Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 821–830 ENTRIES
821
AUG 3, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I Meeting - August 3, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I convened on August 3, 2021, at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. Chair Joanna Taft presided, with board members Ron Hampton, Roderick Barhannon, Beth Brandon, and Clint McKay. The board heard and decided numerous variance petitions, including expedited items, indecisive and transferred cases, and new petitions. After reviewing staff reports and hearing testimony, the board approved most requests, denied a few, and continued others to future meetings. Consent Calendar - Expedited Petitions (2021-DV1-028, 041, 042, 043, 044, 045): All six expedited variance requests were voted on together and approved unanimously (5-0) with no opposition from the public. These included: - 2021-DV1-028 (Amended): Variance to create two lots (114,686 sq ft and 95,669 sq ft) at 7338 Five Points Road with reduced setbacks and open space (from three-acre lots requiring 250-foot width, 30-foot side setbacks, 75-foot aggregate side, 75-foot rear, 85% open space). Staff originally recommended denial but changed to approval after amended plans. - 2021-DV1-041: Variance to legally establish a driveway to 33rd Street at 615 East 33rd Street (alley access required). - 2021-DV1-042: Variance to relocate a 60-foot tall, 605.4-sq ft pole sign along I-465 at 1720 West Thompson Road (only one free-standing sign permitted within 660 feet of interstate; pole signs not permitted in C-S; max 20-ft height, 300-sq ft area). - 2021-DV1-043: Variance to relocate/replace an 85-ft tall, 792-sq ft pole sign with an 85-ft tall, 526.3-sq ft pole sign along I-465 and replace a 40.17-ft tall, 157-sq ft sign with a 30-ft tall, 130.8-sq ft sign along Harding Street at 4607 South Harding Street. - 2021-DV1-044: Variance for a detached garage accessory to a single-family dwelling with 56% open space (60% required) and within the clear sight triangle of abutting alleys at 847 Lincoln Street. - 2021-DV1-045: Variance for a detached garage with 46% open space (60% required) and a 4-foot rear setback (5-foot required) at 522 Cottage Avenue. Public Comments & Testimony - Richard Costrashewski (1546 Ringgold Avenue): Expressed concerns about neighboring properties at 1540 and 1544 Ringgold Avenue (2021-DV1-046), mentioning lack of gutters and a knocked-down fence. The petition was continued to September without notice. - Heather Ressler (homeowner, 664 North Beville Avenue): Testified in favor of 2021-DV1-013, describing her sustainability efforts (rain garden, rain barrels, native plants) and the importance of preserving green space. She stated the builder constructed the driveway and deck without her knowledge. - Pamela Page (attorney for homeowner): Argued for equity, noting the homeowner purchased the house as-is and that moving the driveway would eliminate backyard green space and undermine sustainability efforts. - Mark Demerly (petitioner, 1709 Alvord Street): Presented 2021-DV1-039, emphasizing the need for a four-car garage to minimize street parking and citing previous approvals for similar garage setbacks. - Cahmelan Porter (petitioner, 1336 Shelby Street): Supported 2021-UV1-014, explaining the temporary nature (max 24 months) of shipping container retail, the property's prior C-3 zoning, and support from local merchants associations. Discussion Items - 2021-UV1-012 (619 Holly Avenue): Variance to convert a single-family dwelling into two dwelling units on a lot with 45 feet of frontage (70 feet required). No remonstrators present. Staff recommended approval, noting the lot is over 15,000 sq ft (exceeding the 7,200 sq ft minimum for new duplexes) and that there are seven other two-family dwellings within one block. Approved 5-0. - 2021-DV1-013 (664 North Beville Avenue): Variance to legalize a deck within the right-of-way, attached garage without alley access, fence within clear sight triangle, and 57% open space (60% required). Staff recommended denial due to safety concerns and noncompliance. Petitioner argued for equity and sustainability. Board voted on five separate components: - Deck in right-of-way: Approved (5-0). - Front porch in clear sight triangle: Approved (5-0). - Driveway/garage access from St. Clair Street: Approved (4-1, Hampton opposed). - Fence in clear sight triangle: Approved (4-1, Hampton opposed). - Open space (57%): Approved (5-0). - 2021-DV1-039 (1709 Alvord Street): Variance for a two-family dwelling with reduced setbacks and a four-car garage with 2-foot side setbacks (4-foot required). Staff recommended approval for dwelling setbacks and open space (52% vs 55%), but denial for garage setbacks. Board voted: - Garage with 2-foot side setbacks: Denied (0-5). - Remaining requests (front setback 16 ft, side setbacks 3.5 ft, building separation 4.5 ft, open space 52%): Approved (5-0). - 2021-UV1-014 (1336 Shelby Street): Variance for two shipping containers (8x20 ft and 8x40 ft) for retail pop-up and store with zero-foot north side setback and reduced parking (6 spaces vs 10 required). Staff recommended denial as self-imposed hardship and nonconformity. Petitioner offered a 2-year limit. Approved (4-1, Hampton opposed) with condition that the use be temporary for two years. Key Outcomes - Approvals: - Expedited petitions (6 items): Approved 5-0. - 2021-UV1-012: Approved 5-0. - 2021-DV1-013: Approved in 5 parts (deck, porch, driveway, fence, open space) with two 4-1 votes. - 2021-DV1-039 (dwelling and open space): Approved 5-0. - 2021-UV1-014: Approved 4-1 with condition of 2-year temporary use. - Denials: - 2021-DV1-039 (garage with 2-foot side setbacks): Denied 0-5. - Continuances: - 2021-DV1-046: Continued to September 7, 2021, without notice. - 2021-DV2-036: Continued to September 7, 2021, without notice. - 2021-UV1-016: Continued to September 7, 2021, with notice. - 2021-UV1-015: Continued to October 5, 2021, with notice. - 2021-UV1-017: Continued to September 7, 2021 (automatic continuance). - 2021-UV1-019: Continued to September 7, 2021, with notice. - Withdrawal: - 2021-UV1-018: Withdrawn as requested by the petitioner. All approved variances requiring revised findings of fact were continued for submission and adoption of supporting findings.

