Public Meetings - Detroit, Michigan

The Planning and Economic Development (PED) Committee of the Detroit City Council met on September 11, 2025, at 17:54 UTC. The meeting focused on a detailed investigation into the Garden Bug rezoning case, public comments on the Detroit Land Bank Authority (DLBA) and other issues, and routine business. No public hearings were held, allowing extended discussion. Consent Calendar - Approved minutes of previous meeting. - Received and filed several items, including reports from legislative policy and council president offices. Public Comments & Testimony - India Hawkins (representing Waverly property adjacent to Garden Bug) expressed frustration over unresolved safety issues and lack of accountability from the city regarding the business's operation on West Davidson. She emphasized that the flower shop was a beautiful vision but poorly planned, and that the city failed to enforce proper channels. - Ernestine Hawkins (property owner) detailed three years of complaints about parking violations, trespassing, and lack of enforcement from multiple city departments, including BC Inspectors, District 7 office, and police. She stated that action only came after contacting the Ombudsman office. - Travis Ennis (on behalf of Waverly property) reiterated safety concerns and called for a resolution. - Tina Castleberry (owner of Garden Bug) argued that the business is only open four months a year, that the property was vacant for 50 years, and that she has accommodated parking. She stated that no one from the city has reached out to her despite commitments made in the previous meeting. - Miko Williams (lifelong Detroit resident) spoke against the Land Bank, calling for town halls in all seven districts before any new MOU vote. - Betty A. Barner (president of Soda Else World Black Association) thanked the council for help with flooding and requested donations for her organization's park expansion. - Other callers addressed land bank reform, senior property tax concerns, election integrity, and the need for community input on the DLBA MOU. Discussion Items - Garden Bug Rezoning (Item 5.2): The committee reviewed the Ombudsman's report on the property at 4213 & 4225 West Davidson. The Ombudsman, Bruce Simpson, detailed that the business had been operating since 2022 without proper zoning (R3 residential), despite a purchase agreement from the DLBA that required rezoning. He noted that the city's enforcement was lacking, and that Motor City Match and Detroit Means Business awarded grants without verifying zoning. The Ombudsman concluded that the situation stemmed from a lack of consistency and enforcement. Council members questioned the timeline and failures, with Member Durhal expressing concern about the three-year gap before enforcement. The committee heard from CPC staff, who noted that the first rezoning application was incomplete in 2021. Director Todd added that the commission's recommendation would expire on November 25, 2025, if no action taken. The applicant, Tina Castleberry, stated she was unaware of the process and apologized for delays, but asked to remain on site. She suggested the city purchase adjacent land for parking. Council members indicated a need for finality and directed Castleberry to contact planning department. The item was brought back one week. - Land Bank MOU (Items 5.6, 6.12, 6.16, 6.17): Multiple items related to the proposed amendments to the DLBA MOU were discussed. Member Waters requested an extension for further discussion. The committee agreed to bring these items back on October 2, 2025. - Community Land Trust Ordinance (Item 6.11): Member Johnson introduced the draft ordinance. It was referred to the Law Department for review and scheduled to return in three weeks. - Other Items: Several items were processed, including referrals for rental property inspections, term limits for DLBA board members, and questions on tax abatements and senior housing. The committee also discussed the secondary streets process, with Member Johnson advocating for recognizing lesser-known residents. Key Outcomes - Item 5.1 (Tax preparation services): Brought back in one week. - Item 5.2 (Garden Bug rezoning): Brought back in one week; council expects a vote at that time. - Item 5.5 (Tax abatements in District 1): Brought back in one week. - Items 5.6, 6.12, 6.16, 6.17 (Land Bank MOU): Brought back on October 2, 2025. - Item 6.11 (Community Land Trust ordinance): Referred to Law Department, return in three weeks. - Item 6.15 (Audit of DLBA): Sent to formal session with recommendation to approve. - Item 6.14 (Rental property inspections): Referred to HRD and BSEED, return October 2. - Item 6.18 (DLBA partnership sales): Referred to HRD and DLBA, return October 2. - Item 6.19 (Expiring tax abatements): Referred to LPD, return October 2. - Item 6.20 (Senior buildings with HUD contracts): Referred to LPD and BSEED, return October 2. - Item 6.21 (Bagley Community NEZ boundaries): Referred to LPD, return in one week. - Item 6.6 (DLBA oversight resolution): Removed from agenda as previously handled.

