OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

City Council Study Session on Erie County Human Relations Commission - August 28, 2025

City CouncilThursday, August 28, 2025
BodyErie, Pennsylvania
SessionCity Council
DateThursday, August 28, 2025
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 27:11

Transcript — Verbatim
0:05

Thank you everybody for coming tonight.

0:06

We are going to hear from Dr.

0:08

Christa Genebis with the Erie County HRC, the Human Relations Commission.

0:12

I asked for the study session as there are a lot of things that are happening in the world right now.

0:17

But there's been just a little bit of shifting and some of the things that are happening with the HRC, not to be confused with the other some of the other HRCs that we have recently talked about.

0:26

But I just wanted her to come give us some updates on the work that she's been doing and just some of the statistics and why this is such a critical resource right now in the city and how it can be an asset to the community members that we're serving.

0:38

All right, thank you.

0:40

Yeah, so I am the director of the Erie County HRC.

0:44

I started full time in June, so I've not been in this role for very long, but I feel like I've really hit the ground running and uh have done a lot and have a lot to share, and really want to get this in front of as many people as possible because I think there's a lot of work to do.

1:00

And I'm gonna talk a little bit about what we do and a little bit about the involvement that the city has, which you do.

1:07

Um you have a total of five appointments for either my commission and my advisory board.

1:13

Um a lot of the complaint and a lot of things that happen also occur in the city.

1:20

Uh so I'm not gonna read that to you, but what we do is we take in uh potential claims of discrimination, and on another slide I'll go over all the different classes.

1:29

There's over a dozen different protected classes for the ordinance here in Erie County.

1:35

And so we can take in those claims and we can move forward with an investigation and potentially a settlement, a mediation.

1:44

Uh this can go to trial if if deemed um necessary to do so.

1:51

Um, and we really are kind of a make whole agency.

1:55

We want if somebody is being discriminated against, we want what was lost, brought back.

2:00

So say they missed uh pay, we want that back.

2:02

Say they got evicted, we want that reinstated, or they're missing out on um, you know, AB and C could be multiple things.

2:10

A lot of times, not a lot of times, sometimes um it's not monetary uh at all what they're looking for.

2:18

Sometimes they just want acknowledgement or a policy change or an apology.

2:22

Um, so that is kind of the more official part of what we do.

2:26

The other part that the commission does is an educational outreach, uh, which I've been really, really trying since I've started here in early summer, is to have events in the community so people know what we do, how we can help.

2:41

Um, and we talk about human relations.

2:44

So we work with humans and the relations that are happening in the community.

2:49

Um so we do a lot of that too.

2:52

Uh important part of what we do is this is about discrimination three main areas, and I highlighted them.

2:59

Uh employment, housing, and public accommodations.

3:03

So it's discrimination in those three areas that we address.

3:10

Uh why is having a local HRC important?

3:13

And this is one that I think is necessary to talk about because there is a state HRC, PHRC, but our specific ordinance is more detailed.

3:26

Uh includes more classes, protected classes, and when you have a local HRC, you're gonna have more immediate care and more immediate attention to an issue.

3:36

Um so I put that on there.

3:37

Accessibility.

3:38

I mean, if you're talking about sending your complaint to the EEOC or to the PHRC, um they have a lot longer of a list that they're dealing with that they're working through.

3:51

Um so accessibility is tough.

3:53

Uh you can't just go to the PHRC here and Erie.

3:56

You'd have to the closest place to go is Pittsburgh.

4:00

Um so that that's a barrier.

4:03

We have community insight.

4:04

Uh I would like to think that I've worked really hard to make some connections with the community.

4:09

So when there is something going on in the community, I'm able to reach out to somebody and get an immediate answer or find out a little bit more.

4:15

Investigation on our end with a local HRC is faster because I could say, hey, you know what, I actually know somebody that works at City Hall.

4:23

So I I'm gonna call somebody.

4:25

Or I know somebody that works with you know social workers, I'm gonna make a call.

