Public Meetings - Detroit, Michigan

The Detroit City Council convened on July 29, 2025, for a regular session that included public comment on a range of community issues, a lengthy discussion and vote on an amended curfew and parental responsibility ordinance, and approval of numerous resolutions and appointments. The meeting began at approximately 9:00 AM and concluded in the early afternoon. Consent Calendar - Approved journal of July 15, 2025. - Approved multiple contracts, grants, and resolutions under internal operations, procurement, law, housing, and other departments without objection, including: - Appointments to the Board of Police Commissioners (Robert Jones) and Board of Ethics (Raymond Carr after a tie-breaking vote). - Supplemental checks for city retirees ($467 for general, $654 for police/fire). - Several contract amendments and new awards, including legal services, fiber cable installation, and roof replacements. - Water system improvement contracts totaling $33 million (LGC Global) for DWSD, approved after discussion. Public Comments & Testimony Numerous residents spoke during the public comment period, both in person and virtually. Key positions included: - Bus service concerns: Jacob Smith (Detroit Alliance Against Racist and Political Repression) urged support for police body cam release ordinance. Multiple speakers criticized DDOT bus reliability and driver professionalism. - Police body cameras: Connor Roth and others demanded immediate release of body cam footage after incidents, opposing any watered-down ordinance. - Traveler's Inn (11560 Harper): Residents from Ravendale expressed urgency to shut down the motel due to rampant prostitution, drug activity, and violence. Several speakers described deteriorating neighborhood conditions, including Crystal Hinkle (former resident) who reported lack of help. - Curfew ordinance: Public speakers were divided. Supporters (Lieutenant Mark Young, Chief Davenport) argued the curfew with increased fines and decriminalization would save lives and provide services. Opponents (Miko Williams, Malik Shelton, Cece) warned fines would harm poor families and that the ordinance does not address root causes like poverty and lack of youth programs. - Other issues: Concerns about homelessness, police accountability, property tax foreclosures, and election integrity were raised. Discussion Items - Traveler's Inn Update: Chief Bettison and BC provided an update. Since June 2024, Vice Enforcement conducted 11 operations; 488 calls for service, 21 violent crimes, 13 death investigations, 4 overdoses. Efforts to shut down the motel legally continue, with $500 in tickets issued for violations. Councilmember Johnson will follow up with health department. - Curfew/Parental Responsibility Ordinance (Line Item 18.1): Councilmember Young moved to pass an amended ordinance decriminalizing violations (removing jail time) and increasing fines (from $250 to $500 for first offense, higher for repeat) while offering court-ordered wrap-around services instead of payment. Lengthy discussion involved Chief Bettison, Commissioner Woods, law department, and council members. Supporters emphasized decriminalization, services (parenting classes, counseling, anger management), and the need for accountability. Opponents (Councilmember Waters) expressed concern that fines hurt low-income families and do not address underlying issues. The ordinance was finally approved 7-1 (Councilmember Santiago Romero voted no). - Board of Ethics Appointment: After multiple votes, Raymond Carr was appointed with 5-3 over Josh Mack. - Other Agenda Items: Approved zoning changes, brownfield redevelopment agreements, housing repair contracts, and various grants. Key Outcomes - Curfew Ordinance Passed: The amended ordinance (decriminalizing parental responsibility violations and increasing fines) passed with a 7-1 roll call vote. Councilmember Santiago Romero opposed. The ordinance includes a provision allowing parents to opt for court-ordered services instead of paying fines. - Traveler's Inn: Referred to Public Health and Safety committee for a written response. DPD and BC continue legal steps to close the motel. - Board of Ethics: Raymond Carr appointed to a term ending June 30, 2030. - Retiree Supplemental Checks: Approved $467 for general retirees and $654 for police/fire retirees. - DWSD Contracts: Approved $33 million in water system improvement contracts, despite complaints about short notice. - Other Approvals: Numerous consent agenda items, appointments, and contracts approved without objection.

The Detroit City Council convened on July 28, 2025, with a quorum present. The meeting covered unfinished business items, approval of multiple contracts and grants, discussion of major water main replacement projects, and several items postponed to after the August recess. The session closed with member reports and a poem. Consent Calendar - 8.1: Contract for environmental consulting services ($400,000) with Atlas Technical Consultants – approved and sent to formal session. - 8.2: Contract for removal, transport, and disposal of fill material ($66,000) with Inner City Contracting – approved. - 8.5: Amendment to fire incidence alerting system contract – time extension only, no cost increase – approved. - 8.6–8.8: Transportation contracts (bus fare cards, bus stop signs, power washer maintenance) – approved and sent to formal session. - 8.9: Emergency EMS billing services contract ($1,118,864) with Digitech – approved after discussion with Deputy Commissioner Derek Hillman and Chief Procurement Officer Sandra Stahl. - 8.10–8.15: Deferral recommendations for various properties – received and filed. - 8.16–8.21: Grant applications and acceptances (Hamtramck Drive improvements, public health emergency preparedness, fire prevention, bus replacement, brownfield redevelopment, birthing futures) – approved and sent to formal session after discussion with Richard Doherty. - 8.22: Authorization to grant DTE an easement for EV charging stations at 19384 Livernois – approved after explanation by Tony Guerra and Keith Hutchins (two charging stations with four heads). - 8.23: Resolution to accept donated vehicles for crime reduction – approved. - 8.24: Intergovernmental agreements with Wayne County for Hamtramck Drive improvements – approved. - 8.25–8.28: Various easement and encroachment requests – approved. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comment period was observed in the transcript. Discussion Items - 7.1 (Health department wellness checks for senior citizens): Brought back to September 8, 2025; no objection. - 7.2 (Citizens radio patrol ordinance): Requires meeting between Councilmember Callaway’s team, Law, Blight, and DPD; brought back TBD after recess. - 7.3 & 7.4 (Blight violations and DPD video release): Awaiting legal review; brought back to September 8, 2025. - 7.5–7.7 (Emergency demolition contracts): 7.5 ($15,000, Detroit Next) – tax clearance denied; brought back to September 8. 7.6 ($41,650, Inner City Contracting at 3935/3941 Fairview) – property removed from pipeline; correction letter required, brought back to September 8. 7.7 ($19,268, Celebean at 5198 S Clarendon) – DTE disconnect not cleared; brought back to September 8. Councilmember noted 3941 Fairview was pulled from the pipeline and requested a correction letter. - 8.3 & 8.4 (Water main replacement contracts): Two contracts with LGC Global ($13,892,423 for WS-741 and $19,477,752 for WS-742) – funded by Drinking Water State Revolving Fund with partial principal forgiveness. Deputy Director Sam Smalley and Procurement Analyst Michelle McKenzie described 22,580 linear feet of water main replacement in District 1 (8.3) and 32,300 linear feet in Districts 2 & 3 (8.4). Councilmembers raised concerns about lack of socialization with colleagues and potential disruption to residents. The administration acknowledged the need for outreach. Motion to send to formal session without recommendation – approved. - 8.16 (Hamtramck Drive improvements): Discussion with Richard Doherty confirmed reconstruction from East Grand Boulevard to St. Aubin (0.57 miles), including off-road bike path using congressional allocation; part of larger project around Factory Zero. - 8.22 (DTE easement): Confirmed EV charging stations with two stations/four heads; if access issues, could reduce to one station/two heads. - 8.29 (Memo relative to AVIRAS Specialty Services Corp): Brought back to September 8; resolution provided but council needed time to review. - 8.30 & 8.31 (Funding for accessibility program and vending zone changes): Received and filed. - 8.32 (Request to extend summer recreation center hours): Brought back to September 8. Key Outcomes - Unfinished Business: All items (7.1–7.4) postponed to dates after recess (Sept 8 or TBD). - Demolition Contracts (7.5–7.7): All three brought back to September 8 due to tax clearance issues, property removal from pipeline, or pending DTE disconnect. - Major Water Contracts (8.3 & 8.4): Sent to formal session without recommendation due to lack of prior socialization; administration committed to reaching out to councilmembers before formal session. - Other Contracts (8.1, 8.2, 8.5–8.9, 8.16–8.24, 8.25–8.28): Approved and sent to formal session with recommendation to approve. - Grants (8.16–8.21): Approved, including $4.2 million for Hamtramck Drive reconstruction. - Councilmember Reports: Councilmember Mary Waters reported attending a press conference for starter businesses funded by the budget. Council Chair read a poem titled "Turning to One Another" by Margaret Whitley to close the session. - Meeting Adjourned: The Council recessed for August and will return on September 8, 2025.

The Detroit City Council's Public Health and Safety Standing Committee met on Monday, July 28, 2025, at 10:30 a.m. EDT. The meeting included general public comments, two public hearings on proposed ordinance amendments (misdemeanor prosecution shift and curfew fines), and committee votes. The committee approved sending the misdemeanor ordinance to formal regular business with a recommendation to approve, and forwarded the curfew ordinance to new business without recommendation due to a lack of consensus. Consent Calendar - Minutes from the previous session were approved without objection. Public Comments & Testimony General Public Comments (12 callers + in-person speaker) - Brother Cunningham (in person) described his weekly distribution of 200 bus tickets and frozen water bottles at transit centers, and encouraged council members to support these efforts. - Galaxy S22 Ultra (caller) complained about ongoing fumes from the Chrysler plant on the east side, stating that residents are not receiving adequate assistance or grants. - William M. Davis called for better coordination between the city health department and recreation department, and criticized health department employees parking in paid spaces, making it difficult for seniors and families to access services. - Sonia Brown expressed frustration that the city has not compensated her for property damage caused by broken water mains, despite submitting over 200 photos of damage. - Not That Karen noted that Social Security recipients have lost 20% of purchasing power since 2010, and called for immediate financial relief for seniors in Detroit. - Stephen Haring (personal opinion) compared Detroit unfavorably to Miami on public transit and development, but praised Mayor Mike Duggan. - Jacqueline Miller (former Beniteau resident) spoke about the impact of industrial development on elderly residents, and urged the council to coordinate with state and federal levels. - Betty A. Barner (president, Soda Ellsworth/Black Association) invited the community to a family event with school supplies, and asked for landscaping boulders. - Ronald Foster requested that Officer D. Kennedy (ID 2957) be summoned to explain tactics used during a traffic stop, and called for a legal opinion on the definition of police "operating" a vehicle. - Miko A. Williams opposed the curfew ordinance, criticized the police force's racial composition (55% white, according to the caller), and accused the administration of corruption. - Broderick's iPhone (caller) expressed support for the youth curfew and fines for parents. - Stephen Grady and Alvin Stokes indicated they wanted to speak during the curfew public hearing. Public Hearing on Misdemeanor Ordinance (7 callers + in-person speakers) - William M. Davis questioned the lowball cost estimate of $750,000 and raised concerns about potential lawsuits and police accountability. - Galaxy S22 Ultra (caller) discussed pit bulls running loose, arguing that this is a misdemeanor issue not being addressed. - Stephen Haring expressed general support for any measure that reduces crime in Detroit. - Not That Karen argued that the city is already overwhelmed with existing