Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 751–760 ENTRIES
751
JAN 17, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Public Hearing - January 17, 2023

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III held a public hearing on January 17, 2023, chaired by Joanna Taft, with board members Roger Bohannan, Percy Bland, and others. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were present. The meeting addressed continuances, expedited petitions, and several variance cases, resulting in approvals for most petitions but denial of one. Consent Calendar - Two expedited petitions were approved unanimously after no opposition: 2022 DV3052 (variance for lot frontage and setbacks at 1730 Wishmeyer Lane) and 2022 UV3032 (variance for building line and parking at 10859 East Washington Street). Public Comments & Testimony - William Lee (369 North Brewer Street, Greenwood, IN) expressed concern about parking for petition 2022 UV3039 but did not oppose the continuance. - Greg Stevens (2609 East Banta Road) opposed petition 2022 UV3038, arguing that the petitioner’s fleet of commercial vehicles and stored materials negatively impacted the residential neighborhood and would reduce property values. He stated that no other homeowners operated a business of this scale. - Brad and Sarah Baxter (5964 East Fall Creek Parkway North Drive), represented by attorney James Scahill, opposed petition 2022 DV3055. They argued the setback violation was self-imposed, that the house now directly overlooks their swimming pool, and that it would substantially reduce their property value and marketability. Mr. Baxter testified that the builder knowingly placed the house 11.5 feet from the property line instead of the required 25 feet. - Latasha Bradbury and Christian Rector (petitioners for 2022 DV3055) described their reliance on permits issued by the city and the financial and emotional hardship of having construction halted. Discussion Items - Continuances: Several cases were continued to future hearings: - 2022 UV3039 continued to February 21, 2023, without additional notice. - 2022 UV3029 continued to March 21, 2023, with staff noting this was the last continuance they would support. - 2022 DV3046 and 2022 DV3049 continued to February 21, 2023, with additional notice. - 2022 DV3056 continued to February 21, 2023, due to petitioner’s absence. - 2022 UV3037 was acknowledged as having an automatic continuance filed by a remonstrator. - 2022 DV3054 was withdrawn by the petitioner. - 2022 DV3050 (3501 Southeast Street): Petitioner Joe Calderan requested a variance for a digital display sign on an existing pole sign at a Crew Car Wash. He presented commitments to reduce sign area, limit message duration to 30 seconds, and shut off the sign between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m. Staff recommended denial, citing proximity to protected districts and safety concerns. The board approved 4-1. - 2022 DV3051 (6830 Lake Plaza Drive): Petitioner Michael Rabinowich sought variances to allow 31 parking spaces (maximum 23) and one stacking space (two required) for a Chipotle restaurant with a mobile app pickup window. Letters of support from the Greater Allisonville Community Council and City-County Councilor Dan Boots were presented. Staff recommended denial, stating the parking data did not justify the need and the stacking space requirement was not met. The board approved 4-1. - 2022 DV3053 (1028 East Edwards Avenue): Petitioner James Riedeman requested a variance for driveway access from Edwards Avenue instead of the required alley. He explained that the house was built under permits issued by the city, and that the alley was often obstructed. Staff recommended denial, citing the TOD overlay principles favoring alley access. The board approved 5-0. - 2022 DV3055 (5959 Fall Creek Road): Petitioner Christian Rector and Latasha Bradbury requested a variance to reduce the rear setback from 25 feet to 11.5 feet for a single-family home. The home was already under construction with permits. Staff recommended denial, noting the site could accommodate the required setback. Remonstrators argued the variance was self-imposed and would harm their property. The board voted 0-5 to deny the petition. - 2022 UV3038 (2530 East Banta Road): Petitioner Fernanda Santana requested variances to operate a general contractor business, including storage of commercial vehicles, and to allow a loft shed and two existing accessory structures within a corner front yard. Staff recommended denial for the use and loft shed, but approval to legally establish the two accessory structures. Remonstrator Greg Stevens opposed the business use. The board voted: Part A (use and loft shed) denied 0-5; Part B (two accessory structures) approved 5-0. Key Outcomes - Continuances: All requested continuances were granted as noted. - Expedited petitions: Approved unanimously. - 2022 DV3050 (Crew Car Wash digital sign): Approved (4-1). - 2022 DV3051 (Chipotle parking and stacking): Approved (4-1). - 2022 DV3053 (Edwards Avenue driveway): Approved (5-0). - 2022 DV3055 (Fall Creek Road setback): Denied (0-5). The board directed staff to prepare findings of fact in support of the denial. - 2022 UV3038 (General contractor and structures): Part A (use and loft shed) denied (0-5); Part B (two accessory structures) approved (5-0). Both parts continued for adoption of findings of fact.