The Budget, Finance and Audit Standing Committee of the Detroit City Council met on September 10, 2025. The meeting opened with roll call (Councilmember Coleman Young II absent, excused), approval of the previous meeting's minutes, and public comments from eight callers. Several agenda items were discussed, including financial and ARPA reports and policy matters. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: The minutes from the previous meeting were approved by unanimous consent. Public Comments & Testimony - Fair Elections (Ms. Warwick): Objected to a contract with ACOM, urging the city to hire Detroit residents. Raised allegations of election fraud and criticized officials Mary Sheffield, Janice Winfrey, and the elections department. - Karen Winston ("Not That Karen"): Representing city retirees, called for retirees to be made whole after 12 years of pension and healthcare cuts. Stated that a $464 increase is insufficient, that overtaxation of $600 million should be returned, and urged action on homelessness and senior issues. - William M. Davis: Echoed retiree concerns, detailing a pension cut of 4.5%, loss of cost-of-living adjustments retroactive to 2013, and medical benefit cuts for those under 65. He stated overtaxation exceeds $1 billion and criticized Mayor Duggan’s 40% pay raise versus a $20,000 average retiree pension. - Carolyn Hughes: Raised concerns about speed hump contracts awarded to white men, tax issues, stadium deals benefiting outsiders, and corruption in city operations. Supported election fraud allegations. - Brother Cunningham: Urged support for public transportation and encouraged elected officials to bring community members to meetings. - Joyce E. Jennings: Advocated for city partnership with Detroit Public Schools to provide reliable public transportation in areas where schools have closed, citing safety and affordability issues. Also called for insurance support for city retirees who worked in high-risk jobs. - Mr. Rue: Unable to connect due to technical difficulties; comments to be submitted via email. Discussion Items - Unfinished Business – Line Item 5.1 (OCFO Financial Report): Councilmember Santiago Romero requested a one-week bring-back for the financial report for the 12 months ended June 30, 2025. Motion approved. - ARPA Reports (Line Items 5.2-5.7 & 6.1): Mr. Corley of the Legislative Policy Division presented the status of ARPA (OPERA) funds. He noted a format change and that the city has obligated all $826.7 million in ARPA funds as of December 31, 2024. As of June 30, 2025, the city had spent $84.4 million on payroll and $491 million on contractual services (the transcript initially stated a total of $5.75 million, which appears inconsistent with the breakdown; the sum of those items is approximately $575 million). As of September 8, 2025, spending reached $613 million (74% of total). Mr. Corley also reported on the council ARPA appropriation: several contracts are obligated but actuals are pending, expected by end of September. A second round of reassigned ARPA dollars is anticipated by early October. The reports are available on the city council website. - Line Items 5.8 & 5.9 (Property Tax Rate Flyer): Mr. Corley requested a two-week bring-back to finalize an informational flyer for real estate agents on property tax rate adjustments after property transfer. - Line Item 6.2 (Admissions Tax Report): Mr. Corley requested a two-week bring-back to allow the Citizens Research Council of Michigan and the OCFO to provide input on the report evaluating a local option admissions tax on sports and entertainment venues. Key Outcomes - Minutes approved. - Line item 5.1 (financial report) to be brought back in one week. - ARPA reports (5.2-5.7, 6.1) received and filed. - Line items 5.8 and 5.9 (property tax flyer) to be brought back in two weeks. - Line item 6.2 (admissions tax) to be brought back in two weeks. - Meeting adjourned at the call of the chair.

The Internal Operations Standing Committee met on Wednesday, September 10, 2025, to approve minutes, hear public comments, interview nominees for the Brownfield Community Advisory Council, and consider settlement requests and new business items. The meeting was chaired by Councilmember Letitia Johnson, with Councilmembers Mary Waters and Angela Whitfield Callaway present. Consent Calendar - Motion to approve the minutes from the previous meeting was passed without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - William M. Davis expressed a position that the city spends too much on lawsuits and indemnifications, arguing those funds should instead help retirees and senior citizens. He also criticized tax abatements and clawbacks from retiree checks. - Betty A. Bernard (President, DeSoda Elsewhere Block Association) advocated for her community park, seeking donations for playscape equipment and a land use hearing. She also promoted a free senior services program. - Demiko Williams (prior citizen, taxpayer, legacy Detroiter) alleged that Detroit police, the mayor, and officials are using informants to bully and intimidate him, and criticized police tactics regarding children and parents. - Melissa Love claimed election fraud (being on voter rolls without voting) and demanded removal from rolls, return of resources, and more contracts for Detroit residents. She also questioned the lack of grocery stores in Detroit compared to suburbs. - Fair Elections Matter (caller) urged the committee to investigate the election commission, alleging lies and voter fraud, and criticized solar takings and the mayoral succession. They also commented on voting rights for incarcerated individuals. - Not that Karen spoke in support of retirees, demanding an end to clawbacks and restored healthcare. They also raised concerns about homelessness, asthma rates, and speed humps creating particulate matter. - Galaxy S22 Ultra (Kenny Candleman) praised Councilmember Johnson but criticized speed humps, land bank cleanup, and speeding on his block. Councilmember Waters responded that speed humps require community majority. - Cunningham (caller) discussed distributing bus tickets at stops and urged better bus service. - Owner Papa (Carolyn Hughes) argued that speed humps kill and increase particulate matter, accusing the administration of genocide and corruption. Councilmember Waters clarified speed humps are installed by community request. - To hear Ahmed commended Councilmember Callaway for investigating crypto property owners, criticized Wayne County Treasurer for refusing a foreclosure moratorium on low-value homes, and asked for support to prevent foreclosures and homelessness. Discussion Items - Interviews for Brownfield Community Advisory Council (CAC) - David Bonner (adjunct professor, finance/accounting) was interviewed for the CAC. He highlighted his financial services background and interest in brownfield redevelopment. Councilmembers expressed support; his item was