Public Meetings - Detroit, Michigan

The committee convened to discuss the 2026 Executive Organization Plan (EOP), hear public testimony, and act on multiple settlements, contracts, and appointments. The meeting included a public hearing on the EOP, detailed budget discussions, and decisions on over a dozen items, most passed unanimously to the full council. Public Comments & Testimony - Joanne Warwick called for a second public hearing, stating residents lacked materials to give informed comment. She criticized the administration for not fully implementing Charter Section 7-201 on health services and urged compliance with Section 9-405 on eliminating redundancy. - William M. Davis expressed disappointment that detailed documentation was not available on the agenda. He questioned whether the reorganization would improve efficiency and reduce redundancy, and noted the large expansion of the CFO’s office. - C. Gina Brown Anderson asked whether residents were properly notified of the hearing and whether vacant positions in the health department would be filled with higher‑cost roles requiring council approval. - Carolyn Hughes (Ona Popper) agreed with prior callers about poor notification and lack of documents. She characterized the administration as top‑heavy and questioned the movement of programs out of the health department. - Ms. Ahmad raised concerns about environmental pollution (paint factory, cancer clusters) and asked that past harms be prioritized by the health department. Discussion Items - Executive Organization Plan (EOP): The administration (Ms. Staudemeyer, Mr. Bowser) presented a budget‑neutral restructuring of HRD into three departments: HRD ($45.9M, 89 positions), HHFS ($41.4M, 109 positions), and OCFO ($3.3M, 23 positions). The plan shifts compliance, homelessness services, and outreach under new umbrellas to allow HRD to focus on housing development. Councilmembers questioned vacancy counts (579 general fund non‑public safety full‑time headcount vacancies), the fate of programs like Tangled Titles and Right to Counsel, and the lack of names on the org chart. The administration stated the org chart will be finalized after council approval and posted to Municode. - Public Hearing on EOP: The hearing was called to order at approximately 11:16 AM. Six callers raised concerns about insufficient public notice (legal ad published Feb. 18 in Detroit Legal News), missing documents, and the need for a health department focus on environmental health. The law department confirmed the EOP filing was available via e‑scribe. - Settlement – Nicole Benjamin (Line Item 8.1): A $134,833 settlement for a sidewalk injury caused by a city tree. DPW acknowledged the defect was first reported in 2022 and admitted the backlog of sidewalk repairs. Director Brundich announced a return to temporary cold‑patch repairs to prevent future injuries. The motion to approve passed without objection. - Settlement – Pignataro (Line Item 8.2): A $35,000 settlement for a pedestrian cut by a metal post cut flush but left sharp. DPW will inspect the location (Clifford between Henry and Fisher Service Drive) and ensure it is properly covered. Approved. - Cannabis Social Equity Research Contract (Line Items 8.6 & 9.4): A $500,000 contract (later amended to use 100% Homegrown funds) with the University of Michigan for a research report on social equity in Detroit’s cannabis industry. Councilmembers pressed for inclusion of public health and youth impacts. U‑M researchers Dr. Melissa Creary and Dr. Catherine Hindi agreed that health equity is central and would be incorporated, though the scope primarily focuses on licensees and policy makers. After debate, the motion to move to formal with recommendation to approve as amended passed without objection. - Right to Counsel Contract Amendment (Line Item 9.3): $500,000 increase (state grant funding) to Neighborhood Defender Service for legal representation. Executive Director Diamond Conley reported that in 2025 the program provided full representation to 94% of 10,000 tenants, keeping 53% in their homes. Funding from ARPA is expected to last through mid‑2027. Approved to formal. - Disability Task Force (Line Item 8.3), EOP Questions (Line Item 8.4), Miller Law Firm Contract (Line Item 8.5), and Legal Opinion on Bond Issuance (Line Item 8.7) were all brought back one week. - Board of Ethics – Privilege Memo (Line Item 9.10), Human Resources Compensation Schedule (Line Item 9.11), and Data Sharing Report (Line Item 9.14) held for two weeks; CAC Rules (Line Item 9.14) also held two weeks. Key Outcomes - EOP – Public Hearing: Held and closed. No vote taken; the matter remains in committee for further consideration. - Settlements Approved (moved to formal): - Nicole Benjamin (sidewalk injury): $134,833 – unanimous. - Thomas Pignataro (metal post injury): $35,000 – unanimous. - Tavares Hernandez (Line Item 9.5): $9,500 – unanimous. - Claude Barnes (Line Item 9.6): $70,000 (DPD) – unanimous. - Regina Hans (Line Item 9.7): $40,000 (D‑dot) – unanimous. - Tunstall Marshall (Line Item 9.8): $10,000 (D‑dot) – unanimous. - Cannabis Research Contract (8.6/9.4): Moved to formal with recommendation to approve, funding source changed to Homegrown dollars – unanimous. - Right to Counsel Amendment (9.3): Moved to formal with recommendation to approve – unanimous. - Items Brought Back: - Line Items 8.3, 8.4, 8.5, 8.7 (one week). - Line Items 9.10, 9.11 (one week); 9.14, 9.15 (two weeks). - Appointments Scheduled: - Nifa Cancel and Sabrina Louvine to the Human Rights Commission – interviews set for March 4, 2026 at 10:20 AM. - Richie Harrison reappointment to the City Planning Commission – brought back one week pending interview. - Pamela Powell appointment to District 4 CAC – received and filed (discretion of district councilmember). - Line Item 9.7 (Latino Properties settlement): Removed from agenda as previously discussed. - Meeting Recess: The Budget, Finance and Audit Committee (chaired by Councilmember McCampbell) was called to order and immediately recessed at 1:00 PM, after which the Internal Operations meeting continued and later adjourned.