4:29

Um when you're talking about a statewide or uh a national agency, they definitely don't have that.

4:35

Um we provide local trainings, um, we provide local educational sessions, we provide panels so that people can talk about what's going on in the community and what their need is, round tables, things like that.

4:47

You're not gonna get that from a state or uh a national.

4:50

And there's accountability here where we can maybe move the needle and change things.

4:56

Uh so bottom line, I think uh local HRC is incredibly important, and we're lucky that we have one.

5:01

And I think the goal now that uh things are moving forward and uh with a good momentum is that we can really have some positive changes.

5:11

So these are all the protected classes that we have.

5:14

There is, I think 14 on that list.

5:17

Um of them are maybe the obvious ones that people they're the things that you can see, right?

5:22

But there's a lot that maybe you can't see or you don't think about that are on this list.

5:28

Um, some that are on this list that are not on others would be criminal history.

5:32

We have protections for folks with criminal history that is not at the state level.

5:37

I think that's really important.

5:39

Um we also have added protections for sexual orientation and gender identity.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Community Engagement█████████████████████████████████████████████67%
Racial Equity█████████████20%
Budget Equity Analysis█████7%
Election Process████6%
Summary of Proceedings

City Council Study Session on Erie County Human Relations Commission - August 28, 2025

The Erie City Council held a study session on August 28, 2025, featuring a presentation by Dr. Christa Genebis, Director of the Erie County Human Relations Commission (HRC). Dr. Genebis provided an update on the HRC's operations, challenges, and community impact. The session highlighted the HRC's role in investigating discrimination claims in employment, housing, and public accommodations, as well as its outreach and educational efforts. Council members discussed budget constraints, vacancies on the commission, and ways to support the HRC's mission.

Presentation by Dr. Christa Genebis

  • Dr. Genebis started as full-time director in June 2025 and reported that the HRC handles discrimination claims under 14 protected classes, including criminal history, sexual orientation, gender identity, and use of a guide or support animal — protections not fully covered by state law.
  • The HRC investigates complaints in three areas: employment, housing, and public accommodations. Mediation is prioritized, but cases can proceed to hearings (which are public) or trials if necessary.
  • Current intake statistics (since June 2025): 9 housing complaints, 4 employment, 4 public accommodations; 24 active investigations, 5 on hold with other agencies, 6 closed (settled or administratively closed). Housing complaints often involve service animals, evictions, harassment, or landlord issues.
  • The HRC has experienced repeat respondents, which may indicate patterns or clients referring others.
  • Outreach efforts include the "Being Black in Erie" panel series (next event October 1, 2025, focusing on the younger generation), a disability rights training offering CE credits for social workers and attorneys, and workplace discrimination trainings.
  • Dr. Genebis noted the HRC office recently moved to the ground floor of the Masonic Temple in the city, with visible window space for events.

Budget and Vacancy Challenges

  • The county executive (current officeholder) has removed the HRC from the county budget each year; city council has historically overridden the veto but with increasing difficulty. The 2024 budget was $260,000; the current 2025 budget is $150,000. The city contributes $15,000 annually.
  • The HRC has two commissioner vacancies: one from the county executive (who has not appointed) and one from Councilman Charlie Bale. Only 7 of 9 commissioners are seated, making it difficult to form hearing panels due to scheduling and conflict-of-interest rules. The advisory board has 11 members; the city has 4 appointments, and those are currently filled with active participants including Edison Nicholson and Alex Vaughn.
  • Dr. Genebis is the only staff member, working 50+ hours per week; she hopes to hire part-time help.

Council Discussion

  • Council members expressed strong support for the HRC's mission, acknowledging its importance as a local resource vs. state/federal agencies which are slower and less accessible (closest PHRC office is in Pittsburgh).
  • Council asked about ways to fill the commissioner vacancy from Councilman Bale's district; it was noted the current system requires the district representative to recommend an appointment, though an ordinance could allow override by majority vote.
  • Council members discussed the importance of local elections (November 4, 2025) in determining future support for the HRC.
  • Suggestions were made to increase outreach by tabling at community festivals (e.g., Hispanic Fest, Irish Fest) to raise awareness.
  • No other municipalities contribute to the HRC budget.

