Columbus City Hall Labor Day Event: Panel on Black Women in Labor – August 5, 2025
STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE
Columbus City Hall Labor Day Event: Panel on Black Women in Labor
On August 5, 2025, Columbus City Council President Pro Tem Rob Dorans welcomed attendees to the second annual Labor Day event at City Hall. The event featured a panel discussion moderated by Jamie Shoemaker, Executive Director of the Central Labor Council, focusing on the experiences of Black women in the labor movement. The discussion highlighted the importance of unions in providing economic stability, dignity, and a collective voice for workers.
Opening Remarks
- Rob Dorans introduced the event by emphasizing the value of organized labor, sharing his personal story as a third-generation union member. He noted that Black women are one of the most common demographics of union members, challenging stereotypes.
- Jamie Shoemaker introduced the panel, citing Bureau of Labor Statistics data showing Black women's unemployment rate around 6%, underscoring the relevance of the discussion.
Panelist Introductions
Panelists represented diverse union backgrounds:
- Lisa Ann Ball – Community Education and Racial Justice Manager at Kaleidoscope Youth Center, founding member of Kaleidoscope Workers Union.
- Cheryl Harris – Field Coordinator for the Ohio Federation of Teachers.
- Yanela Sims – Ohio State Director and Recording Secretary for SEIU Local One.
- Marcella Seals – Member of Ohio Local 132 Columbus Cement Masons.
Discussion Highlights
- Impact of Union Membership: Panelists shared how unions provided stability, voice, and a sense of pride. Lisa Ann Ball noted that union membership allowed her to be "unapologetically me." Yanela Sims described it as life-changing.
- Solidarity in the Workplace: Panelists described solidarity as embracing individual differences, uplifting all voices, and recognizing that all workers contribute equally.
- Opportunities for the Next Generation: Panelists emphasized mentoring youth, especially Black women, through education about unions and hands-on experience. Marcella Seals encouraged trades training as an alternative to college debt.
- Challenges for Black Women in Construction: Marcella Seals shared her experience as a Black woman in construction, having to prove her competence on job sites.
- Unionization in Nonprofits: Lisa Ann Ball explained how unionizing improved communication and employee support at Kaleidoscope Youth Center, ultimately benefiting clients.
- Proudest Union Moments: Panelists recalled moments of strength, including solidarity during bargaining, ratification victories, and when others recognized their leadership potential.
Public Questions and Responses
- Question from Ginger Cunningham (former union organizer): Reflected on her organizing experience in the 1970s and acknowledged the panelists' contributions.
- Question from Alicia Norman (community engagement manager, Dipped Custom Prints): Asked how artists and creative small businesses can protect their labor. Yanela Sims advised contacting unions for information and conversations. Panelists also noted that organizers in the audience might help.
- Question from State Representative Meredith Lawson Rowe: Asked about protecting jobs from AI. Responses noted that AI cannot replace tasks requiring human creativity, compassion, or complex judgment. Panelists stressed proactive planning, retraining, and collective bargaining to integrate AI without job loss.
- Question from Imani Mixton (media professional from Detroit): Asked about mentorship opportunities through unions. Panelists encouraged reaching out to admired individuals, being open to mentors of all backgrounds, and using union networks.
- Question from an audience member (burnout restoration consultant): Asked how to promote equitable policies without using the "union" label. Panelists suggested educating employers on benefits of organized workforce (stability, retention, better service).
Closing
Jamie Shoemaker thanked panelists, attendees, and Councilman Dorans's staff for organizing the event. Additional elected officials recognized included State Representatives Latina Humphrey and Meredith Lawson Rowe, City Attorney Klein, Judge Carly Edelstein, and Councilmembers Chris Weich, Beatty, and Reemy.
Key Outcomes
- The event served as a community celebration and educational forum on labor issues, particularly the role of Black women in unions.
- No formal votes or decisions were made; the meeting was a panel discussion and Q&A.
