Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 811–820 ENTRIES
811
NOV 9, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 Public Hearing - November 9, 2021

Chair Mark Young called the meeting to order at 6:00 PM on November 9, 2021. Board members present included Roderick Bohan, Austin (Division 1), Peter Nelson, Mary Kelly, and James Duke. Legal Counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff (Jeffrey York, Robert Ewan Hake, Eddie Honia, Marlena Arretta, Genesis Hill, Heather Stephens) were also present. The hearing addressed several variance petitions, including requests for continuances, an expedited case, and administrative matters. Special Requests & Continuances - Mark Demerly requested to expedite case 2021 DV2059 (1954 Bellefontaine Street) for a two-family dwelling variance. Staff noted an initial opposition inquiry but believed the opposing party would not attend. The board voted unanimously (Bohan yes, Kelly yes, Duke yes, Nelson yes) to move it to the expedited docket. - David King requested a continuance for case 2021 UV2019 (5060 East 62nd Street) to December 14, 2021, without new notice, to meet with the Benford neighborhood group and modify the petition. Staff had no objection. The board unanimously approved the continuance. - Jeff Bellamy requested a continuance for case 2021 DV2057 (10 South Capitol Avenue) to January 11, 2022, with notice, to incorporate staff comments. Staff had no objection. The board unanimously approved. - Staff reported case 2021 DV2058 (8136 East Southport Road) had deficient notice and requested transfer to the November 16, 2021 hearing of Board 3. The board unanimously approved the transfer. - Staff acknowledged the withdrawal of case 2021 UV2020 (1005 East 86th Street) and the automatic continuance of case 2021 DV2060 (1426 Pleasant Street) to December 14, 2021, filed by a registered neighborhood group. The board acknowledged both. Expedited Petition - Case 2021 DV2059 (1954 Bellefontaine Street) by Tee It High and Let It Fly LLC (Mark Demerly) was heard as expedited. The petition sought a variance of development standards for a two-family dwelling: a 3.5-foot side setback (required: 4 feet), a detached garage with 3.5-foot south side setback, 55% open space (required: 50%), and an 8-foot separation between primary dwellings (required: 10 feet). No opposition was present. The board voted unanimously to approve. Other Business - The board adopted revised findings for previously approved case 2021 DV2053 (address on 42nd Street) as signed by members Young, Duke, and Nelson. Key Outcomes - All votes were unanimous. Continuances were granted as requested. The expedited variance was approved. The deficient-notice case was transferred. The withdrawal and automatic continuance were acknowledged. Revised findings were adopted.

PROCEDURAL 63% · ZONING AND LAND USE 37%
812
NOV 2, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Public Hearing - November 2, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 held a public hearing on November 2, 2021, at 6:00 PM. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided, with board members Beth Brandon, Roderick Bohanan, Percy Bland, and Clint McKay. The meeting addressed continuances, withdrawals, an expedited docket, and three non-expedited variance petitions. Staff recommended denial of two non-expedited petitions, but the board approved one and continued another. Consent Calendar - Expedited Docket (4 petitions): The board voted unanimously to approve all four expedited variance petitions (2021 DV1065, DV1066, DV1067, and DV2036) in a single vote after no opposition was voiced. These included variances for a detached garage, porch addition, hot tub/patio, and detached garage with porch addition, each with specific dimensional variances. Procedural Actions - Fee Waiver: The board granted a fee waiver to $0 (from a $50 minimum) for the Office of Public Health and Safety to establish a temporary homeless shelter at 2107 North Riley Avenue. The vote was unanimous. - Continuances and Withdrawals: Multiple petitions were continued or withdrawn by request or automatically due to neighborhood organization filings. Key continuances included 2021 UV1021 (to December 7), 2021 DV2056 (transferred to November 16 hearing), 2021 DV1051 (to December 7 with additional notice), and automatic continuances for 2021 UV1026, 1027, 1028, and 1029 to December 7. Withdrawals were acknowledged for 2021 DB1049 and 2021 DV1068. Discussion Items - 2021 UV1024 – 8356 Lafayette Road (Auto Sales Variance): Petitioner Carmen Tude sought a variance of use for classic car sales and restoration in a C4 zone. The Pike Township Residents Association (PTRA) negotiated commitments, including limiting cars for sale to 10 and restoration vehicles to 10, landscape improvements, and closing a south entrance. Staff recommended denial, citing incompatibility with the comprehensive plan, lack of sewer/water, gravel parking, and potential for more intense use. The board voted 4-1 (Taft dissenting) to approve with PTRA’s commitments, subject to staff approval of an updated plan of operation and site plan. - 2021 UV1030 – 4628 East Edgewood Avenue (Concrete Contractor Variance): Petitioner Epifanio Carbajal requested a variance to legally establish a concrete contractor business with outdoor storage of trucks, trailers, and machinery. The property is in an agricultural zone but used for parking equipment. Remonstrators from nearby neighborhoods expressed concerns over traffic, noise, dust, environmental impacts, and lack of growth limits. A remonstrator requested a continuance for further study. The board granted a continuance to December 7, 2021. - 2021 UV1031 – 1919 Broad Ripple Avenue (Professional Office Variance): Petitioner Russell Brown, representing My Broad Ripple Inc., sought a variance to use a former residential property for a law office. The Broad Ripple Village Association supported the variance. Staff recommended denial, urging rezoning to C1 instead of using a variance. The board voted 5-0 to approve the variance, subject to the plan of operation limiting the office to five employees. Key Outcomes - Approved: 2021 UV1024 (auto sales) with conditions (4-1); 2021 UV1031 (professional office) unanimously. - Continued: 2021 UV1030 (concrete contractor) to December 7, 2021. - Expedited petitions: All four approved unanimously. - Fee waiver: Granted for temporary homeless shelter. - Findings of fact: Adopted from previous hearings (July 6 and August 3, 2021) and from the current date. The meeting adjourned after the board completed its business.

