Berkeley City Council Special Meeting July 23, 2024: Approval of Amended Home Loan Agreement for Former City Manager
STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE
Berkeley City Council Special Meeting – July 23, 2024
The Berkeley City Council held a special meeting on July 23, 2024, at 5:30 PM in the School District Board Room, 1231 Addison Street, Berkeley, CA. The sole agenda item was a resolution to approve amended home loan documents as part of the separation agreement for former City Manager Dee Williams-Ridley.
Public Comments & Testimony
- Elon Auerbach expressed opposition, questioning the approximately $200,000 payoff and calling it an effort to keep events between May 7 and July 10, 2024, confidential. He alleged the former city manager misled the community and unionized employees.
- A second speaker (unnamed) characterized the payment as extortion, criticized the city manager's performance, and questioned the ongoing payments.
- A third speaker (unnamed) criticized the city manager's tenure, citing surveillance and drones, and pleaded for limits on the next city manager's power.
- A fourth speaker (unnamed) recalled turnover in 2018 and argued that the strong city manager form of government was a problem, describing the payoff as $400,000 of taxpayers' money.
- Former Councilmember (on Zoom) called the payment “ridiculous,” alleged corruption and collusion, and noted that the city manager had given herself an $85,000 raise the previous year.
- Matty Tieblum (on Zoom) questioned why the city would write off $200,000 owed to the city, demanded transparency, and asked for precedent or legal justification.
- Kai Freeman (on Zoom) urged the council to be transparent and accountable, stating that the public is watching and questioning the use of funds given the city's fiscal constraints.
Discussion Items
- Motion to adopt the resolution was made by Mayor Arreguin and seconded. No discussion from council members occurred before the vote.
Key Outcomes
- Resolution adopted on a vote of 8 yes, 1 abstention (Councilmember Hahn abstained). No votes were cast in opposition. The resolution approves amended home loan documents for former City Manager Dee Williams-Ridley as part of her separation agreement.
- The meeting was adjourned after the vote, followed by a 15-minute recess before the 6:00 PM regular meeting.
Meeting Transcript
Okay. So um I will now call to order the 5 30 special meeting of the Berkeley City Council and ask the clerk to call the roll. Okay. Councilmember Kessarwani. Calling the role for the 530 meeting. Oh, oh, here. Bartlett. What's the condition of the separation? On present. One graph. President. Luna Parra. Here. Umbert. Yes. And present. There's one item on our agenda. Item one resolution approving amended home loan documents in consideration for former city manager D1's release separation agreement. I move adoption of item one. Second. Any public comment? Please come forward. Any speakers on Zoom? Please raise your hand. Hello, I'm Elon Alerbach. Uh and um, so this is to approve the uh the huge payoff, I think in the tune of about 200,000 to our former city manager who will see cede that in exchange for not suing the city for anything that happened between May 7th, 2024 and July 10th, 2024. So what exactly are you all trying to keep hush hush? This was the city manager who overrode the will of the people time and again, who regularly misled and outright lied to the community and to our unionized employees, did not make good on the negotiations that she negotiated, and on and on and on, and yet she's getting even more money. How come transparency, integrity? I really encourage you to disclose what is going on here to the public because we deserve to know. Thank you. I'm sorry, but I'll move to comment as well. I it feels like extortion. You know, that city manager, boy. All the tears and backslaps and every all the parting, all the kind words to her, and when does it stop? You know, when will enough? Will she have will there be more? Is she just gonna keep coming back? I mean, Lord have mercy. And do you really do you think she did that good a job? Was it worth it? I'm serious. I cannot believe that we're still paying this lady. We paid her and paid her and pay her and paid her, and we're still paying. And I I guess I would ask you, like what you know, we look at the at the strong city manager form of government. Now that we've increased the salaries of the city council members and so forth, I would be interested to see if that ultimately leaves, right? My understanding of the position is that now y'all are being paid more and compensated more so that you could spend more time shouldering the responsibilities of our city government, lessening the responsibilities of the city manager, hopefully, and distributing the power of our city more equitably through because every time I talk to a council member under the rule of D Williams, it looked like everybody was scared of her, and nobody was willing to say that the king or the city manager had no clothes, if you know what I mean. You know, nobody was willing to say that she was doing a bad job because everybody in their district was worried about her retaliation, and so we have a kind of a real structural problem here, and I hope it gets remedied before the next city manager comes in. Thank you. Within Berkeley in my own particularly semi-coherent way sometimes.
openpublica.com