misdemeanor cases and should not take on more without proven capacity. - Miko A. Williams opposed the ordinance, alleging it targets Black residents and is a waste of money, and criticized CVI organizations for supporting the ordinance. - Phone ending in 434 (caller) urged the council to ensure that the new system prevents future crime and secures a better future for youth. - In-person speakers: Ronald Foster urged that policies reflect the city's 31.5% poverty rate and the need for officer discretion; Reverend Lucius Conway began speaking on curfew but was redirected. Public Hearing on Curfew Ordinance (9 callers + in-person speakers) - William M. Davis argued that the city lacks enforcement of existing curfew and that the new fines are a revenue scheme. - Stephen Grady supported the curfew, recalling his own childhood curfew, and urged unanimous approval. - Miko A. Williams demanded the ordinance be tabled until factual research from the past 40 years is presented, and criticized potential partnerships with police. - Not That Karen expressed broad support but questioned the effectiveness of throwing money at programs without oversight. - Stephen Haring strongly supported the ordinance, citing youth involvement in crime. - Sonia Brown opposed the ordinance, warning that it would criminalize children and punish families unable to pay fines. - iPhone 107 (caller) supported the ordinance, stating that those who oppose it are not the ones burying their children. - Alvin Stokes supported the curfew, arguing that the community has lost its "village" approach to raising children. - In-person speakers: Reverend Lucius Conway argued that no data supports curfew effectiveness; DeAndre and Christopher St. Clair (Live in Peace Movement) supported the curfew, citing parental accountability; Ronald Foster raised concerns about police tactics and fatherless homes; Miss Moore urged holding children accountable rather than parents; Miss Glady criticized the closure of the Carmen Young Recreation Center and questioned existing programs. Discussion Items Misdemeanor Ordinance (Chapter 31 amendments) - The proposed ordinance shifts prosecution of certain misdemeanors (e.g., malicious destruction of property, assault and battery, retail fraud) from the Wayne County Prosecutor's Office to the City of Detroit's Corporation Counsel. The goal is to allow the prosecutor's office to focus on violent crimes. The ordinance includes a restorative justice option. - Key speakers: - Councilmember Scott Benson (Vice Chair) championed the ordinance, noting it was developed over nine months with input from the community violence intervention (CVI) community. - Wayne County Prosecutor Kim Worthy stated that 42 of 43 Wayne County communities already handle these cases locally. She emphasized that this is not about charging more people but about reallocating resources. - Corporation Counsel Conrad Mallet argued that the city needs predictable enforcement for quality-of-life crimes, and that the law department already has the capacity (with ARPA experience) to handle these cases. Estimated cost: $750,000 for four attorneys and two paralegals. - Police Chief Todd Bettison expressed full support, noting that the change will streamline investigations and support small businesses. - Zoe (Force Detroit, CVI) supported the restorative justice language and the potential for funds to be redirected to CVI programs. - Questions and concerns: - Councilmember Mary Waters requested data on repeat offenders and economic status of defendants, and questioned the cost to the city. She suggested that Wayne County might share funding. - Chair Gabriela Santiago-Romero asked about the capacity to expand and the use of fines. She suggested fines could be directed to prevention programs. - Attorney Graham Anderson clarified that the cost estimate is $750,000, and that fines are difficult to predict due to judicial discretion. - The committee discussed the need for data on victims' income levels, but noted that such data is not currently captured. Curfew Ordinance (Chapter 29 amendments) - The proposed ordinance increases parental fines for curfew violations from $75 to $250 for a first offense and $500 for a second offense, and requires probation with parenting programs. Jail time is removed. The goal is to leverage fines to encourage parents to enroll their children in conflict resolution and other programs. - Key speakers: - Councilmember Coleman Young II introduced the ordinance, citing the need to protect children after a recent four-year-old's death. He emphasized that the ordinance is not about punishing parents but about providing wraparound services. - Chief Bettison showed a video of a CVI basketball league for at-risk youth, and argued that higher fines give police leverage to get parents into intervention programs. He noted that 143 juvenile curfew violation notices and 81 parental responsibility tickets have been issued since July 4. - Attorney Graham Anderson clarified that the ordinance targets parents whose actions or inactions contributed to the child's delinquent act, and that the responsible adult is defined as a person over 21 entrusted by the parent. - Questions and concerns: - Chair Santiago-Romero expressed reservations about the lack of data on behavioral change and unintended consequences. She stated she could not support approval but would allow the item to move forward without recommendation. - Councilmember Benson made a motion to forward the ordinance to new business (tomorrow's formal session) without recommendation, which was accepted. - Chief Bettison assured that programming with Third Circuit Court and 36th District Court is in place, and that the chief judge will personally handle the docket. Key Outcomes - Misdemeanor Ordinance: The committee voted to send the ordinance to formal regular business (to be considered in September) with a recommendation to approve. The motion passed without objection. - Curfew Ordinance: The committee voted to forward the ordinance to new business (tomorrow's formal session) without recommendation. The motion passed without objection, with Chair Santiago-Romero noting she does not support the ordinance but will allow full council debate. - Next steps: Both ordinances will be considered by the full City Council at its next formal session. The misdemeanor ordinance will be taken up in September; the curfew ordinance will be considered on July 29, 2025.