brought back for a future date. - Josh Mack (educator, urban planner, former Detroit Public Schools housing board chair) was interviewed via Zoom. He detailed his education, administrative experience, and community activism in housing. His item was also held for a week pending a third interview. - Settlement Requests (Unfinished Business) - 7.1: Melody Allen vs. Nathaniel Adams & City of Detroit (DOT) – $43,500 – Approved and sent to formal session. - 7.2: Rosalind Johnson vs. City of Detroit (DOT) – $295,000 – Approved. - 7.3: Teresa Moore vs. Javarica Tyrus & City of Detroit (Police) – $44,000 – Approved. - 7.4: Dorothy McElrath & Diane Davis vs. City of Detroit (Municipal Parking) – $255,000 – Discussion raised about municipal enforcement officers making U-turns. Motion to send to formal without recommendation passed after Councilmember Callaway noted she had one question. - New Business - 8.1: Contract with Detroit Public Schools for August & November 2025 elections – $297,653.32 – Discussion: Councilmember Callaway asked whether Rutherford Winings Academy would remain a polling site for November. Elections Chief of Staff Christian Meduka promised to verify. Approved and sent to formal. - 8.2: ARPA-funded amendment for ICE Arena & Recreation Center improvements – $2,190,000 – Referred to Public Health & Safety Committee per correction letter. - 8.3: Khalia Merriweather vs. Titan Insurance et al. (Fire) – $32,000 – Approved. - 8.4: Thomas Wickman vs. City of Detroit – $19,500 – Approved. - 8.5: Johnny King vs. City of Detroit (DOT) – $30,000 – Approved. - 8.6: Sarah Shuboy vs. City of Detroit (Fire/EMS) – $120,000 – Approved. - 8.7: Patricia Hearin vs. Robert Williams Shelton & City of Detroit (Fire) – $15,000 – Approved. - 8.8: Virginia LaFour vs. City of Detroit – $30,000 – Approved. Key Outcomes - All settlement items except 7.4 were approved and sent to formal session; 7.4 was sent without recommendation. - Nominees David Bonner and Josh Mack for the Brownfield CAC were held over for additional interviews; decision expected in one week. - Elections contract (8.1) approved after a question on polling site status. - Contract 8.2 referred to the Public Health & Safety Committee. - Councilmember reports: Waters announced a Skill Trade Task Force meeting on September 17; Callaway promoted an Ombudsman event, webinar with Wayne County Commissioner, expungement clinic, and district meetings; Johnson reminded of District 4 community meeting on September 15 and fall shred day, and expressed support for addressing the Travel Inn eyesore in Ravendale, advocating for affordable housing. - Adjourned without objection.

The Detroit City Council convened on Tuesday, September 9, 2025, at approximately 10:00 AM (based on the morning invocation). The meeting featured two celebratory presentations—Prince Valley market's 50th anniversary and the Detroit Tigers Nike RBI U18 softball team's world championship—followed by extensive public comment and a legislative session where multiple contracts and resolutions were approved. Notable actions included postponement of a special event permit for Roosevelt Park and approval of ARPA-funded home repair contracts. Consent Calendar - 13 reports from city departments were referred to the public health and safety standing committee. - Multiple contracts and resolutions were approved under consent, including: - Three resolutions from the Office of Contracting and Procurement (OCFO) for auditing and grant compliance (items 15.1–15.3). - Six resolutions for media services, legal representation, and AV production (items 16.1–16.6). - Nine lawsuit settlement resolutions (items 16.7–16.15). - Approval of 2026 medical, dental, and vision plan rates for city employees (item 16.16). - Implementation of a labor agreement with the Association of City of Detroit Supervisors (item 16.17). - Appointment of Byron Osburn to the Detroit Wayne Joint Building Authority (item 16.18). - Three resolutions for housing and revitalization contracts (items 17.1–17.3), including roof/window replacements and homelessness services. - Eleven special event permits (items 18.1–18.12, excluding 18.3 which was postponed). - Two resolutions for software and repair services (items 18.14–18.15). - One resolution for environmental consulting (item 18.13). - Cancellation of standing committee meetings on September 24–25 for the Congressional Black Caucus (item 18.17). - Two resolutions recognizing Welcoming Week (Sept 12–21) and National Hispanic Heritage Month (items 18.18–18.19). Public Comments & Testimony - Detention Center Staff (Taiwan Durham, Richard Bass, Marcus Reed): Multiple detention officers expressed frustration over low pay and severe understaffing at the Detroit Detention Center. They stated that 11 employees had left since the city took over operations in August, and that pay is significantly lower than MDOC or DPD counterparts. They urged council to examine the situation. - Senior Citizen Housing (speaker from Jefferson Ave buildings): A resident reported drug use, theft, and health hazards from chemical spraying in senior buildings (Whittier, River Towers, Parkview Place, Roberts). Councilmember Waters offered to connect her with community liaisons. - Sanctuary City Advocates (Cassandra, multiple others from Detroit Community Action Committee): Several speakers demanded adoption of a sanctuary city ordinance, citing a Supreme Court ruling allowing racial profiling and DPD cooperation with ICE. They argued that 70% of Detroiters oppose using city resources for immigration enforcement (poll referenced). They called for ending ICE collaboration and protecting immigrant communities. - Solid Waste Fee (speaker, name not given): Opposed the increase to $270 ($135 for seniors), calling it underhanded and noting that the cost was not clearly communicated. They stated that trash pickup is still inconsistent. - Property Issues (Charles Miles, others): Complained about city attempts to take property despite taxes being overpaid. Mr. Miles alleged harassment by police and false reports. - Land Bank and Tax Abatements (William M. Davis, virtual): Called for transparency in Land Bank board composition and a halt to tax abatements without accountability. Noted that 400 Detroit retirees died this year due to clawbacks. - Tax Foreclosure (Tahira Ahmed, virtual): Reported that 834 homes face foreclosure on September 10, urging Treasurer Eric Sabree to impose a moratorium. Cited University of Chicago study showing 62% of owner-occupied homes under $50,000 are illegally overassessed. - Speed Humps (Omar Papa, virtual): Cited a report that speed humps increase particulate matter by 5%, contributing to asthma and cancer. Urged removal. - Youth Curfew (Bobby Johnson, in person): Criticized the new curfew and first-time misdemeanor prosecution policy, arguing it criminalizes young people. Councilmember Young responded that the legislation was amended to remove jail