The Metropolitan Development Commission met on March 15, 2023, at 6:00 PM. The meeting included public bid openings, several unanimous approvals of resolutions, and contested public hearings on two rezoning petitions. New commissioner Michael James was welcomed. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: The minutes of the March 1, 2023 meeting were approved 7-0 with one recusal (Commissioner Robinson absent). - Public Bid Opening for Union Station Management: Two bids were received—from JL and Kinmar—and referred to staff for evaluation and recommendation. - Real Estate Resolution 2023 R005: Approved 6-0, transferring 3950 Meadows to HHC for government use. - City Market Redevelopment Areas (2023 E01 and 2023 E012): Two confirmatory resolutions creating the City Market North and East allocation areas and authorizing a pledge of tax increment for bonds were both approved 8-0 (with one recusal on E012). - Final Economic Revitalization Area Resolution 2023 A014 (Gershman Partners): Approved 7-0 with one recusal for an expanded mixed-use project in Broad Ripple. - Groundwater Protection Fund Resolutions (2023 P009 and P008): Both approved 8-0, establishing a $275,000 budget and authorizing assessment of water supply systems to fund the program. - Zoning Code Amendment 2023 A001: Approved 8-0 after a presentation by Shannon Norman. The amendment includes technical corrections, adds parks and playgrounds as permitted uses in all districts, clarifies mixed-use plan requirements, and limits commercial parking lots to two acres with a special exception requirement. The amendment proceeds to the City-County Council. Public Comments & Testimony - Decatur Township Civic Council (2022 ZON 112): Pat Andrews expressed support for the amended rezoning, stating the change to allow residential development meets community needs and that the previous commercial plan had not materialized. She noted the civic council voted 22-2 in favor. - Councillor Bain (2022 ZON 112): Did not formally remonstrate but expressed concern that the project falls short of the potential for a first-class development on a major corridor. He highlighted that neighbors supported the plan partly out of fear of warehouses, and argued the land was not properly marketed for commercial use. - Remonstrator Chuck Gray (2023 ZON 005): Adjacent business owner at 1351 DeLaw Street, opposed rezoning from I2 to D8 for a single-family home. He argued the change would limit his future ability to expand his industrial business due to a required 30-foot transitional yard, and cited parking and noise concerns. He noted the lot had been industrial for decades and that he purchased the property relying on the industrial zoning. Discussion Items - Continuance Requests: - 2022 CZN/CVR 872 (remonstrator’s attorney absent): Granted to May 3, 2023, over the petitioner’s objection, as remonstrators were present and had requested the delay. Vote 8-0. - 2022 ZON 051 (Southeastern Ave): Petitioner and remonstrators jointly requested continuance to June 21, 2023, citing ongoing negotiations. Granted 8-0. - 2023 C VR 800B (834 E. 64th St): Petitioner requested continuance to April 5, 2023, to submit a revised site plan. Granted 8-0. - Multiple petitions of no appeal (2023 MOD 002, 2023 ZON 003, 2022 MOD 021) were continued to April 5, 2023, pending executed commitments. Approved 8-0 or 7-0 with one recusal. - 2022 ZON 112 (Camby Village LLC): Petitioner Brian Tuey presented a reduced rezoning of 58.5 acres from C4 to C5, removing an industrial component and adding 133 single-family homes, 52 paired patio homes, and two acres of restricted commercial. The Decatur Township Civic Council supported the plan. A staff recommendation for approval noted consistency with the 2018 comprehensive plan. After discussion, the vote was 7-1 in favor, with one commissioner dissenting due to concerns about giving up commercial frontage along a major highway. - 2023 ZON 005 (1405 DeLaw Street): Petitioner Peter Gundy sought rezoning of a 0.08-acre lot from I2 to D8 to build a single-family home. Staff supported the rezoning, noting the lot historically contained a home for over a century and that the comprehensive plan recommends residential use. Remonstrator Chuck Gray opposed, citing impacts on his adjacent industrial business. During deliberation, Commissioner Westrick suggested exploring a preemptive variance for the transitional yard, but the petitioner and remonstrator did not reach an agreement. The petition passed 5-3. Key Outcomes - Approved Resolutions: All resolutions on the consent calendar and those voted on after public hearings (2023 R005, 2023 E01, 2023 E012, 2023 A014, 2023 P009, 2023 P008, 2023 A001) passed unanimously or with minimal recusals. - Continuances Granted: Four continuances were approved as detailed above. - 2022 ZON 112 Approved: 7-1, allowing residential development with reduced commercial on 58.5 acres in Decatur Township. - 2023 ZON 005 Approved: 5-3, permitting a single-family home on a formerly industrial lot in Center Township, with staff clarifying that the adjacent business’s current use is grandfathered but future expansion may be limited by a 30-foot transitional yard. - Meeting Adjourned: The meeting concluded at approximately 8:30 PM, with staff directed to continue developing a process for combined variance requests (as discussed in the 2023 ZON 005 hearing).