The Budget, Finance, and Audit (BFA) Standing Committee of the Detroit City Council met on February 25, 2026, to address a range of fiscal matters including water revenue estimates, mid-year financial reports, and public comment. Due to time constraints, public comment was limited to one minute per speaker, and the scheduled CDBG appeals hearing was postponed to the following day. Public Comments & Testimony - Russ Ballant questioned the basis for a reported $135 million increase in DWSD revenue between FY25 ($590M) and FY26 ($724.4M) from the revenue estimating conference, and asked for clarification on whether all revenue comes from customer accounts. - Owner Papa (Ms. Hughes) raised concerns about the citywide payroll performance audit (Item 6.1) previously available but now inaccessible, and questioned why DWSD was excluded from the audit during Plant Morant's tenure. - William N. Davis echoed previous callers' questions and asked whether the city would provide ratepayer rebates or fully fund DWSD retiree pensions if retirees were shortchanged. - A resident criticized the lack of transparency in agenda attachments and non-compliance with Charter Sections 7-201 and 9-405, and noted the disparity in legal fees between right-to-counsel ($760/case) and Zausmer law firm for solar takings. - Betty A. Varner requested council consider waiving land use hearing fees for community organizations and sought funding for the Sojourner Truth corridor and park expansion. - Carmen Cunningham pleaded for assistance in making peanut butter sandwiches for hungry individuals at transit centers, citing increased food costs. - A caller (phone ending 169) expressed support for public transportation and quoted Bob Marley in reference to underdogs. - Darren McCluskey criticized the city's approach to solar takings, noting a $760/case right-to-counsel vs. tens of thousands spent per property when the city is the aggressor, and alleged fraudulent data used for just compensation. Discussion Items Water Revenue Estimates (115 Presentation) - Valerie Goli (Acting Treasurer/Deputy CFO) and Lashonda Davis (DWSD Director of Finance) presented corrected estimates after acknowledging the revenue estimating conference data was based on stale information. - The previously reported 23% increase for FY26 was inaccurate; revised FY26 revenue estimate is $618 million (vs. $589M actual in FY25), an increase of about $29 million (4.9%). - DWSD will not issue bonds in FY26; a potential $60 million bond issuance (split $30M water/$30M sewer) is under consideration for late FY27, with bond proceeds received around May, not affecting debt service until FY28. - Councilmembers discussed the stagnant $50 million annual payment from GLWA (no cost-of-living adjustment), the 40-year asset lease that extends with bond issuances, and the inability of the city to renegotiate the MOU without regional partners. - Councilmember Waters noted that GLWA does not contribute to the city's general fund, and the $50 million payment will diminish over time. - Councilmember Johnson asked about the rate negotiation process and the burden on ratepayers. - Chair expressed concern that the GLWA arrangement is a "bad deal" for Detroit and that it impacts struggling residents. - Controls for future accuracy: DWSD will now be part of preliminary revenue conference reviews, monthly meetings with the budget team, and formal reviews before public distribution. Six-Month Financial Report (Ending December 31, 2025) - Donnie Johnson (Acting Deputy CFO/Budget Director) and Valerie Goli presented the report. - Revenues: $35.6 million surplus driven by wagering taxes and higher property tax collections. - Expenditures: $8.3 million underspent. - Operating surplus: $43.9 million combined; annual projection now shows a $2.2 million surplus (previous deficit concern alleviated). - Income tax: Withholding up $8.8M year-over-year; corporate income tax down $4M. - Cash position: General ledger cash balance $1.6 billion (down from $2 billion same period last year due to ARPA spend-down and bond proceeds). - Property tax collections: On track; one-time timing difference for mortgage servicer payments noted. - Headcount: Net increase of 23 FTEs citywide; Fire Department dropped 16 FTEs (retirements); Transportation added 53 FTEs (student drivers). - Councilmember Johnson asked about solid waste fee projections tied to property tax collections; reassured alignment with contract expectations. - Mr. Corley noted income tax revenue is steady with moderate growth, and corporate collections have slightly improved; caution advised due to tariff uncertainties. Other New Business - Item 6.1 (Payroll Performance Audit): Moved to be brought back in six weeks, with note that the audit is published on the Auditor General's website. - Item 6.2 (Centralized Fee Schedule): Motion to bring back in one week, as a report is expected in a day or two. - Item 7.1 (Office of City Clerk/Planning Commission report): Received and filed. - Item 7.2 (NEZ Certificate for 1255 Bagley): Chris Gulak (CPC staff) and petitioner Matthew Cassidy presented the application for a single-family rehab in the Corktown NEZ. The property has two parcel numbers; the other half (1257) was approved last month. Estimated rehab cost $103,000; unit is owner-occupied. Council approved and sent to formal session. - Item 7.3 (Delinquent Tax Interest/Fees): Vice Chair Johnson requested LPD evaluation; brought back in two weeks. Key Outcomes - The DWSD revenue estimates were corrected; a revised five-year outlook will be released by the Treasury office. - The 6.1 payroll audit presentation was deferred to return in six weeks; council confirmed the audit is publicly available online. - Item 6.2 will be brought back in one week. - Item 7.2 was approved and sent to formal session (no objections). - Item 7.3 will be brought back in two weeks. - Member reports were suspended, and the meeting adjourned. The CDBG appeals hearing was postponed to February 26, 2026, at the regular scheduled time; public comment for that hearing was taken after the BFA meeting recessed.