The Detroit City Council Neighborhood Community Service Standing Committee met on July 24, 2025, chaired by Council Member Coleman Young II. The meeting included public comments, the routine movement of several event permit petitions to formal session, discussion and votes on several contract amendments, and member reports. Notable topics included resident concerns over city services, rodent migration, DTE energy bills, and the city's parking app. Public Comments & Testimony - Cindy Darrell thanked Council Member Young and his mother for resolving a health department order on her house, but expressed distrust of the city's home repair programs, citing reports of contractors causing additional damage. She indicated interest in starting a housing co-op and requested no city interference. - Caller (ID 124) thanked Council Member Young for clarity on "crypto homes" and raised two issues: (1) improper service of blight tickets leading to collection notices, requesting that tickets be dropped if not properly served; and (2) rodent migration from developer sites, asking for developer responsibility. Council Member Young said he would look into it. - Mr. Overwith accused Council Member Scott Benson of lying about a threat of physical violence, claimed Benson has offshore bank accounts, and stated he would work to ensure Benson loses the upcoming election. He also alleged absentee ballot fraud. - Not that Karen expressed concern about high DTE electric bills, noting that Detroit residents pay more than suburban residents. She inquired about the "interruptible power" program and asked for its reinstatement. - Ms. Vernon (iPhone caller) – President of DeSoda Elsewhere Black Association – thanked Council Member Young for his support, including hygiene bags and donations. She invited attendees to the Rise Detroit event focusing on park funding. - Caller 270 discussed the city's bond debt, stating that the OCFO's report is now showing $2.7 billion outstanding, but claimed it is over $3 billion including interest. He also noted that the city has received $827 million in ARPA funds but has not conducted a required single audit. Discussion Items - Contract 6.16 – Towing services (booted/abandoned vehicles) – Motion to move to formal session without recommendation after Council Member Benson stated he did not support the contract but wanted it to advance. Motion passed. - Contract 6.19 – Parking app (Park Detroit) – Director Keith Hutchings explained the amendment is the last extension before going out to bid. He noted the app is growing and a PR campaign will launch in the next two months. Council Member Benson asked about adding EV chargers to the app; Hutchings said it is technically possible pending a request from the Office of Mobility and Innovation. The motion to move to formal session with recommendation for approval passed. - Contract 6.20 – Towing services (BBK Towing) – Moved to formal session without recommendation, similar to 6.16. - Contract 6.21 – Blight remediation maintenance – Alex Weatherup explained the amendment aligns fee schedules. Moved to formal session with recommendation for approval. Key Outcomes - Event permits (items 6.1–6.15): All petitions for special events (Southwest Vest, St. Joseph Shrine October Fest, Ava Joe Fest, Downtown Synagogue Block Party, Dally in the Alley, Detroit Football Classic, DHD annual block party, DAC Engines & Ice Cream, DAC Employee & Family Day, Detroit Dearborn Community Block Party, Detroit Dragway Reunion Car Show, Dr. Ossian H. Sweet 100th anniversary, Labor Day 2025, Sickle Cell Matters Awareness Week, Detroit Next to Blow Music Fest) were moved to formal session with recommendations for approval. - Contract 6.16 (towing, Sherwood Street): Moved to formal session without recommendation. - Contract 6.17 (ARPA mural projects): Amendment to extend time only; moved to formal session with recommendation for approval. - Contract 6.18 (Fort Street Bridge Park): $900,000 contract for phase two; moved to formal session with recommendation for approval. - Contract 6.19 (parking app): Amendment to extend time and increase funds by $1,548,200; moved to formal session with recommendation for approval. - Contract 6.20 (towing, BBK Towing): Moved to formal session without recommendation. - Contract 6.21 (blight remediation): Amendment to clarify fee schedule; no cost increase; moved to formal session with recommendation for approval. - Member Reports: Council Member Young welcomed interns, announced Coffee with Coleman event on July 25, 2025, and noted Detroit's birthday. - Adjournment: The committee adjourned without objection.

The Planning and Economic Development Standing Committee of the Detroit City Council met on Thursday, July 24, 2025, at 17:44 UTC (local time morning). Council President James Tate chaired the meeting, with members Fred Duro III (arrived later) and Letitia Johnson present. The committee addressed multiple public hearings, general public comment, unfinished business, and new business items. Key actions included approvals for affordable housing rezoning, a life sciences building PD modification, home repair contracts, and brownfield plan terminations, as well as postponements due to developer no-shows. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: The minutes from the previous meeting were approved by unanimous consent. - Motion to Suspend Memorial Reports: Approved. - Adjournment: Approved. Public Comments & Testimony General Public Comment (unscheduled speakers) - Reuben James Crowley Jr.: Accused Council President Tate of being a fraud and threatened his political career. Claims of past threats were referenced. - William Davis: Criticized the city for not conducting exit interviews with closing businesses (e.g., Pepsi) and for poor negotiation during bankruptcy, which he said harmed retirees. - Not that Karen (caller): Complained about pension reductions and lack of cost-of-living increases since bankruptcy, and criticized DTE energy rates. - Galaxy S10 (caller): Expressed frustration with flood recovery from 2016, alleging discrimination and demanding to be made whole. - Betty A. Varner (Soda Elsewhere Block Association): Announced a free community event (Arise Detroit) on August 2nd with resources, food, and activities. - Caller ending 124: Criticized eminent domain for solar farms, demanded pollinator patches be allowed, and raised concerns about Mary Sheffield's office not ticketing properly. - Miko Williams (Hydrate Detroit): Supported earlier caller Ruby Riley, stating she was justified in rejecting a settlement from the city for flood damages. Criticized water department handling of cases. - Brother Cunningham: Reported distributing bus tickets and ice water, praised a bus ride-along with Councilman Benson, and encouraged donations for community support. - Ronald Foster: Quoted Ecclesiastes, urged preparation for back-to-school season, and criticized the city for prioritizing unions and fraternities over the people. - Marguerite Maddox: Comments were garbled but appeared to express concerns about representation. Public Hearing 1015 (NEZ for 3700 Third Avenue) – Public Comments - Melanie Markowitz (Midtown Detroit Inc.): Expressed full support for the redevelopment, citing benefits for walkability, small business, affordable housing, and historic preservation. - Tim Tharp (Grand Trunk Pub/Checker Bar): Gave a testimonial for developer John Hartzell, highlighting his community-focused approach. - Not that Karen: Questioned the developer's phrase "turning lights on" and noted the rendering lacked people of color; also argued that multiple abatements for one project may be illegal per city code. - Julie Faelis: Spoke in support of John Hartzell, noting his commitment to community engagement and arts. - Rebecca Cutber: Supported the project, stating it would bring residents and walkability to the Cass Corridor and that the developer prioritizes diversity. - Jaron Jones: Supported the project, saying