ZONING AND LAND USE 57% · PROCEDURAL 21% · PUBLIC SAFETY 6% · LAND USE REGULATION 6%
813
OCT 19, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 3 Public Hearing - October 19, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 3 held a public hearing on October 19, 2021, at 6:15 PM. The meeting covered two expedited petitions, one withdrawal, one continuance for cause, and two full hearings. Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen presided. Key decisions included approval of expedited petitions, a continuance for a development standards case, and denial of a variance for an electronic variable message sign (EVMS) at a Culver's restaurant. Special Requests and Procedural Matters - The board unanimously waived rules of procedure to vote on expedited petitions in a single vote. - Petition 2021 DV3031 (5859 Forest Lane) was withdrawn at the petitioner's request on October 14, 2021; the board acknowledged the withdrawal. - Petition 2021-SE3-003 (2659 Sutherland Avenue) was continued for cause without notice to the next hearing on November 16, 2021, to clarify a discrepancy regarding the proposed use. No remonstrators appeared. - For expedited petition 2021 UV1-025 (1657 North College Avenue), staff noted a letter of opposition from a registered neighborhood organization, but no remonstrators were present in the audience, so the petition remained on the expedited docket. Expedited Petitions - 2021 DV3051 – 1867 New Street: Variance for a detached garage in the clear side triangle. Approved unanimously (5-0). - 2021 UV1025 – 1657 North College Avenue: Variance for a dwelling/garage addition to a multifamily dwelling. Approved unanimously (5-0). Full Hearing: 2021 DV1-046 (1540-1544 Ring Gold Avenue) - Petitioner Mark Crouch requested variances of development standards for two parcels (single-family dwellings with reduced setbacks and 50% open space). Staff had recommended approval if a duplex or single-family dwelling was built on each parcel with specific setbacks. - During the hearing, the petitioner asked to allow townhomes (separate ownership) on the two lots. Staff opposed, noting that townhomes are not permitted in the D5 zoning district and would require a separate use variance with additional notice. - The petitioner then requested a continuance to November 16, 2021, with notice, to work with staff on the townhome option. The board granted the continuance unanimously (5-0). Full Hearing: 2021 DV3047 (7010 East 21st Street – Culver's) - Petitioner Trey Watts (Springfield Sign, representing Culver's) requested a variance of development standards to replace an existing manual copy board on a 25-foot pylon sign with a digital EVMS. Digital signs are not permitted in the C3 district. - The petitioner argued that an EVMS allows dynamic imagery, employee safety (no ladder use), and the ability to display content across language barriers. He offered commitments: (1) give up the right to install EVMS on the building (already permitted), (2) limit message changes to once per hour with instantaneous transitions, (3) limit sign operation to 30 minutes after closing until 30 minutes before opening. - Staff recommended denial, citing safety concerns near a signalized intersection (Shadeland Avenue and East 21st Street), the recent 2019 sign ordinance update, and the absence of practical difficulty since the site operated for decades without an EVMS. Staff noted the Warren Township Development Association had not submitted a letter of support, despite the petitioner's claim of verbal support. - Board members asked questions about size, operation, and commitments. The board voted 4-1 to deny the variance. Member Anatoli Boshenko voted yes; members Janice Golson Dunlop, Jim Rawlinson, David Duncan, and Chair Von Dalen voted no. The denial includes adoption of findings of fact at a later date. Key Outcomes - Approved Expedited Petitions: 2021 DV3051 and 2021 UV1025 (both 5-0). - Continued: 2021 DV1-046 (Ring Gold Avenue) to November 16, 2021, with additional notice (5-0). - Denied: 2021 DV3047 (Culver's sign variance) with 1 yes, 4 no votes. - Adjourned: Meeting concluded after the final case; no further business.