The Detroit City Council held a formal session on February 24, 2026, addressing the ongoing Leland House tenant crisis, receiving updates on the Kronos concrete plant, and considering a range of resolutions, contracts, and public comments. Key discussions focused on the city's plan to retrieve tenants' belongings from the Leland House following a court hearing, and the health impacts of industrial operations in residential areas. Several items were postponed for further review. Public Comments & Testimony - Residents and activists raised concerns about D-DOT bus service reliability, particularly for disabled riders. - Multiple speakers from the Cadillac Heights area urged the Council to down-zone land near the Kronos concrete mixing plant from M4 to SD2, citing health issues (sinus infections, lung nodules) from dust and particulates. They requested the city initiate the downzoning to avoid resident application fees. - Several callers and in-person speakers demanded the city implement stronger protections against ICE, including declaring city property an ICE-free zone, ending any 287(g) agreements, and requiring judicial warrants for ICE access. - Commenters also called for independent counsel for the Board of Ethics and the Board of Police Commissioners, criticizing Corporation Counsel's influence. - A caller alleged that the city's property tax system has illegally overtaxed homeowners by $600 million and led to 100,000 wrongful foreclosures. - A public commenter reported being drugged, sexually assaulted, and later ticketed by Detroit police, alleging mistreatment by the department. Council President Tate responded, offering to investigate and providing his office number (313-224-1027). Discussion Items - Leland House Update (2:10 PM – 3:10 PM): Council received an update from the Administration during the formal session, before a scheduled 10:00 AM bankruptcy court hearing on the Leland House. Trisha Stein (Senior Director of Strategic Initiatives), Graham Anderson (Law Department), and Julie Schneider (Director of Housing and Revitalization) presented the city’s plan for a potential court-ordered asset retrieval, including temporary electrical restoration and professional moving services. The city had spent the prior week assessing options, including temporary electrical restoration and a no-electricity move. The city’s preference was to restore temporary power to allow tenants to supervise the packing of their belongings. 14 households had found permanent housing; 3 more were awaiting moves. The city committed to providing storage and up to two months of housing for displaced tenants. - Leland House Court Outcome (After Public Comments): Corporation Counsel Conrad Mallett reported back to the Council that Judge Oxholm had accepted the city's plan. Debtor’s counsel conceded that the sale of the building could not proceed until tenants' belongings were removed, strengthening the city’s position as a creditor. A written plan is to be submitted to the court by March 3, 2026, with a hearing for secured creditors on March 10, 2026. - Kronos Concrete Plant: Several council members and public speakers echoed the request for downzoning and expressed frustration over air quality enforcement. - Tree Trimming Contracts: Councilmember Miller submitted a memorandum expressing concern over $18 million in tree trimming contracts. She called for a presentation from the General Services Department (GSD) and the Forestry Department on expanding the city's in-house forestry capacity. A presentation with LPD was confirmed for March 5, 2026. - Property Tax Appeals: Councilmember McCampbell reminded residents that the deadline to appeal property taxes is March 9, 2026 at 4:30 PM. - Flock Camera Technology: A public commenter asked the Council to vote on removing Flock (automated license plate reader) technology from the city. Key Outcomes - Leland House: The city’s plan to retrieve tenants’ belongings was accepted by the bankruptcy judge. Debtor’s counsel admitted the sale cannot proceed without the removal of tenant property. The city will seek to be made a secured creditor. A written plan is due by March 3, 2026, with a hearing for secured creditors on March 10, 2026. - Postponements: - Line Item 19.1 (DCD General Contracting Services contract) was postponed for one week at the request of Councilmember Callaway. - Line Items 20.12 through 20.16 and 23.5 (Tree trimming contracts) were postponed for one week at the request of Councilmember Benson and others, to allow for a presentation by the General Services Department and Forestry on March 5, 2026. - Waivers Granted: Waivers were granted for Line Items 20.10, 20.20-20.22, and 20.2-20.8. - Resolutions Approved: Multiple resolutions were approved, including - Items 16.1-16.3 (MCCampbell) - Items 17.1-17.11 (Various) - Items 18.1 (BD Venture Studio LLC) - Items 20.1, 23.2 (Pro Tem Young) - Items 20.2-20.10 (Santiago Romero – HIV services, police firing range maintenance, DDOT bus repairs) with an objection from Callaway to 20.9 (police firing range) and from McCampbell and Callaway to 20.19 (Auto theft grant) - Items 29.1-29.8 (Testimonials and special privileges) - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned without further business.

On February 23, 2026, the Detroit City Council's Extended Planning and Economic Development Standing Committee convened at 1:00 PM to discuss the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Neighborhood Opportunity Fund (NOF) for FY 2026-2027. The meeting included an overview of the NOF process, a public hearing for applicants, and an appeals hearing for organizations recommended for zero funding. Council President James Tate chaired, with members Scott Benson, Letitia Johnson, Mary Waters, Angela Whitfield, Coleman Young II, and Denzel McCampbell present. Consent Calendar - [No consent calendar items were discussed.] Public Comments & Testimony - Public Hearing (Applicants): Several applicants addressed the committee. Carlton White (North End Village) stated his organization met the 82-point threshold but was denied due to missing proof of two years of operation, though they had submitted documentation. Maridie Mazaira (Society of Hispanic Professional Engineers) reported their application scored 85 but was rejected because a notarized signature form was embedded in a 62-page Word document, causing confusion; they requested that such forms be separate attachments. Other speakers (including Detroit African Youth Development Organization, 826 Michigan, Southwest Detroit Business Association) cited similar clerical errors, misunderstandings about forms (e.g., Exhibit N for lower-tier participants), or system upload issues. Many appealed for reconsideration based on high scores and past performance. - General Public Comment: Kayla Randall (Johnny Saheling/J2H) introduced her organization as a trauma-informed mental health provider and asked to be considered in future rounds. Discussion Items - NOF Process Overview: Chris Gulach (LPD/CPC staff) presented the CDBG/NOF framework. CDBG is a federal formula grant; Detroit’s allocation has declined from $59 million in the 1990s to $32 million currently. NOF, a subset, focuses on public service (limited to 15% of CDBG by HUD). This year, 67 applications were received (up from 54 last year), 42 are recommended for funding, and 25 are not (16 missed threshold criteria, 9 scored below 80). Threshold criteria include 13 items such as meeting a HUD national objective, having 501(c)(3) status, two years of operation, a board of at least five members, and current documentation. - Scoring and Funding Allocation: Tamara Hardy-Fountain (HRD) explained that funding is distributed based on application scores (80-100 points) and a council priority survey. New organizations often receive lower amounts ($50,000-$75,000) to ensure capacity. She noted that the total NOF public service pool is approximately $2.3 million, already fully allocated to recommended groups. - System Challenges and Appeals: Multiple applicants and council members raised concerns about the new Bonfire procurement system. Speakers reported difficulty locating required notarized forms within a lengthy Word document, despite workshops and office hours provided by HRD and OCP. Sandra Stahl (OCP) stated that the system had 23 separate upload lines and that most documents were clearly identified; the certification form had been in the same place for 10 years. Councilmembers Letitia Johnson and Gabriela Santiago-Romero (absent) requested clearer separation of signature pages and a breakdown of federal vs. city requirements. - Specific Application Concerns: Members questioned several cases: - Disability Network Wayne County (application 55): scored 71, below the 80-point threshold; HRD will provide detailed rationale. - North End Village: denied for failing to provide proof of two years of operation; HRD noted they had been funded previously but must submit current documentation each year. - Detroit African Youth Development Organization: scored 96 but board member list was omitted during formatting; HRD will review if documents were submitted correctly. - 826 Michigan: scored 90 but did not sign Exhibit N due to a mistaken interpretation of Bonfire FAQ response. - The Michael Organization (Miracles to Inspire Change): scored 88, but claimed the certification form was actually uploaded with time-stamped proof; HRD agreed to re-verify. - Conflict of Interest: Director Todd noted that a few council members still need to clarify potential conflicts with the Board of Ethics and Law Department before deliberations on Wednesday. Key Outcomes - Appeals Process: HRD will review all eight formal appeals, verify uploads, and report findings to council by Wednesday morning (February 25). If city errors are found, organizations may be reinstated, but additional funds would require reducing other grants (minimum $50,000 per organization). - Schedule: The committee will continue deliberations on Wednesday, February 25 at 2:00 PM (after Budget, Finance, and Audit), with potential follow-up sessions on Thursday, February 26 at 2:00 PM and Friday, February 27 at 10:00 AM if needed. The final vote is targeted for Tuesday, March 3, 2026. - Next Steps: Council requested a document clarifying which threshold criteria are federal requirements (e.g., HUD regulations) versus city policies. HRD will also provide detailed scoring breakdowns for organizations that appealed. Councilmember Scott Benson indicated he may propose adjusting funding amounts for some new organizations based on their scores.