it would add retail, housing, and street lighting. - Marguerite Maddox: Comments were unclear. Public Hearing 1025 (Commercial Rehab for same project) – Public Comments - Cindy Dara: Warned against listening only to developers; urged attention to existing residents' concerns. - Caller ending 989: Shared concerns about the mayor's closed-door planning. - Marguerite Maddox: Brief, unclear comment. Public Hearing 1035 (Rezoning for Bellevue Village) – Public Comments (in-person and online) - Pastor Barry Randolph (Church of the Messiah): Expressed strong support for the affordable housing development. - Chaplain Sherry Scott: Supported the project. - James Marbury (Church of the Messiah housing board): Supported the project. - Not that Karen: Commended the presentation for providing truly affordable housing (60% AMI and below), not just trendy studios, and asked about HOA fees. - Toya Watts (Charlotte World Village Association): Opposed the project, citing insufficient community meetings (only two) and parking concerns in an already congested area. - Josh Pelsa (Housing Revitalization Department): Supported the project, stating it combats gentrification and provides deep affordability. - Michaela Lucas (Genesis Hope): Supported. - Maria (resident on Field Street): Supported the project, appreciated wraparound services, but criticized land bank processing of parcels. - Gabby Rodriguez: Supported the project, emphasizing need for affordable housing. - Charity Whitaker (Democracy for All Michigan): Supported, praising the developer's community work. - Marguerite Maddox: Brief, unclear. - Caller (line item seven): Suggested the project provide a free unit for someone illegally foreclosed. Public Hearing 1050 (Grasshead Life Sciences Building) – Public Comments - Caller ending 124: Expressed skepticism, calling it "decorative planning" and questioning secretive planning and the fate of Frank Murphy Hall of Justice. - Not that Karen: Noted need for development to return to neighborhoods. - Marguerite Maddox: Comments unclear but appeared to ask about accessibility and emergency exits. Discussion Items Neighborhood Enterprise Zone (NEZ) for Detroit 5 & Dime LLC – 3700 Third Avenue (1015 Public Hearing) - Staff Presentation: Casey Jackson (DEGC) and Justice Cook (HRD) presented the request for a PA 147 NEZ for residential portion. The building has been vacant 10 years; $3.4 million renovation into 10 residential units (one-bedroom, 80% AMI and below) and first-floor retail (4 food tenants, bar, outdoor patio). Developer would receive 100% abatement on tax increase for 12 years, then phase in full taxes by year 16. Net benefit to city: $156,761. Developer present deferred 80% of fees. - Developer Presentation: Jonathan Hartzell (Detroit Rise and Development) detailed plans for mixed-use with focus on micro-retail, affordable housing, and walkability. Units will have in-unit laundry and zero-threshold accessibility. No elevator due to building age. Parking via street only; plans to negotiate for additional land. Recycling will be provided. - Council Questions: Member Johnson asked about parking and recycling. Developer confirmed street parking and receptacles. Chair highlighted that no elevator is required due to grandfather clause. Developer committed to automatic doors at main entrance and lobby. Commercial Rehabilitation District (PA 255) for same project (1025 Public Hearing) - Staff Presentation: Casey Jackson explained the separate commercial incentive. Developer currently pays $3,090/year; post-improvement taxes projected $35,000/year. PA 255 would abate the increase for 12 years, then phase in full taxes by year 16. Both incentives deemed necessary for financing. Rezoning for Bellevue Village – 1035 Public Hearing - Presentation: Rezoning from R2 to R5 for seven parcels at Field Street to allow 29-unit affordable housing building (part of 40-unit total including two other sites). Developer: Church of the Messiah Housing Corp. 15 units will be permanent supportive housing. Rents at 60% AMI or below. Community engagement included multiple meetings; 11 letters of support, no opposition. - Council Discussion: Member Johnson praised deep affordability and universal design. Developer noted pre-development risk and $17.3M investment. Parking exceeds city requirements (1.25 spaces/unit vs 0.75 required). Council approved. Planned Development Modification – Grasshead Life Sciences Building – 1050 Public Hearing - Presentation: Request to modify PD ordinance 42-95 at 1326 St. Antoine (former juvenile detention site) to allow a six-story life sciences building with cancer research, outpatient treatment, and lab incubator space. Remaining 1.4 acres to be developed later. City Planning Commission approved in May 2025. - Council Discussion: Questions about accessibility (all entrances at grade, automatic doors, elevators), parking (valet for patients, within 5-min walk for employees), and bird-friendly glazing. Developer confirmed no demolition of Frank Murphy Hall of Justice; adaptive reuse being studied. Approved. Unfinished Business – 9.1 and 9.2: Brownfield Plan and Property Sale at 301/321 Edmund Place - Discussion: Item brought back from prior week due to concerns about automatic doors and recycling. Developer committed to push-button automatic doors at lobby and elevator core, and separate recycling bins in trash room (chutes not feasible due to unit loss). Approved. Stellantis Home Repair Program – Line Items 10.1, 10.2, 10.5 - Summary: $3.3 million total (original CBA funds plus $2.7M) for critical home repairs in impacted area. Phase 3 will address at least 130 houses with roof, HVAC, windows, etc. Outdoor air quality monitors and an August wellness event providing air purifiers were noted. Approved. Brownfield Plan Terminations – Line Items 10.6-10.16 - Explanation: These terminate outdated Michigan Business Tax Credit plans for projects that never used the credits (deadline passed 15+ years ago). This cleans up city records. Approved. Key Outcomes Votes & Approvals - General Public Comments: Concluded without action. - Line Item 7 (Rezoning for Bellevue Village): Motion to send to formal with recommendation to approve. Adopted by unanimous voice vote. (No roll call required as no objections). - Line Item 8 (Grasshead Life Sciences Building PD): Motion to send to formal with recommendation to approve. Adopted. - Line Items 9.1 & 9.2: Sent to formal with recommendation to approve. - Line Items 9.3, 10.20, 10.21, 10.22: Approved together. - Line Items 10.1, 10.2, 10.5: Approved. - Line Items 10.3, 10.4: Approved. - Line Items 10.6-10.16: Approved. - Line Items 10.17, 10.18, 10.19: Each approved individually. - Line Item 10.23: Approved (acquisition of 10 tax foreclosed parcels for strategic purposes). - Line Item 10.25: Approved (Make it Home program property sales). - Line Item 10.24: Approved (sale for stormwater project in District 4). - Line Item 5 (NEZ for 3700 Third): Sent to formal with recommendation to approve, with a 60-day gestation period before final action (brought back in 60 days). - Line Item 6 (Commercial Rehab for 3700 Third): Sent to formal with recommendation to approve. Referrals & Future Dates - Line Items 9.4 & 9.5 (Real Token properties): Brought back to September 4, 2025, for update on tenant support and court ruling. - Line Item 9.6 (Land Bank oversight): Brought back to September 4, 2025. - Line Item 9.7 (Community Benefits Agreement): Received and filed. - Line Item 9.8 (Recovery Park update): Brought back to September 11, 2025. - Line Item 10.26: Referred to City Planning Commission, brought back September 4. - Line Item 10.27: Referred to LPD, brought back September 11. - Line Item 10.28 (MOU amendment): Referred to law and LPD, brought back September 11. - Line Item 10.29 (Motor City Mitten Mission contract): Referred to HRD, brought back September 4. Other Actions - Meeting Adjourned: Last meeting before recess; next scheduled September 4, 2025.