ZONING AND LAND USE 70% · PROCEDURAL 11% · SUSTAINABILITY 6% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 4%
822
JUL 29, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 Meeting - July 29, 2021

Note: The transcript indicates the meeting was held on January 12, 2021, but the provided date for this summary is July 29, 2021. The following summary is based on the transcript content. The meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 was called to order by Chairperson Mark Young. The meeting was conducted electronically due to COVID-19. Several special requests for continuances and expedited agenda items were addressed, and one full hearing was conducted on a variance of use petition for a hemp farm. The board denied the variance. Consent Calendar / Special Requests - Continuances granted: Several petitions were continued to future dates: 2020 DV3049 (7430 East Southport Road) to March 9, 2021; 2020 UV2019 (3401 West 10th Street and 970 North Tibbs Avenue) to February 9, 2021; 2020 DV3050 (5809 Bluff Road) to February 9, 2021; 2020 UV2009 (10131 East Thompson Road) to February 9, 2021; 2020 SC2002 (604 West Stop 11 Road) to March 9, 2021 with additional notice. All continuances were approved unanimously. - Expedited petitions moved: Two petitions were moved to the expedited agenda: 2020 UV2020 (250 North Girls School Road) and 2020 DV2060 (1531 Span Avenue) after petitioners agreed to staff conditions. These were approved as part of the expedited block. - Withdrawals acknowledged: Petitions 2020 UV2-005 (339 West 71st Street) and a petition for 8554 Springview Drive were withdrawn by request. Public Comments & Testimony - Call-in participants identified: Several call-in users were identified, including Daniel Rushello (petitioner attorney for 2020 SE2002), Robin Davis (homeowner in opposition), Karen Farmer (listening), and Trina Bond (opposition to 2020 SE2002). - On the full hearing case (2020 UV2016): Remonstrators Susan Blair (Pike Township Residents Association), Mike Hoy (adjacent property owner), and others spoke in opposition. Blair stated the PTRA board voted unanimously to oppose, citing incompatibility with residential area and failure to meet findings of fact. Hoy presented a petition signed by 15 of 21 available property owners (71%) on Hollingsworth Drive opposing the variance, citing overwhelming skunk-like smell lasting 6-8 weeks, loss of use of property, security concerns, and decreased property values. Other remonstrators (Charles Blackett, Terry Blackett, Brian Gornick) opposed but did not add further testimony. Discussion Items - Full hearing: 2020 UV2016 – 7300 Highland Road (Pike Township): Petitioner Stan Kloss requested a variance of use to operate a commercial hemp farm on property zoned D1 and D3 (dwelling districts). Kloss argued the use is consistent with the comprehensive plan's rural/estate neighborhood typology, poses no additional crime or infrastructure burden, and is organic. He offered to remove one field as a compromise. Staff recommended denial, stating the proposed use is incompatible with the established suburban residential neighborhood, no practical difficulty exists, and the site can be developed residentially as zoned. The board discussed the findings of fact; Chairperson Young noted the petitioner had possibly met the fifth finding (interference with comprehensive plan) but had not met the others regarding adverse effect on adjacent properties, practical difficulty, or unnecessary hardship. Key Outcomes - Vote on 2020 UV2016: The board voted unanimously (0 yes, 5 no) to deny the variance. Members present: Alicia Reuter (no), Mary Kelly (no), James Duke (no), David Duncan (no), Mark Young (no). Negative findings of fact will be adopted in support of the decision. - Expedited petitions approved: All four expedited petitions (2020 GV2061, 2020 DV2062, 2020 UV2020, 2020 DV2060) were approved in a single vote on condition of commitments. - Staff introductions: New staff members Genesis Hill (associate planner) and Michael Weigel (tech support) were welcomed.

ZONING AND LAND USE 59% · PROCEDURAL 25% · CANNABIS REGULATION 7% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 5%
823
JUL 29, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Indianapolis BZA Division 1 Meeting - July 29, 2021

[Note: The transcript states the hearing occurred on January 5, 2021; the date provided for summary is July 29, 2021. This discrepancy is noted.] The Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 convened with three members (Chair Joanna Taft, Clint McKay, Rodrigue Bohanen) due to reduced attendance. The meeting handled special requests for transfers and continuances, approved an expedited docket, and heard three variance petitions. Two petitions resulted in indecisive votes due to lack of a fourth board member, requiring future hearings. Consent Calendar - Withdrawals and continuances acknowledged: 2020 UV1020, 2020 UV1013 withdrawn; 2020 UV1019 continued to February 2, 2021. - Expedited petitions (2020 DV1039, 2020 DV1079, 2020 UV1021, 2020 UV1022) approved in a single vote with no opposition. Public Comments & Testimony - For the Evison Street petition (2020 DV1080), 14 supporters spoke, including Anna Stephens and Leslie Ropel, praising the Montgomery family and noting diverse housing styles in the neighborhood. Two remonstrators (Jeffrey Morgan and Paul D. Jack Robinson) opposed, citing safety concerns, incompatibility, and process issues. - For the fence petition (2020 DV1083), two supporters (Jerry Sanford and Brian Pecaris) confirmed dog attack dangers. No remonstrators. - No public comments listed for other cases. Discussion Items - Special Requests: - 2020 DV1009 (Bob Evans Farms) transferred to BZA3 on January 19, 2021, due to indecisive vote potential (unanimous). - 2020 DV1076 transferred to BZA3 on January 19, 2021 (unanimous). - 2020 UV1018 (5660 Madison Ave) continued to February 2, 2021, as last continuance (unanimous). - 2020 UV1016 withdrawn and fees transferred to a new rezoning petition (unanimous). - Full Hearings: - 2020 DV1078 (1854 New Street): Petitioner Maureen Miller sought open space variance for a new home with garage and carriage house. Staff recommended denial, citing no practical difficulty and potential overdevelopment. Board voted 0-3 to deny. - 2020 DV1080 (1238 Evison Street): Petitioner Paul Munoz for Montgomery family sought variance for driveway and fence after a permit error. Staff recommended denial but suggested commitments. Board voted 2-1 (McKay and Bohanen yes, Taft no), resulting in indecisive. Continued to February 2, 2021. - 2020 DV1083 (2437 South McClure Street): Petitioner Richard Gray sought fence variance for safety from aggressive dogs. Staff proposed a compromise with a lower fence; Gray rejected. Board voted 2-1 (McKay and Bohanen yes, Taft no), indecisive. Continued to February 2, 2021. Key Outcomes - Denied: 2020 DV1078 (open space variance) – 0-3 vote. - Indecisive (continued): 2020 DV1080 and 2020 DV1083 – both require a full board hearing on February 2, 2021. - Transfers: Two cases moved to BZA3 on January 19, 2021. - Continuances: 2020 UV1018 and 2020 UV1019 continued to February 2, 2021. - Withdrawals: 2020 UV1016, 2020 UV1020, 2020 UV1013 withdrawn. - Expedited petitions: All approved. - New staff: Welcomed Associate Planner Genesis Hill and Michael Weigel.