time and instead provide services and parental training. - Other topics: Election fraud claims (Melissa Love, Ramal Jackson), police harassment (speaker who said he was attacked by 9th precinct officers), support for Willie Burton's council campaign (Miko A. Williams), and congratulations to the softball team (multiple callers). Discussion Items - Item 18.3 – Tailgate Event at Roosevelt Park: Councilmember Santiago Ramiro expressed concerns about parking and noise impacts on residents. Special Events staff confirmed outreach to block clubs and police coordination. Councilmember Young raised concerns about ICE targeting attendees in Southwest Detroit. A motion to postpone for one week was approved to allow further community engagement. - ARPA Fund Status Walk-On: A request to walk on a report on American Rescue Plan Act fund status as of December 31, 2024 was approved for referral to the Budget Finance and Audit standing committee. Councilmember Callaway noted the attachment font was too small; staff agreed to post a readable version online immediately. Key Outcomes - Approvals: All consent items passed without objection, including contracts for home repair, homeless services, auditing, and special events (except 18.3). Waivers were attached to several items to expedite implementation. - Postponement: Item 18.3 (Roosevelt Park tailgate) was postponed for one week to allow further community outreach. - Referrals: 13 departmental reports and the ARPA fund status report were referred to the appropriate standing committees. - Public comment link: Councilmember Waters agreed to connect senior building resident with community liaisons; Councilmember Young clarified that the youth curfew policy does not involve jail time. Additional Notes - The meeting included invocation by Chaplain Ali (Islamic prayer). - Presentations highlighted Prince Valley market (110 employees, 2-300 cakes/week, 1000 tamales/day) and the U18 softball team's world championship (allowed 1 run in final, won 3-1, three sisters on team). - Councilmember Young visited Metro Detroit Youth Day and Austin Sweet Home Memorial Park; Councilmember Santiago Ramiro invited residents to community meetings on the DCFC Stadium project (Sept 11) and coffee council (Sept 18).

The Public Health and Safety Standing Committee of the Detroit City Council convened on Monday, September 8, 2025, at 10:00 AM, with Chair Gabrielle Santiago Romero presiding. This was the first meeting back after the summer recess. The committee approved the minutes from the previous session, heard public comments from nine callers, and processed a series of contracts, memos, and resolutions. Most items were approved unanimously, with several held for further information. Consent Calendar - Approval of minutes from previous session. - Contract 6007252 (Tetra Tech, environmental consulting, $400,000) – approved. - Contract 6007286 (DPD specialty uniforms) – removed from agenda per administration. - Demolition contracts 5.2 and 5.3 – brought back in one week. - Contract 308474 (emergency demo at 14320 Wilshire, $20,590) – approved (demolished August 18, 2025). - Various demolition contracts under bond funding (6.4-6.13) – approved. - Corrected contracts 6.1 and 6.2 – approved. - Contract 6007402 (electrical maintenance, $3.5M over 3 years) – approved (noted tax balance expired). - Contract 6007056 (crisis intervention program, $360,000) – approved. - Dangerous buildings findings and orders (6.16-6.20) – received and filed. - Building safety recommendations for 10242 West Grand River and 319 Ed Sol Ford (6.21, 6.22) – concurred with department. - Cash donation from Valerie R. Williamson for police academy (6.24) – approved. - Memo on speed humps and particulate matter (6.25) – received and filed. - Resolutions 6.26-6.33 (supporting Senate Bill 492, Focus Hope, Amber Alert bills, banner installations, Welcoming Week, Hispanic Heritage Month, accessibility funding) – all approved. - Memos 6.34-6.36 – brought back in one week. Public Comments & Testimony Nine callers provided public comment. Key themes: - Election finance concerns: Caller Miko A. Williams warned about outside money and developer influence, criticizing Councilmember Scott Benson and developer Dan Gilbert. - Senior services: A caller promoted Franklin Wright Settlement Senior Chore Services (free services for seniors 60+). - Prayer and community: Caller Cunningham shared personal testimony and encouraged prayer. - Property assessment: Tahir Ahmed cited a University of Chicago study finding Detroit illegally inflates assessments on low-value homes, urging a foreclosure moratorium for 2025. - Retiree issues: Multiple callers (not that Karen, William M. Davis, Cecily McClellan) demanded restitution for city retirees, including stopping the clawback and providing affordable insurance. - Water affordability: Cecily McClellan urged codification of a water affordability program, noting the Detroit Lifeline Program lost funding and only 8,000 of 60,000 eligible residents are served. - Speed humps: A caller (owner Papa) argued speed humps increase particulate matter and harm health, calling for their removal. The Vice Chair noted that a report on the issue was commissioned due to her concerns. - Health department access: William M. Davis criticized lack of parking at the health department. - Lighting and safety: Marguerite Maddox requested attention to street lights at First and Rocks. - Poverty: Ronald Foster called for generational approaches to poverty. Discussion Items - Contract 5.5 (Linden Street facility renovations, $500,000): Held for one week to allow Pro Tem Tate to review responses to questions. - Contract 5.6 (emergency demo): Discussion on blight vs. bond funding. Group Executive Lewan Counts explained that bond funds are exhausted, so blight/general funds are now used for emergency demos. Vice Chair noted $27.7M in bond funds shown as available, but Counts indicated those are encumbered for identified properties. - Contract 5.12 (emergency demo at 19436 Westbrook): Tax clearance not yet received; brought back TBD. - Contract 5.14 (emergency demo at 5198 South Clearden): DTE still not disconnected; anticipated NTP later today; approved to move to formal. - Contract 6.14 (electrical maintenance): Discussion on lack of city electricians for 3-5 years. Group Executive noted challenges in hiring trades due to pay and union negotiations. Motion to approve passed. - Building safety item 6.23 (7285 Prairie): Member Waters wanted to see a photo; brought back in one week for more information. Key Outcomes - All items that were approved passed unanimously with no objections. - Items held for later: 5.2, 5.3, 5.5, 5.8, 5.11, 5.12, 6.3, 6.23, 6.34-6.36. - The committee received and filed several memos and reports. - The chair directed LPD to resend information on water affordability ordinances. - Committee directed follow-up on street lighting concerns with Ms. Maddox.

