat), G1 (affordable housing ordinances), H2 (joint CBAC meeting), and H3 (flood mitigation discussion). - Failed 5-3: Motion to refer H1 (straw poll discussion) to COW. - Staff Directives: Staff to convene a meeting with CBAC members before any further changes; staff to explore alternatives to the $850,000 tree mapping study. - Next Steps: The straw poll idea is tabled; tree grant to proceed with volunteer hours tracked; SPC property to be rezoned and RFP issued; YMCA/school set to open in December 2023 (YMCA) and fall 2024 (school). Announcements - Birthday wishes for Paul Tracy (Clerk's office). - Condolences for Ambassador Mel Sembler (passed away) and Reverend Robert DePew (affordable housing advocate). - Council Chair Gabbard addressed concerns about Sunshine Law compliance at an Albert Whitted Airport event, noting two council members spoke and minutes were requested. Other council members assured no violation.
The St. Petersburg City Council met on October 20, 2023, at 6:15 PM (the meeting began on October 19 but continued into the evening) to consider a variety of agenda items including consent items, a grant award, a major theater update, several public hearings, and a controversial community benefits program amendment. The meeting also featured extensive public comment regarding the city's recent resolution supporting Israel. Consent Calendar - Approved the consent agenda unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Open Forum (early): Lolita Campbell, a public policy student, expressed full support for Ordinance 561H, which creates a tax abatement for affordable housing projects under the Live Local Act. She argued it would provide safe housing, foster economic growth, and make the city more inclusive. - Public Hearing on J3 (Community Benefits Program): Multiple speakers, including representatives from labor unions and the Community Benefits Advisory Committee (CBAC), expressed concerns about the ordinance. Speakers urged council to strengthen language regarding best faith efforts, apprenticeship requirements, and equitable inclusion of small, minority, and women-owned businesses. They noted that the CBAC had not met recently and requested more dialogue before approval. - Open Forum (late evening): A large number of speakers (approximately 20) addressed the council demanding repeal of a resolution passed on October 12, 2023, that expressed support for Israel. Speakers argued the resolution was unbalanced, ignored the history of Palestinian displacement, and risked fueling Islamophobia. They called for a ceasefire and criticized the city's use of taxpayer dollars in support of Israel. Several speakers identified as Jewish, Palestinian, or allies and emphasized that criticizing Israel is not anti-Semitic. Discussion Items - Good News Item F3 – CAD RMS Grant: Assistant Police Chief David Gerardo and Administrative Services Assistant Director Megan McGee presented a $750,000 federal technology grant from the Office of Community Oriented Policing Services. The grant will fund enhanced data storage for a multi-jurisdictional computer-aided dispatch and records management system, improving response coordination among Pinellas County agencies. Councilmember Gurtis celebrated the grant. Approved unanimously. - Ordinance E1 – Affordable Housing Tax Relief (First Reading): Housing Administrator Amy Foster presented the first reading of a new chapter 28 in the city code, creating a tax abatement for affordable housing projects. No presentation was given; the item was previously heard in committee. Approved unanimously. - Item F1 – Reallocation of ERA2 Funds: Housing Assistant Director Avery Schuyler requested approval to accept $156,923.83 in additional U.S. Treasury funds for emergency rental assistance, combined with existing ERA2 funds. The resolution obligates funds for homeless prevention contracts with local agencies and utility arrear agreements. Councilmember Floyd asked about the utility arrear process. Approved unanimously. - Item F2 – Mahaffey Theater Update (Big Three Entertainment): Development Coordination Director Chris Ballestra introduced a report on the theater's progress. Bill Edwards, head of Big Three Entertainment, presented a video showcasing investments of over $10 million, a new restaurant (Sonata) with chef Ted Dorsey, and the Class Acts youth education program that has served over half a million students. Councilmembers