Public Meetings - Livonia, Michigan

The Livonia City Council held a Study Meeting on Monday, August 17, 2026. Although the agenda listed an 8:00 p.m. start, the meeting was called to order at 10:11 p.m. by President Reid. All seven council members were present. The meeting served to set the agenda for the Regular Voting Meeting on August 31, 2026. Most items were directed to the Consent Calendar, while the Security Camera Bid and the Library Elevator Modernization items were moved to the Regular Agenda. Several residents provided public comments. Public Comments & Testimony - John Schafer requested the council consider a policy requiring gas station remodels to include environmental abatement and pump modernization for public safety. - Steve King criticized the lengthy agenda and city procurement processes, raising concerns that rules were being ignored. He specifically referenced a bathroom project costing over $300,000 and stated no council member asked for the cost breakdown. - Jim Biga discussed the 'Book 5' master plan, stating the promised 45-day public comment period did not occur as expected. He argued the plan should address converting industrial sites to housing and the lack of affordable housing, noting that new construction in Livonia has not been approved under $400,000. He also claimed the plan contained inaccuracies, such as stating the city has 94,000 housing units when it actually has around 37,000. - Jerry Karasinski noted Livonia is the eighth largest city in Michigan with a $76 million general fund budget and 300 employees, and urged the council to follow established rules and processes rather than pushing them aside. - Denise Mika (on Item 5) questioned why the contract for golf course roof replacement professional services was awarded to OHM Advisors over a lower bidder (DAG), asking if the timeline was the deciding factor. - Lamberto Smigliani (Item 1 applicant) requested a sidewalk waiver for a new home at 15505 Auburndale Avenue. - Sarah Mahison (on behalf of property owner) requested approval for sign rebranding at the Amoco station at 29401 Seven Mile Road, but preferred not to modify the existing monument sign structure as requested by the Planning Commission. - Vito Cicinelli (Kimley-Horn & Associates, for Target) confirmed the request was for five wall signs, with one being an existing sign. Discussion Items - Item 4: Security Camera Upgrades. Superintendent Michelle Koppin requested approval of a $72,063.37 bid to ASC Security Systems for 20 new cameras and 14 upgrades or replacements at the Kirksey Recreation Center, Botsford Pool, and Clements Circle Pool. Councilmember McDonnell requested the item be moved to the Regular Agenda to review detailed pricing and ensure all bidders quoted on identical scope. - Item 8: Library Elevator Modernization. Assistant City Engineer Dave Lear requested approval of a $379,655 contract with City Elevator for upgrading the passenger and service elevators at the Robert and Janet Bennett Civic Center Library. The vendor is an approved provider under a State of Michigan contract. Councilmember McDonnell requested the item be moved to the Regular Agenda. - Book 5 Master Plan: Councilmember Budzinski confirmed with Planning Director Mark Taormina that the Planning Commission is considering holding an additional 45-day public comment period and a new public hearing for the 'Book 5' master plan. - Item 1: Sidewalk Waiver. Assistant City Engineer Dave Lear supported the waiver, noting there are no sidewalks on the street. Councilmember McCullough supported the waiver but suggested the council consider developing a long-term citywide walkability plan. - Item 2 & 3: Sign Petitions. Director Taormina explained the rebranding of the Amoco station (Shell to Amoco) and Target store, both located within special area development control districts. - Item 5: Golf Course Roof Replacement. Koppin explained the professional services contract ($23,168.75 to OHM Advisors) was brought to council because combined costs met the approval threshold. Councilmember Budzinski praised the transparent presentation of the item. - Item 6: Middle Belt Road Improvement. Lear requested approval of the intergovernmental agreement with Wayne County. The city's share is 9.075% ($204,387 of the $2.59 million project). The work has already been completed. - Item 7: Storm Water Agreement. Lear presented the formal storm water facilities maintenance agreement for True Community Credit Union. Key Outcomes - Direction for Consent Agenda (August 31, 2026): Items 1 (Sidewalk Waiver), 2 (Amoco Sign), 3 (Target Sign), 5 (Golf Course Roof Professional Services), 6 (Middle Belt Road IGA), and 7 (True Community Credit Union Storm Agreement). - Direction for Regular Agenda (August 31, 2026): Item 4 (Security Camera Bids) and Item 8 (Library Elevator Modernization) were moved to the Regular Agenda for further discussion and voting. - Further Direction on Book 5: An additional 45-day public comment period and rehearing are being considered by the Planning Commission.

The 2,046th Regular Meeting of the Livonia City Council convened on Monday, August 17, 2026, at 7:00 PM at City Hall. All seven council members were present. The meeting featured extensive public comment on fiscal policy, development, and city transparency. Notable actions included the denial of an adult foster care facility after concerns over minimum standards, the approval of a Culver's development, a heated debate over boiler bid procedures leading to a tabling, and moves to improve virtual meeting capabilities and revise council agenda processes. (Note: A discrepancy exists in the source documents concerning the date of the previous meeting's minutes; the agenda and transcript cite July 27, 2026, while the written minutes identify July 13, 2026.) Consent Calendar - The consent agenda, covering a block party (Flamingo Blvd), three sidewalk requirement waivers, and three storm water maintenance agreements, was approved unanimously in a 7-0 vote. - Public Comment: Steve King spoke during the consent agenda, urging the council to decide whether Livonia wants to be a walkable and bikeable community before continually waiving sidewalk requirements. Public Comments & Testimony (Initial 30-minute audience communication period) - Beth Cheola (Doris Street): Requested clearer city ordinances for trash receptacle placement after a dispute with a neighbor led to property damage. She noted receiving conflicting information from the city's ordinance department. - Steve King (Coventry Gardens): Argued the August 4th public safety millage passage was a missed opportunity for fiscal reform, warning that public safety costs consume roughly 70% of the operating budget and that the renewal mortgaged the city's solvency without structural changes. - Jackie Carns (Oakview Street): Promoted the Epilepsy Foundation of Michigan's "Toasting Hope" event on September 18th, citing that 1 in 26 people will be diagnosed with epilepsy in their lifetime. - Debbie McDermott: Described a lack of timely communication from the city regarding a water main break that caused brown water, criticizing a dismissive response from a DPW representative. - Jenaveve Lenoir (Beatrice Street): Criticized the Book 5 Master Plan update process for insufficient community outreach. Also raised concerns regarding the Flock camera contract, specifically the data licensing terms granting the company a non-exclusive, irrevocable, worldwide, royalty-free license to use customer-generated data. Urged attention to the neglected Noble community center. - Frank McDermott (Rayburn Street): Characterized the lifetime ban of Steve King from the Senior Wellness Center and Recreation Center as an excessive punishment for a trespassing fine, arguing for selective enforcement. - Jim Biga (Livonia): Stated that the Book 5 public hearing appeared to be a final reading without the proper public notice and robust comment period council had previously requested. - Greg Ralko (Golfridge Villa): Questioned why the city's law department is defending a ZBA decision against residents in court, urging council to direct the city attorney to stipulate to the residents' relief. - Denise Mika (Livonia): Criticized blurred lines between the legislative and executive branches in the city and a lack of proactive communication from the administration on Book 5 and water quality issues. Discussion Items - Council President Reid's Agenda Reform Proposals: President Reid proposed transferring agenda-setting duties from the Council Office Administrator back to the City Clerk's office for neutrality and backup support, and moving the cutoff for new data to 12:00 p.m. the business day prior. Following debate on separation of powers and functionality, both items were referred to the Committee of the Whole (agenda duties: 6-1; data cutoff: 7-0). - Flock Safety Cameras: Councilmember Budzinski successfully moved to refer the topic of Flock cameras to the Public Safety Committee for a public update and discussion, citing increased public dialogue and privacy concerns. (Vote: 7-0). - Hybrid Meeting Capabilities: Council voted to ask the Law Department to draft an ordinance allowing virtual attendance for audience communication (following the Ann Arbor model). Separately, council authorized the purchase of a tri-caster system via government co-ops at a cost not to exceed $40,000 to facilitate the hybrid format. (Both 7-0). - Capital Planning & Budget Manager (Item 11): Council approved the establishment of a new classification combining two positions to coordinate long-term capital planning and budgeting across all departments. The salary range is equivalent to the Chief Accountant classification ($101,004.80 to $117,936.00). Approved 7-0. - Adult Foster Care Facility Denial (Item 12): Council denied a waiver petition for a 12-bed adult foster care facility at 38525 Eight Mile Road. Concerns included meeting only minimum state staffing requirements (videos over CNAs), small 25-square-foot powder rooms, garbage management without a dumpster, and inadequate accessibility. The motion to deny cited a detrimental effect on neighboring properties. (Vote: 5-2 for denial). - Culver's Drive-Through Approval (Item 13): Council approved a waiver petition for a Culver's and multi-tenant retail building at 29155 Seven Mile Road, subject to 17 conditions including landscaping and seating limits. A separate motion to waive the requirement for two separate driveways was also approved, citing secondary access via an easement. (Both 7-0). - Library Boiler Replacement Dispute (Item 14): A major debate occurred over awarding a $152,596 boiler replacement bid to Guardian Environmental Services. Councilmembers McCullough and McDonnell argued the bid was non-responsive, as the vendor missed a mandatory pre-bid meeting, the bid bond was improperly executed, and the compressed timeline over the July 4th holiday discouraged competition. Despite staff arguing the vendor was qualified and the price was substantially lower (next bid $200k), the council voted to table the item to the August 31st meeting to seek a legal opinion on the bid validity. (Vote to table: 7-0). - Library ADA Restroom Renovations (Item 15): Council awarded a total contract of $333,623 to C&S Construction Management ($304,123) and DLZ Michigan, Inc. ($29,500) for renovating the family and women's atrium restrooms. The funding is from the Neighborhood Revitalization Fund. (Vote: 6-1). - Wildwood Sourfest Noise Waiver (Item 17): Council approved a request from Supernatural Spirits and Brewing to waive the noise ordinance for an event on August 29th with live music until 10:30 p.m. (Vote: 7-0). Key Outcomes - Minutes Approved: Minutes of the previous meeting approved (7-0). [Discrepancy noted in source documents regarding the date of these minutes]. - Consent Agenda: Approved (7-0). - Agenda & Data Cutoff Reform: Referred to Committee of the Whole. - Flock Cameras: Referred to Public Safety Committee (7-0). - Hybrid Meetings: Ordinance drafting referred to Law Dept (7-0). Tri-caster purchase authorized up to $40k (7-0). - Capital Planning Manager: New classification approved (7-0). - Adult Foster Care Facility (Item 12): DENIED (5-2). - Culver's Development (Item 13): APPROVED (7-0). Driveway waiver approved (7-0). - Library Boiler (Item 14): TABLED to August 31, 2026 regular meeting (7-0). - Library ADA Restrooms (Item 15): Contract awarded (6-1). - Wildwood Sourfest Noise Waiver (Item 17): Approved (7-0).

The Livonia City Council held a study meeting on Monday, July 27, 2026, beginning at 8:24 p.m. in City Hall Auditorium. President Reid presided, with Councilmembers Eileen McDonnell, Carrie Budzinski, Robin Persiconi, Martha Ptashnik, and Vice President Brockway present. Councilmember Brandon McCullough was absent. The meeting served to set the agenda for the Regular Meeting on August 17, 2026, where formal votes will take place. Thirteen items were reviewed and assigned to either the Consent or Regular agenda. Several residents spoke during public comment, and council discussed a range of topics including a new staff classification, a group home, a drive‑through restaurant, a library boiler replacement, and ADA restroom renovations. Consent Calendar - Item 1 – Block Party (Karen Werden): Twentieth annual block party on Flamingo Boulevard, August 29, 2026 (rain date August 30). Direction: Consent. - Item 3 – Sidewalk Waiver (TCM Development LLC, 37633 Scone Court): No sidewalks exist on the west side of the street. Direction: Consent. - Item 4 – Sidewalk Waiver (Bilal Saad, 27416 Sunnydale): No sidewalks in the area. Direction: Consent. - Item 5 – Sidewalk Waiver (Joe Eadeh/American Building Co., 18252 Lathers): No sidewalks. Direction: Consent. - Item 10 – Storm Water Facilities Maintenance Agreement (Emerson Oaks‑Livonia LLC): Housekeeping item to close out the storm drain system project. Direction: Consent. - Item 11 – Storm Water Facilities Maintenance Agreement (UAG Realty LLC / Bill Brown Ford): Standard maintenance agreement. Direction: Consent. - Item 12 – Storm Water Facilities Maintenance Agreement (The Cornelia Group LLC / Penske Automotive): Standard maintenance agreement. Direction: Consent. Public Comments & Testimony Opening Audience Communication (before agenda items): - Steve King criticized the city’s tendency to create new management positions instead of demanding accountability; he also argued that the $152,596 boiler bid was excessive and questioned why the project was moving forward without Councilmember McCullough present. - Christopher Martin raised concerns about the Comcast cable franchise agreement and e‑bike/scooter regulations on sidewalks, stating that city policies may conflict with state law. - Frank McDermott urged the council to address the life‑time ban imposed on Steve King by the recreation commission, noting the disparity between a $50 fine from the 16th District Court and the ban. - Greg Ralko disputed earlier statements about zoning votes at Eight Mile and Newburgh, asking who instructed the legal department to defend the city against citizen appeals related to the proposed gas station. - John Pastor expressed support for the police and fire millage but opposed the SMART bus millage, arguing SMART has not managed its finances well. - Laura Shoemaker defended citizens’ right to speak and asked who directed the legal department’s response to appeals; she warned that lack of transparency could affect her future votes. - Barbara Glover argued that Steve King, who had charges dropped, should be allowed back into city facilities, and noted the lack