ZONING AND LAND USE 47% · LAND USE REGULATION 12% · SIGN REGULATION 9% · PARKING MANAGEMENT 8%
752
JAN 10, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 Public Hearing - January 10, 2023

This public hearing of the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 2, was called to order at 6:00 PM on January 10, 2023, under Acting Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen. Board members present included James Duke, Beth Brandon, and new member Tom Barnes. The board heard special requests for continuances, an expedited petition, and two contested variance petitions. The meeting concluded with a discussion about electing officers, which was deferred to the next meeting. Consent Calendar - 2022 DV2-046 (14 East Caven Street) – Expedited Variance: Petitioner Mark Crouch requested a variance for a multi-unit house on a substandard lot, with support from the Old Southside Neighborhood Association and staff. The board voted 4-0 to approve. - 2022 AP2-02 (977 Roche Street): Withdrawal acknowledged by the board. - 2022 UV2-030 (2307 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Street): Continued to February 14, 2023, without additional notice, per petitioner's request. - 2022 UV3-022 (830 River Avenue): Continued to March 14, 2023, without additional notice, to allow staff further review. - 2022 DV2-047 (2304/2302 West 60th Street): Continued to February 14, 2023, without additional notice, for additional information. - 2022 DV2-048 (3815 River Crossing Parkway): Automatic continuance acknowledged to February 14, 2023. - 2022 UV2-029 (1645 East Minnesota Street): Continued to February 14, 2023, with additional notice due to mailing discrepancies. Public Comments & Testimony - 2022 UV2-024 (3916 East Minnesota Street): Petitioner Angel Mendoza, represented by David Kingan, and supporter Michael Shin testified in favor. Mendoza stated his business involves landscaping and hardscape, that he parks vehicles overnight only, and that he has letters of support from five closest neighbors. Shin highlighted Mendoza's community contributions, including projects for the city animal shelter. No opposition speakers appeared. - 2022 UV2-028 (1634 Southeast Street): Petitioner Marcus Crouch spoke in favor, arguing the proposed bar would be an asset to the Bates Hendricks neighborhood and that the two protected districts within 100 feet had submitted letters of support. Randy Raber, owner of Bates Ice Cream Shop, also testified in support, stating more businesses are needed on the corridor. No opposition speakers appeared. Discussion Items - 2022 UV2-024 (3916 East Minnesota Street) – Variance of Use for Commercial Vehicle Storage: The petitioner sought approval to store commercial vehicles and equipment on a residential lot. Staff recommended denial, citing the D3 district's residential purpose, lack of buffering, gravel surface issues, and concerns about expansion of commercial use. During testimony, the petitioner amended the request to three commercial vehicles (including a trailer) and two pieces of heavy equipment. The board voted 4-0 to approve the amended variance, noting no letters of remonstrance were filed. - 2022 UV2-028 (1634 Southeast Street) – Variance of Use for Bar within 75 feet of Protected Districts: The petitioner requested a variance to operate a bar 22 feet and 75 feet from protected residential districts (100 feet required). Staff recommended denial, citing insufficient parking, no formal parking plan, and that the site could be used for other C3 uses without a variance. The board voted 1-3 to deny the petition (Brandon yes; Barnes, Von Dalen, Duke no). The matter will be continued for adoption of findings of fact. Key Outcomes - Vote on 2022 DV2-046: Approved (4-0). - Vote on 2022 UV2-024: Approved (4-0) with amendment to limit to three commercial vehicles and two pieces of heavy equipment. - Vote on 2022 UV2-028: Denied (1-3). - Election of Officers: Deferred to the next meeting due to absence of the full board. - Future Meeting Dates: The board acknowledged that Chairperson Von Dalen may be absent in March and May; the next regular hearing is scheduled for February 14, 2023.

ZONING AND LAND USE 69% · PROCEDURAL 6% · PUBLIC SAFETY 6% · ALCOHOL BEVERAGE REGULATION 5%
753
JAN 4, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
Metropolitan Development Commission Public Meeting - January 4, 2023

The Metropolitan Development Commission held a public meeting on January 4, 2023, at 6:00 PM. The commission addressed the absence of minutes from two previous meetings, approved three resolutions, granted continuances for three petitions, and approved six petitions with no appeals. All votes were unanimous 8-0. Minutes and Resolutions - The commission noted that minutes from two previous meetings were not received and directed the executive director to provide them by the January 18 meeting. - Three resolutions were read into the record: 2023 E001 (authorizing $400,000 from the airport economic development area TIF district allocation fund for an interlocal agreement with MSD Wayne Township for adult education programs through 2023), 2023 P001 (authorizing rezoning of the former GL2 site to CBD 2), and 2023 P002 (appointment of BZA member for Division 2). The commission approved all three resolutions as a group with a motion and second, passing 8-0. Continuance Requests - 2022 ZON 110 (2920 and 2926 Bluff Road): Attorney Paul Page requested a continuance to March 15, 2023, to allow time for site plan and building elevation drawings. Remonstrator Glenda Huber had no objection. Staff supported. Approved 8-0. - 2022 CZN 857 and C VR 857 amended (WEB Property Group): Attorney Alex Intermill requested a continuance to February 1, 2023, to continue discussions with staff. Staff supported. Approved 8-0. - 2022 ZON 063: Staff requested a continuance to January 18, 2023, pending receipt and review of executed commitments. Approved 8-0. Petitions with No Appeals - Six petitions were listed with no appeals: 2022 ZON 116 (205 Palmer Street), 2022 ZON 127 (1302 Columbia Avenue), 2022 ZON 129 (3904, 3908 North Audubon Road), 2022 ZON 130 (8020 Brookville Road), 2022 CZN 869 (1631, 1851 West Thompson Road), and 2022 REG 067 amended (675 East Washington Street). The commission approved them all unanimously 8-0. Key Outcomes - All three resolutions passed 8-0. - All three continuance requests were granted. - All six petitions with no appeals were approved. - The commission adjourned, noting the next meeting on January 18, 2023.