praised the partnership and Mr. Edwards' contributions. Councilmember Montaneri raised concerns about needed capital repairs (electrical, sound system, fountain) and suggested the city should budget for maintenance. Mr. Edwards noted the city needs to invest in its own asset. The item was a report, not a vote. - Item F4 – Vanoy Golf Club Canal Dredging: Engineering Director Brajesh Prayman presented a resolution for construction phase services to dredge a canal and improve drainage in the Snell Isle neighborhood. The project aims to increase hydraulic capacity and reduce flooding. Councilmember Montaneri highlighted the long-standing flooding issue. Approved unanimously. - Item H1 – Council Committee Report: Councilmember Gurtis moved approval of a scope of services for a management evaluation of St. Petersburg Fire and Rescue, authorizing a request for proposal. Approved unanimously. - Public Hearing J1 – Right-of-Way Vacation: Deputy Zoning Official Scott Board presented a vacation of 332 square feet of right-of-way on 8th Street North, with a condition to replat the abutting property. No opposition. Approved unanimously. - Public Hearing J2 – Development Agreement Amendment (Gateway J Bill): Planner Britton Wilson presented a first amendment to a development agreement due to unforeseen subsurface soil conditions. The amendment reduces the concurrent industrial space requirement from 200,000 to 143,000 square feet, but increases total industrial space to 290,000 by February 2025. Staff recommended approval, noting that leaving 412 multifamily units (including 83 workforce units) empty would be contrary to public interest. Approved unanimously. - Public Hearing J4 – Special Events in Edge District: Assistant City Attorney Michael Dima presented an ordinance creating a council waiver process for the 60-day lead time for special events. A resolution approving a specific event was also considered. Roger Curlin of the Edge Business District Association spoke in support. The ordinance (J4A) and resolution (J4B) were approved separately, each unanimously. - Public Hearing J5 – Special Assessment District (Alley Paving): Engineering Director Brajesh Prayman presented a resolution for alley improvements between 1st and 2nd Avenue North, leveraging existing utility work to reduce costs. The average assessment is approximately $35 per month. Councilmember Hanowitz asked about the process for notifying homeowners. Approved unanimously. - Public Hearing J6 – Pathways to Removing Obstacles to Housing Grant: Assistant Director Avery Schuyler presented a resolution to apply for a $10 million HUD grant to remove barriers to affordable housing, focusing on the Deuces community and citywide strategies. The grant requires no match. Councilmember Gurtis praised the deliverables and tracking plan with USF. Councilmember Floyd noted the unusual requirement for a resolution before applying. Approved unanimously. - Public Hearing J3 – Community Benefit Program Amendments (Ordinance 556-H and Resolution): Economic Development Director Brian Caper presented updated ordinance and guidance document changes. Key changes included bifurcating AMI levels (30% at 120% AMI in specified districts, 80% AMI elsewhere), increasing payment-in-lieu from $100,000 to $150,000 per unit, eliminating the "or" provision in the streamline process, and requiring written documentation of good faith efforts. The streamline process now requires developers to utilize apprentices, disadvantaged workers, and provide public parking in certain zones. A joint meeting with the CBAC and future discussion on apprenticeship language were requested by several councilmembers. After debate, the ordinance (J3A) passed 5-3 (Driscoll, Gabbard, Gurdis, Hanowitz, Montaneri yes; Fig Sanders, Floyd, Mohammed no). The resolution (J3B) also passed 5-3 with the same vote. Key Outcomes - Consent agenda and most routine items were approved unanimously. - Item J3 (Community Benefits Program) was approved on a 5-3 vote. The council directed staff to consider further amendments, particularly regarding apprenticeship requirements and alignment with the city's procurement code. A joint meeting with the CBAC was suggested but not formally scheduled. - Multiple speakers in open forum called for the repeal of the council's recent resolution supporting Israel. No action was taken on that request during this meeting, but the matter was noted.