Key Outcomes

  • Council received information for budget season, which is upcoming. No formal votes were taken.
  • Council members committed to promoting HRC events and referring potential discrimination complainants.
  • The session served as an educational update for council on the HRC's operations and needs.

Meeting Transcript

Thank you everybody for coming tonight. We are going to hear from Dr. Christa Genebis with the Erie County HRC, the Human Relations Commission. I asked for the study session as there are a lot of things that are happening in the world right now. But there's been just a little bit of shifting and some of the things that are happening with the HRC, not to be confused with the other some of the other HRCs that we have recently talked about. But I just wanted her to come give us some updates on the work that she's been doing and just some of the statistics and why this is such a critical resource right now in the city and how it can be an asset to the community members that we're serving. All right, thank you. Yeah, so I am the director of the Erie County HRC. I started full time in June, so I've not been in this role for very long, but I feel like I've really hit the ground running and uh have done a lot and have a lot to share, and really want to get this in front of as many people as possible because I think there's a lot of work to do. And I'm gonna talk a little bit about what we do and a little bit about the involvement that the city has, which you do. Um you have a total of five appointments for either my commission and my advisory board. Um a lot of the complaint and a lot of things that happen also occur in the city. Uh so I'm not gonna read that to you, but what we do is we take in uh potential claims of discrimination, and on another slide I'll go over all the different classes. There's over a dozen different protected classes for the ordinance here in Erie County. And so we can take in those claims and we can move forward with an investigation and potentially a settlement, a mediation. Uh this can go to trial if if deemed um necessary to do so. Um, and we really are kind of a make whole agency. We want if somebody is being discriminated against, we want what was lost, brought back. So say they missed uh pay, we want that back. Say they got evicted, we want that reinstated, or they're missing out on um, you know, AB and C could be multiple things. A lot of times, not a lot of times, sometimes um it's not monetary uh at all what they're looking for. Sometimes they just want acknowledgement or a policy change or an apology. Um, so that is kind of the more official part of what we do. The other part that the commission does is an educational outreach, uh, which I've been really, really trying since I've started here in early summer, is to have events in the community so people know what we do, how we can help. Um, and we talk about human relations. So we work with humans and the relations that are happening in the community. Um so we do a lot of that too. Uh important part of what we do is this is about discrimination three main areas, and I highlighted them. Uh employment, housing, and public accommodations. So it's discrimination in those three areas that we address. Uh why is having a local HRC important? And this is one that I think is necessary to talk about because there is a state HRC, PHRC, but our specific ordinance is more detailed. Uh includes more classes, protected classes, and when you have a local HRC, you're gonna have more immediate care and more immediate attention to an issue. Um so I put that on there. Accessibility. I mean, if you're talking about sending your complaint to the EEOC or to the PHRC, um they have a lot longer of a list that they're dealing with that they're working through. Um so accessibility is tough. Uh you can't just go to the PHRC here and Erie. You'd have to the closest place to go is Pittsburgh. Um so that that's a barrier. We have community insight. Uh I would like to think that I've worked really hard to make some connections with the community. So when there is something going on in the community, I'm able to reach out to somebody and get an immediate answer or find out a little bit more. Investigation on our end with a local HRC is faster because I could say, hey, you know what, I actually know somebody that works at City Hall. So I I'm gonna call somebody. Or I know somebody that works with you know social workers, I'm gonna make a call. Um when you're talking about a statewide or uh a national agency, they definitely don't have that. Um we provide local trainings, um, we provide local educational sessions, we provide panels so that people can talk about what's going on in the community and what their need is, round tables, things like that. You're not gonna get that from a state or uh a national. And there's accountability here where we can maybe move the needle and change things.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com