Public Meetings - Livonia, Michigan

The Livonia City Council met for a study session on Monday, May 18, 2026. The agenda listed 8:00 p.m., but the minutes record the meeting was called to order at 8:17 p.m. in the City Hall Auditorium by Council President Reid. Present were Robin Persiconi, Martha Ptashnik, Vice President Brockway, Eileen McDonnell, and President Reid; Carrie Budzinski and Brandon McCullough were absent. The meeting was an agenda-setting session for the June 1, 2026 regular meeting, described as the 2042nd regular meeting, where final votes are scheduled. It adjourned at 10:02 p.m. Officials present included Interim City Attorney Eric Goldstein, Planning Director Mark Taormina, and City Engineer Todd Zilincik. Consent Calendar Council directed the following items to the consent agenda for the June 1, 2026 regular meeting: - Three block party requests: Nicholas Scott (Ohio Street, July 4), Brittany Matties (Ladywood Street, July 25), and Carol Dobos (Cranston Street, August 22), all with rain dates. - Vacating petition 2026-03-03-01 for water main and scenic easements at 33500 Seven Mile Road. - Reappointments of Sam Caramagno, Peter Ventura, and Glen Long to the Planning Commission for three-year terms expiring June 9, 2029. - Bound Tree Medical contract extension for emergency medical supplies and equipment, not to exceed $130,000 annually. - Waiver of sealed bidding for seven marked and five unmarked police vehicles through State of Michigan cooperative pricing. - CLEMIS participation agreement and membership continuation. - ESRI GIS software maintenance renewal for one year at $47,305. - Greenmead Historical Village caretaking contract with Jeffrey Ronayne for December 1, 2026 through November 30, 2028, with two additional two-year renewal options. - Two donations: $138 from Michiganense Natives and $7,500 from the Michigan Recycling Coalition. - Ford Field Diamond 7 backstop and dugout bench replacement bid award of $14,140. - Sole source authorization for stormwater, water main, and sanitary manhole items not to exceed $200,000 annually for July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2027. Public Comments & Testimony General audience communication: - Denise Mika requested that legal notices published in newspapers also be posted on the city website or in council minutes, and asked a procedural question about when bond notices become valid. - Steve King expressed opposition to the wetlands police station plan, saying 18,000 people rejected the original plan and that the current station could be renovated for one-third of the cost. He supported funding police from the general fund and accused the city of pausing the wetlands plan until after the August safety millage vote. - Jim Biga recommended the council assign resident concerns to individual council members and report back at the next meeting. - Christopher Martin asked for agenda-item assignments and asked whether council members should endorse items from the dais or only from the podium as individuals. - John Pastor gave a road project update and defended the police department and council, criticizing Steve King. - In response, Reid said legal notices are included in approved minutes and noted that about 66% of the general fund, approximately $50 million, pays for public safety. McDonnell raised library accessibility issues and said the areas behind the courthouse and library are wetlands, though unregulated because they are under five acres. - At the end of the meeting, James Crowley said a resident should not have been allowed to attack another resident and asked the council to address transparency when people doing contracts with the city speak as residents. Item 4 (Fox Drive condition): - Brandon Grysko, attorney for Mannik & Smith Group and Six Mile LLC, requested amendment of Council Resolution 402-25, arguing the petitioner does not control the right-of-way and needs the Fox Drive access condition removed or modified so the development and the traffic signal can proceed. - Jeff Horka of Masco Corporation supported the request, calling the traffic signal critical to safety and noting Masco has about 200 employees in the area. - John Wright of Schoolcraft College supported it, saying the $1.2 million signal would reduce angle crashes; he cited eight angle crashes from 2017 to 2021 that the signal could address. - Jake Relette of Mannik & Smith Group said the trip-generation analysis was for the use change and would not materially differ with or without Fox Drive access. - Residents Jim Biga, Jerry Karasinski, and Denise Mika voiced concerns or opposition. Biga said the proposed signal placement was unsafe and the public had been misled; Karasinski said he was not in favor of making the concession to the developer and suggested businesses buy out the landowner rather than rely on eminent domain; Mika said the earlier approval was rushed and the traffic study was not in the packet. - Horka later suggested eminent domain may be necessary if the landowner continues not to respond. Item 13 (Greenmead caretaker): - Christopher Martin opposed the contract because it includes rent-free residence in the Greenmead parsonage, arguing the city should seek rent and still require the caretaking services. Item 6 (reappointments): - Christopher Martin opposed Sam Caramagno's reappointment, citing multiple committee roles and cronyism concerns. Jerry Karasinski supported Caramagno. Steve King asked the council to consider term limits and conflicts for long-serving commission members. Item 19 (water and sewer rates): - Jerry Karasinski asked about the $1.7 million billing cost and efficiency. Cindy Fleming encouraged residents to participate in the lead service line identification program. Discussion Items - Item 4: Councilmembers debated whether removing the Fox Drive condition would make the access optional. Planning Director Taormina confirmed that under the substitute language, the Fox Drive access would no longer be required. Councilmember McDonnell requested the current traffic study and wanted the item on the regular agenda. Councilmember Persiconi suggested language that would let the developer adjust driveways while keeping Fox Drive access as a continuing condition. Vice President Brockway cited planning commission minutes in which a traffic engineer said a second access was crucial, and offered a denial motion. The council ultimately directed both an approval motion and a denial motion to the June 1 regular agenda. - Item 17 (rock salt): Doug Moore explained the cooperative bid through Farmington Hills had a low bidder become unresponsive, so Detroit Salt was recommended. Livonia would commit to 4,200 tons for the 2026-2027 season, with a second season and four one-year extensions at 5% increases. Councilmember McDonnell asked about the ability to opt out; Moore said the city would likely pay market rates if it left the consortium. Vice President Brockway moved the item to the regular agenda for review. - Item 19 (water and sewer rates): Zach Haapala presented the FY 2026-27 rate proposal. Water and sewer are a self-funded enterprise fund. GLWA's water rate increase for Livonia is 5.62% and Wayne County's sewer increase is estimated at 6.58%, effective July 1, 2026. The proposal keeps fixed fees unchanged and increases variable rates; the average residential user at 20 units per quarter would see an increase of $4.60 per month, or $13.80 per quarter, a 6.16% increase. Projected expenditures are about $55.3 million, with projected cash of just under $16 million, covering about 135 days. Capital projects include replacing water main in Section 22, where there have been 96 breaks since 2016, lead service line work, and sewer lining. Councilmember Ptashnik voiced support and moved the item to the regular agenda. Key Outcomes - No binding votes were taken; this was a study meeting. - Consent agenda recommendations were made for items 1-3, 5-16, and 18. - Item 4 was directed to the June 1 regular agenda with both an approval motion and a denial motion. - Item 17, the rock salt purchase authorization, was directed to the June 1 regular agenda. - Item 19, the water and sewer rate adjustments, was directed to the June 1 regular agenda. - The meeting adjourned at 10:02 p.m.; final votes are scheduled for the June 1, 2026 regular meeting.

