Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 791–800 ENTRIES
791
MAY 17, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II Public Hearing - May 17, 2022

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II held a public hearing on May 17, 2022, at 6:00 PM, chaired by Craig E. Von Dalen, with members Beth Brandon, James Duke, and Joanna Taft present. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were also in attendance. The board addressed several petitions for variances, continuances, and withdrawals, and approved all expedited petitions unanimously. Procedural Matters - The board voted unanimously to waive its rules of procedure to allow a single vote on all expedited petitions, rather than voting on each separately. The motion was made by Joanna Taft, seconded by James Duke, and passed with all four members voting yes. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments or testimony from non-petitioners were presented during the hearing. Discussion Items - Continuance Request – 2022 DV209 (1635 South Sherman Drive): Petitioner Brent Bennett requested a two-month continuance to July 12, 2022, with notice, to amend the petition. Staff had no objection but noted this would be the final continuance supported. The board granted the continuance unanimously. - Expedited Docket Request – 2022 DV2-011 (1340 East 86th Street): Petitioner Joe Calderan requested moving the petition to the expedited docket, citing a letter of no objection from the neighborhood organization and staff recommendation for approval. Staff had no objection. The board voted unanimously to move it to the expedited docket. - Continuance Request – 2022 UV 206 (6215 North Tacoma Avenue & 2620 East 62nd Street): Petitioner David Kingan requested a two-month continuance to July 12, 2022, without notice, to meet with a neighboring property owner and obtain drainage engineer input. Staff had no objection but noted this would be the final continuance supported. The board granted the continuance unanimously. - Continuance Request – 2022 UV 2007 (1259 West 29th Street): Petitioner David Kingan requested a continuance to June 14, 2022, without notice, to provide additional information to staff. Staff supported the request. The board granted the continuance unanimously. - Withdrawal and Expedited Docket Request – 2022 DV2-013 (1609 Fletcher Avenue): Petitioner Mark Crouch withdrew a portion of the petition (requesting variances for side setbacks) as it was grandfathered, and requested moving the amended petition to the expedited docket. Staff recommended approval. The board voted unanimously to move it to the expedited docket. - Staff Requests: - Withdrawal of 2021 DV1077A (indecisive petition) acknowledged by the board. - Automatic continuances acknowledged for 2022 UV2-009 (1251 West 96th Street), 2022 UV2-010 (2400 Roosevelt Avenue), 2022 UV2-011 (1355 West 96th Street), and 2022 UV2-012 (automatic continuance to June 14, 2022). - Withdrawal of 2022 DV2-005 (1039 Kessler Boulevard East Drive) acknowledged. Key Outcomes - The board approved all expedited petitions in a single vote: 2022 DV2014 (5045 West Southport Road), 2022 DV2015 (1207 Madeira Street), 2022 UV2008 (1061 East Southern Avenue), 2022 DV2011 (1340 East 86th Street), and 2022 DV2013 (1609 Fletcher Avenue) – all with 4 yes votes. - Petition 2022 DV2016 (2932 North New Jersey Street) was approved with 3 yes votes (board member Taft recused). - Findings of fact for all approved petitions were adopted. - All continuances and withdrawals were granted as noted above.

PROCEDURAL 73% · ZONING AND LAND USE 22% · COMPLIANCE AND INTERNAL AUDIT 5%
792
MAY 10, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Indianapolis Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Hearing - May 10, 2022

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 met on May 10, 2022, at 18:15 UTC, with Chairperson Mark Young presiding and members Clinton McKay, Peter Nelson, Matt Boone, and Patrice Ducket Brown present. The board addressed numerous continuances, approved a slate of expedited petitions, and conducted a contested hearing on a fence and shed variance. Consent Calendar - 2022 DV1015 (1701 Hoy Ave): Variance to allow a single-family dwelling and detached garage/carriage house with a 5-foot corner side setback (8 feet required), a 2-foot rear setback (5 feet required), and a structure within the clear side triangle. Approved. - 2022 DV1020 (8197 Clearwater Point): Variance for a 2,291-square-foot addition with a 12-foot south side setback and a pool with a 10-foot south side setback (15 feet required), resulting in 78% lot open space (85% required). Approved. - 2022 DV1022 (4780 East 41st Street): Variance of development standards. Approved. - 2022 DV1024 (101 West Washington Street): Variance to allow a fifth skyline sign on one building (maximum four permitted). Approved. - 2022 DV2010 (2827 East 10th Street, amended): Variance to convert parking spaces into an outdoor seating area, resulting in one ADA parking space (17 parking spaces and one ADA space required). Approved. - 2022 UV1007 (3057 Park Avenue, amended): Variance of use and development standards for a residential triplex (not permitted) with a 6-foot north corner side setback (8 feet required). Approved. Special Requests and Procedural Actions - 2022 DV1025 (16 West Morris Street and 1150 South Meridian Street): Continued to the July 5 hearing (not transferred to Board 3 as requested) without additional notice. Approved. - 2022 UV1009 (8930 West Washington Street): Continued to the June 7 hearing without additional notice. Approved, with a remonstrator noting it was not timely filed and objecting to any further continuances. - 2022 UV1002 (2535 East 79th Street): Continued to the June 7 hearing without additional notice. Approved. - 2022 DV1019 (5329 and 5425 East Thompson Road): Continued to the June 7 hearing without additional notice. Approved. - 2022 DV1023 (4330 Michigan Road): Continued to the June 7 hearing without additional notice. Approved. - 2022 UV1011 (8620 West 82nd Street): Continued to the June 7 hearing without additional notice. Approved. - 2022 UV1007 (3057 Park Avenue): Moved to the expedited docket subject to the amended site plan. Approved. - 2022 DV1030 (8501–8515 West Washington Street): Approved a request to measure notification distance from the subject property instead of the entire airport perimeter. - 2022 UV1010 (2211–2219 and 2143 Prospect Street and 1121 Churchman Avenue): Continued to the June 7 hearing with additional notice (staff request for cause). Approved. - 2022 DV1021 (1868 Lafayette Road): Continued to the June 7 hearing, with notice if required. Approved. - 2022 DV1011 (1422 English Avenue): Acknowledged a timely automatic continuance to June 7. - 2022 DV1026: Acknowledged a timely automatic continuance. - 2022 DV1016 (1810 South Meridian Street): Acknowledged withdrawal of the petition. Discussion Items 2022 DV1018 – 9490 North Delaware Street - Request: Variance to allow a six-foot-tall fence in the front yard along 95th Street and to legally establish a shed within the front yard (maximum fence height 3.5 feet; minor residential structures not permitted in the front yard). - Petitioners’ testimony (Linda J. Griggs and T. Matthew Griggs): They own the property, built the shed in 1998, a four-foot fence in 2001, and a pool in 2006. They stated the 20-year-old fence needs replacement and a six-foot height is needed for pool safety, citing an incident where an eight-year-old neighbor climbed the fence. They presented a petition signed by all contiguous neighbors and letters of support, and noted the Nora Community Council supported the request with no objections. They also noted that 15 of 24 houses along 95th Street have fences. - Staff position: Staff recommended denial, stating that the shed and fence are in the front yard and that moving the fence back approximately 17 feet to align with the house’s front facade would bring it into compliance. Staff argued that fence height limitations preserve residential aesthetics, and that pool safety could be addressed through a pool cover or enclosing the pool. - Petitioners’ rebuttal: They argued that moving the fence would be impractical and financially burdensome due to existing landscaping and mounds, that a neighbor across the street (9461 N Delaware) was previously granted a similar variance, and that all contiguous neighbors signed in support. - Board action: The board voted 5–0 (Ducket Brown, Young, Boone, Nelson, McKay) to approve the variance. Key Outcomes - Approved all six expedited petitions in the consent calendar via a single unanimous motion. - Granted all requested continuances and transfers as listed above. - Approved the notification-area waiver for 2022 DV1030. - Approved 2022 DV1018 by a 5–0 vote.