The St. Petersburg City Council met on October 12, 2023, at 2:00 PM (estimated) to consider a full agenda including proclamations for Fire Prevention Week, Domestic Violence Awareness Month, Breast Cancer Awareness Month, and Clergy Appreciation Month, as well as presentations on youth baseball achievements, master swimming, and a water supply update from Tampa Bay Water. The council also debated and voted on a resolution supporting Israel and condemning Hamas. Open forum included public comments on the Israel-Hamas conflict and the Rays stadium deal. Councilmember Mohammed was absent. Mayor Ken Welch was also absent, sending regrets. Public Comments & Testimony - Craig Scher (Chairman of Backstreets Capital) thanked the council for their support of Israel and urged passage of a resolution supporting the state, calling the attack a 'difficult week' for the Jewish community. - Eric Ludin (St. Petersburg attorney, wife a Holocaust survivor's daughter) described the personal meaning of Israel to his family and expressed gratitude for the council's resolution, noting it provides comfort amid the 'brutal' attacks. - Dan Harvey Jr. (resident) urged the council to scrutinize the Rays/Heinz development deal, emphasizing the need to ensure fair value for the 86 acres and to direct funds to the black community. He stated, 'We should do whatever it takes to keep [the Rays].' - Karen Lieberman (resident) provided historical context on Israel, the Balfour Declaration, and the Holocaust to counter claims that Israel has no right to exist. She quoted the Hamas Charter and its explicit calls for Jewish death. - Michael Eagle (Board Chair, Florida Holocaust Museum) recalled his grandparents' Holocaust survival and family in Israel. He stated this is a 'moral issue, not a political issue' and thanked the council for adopting the IHRA definition of anti-Semitism, which he said must now be used. - William Kilgore (resident) expressed mourning for all victims but dissented from the resolution, arguing it ignores Palestinian civilian casualties, connects Iran without clear evidence (citing U.S. intelligence), and risks escalating conflict like the Iraq War. He called for peace. Discussion Items - Proclamations: Councilmember Montanari presented a Fire Prevention Week proclamation (Oct 8-14, 2023) with Fire Marshal Womack highlighting cooking safety, 209 public education programs, 250+ smoke alarm installations, and the Oct 14 block party. Vice Chair Fig Sanders presented Domestic Violence Awareness Month with CASA CEO reporting 23,044 bed nights and a new Family Justice Center serving 2,500+ people. Councilmember Gurtis presented Breast Cancer Awareness Month, noting his wife's survival and urging early detection. Vice Chair Fig Sanders presented Clergy Appreciation Month with Rev. Pritchett and other clergy present. - Youth Baseball All Stars: Sean Dronen introduced Cameron and Diego, who won a national STEM-based baseball competition at MLB All-Star Weekend in Seattle, representing St. Pete. They brought the championship home. - St. Pete Masters Swimming: Bob Beach (world record holder), Coach Gary Basty, and Dr. Peter Betzer celebrated St. Pete Masters achievements, including national champions and world records. They thanked the city for North Shore Pool support. - Tampa Bay Water Update: General Manager Chuck Carden presented the state of Tampa Bay Water, noting the agency's 25th anniversary, current wholesale rate of $2.60 per 1,000 gallons, and the 2023 long-term master plan. The system is 60% groundwater/40% alternative sources. A stage one water shortage was declared due to an 8.3-inch rainfall deficit over 12 months. He also reported PFOS levels at 4.1 parts per trillion in two locations (slightly above EPA's proposed limit of 4 ppt) and outlined seven project concepts to meet 2033 demand, including surface water, desalination, and groundwater. - Resolution Supporting Israel: Councilmember Montanari introduced the resolution, stating 'we need to stand against evil' and citing the Oct 7 Hamas attack as the largest single-day murder of Jews since the Holocaust. Councilmember Hanowitz called Hamas 'no better than al Qaeda' and condemned the 'indiscriminate killing.' Councilmember Driscoll emotionally described Hamas posting a video of a woman's murder on her Facebook page. Councilmember Floyd dissented, arguing the resolution's condemnation of Iran 'feels eerily similar to 2003' and could escalate conflict; he called for peace and an end to the Gaza siege. Key Outcomes - Consent Agenda: Motion to approve the agenda passed unanimously with Councilmember Mohammed absent. - Resolution Supporting Israel (Item F4): Passed 6-1 (Councilmembers Driscoll, Fig Sanders, Gabbard, Gurtis, Hanowitz, Montanari voting yes; Councilmember Floyd voting no; Councilmember Mohammed absent). - Tampa Bay Water: Council received the presentation and thanked Councilmember Hanowitz for her service on the board. - Youth and Swimming Presentations: Recognized with appreciation; no formal vote required. - Proclamations: All adopted by acclamation or as presented. - Future Meeting: Councilmember Driscoll announced she will invite PSTA CEO Brad Miller to present transit awards at a future meeting. - Meeting Adjourned: No further business.