The Livonia City Council held its 2041st regular meeting on Monday, May 18, 2026, from 7:00 p.m. to 8:02 p.m. at City Hall. Five councilmembers were present (Persiconi, Ptashnik, Brockway, McDonnell, Reed); two were absent. All votes passed 5-0. A significant portion of the meeting was devoted to public comments on the upcoming Wayne County Transit Millage, with over a dozen residents speaking in support. Consent Calendar The council approved 10 items on a single vote, including: - Minutes of the May 4, 2026 meeting (Resolution 181-26). - Block party for Jasmine Cone on June 4, 2026, on Alexander Street. - Sidewalk waiver for Shadyside Development LLC at three properties on Shadyside Street. - Waiver petitions for Costco Wholesale (reconfigure fueling and parking at 13700 and 13550 Middle Belt Road), Meijer Inc. (new gas station and convenience store at 13000 Middle Belt Road), and El Car Wash Mid-West LLC (auto wash at 13000 Middle Belt Road). Each was granted with conditions. - Amendment of Resolution 151-25 replacing the authorized representative for the Drinking Water Revolving Fund project with Zach Haapala. - Approval of Water Service Contract Amendment No. 5 between GLWA and the City, effective July 1, 2027. - Acceptance of storm water maintenance agreements from Plymouth Auto Sales, Seven Mile/Farmington Venture Limited Partnership, and JB Tool. Public Comments & Testimony First Session (7:13 p.m. – 7:35 p.m.): - Transit millage supporters dominated the first audience period. Speakers (including Justin Gooch, Chris Hench, Alice Angdahl, Kim Snider, Valerie P., John Lauderman, Jeremy Cubs, Sean C., Matthias Reed, Debra Freier, Sarah Blouin, and Anaya Kelly) urged the council to support the Wayne County Transit Millage on the August 4, 2026 ballot. They highlighted that 12% of Livonia residents have a disability, 3% of households lack a car, and that for a median-value home the tax would be about $12 per month. Several shared personal stories of limited mobility and the high cost of alternatives like Uber ($80–$160 round trips). Jeremy Cubs and Sean C. from the group PEAK described their travel training and desire for independence. - Steve King raised concerns about a $1M+ HVAC contract on a previous consent agenda, alleging that two of three bidders were disqualified and the process lacked transparency. He also stated he had contacted the Attorney General about an alleged Open Meetings Act violation. - Christopher Martin criticized the "rubber stamp" approval of spending, suggested broadcasting ZBA meetings, and recommended a new appointment to the ZBA. Second Session (7:50 p.m. – 8:02 p.m.): - Peter Dale (Livonia Historical Society) supported the transit millage, recalling the loss of historic interurban rail. - Chris Urso questioned why council does not directly answer resident questions from the podium, asking for a better system. - John Pastor opposed the transit millage, stating it would harm Livonia's existing Livonia Community Transit (door-to-door service) and that SMART would only serve a few major roads, not adequately serve disabled seniors. - Laura Jannika argued for equity, recounting the story of a blind engineer who spends $30 each way to attend meetings. Council Response: Vice President Brockway acknowledged frustrations and directed residents to submit questions via email, the "ticket" system, or attend study sessions for more dialogue. Discussion Items - Items 11–14 (Easements and License Agreement): The council accepted three grants of easement from Seven Mile/Farmington Venture Limited Partnership (one storm sewer, two water main) for the Meijer development, and approved a license agreement with Consumers Energy for a construction staging area on Middle Belt property. All passed 5-0 after brief explanation as routine housekeeping. - Referral on Fence Mesh Ordinance: Councilmember Brockway motioned to refer Title 15, Chapter 44, Section 090 (mesh prohibitions) to the Law and Education Committee after a resident questioned the prohibition of mesh used as a deer deterrent. The referral passed 5-0. - Sidewalk Connectivity in Millennium Park: Councilmember McDonnell requested that staff reach out to property owners about adding a sidewalk network to connect Middle Belt Road businesses (including Meijer, Costco) to bus stops. Planning Director Taormina said it would require multiple property owners and requested at least a month to report back. Key Outcomes - All consent agenda items (10) and new business items (4) approved 5-0. - Law and Education Committee will review and report on fence mesh regulations. - Staff to explore sidewalk improvements in the Middle Belt/Millennium Park corridor. - The Finance Department's monthly purchase report was received and placed on file. - An ADA ramp for City Hall is expected to be installed in June ahead of early voting. - The meeting adjourned at 8:02 p.m. Note: The transcript contains an ambiguous remark suggesting a different tally for minutes approval, but the official minutes and roll call confirm a unanimous 5-0 vote.