ZONING AND LAND USE 71% · PROCEDURAL 29%
793
MAY 4, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
Metropolitan Development Commission Meeting - May 4, 2022

The Metropolitan Development Commission of Marion County, Indiana, met on May 4, 2022, at 6:00 PM. The meeting featured approvals of routine resolutions, continuances, and several public hearings, including a controversial rezoning for a women's recovery home, a parking lot variance in Broad Ripple, a major redevelopment project at the former GM stamping plant, and a multifamily development at McFarland Boulevard. The meeting was moved quickly with a stacked agenda. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: The minutes from the April 20, 2022, meeting were approved by voice vote. - Resolution Group Approval: Three resolutions (2022 E019, 2022 A007, and 2022 C003) were approved 8-0. Note: The secretary's earlier reading included 2022 A016 instead of 2022 A007, creating a discrepancy. - Continuances: - Resolution 2022 P006 (rules of procedure) continued to May 18, 2022. - 2022 ZON028 (4020 East 21st Street) continued to June 1, 2022. - 2022 MOD002 (1533 Lewis Street) and 2022 ZON007 (Barth Avenue) continued to May 18, 2022, pending commitments. - 2022 ZON029 (27 East 86th Street) automatically continued to June 1, 2022. Public Comments & Testimony Public comments were embedded within the public hearings listed below. Discussion Items - 2022 A016 – Aero Container LLC Tax Abatement: Public hearing for a seven-year personal property tax abatement at 6550 East 30th Street. Staff recommended approval. Motion passed 8-0. - Appeals and Improper Filings: Two cases were moved to the petitions of no appeals docket after the Commission found that the filer (Clark Collow) lacked standing. The cases were 2022 ZON017/2022 VAR002 (West 86th Street) and 2022 CZN810/2022 CVR810 (Washington Park Cemetery). Both were subsequently approved. - 2022 ZON012 – Overdose Lifeline Women's Recovery Home: Rezoning of 4903 and 4907 Winthrop Avenue from CS to CS (same district) to allow a women's recovery residence for up to 20 residents and their young children. Petitioner argued the use is less intense than the current hostel zoning. Remonstrators raised concerns about parking, traffic safety, and the facility's intensity. Staff supported approval. The Commission approved 7-1. - 2022 UV2005 – AudioCuck Parking Lot Variance: Variance of use and development standards to create a 15-space surface parking lot at 6360 Guilford Avenue in Broad Ripple. The lot would serve employees of AudioCuck, a podcast media company. The petition faced opposition from staff and a neighboring business owner (Tom Healy) who cited conflicts with the Envision Broad Ripple plan and the Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) overlay. Staff recommended denial. The Board of Zoning Appeals had previously approved it 4-1. Under MDC rules, a two-thirds vote (5 votes) was needed to defeat the approval. The motion to approve passed 5-2. - 2022 CZN824/2022 CPL824 – GM Stamping Plant Redevelopment: Rezoning and plat approval for 93.23 acres along the White River for a mixed-use development including a new bridge. The Commission expressed strong support, noting it would be the first new bridge built in Indianapolis in 50 years. Approved unanimously 7-0. - 2021 ZON146 – Homestead Development at McFarland Boulevard: Rezoning of 13.614 acres from SU1 to DP for a senior independent living facility and 172-unit multifamily housing. Remonstrators from McFarland Farms cited drainage issues, traffic, lack of green space, and school impacts. Staff recommended approval. The motion to approve failed, with all commissioners voting no. Key Outcomes - Approved: Minutes, resolutions 2022 E019, 2022 A007 (discrepancy noted), 2022 C003, 2022 A016. - Continued: 2022 P006, 2022 ZON028, 2022 MOD002, 2022 ZON007, 2022 ZON029. - Moved to No Appeals Docket: 2022 ZON017/2022 VAR002 and 2022 CZN810/2022 CVR810; subsequently approved. - Approved: 2022 ZON012 (7-1), 2022 UV2005 (5-2, upholding BZA approval), 2022 CZN824 and 2022 CPL824 (both 7-0). - Denied: 2021 ZON146 (motion failed unanimously).