The Budget, Finance, and Audit Standing Committee of the Detroit City Council met on Wednesday, July 23, 2025, at approximately 1:10 PM. This was the committee's last meeting before a summer recess, with the next meeting scheduled for September 3, 2025. The meeting included public comment, discussion of a feasibility study on taxing short-term rentals, fiscal impact reports on a misdemeanor prosecution ordinance and an electric vehicle charging ordinance, and the monthly financial report for the 11 months ending May 31, 2025. Consent Calendar - Approval of the minutes from the previous meeting was moved and adopted without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - Ruben James Crowley Jr. (citing an alias) alleged election fraud against Councilmember Fred Durhal and made accusations regarding a resource center at St. Suzanne's and a property at 19321 West Chicago. - Ronald Foster praised Councilmember Durhal's advocacy for underrepresented groups and requested attention to overgrown trees blocking stop signs at Homer and Tuxedo. He also made a lighthearted remark to Councilmember Jones. - Betty A. Varner, president of the DeSoda Elsewhere Block Association, thanked Councilmember Durhal for his support and requested continued help with landscape boulders. She promoted an August 2nd event in Erasmus Detroit. - Karen Winston commented on council punctuality, urged staff not to take constituent complaints personally, and asked whether council staff work during recess. - William M. Davis advocated for increasing the $5 million allocation for general fund legacy retirees, suggested the city conduct exit interviews with closing businesses, and criticized the drainage fee as burdensome. - Cindy Dara reported that the city demolished her fence without notice, leading to a default judgment against her. She asked for information and legal help for citizens. Councilmembers Santiago-Romero and Young responded that the demolition order had been rescinded and they would facilitate a meeting with the health department and ombudsman. - Malik Shelton questioned a $56.737 million line item labeled "miscellaneous" in the city's FY2024 annual comprehensive financial report and noted interest payments on long-term bond debt ($71 million) are more than double what the city spends on health ($30 million). He linked this to the city's unhealthiest ranking. - Bernard Manchunski (Detroit People's Platform) called for a stress test and revenue-estimating budget scenario assuming severe federal funding cuts, and urged that any county transit ballot proposal add new revenue for DDOT. - Joanne Warwick expressed appreciation for council's work with Cindy Dara, alleged lies by city employees regarding tree cutting and election department hiring, and warned of equal protection issues if the city doesn't help residents like Dara. - Carolyn Hughes echoed concerns about the $56 million uncategorized revenue, criticized proposed ordinance 6.3 as a fine increase without proof of deterrence, and asked about a $360 special fee on her tax bill. Discussion Items - Feasibility of Tax on Short-Term Rentals (Items 6.1 & 6.4): Marcel Hurt of the Legislative Policy Division (LPD) presented a study requested by Councilmember Mary Waters. He noted that short-term rentals are currently prohibited under Detroit's zoning code (Chapter 50, Section 50-12-492) unless used as home occupations. The city could not levy a tax without state legislative authorization and voter approval. A 2% excise tax is currently available only to Kent County. A correction was issued for an earlier error. The report also noted nine bills on short-term rental regulation introduced in the Michigan legislature from 2021–2024, none passed. Donnie Johnson, acting deputy CFO and budget director, confirmed OCFO also lacks capacity to design a tax collection system without a draft ordinance. Councilmember Santiago-Romero clarified that changes to both zoning (via a sixth text amendment being prepared by CPC and the law department) and state law are needed to allow a local tax. The committee voted to receive and file the items. - Fiscal Impact – EV Charging Ordinance Amendment (Item 6.2): Donnie Johnson reported that EV charging revenues go into a special revenue fund, making the ordinance revenue neutral with no general fund impact. The committee voted to receive and file the item. - Fiscal Impact – Misdemeanor Prosecution Ordinance (Item 6.3): The fiscal impact statement showed a negative impact in FY2027 because the program is currently funded by one-time ARPA dollars (FY2026). The law department explained the goal is to prosecute misdemeanors (e.g., assault and battery, retail fraud, larceny) in-house, improving justice for residents and diverting fine revenue to the city’s general fund (currently fines go to the state). Graham Anderson (Law Department) presented data on case volumes and fine potentials but noted fine revenue is difficult to project. Chair Durhal expressed concerns about sustainability and requested cost details for the case management system before a vote. Public hearing is scheduled for Monday, July 28. The committee voted to bring the item back on September 3. Key Outcomes - Consent calendar approved by unanimous consent. - Items 6.1 and 6.4 (short-term rental tax study) received and filed. - Item 6.2 (EV charging fiscal impact) received and filed. - Item 6.3 (misdemeanor prosecution fiscal impact) brought back for September 3 meeting, pending further information on case management system costs. - Monthly financial report (Item 7.1) received and filed. - Item 7.2 (duplicate resolution) removed from agenda. - Meeting adjourned to the call of the chair.