of ADA‑accessible bathrooms in City Hall. Comments on Specific Agenda Items: - Item 6 – New Classification (Capital Planning and Budget Manager): Steve King opposed the position, stating it adds another layer of government without accountability. Denise Mika asked that the item be studied further (tabled or committee of the whole). - Item 7 – Adult Foster Care Facility (38525 Eight Mile Road): Jim Biga urged careful review of room sizes and shower facilities; Denise Mika noted that nearby residents had not received proper notice and requested the item be placed on the Regular agenda for full public input. - Item 9 – Boiler Replacement (Bennett Civic Center Library): Steve King criticized the cost and the decision to rebid, stating the price increased $37,929. Barbara Glover expressed support for the boiler replacement to keep the library operational. Discussion Items - Item 6 – Request to Establish New Classification (Capital Planning and Budget Manager): Human Resources Director Jeannine Laible and Finance Director Benjamin Greer explained that the position consolidates two existing roles (budget manager and capital planning manager) to improve efficiency and align capital planning with city goals. Councilmember Budzinski asked about the mayor’s asset management committee; the administration will provide an update. The council directed the item to the Regular agenda with a possible committee‑of‑the‑whole discussion. - Item 7 – Waiver Petition for Adult Foster Care Facility (J.B. Donaldson Company): Planning & Economic Development Director Mark Taormina presented the request to convert a historic home into a medium‑sized group home (capacity 7–12). The property has been used for non‑residential purposes for 35 years. Under state law, homes with 6 or fewer residents are permitted by right; this petition is required for 7–12 residents. Planning Commission recommended approval. The applicant Simona Surgeo, a nurse practitioner, described staffing plans (24‑hour caregivers) and state training requirements. Councilmembers asked about fencing, lighting, trash, medication storage, and the front porch for resident use. The council agreed to place the item on the Regular agenda to allow time for review of updated plans and further public comment. - Item 8 – Waiver Petition for Culver’s Drive‑Through and Retail Building (29155 Seven Mile Road): Mark Taormina detailed plans for a 4,400‑sq‑ft Culver’s with double drive‑through and a separate 4,675‑sq‑ft multi‑tenant retail building on the former VFW site. The retail building design will be reviewed separately. Applicant Brent Bridgewater noted an updated plan improving pedestrian access from Seven Mile Road. Councilmembers requested additional landscaping on the rear parking lot (parcel three) and consideration of bike racks. The item was directed to the Regular agenda for final review. - Item 9 – Award of Bid for Boiler Replacement at Bennett Civic Center Library: Interim DPW Director Doug Moore reported that Guardian Environmental was the low bidder at $152,596—$37,929 more than the extension price quoted in April. Rebidding occurred at council’s request. The next lowest bid was nearly $200,000. Councilmember Ptashnik expressed frustration over the cost increase; Councilmember Budzinski noted the price was still significantly below the other bids. Councilmember McDonnell pointed out that the bid bond lacked a proper signature and witnessing, requiring verification. The item was placed on the Regular agenda to address the bond issue. - Item 13 – Award of Contract for ADA Restroom Renovations at Bennett Civic Center Library: Assistant City Engineer Dave Lear explained that after receiving unexpectedly low bids on the family‑style ADA bathroom, the city added a women’s ADA bathroom to the project. CNS Construction Management was the low bidder at $304,123, plus $29,500 for architectural oversight from DLZ, totaling $333,623. The men’s bathroom cannot be added due to structural limitations. Councilmember Budzinski asked whether an adult‑sized changing table would be included; the library director will clarify. The item was directed to the Regular agenda. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Block Party, Werden): Assigned to Consent. - Item 2 (Block Party, Shatter): Assigned to Regular (applicant not present; staff will contact them). - Item 3 (Sidewalk Waiver, TCM Development): Assigned to Consent. - Item 4 (Sidewalk Waiver, Bilal Saad): Assigned to Consent. - Item 5 (Sidewalk Waiver, American Building Co.): Assigned to Consent. - Item 6 (New Classification – Capital Planning & Budget Manager): Assigned to Regular; may be referred to Committee of the Whole. - Item 7 (Adult Foster Care Waiver): Assigned to Regular for further review of updated plans and neighbor notification. - Item 8 (Culver’s Drive‑Through & Retail): Assigned to Regular to allow council to review updated pedestrian access and landscaping plans. - Item 9 (Boiler Replacement – Guardian Environmental): Assigned to Regular; bid bond irregularity to be resolved. - Item 10 (Emerson Oaks Storm Water Agreement): Assigned to Consent. - Item 11 (UAG Realty Storm Water Agreement): Assigned to Consent. - Item 12 (Cornelia Group Storm Water Agreement): Assigned to Consent. - Item 13 (ADA Restroom Renovations): Assigned to Regular; staff to clarify changing table specifications. The meeting adjourned at 10:02 p.m. All items will be voted on at the Regular Meeting on Monday, August 17, 2026.

The 2045th regular meeting of the Livonia City Council was called to order at 7:00 p.m. on July 27, 2026, at City Hall Auditorium, 33000 Civic Center Drive. Six council members were present (McDonnell, Budzinski, Persiconi, Ptashnik, Brockway, Reid); Brandon McCullough was absent. The meeting included audience communications on multiple topics, unanimous approval of a consent agenda, several individual items, and a second reading of an ordinance amendment, followed by a resolution extending a payment-in-lieu-of-taxes (PILOT) agreement for a senior housing project. Consent Calendar - Approved minutes of the July 13, 2026 regular meeting (Resolution 263-26). - Approved block party requests for: Stacy Robeniol (Aug 1, rain date Aug 8), Erin Dobbins and Jerome Pfeifer (Aug 29), Tracy Nolte (Aug 29), and Michael Camilleri (Sep 19, rain date Sep 26). - Authorized purchase of four Whelen emergency warning packages from Priority One Emergency for $45,999.16 (Resolution 269-26). - Referred to the Law Department to prepare an ordinance amendment to Chapter 8.16 (Restaurants) (Resolution 270-26). - Approved waiver petition 2026-05-02-14 for Oval Auto to operate an automobile repair facility at 28755 Plymouth Road, subject to 15 conditions (Resolution 271-26). - Authorized execution of the SMART Municipal and Community Credit contract for the Liv&Go transit program in the amount of $89,424.00 (Resolution 272-26). - Approved the 2026-2030 Consolidated Plan and 2026-2027 CDBG Annual Plan and Budget (Resolution 273-26). - Authorized hold harmless contracts with First Step, Fair Housing Center of Metropolitan Detroit, Wayne Metropolitan Community Action Agency, Cruz Clinic, Stonebrook Counseling Associates, PLCC, and CARES in Farmington Hills for CDBG-funded programs (Resolution 274-26). - Approved a 10-year Cable Franchise Agreement with Comcast, including a 5% franchise fee and 1% PEG fee (Resolution 275-26). - All consent agenda items were adopted unanimously (6-0). Public Comments & Testimony First Session (pre-agenda): - Dave St. Clair (Fairfield) urged the city to address the deer population, citing DNR data on vehicle accidents (58,000 accidents, 1,700 injuries, 19 deaths in 2023) and calling for a cull with meat donated to food banks. - Barbara Glover expressed that many residents enjoy the deer and opposed a massive cull, advocating coexistence. - Kim Snyder clarified information about the SMART millage, noting there are more than two routes and paratransit options. - Frank McDermott (Rayburn Street) spoke on behalf of Steve King, who was banned for life from the senior wellness center and recreation center after a trespassing incident. McDermott argued the punishment was disproportionate and politically motivated, calling for the ban to be lifted. - Steve King (the aforementioned) alleged that a $600,000 community engagement grant from COVID relief funds was used for a banquet rather than eligible uses such as vaccination drives or rent relief, requesting a full accounting of how the entire grant was spent. - Christopher Martin discussed ballot procedures for the upcoming election and advocated for deer population control, noting bow hunting was previously allowed.