The Public Health and Safety Standing Committee met on Monday, February 23, 2026, with Councilmember Denzel Anton McCampbell presiding in the absence of Chair Gabriela Santiago Romero. Councilmembers McCampbell and Mary Waters were present, establishing a quorum. The committee approved the minutes from the previous meeting, heard public comments, and addressed unfinished and new business items. Key topics included building safety rescissions, emergency contracts, HIV services funding, public lighting decommissioning, and various memoranda. All votes were unanimous. Consent Calendar - 5.1 (removed): Line item removed from the agenda. - 5.4: Memorandum on contaminated dirt from Iron Horse – received and filed. - 5.6: Memorandum on DPD interaction with ICE – received and filed. - 5.7: Memorandum on inspections of shelters – received and filed. - 5.9: Memorandum on notary publics and low-income services – received and filed. - 6.10: Contract with Metal Treatment Technologies for DPD fire maintenance ($150,000) – approved and sent to formal. - 6.12: Amendment to Grand Circus Park road contract (no cost increase, time extension to June 30, 2026) – approved. - 6.13: Contract with Midwest Bus for bus repair services ($6 million over five years) – approved. - 6.15: Dangerous building demolition orders from January 30 hearing – concurred. - 6.16: Fiscal year 2026 Dearborn Auto Theft Unit Grant ($56,691) – approved. - 6.17-6.19: HIDTA crime gun intelligence center grant ($50,000), drug overdose grant ($40,000), and similar grant ($19,008) – approved. - 6.22: Resolution for vacation of Auburn Avenue south of Glendale (utility easement) – approved. - 6.26: Resolution supporting Women in Construction Week 2026 – approved. Public Comments & Testimony - Brother Cunningham (313-444-9114): Requested city officials take urgent action on DDOT bus equipment shortages and driver issues; also noted SMART board meeting and flyers. He provides bus tickets and care packages. - Ruben Crowley Jr. (appearing as Mr. Rue for Kenesha Coleman’s daughter): Alleged mishandling of a DPD case (DPD case 20-1112), disputed the account of a shooting, and claimed election irregularities. Urged council to investigate. - Ronald Foster: Quoted Malcolm X on second-class citizenship; urged council to avoid colorblind policies and ensure representation. Expressed concerns about inequity in city services. - Carolyn Hughes: Highlighted inequality in recreational centers between districts (District 7 receives none, District 6 gets two). Called for investigation of “dirty dirt” using subpoena power. Criticized inaction on environmental hazards and senior issues. - Cecily McClellan (We the People of Detroit): Opposed proposed water rate increase (6% from GLIWA on Feb 25). Stated over 60,000 residents eligible for water affordability, but GLIWA contributes only $4M of needed $25M. Called for increased contributions and resident advocacy. - Betty A. Varner (President, Soda Elsewhere Black Association): Requested clarification on DWSD Lifeline H2O program presentation date (later scheduled for March 4). Asked council to allocate budget for 501(c)(3) land use hearing fees and support for beautification projects. - Tahira Ahmad: Opposed water rate increases, supported dirty dirt investigation, and called for reparations based on reparations task force recommendations noting 85% of low-value homes systematically over-assessed. - Resident (caller): Urged investigation of contaminated dirt and questioned contracts 6.1 and 6.2 ($68,000 and $200,000) for environmental testing and emergency make-safe. Criticized city demolition practices and alleged prioritization of developers. - iPhone caller: Discussed race and labor history; advocated for community involvement in planning and end to divisive policies. Discussion Items - 5.2 (12731 Lynn Wood property rescission): Assistant Chief Dili Patel reported that the building has no roof on half the structure. Owner has not responded despite email contact in December. Committee voted to concur with department recommendation for rescission. - 6.1 (Emergency make-safe after fire): Gert Malil (Planning & Strategy Specialist) explained the emergency request from the fire department for 1944 McCormick. The contract with Domo Demolition ($68,977.11) was not competitively bid due to urgency. Approved. - 6.2 (Environmental training services): The $200,000 contract with Environmental Testing & Consultants over three years will provide EGLE and OSHA training for current demolition staff. Approved. - 6.3-6.9 (HIV services contracts): Leah Smith (Detroit Health Department) presented sub-recipient agreements for Ryan White Part A and Ending the HIV Epidemic programs. Ryan White served 3,676 clients in FY24 (88.5% viral suppression); EHE served 1,329 (86.2% viral suppression). Services include prevention, case management, housing support. Contracts include Matrix Human Services ($1,792,722) and others. All approved. - 6.11 (PLD cable repair contract increase): Dan Vich Levich (Public Lighting Department) stated the department has no employees capable of the work. The increase allows harvesting of scrap copper for sale; revenues ($2.3M so far this FY) exceed expenses. Committee approved the $1.5M increase (to $4.5M total). - 6.14 (DWSD hydrant trucks): Procurement for 10 utility trucks from Bob Maxey Ford ($2,049,920) replacing inoperable vehicles. Bids were advertised 21 days; Bob Maxey was lowest responsible bidder, Detroit-based with CRO certification. Approved. - 6.20, 6.21: Memoranda on property management agreements and notary publics – received and filed. - 5.3, 5.5, 5.8, 6.23-6.25, 6.27: Memoranda on various topics (commercial building liens, public restrooms, quit claim deeds, ordinance updates, city cameras, flooding response, blight violations) were deferred to be brought back in two weeks. Key Outcomes - All items voted on were approved or concurred unanimously. - Several memoranda were scheduled for return in two weeks (5.3, 5.5, 5.8, 6.23-6.25, 6.27). - Councilmember Mary Waters announced upcoming deed fraud town hall meetings: Feb 24 in District 4 (Samaritan Center), Feb 27 in District 7 (Central Baptist Church), Feb 28 in District 3 (Considine Recreation Center). The February skill trades event was well attended; next is March 18. - Councilmember McCampbell promoted the deed fraud event in District 7 on Feb 27 and a coffee hour on Feb 28. He also noted the launch of the Office of Neighborhood and Community Safety by the mayor. - The committee adjourned.