The Livonia City Council held a study meeting on May 4, 2026, to review items for consideration at the regular meeting on May 18, 2026. The meeting was called to order at 8:21 PM and adjourned at 9:31 PM. All ten agenda items were directed to be placed on the consent agenda for the May 18 regular meeting. The council also heard public comments on consent agenda procedures, a pending development, and sidewalk policies, and briefly discussed a potential moratorium on data centers and car washes. Note: The agenda labels item 3 as a 'Master Plan Petition', while the minutes and transcript refer to it as a 'Waiver Petition'; the substance of the request is identical. Public Comments & Testimony - Steve King (Covenant Gardens) criticized the practice of bundling items on the consent agenda, arguing it limits public comment. He stated he would file a formal Open Meetings Act complaint and claimed council efforts to streamline efficiency undermine accountability. - Christopher Martin objected to the consent agenda procedure, asserting that residents should be allowed to speak individually on each item. He referenced the meeting's rules and argued the council made a procedural error. - Greg Ralko (Golf Ridge Villa) spoke about the Sheetz development at Eight Mile and Newburgh. He questioned why the city is defending the ZBA's decision, which he characterized as incompetent and illegal. He urged the council to put the topic on a future agenda, defend its previous 5-2 vote against rezoning, and direct the legal department to withdraw its defense of the appeal. - John Pastor expressed strong support for the ZBA and the Sheetz development. He argued that the opposition is from a small group, that the development benefits the community, and that the council should not waste more time on the matter; instead, let the courts decide. - Vicky Johnson (Jameson Court, Livonia) commented on the sidewalk waiver request, noting safety concerns for pedestrians who must walk in the street when sidewalks are absent or inconsistent. She urged the city to avoid creating patchwork sidewalks that increase danger. Discussion Items Consent Agenda Protocol During council comments, Councilmember McCullough and Assistant City Attorney Rogers clarified that the three-minute comment period applies per speaker, not per item, and that residents may request a council member to pull an item for separate discussion and comment. Data Center and Car Wash Moratorium Councilmember McDonnell asked for an update on the moratorium document for data centers and car washes. Assistant City Attorney Rogers stated that the legal department is actively researching and expects to present it by ordinance, but no specific timeline was available; she noted that Mr. Goldstein would provide an update at the next meeting. Development Proposals at Millennium Park (Items 3-5) Three waiver use petitions were presented together due to their interrelated nature, all involving the Millennium Park shopping center on Middle Belt Road. - Costco (Item 3): Costco proposes to remove its existing fueling facility in front of the warehouse and construct a new 20-pump fueling station behind the building on land owned by Millennium Park. The project also adds 88 new parking spaces where the current station sits, improves traffic circulation by making an exit onto Middle Belt Road right-turn-only, and creates a new four-way stop on the service drive behind Costco. The existing eight-pump station will be decommissioned and removed. The relocation is designed to reduce congestion at the Middle Belt/Millennium Drive entrance, currently the highest incident location in the city. - Meijer Gas Station & Convenience Store (Item 4): Meijer will construct a gas station with eight pumps and a 3,300-square-foot convenience store on land it owns at the east side of Middle Belt Road. The facility is intended to serve customers already shopping in the plaza and will include enhanced landscaping and architecture. - El Car Wash (Item 5): El Car Wash Mid-West LLC proposes to build a car wash at the north end of the Meijer parking lot. The project includes 24 indoor vacuum stations in a climate-controlled glass building, seven additional outdoor vacuums, and a design that will block six of the current 12 drive lanes through the Meijer lot to create more orderly traffic flow. The car wash recycles over 80% of its water and will be built with masonry and glass materials. The site is over 1,800 feet from the nearest residence. The combined projects represent approximately $26–27 million in private investment. Planning Director Taormina noted that the three petitions are coordinated under a single reciprocal easement and operating agreement and were approved unanimously by the Planning Commission after revisions. Councilmembers McCullough, Ptashnik, Persiconi, and McDonnell expressed support, citing improvements to traffic safety, increased green space (over one acre added), and the reuse of underutilized parking areas. Councilmember McDonnell also asked about phasing; the applicant indicated all projects will be developed concurrently, with the Costco relocation phased so the old station remains open until the new one opens. Consent Calendar The following items were directed to be placed on the consent agenda for the May 18, 2026 regular meeting: - Block Party: Jasmine Cone's request for a block party on Thursday, June 4, 2026, from 10:00 AM to 7:00 PM on Alexander Street between 14926 and 14966. - Sidewalk Waiver: Shadyside Development LLC's request to waive sidewalk requirements for three infill properties on Shadyside Street. The City Engineer noted the area has no existing sidewalks and recommended approval. - Amendment to Council Resolution 151-25: Replacing the authorized representative with Zachary Haapala for the lead service line replacement plan. - Water Service Contract Amendment No. 5 (GLWA): Minor adjustments to the contract, effective July 1, 2027, for four years. The new agreement lowers peak consumption limits to 21.4 million gallons per day (max day) and 30 million gallons per day (peak hour). - Stormwater Maintenance Agreements: Three separate agreements for Plymouth Auto Sales (36534 Plymouth Road), Seven Mile/Farmington Venture Limited Partnership (33500 Seven Mile Road, for new Meijer), and JB Tool (13000 Farmington Road). Key Outcomes - All 10 agenda items were approved for placement on the consent agenda for the May 18, 2026 regular meeting, where final votes will be taken. - The council discussed but took no formal action on the data center and car wash moratorium; the legal department is continuing to draft the ordinance.