The Neighborhood Community Services Standing Committee of the Detroit City Council convened on September 4, 2025, at approximately 6:16 p.m. with a quorum present (Councilmembers Young, Whitfield Callaway, and Benson). The committee approved minutes, heard public comments, and moved several agenda items to formal session. Key discussions included the removal of a past-due election event, questioning of ticket pricing for a private event in a public park, and member reports highlighting community events and services. Consent Calendar - Approval of the meeting minutes (motion, no objections). Public Comments & Testimony - You Matter: Expressed disagreement with the mayor's meeting procedures, alleging First Amendment violations by restricting public comment due to past misconduct. Requested that Councilmember Young ask the Law Department to investigate legality. Also thanked the demolition department for boarding up 296 Smith, a property owned by the North End Landing developers, which had been open to trespass. - Cunningham: Praised council members for their Labor Day Parade presence and urged them to ride Detroit Department of Transportation (DDOT) buses to understand service issues (unreliable, unclean). Also promoted his own efforts providing ice water and bus tickets at bus stops. - William M. Davis: Invited attendees to the City of Detroit Retiree Task Force meeting (Sept 5, 11 a.m.–12:30 p.m., in-person and Zoom). Stated that retirees continue to suffer and that the city has not done all it should. - Evelyn Garcia: Mistakenly thought the meeting was for East Point, Georgia; inquired about lack of East Point police response to package thefts and car thefts. After being informed this was Detroit City Council, she stopped her comments. - Mr. Rue: Alleged widespread election fraud by the council, mayor, school board, and police commissioners. Claimed the Detroit Police Department homicide unit and a medical examiner changed a homicide ruling to suicide. Accused the city of diverting funds from children to downtown development. - Caller 169: Asked public commenter Cunningham to reveal his voting preferences for governor, mayor, and all city council districts. - Betty A. Barner (President, Soda Ellsworth Block Association): Promoted the Franklin Wright Settlements Senior Chore Services program (free for ages 60+, 313-579-1000 ext. 301), describing various home maintenance and cleaning services available. - Shakira Haleem (caller "Shakira's iPhone"): Questioned how residents can work with council to change Land Bank rules given Mayor Duggan's opposition to diminishing the Land Bank. Councilmember Young responded that they are reviewing the MOU through the Planning and Economic Development committee and will bring it to the full floor for further discussion. Discussion Items - Item 5.1 – Repair & Maintenance Services Contract: Contract with Michigan Recreational Construction for citywide repair and maintenance at public spaces, total $2,770,000, through July 14, 2027. Previously held by Councilwoman Santiago-Romero but hold removed. Moved to formal session. - Item 6.2 – Get Out the Vote Event (July 26, 2025): Councilmember Benson noted the event had already occurred and questioned why it was on the agenda. After clarification from Ms. Fife (Manager of Special Events) that it was planned late during recess, and the Law Department confirmed it was legally moot, Benson moved to remove the item. Council agreed (no objections). - Item 6.4 – Trap Tailgate (Oct 12, 2025, Roosevelt Park): Vice Chair Whitfield Callaway asked if the event is ticketed and what the fee is. Ms. Fife confirmed there are admission sales but no rate schedule required. Whitfield Callaway expressed concern about private entities charging the public in a public park without known pricing, suggesting future applications include such details. Item moved to formal session. - Item 6.15 – Wayne County Parks Village Grant Time Extension: Councilmember Benson asked why an extension was needed. Alex Weatherup (Assistant Director, General Services) explained that some amenities (benches, picnic tables, trees) still need installation. Grant amount unchanged ($280,000), end date extended to Sept 30, 2026. Motion approved, moved to formal session. - Member Reports: - Vice Chair Whitfield Callaway announced several upcoming events: Six Mile Street Festival (Sept 6), coffee & conversation (Sept 8), annual cookout at Palmer Park (Sept 13), community webinar (Sept 15), mandated meeting at Fellowship Chapel (Sept 23), Lunch and Learn at First Merchants Bank (Sept 17), and expungement clinic with Judge Greg Mathis (Sept 20). - Councilmember Benson thanked the senior task force for a movie day with over 600 seniors. Reminded residents about free estate planning workshops, stating the city is saving $400,000 per month in Detroit home equity through these programs, which sunset on June 30, 2026. - Councilmember Young (Chair) welcomed everyone back from August recess, noted the passing of Mr. Edward Deeb, announced the last produce pickup at Buttle on September 10, and listed recess activities including awards presented and events attended. Key Outcomes - All remaining items (5.1, 6.1, 6.3, 6.4, 6.5, 6.6, 6.7, 6.8, 6.9, 6.10, 6.11, 6.12, 6.13, 6.14, 6.15) were moved to formal session with record dates for approval. - Item 6.2 was removed from the agenda by unanimous consent. - No roll call votes were recorded; all actions were by voice vote with no objections. - The committee adjourned without objection.