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaThis public hearing of the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 was held on March 14, 2023, at 18:15 UTC, chaired by Vice Chairperson James Duke. Board members present included Patricia Ducket Brown, Beth Brandon, Tom Barnes, and alternate Aaron McBride. The meeting addressed three petitions: one expedited parking variance, two continuance requests, and two contested variance petitions. Decisions were made on all items. Consent Calendar - Expedited Docket (2023 DV202149): A variance of development standards to allow a detached garage at 2149 Olive Street with reduced side yard setbacks and encroachment into the clear sight triangle. The petition was approved unanimously (5-0) without further testimony. Public Comments & Testimony - 2022 DVD 2047 (2302 West 60th Street): The Crooked Creek Land Use Committee, represented by Carrie Michael Manders, opposed the petition for a 15-foot pole barn behind a house. Manders argued the petitioner lacked transparency, had previously stored commercial vehicles illegally on site (confirmed by staff photos), and expressed concern that commitments would not be honored based on past enforcement failures. The petitioner, Jimmy Laments of In and Out Unlimited LLC, countered that the owner owns multiple parcels, the barn is for personal storage of a boat, motorcycles, and vehicles, and that the request had been reduced from 18 feet to 15 feet. Manders also requested a two-month continuance due to surgery, but only a one-month continuance was granted. - 2023 DVD 2001 (801 Shelby Street): Multiple remonstrators spoke in opposition, including Anson Keller (1111 Lexington Ave), Liz Sutton (1111 Lexington Ave), Robert Drew (1115 Lexington Ave), and Deborah Millot (1132 Lexington Ave). They raised concerns about: (1) the church having been built in 1925, not 1915 (post-zoning), undermining staff’s basis for recommending approval; (2) severe parking deficits (75% deficiency after reductions) leading to safety hazards; (3) residents already having difficulty parking due to nearby business events; (4) ADA compliance issues; and (5) the proposed off-site parking agreement with Calvary Church being too far (700+ feet) and unlikely to be used based on past behavior. A letter of support from City-County Council Vice President Zach Adamson was noted. Discussion Items - Continuance Request 2022 UV 3022 (830 River Avenue): Petitioner requested a two-month continuance to May 16th (later clarified to April 11th) to provide amended plans; no neighborhood objection. Board approved unanimously. - Automatic Continuance 2023-32-003 (2231 Wellington Road): A timely filed automatic continuance was acknowledged, moving the case to April 11th (Division 2). Board acknowledged. - 2022 DVD 2047: The petitioner sought a variance to build a 15-foot-tall pole barn on a property where the primary building is 14.25 feet tall (variance of 9 inches). Staff recommended approval with a commitment that no commercial vehicles be stored on site. Petitioner agreed. Board voted 4-1 in favor (Barnes opposed). - 2023 DVD 2001: The petitioner (RCA Properties/Switchboard) sought a variance to use a former church (15,000 sq ft) as office space with only 8 on-street parking spaces (27 required after reductions, but staff noted the use is less parking-intensive than the previous church use). Petitioner had a five-year parking agreement for 20 spaces at Calvary Church two blocks north. Staff recommended approval, highlighting the site’s C5 zoning and transit-oriented development area. Remonstrators presented evidence that the building dated to 1925 (not 1915), and that the parking reduction was unprecedented. Board voted 3-2 to approve (Barnes and Ducket Brown opposed; Duke, McBride, Brandon in favor). Key Outcomes - Continuances: Both continuance requests were granted: 2022 UV 3022 continued to April 11, 2023 (without additional notice); 2023-32-003 continued to April 11, 2023 via automatic continuance. - Expedited Petition (2023 DV202149): Approved unanimously (5-0). - 2022 DVD 2047 (pole barn): Approved with a commitment of no commercial vehicle storage. Vote: 4-1 (Duke, Ducket Brown, McBride, Brandon yes; Barnes no). - 2023 DVD 2001 (parking variance): Approved with the condition that the petitioner install 10 additional bicycle parking spaces to qualify for the 35% parking reduction. Vote: 3-2 (Duke, McBride, Brandon yes; Barnes, Ducket Brown no).
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 met on March 7, 2023, at 6:15 p.m. to hear a variety of variance petitions, including requests for continuances, expedited items, and full hearings on sidewalk cafes, garage access, accessory structures, and commercial development. Acting Chair Peter Nelson presided, joined by board members David Duncan, Andrew Catona, Jennifer Witt, and Anthony Bridgman (late). Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were present. The meeting lasted over three hours and included extensive public testimony, staff recommendations, and board votes. Consent Calendar (Expedited Actions) - 2022-UV1-035 (Exotic Metal Treatment, 6234 E. Hannah Ave.): Withdrawal of sidewalk waiver acknowledged; moved to expedited and approved unanimously (5-0) with amended findings. - 2023-DV1005 (3100 N. Meridian St.): Two-day waiver of mail notice granted; moved to expedited and approved unanimously (5-0). - 2023-DV1007 (3651 Five Points Rd.): Agreed to staff conditions; moved to expedited and approved unanimously (5-0). Public Comments & Testimony - On continuance of 2023-UV1-004 (Speedway Inc.): Lisa Bentley (Indy Gateway) and Clarence Ward (neighbor) opposed the continuance, citing property in disarray, illegal business operation, and neighborhood nuisance. Leanne Johnson also opposed, raising trash and hazardous tree concerns. - On 2022-DV1063 (Patachou, 4901 N. Pennsylvania St.): - Support: Emma Klust (Meridian Kessler Neighborhood Association) spoke in favor, calling the project an asset to the community. - Opposition: Paula Light (4812 N. Pennsylvania St.) argued the expansion violates 2009 conditions, creates parking deficits, and contradicts the 2016 Meridian Kessler Plan. Pat Andrews (Marion County Alliance of Neighborhood Associations) noted discrepancies in the site plan and claimed the effective sidewalk would be reduced to 36 inches, violating safety standards. Terry Sanderson (4601 N. Pennsylvania St.) listed past violations and argued the proposal is inconsistent with the neighborhood plan. - On 2023-DV1003 (Paul Brannen, 8838 W. 21st St.): Lisa Bentley (Indy Gateway) expressed concern about potential commercial use and heavy equipment, but acknowledged commitments to prohibit such use. - On 2023-DV1008 (Starbucks/DRGSF surplus, 8144 E. Southport Rd.): No public opposition was voiced; only petitioner testimony was heard. Discussion Items 1. 