PROCEDURAL 76% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 24%
754
JAN 3, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division One Meeting - January 3, 2023

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division One met on January 3, 2023, at 6:15 PM under acting chairperson David Duncan. The board considered multiple variance requests, including applications for commercial setbacks, residential garage access, a tow truck parking, self-storage expansion, and a methadone clinic. Several continuances were granted, and votes were taken on all cases. Continuances & Procedural Matters - 2022 DV1047 (409 E Moore St) – Continuance to February 7 granted unanimously. - 2022 UV1035 (6234 E Hand Ave) – Continuance to February 7 with additional notice granted unanimously. - 2022 DV1061 (address not specified) – One‑day waiver of mailing notice granted. - 2022 SE1001 (4330 N Michigan Rd) – Two‑month continuance to March 7 granted. - 2022 DV2045 (1251 Alabama St) – Continuance to March 7 granted. - 2022 UV1038 (4100 W 86th St, Pike Township methadone clinic) – Remonstrators requested a continuance; petitioner opposed. Vote 2‑1 (Napoleon and Witt yes, Duncan no) to continue to March 7, 2023. The board later heard this case on its merits (see below). - 2022 DV1062 (1012 Olive St) – Automatic continuance acknowledged. - 2022 DV1063 (114 E 49th St) – Automatic continuance acknowledged (filed by neighborhood organization). - 2022 UV1044 (5702 N College Ave) – Automatic continuance acknowledged (filed by petitioner). Expedited Docket Petitions 2022 DV1060 (5224 N Pennsylvania St) and 2022 DV1061 (4915 Patricia St) were approved unanimously by ballot (3‑0) without testimony. Discussion Items 2022 DV1051 (3127 W Washington St) – Petitioner RSM Oil requested variances to construct a retail building: a 32‑ft front setback (max 25 ft) and a 44% building line (60% required). Staff recommended denial of the setback variance (self‑imposed hardship due to existing sign) but approval of the building line variance. The board split the petition. Outcome: Part A (front setback) approved 3‑0; Part B (building line) approved 3‑0. Findings of fact to be revised and submitted. 2022 DV1052 (358 E Terrace Ave) – Petitioner sought variances to construct a detached garage with access from South New Jersey Street (alley access required) and reduced side/clear‑site setbacks. Staff opposed, stating alley access is feasible and adjacent properties comply. Neighborhood association, Southeast Neighborhood Development, and Councilor Kristen Jones supported. Outcome: All variances approved 3‑0. 2022 DV1057 (401 N Park Ave) – Petitioner requested a second continuance to gather neighbor support letters. The Meridian Kessler land use committee voted 6‑0 in opposition. Staff requested this be the final continuance. Outcome: Continuance to February 7 granted. 2022 DV1058 (1635 Cornell Ave) – Request for a duplex on an undersized lot (5,396 sq ft vs. 7,200 required) and reduced garage setbacks. Staff recommended approval after petitioner improved open space to 55%. No remonstrators appeared. Outcome: Approved 3‑0. 2022 UV1020 (6805 Jackson St) – Petitioner John Miller Jr. sought a use variance to park a commercial tow truck at his residence (garage or carport). Staff strongly opposed, noting the prohibition has existed since 1989 and the vehicle is ineligible for exceptions. Petitioner presented letters of support from four law enforcement agencies. The Rockville Road/High School Road/Girls School Road Neighborhood Association opposed. Outcome: Denied 0‑3. 2022 UV1036 (2727‑2719 Madison Ave) – Petitioner Store‑Space requested a use variance to allow outdoor covered storage of RVs and boats on 1.5 acres of an existing self‑storage site (former Kmart). Staff opposed, citing the lack of a demonstrated hardship and inconsistency with the C5 zone and comprehensive plan. Petitioner committed to a detailed landscape plan and screening. The board added a condition for a landscape plan with mature screening along the western and northern fence lines. Outcome: Approved 3‑0. 2022 UV1038 (4010 W 86th St) – Valley Vista Health System requested a variance to operate an opioid treatment program (methadone clinic) in a C1 zone, with less than 500‑ft separation from a dwelling district. Staff recommended approval, noting the two nearby D2‑zoned properties are used commercially. Petitioners presented testimony on safety, state support, and success in Greenwood. Remonstrators from Pike Township argued insufficient community notice, existing treatment facilities, and public safety concerns. The board initially continued the case (see Continuances), but the continuance vote was 2‑1 (indecisive), resulting in an automatic continuance to February 7. The case was then heard on its merits. Outcome: After testimony and rebuttal, the board voted 2‑1 (Duncan and Witt yes, Napoleon no). Because the vote was indecisive (2‑1), the petition was automatically continued to the February 7, 2023 hearing without additional notice. Key Outcomes - Approvals: DV1051 (both parts), DV1052, DV1058, UV1036. - Denials: UV1020. - Continuances (board action): DV1047, UV1035, DV1061, SE1001, DV2045, DV1057, UV1038 (automatic due to indecisive vote). - Automatic continuances acknowledged: DV1062, DV1063, UV1044. - Expedited approvals: DV1060, DV1061.