<br- Sonia Tacoma (near Rotary Park) reported seeing a herd of 17 deer at once and expressed safety concerns for children, supporting population control. - Greg Ralko (Golf Ridge Villa) recounted a deer-vehicle collision causing $2,500 in damage and questioned why the city defended appeals against the denial of a Sheetz gas station at Lyndon/Newburgh, asking who instructed the Law Department to defend. - Roseanne Martell (Cranston) reported an incident on July 25 where youths on motorized bicycles rode on sidewalks at a rally, raising safety concerns and asking for ordinance enforcement. - Laura Shoemaker (Golf Ridge Villa) supported the police/fire millage renewal and requested answers about who is behind the city's defense of the Sheetz appeal, suggesting a FOIA request if necessary. Second Session (post-agenda): - Cindy Fleming thanked former Parks Director Ted Davis for ensuring all restrooms at Rotary Park include adult changing tables and are ADA accessible; she also urged council to review federal grant tracking after the audit finding. - Denise Maika recalled a previous misappropriation of funds for the senior center development and requested that the city better communicate emergency resources (e.g., masks during poor air quality) and extend senior center hours. - Laura Jannika (Munger Street) asked for details on Sheldon Park plantings and expressed concern about the city planting non-native ginkgo trees in monocultures.<br- John Schafer (Brookwood) raised public safety concerns about generators for traffic lights during power outages and questioned why the recreation center—the city's emergency shelter—closes when the power goes out if it lacks a backup generator. Parks Superintendent Michelle Coppin responded that the recreation center does have a backup generator that activates within 10 seconds. Discussion Items - Trash Can Placement Ordinance Referral (Council Announcements): Councilmember McDonnell requested referral to the Law and Education Committee to review restrictions on trash bin placement near neighboring properties. The motion passed unanimously. - Update on Deer Cull: Councilmembers Ptashnik and Budzinski reported that the city is part of a coalition with Farmington Hills and Southfield, awaiting DNR and USDA availability; a three-year plan is being developed. Director of Government Affairs Erica Smith confirmed that a single cull is insufficient and a multi-year USDA contractor would be shared among communities. - Update on E-bikes/Ordinance: The Law and Education Committee is working on an ordinance regarding e-bikes, e-scooters, and golf carts. - Sheetz Rezoning Clarification: Councilmember Ptashnik corrected that the rezone was denied 5-2 (not the site plan), and C1/C2 zoning already permits gas stations. - Second Reading of Ordinance Amendment (Item 12): Council gave a second reading and adopted an ordinance amending Chapter 3.12 (Senior Citizens Housing Tax Exemption) to allow extended PILOT agreements. Unanimous (6-0). - PILOT Resolution for Ziegler Place Apartments (follow-up to Item 12): The council approved a resolution extending the PILOT for Ziegler Place, a 141-unit senior affordable housing project at 30001 St. Martins Street, at 10% of annual shelter rent for up to 50 years. Unanimous (6-0). The developer, Jonathan Rose Companies, represented by Steve Rypma, requested approval to meet a mid-August financing deadline. - NeoGov Sole Source Contract (Item 13): Council approved a $21,634.07 expenditure for recruitment and applicant tracking services from NeoGov, including a 10% renewal discount and a 16% discount on job listings. Unanimous (6-0). - Locker Room Re-grouting Bid (Item 14): Council accepted a $34,500 bid from Keystone Strategic Partners for locker room re-grouting at the Jack E. Kirksey Recreation Center. Unanimous (6-0).<br- Luxe Events Banquet Facility Waiver (Item 15): Council approved a waiver use for a banquet facility with occupancy over 50 at 27600 Schoolcraft Road, subject to conditions including a 11 p.m. (Sun-Thu) / 12 a.m. (Fri-Sat) curfew and parking lot security. Unanimous (6-0). - Block Party (Item 11): Approved Christina Zeoli's luau-themed block party on Summers Street for August 22, 2026. Unanimous (6-0). Key Outcomes - Minutes approved (6-0). - Consent Agenda (Items 1-10) approved (6-0). - Block Party (Item 11) approved (6-0). - Ordinance Amendment to Chapter 3.12 (Item 12) adopted (6-0). - PILOT Resolution for Ziegler Place Apartments approved (6-0).<br- NeoGov contract (Item 13) approved (6-0). - Locker room re-grouting bid (Item 14) approved (6-0). - Luxe Events waiver (Item 15) approved (6-0).<br- Referral of trash bin placement to Law and Education Committee approved (6-0).<br- Meeting adjourned at 8:07 p.m.

This study meeting of the Livonia City Council was held on Monday, July 13, 2026, beginning at 8:45 p.m. in the City Hall Auditorium. The meeting set the agenda for the regular voting meeting scheduled for July 27, 2026. All 14 items on the agenda were discussed and assigned to either the consent or regular agenda for that upcoming voting meeting. The meeting adjourned at 9:51 p.m. Consent Calendar - Block Party (Item 1): Stacy Robeniol's block party on Shadyside Street on August 1, 2026 (rain date August 8) was placed on the consent agenda. - Block Party (Item 3): Erin Dobbins and Jerome Pfeifer's block party in SMB Estates on August 29, 2026 was placed on the consent agenda. - Block Party (Item 4): Tracy Nolte's block party on Marie Street and Court on August 29, 2026 was placed on the consent agenda. - Block Party (Item 5): Michael Camilleri's block party on Parklane Street on September 19, 2026 (rain date September 26) was placed on the consent agenda. - Fire & Rescue Warning Equipment (Item 6): Authorization to purchase four emergency warning packages from Priority One Emergency (lowest of four bids) was placed on the consent agenda. - Ordinance Amendment – Restaurant Licenses (Item 9): City Clerk Lori Miller's proposal to amend Chapter 8.16 to eliminate the uniform November 30 expiration date for restaurant licenses, instead renewing one year from issuance, was placed on the consent agenda. This change aims to reduce administrative bottlenecks. - Planning Commission Waiver – Oval Auto (Item 11): Waiver use approval to operate an auto repair facility at 28755 Plymouth Road (expanding an existing business) was placed on the consent agenda. The resolution includes a provision that the owner must return to council before selling the business. - SMART Agreement (Item 12): Approval to execute the 2027 agreement with SMART for Liv&Go transit program credits of $89,424 was placed on the consent agenda. The credit is contingent on the August SMART millage passing. - CDBG Consolidated Plan and Contracts (Item 13): Approval of the 2026-2030 consolidated plan, 2026-2027 annual budget ($359,489 in entitlement funds plus $650,000 estimated program income), and hold harmless contracts with six