The City Council of Livonia held its 2040th Regular Meeting on Monday, May 4, 2026, at 7:00 PM. Councilmembers McDonnell, Persiconi, Ptashnik, Brockway, McCullough, and Reed were present; Budzinski was absent. The meeting included approvals for park improvements, a denied appeal for charity poker, and authorization to distribute the Master Plan's Housing Sustainability chapter (Book 5) for public review. The meeting adjourned at 8:07 PM. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (Block Party on Arden Street): Approved for June 12, 2026. - Item 2 (Accessible Entrance at Newburg Schoolhouse): Awarded to KAB Enterprises ($55,075). - Item 4 (HVAC Maintenance at Recreation/Senior Centers): Awarded to W.J. O'Neil Company ($1,042,664 over 3 years). - Item 5 (Shelden Park Site Furnishings): Awarded to Kerr Albert Office Supply ($49,674). - Item 3 (Greenmead Roof) and Item 6 (City-Owned Property Purchase): Removed from the consent agenda for separate handling. Public Comments & Testimony - Steve King: Criticized the meeting structure for placing important business late in the agenda and argued the consent agenda is too large, undermining transparency. Later spoke against wood shakes for the Greenmead roof, promoting synthetic alternatives. - Denise Mika: Questioned the city's financial reporting, citing a $2.4 million budget adjustment in Department 265 and requesting more transparency on budget changes rather than simple 'receive and file' approvals. - Christopher Martin: Raised concerns about 16th District Court work program employees idling in city vehicles and asked about the city's process for removing dead deer from roadways. - John Schaefer: Asked about the status of city generators used to power traffic lights during outages and requested a summary of the Master Plan's Book 5. - John Grzebik: Expressed strong support for the police/fire and senior/parks/cultural millage renewals, emphasizing they are renewals with no new taxes. - Greg Ralko: Criticized the city for defending the ZBA's decision on a Sheetz development in court, questioning who in the city administration is pushing the defense. Later argued the Sheetz proposal conflicts with Greenmead's historic setting and the master plan. - Betsy Calhoun: Defended the Historic Preservation Commission's process for the Greenmead roof, stating they follow Secretary of the Interior guidelines. Later stated Book 5 gives insufficient attention to environmental sustainability. - Jerry Karasinski: Supported historical preservation for Greenmead and urged moving the master plan amendment forward to begin the public comment process. - Jim Biga: Requested a long-term maintenance plan for Greenmead roofs. Later criticized the Book 5 review process for lacking sufficient public input before moving forward. - Jim Baringhaus: Chair of the Greenleaf Commission, stated Book 5 does not fully address environmental sustainability and should include energy efficiency, water conservation, and sustainable site planning. - Naz Cimsit: Encouraged the city to address carbon emissions and the impact of mosquito spraying on native pollinators in the housing plan. - John Pastor: Urged a 'no' vote on the Wayne County transit millage to protect Livonia's local transit authority from being overridden. Discussion Items - Council Announcements: Councilmember McDonnell passed a motion to review purchases between $15,000 and $19,999 at the Committee of the Whole for greater transparency. Vice President Brockway referred the topic of ultralight aircraft safety to the Law and Education Committee. Councilmember McCullough announced a charity hockey event raising nearly $10,000. - Greenmead Roof Replacement (Item 3): Councilmember McCullough argued for traditional cedar shakes to preserve the historical character of the park, despite hearing comments about synthetic alternatives. The bid from Cedar Preservation Systems ($23,680) was unanimously approved 6-0. - Waiver Petition - The Rack Charity Poker (Item 7): Council unanimously (6-0) denied the appeal of a Planning Commission denial for a pool hall to host charity poker games. The denial cited incompatibility with the commercial corridor, over-concentration of gaming, parking deficiencies, failure to meet waiver standards, and potential for an undesirable precedent. - Master Plan Amendment - Book 5 Housing Sustainability (Item 8): Council clarified the vote authorized distribution for a public hearing, not final adoption. The motion to distribute passed 6-0. A subsequent motion to refer the item to the Law and Education Committee also passed 6-0. Key Outcomes - Greenmead Roof Bid (Item 3): Awarded to Cedar Preservation Systems ($23,680). Passed 6-0. - Charity Poker Appeal (Item 7): Denial upheld, concurring with Planning Commission. Passed 6-0. - Master Plan Amendment Distribution (Item 8): Authorized for public review and hearing. Passed 6-0. Referred to Law and Education Committee. Passed 6-0. - Ralko Speaking Time: Extended by 90 seconds by a 5-1 vote (Ptashnik dissenting). - Council Procedures: Purchases between $15,000 and $19,999 to be reviewed at the Committee of the Whole. - Committee Referrals: Ultralight aircraft and Master Plan Book 5 referred to Law & Education Committee. - Agenda Adjustments: Item 6 (Request to Purchase City-Owned Property) was removed from the agenda.