ZONING AND LAND USE 47% · PROCEDURAL 14% · TOW REGULATION 7% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 7%
755
DEC 20, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Indianapolis Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Meeting - December 20, 2022

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III convened on December 20, 2022 at 1:00 PM (18:00 UTC) under Chairperson Joanna Taft. Board members present included Roderick Brohannan, Bart Brown, Cameron Radford, and later Percy Bland. The docket included continuances, withdrawals, and two contested variance petitions. Both petitions received staff recommendations for denial but were approved by the board with 3-2 votes. Consent Calendar - 2022-DV3-046 (1321 Sturm Avenue): Continued to January 17, 2023, with additional notice at the petitioner's request. Staff had no objection. - 2022-UV3-031 (10435 East Washington Street): Initially moved to the end of the docket for further discussion, the petitioner later withdrew the petition and requested fee transfer to a new plat petition. Staff supported the transfer and withdrawal. - 2022-UV3-032 (10859 East Washington Street): Continued to January 17, 2023, at the petitioner's request to allow revisions. Staff had no objection. - 2022-UV3-036 (1516 East Edwards Avenue): Withdrawn by the petitioner at the hearing. Staff acknowledged the withdrawal. - 2022-DV3-050 (3501 South East Street): A registered neighborhood organization’s automatic continuance to January 17, 2023, was acknowledged by the board. - 2022-DV3-049 (2315 North Spencer Avenue): Continued to January 17, 2023, at staff’s request for additional information and amendments. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments or testimony were offered outside of the formal petition hearings. Discussion Items - 2022-UV3-034 (3030 North Shadeland Avenue) – Auto Sales Lot Variance: Petitioner Abdallah Alshorman, represented by David Kingen, requested a variance of use to operate an auto sales lot (C-5 use) on a C-4 zoned site (former bank). The petitioner cited the property’s two-and-a-half-year vacancy and support from two neighborhood organizations. Commitments included landscaping, ornamental fencing, a 40-vehicle limit, and a list of excluded uses. Staff recommended denial, arguing the use would deviate from the Comprehensive Plan (community commercial), encourage encroachment of heavy commercial uses north of I-70 toward a planned transit corridor, and that no hardship existed because the property could be used for permitted C-4 uses. The board approved the variance by a 3-2 vote (Bohannan, Bland, Radford voting yes; Taft, Brown voting no). - 2022-UV3-035 (1621 East Thompson Road) – Dog Training and Boarding Variance: Petitioner Margaret Bridges, represented by Russell Brown, requested a variance of use to operate a dog training and boarding business (C-3/C-4 use) on a D-3 zoned single-family residential property. The petitioner argued the operation qualified as a home occupation under the ordinance and presented a plan limiting to 10 dogs overnight, 6 daily customers, and 600 sq. ft. indoor use. A letter of support from an adjacent neighbor was submitted. Staff recommended denial, citing the defined commercial use, potential noise/odors, gravel driveway concerns, and inconsistency with the Comprehensive Plan. The board approved the variance by a 3-2 vote (Bohannan, Brown, Radford voting yes; Taft, Bland voting no). Key Outcomes - 2022-UV3-034 approved (3-2): Auto sales lot permitted subject to plan of operation and commitments. - 2022-UV3-035 approved (3-2): Dog training and boarding permitted subject to plan of operation. - All continuances and withdrawals were granted as requested. - The board adopted findings of fact for prior petitions 2022-DV3-048, 2022-UV1-026, negative findings for 2022-DV3-0042, and transferred petition 2022-DV2-039. - The next regular hearing is scheduled for January 17, 2023.

ZONING AND LAND USE 54% · PROCEDURAL 28% · ANIMAL CARE 7% · ANIMAL WELFARE 6%
756
DEC 13, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II Meeting - December 13, 2022