agencies for domestic violence assistance, fair housing, mental health counseling, utility/food assistance, and senior transportation was placed on the consent agenda. Notable allocations include $150,000 for Hillcrest Park improvements and $450,000 for accessible bathrooms at the Civic Center Library. - Comcast Franchise Agreement (Item 14): Renewal of a 10-year cable franchise agreement with Comcast, establishing franchise fees and PEG channel support, was placed on the consent agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - Jerry Karasinski expressed concern about the timing of the locker room re-grouting project (Item 8), noting the rec center was recently closed for other improvements and questioning why this work wasn't included then. He also criticized the lack of a family locker room in the scope. - Laura Jannika urged the council to be more careful about placing items on the consent agenda, referencing past approval of Flock cameras without sufficient debate. - Jim Biga questioned how the NeoGov talent acquisition system (Item 7) would make hiring more transparent and efficient, comparing it to federal systems. - Denise Mika spoke on multiple items: she noted the locker room re-grouting bid did not include family locker rooms; she raised concerns about alcohol and insurance at the Luxe Events facility if renters do not use the owner's packages; she expressed disappointment that council members sometimes fail to answer direct questions from the public; and she questioned the lack of an environmental study before tree removal at Golden Oaks. - Elijah (first-time attendee, Metro Detroit DSA member) spoke against Flock and AI surveillance systems, arguing they are dangerous and unsecure, and asked for further discussion. - Lynn Mills echoed concerns about retribution against citizens who speak, defending free speech and criticizing mockery of residents. - Frank McDermott recounted the case of Steve King being banned for life from the Senior Wellness Center and Recreation Center after a trespassing charge (fined $50 by the court), calling the ban politically motivated retaliation related to King's opposition to a $145 million bond, and urged the council to lift the ban. Discussion Items - Block Party (Item 2): Christina Zeoli's block party on Summers Street on August 22, 2026 was placed on the regular agenda for further discussion. - Civil Service – NeoGov (Item 7): Human Resources Director Jeannine Laible explained NeoGov is the sole source provider that ensures a blind, fair, and equitable civil service hiring process. Councilmember McDonnell asked about potential discounts through Sourcewell; Laible reported NeoGov offers no discounts. The item was placed on the regular agenda. - Parks and Rec – Locker Room Re-grouting (Item 8): Superintendent Michelle Koppin reported one bid was received for the locker room re-grouting at Jack E. Kirksey Recreation Center. Councilmember Budzinski initially offered consent, but Councilmember Ptashnik requested moving to regular to allow Koppin to confirm the scope (only men's and women's locker rooms, not family). The item was placed on the regular agenda. - Planning Commission Waiver – Luxe Events (Item 10): Petitioner Tiffany Munson proposed a banquet/event facility for up to 150 people at 27600 Schoolcraft Road. The facility would not serve food or alcohol, but licensed mixologists would be allowed through a bartending school partnership. Hours were discussed: originally proposed to midnight, but council indicated consistency with previous approvals would require events to end by 11:00 p.m. (weekdays) with an hour for cleanup. Council suggested the petitioner introduce herself to neighbors. The item was placed on the regular agenda. - Audience Communication (General): Multiple speakers raised concerns about the lack of responsiveness from city officials, retribution against residents, and the need for transparency. Councilmembers did not directly respond to most points. Key Outcomes - All 14 items were assigned to either the consent or regular agenda for the July 27, 2026 regular voting meeting. - Consent Agenda Items (expected to pass as a block on July 27): Items 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14. - Regular Agenda Items (will receive separate discussion and votes on July 27): Items 2, 7, 8, 10. - Requests for further clarity: - The scope of the locker room re-grouting (Item 8) will be confirmed as men's and women's only. - The hours of operation for Luxe Events (Item 10) will be aligned with previous council practice (11 p.m. event end on weekdays, cleanup until midnight). - The petitioner for Luxe Events was encouraged to contact neighboring residents. - Councilmember Budzinski announced a new grant: The Trinity Healthy Livonia grant awarded to the Livonia Housing Commission to fund a social worker at MAC Towers, Silver Village, and Newburgh Village to support seniors after hospital discharge.

The Livonia City Council held its 2,044th Regular Meeting on July 13, 2026, at 7:00 p.m. in the City Hall Auditorium, 33000 Civic Center Drive, Livonia, Michigan. All seven councilmembers were present: Brandon McCullough, Eileen McDonnell, Carrie Budzinski, Robin Persiconi, Martha Ptashnik, Patrick Brockway, and Kayleigh Reid. The meeting opened with the Pledge of Allegiance and a life-and-legacy tribute to Kate Cheshoffsky, a Livonia resident, mother, nurse, lawyer, and president of the Livonia Democratic Club, followed by a moment of silence. The Council unanimously approved the June 15, 2026 meeting minutes, passed the consent agenda 7-0, heard public comment, received the annual audit report, and acted on resolutions before adjourning at 8:30 p.m. Consent Calendar - June 15, 2026 Regular Meeting minutes approved 7-0 (Resolution 244-26). - Departmental Purchases Report for the month ending May 31, 2026, received and filed. - Block party approvals, subject to Police Department approval: - Alex Quint: Fairfield Street between 9912 and 10000, August 15, 2026, 3:00-10:00 p.m.; rain date August 22, 2026. - Erin King: Hampshire Road between 33204 Hampshire Road and 16126 Woodring Court, August 22, 2026, 3:00-10:00 p.m. - Jasmine Wieczorek: Rayburn Street between Williams Street and Levan Road, August 22, 2026, 12:00-10:00 p.m.; rain date September 5, 2026. - Awarded Fire Department uniform supply bid to Allie Bros. Uniforms, Inc., not to exceed $163,517.06, for three years from July 14, 2026 through July 13, 2029, with a potential two-year extension. - Awarded Rotary Park outdoor fitness area bid to Snider Recreation for $150,000, covering a 3,300-square-foot area with 14 units serving up to 38 people, funded through a Wayne County Park Grant. - Authorized purchase of two 2027 Freightliner dump trucks and upfitting through the Rochester Hills Cooperative Award Agreement, total not to exceed $617,158.72, including an 8% contingency. - Authorized purchase of one 2027 Freightliner tandem-axle dump truck and upfitting through the Rochester Hills Cooperative Award Agreement, total not to exceed $326,787.52, including an 8% contingency. - Awarded Idyl Wyld Golf Course mini-split AC replacement to Guardian Environmental Services for $23,220. - Appointed Michael A. Testa to the Zoning Board of Appeals. The agenda described the appointment as filling an unexpired term ending July 12, 2028; the minutes state a three-year term expiring July 12, 2029. - The entire consent agenda passed 7-0. Public Comments & Testimony During the first audience period, residents and stakeholders raised the following: - Kim Snyder described difficulty using current transit to attend the meeting, noting the last ride left at 6:00 p.m. for a 7:00 p.m. meeting, and called for expanded transportation options. - Harmony Lloyd, Deputy General Manager and COO of SMART, said she was