The Detroit City Council Committee of the Whole met on September 4, 2025, at 6:15 PM. The meeting addressed the continued discussion on the Detroit Land Bank Authority (DLBA) Memorandum of Understanding (MOU), received 13 public comments, and considered numerous unfinished and new business items, including a controversial rezoning request for a garden center. Key votes included sending several contracts to formal session and scheduling further discussions on the MOU for September 11, 2025. Public Comments & Testimony - Tracy Peters (District 4) expressed hope for a meaningful MOU and referenced historical housing discrimination. Councilmember Johnson asked her to provide proposed language for amendments. - Tina Castleberry, owner of The Garden Bug, urged council to rezone her property at 4225 W. Davison from R3 to B2 so she could legally operate a garden center. She stated she invested $195,000 and had community support. - Leslie Robinson (Russell Woods Sullivan area) supported Ms. Castleberry and questioned why the Planning Commission denied the rezoning. - Brother Cunningham promoted his cash app and outreach work. - Ruben James Crowley Jr. accused Councilmember Tate of failing to investigate a death and made political remarks. - Miko Williams criticized Councilmember Tate for lack of public town halls on the MOU and urged slowing the process. - Betty A. Bon (Soda Ellsworth Block Association) shared information about the Choice Waiver program for seniors and disabled residents. - An unnamed caller (referencing the City Charter) argued the council gave away its property powers via the MOU. - Cindy Dara voiced concerns about trust in government and state laws. - A caller claimed 100,000 homes were illegally foreclosed and called Councilmember Tate weak. - Kathy Montgomery (attended Councilmember Waters’ town hall) demanded the DLBA contract not be renewed, citing disrespectful treatment of residents. - Margaret Manox requested ADA compliance for sidewalks. Discussion Items - Land Bank Authority MOU (Line Item 5): Councilmember Tate delivered a lengthy statement, accusing unnamed colleagues of spreading false narratives that the committee is holding up the MOU. He stated the committee had placed the MOU on the agenda multiple times, requested amendments, but lacked cooperation from sponsors to provide detailed legal language. He used the metaphor “calls coming from inside the house” and urged colleagues to work together. The MOU discussion will resume on September 11, 2025. - Garden Bug Rezoning (Line Item 7.4): Dr. Bolger (City Planning Commission) presented the CPC’s 8-0 recommendation to deny a rezoning from R3 (low-density residential) to B2 (local business) for 4213 and 4225 W. Davison. The commission found the site unsuitable due to shallow lot depth (53 ft) and safety concerns. Councilmembers questioned how the business operated for years without proper permits and zoning. Directors Bell (BSEED) and Bush (PDD) offered alternative locations and expedited permitting. Ms. Castleberry countered that she had followed city directives and created seven off-street parking spots. The item was brought back for one week. - Real Token Properties (Line Item 6.5): The committee awaited a response from the DLBA on how many properties purchased by real token LLC originated from the land bank. Attorney Anderson stated a response was received that day; the item was brought back in one week. - Michigan Land Bank Authority Oversight (Line Item 6.6): Attorney Anderson clarified that the council has no authority to compel the Michigan Land Bank Authority to provide information. The MOU discussion will include term limits for DLBA board members. - 2150 Bagley LLC Abatement Extension (Line Item 7.10): Developer Don Tapp requested a one-year construction extension (third request) for a historic building renovation. Justice Cook (HRD) supported the extension, citing ongoing construction and secured financing. The committee sent the item to formal session with a recommendation to approve. Key Outcomes - MOU Discussion: Continued to September 11, 2025. Councilmember Tate requested that colleagues provide detailed amendment language before that date. - Garden Bug Rezoning: Brought back in one week to allow further conversations between Ms. Castleberry, PDD, and the Ombudsman’s office. - Unfinished Business: - Line item 6.1 (income tax preparation) – brought back 1 week. - Line item 6.2 (ADA/bird safety) – brought back 2 weeks. - Line items 6.3, 6.4, 6.7 – received and filed. - Line item 6.5 (Real Token properties) – brought back 1 week. - Line item 6.6 – received and filed. - New Business Approved for Formal Session: - Line items 7.1, 7.2, 7.3 (ARPA and city fund contracts) – sent with recommendation to approve. - Line item 7.10 (2150 Bagley abatement extension) – sent with recommendation to approve. - New Business Brought Back: - Line items 7.4 (Garden Bug), 7.5 (DLBA quarterly report – October 2), 7.14, 7.15 – various bring-back dates. - Line items 7.13 & 7.16 (Pistons facility) – brought back 2 weeks. - Line items 7.17, 7.18, 7.19 – referred to departments with 3-week bring-back. - Public Hearing Scheduled: Line item 7.6 (CPA building historic district) – set for public hearing. - Member Reports: Vice Chair announced a retiree task force meeting on September 5; Member Johnson promoted a CDBG virtual session and a celebration for the 100th anniversary of the Dr. Sweet house (Sept 7-9).