ZONING AND LAND USE 56% · PROCEDURAL 27% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 9% · PERSONNEL MATTERS 4%
824
JUL 22, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 Hearing - July 22, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 (BZA2) convened electronically on July 22, 2021, at 1:15 PM, chaired by Mark Young. The meeting addressed five continuance requests, two petition withdrawals, and three expedited petitions approved in a single vote. The primary contested item was a variance of use petition for a hemp farm in a residential area, which was denied unanimously. Special Requests and Continuances - 2020 DV3049 (7430 East Southport Road): Continued to March 9, 2021, without additional notice (third continuance by petitioner; staff noted no further continuances would be supported). - 2020 UV2019 (3401 West 10th Street / 970 North Tibbs Avenue): Continued to February 9, 2021, with additional notice at the request of the neighborhood zoning office. - 2020 DV3050 (5809 Bluff Road): Continued to February 9, 2021, without additional notice to allow further neighborhood negotiations. - 2020 UV209 (10131 East Thompson Road): Continued to February 9, 2021, without additional notice to obtain documentation. - 2020 SC2002 (604 West Stop 11 Road): Continued to March 9, 2021, with additional notice due to a newly added variance and to address remonstrator concerns. - 2020 DV2042 (8554 Springview Drive): Withdrawn by petitioner, acknowledged by the board. - 2020 UV2005 (5339 West 71st Street): Withdrawn by petitioner, acknowledged by the board. Expedited Petitions (Consent Calendar) The board waived its rules to vote on all expedited petitions in a single vote. The following petitions were approved unanimously with agreed commitments: - 2020 DV2061 (944 Hervey Street): Variance to legally establish a single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks and open space. - 2020 DV2062 (2207 Lexington Avenue): Variance for a porch reconstruction with a reduced front setback. - 2020 UV2020 (250 North Girls School Road): Variance of use to provide a rental office for apartments and maintain a freestanding sign, with commitments to remove an existing poll sign. Public Comments & Testimony (Full Hearing Case 2020 UV2016) - Petitioner Stan Kloss (6607 Bridge Court) argued for a variance of use to grow hemp commercially on three fields at 7300 Highland Road. He stated the operation was organic, secure, and consistent with the comprehensive plan's rural/estate recommendation. He noted no crime or infrastructure strain and offered to adjust the plan to remove the western field. - Remonstrators (residents and Pike Township Residents Association) opposed the petition: - Susan Blair (PTRA president) stated the board voted unanimously to oppose, citing incompatibility with residential zoning, the petitioner not owning the land, and a prior violation. She argued the use would be detrimental to health, safety, and welfare. - Mike Hoy (7310 Hollingsworth Drive) presented a petition signed by 15 of 21 non-Lowry property owners (71%) in opposition. He described a six-to-eight-week pungent skunk-like odor from blooming hemp that prevented outdoor use, reduced property values, and raised security concerns (citing a nearby shooting incident). He emphasized the area has been residential for 70 years. - Additional remonstrators (Brian Gornick, Charles Blackett, Terry Blackett) declined to speak but concurred with previous testimony. Discussion Items - 2020 UV2016 (7300 Highland Road) – Variance of use for commercial hemp farming (agricultural use) on parcels zoned D1 and D3 (dwelling districts). - Staff Presentation: Senior Planner Robert Eulenhake recommended denial. The comprehensive plan recommends rural/estate uses but the proposed commercial agriculture is incompatible with the established suburban residential neighborhood. The site could be developed residentially without hardship. The use would increase intensity and be detrimental to adjacent property owners. Staff noted the site includes an illegally converted accessory structure. - Board Clarification: Corporation Counsel clarified the petitioner must meet five findings of fact. The fifth finding (compatibility with comprehensive plan) might be met, but the other four—including hardship and impact on adjacent properties—remain unmet. - Petitioner Rebuttal: Kloss reiterated there was no crime or odor issue, questioned the neighbors' rights vs. his property rights, and asked if a partial commitment (removing one field) could be considered. He referenced the comprehensive plan's rural/estate recommendation as supporting his use. - Remonstrator Rebuttal: Susan Blair noted the petitioner attended only one of three meetings and that hemp farming has high profit potential ($15,000/acre to plant, $280,000/acre return) and attracts crime. Mike Hoy reiterated the 71% opposition and loss of use for 1.5 months. Key Outcomes - 2020 UV2016 – Denied unanimously (5-0). Board members Alicia Reuter, Mary Kelly, James Duke, David Duncan, and Mark Young all voted no. The board will adopt negative findings of fact. Petitioner was advised to contact the board secretary for appeal procedures. - All expedited petitions approved unanimously via single vote. - All continuances granted as requested. - New staff introductions: Genesis Hill (associate planner) and Michael Weigel (tech support) were welcomed. The meeting was adjourned at 2:21 PM.