The Detroit City Council Committee of the Whole convened on Thursday, February 19, 2026, at approximately 10:00 a.m. with Chair Letitia Johnson presiding, Vice Chair Gabriel Santiago Romero, and Pro Tem Tim Young (who arrived shortly after the start). The meeting included roll call with quorum, approval of previous minutes, general public comment, unfinished business, a public hearing on a proposed tax abatement, new business items, and member reports. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes of the meeting (motion without objection). - Received and filed Line Item 6.2 (memorandum on property management agreements). - Received and filed Line Item 6.3 (memorandum on tax abatements in District Six, noting response in 7.3). - Received and filed Line Item 7.1 (Historic Designation Advisory Board resolution for Black History Month social media posts). - Received and filed Line Item 7.3 (report on District Six tax abatements 2022–2025). Public Comments & Testimony General public comment was held from approximately 10:00 to 10:05 a.m. Eleven virtual and one in-person speaker participated. - Mr. Foster (in person): Provided historical context on the Fair Housing Act (1968) and argued that systemic discrimination persists in Detroit's housing funding; urged the city to ensure equitable distribution of housing funds. - William M. Davis: Expressed support for lowering the community benefits threshold, shifting development emphasis from downtown to neighborhoods, and requiring Little Caesars Arena to make direct payments to the city. He noted vacant apartment buildings as potential housing for seniors. - Owner Papa: Supported Mr. Davis's remarks; called for tax abatement memoranda to be broken out for all districts, criticized what he saw as an over-focus on District 6, and asserted that council should prioritize existing residents over attracting new ones. - Betty A. Varner (President, Soda Els World Black Association): Requested clarification on the Lifeline H2O water assistance program, stating she was approved for $34/month but received a past-due bill; asked the water department to explain how the program works. - A caller (who stated 'please stop land bank nuisance abatement program'): Opposed the Detroit Land Bank Authority's nuisance abatement program, warning of a federal lawsuit; urged a halt to property seizures, especially during Black History Month; also criticized the solar takings program and asked for fairer compensation. - Caller named iPhone: Expressed concerns about inadequate equipment at recreation centers, specifically the swimming pool and exercise equipment at Patton and Coleman rec centers; urged better involvement of staff and attention to quality. - Steven Rimmer: Thanked council for discussing Lena House; reported on a court hearing (Feb 3) where the property owner's attorney stated that $75,000 is needed to repair the electrical system; argued that since the owner has $77,000 and the building is not in critical disrepair, residents should be allowed to return once power is restored. He noted that only one transformer was working before the outage. - Caller ending in 992 (and 482): Accused Councilmember Santiago Romero of lying about voter fraud allegations and claimed the city government is corrupt. (Allegations not substantiated.) - Caller user one: Requested the introduction of vocational training programs in Detroit (from electrical to eyelash technician) and asked for responses from council members' offices; also raised concerns about building safety and retaliation. - Caller Cunningham: Made a brief religious comment. (Note: The collection of general public comment was cut off at 10:05 a.m.) Unfinished Business - Line Item 6.1 – Hands Farms LLC purchase agreement memorandum: The Detroit Land Bank Authority requested a one-week bring back; motion approved without objection. Public Hearing: Plant Rehabilitation Tax Certificate (PA198) for 1530 Winder (Line Item 5) A public hearing under Act 198 of 1974 was held to consider an industrial facilities exemption certificate for BD Venture Studio LLC. - Presentation: DEGC's Alton Williams presented the proposal. The project entails the rehabilitation of a vacant 14,826 sq ft spice warehouse built in 1960, adding a mezzanine to create 18,800 sq ft of space. The facility will serve as an incubator for food production and retail startups, with small production bays, a commissary kitchen, shared storage, and co-working space. Total capital investment: $4.7 million. Estimated economic benefits: 20 temporary construction jobs and 5 permanent full-time jobs (with an expected 25+ tenant jobs). Tax impact: current annual taxes $6,685; after rehab without abatement, estimated $40,784; with 12-year abatement, taxes would be approximately $6,905/year. The net benefit to the city over 12 years is $127,970. - Developer Jonathan Updike (Brand Detroit, Greatwater Opportunity Capital) noted the project aligns with Eastern Market's vision, citing support letters from neighboring businesses (EW Grobbel, Eastern Market Development Corp., Detroit City Distillery, Strauss Brothers). He emphasized his track record of delivering past projects (Marrow restaurant/meat Processing, East Village single-family homes) and stated that the facility would help Detroit-based food companies scale. He committed to ADA accessibility (two ADA-compliant restrooms, ramps, improved sidewalks, automated entrance door to be considered). - Council Questions and Discussion: - Chair Johnson sought clarification on rental rates (target $15–20/sq ft), parking (MKT zoning waives parking requirements; street parking and rear loading zone available), and ADA details (confirmed two restrooms, automated door requested). She requested a written breakdown of square footage and rental rates per unit. - Pro Tem Young identified a discrepancy in the property tax impact slide (older vs. updated numbers) and asked for an analysis of the project's effect on food insecurity and income inequality. DEGC said they do not have that analysis but would follow up. Young expressed general support for the project. - Vice Chair Santiago Romero asked about the current condition of the building (structurally sound with a steel superstructure; needs roof, alley, and brickwork repairs) and tenant mix (early tenants include Bonbon Bon chocolate moving from Hamtramck). She raised the possibility of including affordable spaces for earlier-stage makers; the developer explained the facility is designed as a springboard for companies ready to grow beyond kitchen incubators. She committed to ensuring accessible, affordable spaces across the maker spectrum. - Public Comments on the Hearing (5 callers): - Owner Papa: Questioned the 12-year abatement length and asked if the project could proceed with fewer years; argued that tax breaks shift burden to residents. - Caller named iPhone: Suggested incorporating a community kitchen model like Jamaica Plain, Boston, to support very small local businesses. - William M. Davis: Supported the incubator concept and urged that Detroit small businesses receive preferential treatment. - Caller ending in 534: Agreed with previous speakers and requested written commitments to ensure local startups benefit. - Marguerite Maddox Scarlet: Asked for details on ADA requirements, including automated doors and door widths. - Developer Responses: Updike stated the project is cash-flow positive from year one but not highly profitable; the longer abatement allows lower rents for tenants. All targeted tenants are Detroit-based. He cited prior project deliveries as evidence of commitments. Regarding ADA, he confirmed compliance and said automated doors will be included based on feasibility. - Outcome: A motion to send Line Item 5 to the formal city council session with a recommendation to approve was passed without objection. Discussion Items - Line Item 7.2 – Secondary Street Sign Process: Janice Tillman (Historic Designation Advisory Board) presented the growing challenge of applications (18 rollovers this year) against a charter limit of five honorees per year. Proposed reforms included reducing rollover years, requiring petition signatures, limiting applications to council sponsors, or using a theme-based selection. Chair Johnson emphasized ensuring representation from neighborhoods citywide and suggested rollovers should require active renewal. Pro Tem Young noted that council sponsorship could reduce numbers. The committee agreed to schedule a future ordinance amendment discussion. The report was received and filed. - Line Item 7.4 – Downzoning of 10631 Whittier (Cover Girls Strip Club): Councilmember Johnson submitted a memorandum requesting the City Planning Commission (CPC) explore downzoning options for the property. Referred to CPC; to be brought back in three weeks. Approved. - Line Item 7.5 – Community Outreach Ordinance Report: Councilmember Johnson requested a report on the community outreach ordinance. Referred to the Legislative Policy Division (LPD); to be brought back in two weeks. Approved. Member Reports - Vice Chair Santiago Romero invited District 6 residents to: a deed fraud conversation with Councilmember Waters (Feb 19, 4–6 p.m. at Community Rec Center), a monthly meeting (Feb 22, 11–1 p.m.) with lunch and topics on foreclosure prevention and know-your-rights, and an annual skate night (Feb 25). - Pro Tem Young announced: a discussion with the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department (DWSD) on the Lifeline program is being scheduled (responding to Betty Varner's query); the deadline for property assessment appeals through the Assessor Review is Feb 22 (4:30 p.m.), and to file with the Board of Review by March 9; and a deed fraud event in District 4 on Feb 24 (4–6 p.m.) at Samaritan Center. Contact numbers were provided. Key Outcomes - Approved: Minutes; referrals/back: 6.1 (1-week bring-back), 6.2 (file), 6.3 (file), 7.1 (file), 7.3 (file), 7.4 (refer to CPC, 3-week return), 7.5 (refer to LPD, 2-week return); and Line Item 5 (recommended approval to full council for tax abatement). - Action requested: Line Item 7.2 to be discussed at a future committee meeting for ordinance amendment; DEGC to explore analysis on food insecurity and income inequality for future projects; developer to provide written breakdown of rental rates and unit sizes; HDAB to circulate to council members for input on secondary street sign policies. - Information shared: Lifeline water assistance discussion to be scheduled; property assessment appeal deadlines; community deed fraud events.