The Livonia City Council held a study meeting on April 20, 2026, at City Hall Auditorium. The meeting was called to order at 9:42 p.m. by President Reid, with all seven council members present (Martha Ptashnik, Vice President Brockway, Brandon McCullough, Eileen McDonnell, Carrie Budzinski, Robin Persiconi, and President Reid). The primary purpose was to set the agenda for the regular voting meeting on May 4, 2026. Items discussed included a request to purchase city-owned property, a block party request, proposed amendments to the Vision 21 Master Plan (Book 5: Housing Sustainability), and several bid awards for parks and recreation projects. Consent Calendar - Item 2: Block Party Request – Jackie Gordon’s annual block party on Arden Street, Friday June 12, 2026, from 4:00 to 10:00 p.m. Motion to place on consent agenda. - Item 4: Accessible Entrance to Newburgh Schoolhouse at Greenmead Historical Park – Bid award to KAB Enterprises for $55,005. Motion to place on consent. - Item 5: Replacement of A.J. Geer Store Roof at Greenmead Historical Park – Bid award to Cedar Preservation Systems for $23,680. Motion to place on consent. - Item 6: HVAC Preventative Maintenance and Service – Three-year contract (June 1, 2026 – May 31, 2029) for Jack E. Kirksey Recreation Center and Livonia Senior Wellness Center; award to WJ O’Neill Company for $1,042,644 (sole qualified bidder). Motion to place on consent. - Item 7: Purchase of Site Furnishings for Shelden Park Redevelopment – Bid award to Kerr Office Supply for $49,647.20 (low bid, $40,000 less than previous estimate). Motion to place on consent. Public Comments & Testimony - Chris Lenoir (Beatrice Street) spoke in support of the public safety millage, arguing that competitive compensation is needed to retain police officers, and promoted an IBEW job fair on May 13, 2026. - Katie Rogowicz (Livonia) cited city ordinance 2.04.050 and argued that the council meeting procedures do not require her to address only the chair. She also noted that a police officer is required to attend meetings per ordinance 2.04.110. - Steve King (Coventry Gardens) questioned the city’s projected $2.4 million annual savings from switching retiree health care to Medicare Advantage, calling the claims speculative without actuarial reports. He also mentioned his social media outreach on city issues. - Jim Biga (Livonia) criticized the Master Plan amendment (Book 5), stating it compares Livonia to Detroit, Warren, and Dearborn rather than neighboring suburbs, and that no housing under $400,000 has been approved. He argued that one public hearing in 45 days is insufficient and called for at least three public hearings. - Steve King (on Item 3) advocated for starter homes and changes to zoning to allow lower-cost construction methods, and supported more public dialogue. - Jenaveve Lenoir (Beatrice Street) argued that the Master Plan update is inadequate and that residents did not have sufficient voice in the process, urging the council to go back to the drawing board. - Jerry Karasinski (Bainbridge Avenue) supported having multiple public comment periods for the Master Plan, noting that housing sustainability means different things to different people. - Steve King (on Items 5 and 6) questioned the necessity of a cedar roof (noting maintenance issues) and called the $1 million HVAC maintenance contract "outrageously high," suggesting re-bidding. Discussion Items Item 1: Request to Purchase City-Owned Property (34200 Hathaway Street) – Raiyan Berry requested to purchase a city-owned lot acquired through foreclosure in 2022. Mark Taormina, Planning and Economic Development Director, explained that the property is likely surplus but that a direct sale requires a two-thirds Council vote to waive the public bid process and a finding of compelling reason. He recommended going through public bidding to ensure the city recoups costs (e.g., demolition). Council discussed the process and agreed to waive the planning commission referral, refer to the assessing department and law department, and proceed with a public bid. The item was placed on the Regular agenda for May 4, 2026. Item 3: Master Plan Petition 2026-01-07-01 (Vision 21 Amendment – Book 5: Housing Sustainability) – The Planning Commission requested authorization to distribute proposed amendments for public comment and to hold a public hearing. Mark Taormina and Donovan Smith (McKenna, project manager) explained that the 44-page plan was funded by a $50,000 MSHDA grant and created with a steering committee. They noted that a community survey and open house were held. Councilmembers discussed the process and the desire for further study. Councilmember McCullough moved to refer the matter to the Law and Education Committee for further study, while Councilmember Persiconi moved to place it on the Regular agenda. The Council ultimately placed the item on the Regular agenda, with an understanding that it could also be sent to committee after the public hearing process. Public speakers criticized the plan as incomplete and insufficiently vetted. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved to proceed with a resolution waiving planning commission referral, referring to assessing and law departments, and directing sale through public bidding process. Placed on Regular agenda. - Item 2: Approved to be placed on Consent agenda. - Item 3: Approved to be placed on Regular agenda for the May 4, 2026 regular meeting; further committee review is anticipated. - Items 4, 5, 6, 7: All approved to be placed on Consent agenda. The meeting adjourned at 10:29 p.m.