ZONING AND LAND USE 45% · SIGN REGULATION 39% · PROCEDURAL 12% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 4%
814
OCT 12, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two Meeting - October 12, 2021

Chairperson Mark Young presided over the meeting of the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division Two, on October 12, 2021, at 6:00 PM. The board considered multiple continuances, transfers, and variance petitions. Votes were taken on expedited cases and three full hearing cases. The meeting included public testimony from remonstrators and staff recommendations. Consent Calendar - Waiver of Rules for Expedited Petitions: Approved unanimously (5-0) to allow a single vote on expedited petitions. - Expedited Petitions: The following petitions were approved in a single vote (5-0): - 2021 DV2041 (6720 Telecom Drive) – variance for trash enclosure and transparency. - 2021 DV2054 (1218 North Keystone Avenue) – variance for front and rear setbacks. - 2021 DV3046 (1202 South Meridian Street) – variance for parking spaces and curb cuts. - 2021 EV2017 (4917 West Minnesota Street) – variance for triplex (moved to expedited at hearing). Public Comments & Testimony - 2021 UV2015 (4822 Man Road): Terry Sylvester, representing the Decatur Township Civic Council, opposed the billboard relocation, citing eight variances from 16 standards, safety concerns, and the community's interest in upholding the 2016 sign ordinance. Sarah Schwemeyer read a letter from City-County Councillor Jared Evans formally opposing the petition, stating the variances would undermine the ordinance and community interests. - 2021 DV2053 (6732 East 42nd Street): No public comments from remonstrators; only the petitioner testified. - 2021 DV2055 (2958 Washington Boulevard): No public comments from remonstrators; only the petitioner testified. Discussion Items - 2021 DV2053 (6732 East 42nd Street) – Shed and Fence Variance: Petitioner Brandon Hatcher requested a variance to keep a 338-square-foot shed in the front yard and a six-foot fence (later reduced to 42 inches). Staff recommended denial, citing the ability to relocate or reduce the structure. The board discussed the lot's corner configuration and the fence's location in the clear site triangle. The petitioner noted neighborhood support and security needs. The variance was approved 3-2 (Nelson, Duke, Young in favor; Reuter, Kelly opposed). Findings of fact to be adopted later. - 2021 UV2015 (4822 Man Road) – Billboard Relocation Variance: Petitioner John Campbell (Reagan Outdoor Advertising) sought eight variances to relocate an existing billboard 20 feet due to INDOT right-of-way expansion. The billboard had been on site for 37 years. Staff recommended approval, noting the government-imposed practical difficulty and potential takings liability. Remonstrators argued the variances were excessive and violated the 2016 sign ordinance. The board discussed the historical context and changes in the area. The variance was approved 4-1 (Kelly, Nelson, Duke, Young in favor; Reuter opposed). - 2021 DV2055 (2958 Washington Boulevard) – Detached Garage Variance: Petitioner Nathaniel Weyman requested a variance for a 24x20-foot detached garage with zero-foot side setbacks and 35% open space. Staff recommended denial, citing the lot's deficiency and the possibility of a smaller structure. The petitioner noted the lot's unusual shape and the need for secure parking. The board questioned the neighbor's garage placement. The variance was approved 5-0. Key Outcomes - Continances and Transfers: - 2021 DV2057 (10 South Capitol Ave) – Continued to November 9, 2021, with notice (unanimous). - 2021 DV2056 (649 Birch Ave) – Transferred to BZA Division 1 on November 2, 2021 (unanimous). - 2021 DV2038 (1042 Woodlawn Ave) – Continued to December 14, 2021, without additional notice; final continuance supported by staff (unanimous). - 2021 UV2016 (804 East Laverack Rd) – Continued and transferred to BZA Division 3 on November 16, 2021, without notice (unanimous). - 2021 UV2019 (5060 East 62nd St) – Continued to November 9, 2021, without notice (unanimous). - Votes on Full Hearing Cases: - 2021 DV2053: Approved (3-2), findings deferred. - 2021 UV2015: Approved (4-1). - 2021 DV2055: Approved (5-0). - Adoption of Findings: The board adopted findings for petition 2021 DV2043 (previously denied) and other findings from the hearing.