2022-DV1063 – Patachou Sidewalk Cafe Expansion - Petitioner (Jonathan Hughes, attorney): Sought to expand outdoor cafe from 777 to 1,142 sq. ft. and add a permanent awning along 49th Street. The site has existing trees, utility poles, and an 18-ft sidewalk. The proposal includes removing tall planters that obstructed pedestrian paths and maintaining a 5-ft clearance. Support from Meridian Kessler NA and Meridian Street Preservation Commission (7-0). Staff recommended approval, noting the use is appropriate for the area and the awning is not an enclosure. Opponents argued parking deficits, violation history, and that the plan reduces pedestrian space. The board heard rebuttals and approved 5-0. 2. 2022-DV1057B – Brandy Wadi Garage Access (4001 N. Park Ave.) - Petitioner (Brandy Wadi): Requested a variance to use a driveway off 40th Street instead of the alley for an existing detached garage. Petitioner stated the alley is narrow and has retaining walls, and many neighbors have similar driveways. Opposition from Meridian Kessler NA (unanimous), citing removal of street trees and inconsistency with neighborhood design. Staff recommended denial, noting the alley is in good condition and the driveway was installed without a permit. The board voted 4-1 to deny (Jennifer Witt voted yes). 3. 2023-DV1003 – Paul Brannen Accessory Structure (8838 W. 21st St.) - Petitioner (Joe Calderon, attorney): Requested a variance to build a 3,456-sq-ft accessory building (hobby shop) on a 3.4-acre lot because its footprint exceeds the primary dwelling’s footprint (2,913 sq. ft.), violating ordinance. Petitioner argued the structure is subordinate in use and the lot has 96% open space. Staff opposed, stating the ordinance requires the accessory footprint to be smaller to maintain the dominance of the primary dwelling, and that multiple smaller buildings could serve the same purpose. The board approved 5-0 with added commitments: no commercial use, no heavy equipment, and setbacks as shown on the site plan (to be recorded). 4. 2023-DV1008 – Starbucks/Three-Tenant Outlot (8144 E. Southport Rd.) - Petitioner (Russell Brown, attorney): Variances needed for three items: (a) a third freestanding sign (260 ft from existing sign, required 300 ft), (b) 51 parking spaces (max 43), (c) drive-through stacking in the front yard (one car) and no bypass aisle. Petitioner argued the site is car-dependent, no public transit nearby, and Starbucks corporate standards require the layout. Support from Franklin Township Civic League. Staff recommended denial, stating variances are self-imposed, the sign can be relocated, shared parking exists, and a bypass aisle is needed for emergencies and customer convenience. After discussion, the board approved 3-2 (Duncan, Witt, Bridgman yes; Catona, Nelson no) with the condition that a revised site plan including an exit point from the stacking lane be submitted for staff approval. Key Outcomes - Approved unanimously (5-0): 2022-UV1-035, 2023-DV1005, 2023-DV1007 (expedited); 2022-DV1063 (Patachou); 2023-DV1003 (Brannen accessory building). - Denied 4-1: 2022-DV1057B (Brandy Wadi garage access). - Approved 3-2 with condition: 2023-DV1008 (Starbucks outlot) – requiring revised site plan with bypass exit. - Continuances granted: 2022-SE1001 (to April 4, no new notice); 2022-SC1002 (to April 4, with new notice); 2022-DV2045 (to April 4, final staff-supported continuance); 2022-DV1062 (to April 4, with new notice); 2023-UV1-006 (automatic continuance acknowledged). - Withdrawals: 2023-UV1-004 (Speedway) withdrawn by petitioner before hearing; 2023-DV1008 part B (parking space size) withdrawn. - Elected officers: Peter Nelson as Chair, David Duncan as Vice Chair, Jennifer Witt as Secretary.
The Metropolitan Development Commission held a public meeting on March 1, 2023, beginning at 6:15 PM. The commission addressed several resolutions for tax abatements, waivers, and economic development projects, as well as continuances and withdrawals of petitions. All votes were unanimous (7-0) unless otherwise noted. Commissioner Karina Bruns participated in her final meeting before departing due to work commitments. Consent Calendar - Approval of the minutes from the February 15, 2023 Commission meeting was moved and seconded, passing unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public provided testimony or comments during the meeting. Only project sponsors, developers, and city staff spoke on agenda items. Discussion Items - Resolution 2023 A009: Waiver of 2022 and 2023 deduction application filing deadlines for tax abatement at 1411 Roosevelt Avenue. Ryan Hunt (DMD) explained that the 2022 filing was late and the waiver covers both years. The project remains in compliance. Rob Corr, representing the developer, acknowledged the missed deadline and thanked the commission. Approved 7-0. - Resolution 2023 A010: Final economic revitalization area for Reyes Holdings LLC/Monarch Distributing at 430 Fintel Drive (real property, 5-year abatement). Ryan Hunt noted the project supports relocation within Marion County and retention of employees, with the site being a former Ford/Vistean brownfield. Mike Scully, Director of Operations for Monarch, testified. Approved 7-0. - Resolution 2023 A011: Final economic revitalization area for Reyes Holdings LLC/Monarch Distributing (personal property, 5-year abatement). Related to A010, approved 7-0. - Resolution 2023 A012: Final economic revitalization area for Lord Corporation at 10401 East 59th Street (personal property, 6-year abatement). Previously