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II met on December 13, 2022, to hear a variety of variance petitions. Key actions included the approval of a daycare facility conversion, approval of a third-story addition and a lot/addition in a suburban district, and denial of three digital billboard proposals. Several petitions were continued or withdrawn. Consent Calendar - 2022-DV2-044 (305 North Beville Avenue): Expedited petition for a variance to allow a 7-foot rear setback for a single-family dwelling. Approved unanimously by voice vote. Public Comments & Testimony - Valerie Johnson (parent/grandparent): Expressed strong support for the Fruit of the Holy Spirit Daycare (2022-UV3-025), citing its high-quality, affordable care and no traffic issues encountered personally. She urged approval. - Gary Chalufo (Historic Urban Neighborhoods of Indianapolis): Opposed the digital billboard petitions (2022-UV2-009, 011, 012), arguing they circumvent the 2019 City-County Council sign ordinance ban on digital off-premise signs. He emphasized driver distraction, privacy, and precedent concerns. - Pete Fisher (NORA North Side Community Council): Opposed all three billboard petitions, stating the NORA Council has long opposed billboards, especially digital ones, and that approval would open floodgates and undermine the public process that created the sign ordinance. - J. Napoleon (Marion County Alliance of Neighborhood Associations): Strongly opposed the billboard requests, arguing the petitioners failed to meet the legal standard for variances and that digital billboards would harm neighborhood character and safety. He referenced the history of redlining and urged the board not to add insult to injury along interstate corridors. - Edwin Locke (community representative): Opposed the Haver Way billboard (2022-UV2-012), noting broad community group opposition and citing the unanimous 2019 council vote against digital billboards. Discussion Items - 2022-UV3-025 (3335 North Sherman Drive) – Childcare Facility: Petitioner Shantae Flemons sought a variance of use to operate a daycare center (ministry) in a D-5 zone. She and her attorney argued the site is unique (circular driveway, large lot, mixed-use arterial corridor) and has operated four years without complaints. Staff recommended denial, citing the residential mid-block location, illegal operation, and lack of hardship. The petitioner committed to a maximum of 25 children. Board members questioned traffic, licensing, and capacity. After staff recommended a 16-child limit if approved, the board voted 4-0 to approve (with findings to be adopted later). - 2022-DV2-042 (21 North Chester Avenue) – Third Story Addition: Petitioner requested a variance to allow a roof-line alteration resulting in a third story (2.5 stories permitted) and a reduced side setback. Staff recommended approval for the setback but denial for the third story, citing self-imposed hardship, neighborhood context, and infill guidelines. The petitioner argued the attic is only 5 feet tall and used for storage. After discussion about the definition of a “story” and permit violations, the board approved the variance 4-1 (Farmer dissenting), with findings to be adopted. - 2022-DV2-043 (220 West 81st Street) – Lot and Addition Variances: Petitioners sought to legally establish a 0.8-acre lot (one acre required) and allow a building addition with reduced rear setbacks and open space. Staff recommended denial, stating practical difficulties were self-imposed and alternatives existed. The petitioner argued the lot’s D-S zoning was inappropriate and that D-1 standards would be more fitting; they submitted a letter of support from an adjacent neighbor. The board voted 4-1 to approve (Farmer dissenting), with findings to be adopted. - 2022-UV2-009 (1251 West 96th Street) – Digital Billboard: Reagan Outdoor Advertising sought variances to convert an existing static billboard to a 40-foot-tall digital sign with reduced setbacks and separation from protected districts. Staff recommended denial, citing the 2019 council ban, self-created injury, safety concerns, and feasible alternatives (maintaining the existing static sign). The petitioner argued no evidence of safety risk and committed to a 10-second display duration. Remonstrators opposed. The board voted 0-3 to deny (Brown, Farmer, Von Dalen all “no”). Negatives findings to be adopted. - 2022-UV2-011 (1355 West 96th Street) – Digital Billboard: Similar petition for a digital sign at a different location, also recommended for denial by staff. The petitioner made similar arguments; remonstrators repeated opposition. The board voted 0-3 to deny. - 2022-UV2-012 (9333 Haver Way) – Digital Billboard: Third digital billboard petition, for a 60-foot-tall sign near an interstate entrance ramp. Staff recommended denial, citing height, separation, and safety. Petitioner conceded time, remonstrators opposed. Board voted 0-3 to deny. Key Outcomes - 2022-DV2-044 (Expedited): Approved (unanimous voice vote). - 2022-UV3-025 (Childcare): Approved (4-0; Ducett Brown, Brown, Duncan, Von Dalen yes); continued for findings. - 2022-DV2-042 (Third Story): Approved (4-1; Farmer no); continued for findings. - 2022-DV2-043 (Lot & Addition): Approved (4-1; Farmer no); continued for findings. - 2022-UV2-009, 011, 012 (Digital Billboards): All denied (0-3 each; Ducett Brown, Farmer, Von Dalen no); continued for negative findings. - 2022-UV2-010 (2400 Roosevelt Avenue): Withdrawn by petitioner; board acknowledged. - 2022-DV2-045 (1251 South Alabama Street): Continued and transferred to January 3, 2023, Division I. - 2022-DV2-046 (14 East Caven Street): Automatically continued to January 10, 2023, Division II (due to neighborhood organization request). - 2022-UV2-027 (3445 Washington Boulevard): Continued to February 14, 2023, with additional notice. - Findings of Fact: The board adopted negative findings for three petitions denied at the November 15, 2022 hearing (2022-UV2-014, 015, 016).

SIGN REGULATION 39% · ZONING AND LAND USE 25% · CHILD CARE REGULATION 11% · PROCEDURAL 8%
757
DEC 7, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
Metropolitan Development Commission Meeting December 7, 2022