ZONING AND LAND USE 37% · SIGN REGULATION 32% · PROCEDURAL 16% · LAND USE REGULATION 10%
815
OCT 5, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division One Public Hearing - October 5, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division One, chaired by Joanna Taft, held a public hearing on October 5, 2021, with four members present. The board heard continuances, special requests, expedited petitions, and three contested cases. Key decisions included the denial of a self-storage facility variance, a tied vote continuing a dog daycare expansion, and approval of a secondary dwelling unit for a veteran. Consent Calendar - The board voted 4-0 to waive rules of procedure, allowing a single vote on all expedited petitions. - Continuances granted: - 2021 DV1051 (3019 Roosevelt Ave) continued to November 2, 2021, without notice; staff indicated this would be the last continuance supported. - 2021 UV1025 transferred to BZA3 October 19, 2021, without notice. - 2021 UV1015 (929 Standard St) continued to December 7, 2021, with notice. - Automatic continuances acknowledged: - 2021 UV1024 (8356 Lafayette Rd) – timely automatic continuance to November 2, 2021. - 2021 UV1021 (929 Standard St) – automatic continuance to November 2, 2021. - Off-docket petition 2021 HOV032 (1230 Pleasant St) continued to a future date. Public Comments & Testimony - 2021 DV3040 (self-storage facility): Remonstrators Vernon Compton (Brightwood Concerned Citizen), Paula Brooks (Hoosier Environmental Council), and Jacqueline McMillan Gunn (Martindale Brightwood Co-compliance and Land Use) opposed the variance. They argued insufficient parking (only 5 spaces available for customers after employees), lack of ADA ramp at Roosevelt entry, dangerous traffic, underground storage tanks, and environmental justice concerns for an overburdened neighborhood. - 2021 DV1049 (Uptown PUP expansion): Remonstrators Daniel Burke (attorney for 54th Street LLC), Hugh and Harry Kenurk (owners of adjacent property), Emily Conerk (tenant), and David Clapper (owner of neighboring shopping center) opposed the expansion. They cited excessive noise from barking dogs disrupting tenant businesses, inadequate parking leading to spillover and liability, and stormwater drainage issues from recent paving. - 2021 UV1022 (secondary dwelling): No remonstrators spoke. Petitioner Mark Crouch presented the case for the veteran owner, emphasizing the need for convalescent care and the owner's desire to avoid additional costs of lot splitting. Discussion Items - 2021 DV3040 (3019 Roosevelt Ave, self-storage): Petitioner Russell Brown (Clark Quinn law firm) represented Inland Real Estate Acquisitions/Devon Self-Storage. The request was to reduce parking from 26 required to 9 spaces (plus 2 loading) for an 800-unit self-storage facility in an existing I-3 warehouse. Brown argued that based on operator experience, a fully leased facility averages 10 customer visits per day, and that the site plan includes street trees, bike parking, and at-grade entry. Staff recommended approval, citing the permitted use and periodic customer visits. The board voted 4-0 to deny. - 2021 DV1049 (Uptown PUP expansion): Petitioners Kathleen Shonsek and Amanda Stetzel (owners) and attorney Joe Calderon sought to expand an existing dog daycare/boarding facility. They proposed demolishing a rear building, connecting it to the front, and adding a covered outdoor play area. They argued the expansion would improve safety, reduce noise via soundproofing, and add jobs. Staff recommended approval with three commitments: (1) submitted site plan, (2) proposed soundproofing improvements (noting an 8-foot fence would require a separate variance), and (3) a plan of operation limiting outdoor dogs to 5 at a time and hours 7am–8pm with a quiet period 1–3pm. The board voted 2-2 (Bohannan and Brandon yes, Bland and Taft no), resulting in an automatic continuance to November 2, 2021, without additional notice. - 2021 UV1022 (8630 E 38th St, two dwellings): Petitioner Mark Crouch requested a variance of use and development standards to legalize an existing second dwelling unit and allow expansion for a veteran needing care. Staff recommended denial, stating the property could be used as a single-family residence or the lot could be split. Crouch argued that splitting would impose additional costs and that the property had been used as two dwellings for decades. The board voted 3-1 (Bohannan, Brandon, Bland yes; Taft no) to approve the variance, with the understanding that the open space variance was unnecessary since the actual open space exceeded 85%. Key Outcomes - 2021 DV3040: Denied by a vote of 4-0. Findings of fact to be adopted in a future hearing. - 2021 DV1049: Tied vote 2-2, automatically continued to November 2, 2021, hearing without additional notice. - 2021 UV1022: Approved by a vote of 3-1. Variance granted for two single-family dwellings on one lot; open space variance not required. - 2021 AP1001 (fee waiver): Approved by a vote of 3-1 (Taft dissenting), waiving the $50 filing fee for the waiver petition. - Findings of fact: The board secretary noted that findings for previously approved cases (including 2021 UV1013) could not be adopted due to missing signature of member McKay, not present.