ZONING AND LAND USE 39% · PROCEDURAL 12% · LAND USE REGULATION 10% · TRANSIT-ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT 9%
794
APR 20, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
Metropolitan Development Commission Public Meeting Summary - April 20, 2022

The Metropolitan Development Commission (MDC) held its regular public meeting on April 20, 2022, at approximately 6:00 PM. The meeting covered administrative approvals, tax abatement resolutions, continuances, and two contested zoning petitions. Key votes included the approval of a final economic revitalization area (8-1), denial of a rezoning for a mixed-use building on East 46th Street (8-1), and approval of a self-storage facility on East 42nd Street (7-1). Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: The minutes from the April 6, 2022 meeting were approved unanimously. - Bid Opening: Bids were opened for properties on the Central State Campus (3000 West Washington Street and 50 North Tibbs Avenue). Staff will evaluate and bring recommendations. - Resolution 2022 R019: Authorized conveyance of 11 properties to Renew Indianapolis for neighborhood redevelopment. Approved 9-0. - Resolution 2022 A014: Authorized a preliminary economic revitalization area for Aerol Container LLC (6550 East 30th Street) with a 7-year personal property tax abatement. Approved 9-0. - Resolution 2022 A015: Approved a final economic revitalization area for AOZI Brookville Building 1 LLC (5505 and 5705 Brookville Road) for a 1.2 million square foot speculative industrial building with up to 7-year real property tax abatement. Approved 8-1 (Commissioner Dillon dissented). Public Comments & Testimony 2021 ZON 116 (2201 East 46th Street) - Keith Monfrida (homeowner at 4538 Caroline Avenue) opposed the rezoning, citing insufficient parking, noise from outdoor music, and lack of benefit to the neighborhood. - Pastor George Williams (4514 Hillside, directly across from the property) opposed, complaining of excessive noise and parking overflow onto Hillside Avenue, which blocked access to his church property. He acknowledged recent improvements in noise. - Ivan Holder (organizer, Bel Air Neighborhood Association) expressed distrust based on prior misuse of approved uses (outdoor concerts beyond permitted microbrewery deck). He initially agreed to a massage therapy use but neighborhood opposition led him to oppose the broader rezoning. He requested documentation to enforce existing restrictions. 2022 ZON 006 (5815 East 42nd Street) - No remonstrators appeared at this hearing. Support letters were submitted from City Councillor Keith Graves, State Senator John Broden, and the Devinwood Communities Association, along with a petition signed by many neighbors. Discussion Items 2021 ZON 116 – Rezoning to Add Hair/Body Care Salon & Massage Therapy - Petitioner (Paul Carroll, Refinery 46 LLC) sought to rezone from CS to CS to add hair and body care salon/service (including a licensed massage therapist) to existing uses (offices, microbrewery with live music, training center). He argued the new use is less intense and would not expand the building footprint. He acknowledged prior unfulfilled commitments (landscaping, site plan) but stated progress was being made. - Staff (represented by hearing examiner) recommended denial, citing overdevelopment, disregard of 2016 commitments (landscaping not installed, dumpster unenclosed, missing site plan approval), and the site’s negative impact on the residential neighborhood. Staff noted the microbrewery had expanded into outdoor entertainment beyond permitted uses. - Remonstrators reiterated parking and noise complaints. The neighborhood association expressed lack of trust. - Vote: Motion to approve failed 1-8 (only Commissioner Westrick voted yes). The denial included a strong message about code enforcement follow-up. 2022 ZON 006 – Rezoning for Self-Storage Facility - Petitioner (Pat Rooney, Path to Prosperity LLC) sought to rezone a former IPS school (abandoned 30 years) to C7 to convert the existing building into indoor self-storage. The original plan included outdoor storage and additional buildings, removed in revised plans. Petitioner committed to limiting use to indoor storage, dedicating right-of-way, and working with the community on the surplus land (possible park). - Staff (Keith) opposed, citing the C7 district is inappropriate adjacent to single-family homes, the comprehensive plan designates suburban neighborhood, and that other reuses (charter school, church, multifamily) are possible. Staff noted the revised plans improved but still introduced heavy commercial zoning to a residential area. - Commission Discussion: Commissioner Hackett acknowledged the dilemma but noted the derelict building is a public nuisance. The petitioner agreed to an amended commitment confining use to indoor storage within the existing building. - Vote: Approved 7-1 (Commissioner Blackburn dissented). Key Outcomes - Approved (9-0): Minutes, Resolution 2022 R019, Resolution 2022 A014. - Approved (8-1): Resolution 2022 A015 (Brookville tax abatement). - Denied (8-1): 2021 ZON 116 (East 46th Street rezoning). The commission directed code enforcement to investigate parking and noise violations. - Approved (7-1): 2022 ZON 006 (East 42nd Street self-storage), with amended commitment 4 limiting use to indoor storage within the existing building and no expansion. - Continuances Granted: 2021 ZON 125 (to May 18), 2022 ZON 004 and 2022 ZON 007 (to May 4), 2021 ZON 149 (to May 18), and 2021 CZN 862A/B/CPL/CVR 862 (to May 4). The latter was continued over objections from a remonstrator; the commission warned no further continuances. - No-Appeal Docket: Eight petitions recommended for approval were passed unanimously (9-0).