The Detroit City Council Internal Operations Standing Committee met on Wednesday, July 23, 2025, at approximately 19:04 UTC (morning local time) with a quorum present (Councilmembers Johnson, Waters, and Callaway). The meeting began with a motion to approve the minutes, followed by public comment, interviews for two board appointments, and action on numerous agenda items including settlements, contracts, and reports. Consent Calendar - Approval of the meeting minutes from the previous session (unanimous). Public Comments & Testimony Ten virtual callers provided general public comment. Key positions included: - William M. Davis: Expressed support for Josh Mack (Board of Ethics) and Robert Jones (Board of Police Commissioners); criticized lack of quorum at Police Commission meetings; called for reducing city lawsuit costs and restoring retiree pensions. - “Not that Karen”: Agreed on retirees’ issues; argued that a fast-track resolution passed the previous day was insufficient and that the city should restore pension clawback funds as promised in the bankruptcy settlement. - “Soher Amon” (likely “Soheir Amon”): Echoed retiree concerns; asked how to file an ethics complaint against Coleman A. Young II for alleged retaliation over public comment; alleged quid pro quo in home repair assistance. - Betty A. Varner (iPhone caller, President of Soda Elsewhere Black Association): Announced donations for landscaping boulders at Diva Community Park; shared information about a senior chore services program (Franklin Wright Settlement). - “We see you” (Mabby Heard): Supported retiree restitution; criticized police curfew ordinance and lawsuit costs; argued the city’s narrative on crime is inconsistent. - Miko A. Williams: Expressed love for community; criticized city leadership and the Duggan administration; urged voter turnout. - Galaxy S10 caller: Complained about being cut off during public comment on previous day; alleged discrimination by DWSD over flood compensation; requested reintegration. - Mike Shelton (phone ending 270): Asserted Detroit is the poorest U.S. city; claimed criminal over‑assessment of homes, unlawful bond issuance, and flagrant violation of the Michigan Constitution regarding use of public funds for private interests. - Galaxy S22 Ultra caller: Called for removal of Janice Winfrey from election duties; questioned funding sources and argued for taking back city services (water, light, garbage) and eliminating the land bank; alleged Black contractors face difficulty obtaining city contracts. - “You Matter”: Raised conflict-of-interest concerns about individuals serving on multiple boards; alleged police camera malfunctions at Detroit Wayne Joint Building Authority; supported Joyce Moore for Board of Ethics; claimed election department misled him about hiring. - Mr. Overwith: Alleged ballot fraud and argued that the mayor controls city, county, and state governments. Discussion Items Interviews for Board Appointments - David Bonner – Board of Ethics (10:15 a.m.): Presented background in finance and banking, MBA, associate professor. No substantive questions; Councilmember Callaway noted Bonner’s wife works for her as a special projects manager but recused from voting. Council expressed appreciation. - Josh Mack – Board of Ethics (10:25 a.m., virtual): Presented education (BS, MS, doctoral work), and extensive experience in education, juvenile justice, and public service. Councilmembers praised his community involvement. He pledged reliable attendance. - Robert Jones – Board of Police Commissioners (10:35 a.m.): Lifelong Detroiter, retired AT&T director of external affairs. Discussed being a good listener, commitment to attendance, and willingness to enforce discipline when necessary. Councilmembers queried him on quorum issues and handling of officer misconduct. Motions and Votes on Agenda Items - Line items 5, 6, 8.1, 8.2, 8.16, 8.17 (Board of Ethics candidates): Motion carried to send all six names to formal session with a ballot drafted for consideration. - Line item 8.3 (Detroit Wayne Joint Building Authority interview – Byron Osborne Iceburn): Approved after awaiting law department opinion; motion to send to formal with recommendation to approve. - Line item 8.4 (Tracy Reynolds settlement, $80,000): Held pending information on sidewalk repair; brought back after recess. - Line item 8.5 (Trish Cunningham settlement, $125,000): Approved and sent to formal. - Line item 8.6 (Kayla Jefferson settlement, $30,000): Initially held for clarification on officer’s lights/sirens; after DPD confirmed lights/sirens were active but officer did not fully follow policy, motion to approve passed. - Line items 8.7–8.14: Held pending further information; returned after recess. - Line item 8.15 (Fink Bressek legal services amendment, +$400,000): Approved; Councilmember Waters requested a performance report. - Line item 8.18 (Council President Sheffield’s memorandum on debarment ordinance): Held after recess. - Line item 8.19 (Request for opinion on tax abatements for urban agriculture): Held after recess. - Line item 9.2 (Monthly report of contracts approved administratively): Received and filed. - Line item 9.3 (Drone airspace management contract, $397,838): Held after recess per Councilmember Callaway’s request for inventory of existing drones and vendor research. - Line item 9.4 (Fiber cable installation amendment, extension only): Approved. - Line item 9.5 (Neighborhood Defender Service housing legal representation, $1,531,320): Approved after discussion on holistic model. - Line item 9.6 (Legal services for indigent individuals – DSS 10, up to $30,141,587.97): Approved; clarified as state grant with city share of $1 million/year. - Line items 9.7–9.14 (various settlements): Approved. - Line item 9.15 (Dorothy McElrath/Diane Davis settlement, $255,000): Held after recess pending info on employee status. - Line items 9.16–9.19, 9.20 (report, conflicts, etc.): Approved or received and filed. - Line item 9.21 (potential conflicts report): Received and filed. - Line item 9.22 (legal opinion on conflicts): Held awaiting law department response. Key Outcomes - Board of Ethics interviews: Six candidates advanced to formal ballot (David Bonner, Josh Mack, and four others). - Board of Police Commissioners appointment: Robert Jones’ interview completed; likely to be put to vote at formal session. - Settlements approved: Trish Cunningham ($125,000), Kayla Jefferson ($30,000), and numerous others ($5,700–$200,000) – all sent to formal. - Contracts approved: Fink Bressek extension ($400,000), fiber cable amendment, housing legal services ($1.53M), indigent defense program ($30M), and others. - Items held for later: Tracy Reynolds ($80,000), drone contract ($397,838), Dorothy McElrath ($255,000), and several agenda items held until after recess (September). - Public comments: All 10 callers expressed concerns about retiree pensions, ethics, police accountability, and city governance. Member Reports - Councilmember Callaway announced the third annual “Stamping Out Human Trafficking” event on Saturday, July 26, at Mac Alive (3746 Fisher St.), 11 a.m.–3 p.m. - Councilmember Johnson announced a community bike ride on July 31 from Ball Duck Park to Chandler Park, starting at 5:30 p.m.