The Metropolitan Development Commission (MDC) met on December 7, 2022, at 6:15 PM. The meeting covered 19 resolutions, two continuances, three public hearings, and a presentation from IU Health. Several votes resulted in ties, requiring rehearing on December 21. Key actions included approvals of the Convention Center expansion, IU Health’s allocation area, and a self-storage expansion with added commitments. Consent Calendar - Appointed Karina Bronze as assistant secretary (unanimous). - Approved the minutes from November 16, 2022, with Commissioner Bronze recused (5-0). - Passed 15 resolutions (2022 R048, R050, R051, R053, E046, E048, E051, E053, E054, E055, A30, A31, C12, C013, B003) as a single block 6-0. These covered contract amendments, property acquisitions, Monon Trail widening, flood control funding, tax increment pledges, redevelopment area declarations, and a housing trust fund agreement. - Approved 11 petitions of no appeals (2022 MOD 015, MOD 019, ZON 088, ZON 110, ZON 120, ZON 121, ZON 122, REG 065, REG 066) 6-0. Public Hearings Resolution 2022 R052 – Indiana Convention Center / Pan Am Plaza Expansion - Acting DMD Director Rusty Carr presented the resolution, which increased the maximum interest rate for redevelopment district bonds and authorized up to $25 million in TIF revenues for the project. Commissioner Bronze recused. Approved 5-0. Resolution 2022 E045 – 1827 Meridian Redevelopment Area - Confirmatory resolution to designate the project area and adopt a redevelopment plan. Carr voiced full support. Approved 6-0. Resolution 2022 E047 – Odd Fellows Redevelopment Area - Confirmatory resolution for an adaptive reuse hotel project. Carr noted its importance for downtown economic development. Approved 6-0. Resolution 2022 E052 – North Meridian Economic Development & Allocation Area (IU Health Update) - IU Health representatives (Murray Clark, Brian McHugh, Michael Davis, Darius Gartner) presented the new hospital campus at 16th and Capitol. Highlights: the hospital is already under construction, with a record single-day concrete pour of 6,400 cubic yards. The central utility plant (80,000 sq ft) provides infrastructure for the campus. Staff noted the collaborative process. Approved 6-0. 2022 ZON 036 – Beezer Homes Rezoning (63.6 acres at 4161 & 4355 Senior Road) - Petitioner David Rutherford argued that extensive commitments (no vinyl siding, custom fencing) were negotiated with neighbors, and that the comprehensive plan’s “agricultural preservation” designation is outdated. Remonstrator Cassie Foster contested the safety of the entrance and alleged intimidation. Staff recommended denial, citing the comprehensive plan; commissioners debated whether farmland preservation is still viable in Marion County. Vote tied 3-3 (Ash, Dylan, Robinson for; Carver, Bruns, Blackburn against). Set for rehearing December 21. 2022 CVR 833 – Indigo Paratransit Facility (2425 West Michigan Street) - Petitioner Brooke Thomas requested variances for a 10-foot security fence, a dumpster enclosure in the front yard, and a reduced setback. Staff recommended denial, arguing no hardship proven and that the dumpster could be relocated. Vote tied 3-3 (Garver, Bruns, Blackburn for; Dylan, Robinson, Ash against). Set for rehearing December 21. 2022 CAP 858 & CVR 858 – Self-Storage Expansion (3820 North Keystone Avenue) - Petitioner Joe Calderon and owner James Leonard sought approval to add storage buildings and remove an existing residence. Staff initially recommended denial over buffering and use concerns. After negotiation, the petitioner agreed to commitments: maintain existing chain-link fence with black mesh, remove barbed wire, install year-round landscaping along Hillside and 39th, limit operating hours to 6 AM–10 PM, and prohibit plasma center, substance abuse treatment, nightclub, indoor/outdoor recreation, liquor store, and pawn shop. Both the rezoning (CAP) and variance (CVR) were approved 6-0. Discussion Items - Continuances: Case 2022 ZON 112 (petitioner agreed) was moved to January 18, 2023, at the request of Councilman Josh Bain, approved 6-0. Case 2022 ZON 117 was continued to December 21, pending receipt of commitments, also approved 6-0. Key Outcomes - Approved: Five resolutions (R052, E045, E047, E052) and the 15-consent-block, plus 11 no-appeal petitions. - Approved with Commitments: CAP 858 and CVR 858 (self-storage) 6-0. - Tied (3-3) – Rehearing December 21: ZON 036 (Beezer Homes rezoning) and CVR 833 (Indigo variances). - Continued: ZON 112 to January 18, 2023; ZON 117 to December 21, 2022. - Next Meeting: December 21, 2022, with a heavy docket and a full board expected to resolve ties.

ZONING AND LAND USE 40% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 12% · LAND USE REGULATION 9% · PROCEDURAL 8%
758
DEC 6, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Public Hearing - December 6, 2022

This public hearing of the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 was held on December 6, 2022, at 18:15. Acting Chairperson Peter Nelson presided, with board members Beth Brandon, Renee Napoleon, and Anthony Bridgman (arriving later). Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and staff from the Division of Planning were present. The board considered continuances, a withdrawal, expedited petitions, and two variance requests. The meeting concluded with acknowledgment of staff member Genesis Hill's departure. Consent Calendar - Waiver of rules for expedited petitions: The board unanimously voted to waive procedural rules and allow voting on all expedited petitions without additional testimony. - Expedited petitions approved unanimously (4-0): - 2022 DV1054 (Amended) – 2655 Oliver Avenue: Variance for single-family dwelling setback and front entry feature. - 2022 DV1056 – 235 West 44th Street: Variance for rear and side yard setbacks for an attached accessory dwelling. - 2022 DV1059 – 7036 Warwick Road: Variance for side yard setback for attached garage and addition. - 2022 UV1041 – 1110 Bates Street: Variance for side and rear yard setbacks for a detached garage in an I-4 district. Continuances and Special Requests - Petitions continued to January 3, 2023, without additional notice (unanimous): - 2022 UV1036 (2711-2719 Madison Avenue) – to allow updated renderings. - 2022 UV1038 (4010 West 86th Street) – to meet with Pike Township Residents Association. - 2022 DV1057 (401 North Park Avenue) – to meet with Meridian Kessler Neighborhood Association. - 2022 DV1047 (409 East Morris Street) – to revise plans with staff and Fountain Square Neighborhood Association. - 2022 DV1051 (3127 West Washington Street) – to resolve issues with staff. - 2022 DV1058 (Cornell Avenue) – to meet with Kennedy Park Neighborhood Association. - 2022 SE1001 (4330 Michigan Road) – to meet with neighbors. - 2022 DV1052 (358 East Terrace Avenue) – due to petitioner unavailability (medical personnel). - 2022 UV1035 (6234 East Hannah Avenue) – continued to January 3, 2023, with notice if amended. - Petitions continued to February 7, 2023, without additional notice unless needed (unanimous): - 2022 UV1027 (2803 North New Jersey Street) – to allow petitioner to relocate proposed request. - 2022 SE1002 (9140 East McGregor Road) – to provide additional information. - Withdrawal acknowledged: 2022 DB1055 (2853 and 2849 McPherson Street) – petitioner withdrew. - Waiver of notice granted: 2022 DV1059 – one-day waiver of posting requirement due to Labor Day holiday (unanimous). Discussion Items - 2022 UV1042 – 3401 East 96th Street (former Regions Bank): Petitioner Jason Lucking (Sulkey & Ogden) requested a variance of use to allow buying, selling, and leasing of motor vehicles in a C4 district. He argued that road changes (roundabout at 96th & Keystone, loss of frontage on Thrill Road) created a hardship, and that surrounding auto dealerships make the site more suitable for motor vehicle sales. He cited 20-30 vehicles on-site and no servicing. Staff recommended denial, citing that permitted C4 uses exist and that the use does not align with the community commercial comprehensive plan recommendation. The board voted 3-1 to approve (Bridgman, Brandon, Napoleon in favor; Nelson opposed). - 2022 UV1040 – 1220 South High School Road (MSD Wayne Township Education Center): Initially continued, the board rescinded its continuance (unanimous) and heard the petition. Barry Gardner (MSD Wayne Township) requested a variance to allow solar panels on carports in the front yard (solar panels not permitted in front yards). He stated the panels would be on carport roofs, not visible from the street, and no remonstrance was received. Staff recommended approval, noting the dual purpose and aesthetic benefit. The board unanimously approved the variance. Key Outcomes - All continuances and the withdrawal were granted as requested. - Waiver of notice for 2022 DV1059 granted. - Expedited petitions approved unanimously (4-0). - 2022 UV1042 approved by a vote of 3-1. - 2022 UV1040 approved unanimously after rescinding its continuance. - Staff member Genesis Hill was acknowledged for her service as she departs the division.