ZONING AND LAND USE 64% · PUBLIC SAFETY 17% · PROCEDURAL 13% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 4%
795
APR 19, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Meeting – April 19, 2022

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III met on April 19, 2022 at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. Acting Chair Joanna Taft presided, with board members Cameron Radford, Roderick Bohannan, Percy Bland, and Brian Hannon. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and staff from the Division of Planning were also present. The agenda included special requests for continuances and withdrawals, approval of expedited petitions, and hearings on two contested variance petitions. The board also elected its officers for the year. Consent Calendar - All expedited petitions were approved in a single roll-call vote (5–0): - 2022-DV3-007 – Variance for a seven-story hotel with encroachment into Sky Exposure Plane Two and a nine-foot courtyard wall at 25 E McCarty St / 815 S Meridian St. - 2022-DV3-010 – Variance for a dumpster enclosure in the front yard at 450 S Meridian St (Rolls-Royce). - 2022-UV3-006 – Variance of use for vehicle sales and leasing at 3402 N Shadeland Ave. - 2022-DV3-011 – Variance for industrial development with additional parking and loading areas at 6900 English Ave (Lauth Group), subject to commitments. - 2022-DV3-012 – Variance for two digital-projection wall signs at 9115 Hague Rd (Roche Diagnostics), subject to commitments. - 2022-UV3-007 (amended) – Variance of use and development standards for a daycare/preschool and parking in the right-of-way at 3417 S Sherman Dr (Making Memories Daycare), with the pole sign portion withdrawn. - 2021-DV1-078 (amended) – Variance for a detached garage with reduced setbacks at 673 River Ave. Special Requests & Continuances The board granted several continuances and withdrew petitions as noted: - 2022-DV2-004 (5345 W 81st St) – Continued to May 24, 2022 without additional notice, pending revised site plan. - 2021-UV1-029 (3301 N Raceway Rd) – Withdrawn by petitioner; refund of filing fee (minus $100) authorized for related petition 2022-AP3-001. - 2022-DV3-004 (7557 Shelby St) – Continued to May 24, 2022 with notice. - 2022-DV3-009 (8630 Brookville Rd) – Continued to May 24, 2022 without additional notice. - 2022-UV3-005 (3017/3031 Chase St) – Continued to May 24, 2022 via automatic continuance by a registered neighborhood organization. - 2022-DV3-014 (337 Parkway Ave) – Continued to May 24, 2022 to provide legal notice. - 2022-DV3-013 (8418 Castle Farms Rd) – Granted a one-day waiver of legal notice requirement (moved to regular docket). Public Comments & Testimony No members of the public testified. All speakers were petitioners or their representatives. Discussion Items 2022-UV3-002 (3900 N Kitley Ave) – Petitioner David Cable, represented by Edwin Watson, requested a variance of use to allow a secondary dwelling unit where neither unit is owner-occupied and the entrance is not visible from a public right-of-way. The petitioner argued the unit would provide affordable housing and that financial hardship could lead to foreclosure. Staff recommended denial, citing the ordinance requirement for owner occupancy to prevent over-intensification in a single-family neighborhood and safety concerns regarding emergency access. The petitioner withdrew the entrance visibility variance and committed to relocating the door. However, the board voted 2–3 to deny the remaining variance (owner occupancy requirement). 2022-DV3-013 (8418 Castle Farms Rd) – Petitioner Scott Lemming requested a variance to place a 960-square-foot accessory structure 14 feet into a 20-foot drainage and utility easement. He proposed elevating the structure on piers to allow water flow or rotating it to reduce the encroachment. Staff recommended denial, stating the easement is critical for stormwater management and that adequate room exists elsewhere on the property. The board voted 0–5 to deny the petition. Election of Officers – The board elected Joanna Taft as Chair, Percy Bland as Vice Chair, and Roderick Bohannan as Secretary for the year. The board also announced a return to ballot voting starting in May 2022. Key Outcomes - Expedited petitions: All seven approved unanimously. - 2022-UV3-002: Denied (2–3) – staff recommendation upheld. - 2022-DV3-013: Denied (0–5) – staff recommendation upheld. - Continuances: Six cases continued to May 24, 2022; one petition withdrawn and refund authorized. - Officers elected: Taft (Chair), Bland (Vice Chair), Bohannan (Secretary). - Next meeting: May 24, 2022; ballot voting to be implemented.

ZONING AND LAND USE 53% · PROCEDURAL 31% · EASEMENT REGULATION 9% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 6%
796
APR 14, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 Meeting – April 14, 2022

The Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 met on April 14, 2022, at 1:00 PM to consider continuances, withdrawals, and variances on several properties. Chairperson Craig E. Von Dale presided, with board members James Duke, Patrice Duckett Brown, Beth Brandon, and Kurt Farmer in attendance. Staff presented recommendations, and public testimony was heard on two contested petitions. The board voted to deny a variance for a 14-unit apartment building on Elm Street, approved a variance for three skyline signs on an office building on 82nd Street, and approved a five-year use variance for a surface parking lot on Guilford Avenue. Consent Calendar (Procedural Actions) - Petition 2022 UV2‑006 (6215 N. Tacoma Ave. / 2620 E. 62nd St.): Continued to the May 17 hearing without notice unless the petition is amended. Motion carried unanimously (5‑0). - Petition 2022 DV2‑010 (2827 E. 10th St.): Continued and transferred to Board One’s May 10 hearing with additional notice. Motion carried unanimously (5‑0). - Petition 2021‑DB2‑038 (1042 Woodland Ave.): Withdrawal acknowledged unanimously. - Petition 2022‑DB2‑005 (1039 Kessler Blvd. E. Dr.): Continued to the May 17 hearing with additional notice (petitioner absent). Motion carried unanimously (5‑0). - Petition 2022‑DV2‑009 (1635 S. Sherman Dr.): Continued to the May 17 hearing with additional notice. Motion carried unanimously (5‑0). - Petition 2022‑DB2‑011 (1340 E. 86th St.): Automatic continuance to May 17 by a registered neighborhood organization acknowledged. - Petition 2022 UV2‑004 (3415 N. Sherman Dr.): Withdrawn; fees transferred to a new rezoning petition. Withdrawal acknowledged and transfer approved unanimously (5‑0). Public Comments & Testimony - On Petition 2022 UV2‑002 (Elm Street): - Jordan Ryan (president, North Square Neighborhood Association) stated the association opposed the development because it did not support the goals of the Equitable Transit‑Oriented Development (ETOD) overlay. She noted that rents would be $1,400‑$1,800/month and that developers were not interested in affordability incentives. She urged the board to set a precedent for development that creates affordable housing. - Jill Steinhauer (1027 Elm Street co‑owner) expressed concerns about increased traffic, alley flooding, lack of green space, and inadequate communication from the developer. She argued the project was too large for the site. - On Petition 2022 UV2‑005 (Guilford Avenue): - Murray Clark (attorney, Faegre Drinker) spoke in support of AudioChuck’s variance, highlighting the company’s community involvement and the innovative, limited nature of the five-year request. - During continuance discussion on 2022 UV2‑006: - You Bank Michaell (adjacent property owner) asked for additional notice if the petition is amended; the board acknowledged his concern. Discussion Items Petition 2022 UV2‑002 – 1035‑1043 Elm Street (14‑unit apartment building) Petitioner Hannah Abel and Mark Demerley (agent) presented an amended plan for a three‑story, 14‑unit medium apartment building in the D8 zone. The original variances for front/rear setbacks were eliminated; remaining variances sought were for use (medium apartment instead of small apartment), floor‑area ratio (FAR) of 1.19 (permitted 0.60), and livability space ratio of 0.46 (permitted 0.66). The site is in a TOD overlay. The petitioner argued the project meets TOD objectives, adds density near transit, and provides two‑bedroom units (10 two‑bedroom, 4 one‑bedroom) for families. Staff recommended denial, stating the site is too small for a medium apartment (10,454 sq ft vs. required 12,000 sq ft), the livability space ratio is 30.3% below requirement, and the proposed elevation is out of character with the single‑family neighborhood. The board voted to deny the petition (2 yes – Von Dale, Duke; 3 no – Duckett Brown, Brandon, Farmer). The petition was continued for adoption of findings of fact. Petition 2022 DB2‑012 – 3755 E. 82nd Street (three skyline signs) Petitioner Timothy E. Oaks (for Delta Wealth Advisors) requested a variance to allow three skyline signs on the north building elevation (one per facade permitted). The signs would replace signs that had existed for over 20 years. The building is a three‑story office building oriented toward 82nd Street; the petitioner argued that only the north facade is visible from the street and that the east and west facades are not effective for signage due to trees and orientation. The Greater Allisonville Community Council submitted a no‑objection letter. Staff recommended denial, stating that the east and west facades are partially visible and that ground sign alternatives exist, and that allowing three signs could lead to proliferation. The board approved the variance (4 yes – Duke, Duckett Brown, Brandon, Von Dale; 1 no – Farmer). Petition 2022 UV2‑005 – 6360 Guilford Avenue (surface parking lot) Petitioner David Gilman (for AudioChuck) requested a five‑year use variance to convert a gravel lot into a surface parking lot with 15 spaces, a 3.5‑foot decorative block wall, electric vehicle charging stations, bike racks, and public seating. The lot would serve AudioChuck’s employees at the nearby G‑Block building. The property is within the new TOD overlay district, which generally prohibits surface parking as a primary use. The petitioner argued the lot incorporates community amenities and is a temporary use while the company plans future mixed‑use development. Staff recommended denial, citing the TOD overlay’s intent to promote walkability and transit use, the availability of transit (0.26 miles to the Red Line bus stop), and the site’s potential for higher‑density development. The board approved the variance (4 yes – Duke, Duckett Brown, Brandon, Von Dale; 1 no – Farmer). The approval included the petitioner’s 10 written commitments, though staff expressed concerns about the enforceability of a five‑year limit. Key Outcomes - Petition 2022 UV2‑002 (Elm Street apartment): Denied (2‑3). Continued for adoption of findings of fact. - Petition 2022 DB2‑012 (82nd Street signs): Approved (4‑1). Variance granted for three skyline signs on the north elevation. - Petition 2022 UV2‑005 (Guilford Avenue parking lot): Approved (4‑1). Five‑year use variance and associated development standard variances granted, subject to the petitioner’s commitments. - All continuances and withdrawals were granted as noted in the Consent Calendar.