The meeting began with an invocation, pledge of allegiance, roll call, and unanimous approval of the agenda and consent agenda. Ceremonial items included a visit from the Takamatsu, Japan delegation celebrating the 60th anniversary of the sister city relationship, a proclamation for St. Petersburg Folk Festival Days, and the introduction of Lanise Emmanuel as the city's first Chief Equity Officer. Public comment addressed the proposed stadium deal, digital inclusion, and business equity initiatives. Legal settlements were approved, and ordinances were debated on a minority and women business enterprise program, a bus pass subsidy for low-income residents, amendments to the community benefits program, and a waiver for Edge District special events. The meeting adjourned after announcements. Consent Calendar - The agenda was approved unanimously. - The consent agenda (routine items) was approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Tori Walker (St. Vincent DePaul Disaster Services) introduced the organization's disaster case management program for Hurricane Ian survivors and requested partnership with the city. - Jeremy Tolberg (Snell Isle resident) opposed publicly funding a new stadium, citing studies showing overestimated economic benefits and the Miami Marlins example. - Beatrice Farrell expressed support for digital inclusion efforts, highlighting the city's progress and a planned Municipal Trailblazer Award submission. - Carrie Mueller (Campbell Park resident) praised recent business equity events, including a Turner Construction class, a health equity community event, and the supplier diversity day. - Ruth Whitney (700 14th Ave N, member of the Community Benefits Advisory Council) spoke against the streamlined process in the community benefits program amendment, urging that community input not be bypassed. - Kimberly Stidham (St. Petersburg College student) spoke in favor of the Edge District special events waiver, noting the slow summer for hospitality. - Roger Curlin (Executive Director, Edge Business District Association) supported the waiver for the Orange Belt Criterium cycling event, citing business support and a police-approved safety plan. - Nathan Stonecypher (Co-founder, Green Bench Brewing) explained the event's mission to promote cycling diversity and accessibility, and its potential to attract professional cyclists. Discussion Items - Minority and Women Business Enterprise (MWBE) Program (Item E4): Staff presented an ordinance creating an MWBE program with project-specific goals, a Business Equity Advisory Committee, and a five-year sunset. Councilmember Montaneri raised constitutional concerns under strict scrutiny, referencing the Richmond v. Crizon and Students for Fair Admissions cases. City Attorney staff explained the disparity study and narrow tailoring. Councilmember Mohammed urged passage as a moral imperative. Passed 7-1, with Montaneri voting no. - Transportation Disadvantaged Program Bus Pass Subsidy (Item F1): Transportation Director Evan Mori proposed a $175,000 annual subsidy to eliminate fares for low-income residents (below 200% federal poverty level) who meet transportation disadvantage criteria. PSTA's Ross Silver described the application process. Councilmember Floyd requested streamlining documentation for vulnerable populations. Approved unanimously. - Community Benefit Program Amendments (Item G3): Economic Development Director Brian Cover presented revisions including a streamlined process, alternative benefits, and exemptions. The streamline option allows developers to either provide 30% residential units at 80% AMI with a 30-year affordability period or make a payment in lieu plus meet other requirements (SBE/MWBE participation, lead certification, etc.). The stadium development was explicitly excluded. Councilmembers Gabbard, Driscoll, Floyd, and Mohammed expressed concerns about community input, the exclusion of the stadium, and the "or" provision for mixed-use projects. Promised clarification language before second reading. Passed 6-1 (Councilmember Floyd voting no; Councilmember Gurdas absent). - Edge District Special Events Waiver (Item G4): An ordinance to allow council to waive the 60-day application requirement for special events in the Edge District Specialty Center. Councilmember Driscoll noted the district's stricter rule vs. the 30-day requirement elsewhere and indicated plans for a permanent change. Approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - MWBE Program (E4): Passed 7-1. Establishes certification, project-specific goals, a Business Equity Advisory Committee, and a five-year sunset. - Bus Pass Subsidy (F1): Approved unanimously. Authorizes a three-year agreement with PSTA to subsidize fares to $0, budgeted at $175,000/year, starting November 1, 2023. - Community Benefits Program Amendments (G3): Passed 6-1. Revises the code with a streamline process, alternative benefits, and clarifications. Further revisions to be presented for second reading on October 19, 2023. - Edge District Special Events (G4): Passed unanimously. Grants council authority to waive the 60-day notice requirement. - Legal Settlements (Items J1-J4): Approved unanimously. Settlements: Charles Myers ($200,000) and Loretta Myers ($30,000) for a police vehicle collision; James Culverson ($80,000) for workers' compensation; Richard Miranda ($245,000) for workers' compensation and separation from the police department; and authorization to make an offer of judgment up to $65,000 in a pending auto accident case. - Referral (I1): Approved unanimously. Referred to the Budget, Finance and Taxation Committee to discuss proposed procurement code changes.