The Budget, Finance and Audit Standing Committee of the Detroit City Council convened on September 3, 2025, to address a lengthy agenda encompassing the city's fiscal status, contract approvals, transition protocols for elected officials, and updates on ARPA funding. The meeting included significant public testimony advocating for shifts in spending priorities towards prevention and retiree relief. Consent Calendar - Approval of minutes from the prior meeting. - Received and filed a report on the fiscal impact of amendments to Chapter 31 of the City Code (Item 5.3). - Received and filed a report on the fiscal impact of amendments to Chapter 29 of the City Code (Item 6.6). Public Comments & Testimony - Ronald Foster (In-Person): Argued the city should reallocate funds from law enforcement and corporate counsel to preventive community measures. He stated that 20 to 40 children were shot and killed in the city over the summer, primarily in parks, and criticized city leadership for dismissing community advocacy. - William M. Davis (Virtual): Invited the public to the City Retiree Task Force meeting and his Detroit Active Retired Employee Association meeting. He argued that retirees bore the brunt of the city's financial recovery, citing a combined 23% reduction in pension and annuity clawbacks, and called on the city to retroactively eliminate clawback interest. - Betty A. Varner (Virtual): President of the Soda Ellsworth Block Association, reported the purchase of lots to expand the neighborhood park and requested donations for landscaping boulders. - Cunningham (Virtual): Thanked donors for supporting his community efforts with bus tickets and ice water. He requested the Mayor provide longer notice for meetings and acknowledged the addition of a voicemail to the Mayor's office phone line. - Not That Karen (Virtual): Expressed support for Mr. Davis's statements on retiree struggles and raised concerns about the lack of documentation proving her property lies in an enterprise zone, which she believes should reduce her taxes. - Carolyn Hughes (Virtual): Echoed prior commenters on retiree issues and police spending. She criticized the approval of items with negative fiscal impacts, warning such actions could lead the city back toward bankruptcy. Discussion Items - 5.1 ARPA Compliance Contract (AECOM): The committee reviewed a $3.8 million amendment to a $21.8 million contract to ensure compliance and audit readiness for ARPA funds. Deputy CFO Terry Daniels stated the cost is under 3% of total ARPA funds and is crucial to avoid repaying funds. The item was sent to formal session for approval. - 5.2 Fiscal Impact of the 'Big Beautiful Bill': Introduced by Council Member Mary Waters, LPD requested an additional month to analyze the fiscal impact and coordinate with the OCFO. - 5.4 Detroit Public Library Foundation Information: LPD reported the foundation is involved in a legal matter and requested two weeks to obtain more information from the library's CFO. - 6.1 & 6.2 Auditing Services Contracts (Plante Moran): Two contracts were approved for the Auditor General ($9.2 million) and the OCFO ($370,000) to provide auditing services and prepare the Comprehensive Annual Financial Report (CAFR) over five years. Deputy Auditor General Mark Lockridge noted the contracts were put out for bid for the first time in 10 years. - 6.3 Financial Report for Fiscal Year 2025 (June YTD): Acting Budget Director Donnie Johnson presented a preliminary unaudited report showing an estimated $60.2 million surplus in the unassigned fund balance, driven by $69.1 million in underexpenditures against a $7 million revenue shortfall. Council Member Corley questioned surpluses in specific expense categories (professional services, operating supplies, and other expenses). Johnson and Deputy CFO Regina Greer explained that the underspends are largely due to the timing of invoices and year-end accruals. The item was brought back for one week. - 6.4 Large Events Report (Q4 FY25): Deputy CFO Regina Greer reported combined special events revenue of $735,913 for Q4 and $2.66 million for the fiscal year. Chair Payne expressed interest in exploring revenue generation for the Fire Department and EMS through a right of first refusal on event services. - 6.5 Elected Officials Office Budget Resolution: A resolution to place 50% of elected official office budgets into a lockbox to preserve funds for incoming officials was discussed. Chair Payne voiced support but requested detailed expenditure projections for each office before voting, citing concerns about staffing reductions during the transition. Council Member Santiago Romero raised the question of how the Council President's larger budget would be handled. The item was brought back in two weeks. - 6.7 Status of Legislative Policy Resolutions: LPD requested time to prepare a PowerPoint on the status of financial and budgetary priority resolutions (2024–2026). The item was brought back in two weeks. - 6.8 – 6.13 ARPA Fund Status Reports: A series of monthly ARPA reports were discussed. Council Member Corley requested the addition of the January 2024 report and asked for the entire package to be brought back in one week. Key Outcomes - Item 5.1: Sent to formal session with a recommendation to approve. - Item 5.2: Referred to LPD and OCFO; due back in one month. - Item 5.4: Brought back in two weeks. - Items 6.1 & 6.2: Sent to formal session with a recommendation to approve. - Item 6.3: Brought back in one week for further analysis on expenditure surpluses. - Item 6.4: Received and filed. - Item 6.5: Brought back in two weeks with a request for individual office budget breakdowns. - Item 6.7: Brought back in two weeks. - Items 6.8 – 6.13: Brought back in one week.