ZONING AND LAND USE 57% · PROCEDURAL 23% · PARKING MANAGEMENT 5% · ANIMAL WELFARE 4%
816
SEP 21, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Three Meeting - September 21, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Three convened on September 21, 2021, at 6:00 PM (ET) under Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen. The board addressed multiple continuances, withdrawals, expedited petitions, and two full variance hearings. Key decisions included approval of a four-lot subdivision on Acton Road and approval of an illuminated digital sign for a church on Shelby Street. Continuances and Withdrawals - 2021 DV3040 (3019 Roosevelt Ave): Continued and transferred to Division 1 on October 5, 2021, without additional notice (petitioner's first request). - 2021 DV3038 (8860 Zionsville Rd): Continued to November 16, 2021, with additional notice. - 2021 DV3046 (1202 S Meridian St): Continued and transferred to Division 2 on October 12, 2021, with additional notice; a waiver of 5 days notice also approved. - 2021 DV3031 (5859 Forest Lane): Continued to October 19, 2021, without additional notice despite opposition from neighboring property owners (represented by Attorney Greg Zubek) who cited multiple continuances and lack of progress. Staff had no objection. Approved 5-0. - 2021 DV3002 (114 E 49th St): Withdrawn, acknowledged. - 2021 DV3018 (8355 N Pennsylvania St): Withdrawn, acknowledged. - 2021 DV3047 (710 E 21st St): Automatic continuance to October 19, 2021, acknowledged. - 2021 UV3011 (449 N Arsenal Ave): Withdrawn; fees transferred for rezoning refiling (approved 5-0). - 2021 SE3001 (1718 & 1722 Olive St): Withdrawn (no opposition present). - 2021 SE3003 (2659 Sutherland Ave): Continued to October 19, 2021, with additional notice (approved 5-0). Public Comments & Testimony - For 2021 DV3031 (5859 Forest Lane), attorney Greg Zubek, representing adjacent homeowners Scott and Jane Ann Himsel, opposed the continuance. He stated that the petitioner had already received an automatic continuance and a prior continuance for cause, and that no updated plans had been submitted. He noted that staff recommended denial, the neighborhood association voted to recommend denial, and 50 signatures opposed the variance. The board nevertheless voted to grant the continuance. - No other public testimony was offered on the remaining items. Expedited Docket The board approved two expedited petitions in a single vote (5-0) without testimony: - 2021 DV3050 (2827 Boulevard Place): Variance to allow a detached garage with reduced setbacks. - 2021 DV3021 (3511 W 20th St / 1949 N Exeter Ave): Variance of use to allow an addition and temporary two dwellings on one lot. Discussion Items 1. Case 2021 DV3042 – 6701, 6751, 6801 Acton Road Petitioner: Gregory D. and Kathy A. Spivey, represented by attorney David Rutherford. Request: Variance of development standards to create four three-acre lots with 148 feet of lot width instead of the required 250 feet in the DA (Agricultural) district. Key Arguments: - The property is surrounded by similar large-lot developments; the lots are consistent with the surrounding area and the comprehensive plan. - The project includes shared driveways and commitments for high-quality homes (minimum square footage, no vinyl siding, etc.). - The Franklin Township Civic League and City-County Councilor supported the proposal. - A drainage issue on Acton Road would be resolved privately as part of development. Staff Position: Recommended denial, stating that the reduced lot width creates nonconformity and the practical difficulty is self-imposed (they could reduce to two lots to comply). Board Vote: Golson Dunlop (yes), Boshenko (yes), Rollinson (yes), Bohanan (no), Von Dalen (yes) – Approved 4-1. 2. Case 2021 DV3049 – 611 Shelby Street Petitioner: Calvary Evangelical Lutheran Congregation, represented by Joshua Reefstock and Elmer Flug. Request: Variance to install a 5-foot-tall internally illuminated digital monument sign (140 sq ft) within a protected district. The sign would be 45 feet from a protected residential district (required 600 feet for digital displays). Key Arguments: - The existing sign was damaged; the new sign would be similar in size but with digital display to allow dynamic messaging and reduce temporary banner use. - The sign would be dimmed at night and turned off by 11 p.m.; no flashing or motion graphics. - Southport High School (nearby) has a similar digital sign facing the same neighborhood. - Letters of support from Councilors Joshua Bain and Paul Anne. Staff Position: Recommended denial; the digital display and illumination are out of character with the neighborhood and no practical difficulty exists. Staff would support a like-for-like replacement without illumination. Board Vote: Golson Dunlop (yes), Boshenko (yes), Rollinson (no), Bohanan (yes), Von Dalen (yes) – Approved 4-1. Key Outcomes - Case 2021 DV3042 (Acton Road variance) approved (4-1) subject to commitments including shared driveways, minimum home sizes, and agricultural use preservation. - Case 2021 DV3049 (Shelby Street digital sign) approved (4-1) subject to petitioner's policy on dimming and shutoff times. - Continuances and withdrawals handled as noted above, all approved. - Expedited petitions approved. - Fee transfer for withdrawn UV3011 approved. - Adjourned without additional business.