The Detroit City Council met on July 22, 2025, at 10:00 a.m. (session started after invocation) for a formal session. The meeting included two presentations, public comment, and approval of numerous resolutions. Key topics included a Spirit of Detroit Award, a presentation on truck traffic and pollution, a contract for after‑hours homeless outreach, and introduction of a curfew ordinance with increased fines. Presentations - Spirit of Detroit Award to Pierre Hatton – Councilmember Young presented the award to Pierre Hatton, president of the Boston Edison Association, for his community service and leadership. Multiple council members praised his work. - Trucks Off Our Streets Coalition – Simone (Southwest Detroit Community Benefits Coalition), Jeff Jones (Hope Village CDC), Dr. Toby Lewis (pediatric pulmonologist, U‑M), and Dr. Natalie Sampson (public health, U‑M) presented on the health and safety impacts of truck traffic on residential streets. They highlighted that 1,000 trucks per day travel on Livernois Street, that Detroit has 16% childhood asthma (double the national rate), and that the city is out of attainment for particulate matter. They called for enforcement of existing laws and a strong truck route ordinance. Councilmember Santiago Romaro stated a truck route ordinance is expected to be voted on this fall. Public Comments & Testimony - Michelle Thurman (Garden View Estates tenant) complained of retaliation and harassment after settling a landlord‑tenant case. - Betty Lyons criticized Councilmember Santiago Romaro’s perceived power and the handling of senior issues. - Ann Goulet (architect) criticized the administration’s property development decisions and asked the council to stop sale of public properties. - Kenneth Holloway (east side resident) said the $15,000 grant from Chrysler was inadequate for the health impacts of pollution. - Malik Shelton urged the council to declare a health emergency, noting Detroit’s poor health rankings and lack of a health advisory commission. - Ramon Jackson complained about ballot irregularities and lack of representation. - Emily Ambeck (Southwest Detroit) urged quick action on the truck route ordinance. - James Garden alleged police misconduct and prosecutorial misconduct. - Cunningham (community advocate) thanked Councilmembers Johnson and Callaway for help. - Shirley Miller complained about DDOT bus driver rudeness. - Melissa Love alleged voter fraud and corruption. - Demetria Kins and Christian Gary (SEIU) expressed concern about janitors at the Renaissance Center facing displacement due to renovations. - Barbara Logan complained about overassessment of property taxes. - Richard Noto praised the council for positive work. - Charles Cousin urged the council to address poverty and create same‑day work programs. - Renita Moore complained about conditions at a child care center (Cash Community). - Dante Smith criticized Councilmember Benson’s handling of a conflict facility and thanked Councilmembers Sheffield and Santiago Romaro. - Virtual callers included support for Willie Burton for District 5, concerns about pension disparities, and many comments on truck traffic and health. Discussion Items - Motor City Mission Contract (Line 19.1) – A $767,000 contract for after‑hours homeless outreach (6 p.m.–8 a.m. weekdays, 24 hours weekends/holidays). Councilmembers Waters and Callaway expressed concerns about the organization’s board composition, wages ($15–$17/hour), and the effectiveness of the program. After discussion, the contract was approved with objections from Waters and Callaway. - Curfew Ordinance (Line 21.14) – Introduced by Councilmember Young. The ordinance increases fines for parents whose children violate curfew (first offense $250, second $500, with possible probation and parenting programs). Councilmembers Tate, Santiago Romaro, and others raised questions about available diversion programs and wraparound services. The chief of police assured the council that programs would be developed. A public hearing was set for July 28, 2025, and the ordinance was approved on a 5‑day waiver. - 19.5 – Consolidated Plan Amendment – Postponed back to committee after discussion. - 19.7 – Land Bank resolution – Initially objected to by Councilmember Waters, but after reconsideration, she changed her vote to yes. Key Outcomes - Approved Consent Calendar – Journal of July 8; referrals to standing committees. - Approved Resolutions (selected): - 17.1–17.5 (budget, audit, parking fees – 17.5 amended to include $225 inspection fee, later approved) - 18.1–18.23 (worker’s comp, lawsuit settlements, indigent defense grant, retiree fast track program) - 19.1 (Motor City Mission contract, $767,000) – Approved with objections (Waters, Callaway) - 19.2 (Home repair program, $3.2M) – Approved - 19.3 (Artifact donation to Wayne State) – Approved, waiver denied - 19.7 (Land Bank resolution) – Approved after reconsideration - 20.2 (Compliance system) – Approved - 21.1–21.5 (City events) – Approved with scrivener’s error corrected - 21.6–21.13 (Various contracts: EMS annex, basement backup, road reconstruction) – Approved, except 21.13 objected by Callaway (noted) - 21.14 (Curfew ordinance) – Introduced, public hearing set for July 28, 2025, approved with waivers - 21.15 (Public hearing scheduling) – Approved - 21.16 (OCFO resolution) – Approved - 21.17 (KEM Day resolution) – Approved as amended (July 23, 2025) - Waivers Granted – For numerous items to expedite. - Ombudsperson Search – Attorney Barcliff reported 10 nominees; interviews will be scheduled after recess in September. Adjournment The meeting adjourned at approximately 1:30 p.m. (after the last actions).