not there to tell anyone how to vote on the August 4 millage. She said passage would expand fixed-route bus service along Seven Mile, Plymouth, Haggerty, and Middlebelt; add SMART Connector curb-to-curb service for seniors and people with disabilities; and increase support for Livonia's Live & Go service. She noted SMART currently provides eight buses costing about $1.5 million and said new scheduling software could save the city about $100,000 per year. She warned that if the SMART millage fails, SMART would no longer operate transit service in Wayne County, ending Live & Go support. - Joe Gilligan, a Livonia Arts Commissioner, paid tribute to Kate Cheshoffsky and promoted an upcoming Music for the Heart series at a Livonia veterans park. - Bob Hauser, a Wild Ones representative, gave an update on native-plant activities, including an August 16 yard tour and sustainability programs being presented to the Greenleaf Commission. - Samantha Lewis described a negative experience filing a sexual harassment police report at her business, saying she faced skepticism and discouragement and that the department does not treat everyone who seeks help equally. - Alyssa raised concerns about the Fire and Police millage and Flock license-plate reader cameras, citing ACLU statistics that less than 1 percent of scanned cars are connected to crime and that 1 in 10 license plates are misread. She asked the city to release the contract and said she opposes what she called the surveillance state. President Reid responded that the Flock camera contract was in the September 26, 2025 study-session packet and was voted on October 6, 2025. - Frank McDermott criticized the lifetime ban of Steve King from the Senior Wellness and Recreation Center, saying the breaking-and-entering charge was dismissed, King pleaded no contest to trespassing and received a $50 fine, and no violence, threats, or property damage occurred. He said King had helped defeat a $145 million bond proposal that 67 percent of voters rejected. - Robert Hencsh asked how the city would inform the public about election monitors, election recourse, and jurisdiction if monitors were sent to polling places. - Denise Mika asked for clearer ordinance wording before approvals, better online access to housing commission information, and a fee for non-resident senior center users. - Laura Jannika requested a Zoom component for the upcoming Committee of the Whole meeting and urged council members to research how other cities handle remote participation. - Lynn Mills raised tree-removal and grubbing issues at the Newburgh Road site planned for future affordable senior housing. During the second audience period: - Debbie McDermott questioned the hold on the permanent concrete ramp, stating that $20,000 had been spent on a temporary ramp, the permanent ramp was estimated at $6,000-$8,000, and it was previously expected to be completed before the August 2026 voting. - Jerry Karasinski asked to comment on the Finance and Budget Committee's annual audit report. - Jim Biga said the city paid $50,000 for stump removal at the Newburgh/Plymouth site but the work was not completed, calling it malfeasance. He said he opposed the bus millage because he doubted the proposed routes would meet Livonia's needs, objected to taxpayer-funded transit authority advertising, and argued that Live & Go should operate during all city operating hours and should not be run by the housing commission. Discussion Items - Annual Audit Report: Councilmember Ptashnik, chair of the Finance and Budget Committee, reported on the June 8, 2026 committee meeting covering the annual audit for the period December 1, 2024 through November 30, 2025, presented by Plante & Moran. The audit received an unmodified, or clean, opinion. There were no significant misstatements and no internal-control findings. The general fund added $2.1 million to its fund balance, ending at $20.2 million, equal to 28 percent of current-year expenditures, or about 3.3 months of expenses. Total general fund revenue was $75 million, up 5 percent, with property taxes accounting for 56 percent of revenue and increasing 6 percent. Expenditures were up about $2 million, or about 2 percent. The general fund finished $3.2 million better than the amended budget, largely because police department vacancies left budgeted positions unfilled. The cable television fund balance had declined from more than $860,000 to $70,000, and the adjudicated forfeiture fund held about $3.2 million. A federal cash-management policy was missing during the audit period but has since been drafted. Auditors also recommended continued focus on cybersecurity and monitoring state road funding changes. The audit reports were received and placed on file. - Transfer of massage establishment waiver (Item 12): Haiyan Pi, owner of Ocean Wellness & Massage, requested transfer of the existing waiver use approval to Xing Yu Chen for 16345 Middlebelt. Councilmember Persiconi initially moved to approve, but after questioning, Chen confirmed a Washington State Department of Health sanction and 24-month probation in July 2022 related to a massage business. Persiconi withdrew her motion, and the Council voted 7-0 to deny the transfer. - Senior Citizens Housing Tax Exemption ordinance: Councilmember Budzinski gave a first reading to a proposed amendment to Chapter 3.12 of the Livonia Code of Ordinances. No adoption vote was taken. - Vacation ordinance (Petition 2026-03-03-01): The Council took from the table and gave second reading and adoption to an ordinance vacating portions of street, alley, and public ground requested by Seven Mile/Farmington Venture LP for 33500 Seven Mile Road. It passed 7-0. - Removed item: Agenda item 14, the request to waive bidding and award the boiler system replacement at the Robert and Janet Bennett Civic Center Library, was removed from the agenda. Key Outcomes - Approved the consent agenda (items 1-9) 7-0, including block parties, bid awards, cooperative purchases, and the ZBA appointment. - Adopted Resolution 245-26 referring the operation of the City Council Office and the production of agenda items to the Law and Education Committee. The transcript roll call shows a 5-2 vote: Ayes McCullough, McDonnell, Budzinski, Ptashnik, Brockway; Nays Persiconi and Reid. - Adopted Resolution 246-26 directing the administration to provide a report on all city facility rental fees waived, reduced, or forgiven during the past two years. Passed 7-0. - Adopted Resolution 247-26 directing the Law Department to provide a status update on all outstanding resolutions and when they will be addressed. Passed 7-0. - Approved Allison Adams' Flamingo Boulevard block party (Item 11) 7-0. - Denied the massage establishment waiver transfer (Item 12) 7-0. - Adopted the Seven Mile/Farmington vacation ordinance 7-0. - Accepted three storm sewer easements without monetary consideration, each 7-0: two from A&R Packing Co., Inc., and one from TechnoSports, LLC, all in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 28. - Approved 7-0 a closed Committee of the Whole meeting to discuss pending litigation and attorney-client privileged communications in Shaun Day v City of Livonia, Wayne County Circuit Court Case No. 25-010729-NI, by the required two-thirds roll call vote under the Open Meetings Act. - The meeting adjourned at 8:30 p.m., with a study session scheduled to follow at 8:45 p.m. Discrepancy Notes - For Resolution 245-26, the minutes list Councilmember Persiconi in both the Ayes and Nays columns; the transcript shows Persiconi and Reid voting no, making the vote 5-2. - The agenda described Michael A. Testa's Zoning Board of Appeals appointment as filling an unexpired term ending July 12, 2028, while the minutes state the appointment is for a three-year term expiring July 12, 2029.