presented, it preserves 102 jobs and adds 60. Already approved by Lawrence Common Council. Approved 7-0. - Resolution 2023 A013: Final economic revitalization area for Hall Place Apartments LLC at 1720-1744 North Illinois Street (real property, 10-year abatement). The project includes 15% of units (41 units) set aside as affordable for 15 years, five years beyond the abatement. The site is owned by IU Health and supports their campus expansion. Approved 7-0. - Resolution 2023 C001: Authorizes an agreement with community builders for a 56-unit low-income housing development (including 14 permanent supportive housing units) using up to $700,000 from the Indianapolis Housing Trust Fund. Approved 7-0. - Resolution 2023 P007: Appointment of hearing officer. Approved 7-0. Key Outcomes - All resolutions (A009, A010, A011, A012, A013, C001, P007) passed with 7-0 votes. - Continuances granted: - Case 2022 ZON 112 (77-25 Kentucky Avenue) continued to March 15, 2023, after the petitioner amended the plan to remove industrial rezoning and received 22-2 support from the Decatur Township Civic Council. - Case 2022 MOD 009 (25 McLean Place) continued to March 15, 2023, with staff noting it was the first continuance request. - Case 2023 C VR 800B (834 East 64th Street) continued to March 15, 2023, due to late filing of an amended site plan. - Case 2023 ZON003 (758 North Concord Street) continued to March 15, 2023, pending receipt of commitments. - Withdrawals: - Case 2022 ZON 119 (Hillsdale School) withdrawn; the entity decided to pursue a location in Hamilton County. - Case 2022 REG 077 (902-922 North Capital Avenue) withdrawn at petitioner's request. - Petitions of no appeal: Several petitions approved, including: - 2022 ZON069 (3737 East Washington Street) passed 5-0-2 (Commissioner Westrick and Dillon recused). - 2022 REG080 (1740 West Michigan Street) passed 6-0-1 (Commissioner Westrick recused). - Six other petitions (2022 MOD023, 2022 REG079, 2023 REG001, 2022 ZON071, 2022 ZON091, 2022 ZON128) passed 7-0. - Petition recommended for denial: 2023 ZON002 (3401 North Emerson Avenue) denied by hearing officer; commission confirmed denial 7-0. - Meeting adjourned after farewell to Commissioner Bruns.
On February 21, 2023 at 6:15 PM, the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III convened a public hearing chaired by Joanna Taft, with board members Paula Rivera and Jennifer Witt. Legal Counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were present. The board considered multiple variance and special exception requests, including expedited approvals and a full hearing for a property at 6039 South Harding Street. Consent Calendar - Expedited Requests Granted: The board approved moving the following cases to the expedited docket: 2023 DV3001 (5505 and 5855 Brookville Road), 2023 DV3004 (10220 East Washington Street), 2022 DV3056 amended (4411 East Thompson Road, with commitment to remove storage shed within six months), and 2022 UV3037 (1410 East Epler Avenue, with commitments agreed). - Continuances Granted: The board granted continuances to the March 21, 2023 hearing for: 2022 UV3039, 2023 UB304, and 2022 DV3046 (1321 Sturm Avenue, with withdrawal of part A and noted as last continuance). Automatic continuances filed by registered neighborhood organizations were acknowledged for: 2023-DV3-005 (7548 East Washington Street), 2023-UV3-003 (3146 and 3202 Arbor Street), 2023-DB3-003 (1739 and 1795 North Shadeland Avenue), and 2023-DV3-002 (3620 Southeast Street). - Withdrawal Acknowledged: Petition 2022 DV3049 (2315 North Spencer Avenue) was withdrawn. - Expedited Docket Approval: By unanimous vote, the board approved all six petitions on the expedited docket subject to conditions and commitments: 2023 SE3001 (7201 Pendleton Pike, extra large retail sales and service facility special exception), 2023 UV3002 (5825 East 38th Street, boxing gym variance of use), 2023 DV3001 (Brookville Road, variance for parking and loading areas), 2023 DV3004 (East Washington Street, variance for integrated center with drive-through), 2022 DV3056 amended (East Thompson Road, variance for detached garage height), and 2022 UV3037 (East Epler Avenue, variance for union training facility). Public Comments & Testimony - Linda Waits (petitioner and co-owner of 6039 South Harding Street) testified in support of the variance. She explained that the carport and mini barn were placed on an existing concrete pad to protect vehicles, that the property is in a flood zone and has a septic system limiting backyard use, and that they are willing to lower the carport height below the house roofline. - David Freeman (remonstrator, owner of commercial properties at 1502 and 1540 West Edgewood) spoke in opposition. He expressed concern that the violations and appearance of the structures would negatively impact property values in the area and set a bad precedent. He suggested that removal or relocation of the carport and recreational vehicle would be a compromise. Discussion Items - Case 2023 DV3006 (6039 South Harding Street): The board heard a variance of development standards request for a carport taller than the primary building and a mini barn located in the front yard, among other violations. Staff recommended denial, stating that the practical difficulties are self-imposed and that the backyard could accommodate the structures. The petitioner argued that the backyard is constrained by a septic system and flood zone. The remonstrator reiterated concerns. During deliberation, board members discussed the possibility of compromise. The petitioner offered to lower the carport height. Key Outcomes - Expedited Petitions Approved: All six expedited petitions were approved unanimously with conditions. - Case 2023 DV3006 Continued: The board vote resulted in one yes (Witt) and two no votes (Taft and Rivera). Because a unanimous vote is required for a three-member board, the petition was automatically continued to the March 21, 2023 hearing without additional notice. The board encouraged the petitioner to work with staff and the remonstrator before the next hearing. - Continuances and Withdrawals: Several cases were continued or withdrawn as listed in the Consent Calendar.
