Alameda Planning Board Reviews Annual Reports on Housing, Transportation, and Climate (February 26, 2024)
STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE
Alameda Planning Board Meeting - February 26, 2024
The Planning Board of Alameda met on February 26, 2024, at 7:00 PM in City Hall Council Chambers to review and comment on three annual reports: the General Plan/Housing Element, the Transportation Choices Plan/Vision Zero Action Plan, and the Climate Action and Resiliency Plan (CARP)/Climate Adaptation and Hazard Mitigation Plan. The board also discussed staff communications, future meetings, and a subcommittee for the inclusionary housing ordinance. All three reports were endorsed with board comments and forwarded to the City Council. The meeting adjourned at 8:19 PM.
Public Comments & Testimony
- Denise Tripogne, Board President of Bike Walk Alameda, spoke on the transportation annual report. She noted that half of the CIP projects planned for 2023 were delayed and expressed concern that the 2024 work plan scales back neighborhood greenway conversions compared to the Active Transportation Plan. She urged completing all slow street conversions this year and the remaining neighborhood greenways next year, asking for clarity on staffing resources and a plan to make up the work.
Discussion Items
-
General Plan/Housing Element Annual Report: Steve Buckley, Planning Services Manager, presented the 2023 report. He noted that 2023 was a slow year for housing production, with only about 50 ADUs permitted (compared to a goal of 70/year) and no at-risk affordable housing units expiring. The city is working on an inclusionary ordinance update, objective design standards, and the North Housing and Webster Street permits. Board members discussed the need to track time-bound commitments, the first-time homebuyer program, and the affordable housing bond timeline. The board endorsed the report with comments.
-
Transportation Choices Plan/Vision Zero Action Plan: Lisa Foster, Acting Transportation Planning Manager, presented. Key statistics: three traffic fatalities and six severe injuries in 2023; 3.4 miles of roadway and 20 intersections improved with safety upgrades; 164,000 ferry rides taken by 800 pass holders; estuary water shuttle service to launch summer 2024. Board members discussed the relationship between the plans, the federal grant proposal for the Lincoln/Marshall/Pacific project (not awarded), and the need to prioritize equity. The board endorsed the report with comments.
-
Climate Action and Resiliency Plan (CARP) and Climate Adaptation and Hazard Mitigation Plan: Danielle Miller, Sustainability and Resilience Manager, presented. Highlights: 6.8% of registered vehicles in Alameda are electric (up from 2.3% in 2017); 677 net new trees since 2019 (below 350/year goal); natural gas use up in commercial sector; building electrification ordinance no longer enforceable on private property due to Berkeley court case; sea level rise adaptation projects underway with a $55 million FEMA BRIC grant application for Bay Farm Island. Board members discussed the need to clarify waste diversion data (81% reported vs. chart showing 50/50), acronym usage, and the importance of the urban forest plan. The board endorsed the report with comments.
Key Outcomes
-
Motions to Endorse Annual Reports: The board passed three motions, each with a second, to endorse the annual reports and forward them to the City Council with board comments. All votes were unanimous (4-0).
- General Plan/Housing Element: Moved by Board Member Sal, seconded by Board Member Ruiz.
- Transportation Choices/Vision Zero: Moved by Board Member Sal, seconded by Board Member Ruiz.
- CARP/Climate Adaptation: Moved by Vice President Cisneros, seconded by Board Member Sal.
-
Staff Communications: The board agreed to cancel the March 11, 2024 meeting due to lack of agenda items. Staff will proceed with hiring a consultant for the inclusionary housing ordinance update and will seek board volunteers for a subcommittee at a later date when all members are present.
Meeting Transcript
Board member Teresa Ruiz will be leading it. I'd like to allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. And two in public forward systems undervisible with liberty and justice for all. Okay, thank you. Okay. Roll call, please staff. Okay, good evening. Board member Sue. Here. Board Member Ruiz. Here. Board Member Cisneros. Here. And President Hong. Here. Yes, and we have uh three absences this evening. Excuse absence, but we do have four board members here, so we do have a quorum. So that's wonderful. So any agenda changes. This may not actually be an agenda change, but uh I did speak with staff about this for item five A. We have basically three annual reports for review. And we have a different staff presenting on each item. So suggestion is for us to take each one separately, uh take public comments, and then we can you know provide our comments and if we want to endorsement separately for each one. So we'll handle it. Handle it that way. So um at this point, we're we're still at the non-agenda public comments portion. So anyone who would like to speak on an item that's not on the agenda, uh it's open to the public for comments for three minutes apiece. So staff, do we have anyone in the audience submit a speaker's card? Anyone online? I don't see any hands raised, and there are no speakers in person. Okay, great. And then uh we do not have any consent calendar items on tonight's agenda, so we'll move on to item five, which is the uh annual reports. So the first one we'll be considering tonight for review and comment uh by the planning board is the annual report and the general plan and housing element. So um staff presentation. Yes, good evening. I'll wait for the slides to come up. Um I'm Steve Buckley, the planning services manager, and I'm here to present the first part of this evening's uh annual report um on the general plan and housing element. Um then we'll have uh two other staff members uh presenting the remainder of the material. Um there we go. So um the general plan, as you know, uh was and the housing element were adopted um back at the end of uh 2022. Um so we've had uh a full year of uh uh implementation and engagement on that the two um documents. The general plan, this is the outline of the general plan, uh includes uh seven chapters, um six sort of you know, content chapters, um, covering land use, uh, urban design, um, conservation, climate action, mobility, open space and parks, health and safety, and housing. And um overall, um, you know, we're sort of implementing the general plan pretty much every day. Um, you know, these these elements and these policies and and programs are integral to how the city operates, um how the city council sets its uh strategic plan priorities and budget priorities, how uh parks and rec and public works and other departments sort of go about their business, and so um I don't have really much to say about the general plan implementation per se, except um you know, we've we sort of pick off different parts of it, like the zoning obviously was re uh adopted with the general plan, so that's mostly taken care of. Um you'll be hearing more about the conservation um and uh climate action uh mobility uh this evening, where there are specific implementation plans that are also being um you know followed, and then um as I said parks and rec, you know, we we have a number of programs that are underway with the swim center and uh Gene Sweeney, and uh we'll also be looking at um uh urban forestry plan and other things that are all sort of integral to how the city operates. So with that I'm just gonna move on to the housing element, which is much more sort of how the planning department um and the planning board are specifically engaged. Um with the housing element, as you know, um we had the prior uh housing element with its uh regional housing needs allocation um there on the first column, and um you know the city was successful in building uh more housing than was allocated last time around in the prior element, um as with most cities in the Bay Area, um we we came up a little short on the actual affordable component of that. Um so um in the new housing element, we have about three times as much of an allocation and about three times as much affordable housing to build. So it's quite a challenge. Um and uh I have to say 2023 has been a slow year for housing production.
openpublica.com