This Committee of the Whole meeting, convened by Council President James Tate, focused on two potential revenue sources for Detroit: a local option admissions tax on sports and entertainment events, and a local option sales tax. The session featured presentations from the Citizens Research Council of Michigan (CRC), the Equitable Development Task Force (EDTF), and city administration officials, followed by public comment. No formal votes were taken; the meeting served as a discussion and information-gathering session. Public Comments & Testimony - William M. Davis (online caller): Expressed support for starting with an admissions (excise) tax on tickets, arguing it would be easier to implement and would not adversely affect most Detroit residents, as many attendees of downtown events are suburbanites. He suggested a sales tax could be considered later. - Speaker (name not given, online caller): Opposed the sales tax, calling it a "hoax" and criticizing the utility users tax for being used to pay bonds for the Public Lighting Authority in violation of the city charter. He argued that the city should stop providing tax abatements that reduce general fund revenue. - Mia Paul (online caller): Opposed new taxes, stating that residents have not been adequately served by the city. She noted that District 3, which she represents, has been underserved and that her council seat was empty during the meeting. She advocated for participatory budgeting instead of new taxes. Discussion Items - Citizens Research Council (CRC) Presentation: Eric Lufer and Madou Anderson presented two reports requested by City Council. They explained that Detroit relies heavily on income taxes, with minimal consumption taxes, and that a local option sales tax or admissions tax could help diversify revenue. For a 1% local sales tax, they estimated $72 million annually, but noted significant legal hurdles: a constitutional amendment and statewide vote would be required. For an admissions tax (excise tax on tickets), they estimated $14–$47 million (up to $50 million at 10%), depending on the rate. This tax would require state legislation and a citywide vote, but not a constitutional amendment. They noted that most peer cities already levy such taxes. The presentation included evaluations of equity, neutrality, and administrative efficiency, concluding that the admissions tax is a more feasible near-term option. - Equitable Development Task Force (EDTF) Presentation: Toy New Reeves, a PhD candidate in economics and EDTF taxation committee member, advocated for a local option sales tax (LOST), coining the phrase "Get LOST" as a policy goal. He argued that LOST would allow Detroit to stabilize local revenues in response to economic shocks, citing examples from states like Georgia and Florida. He noted that over 80% of states with sales taxes allow local options, and that LOST can shift the tax burden to visitors and tourists. He emphasized that Michigan's current tax system is outdated and that Detroit missed collecting millions during the 2023 NFL draft. He supported the CRC's work and called for a statewide conversation on LOST. - Administration Remarks: CFO Tanya Stodemyer and Director of State Governmental Affairs Fred Durhal voiced support for exploring revenue diversification, noting Mayor Sheffield's commitment to property tax reform and equitable relief. Durhal emphasized the need for a unified voice from Detroit in Lansing, and acknowledged that the process would be challenging but worthwhile. He stated that the administration is analyzing various options, including the governor's executive budget proposal, which keeps revenue sharing flat. Stodemyer noted that the cost of pursuing the process has not yet been quantified. - Councilmember Questions and Comments: Multiple councilmembers engaged with the presenters. Councilmember Letitia Johnson asked about the methodology behind the $72 million sales tax estimate and the legal distinction between excise and sales taxes. Councilmember Renata Miller questioned the feasibility of a statewide vote for a Detroit-specific sales tax, noting that only 24 of 273 Michigan cities have a local income tax. Councilmember Gabriela Santiago Romero expressed support for new revenue tools, linking the conversation to broader state preemptions limiting Detroit's self-governance. Councilmember Angelo Bitfield Callaway asked about the process for a legislative excise tax versus a constitutional amendment, referencing the recent cannabis excise tax. Councilmember Pro Tem Mary Waters (likely refers to Pro Tem Young) asked about the need for a constitutional amendment for a local sales tax and the impact on the streamlined sales tax agreement. He also raised concerns about regressivity and the timing of such a tax, suggesting the city should wait for a more diverse tax base. Councilmember Denzel McCampbell clarified the steps needed for each tax and asked about the possibility of progressive taxes like a CEO pay gap tax, noting that most new taxes require state legislative approval. Key Outcomes - No votes or formal decisions were made during the meeting. The session was informational and exploratory. - Council and administration expressed alignment on the need to diversify revenue sources and explore both the admissions tax and local option sales tax. - Next steps include continued analysis by the city, potential further studies by CRC (e.g., income inequality impact), and coordinated advocacy in Lansing. Councilmember Santiago Romero offered to participate in state-level discussions. - The meeting adjourned at approximately 4:45 PM to allow for the subsequent City Planning Commission meeting.