The Livonia City Council held a study meeting on June 15, 2026, to set the agenda for the July 13, 2026 regular meeting. The meeting began at 8:20 p.m. and adjourned at 9:26 p.m. Council President Reid presided, with all members present except Martha Ptashnik. Public Comments & Testimony - Steve King (Coventry Gardens) requested the council investigate and lift a lifetime ban imposed on him from the recreation center and senior center, arguing the ban was retaliation for his outspoken criticism of the administration. He stated trespassing charges were dismissed and no other individuals were reprimanded for the same incident. - Christopher Martin spoke in favor of free speech, referencing a previous incident where a council member wanted him to stand for prayer. He opposed mandatory participation in patriotic rituals. - Greg Ralko (Golf Ridge Villa) urged the council to adopt an ordinance limiting new gas stations and car washes, citing examples from Farmington Hills and Warren. He criticized the council for acting too late. - John Pastor (Capri Court) argued against further restrictions on businesses, supporting the council's case-by-case approach. He also commented on Steve King's trespassing incident, stating King should face consequences, and urged a yes vote on the police and fire millage and a no vote on SMART. Discussion Items - Block Parties: Four block party requests were discussed. Allison Adams (Flamingo Blvd) directed to regular agenda because petitioner not present. Alex Quint (Fairfield St), Erin King (Hampshire Rd), and Jasmine Wieczorek (Rayburn St) directed to consent agenda after brief presentations. - Massage Establishment Waiver Transfer (Item 5): Haiyan Pi and Doug Rands (Ocean Wellness) requested extension of waiver use approval to new buyer Shin Yu. Council requested documentation of Shin Yu's massage license and credentials. Item directed to regular agenda for further review. - Ziegler Place Senior Apartments (Item 6): Scott Frye (Jonathan Rose Companies) presented a $8.8 million comprehensive rehabilitation plan for the 153-unit senior housing complex, including a request to extend the PILOT (payment-in-lieu-of-taxes) and amend Chapter 3.12. Council supported the project but requested more financial details. Item directed to regular agenda for first reading of ordinance and subsequent approval of PILOT extension. - Fire Department Uniforms (Item 7): John McKee requested award of bid to Ali Brothers Uniforms (lowest bidder). Directed to consent. - Rotary Park Fitness Area (Item 8): Michelle Koppin requested award to Snyder Recreation for outdoor fitness cluster replacement using Wayne County Park Millage funds. Directed to consent. - Dump Trucks (Items 9 and 10): Doug Moore requested waiver of formal bidding to purchase three 2027 Freightliner dump trucks via Rochester Hills cooperative agreement. Total cost for two trucks (Item 9) $618,158.72; one truck (Item 10) $326,787.52. Public comment criticized lack of due diligence and questioned necessity. Councilmember McCullough defended the cooperative agreement process. Items directed to consent. - Library Boiler (Item 11): Moore requested waiver of bidding to replace boiler at Bennett Library using pricing from Sandberg Library bid. Council divided: McCullough and McDonnell opposed waiver, Budzinski supported. Item directed to regular agenda with both approving and denying motions. - Idyl Wyld Golf Course AC (Item 12): Moore requested award of bid to Guardian Environment for $23,770 to replace failed mini-split system. Directed to consent. - Zoning Board of Appeals Appointment (Item 13): Councilmember McCullough initially nominated John Grzebik, who withdrew. McCullough then nominated Mike Testa, who was previously on the ZBA and received praise. Directed to consent. Consent Calendar Items approved for consent agenda (to be voted on as a block at July 13 regular meeting): - Block parties: Alex Quint, Erin King, Jasmine Wieczorek. - Fire Department uniforms bid award. - Rotary Park fitness area bid award. - Two dump trucks purchases (Items 9 and 10). - Idyl Wyld Golf Course AC replacement. - Appointment of Mike Testa to Zoning Board of Appeals. Key Outcomes - All items were directed to either consent or regular agenda for the July 13, 2026 regular meeting. No final votes were taken at this study meeting. - Item 5 (massage waiver transfer) and Item 6 (Ziegler Place) will be on the regular agenda for further discussion and vote. - Item 11 (library boiler) will be on the regular agenda with both a motion to approve (Budzinski) and a motion to deny (McCullough). - Councilmember Persiconi noted she would follow up on the Housing Commission website error. - Councilmember McDonnell reminded all city authorities to follow purchasing laws.

The Livonia City Council held its 2043rd regular meeting on June 15, 2026, at 7:00 PM in City Hall Auditorium. Council President Kayleigh Reid presided. Six council members were present (Patrick Brockway, Brandon McCullough, Eileen McDonnell, Carrie Budzinski, Robin Persiconi, and Kayleigh Reid) with Councilmember Martha Ptashnik absent. The meeting began with approval of the minutes from the June 1, 2026 regular meeting (Resolution 225-26, 6-0). The agenda included consent items, committee reports, unfinished business, and new business. Audience communication addressed topics including utility permits, a police millage event, flags on private property, and city finances. The meeting adjourned at 8:08 PM. Public Comments & Testimony Residents spoke during two audience communication periods. Key comments included: - May Saba (resident): Complained about Easy Fiber digging in the right-of-way without proper notification. She expressed opposition to the company's practices. City Engineer Todd Zilincik explained that permit requirements include pamphlet distribution and suggested contacting the Michigan Public Service Commission for complaints. Saba planned to follow up. - Mila Pershyna (president, AMP Global Foundation): Described a community fundraiser, "Punch for a Purpose," on July 11, 2026, to support James Gray, owner of Impact Mansion Jiu-Jitsu, who is facing medical and financial challenges. She requested city assistance in promoting the event and finding sponsors. - Steve King (resident): Criticized the administration's use of a community engagement grant to fund an invitation-only dinner on June 16, 2026, at St. Mary's, promoted by the mayor and police chief ahead of the August 4 public safety millage vote. He argued this is a "tax-funded echo chamber" that violates transparency and should be debated openly. He noted his reel on the topic had over 54,000 views. - Robert Malkowski (resident): Objected to a controversial flag flown on Middle Belt Road, visible to children. City Attorney Eric Goldstein later explained the flag is on private property and content-based regulation is prohibited by the First Amendment. - Christopher Martin (resident): Stated he will vote no on the public safety millage because the general fund allocation for police/fire rose from 60% to 66% while other requests were approved. He also criticized the quality of a standing seam roof installed at Rotary Park. - Denise Mika (resident): Echoed concerns about the June 16 dinner, questioned whether grant funds could be used for alcohol, and said the event lacked transparency. She also raised questions about the Housing Commission's use of funds and website accessibility. - Greg Ralko (resident): Criticized the council for not discussing the Zoning Board of Appeals’ decision to approve rezoning at Eight Mile and Newburgh, which contradicted the council's earlier 5-2 vote against rezoning. He urged council members to publicly explain their positions. - Jim Biga (resident): Noted the Housing Commission's webpage on the city website is password-protected and inaccessible, contrary to claims of transparency. He also questioned whether the city used grant funds for alcohol at the June 16 dinner. - Jerry Karasinski (resident): Encouraged the city to hold information sessions about the public safety millage, explaining that voting it down would lose approximately $10 million out of a $76 million general fund. - Frank McDermott (resident): Questioned why the city paid $20,000 for a temporary accessibility ramp when a permanent fix could cost $6,000 to $8,000, as reported by an assistant engineer on local news. He requested clarification. - John Pastor (resident): Urged voters to support the police/fire millage and oppose the SMART bus millage due to low ridership (3.8 riders per bus on average) and pension debt. He also defended the replacement of bands for the Livonia Spree. - Sandra R. (resident): Suggested closing the Spree area earlier (9:00-9:30 PM) to prevent teenage disruption before fireworks at 10:00 PM. Consent Calendar The council unanimously approved all 12 consent items (Resolutions 226-26 through 237-26) with a 6-0 vote. Items included: - Block parties for June 28 (Five Mile Service Rd), July 4 (Roycroft St), and August 29 (Brentwood St) 2026. - Recognition of Kindred Spirits Quilters of Livonia as a non-profit for charitable gaming license purposes. - Waiver of driveway ordinance for 15273 Gary Lane. - Waiver use approval for Second