ZONING AND LAND USE 56% · PROCEDURAL 21% · SIGN REGULATION 18% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 3%
817
SEP 14, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 Meeting - September 14, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 held a public hearing on September 14, 2021, chaired by Mark Young, with members Leisha Reuter, Peter Nelson, Mary Kelly, and James Duke. The board addressed procedural motions, approved a consent docket of expedited variance petitions, and conducted a full hearing on a sign variance for an adult entertainment business. The board unanimously denied the sign variance. Consent Calendar - Waiver of Rules of Procedure: The board unanimously voted to allow a single vote on all expedited petitions rather than separate votes. - Special Requests (Continuances and Waivers): - 2021 DV2038 (1042 Woodlawn Avenue): Continued to October 12, 2021, without additional notice (unanimous). - 2021 DV2050 (209 Jefferson Avenue): Granted a three-day waiver for sign posting (unanimous). - 2021 DV2052 (1460 Bates Street): Granted a three-day waiver for notice mailing and sign posting (unanimous). - 2021 UV2017 (4917 West Minnesota Street): Continued to October 12, 2021, without additional notice (unanimous). - 2021 DV2041 (6720 Telecom Drive): Continued to October 12, 2021, without additional notice unless needed (unanimous). - 2021 UV2016 (804 East Lavero Road): Acknowledged an automatic continuance to October 12, 2021. - 2021 DV2025 (8008 Fishback Road): Acknowledged the petitioner's withdrawal. - 2021 DV2053 (6732 East 42nd Street): Continued to October 12, 2021, with new notice required (unanimous). - 2021 UV2015 (4822 Man Road): Acknowledged an automatic continuance to October 12, 2021. - Expedited Petitions: The board unanimously approved all 20+ expedited variance petitions (listed as 2021 DV2049, DV2050, DV2051, DV2052, UV2018, and others) in a single vote. Public Comments & Testimony Public testimony was limited to the full hearing on Petition 2021 DV2043 (4250 East Southport Road). Remonstrators spoke in opposition to the requested sign variance: - Mike Speedy (State Representative, office near the site): Opposed the sign, citing proximity to a daycare, churches, a trampoline park (Sky Zone), and residential neighborhoods. He submitted a petition of 2,864 signatures against the sign. He argued the sign would harm the community's front door, property values, and family-oriented character. - Amy Stens (McFarland Farms Property Owners Association): Opposed the sign, stating the zoning ordinance already prohibits detached signs for adult businesses. She noted the sign would be 525 feet from a daycare and near a church and homes, and that the business should not receive special visibility. - Matt Roller (Pastor, Indianapolis Baptist Temple): Opposed the sign and the business, emphasizing the need to protect children and citing concerns about human trafficking and addiction. - Sandra Tilton (White Oak Farms): Opposed the sign, arguing it resembles a children's image and would be a distraction near hotels housing youth groups. Discussion Items - Petition 2021 DV2043 – 4250 East Southport Road: The petitioner, Sean Ensign (Legacy Sign Group), requested a variance to allow a freestanding monument sign for an adult entertainment business (Lions Den) in a C4 zone with an integrated center designation. He argued the sign was essential for westbound traffic visibility and that the business only had a small wall sign approved. Staff recommended denial, stating the zoning ordinance permits only a wall sign for adult entertainment businesses in integrated centers, and allowing a monument sign would undermine the purpose of integrated center signage. The board heard petitioner's rebuttal and remonstrators' closing statements. Key Outcomes - 2021 DV2043: Denied (5-0 vote: Reuter no, Kelly no, Nelson no, Duke no, Young no). The board found the request inconsistent with use-specific standards for adult entertainment businesses. - Adoption of Findings of Fact: The board adopted revised findings of fact for prior cases: - 2021 DV2034 (Parts A and B, heard July 13, 2021): Part A signed by all members; Part B signed by members Duke, Nelson, and Young. - 2021 SE201 (heard August 10, 2021): Unanimous denial findings adopted. - Next Steps: The denied petition (DV2043) will continue for adoption of formal findings of fact.

SIGN REGULATION 32% · ZONING AND LAND USE 30% · PROCEDURAL 20% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 18%
818
SEP 7, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Public Hearing - September 7, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division 1 convened on September 7, 2021, at 6:15 PM (local time) under the chairmanship of Joanna Taft. Board members present included Beth Brandon, Roderick Brahannon, and Clint McKay. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff members Matt Pleasant, Robert Yulenhaek, and Heather Stefan were also in attendance. The meeting addressed multiple special requests for continuances, a block of expedited petitions, and one contested non-expedited case involving a request for use and development variances. Special Requests & Continuances - Case 2021 DV1049 (2112/2126 East 54th Street): Petitioner requested a two-day waiver of notice requirements. A remonstrator opposed, stating insufficient time to prepare. After discussion, the board declined to grant the waiver, and the petitioner then requested a continuance. The board continued the case to October 5, 2021. - Case 2021 UV1021 (929 Sanders Street): Petitioner requested a one-month continuance to gather more information from the neighborhood association. No opposition; staff had no objection. Continued to the October 2021 meeting. - Case 2021 DB2036: Petitioner requested a continuance to November 2, 2021, due to a scheduling conflict. No opposition; staff no objection. Continued. - Case 2021 UV1023 (1950 North Rural Street): Petitioner requested the case be moved to the expedited docket, noting no remonstrators were present. Staff had no objection. The board approved adding it to the expedited docket. - Case 2021 DV1046: Petitioner requested a continuance and transfer to Board 3 for the October 19, 2021 hearing. Staff had no objection. Continued and transferred with notice if needed. - Case 2021 DV1051 (3014/3018/3039 Alice Avenue): Petitioner requested a 30-day continuance to revise plans. A remonstrator initially opposed but later agreed after discussion. The