The Neighborhood Community Service Standing Committee of the Detroit City Council met on February 19, 2026, with Council President Pro Tempore Coleman A. Young II presiding. The meeting opened with a roll call, approval of minutes, and a tribute to the late Reverend Jesse Jackson, with President Pro Tem Young reading Jackson's "I Am Somebody" speech. The committee then heard public comments, discussed several street activity petitions and contracts, and received member reports. Councilmember Scott Benson was excused due to travel. Consent Calendar - Approval of the minutes from the previous meeting was moved and passed without objection. Public Comments & Testimony Five members of the public addressed the committee: - William M. Davis expressed support for Reverend Jackson and urged the city to redirect spending towards local businesses and Detroiters. He criticized the outflow of dollars to outside entities and called for more support for Black-owned businesses and for the city to charge fees to venues like Little Caesars Arena. - Betty A. Varner (President, Soda Elsworth Black Association) thanked council for addressing water department issues. She requested that the city budget allocate funds for Black clubs and associations to undertake neighborhood projects, and that the $1,500 land use hearing fee be waived for such organizations. She also looked forward to a presentation on the H2O lifeline program. - Cunningham provided contact information, encouraged attendance at a DDOT meeting, and offered prayers and chocolates for staff. - Owen Papa criticized the city for awarding tree-trimming contracts to companies located in Troy and Attica, Michigan, arguing that dollars should stay in Detroit. He expressed frustration with the focus on business over neighborhood needs, highlighted high unemployment, and raised concerns about AI displacing jobs. Discussion Items Petitions and Events - Line 6.1: Backwoods and Bonfires – A petition to hold the event at Eastern Market Detroit on July 11, 2026, with setup on July 9–10 and teardown through July 12. Moved to formal session for approval. - Line 6.2: A second petition for an event taking place March 26–28, 2026, moved to formal session without substantive discussion. Contracts and Procurement Several tree-trimming and removal contracts funded by Major Street Funding were presented. All were three-year contracts (despite some documents showing two years, corrected during the meeting). - Line 6.3: Grays Outdoor Services (Garden City, MI) – $3,000,000 for tree trimming and removal. Deputy Director Jarrell Harris (General Services) explained that the city’s in-house forestry crew of about 20 staff manages trees at parks and recreation centers but cannot handle all 350,000 public trees; outsourcing is necessary. Councilmember Miller questioned why the city does not expand its forestry department, citing high unemployment (8‑9%) and the need for good‑paying city jobs. Harris noted that the department struggles to retain staff due to low wages (starting $15.89/hour). The contract was moved to formal session with recommendation for approval, amended to reflect the correct three-year term. - Line 6.4: Kirk's Automotive (Detroit, MI) – $135,000 for small engine repair. Moved to formal session. - Line 6.5: Robles Tree Services (Detroit, MI) – $3,000,000 for tree trimming. Moved to formal session. - Line 6.6: PPM Tree Service and Arbor Care LLC (Westland, MI) – $2,000,000. Moved to formal session. - Line 6.7: Owen Tree Service Inc. (Attica, MI) – $2,000,000. Moved to formal session. - Line 6.8: Rainbow Lawn and Tree Service LLC (Detroit, MI) – $3,000,000. Moved to formal session. - Line 6.9: Tree Service to Troy LLC (Troy, MI) – $3,000,000. Moved to formal session. - Line 6.10: $750,000 for tree trimming? (contractor unknown from transcript). Moved to formal session. - Line 6.11: $750,000 for light duty, general repair and body work (Troy, MI). Moved to formal session. Residential Parking Concerns - Line 6.12 – Councilmember Santiago‑Romero requested a response from the Legislative Policy Division on residential parking alternatives. The report was received; the item was received and filed without objection. Key Outcomes - All contract items (6.1 through 6.11) were moved to the formal session of the full City Council with a recommendation for approval. (Line 6.3 was noted as amended regarding contract duration.) - Line 6.12 was received and filed. - The committee noted that a broader presentation on the tree canopy and forestry operations will be delivered in March, requested by Councilmember Benson. - Councilmember Miller announced upcoming events: a coffee hour (Feb 21, District 5), a foreclosure prevention workshop (Feb 22), and a District 5 community meeting (Feb 24). She also reminded residents of the February 22 deadline for the Homeowners Property Exemption (HOPE) program and assessment appeals. - President Pro Tem Young reported on a ribbon‑cutting for a DEGC Green Grocer Grant recipient and reminded residents of the HOPE program deadline. - The meeting adjourned.