On February 15, 2023, the Indianapolis Metropolitan Development Commission held a public meeting with a quorum of five commissioners. The meeting included the election of an acting secretary, approval of prior minutes, consideration of seven resolutions (real estate and economic development), and action on several planning petitions. Key actions included approval of tax abatements for a beverage distributor, continuances for zoning cases, and a recusal-driven deferral. Consent Calendar - Commission voted to appoint Commissioner Garver as acting secretary (moved by Commissioner Blackburn, seconded by Commissioner Ash, all ayes). - Minutes from the February 1, 2023 meeting were approved unanimously (motion by Commissioner Garver, second by Commissioner Ash). Discussion Items - Real Estate Resolutions (2023 R004, R005, R006): Authorized: (1) extension and funding for renovating Greyhound/Amtrak restrooms at Union Station; (2) amendment to joint services agreement for placemaking at Luger Plaza, Georgia Street, and city-owned portions of the downtown canal (additional $215,000, with $175,000 from DPW); (3) amendment to joint services agreement for placemaking at Monument Circle (additional $175,000 from DPW). - Economic Development Resolutions (2023 A005–A008): (1) Preliminary economic revitalization area and five-year real property tax abatement for Reyes Holdings LLC (Monarch Distributing) at 430 Thin Tail Drive (formerly 6900 English Avenue), creating/retaining 500+ jobs (200 in Marion County). (2) Similar five-year personal property tax abatement for Reyes Holdings. (3) Six-year personal property tax abatement for Lord Corporation at 10401 East 59th Street. (4) Ten-year real property tax abatement for Hall Place Apartments LLC at 1720–1744 North Illinois Street and 1715 Hall Place. - Petitions and Continuances: - 2022 MOD 023 (5340 Sean Hour Road) continued to March 1, 2023 due to pending commitments. - 2022 ZON 091 (3510 Division Street) continued to March 1, 2023 for revised site plan. - 2022 ZON 112 (7305 and 7725 Kentucky Avenue) continued to March 1, 2023 at petitioner’s request for further discussion with Councilor Bain. - 2022 ZON 069 (3737 East Washington Street) — Commissioner Westrick recused herself, reducing quorum to three, so item automatically continued to March 1, 2023. - Petition Approved: 2022 CZN 861 (4016 East 82nd Street) passed 4-0 (Commissioner Westrick recused), with unanimous ayes from the remaining four commissioners. Key Outcomes - All seven resolutions (R004, R005, R006, A005, A006, A007, A008) passed 5-0. - Three continuances (MOD 023, ZON 091, ZON 112) granted 5-0 to March 1, 2023. - ZON 069 automatically continued to March 1, 2023 due to insufficient quorum after recusal. - CZN 861 approved 4-0. - Meeting adjourned.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II convened on Tuesday, February 14, 2023, at 1:00 PM local time (18:15 UTC) in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen presided over the meeting with members James Duke, Patrice Ducett Brown, Beth Brandon, and Tom Barnes. Legal counsel was Chris Steinmetz, and staff from the Division of Planning supported the proceedings. The board addressed continuances, expedited petitions, and two public hearings, culminating in approvals for both contested variances. Continuances and Procedural Matters - Case 2022-DV2-047 (2304 and 2302 West 60th Street): An automatic continuance requested by a registered neighborhood organization was acknowledged, moving the hearing to March 14, 2023. - Case 2023-DV2-001 (801 Shelby Street): An automatic continuance was acknowledged, also continuing the matter to March 14, 2023. - Case 2022-UV2-030 (2307 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Street): The board granted a one-day waiver of the public notice requirement (5-0 vote), allowing the petition to be heard that day. - Case 2022-UV2-029 (1645 East Minnesota Street): The board granted a one-day waiver of the public notice requirement (5-0 vote) to hear the petition. Expedited Petitions Two petitions were considered under the expedited docket after a waiver of standard procedures (unanimously approved): - 2022-UV2-027 (Amended) (3445 Washington Boulevard): Requested a variance of use and development standards for a mixed-use development—a 3,580-square-foot dwelling unit, 6,410 square feet of office, and a 1,810-square-foot basement dwelling unit with 13 parking spaces (23 required). - 2022-UV2-029 (1645 East Minnesota Street): Requested a variance of use to legally establish an existing single-family dwelling and accessory structure with a seven-foot rear setback (eight feet required). - Both petitions were approved unanimously (5 yes votes each). The second petition was continued for submission of revised findings of fact. Public Hearings Case 2022-DV2-048 – 3815 River Crossing Parkway (Skyline Sign Variance) - Petitioner: ASAP Permits (Brent Bennett) on behalf of Sanctuary Wealth, a wealth management firm relocating from Hamilton County to Marion County. They sought a second skyline sign on the northern elevation (one permitted per elevation). The sign would replace a previous tenant’s sign on the same facade, facing I-465 (over 200,000 vehicles per day). - Arguments: Sanctuary Wealth plans a $1.7 million investment in the space; the building owner (Felton Properties) purchased the property for $35 million and will invest an additional $3 million in upgrades. The northern elevation provides critical visibility, and signs at lower elevations would be obscured by a tree line. Denial would harm a growing local business and reduce property values. - Staff Recommendation: Denial. Staff noted that the 2019 ordinance limits skyline signs to one per facade to prevent visual clutter. The tenant could install a sign below 26 feet without a variance, and the building already has a freestanding sign with tenant identification. Other tenants operate without skyline signage. - Board Deliberation: Members questioned the removal of the previous sign and whether that forfeited grandfathered status. Board member Barnes expressed concern that the city’s position seemed punitive. - Rebuttal: Petitioners emphasized