PROCEDURAL 49% · ZONING AND LAND USE 42% · ENERGY EFFICIENCY 7% · LAND USE REGULATION 1%
759
NOV 22, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Hearing - November 22, 2022

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III met on November 22, 2022, at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building, Indianapolis, Indiana, under the chairmanship of Joanna Taft. The board considered several variance petitions, including signage disputes, commercial building setbacks, and storage additions, with staff recommendations ranging from denial to approval. Key discussions involved sign proliferation, protection of residential districts, and practical difficulties arising from government action. Consent Calendar - 2022-DV3-043 (1423 South State Avenue): Approved as an expedited petition without objection. The variance legally established an existing zero-foot south side setback and permitted a two-foot south setback for a building addition, subject to the commitment that the zero-foot setback applies only to the existing dwelling built in 1930; if demolished or replaced, the variance lapses. Public Comments & Testimony - City-County Councillor Dan Boots (District 3): Spoke in opposition to 2022-DV2-039 (6111 N. Keystone) and 2022-DV3-048 (6303 E. 82nd Street). He argued that Keystone Avenue suffers from "significant sign pollution" and that signs should be monument-style rather than pylon. For the Castleton area, he noted the adopted Castleton Plan calls for reducing digital and pole signs, and he urged denial of petitions that increase sign intensity. He expressed no objection to an existing illuminated pole sign or a dumpster at 6303 E. 82nd Street but opposed any digital display. - Thomas Lorenz (Northwest Perry Neighborhood Association): Remonstrated against 2022-UV3-030 (4613 S. Harding Street), opposing a height increase from 40 to 60 feet for a relocated billboard. He stated the neighborhood recognized the need for relocation due to INDOT construction but argued the replacement should match the original dimensions, and no definitive evidence of roadway elevation change had been provided. - Zach Decker (Carson Plus LLC, adjacent property owner): Opposed 2022-DV3-045 (3141 E. Thompson Road), asserting the petitioner had no recorded easement to use his property for access and that the hardship was self-imposed; the building could be redesigned or reduced in size. Discussion Items - 2022-DV2-039 (6111 North Keystone Avenue): Petitioner Lauren Obendorf (Green Sign Company) requested a variance for a fourth freestanding pylon sign and digital display within 400 feet of a protected district for Culver's restaurant. They argued the sign was essential for navigation and branding, with brightness controlled. Staff and Councillor Boots opposed on grounds of sign proliferation, proximity to residential (405 feet), conflict with 2019 sign regulations, and lack of practical difficulty. The board denied the petition 4-1 (Bohanan voted yes). - 2022-DV3-042 (3510 South Keystone Avenue): Petitioner David Gilman requested a 40-foot tall pole sign with digital display for Richmond Exteriors, citing poor visibility from I-65 and seasonal advertising needs. Staff opposed due to height (20 feet allowed), digital display not permitted on pole signs, and proximity to protected district (210 feet). The board denied unanimously 5-0. - 2022-UV3-030 (4613 South Harding Street): Petitioner Mike Lewinsky (Lamar Advantage) requested relocation and height increase (to 60 feet) for a billboard displaced by INDOT's I-465/I-69 expansion. The digital conversion request was withdrawn as an administrative mistake. Staff recommended approval, citing a government-imposed practical difficulty and Indiana Code 8-23-20-25.6. The motion passed 4-1 (Taft voted no). - 2022-DV3-048 (6303 East 82nd Street): Petitioner Sean Smith (City Barbecue) sought variance for an internally illuminated pole sign with digital display and a dumpster in the front yard. After discussion, the digital display request was withdrawn. The board voted to split the ballot and then withdrew that motion; a single vote on the dumpster with a landscaping commitment passed 5-0. - 2022-DV3-045 (3141 East Thompson Road): Petitioner Bill Niemier requested a 96.5-foot front setback (max 85 feet) for a new pharmacy building, citing constraints from an existing pylon sign on an adjacent parcel. The adjacent owner disputed access rights. Staff recommended denial, asserting the design could be rotated or reduced. The board voted 3-2 to approve (Radford, Brown, Bohanan yes; Bland, Taft no). - 2022-DV3-047 (920 Mitthoefer Road): Petitioner Martin Tomey requested a building addition with 24-foot height and 15-foot rear transitional yard for an auto repair shop. He argued roof pitch needed to avoid water damage, and bad weather hindered vehicle storage. Staff opposed citing overdevelopment and no practical difficulty. The board approved 3-2 (Taft, Brown, Bohanan yes; Radford, Bland no). Key Outcomes - 2022-DV2-039: Denied (4-1) – continued for adoption of negative findings of fact. - 2022-DV3-042: Denied (5-0) – continued for adoption of negative findings of fact. - 2022-UV3-030: Approved (4-1) – continued for adoption of positive findings of fact; digital conversion request withdrawn. - 2022-DV3-048: Approved (5-0) – dumpster portion only, with commitment to work with staff on landscaping; digital display request withdrawn. - 2022-DV3-045: Approved (3-2). - 2022-DV3-047: Approved (3-2). - 2022-UV3-029 (1009 West Edgewood Avenue): Continued to January 17, 2023, at petitioner's request. - 2022-UV3-033 (8020 Brookville Road): Withdrawn by petitioner; $2,044 filing fee transferred to a future rezoning petition, acknowledged by board. - 2022-DV3-044 (111 Albert Drive): Withdrawn by petitioner, acknowledged. - 2022-UV3-032 (10859 E. Washington Street): Continued to December 20, 2022, at petitioner's request. - 2022-DV3-046 (1321 Sturm Avenue): Automatically continued to December 20, 2022, due to a timely neighborhood organization request; petitioner intends to amend with new notice.