The Livonia City Council held its 2039th regular meeting on April 20, 2026, at 7:00 PM in City Hall. The meeting included recognitions, consent agenda approvals, numerous public comments, and a major discussion on the proposed new police station, which was ultimately referred to the Committee of the Whole. All votes were unanimous (7-0) unless noted. Consent Calendar The following items were approved unanimously (7-0) as part of the consent agenda, with the exception of Item 8 which was pulled for separate consideration: - Item 1: Waive noise ordinance for St. Mary Antiochian Orthodox Church festival (Aug 14-16, 2026) with conditions including 60 dB limit. - Item 2: Proclamation designating May 2026 as ALS Awareness Month. - Item 3: Waiver petition for Wade Shows carnival (May 18-June 1, 2026) at former Sears lot. - Item 4: Site plan for new gas station/convenience store at 36300 Five Mile Road. - Item 5: Additional benefit (clothing voucher increase from $100 to $125/year) for non-represented employees. - Item 6: Adoption of Wayne County Hazard Mitigation Plan (approved by FEMA Feb 20, 2026). - Item 7: Award of bid for bridge repairs at Idyl Wyld Golf Course ($40,900 to Custom Bridges and Boardwalks). - Item 8: (Pulled – see Discussion Items) Replacement of HVAC/boiler at Sandburg Library. - Item 9: Waive bidding for temperature controls at City Hall Annex ($43,312 to Havel). - Item 10: Award of contract for 2026 Sidewalk & Pavement Replacement Program ($287,458 to Rotondo Construction). - Item 11: Proclamation for April as Autism and Hashimoto's Thyroiditis Awareness Month. Public Comments & Testimony During Audience Communication (7 residents spoke on non-agenda items): - Mathew Wilk (Northville) spoke against the proposed $570 million SMART bus system renewal, citing 3.88 average riders per bus and a $20-72 million pension hole. Urged residents to vote it down. - Rhonda Snyder (Livonia) called for government transparency and trust, stating citizens are "angry and distrust our government." - Betsy Calhoun (Livonia) expressed fear that the public safety millage renewal in August might fail due to resident distrust, citing the failed bond issue last year and the importance of optics. - Steve King (Livonia) warned of economic downturn (tariffs, rising costs) and advised fiscal discipline, saying "you don't spend aggressively when the ground is shifting." - Katy Rogowicz (Livonia) complained about sidewalks, enforcement of ordinances, and criticized the mayor for not attending meetings. Noted she was unblocked from the police Facebook page after contacting the city attorney. - Wayne Snyder (Livonia) urged council to reconsider large expenditures if a majority of citizens oppose them, and argued any tax increase should go to voters. - Christopher Martin (Livonia) criticized library closures over Easter weekend and urged better maintenance. On Item 8 (Sandburg Library HVAC): Eight residents spoke overwhelmingly in favor of proceeding with the boiler replacement, arguing against deferring maintenance and noting the building had recently received a new roof. They emphasized that the funds come from the library millage, not the general fund, and delaying could lead to more costly emergency repairs. On Item 17 (New Police Station): Following the referral to committee, 26 residents spoke on the police station topic after council suspended rules. Key themes: - Strong opposition to building on the proposed wetland site (Five Mile & Farmington area). Many cited cost of engineered fill, flooding risks, and desire to preserve natural areas. - Suggestions to renovate/expand the existing station or build at the corner of Five Mile and Farmington (non-wetland site). - Concerns about the $55 million cost, funding model (1% admin fee), and impact on future millage renewals. - Calls for greater transparency and involvement of residents in the process. Discussion Items Item 8 – Sandburg Library HVAC Replacement: Councilmembers moved to table the item to allow more time to assess long-term plans for the library. After debate (some members argued deferring maintenance leads to larger costs; others wanted to ensure prudent spending), the motion to table was withdrawn and the original motion to approve the bid (Guardian Environmental Services, $121,922) passed 7-0. Item 12 – Capital Grille Liquor License: Unanimous approval (7-0) for both resolution A (Class C/SDM license) and resolution B (waiver of 1,000-foot separation requirement). Petitioner noted it would be their second Michigan location, creating about 150 jobs. Item 13 – Axe Parlor Liquor License: Unanimous approval (7-0) for resolution A (Class C license) and resolution B (waiver of 1,000-foot separation). A third resolution C was added and passed 7-0 to waive the 400-foot separation from a church, as noted by the planning director. Item 14 – Assistant Library Director Classification: Unanimously approved (7-0). The Human Resources Director clarified it is a title change, not a new position, with no increase in headcount or cost. Item 15 – Myrna Avenue Water Main Replacement: Unanimously approved (7-0) contract to Bricco Excavating for $689,000. Item 16 – Easement from Livonia Public Schools: Unanimously approved (7-0) for a water main easement related to the Early Childhood Center. Item 17 – New Police Station (CR 38-26): A motion to send the matter to the Capital Outlay and Infrastructure Committee was initially made but withdrawn after debate. A substitute motion to refer it to the Committee of the Whole (open to all council members and the public) was made and passed unanimously (7-0). Councilmembers emphasized the need for more data, transparency, and public input before any site decision. Subsequently, council voted 7-0 to suspend rules to allow public comment on the item, after which 26 residents spoke. Key Outcomes - Consent Agenda (Items 1-7, 9-11): Approved 7-0. - Item 8 (Sandburg HVAC): Approved 7-0 after motion to table was withdrawn. - Item 12 (Capital Grille): Both resolutions approved 7-0. - Item 13 (Axe Parlor): Resolutions A and B approved 7-0; Resolution C (church separation waiver) added and approved 7-0. - Item 14 (Assistant Library Director): Approved 7-0. - Item 15 (Myrna Avenue Water Main): Approved 7-0. - Item 16 (Easement): Approved 7-0. - Item 17 (Police Station): Referred to Committee of the Whole (7-0). Public comment allowed after rules were suspended. The committee will meet to deliberate site options, financing, and gather more information. - Meeting adjourned at 9:28 PM.