The Detroit City Council Committee of the Whole met on September 3, 2025, to hear public comments, conduct interviews for the Brownfield Redevelopment Citizens Advisory Council (CAC), discuss contracts for audiovisual production services, and consider multiple settlement agreements and other routine matters. The meeting began with public comment limited to two minutes per speaker, with nine virtual participants. Notable discussions centered on bus service improvements, retiree concerns, solar takings, and equity in media coverage. Public Comments & Testimony - Miko A. Williams thanked Detroit for recent voter turnout, expressed support for justice and democracy, and called for liberation of the city from control by the rich and white. - Sean Help Cunningham requested cleaner bus stops, benches for elderly riders, and better on-time performance. Councilmember Mary Waters agreed and noted the need for trash cans at stops. - Cunningham (second caller) reported that residents feel council does not care about bus services; urged council to improve transit and provided his community hotline number. - Not That Karen spoke on behalf of retirees, noting no cost-of-living adjustment in 12 years, and requested elimination of the clawback and equal treatment with public safety retirees. Also complained about an overgrown city parking lot on West McNichols and asked for blue recycle bins. Councilmember Angela Winfo Callaway responded that $500,000 was secured in the budget for recycle bins. - William M. Davis agreed with retiree concerns, criticized the city for not renegotiating bankruptcy-era deals (Great Lakes Water Authority, Bell Lao), and called for better stewardship. - You Matter criticized the city’s handling of solar takings, alleged conflict of interest involving Byron Osburn serving on both the Board of Zoning Appeals and Community Advisory Council, and demanded better oversight of Detroit Police body cameras and building cameras. - Tyson Gersh argued that the city does not need certified court reporters at zoning hearings; municipalities record and post online. He questioned why appellants must pay nearly $5,000 for transcripts to challenge decisions. - Mr. Ronald Foster urged council to protect free speech and stop retaliating against critics, and called for transparency regarding lobbyists and dark money in public comment. Discussion Items - Brownfield Redevelopment CAC Reappointments (Line Items 5 & 6): Interviews were conducted with Marlo Sean Franklin and George Etheridge. Franklin highlighted his 75% attendance and focus on community engagement. Etheridge noted 99% attendance, discussed his experience as a former council policy analyst, and emphasized the need for community voice in brownfield developments. Councilmember Callaway requested that the Law Department and Legislative Policy Division explore establishing a brownfield district in the James Cousins area to revitalize vacant properties. - AV Production Services Contracts (Line Items 7.1–7.4): Communications Director Vicky Thomas and Media Services Admin Director Myesha Crawford presented a tiered approach to split a previous single contract into four tiers to include smaller Detroit-based companies. Contracts: Mish Brew Multimedia ($250,000), Good Boy Records ($90,000), SR Audio ($134,000), and Creative Day ($502,000, two-year total). Councilmembers raised concerns that Creative Day, based in Troy, Michigan, receives the lion’s share, and questioned whether mileage fees are included. Councilmember Callaway and Councilmember Johnson expressed frustration that Media Services prioritizes the Mayor over council events, citing several instances of inadequate coverage (e.g., summer sizzler, band shell reveal, MGM event). Thomas responded that her goal is equitable coverage and committed to improving. A motion to approve all four contracts passed without objection. - Settlement for Dorothy McGillrath & Diane Davis (Line Item 7.8): Councilmember Callaway asked whether the employee who caused the accident was disciplined or still driving. Law Department did not have the answer; the item was brought back in one week. - Other Settlements (Line Items 7.9, 8.1–8.11): Multiple settlement requests were approved or brought back for questions. Notable: 7.9 ($80,000, DPW) approved after clarification that e-scooters are allowed on sidewalks; 8.1 corrected to $1,551,320 for legal representation; 8.3 and 8.4 (DDOT) held for questions; 8.5 (police) held; others approved. - Appointment to Detroit Wayne Joint Building Authority (Line Item 7.5): Councilmember Letitia Johnson’s reappointment of Byron Osburn was approved after receiving favorable legal opinion. - Unmanned Aerial Systems Contract (Line Item 7.6): Three-year contract with Airspace Link for $397,803 approved. - Debarment Ordinance (Line Item 7.19): Motion to bring back in one month. Key Outcomes - Approved by motion (sent to formal): Line items 7.1–7.4 (AV production contracts), 7.5 (Byron Osburn appointment), 7.6 (drone contract), 7.9 (settlement $80,000), 8.1 (legal representation contract, as amended), 8.2 (settlement $75,000), 8.6–8.11 (settlements ranging $10,000–$325,000), 8.14 (medical/dental/vision rates resolution), and 8.15 (supervisors labor agreement resolution). - Brought back for future dates: Line items 5 and 6 (Brownfield reappointments – date to be determined), 7.8 (settlement – one week), 8.3 ($43,500 – one week), 8.4 ($295,000 – one week), 8.5 ($44,000 – one week), 7.10 and 7.12–7.18 (closed session – date to be determined), 7.19 (debarment ordinance – one month). - Received and filed: Line items 7.7 (legal opinion on multiple board service), 7.11 (memo on independent legal counsel), 7.20 (tax abatements for urban agriculture), 8.12 (Board of Ethics report), 8.13 (campaign contribution disclosures), 8.16 (ombudsman interview list). - New business: Councilmember Callaway established a motion to direct LPD and Law Department to investigate a brownfield district for the James Cousins corridor. The motion passed without objection. - Member reports: Councilmember Johnson announced a skilled trade task force meeting on September 17. Councilmember Callaway reported several upcoming district events and raised a formal complaint about a district manager pre-announcing a street name change without council approval.