ZONING AND LAND USE 47% · PROCEDURAL 32% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 11% · AGRICULTURE 3%
825
JUL 22, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Hearing - July 22, 2021

Note on date discrepancy: The raw transcript states the meeting date as January 5, 2021, but the provided date for this summary is July 22, 2021. All references to future dates (e.g., continuances to January 19, 2021) are taken directly from the transcript and may reflect the original meeting date rather than the date given here. The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 1, convened electronically under COVID-19 guidelines. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided with board members Clint McKay and Roderick Bohanan (three members total). Many petitions required transfers or continuances because the three-member board risked indecisive votes. The meeting included special requests, an expedited docket, and three full hearings. Special Requests, Continuances, and Transfers - 2020 DV1-009 (Bob Evans Farms): Requested transfer to BZA3 on January 19, 2021, to avoid another indecisive vote. Remonstrator Mark Menko did not object. Staff supported. Motion carried unanimously. - 2020 DV1076: Transferred to BZA3 on January 19, 2021, with no remonstrators. Staff supported. Motion carried unanimously. - 2020 UV1018 (5660 Madison Adam Avenue): Continued to February 2, 2021, for further work with staff and neighbors. Remonstrator Greg Kitzmiller did not object. Staff supported as last continuance. Motion carried unanimously. - 2020 UV1016: Withdrawn by petitioner Nick Burrow, with fees transferred to a future rezoning petition. Motion carried unanimously. - 2020 UV1-020 (1854 New Street): Withdrawn at staff request (amended and redocketed as 2020 DV1078). Acknowledged by board. - 2020 UV1013 (359 North Lynnhurst Drive): Withdrawn by petitioner. Acknowledged. - 2020 UV1019 (2026 East 10th Street): Continued to February 2, 2021, to allow amendment to rezoning. Staff supported as final continuance. Motion carried unanimously. - 2020 DV1077: Automatic continuance by registered neighborhood organization acknowledged. Expedited Docket - Petitions: 2020 DV1039, 2020 DV1079, 2020 UV1021, 2020 UV1022. All petitioners agreed to staff findings. A single vote approved all after a late-arriving caller (Stan) on 2020 DV1079 confirmed no opposition. Motion passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - 2020 DV1078 (Maureen Miller): No remonstrators. Petitioner argued the variance (56% open space vs. 60% required) was modest and supported by neighborhood. Staff opposed, citing overdevelopment and self-imposed hardship. - 2020 DV1080 (1238 Evison Street): 14 supporters voiced support via QA, including Anna Stephens and Leslie Ropel, who praised the Montgomery family and noted other homes with front driveways. Two remonstrators, Jeffrey Morgan and Paul D. Jack Robinson, opposed the driveway turnaround and fence, citing safety, neighborhood character, and the builder's failure to obtain proper permits. A city-county councilor (Frank Muscari) submitted a letter of support. Staff recommended denial. - 2020 DV1083 (2437 South McClure Street): Petitioner Richard Gray, supported by neighbors Jerry Sanford and realtor Brian Bacars, described two dog attacks and argued the 6-foot front fence was necessary for safety. No remonstrators. Staff recommended a compromise (4-foot fence with partial 6-foot) but petitioner insisted on full variance. Discussion Items - 2020 DV1078: Petitioner Maureen Miller sought a variance to allow 56% open space (60% required) for a new single-family dwelling with garage and carriage house. She cited neighborhood support and comparable approved variances. Staff argued the lot size exceeds minimums, so no practical difficulty exists, and the proposed overdevelopment would harm adjacent properties and set a precedent. Board asked no questions. - 2020 DV1080: Petitioner (represented by counsel) sought variances for a driveway turnaround and fence after a city-issued permit was revoked. The revised plan removes the Orange Street curb cut and uses alley access. Remonstrators raised visibility and aesthetic concerns. Staff recommended denial but offered commitments (fence height ≤3.5 ft, fence location). Petitioner accepted commitments. - 2020 DV1083: Petitioner argued the full 6-foot fence is essential to prevent dog attacks. Staff recommended partial reduction to 4 feet for 11 feet along the front property line, with shrubs as screening. Petitioner rejected compromise, stating any reduction would allow dogs to jump over. Key Outcomes - 2020 DV1078: Denied (0-3 vote). Findings to be adopted later. - 2020 DV1080: Indecisive vote (2-1 in favor; McKay yes, Bohanan yes, Taft no). Automatically continued to February 2, 2021, hearing. - 2020 DV1083: Indecisive vote (2-1 in favor; McKay yes, Bohanan yes, Taft no). Automatically continued to February 2, 2021, hearing. - Expedited petitions: Approved. - All transfers and continuances: Granted as above. - New staff: Genesis Hill (associate planner) and Michael Weigel (host/QA) were welcomed.

ZONING AND LAND USE 57% · PROCEDURAL 17% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 9% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 5%
826
JUL 21, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Hearing - July 21, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division III, held a public hearing on Wednesday, July 21, 2021, at approximately 3:00 PM. Acting Chairperson Ron Hampton presided, with board members Janice Golson Dunlap, Tony Bushinko, Catherine Chi, and Jim Rollinson. The board heard several continuance requests, an expedited docket, and six full hearing petitions, covering signage variances, an affordable housing development, a home-based ministry, and residential fence and lot variances. Votes were conducted by roll call. Consent Calendar - The board approved a waiver of the rules of procedure to allow a single vote on all expedited petitions and their findings of fact. Motion carried 5-0. - The expedited docket (cases 2021 DV3030, 2021 DV3033, 2021 DV3034, 2021 UV3008, 2021 UV3009) was approved unanimously (5-0). Special Requests, Continuances & Withdrawals - Case 2021 SE3001 (1722 Olive Street): A one-month continuance to August 17, 2021, with additional notice, was granted unanimously (5-0) at the request of petitioner Sarah Walters, due to address and ownership issues. - Case 2021 UV3010 (1822 Cornell Avenue): A continuance to August 17, 2021, without additional notice, was granted unanimously (5-0) to allow petitioner to confirm IPL pole setbacks. - Case 2021 DV3031 (5859 Forest Lane): A timely automatic continuance to August 17, 2021, was acknowledged by the board. - Case 2021 DV3028 (2825-2849 Central Avenue/507 E 29th Street): A request to move this case to the expedited docket was denied after a remonstrator appeared; the case was heard in the full docket. Public Comments & Testimony - For 2021 DV3028 (Central Avenue affordable housing), remonstrator Andre Solomon (2916 Central Avenue) expressed opposition specifically to the inclusion of 14 permanent supportive housing units for formerly homeless individuals, citing safety concerns, drug use issues reported at a similar facility (Penn Place), and the proposed 50-foot building height in a predominantly residential area. He noted he is a board member of the Mapleton Fall Creek Neighborhood Association, which voted to support the project, but he spoke as an individual. He requested that the 14 units be placed on the first floor and asked about on-site security. - For 2021 UV3007 (4017 South State Avenue), remonstrator (neighbor) testified against the religious office and illuminated 12 sq ft sign, stating the sign is too large for the D3 residential zone, creates light trespass, and that the petitioner’s Airbnb and other activities generate excessive traffic and parking issues. She claimed the petitioner had a history of neighbor disputes and that the office could be located in a commercial area. A petition with nine remonstrator signatures was presented. - For 2021 DV3032 (5754 Hillside Avenue), a neighbor voiced concerns about pedestrian safety due to the fence encroaching into the right-of-way and blocking sight lines, especially given cut-through traffic and nearby high school. - For 2021 DV3036 (Fletcher Avenue), remonstrator James Dial (1444 Fletcher Avenue) expressed concerns about fire safety and structural damage due to the proposed 5-foot separation between new homes and his property. He welcomed the development but sought adequate spacing. Discussion Items 2021 DV3025 – Krispy Kreme Sign (6022 E 82nd Street) Petitioner (Anchor Sign/Krispy Kreme) requested a variance for a 15-foot tall pylon sign within 300 feet of existing signs. After discussion, the petitioner and Councilman Dan Boots jointly requested a 30-day continuance to explore a 10-foot monument sign consistent with the Castleton Strategic Revitalization Plan. The board continued the petition to August 17, 2021, with notice (motion 5-0). Staff recommended that the petitioner also consult with the Allisonville Community Council and clarify sign square footage. 