The Livonia City Council held a study meeting on April 8, 2026, at 8:01 PM in City Hall Auditorium to review agenda items for the regular meeting scheduled for April 20, 2026. All seven council members were present, along with city staff. The meeting included audience communication and discussion of 15 agenda items. Public Comments & Testimony - Kathleen McIntyre of Fairway Street discussed the impact of the 2015 FTA Act on cell tower fees and praised TJW Enterprises for managing golf courses effectively. - Steve King of Coventry Gardens criticized the housing commission meetings, claimed agendas were not properly posted, and noted white buckets catching water at municipal buildings. Councilmember Persiconi refuted these claims, stating agendas are posted online and in common rooms, and key fobs are used for security. - During second audience communication, Laura Wojcik of Brookfield shared personal experience with Hashimoto's disease, linking it to fertility struggles. - Jerry Karasinski of Bainbridge Avenue suggested standardizing housing commission website links and supported the assistant library director position. - Denise Mika of Livonia raised concerns about conflict of interest and confusion in paperwork for the library director position. Consent Calendar Items directed to the Consent Agenda of the April 20, 2026 Regular Meeting: - Noise Ordinance Waiver for St. Mary's Festival: Motion by Councilmember Persiconi to approve with conditions limiting live music on Saturday to 11 PM and applying decibel limits similar to the St. Rafka festival. - ALS Awareness Month Proclamation: Motion by Councilmember Budzinski to designate May 2026 as ALS Awareness Month. - Carnival by Wade Shows: Sponsored by the Livonia AM Rotary Club, approved as requested. - Gas Station Redevelopment: Site plan approval for 36300 Five Mile Road, with recommendations to extend brick and remove LED band lighting. - Employee Clothing Benefit: Extension of a $125 clothing allowance to non-represented employees and department heads. - Hazard Mitigation Plan Approval: Resolution to adopt the Wayne County Hazard Mitigation Plan for five years. - Bridge Repairs at Idyl Wyld Golf Course: Award of $40,900 bid for repairing three bridges on holes 11, 15, and 16. - HVAC Replacement at Sandburg Library: Award of $121,922 bid to Guardian Environment. - Temperature Controls at City Hall Annex: Waiver of formal bidding and contract award for $43,312, with 98.4% recoverable through an EECBG grant. - Sidewalk and Pavement Replacement: Award of $284,583.52 contract to Joe Rotundo Construction for water main break repairs. - Proclamation for Autism and Hashimoto's Disease Awareness: Designating April as awareness month; a resident provided extensive testimony about Hashimoto's disease. Discussion Items Items directed to the Regular Agenda for further consideration: - Capital Grille Liquor License Waiver: Mark Taormina explained the need for a waiver due to proximity to another licensed establishment. Council received the update but will discuss further at the regular meeting. - Axe Parlor Liquor License Waiver: The applicant seeks to relocate and requires a waiver for separation requirements from a church and restaurant. Discussion centered on required parking lot repairs and bonding options. Councilmember McCullough expressed support but wanted more information from the building owner. - Assistant Library Director Classification: Jeannine Laible requested renaming the vacant branch librarian position to Assistant Library Director, with no budgetary impact. Several residents expressed confusion, suggesting it might be a new position. Council requested clarification in documentation. - Myrna Avenue Water Main Replacement: City Engineer Todd Zilincik recommended awarding the $689,000 contract to Breco Excavating for replacing 2,800 feet of water main. Councilmember McDonnell requested placement on the Regular Agenda due to the dollar amount. Key Outcomes - All items were directed to either the Consent or Regular Agenda of the April 20, 2026 Regular Meeting. - The meeting adjourned at 9:16 PM. - No formal votes were taken; directions were unanimous on all motions.

The Livonia City Council held its 2038th regular meeting on Wednesday, April 8, 2026, at 7:00 p.m. in the City Hall Auditorium. The meeting was called to order by President Kayleigh Reid. All seven council members were present. The minutes of the March 23, 2026 meeting were approved unanimously. Presentational Items - The council recognized the Livonia United Girls High School Hockey team as state champions. Coach Janine Martinez highlighted the team's accomplishment and her selection as Coach of the Year. - Fire Chief Jennison presented a certificate of commendation to retired Fire Captain Rob Werlinger for his work as department historian. Public Comments & Testimony - Kathleen McIntyre (Fairway Street) spoke in support of renewing the public safety millage, clarifying that millage funds cannot be used for facilities and urged voters to separate the millage from the police station debate. - Paul Condon (Hillbrook Street) expressed support for the millage renewal, emphasizing it is not a new tax and noted his household pays about $128 annually for it. - Steve King (Coventry Gardens) spoke about the death of a senior center employee, read a teacher's complaint about recreation center conditions (including broken equipment and unwelcoming staff), and called for a review of cell tower leases. - John Pastor (Capri Court) defended his company's work on the Rotary Park pavilion (stating his bid was $50,000 lower than others), and expressed support for the police millage and new police station. - Mike Martin (Trillium) praised community patriotism and unity. - Frank McDermott criticized the council's approach after the defeat of a $145 million bond, suggesting individual projects be put to voters. Council & Staff Reports - Councilmembers discussed the upcoming public safety millage renewal (August 2026), with several noting it is a renewal, not a tax increase, and that the general fund already devotes 64% to public safety (police 41%, fire 23%). They expressed strong support for the millage and a separate new police station. - Councilmember Ptashnik clarified the plan to separate public safety from the larger civic center project and proceed with a police station first. - Councilmember McCullough highlighted the Rotary Park pavilion progress and affirmed his support for the millage. - Councilmember McDonnell reminded residents of also-important senior center and green mead millage renewals. - Councilmember Budzinski promoted the Citizens Police Academy and local businesses. Consent Calendar All ten consent agenda items were approved unanimously (7-0): 1. Street barricade for a cross-country meet (Aug. 21-22, 2026). 2. Noise ordinance waiver for a July 4 party. 3. Banner displays for SPREE '76 (May 22 – June 29, 2026). 4. Street closures for SPREE '76 (June 22-29, 2026). 5. Permits for carnival, fireworks (June 28), and facility use. 6. Purchase of one ambulance ($344,420). 7. Purchase of four pickup trucks ($234,340). 8. Cancer screening services for firefighters ($38,940). 9. Golf cart path repairs ($578,170) and budget amendment ($580,000). 10. Seventh amendment to AT&T wireless lease. Discussion Items Item 11 – Rezoning at 13400 Newburgh Road (J&J Land Holdings) – Second reading and adoption; approved 7-0. Item 12 – Waiver Use for Gas Station (J&J Land Holdings) – Approved 7-0 with conditions. Item 13 – Waiver Use for Outdoor Display (Great Lakes Pawn, 27675 Grand River Avenue) – The council discussed conditions and resident concerns about items on sidewalks and overnight storage. The motion to approve failed 1-6 (Councilmember McCullough in favor; others opposed). Key Outcomes - Consent agenda and items 11 and 12 passed unanimously. - Item 13 (outdoor display waiver) was denied. - The meeting was adjourned at 7:50 p.m. - Council members reiterated their support for the August 2026 public safety millage renewal and a new police station.