Meeting Transcript
Happy Labor Day week. You're welcome. Welcome to City Hall. It's uh great to have so many folks with us here today. Uh if you don't know who I am, my name's Rob Dorrans. I have the honor of serving as President Pro Tem of Columbus City Council. Um, and welcome to our second annual Labor Day event here in uh Columbus City Hall. Um, every year we've like to have this event um as a run up to Labor Day, uh, at a time in which we've seen attacks on organized labor uh in our state house here in Ohio, um, across the country, uh, and certainly in Washington, DC, it is important for us as a community, I think, to take pause and recognize uh folks in our community who have dedicated their careers to helping to uplift workers in Columbus. Um you know anything about me, you know that uh I'm a proud third generation union member. Um my dad, a couple years ago just retired after 41 years uh working in the in the IBW. And uh watching him in retirement with my mom has been an absolute privilege to see uh what economic stability has meant to our family. Um, you know, my sister and I were the first of our family ever to go to college, and that was because of his collective bargaining agreement. Uh we did not have to worry about um keeping a roof over our head because of that collective bargaining agreement. Watching my dad in retirement being able to travel and enjoy his grandkids is because of that collective bargaining agreement. And that is something that has meant the world to my family, and so many families, not only here in Columbus, but across the country, uh, the economic trajectory for their entire families have been completely changed because workers banded together uh to organize a union and stand up stand up for one another. So when we get towards uh Labor Day here next week, uh it's not only just a day off, but it's a day to remember uh folks um that have dedicated their lives to making the world a better place for them and their families. Um I do want to pause and recognize a number of elected officials that have joined us here today. I know we have State Representative uh Meredith Lawson Rowe. Uh, I know we have City Attorney Klein, who's with us here as well. Thank you. Uh Judge Carly Edelstein from the 10th District is here with us as well, Summer. Judge. Uh, we have Councilmembers Chris Weich, uh, Councilmembers Beatty, uh, Councilman Reemy. Um, have I missed anyone? I don't. Oh, Otter Kilgore speaking of elected officials that helped to make this place run uh and run better. So thank you all for being here today. Um, before I introduce our MC for the panel um here today, I I did want to talk a little bit about um today's event. You know, as I mentioned a moment ago, um, you know, my dad is somebody who that when you ask someone who uh what a union member is, oftentimes they think of people like my dad. They think of an old white guy who went to went to work with a lunch pail and you know wore jeans and you know worked in a power plant. And one of the most common demographics in this country of union members is black women. Think about that. We think about how oftentimes people want to pit workers against each other and try to drive wedges between people along class and racial lines. One of the most common demographics is uh of union members is women and particularly black women. And when we're at a moment in time in which there's so much divisiveness over trying to pit again working people against one another, I thought it was important for us to take a moment today to really think about what the labor movement means for for all workers, but particularly for black women that have stepped up to help lead this movement, to organize workers, uh, to help make sure that families um every single job has dignity, whether or not folks are sweeping floors, taking care of our kids, every single job has dignity, and it requires uh a union to help stand up to make sure that those workers have that dignity for them and their families, um, which is why I thought it was important, uh, given everything that's going on in our country right now that we have an event like this today. Uh so with that, I want to invite uh one of my favorite women in the in the labor movement, uh Jamie Shoemaker, who's the executive director of our Central Labor Council here in Columbus, who's the first woman ever elected to that position as well. So with that, I'm turning the floor over to Jamie. Hello everyone. Thank you, Councilmember and Dorans. I'm excited to be here today and grateful for the opportunity to assist in this important conversation because women on this panel have helped pave the way for me to be a union leader and other women to become labor leaders. I will always be thankful and hope and encourage the next generation, just like you guys have. Spaces like this are always powerful when you share insight, build solidarity, and find our potential solutions. With the recent job loss, data showing black women being disproportionately affected. With black women's unemployment rate hovering around 6%, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. This isn't just a number. This isn't just a this is a lot of people's reality that's impacting the lobbyhood livelihoods of families and their futures. That's why today's discussion is so important and couldn't be more honored to join this group of panelists who will bring a wealth of experience, perspective, and passion to this topic. So let's meet them. I am going to let them introduce themselves. I've already screwed up somebody's name multiple times today, and I am not going to do it.
openpublica.com