ZONING AND LAND USE 30% · PROCEDURAL 14% · SIGN REGULATION 14% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 12%
797
APR 5, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Public Hearing - April 5, 2022

This public hearing of the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 1, was held on April 5, 2022, at 6:15 PM. Acting Chairperson Mark Young presided, with board members Clinton McKay, Eduardo Luna, Brian Hannon (alternate), and Reina Napoleon (alternate). Legal counsel Chris Steimetz and planning staff were present. The meeting addressed special requests, continuances, and several variance petitions, including expedited and contested cases. Consent Calendar - The board voted unanimously to approve a single vote on all expedited petitions: 2021 DV1074, 2022 DV1017, 2022 DV1007, 2022 DV1009, 2022 UV1006, and 2022 UV1008. These petitions were moved to the expedited docket and approved collectively. Public Comments & Testimony - 2021 DV3058B (1523 Marlowe Ave): Remonstrator David Rustin (16 North State Ave) expressed concern that the developer ignored a stop-work order and continued construction, setting a dangerous precedent. Scotty Wilson, president of the Holy Cross Neighborhood Association, urged denial, citing self-imposed hardship and the risk of rewarding non-compliance. Tenants Bailey and Abigail spoke in support of 2022 UV3004 (3326 Ruckle St), emphasizing the importance of maintaining their affordable housing. - 2022 UV3004 (3326 Ruckle St): No remonstrators appeared. Letters of support from Midtown Indy and Councilor William Oliver were noted, highlighting the need for affordable housing. - 2022 DV1002 (7736 Zionsville Rd): No public testimony in opposition; petitioner Frederick Lawrence presented the revised plan. - 2022 DV1008 (9020 Rockville Rd): No remonstrators; support from Councilor Evans via letter. - 2022 DV1014 (1206-1210 Madeira St): Pastor David Bacon spoke in support of affordable housing; Stephen Stone (1202 Madeira St) expressed desire to purchase the adjacent lot himself but did not oppose the variance. Discussion Items - 2021 DV3058B (1523 Marlowe Ave): Petitioner sought variances for a two-family dwelling with reduced setbacks, three stories, and encroachment into clear sight triangle. Staff recommended denial, arguing the issues were self-imposed (design for two-family required third story). The board approved 3-2 (McKay no, Napoleon no; Luna, Hannon, Young yes). - 2022 UV3004 (3326 Ruckle St): Request to legalize a secondary dwelling unit (1,176 sq ft vs. 720 sq ft max) and waive owner-occupancy requirement. Staff recommended denial, citing overintensification and non-compliance with density. The petitioner argued the unit existed before purchase and provides affordable housing. Board approved 5-0. - 2022 DV1002 (7736 Zionsville Rd): Petitioner sought variances for unscreened roof equipment and a 10-foot fence with barbed wire. Staff supported the roof equipment variance but opposed barbed wire, citing lack of practical difficulty. Board split the vote: Part A (roof equipment) approved 5-0; Part B (barbed wire) approved 3-2 (Napoleon no, Young no? Actually transcription shows Napoleon no, Young yes; but votes: McKay aye, Luna yes, Hannon yes, Napoleon no, Young yes — so 3 yes? Wait: McKay aye, Luna yes, Hannon yes, Napoleon no, Young yes = 4 yes? Let's recount: transcript says:

ZONING AND LAND USE 57% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 14% · PROCEDURAL 8% · STREAM PROTECTION 8%
798
MAR 15, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Meeting - March 15, 2022

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III convened on March 15, 2022, to hear petitions for variances of use and development standards. The meeting included several continuances, withdrawals, and two substantive decisions: approval of an auto repair use variance and denial of a digital display sign variance. The board consisted of four members (Joanna Taft acting chair, Rodrigue Bohanan, Percy Bland Jr., and Brian Hannon), with legal counsel and staff present. Consent Calendar - 2022-DV3-002 (1206 St Paul Street): Withdrawn by petitioner; acknowledged by board. - 2021-UV3-017 (5930 Brookville Road): Withdrawn by petitioner; acknowledged by board. - 2022-DV3-007 (25 E McCarty Street / 815 S Meridian Street): Continued to April 19, 2022, without additional notice at petitioner's request. - 2022-UV3-002 (3900 N Kitley Avenue): Continued to April 19, 2022, with additional notice to allow amendment. - 2022-UV3-003 (3232 S Keystone Avenue): Withdrawn by petitioner; board acknowledged withdrawal and approved transfer of fees to a new rezoning petition (4-0 vote). - 2022-UV3-004 (3326 Ruckle Street): Continued and transferred to Board I on April 5, 2022, with additional notice due to notice deficiency. - 2022-DV3-004 (7557 Shelby Street): Continued to April 19, 2022, without additional notice due to petitioner seeking new counsel. - 2021-DV3-057 (8150 N Meridian Street): Withdrawn by petitioner; board acknowledged withdrawal over the objection of a neighbor. - 2021-DV3-058B (1523 Marlowe Avenue): Continued and transferred to Board I on April 5, 2022, after an indecisive vote at the previous hearing; board waived the rule requiring two indecisive votes before transfer (3-1 vote). - 2022-DV3-005 (2346 Redfern Drive): Approved on the expedited docket. Staff recommended approval; no remonstrators present. Vote: 3-0 (Bohanan yes, Hannon yes, Taft yes; Bland recused). Public Comments & Testimony - Kellen Kirschner (8160 N Meridian Street): Expressed concern over the withdrawal of 2021-DV3-057, stating the property is now for sale and requested the board hear the case to impose conditions on the fence. The board advised the neighbor to contact the Department of Business and Neighborhood Services for enforcement options. Discussion Items - 2022-UV3-001 (5990 E Raymond Street) – Auto Repair Use Variance: Petitioner David Gilman requested a variance to allow an automobile repair and service business (not permitted in C-3 zoning) with parking occupying 14% of the front setback (10% max) and a gate/fence within the clear sight triangle. Staff recommended denial, citing inconsistency with the Comprehensive Plan (rural/estate neighborhood) and concerns about commercial intensity. The petitioner presented a plan of operation with commitments including a five-year duration limit (amended from owner-specific). The board approved the variance as amended with three commitments: (1) adherence to the site plan and plan of operation, (2) petitioner-only (later changed to five-year duration), and (3) a five-year time limit from the date of approval. Vote: 4-0 (Bohanan yes, Bland yes, Hannon yes, Taft yes). - 2022-DV3-006 (9501 E Washington Street) – Digital Display Sign Variance: Petitioner Joe Calderon requested a variance to add a digital display element to an existing pole sign (prohibited on pole signs) located 350 feet from a protected district (600-foot separation required). Staff recommended denial, noting the sign could be converted to a pylon sign (which allows digital displays) and that the digital element would negatively impact the adjacent residential property at 9502 E Washington Street. The petitioner argued the poles are below grade, the residential structure is set back over 450 feet, and commitments included static display, no operation during overnight hours, and neighborhood support from Warren Township Development Association. The board denied the petition after a roll call vote: 1 yes (Hannon), 3 no (Bohanan, Bland, Taft). The petition was continued for adoption of findings of fact. Key Outcomes - 2022-UV3-001 approved (4-0) with commitments including a five-year duration, site plan compliance, and operational restrictions. - 2022-DV3-006 denied (1-3) due to proximity to protected district and lack of practical difficulty. - 2022-DV3-005 approved (3-0) on expedited docket for a single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks along I-465 and Keystone Avenue. - 2021-DV3-058B continued and transferred to Board I after indecisive vote; board waived two-indecisive-vote rule (3-1). - Remaining petitions withdrawn, continued, or transferred as noted in Consent Calendar. - Board announced a training session on March 29, 2022, via WebEx.

