Erie City Council Meeting: VNet Fiber Expansion Update - August 22, 2025
Erie City Council Meeting: VNet Fiber Expansion Update - August 22, 2025
Brad Wortell, Chief Operating Officer of Velocy Network (VNet Fiber), provided an update on the company's fiber optic expansion in the city of Erie. He presented a map showing areas currently served (orange) and planned expansions (purple/blue). The company has grown from serving about 10% of households to an estimated 30-40% coverage, with 6,400 subscribers in the Erie area and 20,000 households passed. Key challenges include aging utility poles, high costs for pole attachments and replacements, and changing regulations from First Energy and Verizon. The company is working to fill in gaps in the network, focusing on areas where backbone infrastructure already exists.
Discussion Items
- Progress and Coverage: VNet has expanded from Pittsburgh Avenue to West Grandview Boulevard, covering areas such as Southwest Erie, Mount Calvary, and along 29th Street. The backbone network has been leveraged to feed residential areas. The company has seen a high take rate (over 25%) in some areas but lower (12-13%) in others like Southeast Erie.
- Challenges with Utility Poles: The primary obstacle is the cost and complexity of attaching to older utility poles. Replacement costs can be $15,000 per pole, and in some areas, make-ready fees have increased fourfold. The company is working with First Energy and Verizon to find solutions, including coordinating with pole replacement schedules.
- Tree Trimming and Underground Issues: Tree trimming has caused occasional fiber cuts, but residents have been accommodating. Underground installation is more expensive and problematic in winter, so the company prefers aerial deployment where possible.
- Future Plans: Two imminent areas (purple on map) are near West Erie Plaza and along Bird Drive/Fairmont Parkway. The company aims to fill in gaps in the network, particularly in the East Bayfront and West Bayfront areas, pending pole access and cost reductions.
- Competition and Pricing: VNet offers upload speeds of 1,000 to 2,000 Mbps, far exceeding the FCC standard of 25/3 Mbps. The company has reduced prices and is seeing strong interest from residents switching from Spectrum. The city has provided revolving loans totaling $22.8 million to support expansion.
- Council Questions and Feedback: Council members expressed support for expanding fiber to more residential neighborhoods, especially on the east side. They discussed the importance of coordination with city permitting and infrastructure projects. Council member Chuck noted that citywide fiber could add a quarter billion dollars in home equity.
Key Outcomes
- No formal votes were taken.
- VNet will continue to work with First Energy and Verizon to reduce pole attachment costs and coordinate with pole replacement schedules.
- Council members will reach out to VNet to identify specific areas needing service and to explore ways to streamline permitting and coordination.
- The city will continue its revolving loan program to support VNet's expansion.
- Residents are encouraged to sign up on VNet's website to show demand, which helps prioritize areas for deployment.
Meeting Transcript
Good evening, everyone. Um, I'm Brad Wortell. If you don't know or I haven't met you before, I'm the chief operating for Velocy Network. Um also VNet Fiber. Um appreciate everyone's time uh to to hear about our updates and then get some feedback and we can provide some um additional data and some of the roadblocks and things that we've been seeing that we can maybe work through here, and maybe council can help us out with and continue the growth that we have here. I know while I'm working with Chuck before we had uh you know just a little bit of areas that we were in in the city, and it's been a little bit of uh time here since the last meeting, but I wanted to provide a printout here, and we can get you a digital copy of this as well so you can zoom in. I know I tried to blow it up on uh a larger paper, but uh it didn't really blow up well. So um, but if you know the city uh and and the roads and everything in here, this will kind of uh break out where we've been. We've been really busy um the past year. Um we started with uh permitting or working through uh permits with uh First Energy. Um we had um set a number of poles in the in the city for some areas where we couldn't get on the telephone poles. Um, and as you're aware, majority of the city of Erie, um the utilities are um through the air or aerial. Um there are some areas that are underground. Um there were some sections we we put some uh underground conduit in, but we really expanded uh dramatically from the border of uh Pittsburgh Avenue. Um I would say from 26th, 26th Street to 38th Street, and then just recently we've moved all the way up to uh West Grandview Boulevard. So everything that's highlighted in uh in orange is areas that those houses can get service from VNet Fiber. Uh you need another one? Here we go. The area um you'll see a couple that are in bluish purple. They would look blue on the computer, but it's more purple. Um is uh State Street. We've we've been working on um pole permitting and costing for State Street from about where um Collegiate Academy is up to 38th Street. There's been an area there in the middle that we were running into. There's issues with the telephone poles, and if you're familiar at all uh with the uh telephone uh and power line poles in some parts of the city, they're very old. Some of them are probably in the 60 to 70 years of age. Um, first energy is starting to do a lot of work on replacing those with more uh modern poles. Um you'll see that in different parts of the city. But that how that holds up some of our deployments because we bear the burden of paying for those replacements. Um there's some changes in the FCC uh laws that are coming down that are requiring the power companies to I'd say take the burden on of a majority of those poll replacements because they should have been replaced 25, 30 years ago. Um but what's happened historically is uh providers like us in other regions, other providers when they go to attach to a telephone pole if they're the next one on the power company or the telephone company of Verizon owns they own about probably 20%, 30% of the poles in the city would come and say, okay, velocity, you're the next one to attach. We wouldn't replace this poll if it wasn't for you needing to get on it, and it's $15,000 for that one pole. So we're still running into those things. We had had a crew come out and survey West Bayfront two years ago, East Bayfront, and put together a model for us to be able to go on telephone poles in those areas. That pricing two years ago is not the pricing of today. So there's been some changes in the uh requirements and height requirements, a whole bunch of technical stuff and where we can attach and where we can't. We are working very closely with First Energy and Verizon to see if there's some relief and some different ways we can go about getting on some of those poles. Um there are areas in West Bayfront and even on um East Bayfront that there's poles on both sides of the street. So the power company owns the poles, let's say on the north side, and Verizon owns it on the south side. But if power lines cross your your lines, your telephone lines, we have to maintain clearances. So now we get we would have to pay 800, 900, 1,000 to have first energy move the power lines up higher so that we can fit above spectrum. So there's a whole bunch of different things that go into attaching to telephone poles. We found a lot less of those problems south of 26th Street because there's not as much uh equipment and as many things attached to the polls. So that's what's allowed us to spread out pretty rapidly from Pittsburgh Avenue all the way. I mean, we just wrapped up McClelland and 38th Street. Um that's we were over there. Yeah. Yes. So McClellan 38th to um what uh East Grandview Boulevard. I grew up on English Avenue, so uh you know my parents got fiber finally here, they've been asking for it for like 20 years, but uh over there on uh 40th in English, 44th in English. We've got um a section in um you're over near Mount Calvary and Ricardo's, they're on the north side of East Lake Road.
openpublica.com