SIGN REGULATION 47% · ZONING AND LAND USE 26% · PROCEDURAL 10% · TRANSPORTATION 6%
760
NOV 16, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
Metropolitan Development Commission Meeting – November 16, 2022

The Metropolitan Development Commission met on November 16, 2022, at 6:15 PM. The meeting included approval of minutes, appointment of an acting secretary, adoption of several resolutions (including tax abatements and a contract extension), consideration of continuances for two petitions, and approval of a docket of petitions with no appeals. All votes were unanimous. Consent Calendar - Adoption of the November 2, 2022, meeting minutes. - Appointment of Bridget Robertson as acting secretary for the meeting (due to Commissioner Schumacher's absence). - Approval of Resolution 2022 R045: Authorizing the Director of DMD to extend the legal services agreement with Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP through December 31, 2023, for litigation related to city-owned properties at Town and Terrace housing complex. - Approval of Resolution 2022 R046: Authorizing $100,000 in funding to Intend Indiana Incorporated for a land‑banking program in coordination with DMD. - Approval of Resolution 2022 R047: Authorizing DMD to convey title or an option to purchase three properties to Intend Indiana Incorporated for the sale prices listed in Exhibit A, subject to commitments for neighborhood redevelopment. - Approval of Resolution 2022 C011: Authorizing DMD to contract for acquisition and relocation services. - Approval of the petitions of no appeals docket, comprising 10 petitions recommended for approval (2022 MOD 017, 2022 MOD 018, 2022 ZON 094 amended, 2022 ZON 113, 2022 ZON 115, 2022 CZN 839 amended, 2022 CZN 846, 2022 CZN 854, 2022 CZN 859, 2022 CZN 860). Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were made. Only staff members and a petitioner’s attorney addressed the commission. Discussion Items - Resolution 2022‑A‑027 (public hearing): Final economic revitalization area for RAISE Bio Inc. and PLDAB LLC at 5850 West 80th Street, Pike Township, Council District 1, with a four‑year real property tax abatement. No one spoke in opposition; the commission approved it unanimously. - Resolution 2022‑A‑028 (public hearing): Final economic revitalization area for RAISE Bio Inc. at the same address, with a four‑year personal property tax abatement. Approved unanimously. - Resolution 2022‑A‑029 (public hearing): Amendment to the terms of Resolution 2021‑A‑041 and the associated tax abatement agreement with Cook Indy Investments LLC and M&M Fresh Foods LLC (doing business as Indy Fresh Market). Staff noted that the address in the resolution (6190 East 38th Street) was corrected to 6160 East 38th Street, reflecting the same real estate. Approved unanimously. - Continuance request for 2022 CAP CVR 858 (3820 North Keystone): Petitioner’s new counsel requested a continuance to the December 7, 2022, meeting because the hearing examiner had issued a negative recommendation and the commission was not at full strength. Staff had no objection, and no remonstrators were present. The commission granted the continuance without additional notice. - Continuance request for 2022 VAC 002 (863 and 875 Massachusetts Avenue): Staff reported that the petitioner requested a final continuance to December 21, 2022, due to a funeral of a friend of the petitioner. The petition had been on the docket since July 2022, with ongoing discussions about trail impacts. The commission granted the continuance without additional notice. Key Outcomes - All votes were unanimous (5‑0) on each item: yes votes from Commissioners Blackburn, Robinson, Selm, Westrick, and Acting President Garver. - The meeting adjourned without further business.

PROCEDURAL 55% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 23% · LAND USE REGULATION 13% · PENDING LITIGATION 9%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com