Showing LLC to operate a consignment furniture store at 20412 Farmington Road, subject to conditions (no outdoor storage/sales). - Appointment of Timothy J. Klisz as Substitute Magistrate for the 16th District Court. - Special assessments for unpaid 2025 Sidewalk Program charges on specific parcels. - Award of bid to Cintas Corp for custodial supplies ($41,925 annually, $136,256 total over 39 months). - Appropriation of $26,889 for streetlight removal/installation at Idyl Wyld Golf Course west parking lot. - Appointments of Daniel Steele and Christopher Boloven to the Zoning Board of Appeals for three-year terms expiring July 12, 2029. Discussion Items - Councilmember Reports: Councilmember McCullough mentioned deficiencies at the REC Center (broken windows, chronic problems) and said he is seeking updates on condition repairs. Councilmember Budzinski announced upcoming events (Schoolcraft College open house, Pride event, Wilson Barn farmers market). - Senior Citizens, Families and Environment Committee Meeting (May 20, 2026): Councilmember McDonnell reported on discussions about urban environmental concerns (Racer Trust and Ford Motor Transmission plant) and the Newburgh Senior Housing project. The housing project is approximately $27 million with 100 units, in financing/design phase. Council approved referrals of Racer Trust and Ford Transmission plant to the committee (Resolutions 238-26 and 239-26, 6-0 each). Public comments from Denise Mika and Jim Biga called for more oversight and transparency of the Housing Commission; City Attorney noted funds are separate accounts. Councilmember Persiconi explained that CDBG funds ($800,000-$900,000 annually) are a separate program overseen by the Housing Commission with monthly financials available. - Economic Development, Strategic Planning & Technology Committee Meeting (June 3, 2026): Councilmember Budzinski reported that the city attorney recommended against a moratorium for data centers due to legal challenges. The committee instead recommended creating a special use ordinance for data centers, referred directly to the Planning Commission for a public hearing and eventual council vote. For gas stations and car washes, no further action was taken as they already have special use requirements. An email from Dan West on data centers was placed on file. - Item 15 (Finance & Budget Committee Report): Removed from the agenda; Councilmember Ptashnik will report at the July meeting. - Unfinished Business - Maison Rose Events: Approved (6-0) a waiver use for a banquet facility at 37176 Six Mile Road with conditions (max 136 guests, no events past 11 PM, no LED lightbands, floor plan adherence, and signage separately approved). - Unfinished Business - Easement Vacation: First reading given for petition 2026-03-03-01 to vacate water main and scenic easements at 33500 Seven Mile Road. - Water and Sewer Rate Ordinances (Second Reading): Unanimously adopted five ordinance amendments (6-0 each) updating water consumption rates, industrial waste surcharge, sewer disposal and maintenance rates, and special rates, effective with July 1, 2026 billing. Key Outcomes - All 12 consent items approved (6-0). - Referral of Racer Trust and Ford Transmission plant to committee (6-0 each). - Maison Rose Events waiver approved (6-0) with conditions. - Five water/sewer ordinance amendments adopted on second reading (6-0). - Block party for Kelly Ambrosi approved (6-0) for July 11, 2026 on Beatrice Street. - Lease agreement with Livonia Anniversary Committee, Inc. for Ford Field Park (Spree 76) approved (6-0), allowing the committee to enforce rules as a private event. - Quit claim deed from Soave Homes, Inc. for right-of-way at Scone Court accepted (6-0). - Meeting adjourned at 8:08 PM. Next regular meeting scheduled for July 13, 2026.

The Livonia City Council held a study meeting on June 1, 2026, at 9:27 PM (originally scheduled for 8:00 PM) in City Hall Auditorium, setting the agenda for the June 15 regular meeting. The meeting included public comments on the public safety millage, transit, and city spending; approval of multiple block party requests, a non-profit designation, a driveway waiver, and other routine items; discussion of a banquet facility waiver petition, which was placed on the regular agenda; and appointments to the Zoning Board of Appeals. Most items were directed to the consent calendar for the June 15 voting meeting. Consent Calendar - Block Party Requests (Items 1-3): Three block parties approved: Lauren Feigel's (June 28, 4-10 PM, Five Mile Service Road), Collin Buerkle's (July 4, 12-10 PM, Roycroft Street), and James Rumrill/Ray Franges/Mark Miller's (August 29, 12-10 PM, Brentwood Street, with rain date August 30). - Non-Profit Designation (Item 4): Kindred Spirits Quilters of Livonia designated as a non-profit to obtain a charitable gaming license for a future raffle. - Driveway Ordinance Waiver (Item 5): Aquelio Garcia granted a waiver to allow a driveway approach exceeding 2 feet, 4 inches; Engineer Zilincik noted no issues, calling it a formality. - Consignment Furniture Waiver (Item 7): Second Showing LLC approved to operate a consignment furniture establishment at 20412 Farmington Road, with stipulation that approval is limited to this operator. - Substitute Magistrate Appointment (Item 8): Timothy J. Klisz appointed as substitute magistrate for the 16th District Court, to fill in for full-time magistrate vacations (2-3 weeks per year). - Special Assessments Resolution (Item 9): Resolution adopted placing charges for the 2025 Sidewalk Program (Contract 25-G) on properties whose owners have not paid; approximately 184 properties affected, with payment plans available for about 10 residents. - Custodial Supplies Bid Award (Item 10): Bid awarded to Cintas for custodial supplies, using cooperative purchasing agreements (Omnia/MISD pricing). Total contract value approximately $140,000; staff confirmed it is a state-bid contract. - Streetlight Appropriation (Item 11): Authorization given for $26,889 to install 11 DTE LED lights at Idyl Wyld Golf Course west parking lot, replacing a single damaged light ($11,000 repair). DTE will replace any future damaged lights at no additional cost. - Zoning Board of Appeals Appointments (Items 12 & 13): Daniel Steele (appointed by Council President Reid) and Christopher Boloven (appointed by Councilmember Ptashnik) appointed to three-year terms expiring July 12, 2029. Boloven is a returning member. Public Comments & Testimony - Steve King (Country Gardens) opposed the proposed public safety millage, arguing it diverts general fund money away from essential services and is a "scare tactic." He claimed the city engages in a "shell game" similar to state lottery funding, and urged a "vote no." - Katie Rogowicz (Livonia) raised concerns about the SPRE perimeter fence, criticized the police traffic bureau for not returning calls, and opposed public transit, citing crime increases and a recent stabbing at a bus stop. She called for splitting the fire and police millage. - Christopher Martin (Michigan resident) criticized wasteful spending (work detail vehicles idling on weekends) and library disorder issues. He voiced support for the magistrate appointment (Item 8), calling Timothy Klisz well-qualified, and for Christopher Boloven's ZBA reappointment (Item 13). He also advocated for broadcasting ZBA meetings. - During Item 10, an audience member (likely Christopher Martin) questioned the custodial supplies contract, noting a $7,000 bid line item but a $140,000 total, and suggesting it should have gone to open bid. Staff clarified the pricing was preset through state bidding. Discussion Items - Waiver Petition 2026-03-02-11 (Item 6): Maison Rose Events – Planning Director Mark Taormina presented the request to operate a banquet (event) facility with occupancy over 50 at 37176 Six Mile Road. Petitioner Alfonso Wienclaw described plans for community-centered events (yoga, CPR classes, etc.), stating events would end by 10 PM with a 11 PM cleanup. Alcohol would not be sold or served, but clients could hire a licensed bartender to serve alcohol for free (no cover charge). Security would be present for evening events. Back door access would be locked and off-limits. Council discussed hours, alcohol regulations, and security. Councilmember McCullough moved to place on the regular agenda with stipulations of an 11 PM end time and requirement of a licensed bartender for any alcohol service. The motion passed, with direction for the regular agenda. - Special Assessments (Item 9) – Treasurer Susan Nash reported that about 9-10 residents requested payment plans. Owners have until end of September to pay; interest accrues October 1, and unpaid balances go on December tax bills. Key Outcomes - All agenda items except Item 6 were directed to the consent calendar for the June 15, 2026 regular meeting, indicating unanimous support for routine approval. - Item 6 (Maison Rose Events) was directed to the regular agenda with stipulations (11 PM end time, licensed bartender required if alcohol is served). - Councilmember Ptashnik corrected misinformation, stating that 66% of the general fund ($50 million) goes to public safety. - The meeting adjourned at 10:08 PM.