that visibility at 26 feet is obstructed by highway landscaping and a parking garage, making the high elevation essential. - Vote: 4 yes (Duke, Brandon, Ducett Brown, Von Dalen), 1 no (Barnes). Approved, continued for adoption of findings of fact. Case 2022-UV2-030 – 2307 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Street (Single-Family Dwelling on C1 Lot) - Petitioner: Flanner House Inc. (Brent Lyle) requested a variance of use to construct a single-family dwelling on a C1 (commercial) lot, with a 1.5-foot front setback (10 feet required). The home was already manufactured and awaiting placement. - Arguments: The site and surrounding area are historically residential. Flanner House has secured nearly $1 million in federal grants (including crime prevention funds) tied to this development. Delays hinder neighborhood revitalization efforts. A letter from City-County Council President Vop Osili supported the variance. - Staff Recommendation: Denial of the use variance; staff advised the petitioner to file a rezoning to D-8 (residential) instead. Staff acknowledged the setback variance was acceptable but argued the use change should follow the rezoning process, similar to a nearby parcel rezoned in 2019. - Board Deliberation: Members discussed the legacy C1 zoning, the “sawtooth” effect of piecemeal rezoning, and the comprehensive plan’s support for residential use on the corridor. Board member Duke recused himself, leaving four voting members. - Rebuttal: Petitioner emphasized the building is already paid for and federal funds are at risk, urging approval to avoid bureaucratic delays. - Vote: 3 yes (Brandon, Ducett Brown, Von Dalen), 1 no (Barnes). Approved, continued for adoption of findings of fact. Key Outcomes - Continuances: Two cases continued to March 14, 2023. - Waivers Granted: Two one-day waivers for public notice (unanimous). - Expedited Petitions: Both approved (5-0); one continued for findings of fact. - Skyline Sign Variance (2022-DV2-048): Approved 4-1; continued for findings of fact. - Single-Family Dwelling Variance (2022-UV2-030): Approved 3-1; continued for findings of fact. - Officer Elections: The board unanimously re-elected Craig E. Von Dalen as Chairperson, James Duke as Vice Chairperson, and Patrice Ducett Brown as Secretary.
On February 7, 2023, the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 met at 18:15 to hear various petitions, including variances of use and development standards. The board, chaired by Peter Nelson with members David Duncan and Jennifer Witt, reviewed continuances, expedited petitions, and two contested variance cases. Several procedural actions and one indecisive vote resulted in continuations to future hearings. Consent Calendar (Expedited Petitions and Unopposed Proceedings) - The board unanimously approved moving petition 2023 DV1002 (902-922 N Capitol Ave) to the expedited docket after a request by petitioner's representative Joe Calderan. No opposition was noted. - Petition 2022 UV1035 (6234 E Hannah Ave) was continued for 30 days to the March 7 hearing at the petitioner's request; staff had no objection. - Petition 2022 DV1047 (409 E Morris St) was moved to the expedited docket after the petitioner submitted an amended site plan (reducing from three to two and a half stories) and staff changed recommendation to approval. The board acknowledged withdrawal of the three-story variance request. - Four automatic continuances were acknowledged: 2022 DV1-062 (1012 Olive St) to March 7; 2022 SE1-002 (9140 E McGregor Rd) to March 7; 2022 DV1-063 (114 E 49th St) to March 7; and 2022 UV1-027 (300 E Fall Creek Pkwy) was withdrawn. - The following expedited petitions were approved unanimously (3-0): - 2023 UV1001 (1344 S Belmont Ave) – variance of use for a triplex. - 2023 UV1002 (1090 W 23rd St) – variance of use for a daycare. - 2023 UV1003 (2962 N Delaware St) – variance of use and development standards for a triplex. - 2023 DV1002 (902-922 N Capitol Ave) – variance of development standards for a mixed-use building. - 2022 DV1047 (409 E Morris St) – variance of development standards for lot width and setbacks. Discussion Item: Continuance and Transfer of 2022 UV1044 (5702 N College Ave) - Petitioner Tim Schluge requested a continuance and transfer to Division 2 due to a quorum issue (member Duncan recused). Remonstrator Joseph Lisi (Meridian Kessler land use chair) objected because the case had been continued multiple times and neighbors were not notified. Legal counsel explained that without three voting members the case could not proceed. The board voted to transfer the petition to the February 14 meeting of Division 2. (Duncan abstained? Actually he recused, so only two voted? But transcript shows vote with Duncan recusing? Wait: The transcript says: "All right, board, we have a request to continue and transfer petition 2022 UV 1044... can I get a motion? So moved, wit. And a second, Duncan second. Motion and second, call for vote. Duncan? Duncan, yes. Wit. Yes. And Nelson, yes." This implies Duncan voted despite recusal? Possibly the recusal was for the merits, not procedural. Regardless, the transfer was granted.) Discussion Item: Opioid Treatment Program Variance (2022 UV1-038) – 4010 W 86th St - Petitioner Presentation: Joe Calderan (attorney) and Kristen Primo (Valley Vista Health System) requested a variance of use to operate a state-certified opioid treatment program (OTP) in a C1 office zone. They argued the facility functions as a medical office, but because it administers methadone, it falls under the definition of "methadone clinic," triggering a variance. The 500-foot separation requirement from protected districts is not met (160 feet to residential-zoned parcels), but those parcels are used commercially. A detailed plan of operation was submitted. Doug Hunsinger, executive director for drug prevention and chairman of the Indiana Commission to Combat Substance Use Disorder, spoke in support, citing Governor Holcomb's goal of placing an OTP within an hour's drive of every Hoosier. He noted that crime decreases near OTPs and that the facility has gone above outreach. Valley Vista already operates a successful OTP