board continued the case to October 5, 2021. - Case 2021 DV1049 (revisited): After a break, the remonstrator agreed to a 30-day continuance. The case was continued to the October 2021 meeting. Consent Calendar (Expedited Petitions) The board approved a block of expedited petitions by a single 4-0 roll call vote (McKay, Bohannon, Brandon, Taft all in favor). The following cases were approved: - 2021 SE1002 – Special exception for a daycare center at 3621 Longview Lane / 3730 Yellow Poplar Court. - 2021 DV1050 – Variance of development standards for a detached garage taller than the primary dwelling at 10888 Vandergriff Road. - 2021 DV1052 – Variance for driveway access from Waldemar Avenue (alley access required) at 1122 Waldemar Avenue. - 2021 DV1053 – Variance to allow single-family dwellings and detached garages on substandard lots at 901/907 South Randolph Street. - 2021 UV1016 – Variance of use and development standards for a second-floor addition to a two-family dwelling at 1607 Yandy Street. - 2021 UV1019 – Variance of use and development standards for a restoration contractor and fence at 8010 East 38th Street. - 2021 UV1023 – Variance of use to expand a liquor store at 1950 North Rural Street. Discussion Item: Case 2021 UV1022 (8630 East 38th Street) This case involved a request for a variance of use and development standards to legally establish two single-family dwellings (one existing) and allow an expansion with 60% open space (85% required) on a parcel zoned for agriculture. The petitioner, represented by Mark Crouch, argued that the owner—a senior citizen, veteran, and neighbor of the daughter—needed the expansion for convalescent care and that the property had long contained two structures. Staff recommended denial, advocating for a lot split to create two legal parcels, which would cost an estimated $10,000–$15,500. The petitioner declined, citing cost and the owner’s age. Board members expressed sympathy but noted the complexity, including the agricultural zoning and the precedent of two primary structures on one lot. After discussion, the petitioner agreed to a continuance to explore options, including a possible rezoning. The board unanimously voted (4-0) to continue the case to the October 5, 2021 meeting. Key Outcomes - The board granted 7 continuances (6 individual cases, 1 with a transfer) and added one case to the expedited docket. - All 7 expedited petitions were approved unanimously. - Case 2021 UV1022 was continued to the October 5, 2021 meeting. - The board adopted findings of fact from the August 2021 hearing for case 2021 DV1039 A and B (unanimous votes). - The meeting adjourned after all business was concluded.

ZONING AND LAND USE 53% · PROCEDURAL 35% · SENIOR PROGRAMS 7% · LAND USE REGULATION 5%
819
AUG 17, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Public Hearing - August 17, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III held a public hearing on August 17, 2021, chaired by Craig E. Von Dalen. The board addressed several continuances, expedited petitions, and two contested variance cases. Key decisions included approval of a drive-through variance for a McDonald's restaurant despite staff opposition, and approval of a front porch variance with an eight-foot setback. Consent Calendar - Expedited Petitions: The board approved all expedited petitions in a single vote (5-0) after a correction to petition 2021-DV3-025 (sign height reduced from 9 to 6 feet). Petitions included variances for setbacks, signs, and a temporary modular school classroom. Public Comments & Testimony - Joanna Franklin (Crooked Creek Alerts land use committee) opposed petition 2021-DV2-048 (McDonald's drive-through), arguing that approval would set a bad precedent and undermine streetscape efforts. She requested the board uphold staff's denial. Discussion Items - 2021-DV2-048 (1445 W 86th St) – Carmosino Group/McDonald's: Petitioner Joe Calderon requested a variance to allow a drive-through in the front yard (prohibited on streets over 30 feet wide). He argued that the building was already under construction due to an error by the Department of Business and Neighborhood Services, and that the drive-through orientation was necessary for traffic safety and site constraints. He noted the site is 3-4 feet below street grade and that enhanced landscaping (including evergreen shrubs) would mitigate visual impacts. The Nora North Side Community Council voted not to oppose the project. Staff recommended denial, citing public safety concerns from headlight glare and the precedent of allowing front-yard drive-throughs. A conflict-of-interest discussion occurred regarding board member David Duncan (relationship with petitioner's attorney); Duncan and member Janice Golson Dunlop stated they could be impartial, and no objections were sustained. Remonstrator Joanna Franklin reiterated opposition based on precedent and procedural fairness. The board voted 4-1 (Catherine Chee dissenting) to approve the variance, with a condition that the landscaping be evergreen. - 2021-DV3-039 (5343 E St Joseph St) – Mary Wyland: Petitioner requested a variance for an enclosed front porch with an eight-foot front setback (required 18 feet or block average of 14.5 feet). The original request was for five feet; the petitioner compromised to eight feet after discussions with staff. Neighbors testified in support. Staff recommended denial at eight feet, suggesting a 10-foot setback to maintain streetscape rhythm and emergency sight lines. The petitioner argued that adding to the rear was impractical due to a steep drop and existing patio investment. The board voted 3-2 (Golson Dunlop and Chee dissenting) to approve the eight-foot setback. The findings of fact were continued to a later meeting for correction of dimensions. Key Outcomes - Continuances Granted: Seven petitions were continued to the September 21, 2021 hearing, either with or without additional notice, including 2021-DV3-038, 2021-SE3-001, 2021-DV3-031, and automatic continuances for three others. - 2021-DV2-048 Approved (4-1) with condition for evergreen shrubs. - 2021-DV3-039 Approved (3-2) with eight-foot setback; findings of fact to be revised and adopted later. - Adoption of Findings: Findings from previous hearings (2021-DV3-027 and 2021-DV3-026) were presented for signature. - Conflict of Interest: Board member David Duncan and Janice Golson Dunlop disclosed potential conflicts but were allowed to vote after stating impartiality and no audience objection.