The Budget, Finance and Audit Standing Committee met on February 18, 2026, to consider several items including property tax reform, neighborhood enterprise zone certificates, a quarterly special events cost report, and presentations on the city's long-term financial obligations. Public comment was heard on water affordability, transit, and tax issues. Consent Calendar - Approval of meeting minutes: Motion passed without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - Betty A. Varner (resident, Soda Els World Block Association) expressed confusion about the Lifeline H2O program's billing structure, noting her bill showed a past-due amount despite paying the required $34. She stated the program's rules were never explained in writing and requested a presentation from the water department. The Chair committed to scheduling such a presentation. - Miss Warwick asked the committee to investigate the BZA court reporting contract, specifically concerns about the BZA wanting to see transcripts before release. She also criticized the city's handling of the Gordy Hill bridge area eminent domain versus solar area displacements, arguing that homeowners in solar areas received unfair treatment. - William Davis requested an audit of the city's drainage fee, alleging that some churches and businesses receive disproportionate credits and that the fee has contributed to business closures and retiree deaths. - Renard Monchowski (District 6 resident, Detroit People's Platform) discussed a potential countywide transit millage and urged the committee to ensure the city does not cut its general fund subsidy to DDOT if the millage passes. He noted DDOT lacks stable funding and has reduced service. - Jadante Smith spoke about transit delays and upcoming efforts to address Chronos concrete and down-zoning. He criticized District Manager Keith Butler. - Phone number ending in 039 made unsubstantiated allegations about election fraud and a homicide cover-up. Discussion Items - 6.1 – Petition on Property Tax Fees and Interest (Wayne Ramagan Sr.): Mr. Ramagan, a volunteer with the Caribbean Community Service Center, called for reform of property tax interest and fees, describing the current system as predatory. He cited a personal example where a $57.91 tax bill grew to $329.72 due to fees and interest. The committee discussed options and Vice Chair Johnson moved to request the Legislative Policy Division (LPD) evaluate what it would take to amend the fees and interest charged for delinquent taxes. The motion passed without objection. - 6.2 – NEZ Certificate for 250 Elliott Street (Crosswinds NEZ): The applicant proposed rehabilitating a building into six rental units. After discussion about rental rates, Vice Chair Johnson noted the developer agreed to reduce rates from a previously mentioned higher amount. A motion to send to formal session with recommendation to approve passed without objection. - 7.1 – ARPA Neighborhood Beautification Initiative Audit: The Office of the Auditor General requested the item be brought back in three weeks. Motion to postpone passed without objection. - 7.2 – Quarterly Report on Large Special Event Charges (Q3 2025): Chief Deputy CFO John Naglik and DPD CFO Nevar Nazarko presented the report, showing $893,303 billed in the quarter ($874,000 from DPD, $18,840 from DFD). Members asked about the impact on neighborhood patrols and whether private EMS is used. The committee received and filed the report. - 7.3 – NEZ Certificate for 8133 Kirchalville (West Village NEZ): The petitioners plan to convert a former duplex back to a single-family home with $169,000 in rehab. Member Waters asked about eliminating a rental unit; the petitioner explained the duplex was not viable. The committee sent the item to formal with recommendation to approve. - 7.4 – NEZ Certificate for 9727 Dundee (Nardon Park NEZ): Developer Dolores McKinney (Eminence Group) plans a $54,000 rehab of a vacant house for rental at $1,400/month (80% AMI). She confirmed accepting housing choice vouchers. The committee sent the item to formal with recommendation to approve. - 7.5 – Resolution on City's Long-Term Financial Obligations: LPD director Mr. Corley presented an overview of the city's $1.5 billion in outstanding bonds, $1.6 billion pension liability, and remaining unsecured bankruptcy claims. He explained debt policies and metrics. The committee received and filed the report after discussion about aging infrastructure and potential bond authorizations. - 7.6 – Report on Mr. Ramagan's Request to Speak: Received and filed. Key Outcomes - Motion to request LPD evaluate amending delinquent tax fees and interest passed (6.1). - NEZ certificates for 250 Elliott St. (6.2), 8133 Kirchalville (7.3), and 9727 Dundee (7.4) all sent to formal session with recommendation to approve. - ARPA audit report (7.1) postponed for three weeks. - Quarterly special events report (7.2) received and filed. - Report on city's long-term financial obligations (7.5) received and filed. - Report on Mr. Ramagan's request (7.6) received and filed. - Committee committed to scheduling a water department presentation on affordability programs and to follow up on questions about transit and police deployment impacts.