ZONING AND LAND USE 48% · PROCEDURAL 24% · SIGN REGULATION 21% · TRANSPORTATION 4%
799
MAR 8, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II Public Hearing - March 8, 2022

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II held a public hearing on March 8, 2022, at 6:00 PM. The meeting was chaired by Craig E. Von Dalen, with members James Duke, Patrice Duckett Brown, Beth Brandon, and Kirk Farmer present. Legal counsel was Chris Steinmetz, and staff from the Division of Planning attended. The agenda included continuances, withdrawals, expedited petitions, and a public hearing on a variance request for a proposed 14-unit apartment building on Elm Street. Consent Calendar - The board approved a waiver of rules to vote on all expedited petitions in a single vote, allowing approval of findings of fact collectively. The motion passed unanimously (5-0). - Five expedited petitions were read and approved via a single roll-call vote (5-0): - 2022 DV2-007: 3001 West 60th Street – variance for a single-family dwelling on a 2.78-acre parcel (minimum 3 acres required, 20 ft frontage, 40 ft lot width). - 2022 UV2-003: 2802 Central Avenue – variance of use for a dog grooming business. - 2022 DV2-006: 2216 and 2228 North College Avenue – variance for a three-story mixed-use building with direct vehicular access to College Avenue. Public Comments & Testimony - Jill Steinhauer (co-owner of 1027 Elm Street): Expressed opposition to the proposed 14-unit apartment building. She raised concerns about parking congestion on the street, difficulty backing out of the alley (a one-way alley), potential for increased trash and noise from a rooftop party deck, and disappointment that the vacant lots were not maintained. She urged the board to deny exceptions and require the project to comply with all zoning standards. - Ethan Gilmer (resident of 1045 Elm Street and owner of 1051 Elm Street): Shared similar concerns about parking, noting that street parking is already limited. He asked how many parking spaces were planned and expressed worry about the scale of the building fitting the family-oriented street. He also acknowledged that the empty lots have been a nuisance and that some activity is welcome, but he opposed the proposed density. Discussion Items - Petition 2022 UV2-002 – 1035, 1039, 1041, 1043 Elm Street: Hannah Abel (Demerley Architects) presented a request for a variance of use and development standards to allow a three-story, 14-unit medium apartment building (not permitted in the D8 zoning district) with reduced setbacks (1.5 ft rear setback vs. 10 ft required), a floor area ratio (FAR) of 1.29 (max 0.60), and a livability space ratio (LSR) of 0.25 (min 0.66). The petitioner argued that the two additional units (beyond the 12-unit small apartment permitted) provide a buffer for covered parking at the rear, and that the building is close to the Red Line transit. They added a green roof and gym to improve LSR, but staff noted that the green roof is not usable space and cannot be counted. Staff recommended denial, stating the proposal represents overdevelopment; the lot size (10,400 sq ft) does not meet the 12,000 sq ft minimum for a medium apartment, and the variances are self-imposed since a 12-unit small apartment could be built without most variances. The petitioner requested a continuance to refine the plan. The board granted the continuance to the April 12, 2022 meeting (note: the petitioner had requested April 19, 2022, but the board voted for April 12th). The petitioner also withdrew the front setback variance request, as they now meet the required 7.5 ft setback. Key Outcomes - Continuances (all passed unanimously, 5-0): - 2022 DV2-004 (5345 West 81st Street): Continued to April 19, 2022, and transferred to Board 3 at the petitioner’s request (to allow additional neighborhood meeting). Staff noted this would be the final continuance supported. - 2021 DV1-077A (715 South Keystone Avenue): Continued to May 17, 2022, without additional notice. - 2022 DV2-005 (1039 Kessler Boulevard East Drive): Continued to April 12, 2022, with new notice (petitioner absent; required for fence height and location issues). - Withdrawal acknowledged: 2021 DV2-057 (10 South Capitol Avenue) – withdrawn by petitioner. - Expedited petitions approved: As listed above in the Consent Calendar. - Elm Street case (2022 UV2-002): Continued to April 12, 2022, with additional notice if needed. The front setback variance was withdrawn. The petitioner is to revise plans and return. - Findings of fact: The board adopted findings of fact for petitions approved during the meeting, and members signed them.