2021 DV3026 – Sign at 9605 E Washington Street Petitioner Raymond Mandarino (Synorama) requested a variance for a third freestanding pole sign (17.5 ft, 64 sq ft, digital display) on the property. Staff recommended denial because the site can function with existing signage, the digital display is prohibited on pole signs, and the sign is within 600 feet of a protected dwelling district. The petition was denied (1 yes, 4 no). 2021 DV3028 – Affordable Housing at 2825-2849 Central Avenue Petitioner Mapleton Fall Creek Development Corporation (Joe Calderon) requested variances for a 50-foot, four-story multifamily building (max 35 ft allowed), reduced transitional yards, and less interior parking lot landscaping. The project includes 100% affordable units, with a mix of AMI levels and 14 permanent supportive housing units. Staff supported the request due to the site’s location in a transit-oriented development area and compatibility with the Red Line plan. The remonstrator’s concerns were addressed. The board approved the petition unanimously (5-0) with commitments for a living wall and bus stop collaboration with IndyGo. 2021 UV3007 – Religious Office & Sign at 4017 S State Avenue Petitioner Uche Anogu (Onyx House) requested a variance of use (office for religious use not permitted in D3) and a 12 sq ft wall sign (max 6 sq ft). He testified that the garage is used for his online ministry (no profit, no employees currently, two unpaid interns possible) and that a similar variance was granted to nearby Joyce House (adult daycare). Staff recommended denial, citing self-imposed hardship, lack of pedestrian infrastructure, and suburban neighborhood typology. The remonstrator raised concerns about traffic, parking, and a sign that is already larger and illuminated. The board approved the petition (3 yes, 2 no) with conditions that the sign illumination remain off and an encroachment license for the fence portion be pursued. The petitioner committed to not hiring employees and to addressing neighbor concerns. 2021 DV3032 – Fence at 5754 Hillside Avenue Petitioner Lisa Rainey sought to legalize a 50-inch tall, 50% opaque picket fence that encroaches into the right-of-way and within the clear sight triangle. Staff recommended denial due to safety concerns. The petitioner presented a strong neighborhood support petition (28 residents) and offered commitments to obtain an encroachment license and not place signs outside the fence. The board approved the variance (3 yes, 2 no). 2021 DV3036 – Two Homes at 1448-1450 Fletcher Avenue Petitioner Mark Crouch requested variances for reduced front setback (8 ft vs. 18 ft), reduced separation between dwellings (5 ft vs. 10 ft), and reduced open space (50% vs. 60%). Staff recommended approval with conditions: increase front setback to 10 ft and avoid identical building designs. The petitioner agreed to increase the separation from the west neighbor from 5 ft to 7 ft to address fire safety concerns and confirmed a firewall would be installed. The board approved the petition unanimously (5-0). Key Outcomes - Approved (5-0): Expedited docket; continuances for SE3001, UV3010; DV3028 (affordable housing); DV3036 (Fletcher homes). - Approved (3-2): UV3007 (religious office/sign); DV3032 (fence). - Denied (1-4): DV3026 (sign at 9605 E Washington). - Continued to August 17, 2021: DV3025 (Krispy Kreme sign) with notice; DV3031 automatic continuance. - All decisions on denied and approved petitions include adoption of findings of fact in subsequent meetings.

ZONING AND LAND USE 37% · SIGN REGULATION 18% · FENCE REGULATION 11% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 10%
827
JUL 13, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two Meeting - July 13, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division Two, convened on July 13, 2021, at 6:00 PM under the chairmanship of Mark Young. Board members present included Alicia Reuter, Peter Nelson, Mary Kelly, and James Duke (who arrived later). Staff from the Division of Planning presented on several variance petitions. The meeting covered routine procedural approvals, continuances, and deliberation on three contested variance requests. Consent Calendar - The board voted unanimously to waive rules of procedure to allow a single vote on all expedited petitions and adopt their findings of fact collectively. - Several petitions were continued without debate: - 2020 DB 3049 (7430 East Southport Road): Continued to August 10, 2021, with notice if needed, after multiple prior continuances. Staff requested this be the last continuance. - 2021 DV 2036 (644 North Tacoma Avenue): Transferred to the August 3, 2021, hearing of Division 1 (without additional notice). - 2021 UV 2014 (5053 East Michigan Street): Continued to August 10, 2021, with notice due to a docketing error. - 2021 SE 2001 (1018 and 1030 Lowry Lane): Acknowledged automatic continuance to August 10, 2021. - 2021 DV 2025 (8008 Fishback Road): Continued to August 10, 2021, without additional notice. - 2021 DV 2029 (1445 West 86th Street) was initially moved to the expedited docket but pulled after an objector appeared. - Expedited petitions (excluding 2021 DV 2029) were approved unanimously by roll call. These included variances for garages, open space, and setbacks at addresses including 4002 South Delaware Street, 1623 Hoyt Avenue, 1409 Charles Street, 1525 West 26th Street, 10621 East Edgewood Avenue, and 1841 South East Street. Public Comments & Testimony - Ron Wallace (806th Street, Taunton Road, Greenbrier subdivision) spoke on the 2021 DV 2029 petition (1445 West 86th Street). He initially objected to a sign but expressed willingness to accept the proposed 10-foot monument sign and two menu boards, though he remained concerned about visual impact from the road. He stated he was not aware of the neighborhood organization approval. Discussion Items 2021 DV 2029 (1445 West 86th Street) – McDonald's Sign Variance - Petitioner Sean Smith (6001 Nymph's Parkway, South Bend) requested variances for a 10-foot monument sign (third freestanding sign on 86th Street, within 85 feet of an existing sign) and two menu boards per drive-through lane (one permitted). The petition was amended from a taller pylon sign to a monument design after neighborhood organization input. The neighborhood organization (Nora Northside Community Council) filed a no-objection letter with a condition to protect city-owned trees. - Staff recommended approval, noting the reduced height and size were acceptable. - The board voted unanimously to approve the variance, including the condition regarding trees. 