in Greenwood. - Remonstrance: Susan Blair, president of the Pike Township Residents Association (PTRA), opposed. She stated the board of PTRA voted against the petition. She cited Indiana Administrative Code requiring strong community support, which she said was lacking. Data from the Marion County Public Health Department showed Pike Township had 5% of opioid deaths in Marion County, with 39 overdose deaths in 2022; she argued need is lower elsewhere. Five OTP facilities exist within 10 miles, including one 0.2 miles away. She argued the use is too intense for C1 zoning and should be in C4 or higher. Letters of opposition from Councilor Leroy Robinson, Crooked Creek Alert, and a petition from Pike residents were submitted. - Staff Comments: Staff recommended approval, stating that the site's context (long-standing commercial use of nearby residential-zoned parcels, proximity to major commercial node at 86th and Michigan Rd) makes C3 or C4 uses appropriate. They did not believe the request would have a negative impact. - Rebuttal: Petitioner provided support letters from Greenwood Mayor, Deputy Mayor of Public Health, and others. They noted additional outreach including a visit to KinderCare (which did not oppose). Dr. Simon Fung, medical director of the Greenwood OTP, distinguished methadone clinics from suboxone clinics, emphasizing the unique need and safety. - Vote: The board voted 3-0 to approve the variance. Discussion Item: Driveway Variance (2022 DV1-057) – 401 N Park Ave - Petitioner Presentation: Brandy Wadi and Simone Mitchell requested a variance of development standards to legally establish a driveway providing street access to an existing detached garage (access from alley required) and to legalize side and rear setbacks of the garage. They noted similar driveways on the street and provided neighbor support signatures. They also committed to replant a tree removed during construction. - Remonstrance: A representative from the Meridian Kessler Neighborhood Association (land use committee) stated the committee voted 6-0 in opposition and the full board unanimously opposed. The primary concern was that work was done without permits (driveway appeared first), and the driveway access from the street is inappropriate when alley access exists. The group did not oppose the setback portion. - Staff Comments: Staff gave a split recommendation: approval of the existing setbacks (Part A), but denial of the street access (Part B). Staff argued that granting street access would be injurious to safety and welfare by increasing curb cuts and disrupting pedestrian experience, and that the petitioner could remove the concrete block and access from the alley. They noted the violation and lack of due diligence. - Vote: The board voted separately: - Part A (setbacks): Approved 3-0. - Part B (street access): Received 2 no votes (Duncan and Nelson) and 1 yes vote (Witt), resulting in an indecisive vote. The petition was continued to the March 7 hearing for rehearing. Part A was also continued for adoption of revised findings of fact. Key Outcomes - All five expedited petitions were approved unanimously. - Continuances and transfers: 2022 UV1035 continued to March 7; 2022 UV1044 transferred to February 14 (Division 2); four automatic continuances acknowledged. - 2022 UV1-038: Opioid treatment program variance approved (3-0). - 2022 DV1-057: Setbacks approved (3-0); street access continued to March 7 due to indecisive vote (2-1). - Findings of fact for previous cases (2022 DV1-051 A and B) were adopted. - Meeting adjourned after no further business.
The Metropolitan Development Commission met on February 1, 2023, and approved a series of resolutions, tax abatements, and zoning petitions. The commission conducted three public hearings: a cement batching plant, a mixed-use development, and a redevelopment of the former jail site. All votes were nearly unanimous, with one dissenting vote on a tax abatement. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes of the January 18, 2023 meeting. - Approved six resolutions read into the record as a whole: Real Estate Resolution 2023 R002 (adding $800,000 to a contract with Allied Logistical Services for property preservation, new not-to-exceed $1,150,000 through 2024); Resolution 2023 R003 (amending the agreement with Indianapolis Marion County Building Authority for maintenance, increasing compensation by $100,000); Planning Division Resolution 2023 P004 (authorizing amendment of agreement with Veritas Group Inc. for City Market redesign); Resolution 2023 P005 (authorizing agreements with hearing examiners); Resolution 2023 P006 (appointment of DZA member for Division 1). - Approved three petitions of no appeals (2022 ZON063, 2022 CZN 863, 2022 CZN 875) without discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - No general public comments were taken. During the public hearings, remonstrators spoke on two items: - Cement Batching Plant: No remonstrators appeared in person, but the petitioner noted that nearby resident Ms. Priest had expressed concerns about dust and Kitley Avenue, and Eskenazi Health had submitted a letter of opposition (later not withdrawn but acknowledged as addressed). - Mixed-Use Development: Remonstrator Randy Raber, owner of Bates Ice Cream Shop at 1740 Southeast Street, opposed the project due to lack of off-street parking, overdevelopment, and potential harm to existing businesses. He argued that the project would strain on-street parking and set a precedent for similar developments. Discussion Items 1. Cement Batching Plant (2022 CZN 857 & 2022 CVR 857) – Petitioner Alex Intermill (Bose McKinney & Evans) represented WEV Property Group (WE Beatty Concrete) requesting rezoning of 16.76 acres from I-2/D3 to I-4 (TOD) and a variance to allow a cement batching plant within 500 feet of a protected district. The site is currently gravel and used for concrete construction; the proposal includes a fully enclosed batch plant, dust suppression, a full-body truck wash, and a $100,000 matching fund to repair Kitley Avenue. Staff recommended denial, citing the I-4 district’s incompatibility with adjacent residential uses despite the petitioner’s mitigation efforts. The commission approved the rezoning and variance 8-0, with an additional commitment to adhere to the site plan. 2. Mixed-Use Development (2022 CZN 855, 2022 CVR 855, 2022 CPL 855) – Petitioner Paul J. Lambby (1800 Block LLC) requested rezoning of 0.11 acres from C3 to MU2, a variance for reduced setbacks, encroachments, and landscaping, and a subdivision plat to create a mixed-use building with two townhomes and a commercial space at 1806 Southeast Street. The project is supported by the Bates Hendricks Neighborhood Association and the Stadium Village Business Association. Staff recommended approval, noting that on-street parking can count toward minimum requirements. The commission approved all three petitions 7-0. 