The Livonia City Council held a study meeting on March 23, 2026, at 8:00 p.m. to set the agenda for the upcoming Regular Meeting on April 8, 2026. All seven council members were present. The meeting addressed multiple requests including street closures, noise ordinance waivers, event permits, a development waiver petition, fire department vehicle and equipment purchases, golf course cart path repairs, and a lease amendment. Most items were directed to the consent calendar for the April 8 Regular Meeting, with one item (the gas station waiver petition) placed on the regular agenda for further discussion. Public Comments - Steve King (audience communication at start): King urged the city to invest in technology, drones, officer training, and strategic staffing rather than a new police headquarters, stating that "$60 million is a once-in-a-generation investment" and that cities getting ahead are "building smarter systems." - Spree ’76 Memorial Suggestion: During discussion of the Spree ’76 items, a resident suggested the Livonia Anniversary Committee honor a child who died in a car accident after the 2025 fireworks display and requested increased police presence at the Stark Road and Merriman intersection. Consent Calendar (All items placed on consent for the April 8, 2026 Regular Meeting) - Street Barricade (Item 1): Chris Inch, Six Mile Track Club Coach, requested barricading Perth Street from Stark Road to the dead-end west of Farmington on August 21-22, 2026 for a nighttime high school cross-country meet. Noted the sixth year of the event with 70 high school teams, 1,500 runners, and 2,500 spectators. - Noise Ordinance Waiver (Item 2): David Groff requested a waiver for a July 4, 2026 party with a band at 18111 and 18133 Floral Street, described as an annual event going into its tenth year. - Banner and Sign Display (Item 3): Sam Caramagno, President, Livonia Anniversary Committee, requested banners on Farmington Road and Five Mile Road and a 4' x 8' sign at City Hall and Ford Field from May 22 to June 29, 2026 for Spree ’76. Caramagno noted a clean audit, added security with metal detectors, new bands, 20 food vendors, a free shuttle, and a planned entrance fee for fireworks on Sunday. - Street Closures (Item 4): Caramagno requested closure of Stark Road from L.A.D. to Lyndon (June 22-29) and, subject to Wayne County Road Commission permission, closure of Farmington Road between I-96 overpass and Five Mile Road on June 28, 2026 from 6:00 p.m. to 11:30 p.m. for Spree ’76 fireworks. - Permits for Amusement Rides, Fireworks, and Facility Use (Item 5): Caramagno requested permits for Wade Shows carnival rides at Ford Field and Veterans’ Park (June 23-28), a fireworks display at 10:15 p.m. on June 28, 2026 at Stymelski Veterans’ Park, and authorization to use/lease Ford Field, Eddie Edgar Arena, and Stymelski Veterans’ Park for Spree ’76. Councilmember Reid, who recused herself as Spree organizer, noted a new five-year contract with Wade Shows and expanded fireworks. - Ambulance Purchase (Item 7): Fire Chief Robert Jennison requested authorization to purchase one 2027 or newer Lifeline Type-1 Superliner Ambulance through a consortium bid to replace a frontline ambulance, with delivery expected in at least two years. - Pickup Truck Purchase (Item 8): Chief Jennison requested authorization to purchase four 2026 Ford F-150 Super Crew 4x4 pickup trucks through state and county consortium bids to replace frontline vehicles (11-17 years old). - Cancer Screening Professional Services (Item 9): Chief Jennison requested authorization to purchase Grail-Galleri cancer screening services (proprietary, not subject to bid) for all firefighters. He reported that 80% of firefighter line-of-duty deaths in 2025 were due to cancer, and the blood test can detect 50 types of cancer, 70% of which are not detectable by other means. Councilmembers discussed decontamination practices and the feasibility of adding drying racks or building additions. - Golf Course Cart Path Repairs (Item 10): Douglas Ware, Golf Course Superintendent, requested authorization of a budget amendment and award of bid (low bid $578,170) for removal and replacement of cart path sections (three holes at each of the three city golf courses), funded through the courses’ enterprise fund (user fees). - AT&T Wireless Lease Amendment (Item 11): Request to approve the Seventh Amendment to lease with New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC (AT&T) to move and upgrade equipment on a tower; described as a housekeeping item. Discussion Items - Waiver Petition (Item 6): Petition 2026-01-02-02 by J&J Land Holdings, LLC, requesting waiver use approval to construct a gas station with convenience store and carryout restaurant at 13400 Newburgh Road (southeast corner of Newburgh and Schoolcraft). Attorney Brandon Grysko stated the developer (Mr. Hamadi, a longtime local business owner) agreed to shift the building to prevent traffic from using the property as a shortcut. Councilmember McCullough supported the development, noting it would clean up a blighted corner with a multi-million dollar local investment. The item was placed on the Regular Agenda (not consent) for further discussion and a vote at the April 8 Regular Meeting. Key Outcomes - Ten of eleven agenda items were directed to the Consent Calendar for the April 8, 2026 Regular Meeting, meaning they are expected to be approved in a single block vote. - The Waiver Petition (Item 6) was placed on the Regular Agenda for the April 8, 2026 Regular Meeting, requiring separate discussion and a vote. - The meeting adjourned at 10:10 p.m.