2021 DV 2030 (8252 Kelly Lane) – Crew Car Wash Digital Sign Variance - Petitioner Joe Calderon (11 South Meridian, Indianapolis) represented DOM Number 5, doing business as Crew Car Wash. The request was for a 54.10-square-foot digital sign on an existing pole sign; digital signs are not permitted on pole signs per the 2019 sign code. Calderon argued the existing pole sign is legal and set back from Allisonville Road; the digital sign would replace three panels totaling 80.77 square feet, reducing signage by about 30%. The location is in C4 zoning near Castleton Square with no nearby residences. Commitments included no blinking or flashing, adjusted brightness, off between 10 PM and 6 AM, and limited messaging during rush hours. - Staff recommended denial, citing the 2019 sign code revisions that explicitly prohibit conversion of pole signs to digital displays to reduce proliferation and improve aesthetics. Staff noted the digital display would be permitted if the sign were converted to a monument or pylon sign, and that no practical difficulty existed. - The board voted 5-0 to approve the variance, with all members voting yes. 2021 DV 2034 (2038 Yandy Street) – Duplex Variance - Petitioner Mark Dimmerley (Demerley Architects, 6500 Westfield Boulevard) sought variances for a two-family dwelling (duplex) in D8 zoning: a 10.5-foot front setback (18 feet or average required), 50% open space (55% required), and two-foot side setbacks for a detached four-car garage (four feet required). The site is a 40-foot-wide lot. Dimmerley cited two prior approvals in the King Park area (2056 Park Avenue and 1630/1634 North Carrollton) as precedent. He requested the case be split into two votes: Part A (front setback and open space) and Part B (side setbacks). - Staff recommended denial of the two-foot side setbacks due to concerns about fire separation and overdevelopment; they noted the garage could be reduced to a two- or three-car size. Staff did not oppose the front setback or open space variances. - The board voted separately: - Part A (10.5-foot front setback and 50% open space): Approved 5-0. - Part B (two-foot side setbacks): Approved 3-2 (Reuter and Kelly voted no; Duke, Nelson, and Young voted yes). - Findings of fact were deferred to the August 10, 2021, meeting for adoption, as the submittal was deficient. Key Outcomes - Expedited petitions (excluding 2021 DV 2029): Approved unanimously. - 2021 DV 2029 (1445 West 86th Street): Approved unanimously with a condition to protect city-owned trees. - 2021 DV 2030 (8252 Kelly Lane): Approved 5-0 for a digital sign conversion on an existing pole sign, against staff recommendation. - 2021 DV 2034 (2038 Yandy Street): Part A (front setback and open space) approved 5-0; Part B (side setbacks) approved 3-2. Findings of fact to be presented for adoption at the August 10, 2021, meeting. - Various continuances were granted as noted in the Consent Calendar. - The meeting adjourned after the final case.

SIGN REGULATION 40% · ZONING AND LAND USE 36% · PROCEDURAL 22% · PENDING LITIGATION 2%
828
JUL 6, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Hearing - July 6, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 1, chaired by Joanna Tapp, held a public hearing on July 6, 2021. The board considered continuances, expedited petitions, and two non-expedited variance cases. Board members present were Clint McKay, Beth Brandon, and Roderick Bahannon, with legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and staff from the Division of Planning. Consent Calendar - The board approved a waiver of rules of procedure to allow a single vote on all expedited petitions and findings of fact. Motion carried unanimously. - The following continuances were granted by unanimous vote: - 2021 DV1039 (1709 Alford Street): Continued to August 3, 2021 hearing with notice, as requested by petitioner Mark Demerley due to amended survey conditions. - 2021 UV1012 (619 Holly): Continued to August 3, 2021 hearing without notice, requested by Sarah Walters due to prior indecisive vote. - 2021 DV1013 (address not specified): Continued to August 3, 2021 hearing with additional notice, requested by Sarah Walters because a survey was recently obtained. - 2021 UV1014 (1336 Shelby Street): Continued to August 3, 2021 hearing due to deficient notice, as recommended by staff. - 2021 UV1015 (2415 East Southport Road): Acknowledged automatic continuance to August 3, 2021, filed by a registered neighborhood group. - Petition 2021 DV1036 (7201 North Illinois Street) was moved to the expedited docket with staff's concurrence, as no remonstrator appeared. - Petition 2021 DV2024 (1054 East Troy Avenue) was amended to withdraw variance requests for chain link fence, outdoor storage, and operations in the rear transitional yard; the amended petition was moved to the expedited docket. Public Comments & Testimony - No public testimony was received for the expedited cases. - For non-expedited case 2021 DV1025, neighbor Tom Bailey (2830 North Raider) testified in support, stating the petitioner's work has improved the neighborhood and requesting the board allow completion of the structure. Discussion Items 2021 DV1025 – 2816 North River Avenue (Roy E. Trotter, represented by David A. Rutherford) - Petitioner's Position: Mr. Rutherford explained that the .45-acre lot is zoned DA (designed for larger tracts), and the proposed 1,600 sq. ft. pole barn (22.67 ft tall) would replace an existing dilapidated garage. The new building would have a 3-foot side setback, 13.5-foot rear setback, and 77% open space (vs. required 15 ft side/rear, 85% open space). A height variance was needed because the accessory building exceeds the 14.5 ft house height (though under the 24 ft code limit). Petitioners offered commitments: no commercial vehicle storage in the building and removal of existing outbuildings within one year. They gathered 18 signatures of support from neighbors. - Staff Recommendation: Denial. Staff argued the structure is too large for the site, would not maintain the dwelling as the primary use, and no practical difficulty was demonstrated since a smaller structure could comply. The height and mass would negatively impact the surrounding single-story ranch character. - Board Questions: Chairperson Taft asked to widen the commitment to prohibit commercial vehicle storage anywhere on the premises, which the petitioner accepted. - Outcome: Approved 4-0 (McKay aye, Bohannan aye, Brandon aye, Taft aye). 2021 UV1013 – 4626 East 30th Street (Homes by Luster, LLC, represented by Brent Bennett) - Petitioner's Position: Mr. Bennett requested a use variance to construct a 1,500 sq. ft. steel building for storing vehicles and equipment related to a home cleaning company. The lot is vacant in a D5 zone. He argued the area already contains non-residential uses, such as a nearby lot with nine parked cars. - Staff Recommendation: Denial. Staff stated the use would be inappropriate in the residential context, would adversely affect adjacent property values, and the vacant lot could be developed residentially consistent with the traditional neighborhood plan. A prior variance at 4710 East 30th Street was for an accessory structure to an existing residence, not a standalone commercial use. - Board Vote: McKay aye, Bohannan aye, Brandon aye, Taft no. Approved 3-1. - Follow-up: The board noted that the proposed findings of fact were deficient. The petition was continued to the next hearing for adoption of suitable findings. Key Outcomes - Expedited Docket: All 14 expedited petitions (2021 DV1031, DV1033, DV1034, DV1035, DV1037, DV1038, DV1040, DV2024, DV3029, DV1036 and others listed) were approved by a single unanimous roll call vote (4-0). These involved variances for setbacks, height, open space, parking, and accessory structures. - 2021 DV1025: Approved 4-0 with commitments to remove existing outbuildings within one year and prohibit commercial vehicle parking on the property. - 2021 UV1013: Approved 3-1 but continued for adoption of findings; petitioner to work with staff on revised findings of fact. - Adoption of Findings: The board adopted findings for previously approved petitions (2020 DV1082, 2021 DB1026, 2021 DV1027) presented by Members Taft, Bohannan, and McKay. Findings for petitions approved on July 6 with suitable findings were also signed.