ZONING AND LAND USE 41% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 25% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 19% · PROCEDURAL 14%
800
MAR 1, 2022 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division One Public Hearing - March 1, 2022

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division One held a public hearing on March 1, 2022, at 6:00 PM. Acting Chairperson Mark Young presided over the meeting, with board members Clinton McKay, Peter Nelson, and Eduardo Luna present. Legal counsel was Chris Steinmetz, and staff from the Division of Planning included Principal Planner 2 Eddie Honey, Senior Planner Jeffrey York, Senior Planner Robert Ulenhaik, Senior Planner Marlena Urretha, Associate Planner Genesis Heal, and Senior Specialist Heather Steffen. The meeting addressed numerous petitions for variances of use and development standards, including expedited items, continuances, and contested cases. Consent Calendar - The board approved a waiver of rules to vote on all expedited petitions in a single vote. The following petitions were approved unanimously (4-0) on the expedited docket: - 2022 DV1010 (3021 Southeastern Avenue) – variance for fast food restaurant with stacking spaces in front yard. - 2022 UV1003 (Beachway Drive) – variance for expansion of grocery store. - 2022 DV1006 (11420 East McGregor Road) – variance for lot split. - 2021 UV1039 (758 East Terrace Avenue) – variance for duplex construction with reduced setbacks. - 2022 DV1012 (726 Cottage Avenue) – variance to legally establish a duplex. - 2022 UV1004 (1131 Jefferson Avenue) – variance for single-family dwelling and detached garage with reduced side setbacks. - Several continuances and waivers of sign posting requirements were also approved, including requests for 2022 DV1010, 2022 UV1003, 2022 DV1006, 2022 DV1013 (9625 East McGregor Road), 2021 UV1039, 2022 DV1012, and 2022 UV1004, as well as continuances for 2021 DV1074, 2022 DV1007, 2022 DV1002, 2022 DV1011, and 2021 DV1078. Public Comments & Testimony - 2021 UV1032 (5170 Evanston Avenue – Pickleball Court): Several neighbors and the Bel Air Neighborhood Association spoke in opposition, citing concerns about noise, traffic, parking, privacy, and the commercial nature of the proposed use in a residential area. Jeff McGill (5171 Evanston Avenue) stated the recreational facility was inappropriate for the neighborhood. Lorreen Regulus (5140 Evanston Avenue) objected to the variance, arguing the project would disrupt community character, attract undesirable attention, and burden infrastructure. Ivan Holder (Bel Air Neighborhood Association) expressed uncertainty about the operation of the event space and lack of detail regarding management. - 2021 DV1077A/C (715 South Keystone Avenue – Fence): The petitioner, Christopher Renteria, testified in favor of his fence modifications, emphasizing reduced opacity and improvements since the prior hearing. - 2021 UV1038 (3117/3115 Sutherland Avenue – Beauty Salon): Petitioner Janine Edison argued the unique topography and SU-34 zoning created a hardship, and that the use was consistent with the comprehensive plan. No public opposition was voiced. - 2022 DV1008 (9020 Rockville Road – Fast Food Restaurant): The petitioner, Nick Justice, and property owner representative Jim Mosier, presented arguments for the requested variances, including high parking demand, stream corridor constraints, and a double drive-thru design. No public opponents appeared. - 2022 DV1013 (9625 East McGregor Road – Barn): Petitioner Richard Calvert explained his siting choice due to septic system and floodplain constraints. No public opposition was noted. Discussion Items - 2021 DV1077A & C (715 South Keystone Avenue – Fence): The petitioner sought approval for a corrugated metal fence (A) and a fence encroaching into the clear side triangle (C). Staff recommended denial for both, citing material incompatibility with residential neighborhoods (A) and continued obstruction of sightlines (C). The board voted on A: indecisive (2 yes, 2 no), resulting in automatic continuance to Division 2. For C, the board approved (3-1) subject to a commitment limiting the fence height, but continued for adoption of findings of fact. - 2021 UV1032 (5170 Evanston Avenue – Pickleball Court): The petition sought a use variance for indoor/outdoor recreation and entertainment, plus development standards variances for open space, rear setback, and parking. Staff recommended denial, arguing the use would disrupt residential character, that parking would burden the neighborhood, and that the proposal contradicted the comprehensive plan. The board denied the petition unanimously (0-4). - 2021 UV1038 (3117/3115 Sutherland Avenue – Beauty Salon): The petition requested variances for beauty salon, office, retail uses, and a sign setback. Staff recommended denial due to lack of demonstrated hardship and inconsistency with the comprehensive plan. The petitioner highlighted her 25-year history and community support. The board approved the petition unanimously (4-0). - 2022 DV1008 (9020 Rockville Road – Fast Food Restaurant): The petition involved six variances for parking, stream protection corridor, drive-thru design, and landscaping. Staff recommended denial, citing self-imposed hardships and ordinance alternatives. The petitioner requested a continuance to work with staff; the board granted a continuance to April 5, 2022, without additional notice. - 2022 DV1013 (9625 East McGregor Road – Barn): The petitioner sought a reduced side setback for a barn. Staff recommended denial, asserting no practical difficulty. The petitioner argued floodplain concerns and cited a nearby precedent. The board approved the variance unanimously (4-0). Key Outcomes - Expedited petitions: All six expedited items approved (4-0). - 2021 DV1077A: Indecisive vote (2-2) – automatically continued to Division 2 meeting on March 8, 2022. - 2021 DV1077C: Approved (3-1) subject to commitment, with findings of fact continued. - 2021 UV1032: Denied (0-4) – findings of fact continued. - 2021 UV1038: Approved (4-0) – findings of fact continued. - 2022 DV1008: Continued to April 5, 2022, without additional notice. - 2022 DV1013: Approved (4-0). - Various continuances: Granted for 2021 DV1074, 2022 DV1007, 2022 DV1002, 2022 DV1011, and 2021 DV1078.

ZONING AND LAND USE 78% · PROCEDURAL 5% · ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION 5% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 3%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com