3. Jail Site Redevelopment (2022 ZON 134) – Jeff York (DMD) presented a rezoning of 4.5 acres from SU8 to CBD2 for the former Jail 2 site at 730 East Washington Street and 752 East Market Street. Developer Jeremy Stevenson (1820 Ventures) plans to redevelop the historic buildings into 110 housing units, a 3,000-person entertainment venue (The Vogue), retail, childcare, and office space. No remonstrators appeared. The commission approved the rezoning 7-0. Key Outcomes - Tax Abatement (A003) – Approved a three-year vacant building tax abatement for Midwest Remediation Inc. at 810 and 8806 East 38th Street (Council District 13, Lawrence Township) – passed 8-0. - Tax Abatement (A004) – Approved a five-year real property tax abatement for BMWC Contractors Inc. at 1740 West Michigan Street (Council District 11, Center Township) – passed 7-1 (Commissioner Blackburn dissented). - Redevelopment Area Designations – All three linked confirmatory resolutions and bond pledges were approved 8-0: - Virginia Avenue Redevelopment Area (E004/E005) for White Castle/Link Project. - Guilford Midtown Redevelopment Area (E006/E007) for a vacant site in Broad Ripple. - 1331 Washington Allocation Area (E008/E009) for a project on East Washington Street. - Cement Batching Plant: Rezoning and variance approved (8-0). - Mixed-Use Development: Rezoning, variance, and plat approved (7-0). - Jail Site Rezoning: Approved (7-0).
The Metropolitan Development Commission (MDC) held a public meeting on January 18, 2023, at 6:00 p.m. The meeting included approval of minutes, passage of six resolutions, an update on the Drake property acquisition, continuances for several zoning cases, and a contested rezoning petition for a proposed classical school on Indianapolis's northwest side. All votes were unanimous, with most passing 9-0. Consent Calendar - Minutes: Approved minutes from December 7, 2022, December 21, 2022, and January 4, 2023, by a vote of 8-0 (Commissioner Blackburn had not yet arrived). - Resolutions: Approved all six resolutions (2023 R001, E002, E003, A001, A002, FS001) without discussion. These authorizes DMD property acquisition at 3060 North Meridian Street ($270,000 grant for City Market operations, $400,000 professional services agreement for underwriting, preliminary tax abatements for two sites, and extension of a professional services agreement). Vote: 9-0. - Petitions of No Appeals: Approved two no-appeal zoning petitions (2022 ZON 126 at 1401 Indiana Avenue and 2022 ZON 132 at 8205 Georgetown Road) by a 9-0 vote. Public Comments & Testimony - Rezoning 2022 ZON 119 – Children's Better Health Institute / Classical School: Four remonstrators (Joanna Franklin, Edwin Case, Linda Oglesby, Sue Laudernock) expressed concerns about traffic safety, inadequate notice, and the potential for future enrollment growth. They emphasized that 44th Street is narrow, lacks shoulders and sidewalks, has blind spots, and already experiences congestion. Remonstrators asked for a full traffic study and broader neighborhood notification. Discussion Items - Drake Property Update: Director Rusty Carr reported that DMD is in purchase agreement negotiations with the Children's Museum. The acquisition will resolve outstanding lawsuit. After purchase, DMD plans to issue an RFP for redevelopment, with affordable housing as a likely use. Commissioner Blackburn welcomed the progress. - Continuance – 2022 ZON 112 (Petitioner: Can Be Village LLC): Requested by petitioner due to ongoing negotiations with Councilor Bain. Continued to February 15, 2023 (9-0). - Continuance – 2022 ZON 051 / 2022 VAR 003 (Becknell Holdings): Continued to March 15, 2023, due to scheduling and business conditions (9-0). - Withdrawal of Appeal – 2022 UV 1042: The City-County Councilor filed a withdrawal, which the Commission acknowledged. The underlying Board of Zoning Appeals variance is now granted. - Continuance – 2022 ZON 063 (4720 Kingsway Drive): Continued to February 1, 2023, pending receipt and approval of commitments (9-0). - Rezoning 2022 ZON 119 – Classical School Proposal: Petitioner Tim Oaks (Ice Miller) represented Children's Better Health Institute, proposing a private, secular classical school (K-8, max 140 students) in the former Servoss estate. Initial rezoning was from SU7 to SU2 on 22.79 acres, but reduced to 8.5 acres after neighborhood feedback. The school would operate within the existing home with no new exterior improvements. A traffic analysis by ANF Engineering concluded no negative impact, but staff did not require a full traffic study. The site is inconsistent with the comprehensive plan (rural/estate designation), but staff recommended approval due to limited scope. Several commissioners expressed concerns about the lack of a full traffic study, insufficient pro-forma details, and notice adequacy. After discussion, the petitioner requested a continuance to produce a full traffic study and expand notification. The Commission continued the item to March 1, 2023 (9-0). Key Outcomes - Unanimous approvals on minutes, six resolutions, and two no-appeal petitions. - Drake property acquisition moving forward; RFP for redevelopment, likely affordable housing. - Continuances granted for four zoning cases (to Feb 1, Feb 15, March 1, March 15, 2023). - Rezoning 2022 ZON 119 continued to March 1, 2023, with directive for a full traffic study to include drop-off/pick-up analysis and expanded neighborhood notice.