PROCEDURAL 51% · ZONING AND LAND USE 49%
829
JUN 15, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Meeting - June 15, 2021

The Board of Zoning Appeals Division III convened on June 15, 2021 at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room, 2nd Floor City-County Building, to hear and deliberate on multiple variance petitions. The following summary is based on the agenda and staff reports provided; no transcript of public testimony or board discussion is included in the source materials. Consent Calendar No items were designated for the consent calendar in the provided materials. Public Comments & Testimony No public comments or testimony are recorded in the agenda or staff reports. Discussion Items Each petition is listed below with its case number, address, request, and relevant staff notes or recommendations. - 2021-DV3-027 — 1423 South State Avenue (Center Township, District 21) Request: Variance of development standards to permit reconstruction of a single-family dwelling with a 13-foot front setback (18 feet required), zero-foot south side setback (3 feet required), and 5.5 feet between dwellings (10 feet required). Staff Note: A 1949 variance for the housing project was located; staff recommends approval with a condition to file a rezone petition prior to issuance of an Improvement Location Permit. - 2021-UV1-010 — 1518 Renton Street (Center Township, District 21) Request: Variance of use to provide a community building (with washer/dryers and community room) for an existing multifamily development; use not permitted in I-4/C-1 zoning. Staff Note: This petition was continued from May 18, 2021 at the petitioner's request. Staff recommends approval with a commitment to rezone the property to an appropriate residential district within two years. - 2021-DV3-011 (Amended) — 7001 Hoover Road (Washington Township, District 2) Request: Variance of development standards for a 5-foot tall freestanding sign with a 3.8-foot front setback from Hoover Road (10-foot setback required). An amended site plan relocated the sign and recalculated the clear sight triangle. Staff Note: This case was automatically continued from May 18, 2021 at the request of a registered neighborhood organization. Staff recommends approval of the amended request. - 2021-DV3-021 — 3511 West 20th Street (Wayne Township, District 11) Request: Variance to allow an addition to a detached garage with a 2-foot rear setback (5-foot required) and a footprint greater than the primary dwelling. Staff Note: Automatically continued from May 18, 2021 at the petitioner's request. Staff expressed concerns regarding fire separation and does not support the request. - 2021-DV3-024 — 5529 Snowberry Court (Decatur Township, District 20) Request: Variance to legally establish an existing fence within a drainage/utility easement, a patio encroaching 3.5 feet into the easement, a shed with a 2-foot side setback (5-foot required), and a roofed patio enclosure encroaching 6 feet into the rear setback and easement. Staff Note: Automatically continued from May 18, 2021 at the request of a registered neighborhood organization. Staff is not supportive of the request due to inconsistency with neighboring lots. - 2021-DV3-025 — 6022 East 82nd Street (Lawrence Township, District 3) Request: Variance to erect a 15-foot tall, 51-square foot pylon sign within 180 feet of an existing sign (300-foot separation required) and as the eighth sign along the frontage (maximum two freestanding signs permitted). Staff Note: A timely automatic continuance was filed by a City-County Councilor, moving the hearing to July 20, 2021. - 2021-DV3-026 — 9605 East Washington Street (Warren Township, District 19) Request: Variance for an additional freestanding sign: a 17.5-foot tall, 64-square foot pole sign within 70 feet of an existing sign (300-foot separation required, maximum two signs permitted). Staff Note: Staff recommends continuance to July 20, 2021 to allow addition of a variance for a digital display within 600 feet of a protected district, as the digital component was not included in the original notice. - 2021-DV3-028 — 2825, 2829, 2833, 2837, 2841, 2845, 2849 Central Avenue and 507 East 29th Street (Center Township, District 9) Request: Variance of development standards to allow a 50-foot, four-story multifamily building with reduced front and side transitional yards and less interior parking lot landscaping than required. Staff Note: The petitioner's representative indicated intent to request a continuance for cause to July 20, 2021. No objection from staff. - 2021-UV3-007 — 4017 South State Avenue (Perry Township, District 24) Request: Variance of use and development standards to permit offices for a religious use (not permitted in D-3 district) with a 12-square foot wall sign (maximum 6 square feet permitted). Staff Note: The petitioner's representative indicated intent to request a continuance for cause to July 20, 2021. Staff is opposed to the variance, noting a self-imposed hardship and lack of pedestrian infrastructure. Key Outcomes - Continuances granted or anticipated: Petitions 2021-DV3-025, 2021-DV3-026, 2021-DV3-028, and 2021-UV3-007 were either automatically continued or indicated a planned continuance to the July 20, 2021 hearing. Petitions 2021-UV1-010, 2021-DV3-011, 2021-DV3-021, and 2021-DV3-024 were continued from the May 18, 2021 hearing to the June 15 hearing; their final board decisions are not recorded in the provided materials. - Staff recommendations: For petitions 2021-DV3-027 and 2021-UV1-010, staff recommends approval with conditions (rezoning). For 2021-DV3-011 (amended), staff recommends approval. For 2021-DV3-021 and 2021-DV3-024, staff does not support the variance. For 2021-UV3-007, staff opposes the variance. No board votes are documented. - No public testimony or board deliberation is included in the source, so the meeting's discussion and final actions cannot be fully reported.