ZONING AND LAND USE 61% · PROCEDURAL 32% · SIGN REGULATION 3% · TRAFFIC SAFETY 2%
820
AUG 10, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two Meeting - August 10, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two, chaired by Mark Young, met on August 10, 2021, at 6:00 PM. The board considered multiple variance petitions and a special exception, with many petitions expedited and approved collectively. Two non-expedited cases were heard in detail: a variance for lot width on Southport Road and a special exception for religious use on Lowry Lane. Consent Calendar - The board approved a motion to vote on all expedited petitions together. The expedited docket included: - 2021-DV2-037: 931 Villa Avenue – variance for 50% open space and zero-foot side setback for a detached garage. - 2021-DV2-039: 7030 Emblem Drive – variance to replace an existing pole sign with a smaller illuminated sign. - 2021-DV2-040: 5921 Stafford Road – variance for a 50-foot front setback. - 2021-DV2-044: 4118 Rookwood Avenue – variance for 57% open space for a detached garage. - 2021-UV2-014: 5053 East Michigan Street – variance for a detached garage with reduced setbacks in a C-3 zone. - 2021-DV2-042: 5505 and 5565 Brookville Road – moved to expedited and approved with commitments for industrial parking and loading areas. - 2021-DV2-045: 1442 Orange Street – amended to 50% open space, moved to expedited, and approved for a detached garage. - All expedited petitions were approved unanimously (5-0). Public Comments & Testimony - 2021-SE2-001 (Lowry Lane): Mark Rodemacher, a Lieber Woods neighborhood representative, spoke in opposition. He cited concerns about increased traffic (estimated 5,800+ additional vehicle trips annually), noise from up to 50 attendees and 14 cars four times weekly, and adverse effects on neighborhood character. He read letters from the Crooked Creek Alert Land Use Committee and District 7 Councilor John Barth, both opposing the petition. No public comments were made in support from outside the petitioner's group. Discussion Items - 2020-DV3-049 (7430 East Southport Road): Petitioner David Rutherford sought a variance to divide a nine-acre parcel into three lots for a family compound, with lot width measured at the front wall of each dwelling (instead of at the setback line) and access via an existing shared private driveway. Staff recommended denial, arguing the proposal would create flag lots with inadequate lot width and that the 12-foot driveway was insufficient for two-way traffic and emergency access. Petitioner offered commitments: a recorded shared driveway agreement covering maintenance, signage at the entrance and driveway splits, and 20-foot-wide passing zones at connection points. The board approved the variance 5-0. - 2021-SE2-001 (1018 and 1030 Lowry Lane): Petitioner David Kingan requested a special exception to allow religious use of a former residence and adjacent lot, with gravel parking (later withdrawn in favor of hard surface). Staff recommended denial, citing the property’s location on a local street without sidewalks, lack of proximity to an arterial or public transit, and inadequate sewer capacity for institutional use. The neighborhood and councilor opposed. The board denied the special exception 0-5 after acknowledging withdrawal of the gravel parking request and adding commitments (no employees, commercial sewer permit). - Continuances and Transfers: - 2021-DV2-038 (1042 Woodlawn Avenue) continued to September 14, 2021. - 2021-DV2-041 (6720 Telecom Drive) continued to September 14, 2021 (automatic by neighborhood organization). - 2021-DV2-043 (4250 East Southport Road) continued to September 14, 2021 (automatic). - 2021-DV2-025 (8008 Fishback Road) continued to September 14, 2021 for clarification. - 2021-DV2-048 (1445 West 86th Street) transferred to BZA3 for August 17, 2021. Key Outcomes - Expedited petitions: Approved unanimously (5-0) with no opposition. - 2020-DV3-049: Approved (5-0) subject to commitments for shared driveway, signage, and passing zones. - 2021-SE2-001: Denied (0-5); the board adopted findings of fact in support of denial. - Continuances and transfers: All acknowledged and granted as requested.

ZONING AND LAND USE 51% · PROCEDURAL 14% · RELIGIOUS EXEMPTION 13% · MISCELLANEOUS 6%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com