ZONING AND LAND USE 46% · PROCEDURAL 14% · SIGN REGULATION 12% · TRAFFIC SAFETY 10%
830
JUN 8, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Indianapolis Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two Meeting - June 8, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division Two, held a public hearing on June 8, 2021, at 6:00 PM. Chairperson Mark Young presided, with board members Mary Kelly, Alicia Ruder, James Duke, and Peter Nelson present. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and several planning staff members attended. The board handled continuances, withdrawals, expedited petitions, and four contested variance petitions. Special Requests and Continuances - 2021 SC201 (1018 and 1030 Lowry Lane): Continued to July 13, 2021, without additional notice, to allow petitioner (Central Indiana Christian Fellowship Church) to continue meeting with neighbors. - 2021 UV2007 (6585 East 30th Street): Withdrawal acknowledged. - 2021 DV2024 (1054 East Troy Avenue): Transferred to the July 6, 2021, BZA1 hearing without additional notice. - 2021 DV2025 (8008 Fishback Road): Continued to July 13, 2021, with additional notice if required, to revise site plan for a ground-mounted solar array. - 2021 DV3049 (7430 East Southport Road): Continued to July 13, 2021, with new notice due to an amended petition. - 2021 DV2005 (351 Southeast Street): Withdrawal acknowledged. - 2021 UV2008 (3112, 3118, 3122 Dr. AJ Brown Avenue and 1118 East 30th Street): Withdrawal acknowledged. - 2021 DV2029 (1445 West 86th Street): Automatic continuance to July 13, 2021, acknowledged. Expedited Petitions The board voted unanimously to approve three expedited petitions in a single roll call: - 2021 DV2026: Variance for a single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks. - 2021 DV2027: Variance for a single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks and open space. - 2021 DV2028: Variance for 38 parking spaces where 28 are permitted. Discussion Items 2021 DV2010 – 1718 Southeast Street (10-foot fence) - Petitioner: Michael Scherfik (property owner) requested a variance to allow a 10-foot tall fence in side and rear yards (maximum 6 feet permitted). He argued the fence reduced noise from a restaurant/bar tenant and provided privacy for the courtyard. He submitted 8–11 letters of support from adjacent property owners. - Staff position: Recommended denial, stating that the fence could be reduced to 6 feet and supplemented with landscaping, and no practical difficulty was demonstrated. The property had a zoning violation due to a neighbor complaint. - Board vote: 3–2 in favor (Duke, Nelson, Young yes; Kelly, Reuter no). Approved. 2021 DV2018 – 4102 East 42nd Street (6-foot front yard fence) - Petitioner: Melissa Hawk (homeowner) requested a variance to place a 6-foot privacy fence in the front yard (along Forest Manor Avenue) where a 3.5-foot maximum is permitted. She proposed a 7-foot gap from a tree to preserve neighbor's view of traffic. She cited safety concerns for her children playing in the yard. - Staff position: Recommended denial; the fence could be located at the leading edge of the dwelling to comply (as neighboring property did). No practical difficulty was shown. - Board vote: 4–1 in favor (Kelly, Duke, Nelson, Young yes; Reuter no). Approved, with continuation for adoption of revised findings of fact. 2021 UV2010 – 6739 Shelbyville Road (business office, sign, parking setback) - Petitioner: Attorney David Rutherford, on behalf of Scott A. Smith and the Holcombs (Keller Williams real estate office), requested a use variance to operate a business and professional office, a freestanding sign, and a parking lot with a 6-foot side setback (30 feet required). The property is zone DA (agricultural/estate). The petitioner presented commitments including 30–35 evergreen trees, a 6-foot privacy fence, and arborvitae screening. Letters of support were submitted from City-County Councilor Brian Mowry and State Senator Freeman. The Westport HOA and Franklin Township land use committee supported the petition after negotiation. - Staff position: Recommended denial, citing the use is not permitted in DA, would encourage commercial conversions, and the sign and parking setbacks are inconsistent with the district. Staff noted the revised site plan was received the day before. - Board vote: 5–0 in favor. Approved. 2021 UV2011 – 9265 East 82nd Street (plant nursery) - Petitioner: Keith Bucklew requested a variance to operate a plant nursery (retail sale of trees, shrubs, perennials) on a 7-acre property (zone D1). He described it as a part-time hobby business run by his wife, with limited hours and no employees. He claimed the nursery would be non-intrusive and not visible from neighbors. - Remonstrators: Several neighbors testified in opposition. They cited: ongoing business operations without a variance (zoning violation), altered drainage causing flooding, increased traffic, noise from dump trucks, removal of trees, and concerns about property values. The Sergeant Hills Homeowners Association, represented by John Franklin Reasner, opposed the petition. The neighbors stated the petitioner had not communicated with many of them and that the property was not occupied. - Staff position: Recommended denial, noting the proposed use is heavy commercial retail, the business was already operating, and the variance would be injurious to the community. Staff also cited concerns about visibility, traffic, and inconsistency with the comprehensive plan. - Board vote: 5–0 to deny. Denied, with continuation for adoption of negative findings of fact. Key Outcomes - Approved: 2021 DV2010 (3–2), 2021 DV2018 (4–1, continued for findings), 2021 UV2010 (5–0). - Denied: 2021 UV2011 (5–0, continued for negative findings). - Expedited petitions: All three approved unanimously. - Continuances and withdrawals: As listed above, all granted or acknowledged. Administrator Update on SEA 392 - Matt Pleasant, Plan Administrator, informed the board about Indiana Senate Enrolled Act 392, which will require all nine Marion County townships to be represented across the three BZA divisions starting in 2022. The legislation also affects appointment procedures. The board will work with the City-County Council and Mayor's office to ensure compliance by the end of 2021.

ZONING AND LAND USE 62% · FENCE REGULATION 13% · PROCEDURAL 8% · TOWNSHIP REPRESENTATION 5%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com