City Council Transcript Summary for November 5, 2025
City Council Meeting Summary November 5, 2025
The Erie City Council convened on November 5, 2025, to honor community policing efforts with an award presentation, receive the 2026 preliminary budget proposal involving potential property tax increases, and address public concerns regarding sewage backups and the police review board before proceeding with routine ordinance adoptions and committee reports.
Consent Calendar
- Approved minutes from the October 15, 2025 City Council meeting and bills for payment on November 7th and 14th.
- Passed Ordinance 75-2025 (Council File 16565) appropriating $25,000 from DCNR grant funds, 7-0.
- Adopted Council File Ordinances 1656, 16567, 16568, 16573 on first reading (appropriating funds for housing rehab, McDonald's 911 fundraiser, Irish Wolfhound Association donations, and canine training respectively), all passed 7-0.
Public Comments & Testimony
- Kenneth Bounds expressed frustration and request for action regarding sewage flooding in his basement on South Shore Drive. He requested an engineering report on the backup causes and requested the city coordinate improvements with Milk Creek Township to prevent recurrence. The administration responded that the sewer department has been investigating the area actively since the incident.
- Deontay Coley expressed gratitude for the recognition of police officers in the community but raised concern regarding the lack of a citizen police review board. He stated that residents with credentials, including retired trooper Brian Harrington and retired principal Cleet Collins, are interested in serving on such a board. He criticized Mayor Joe Schember for allegedly focusing on candy crush or texting during his speech, stating this behavior is rude and indicative of a disconnect from community engagement.
- Robert Tacus expressed urgency and concern regarding three issues: requested the installation of a stop sign at 16th and Myrtle for safety; expressed indignation regarding being pulled over in a wheelchair due to broken sidewalks while criticizing the city for collecting taxes without maintaining walkability; requested immediate help from the council regarding the "Justice for Tricello" case, stating the delay in the District Attorney's actions is ridiculous given the family's suffering.
Discussion Items
- Jason Belton Award Presentation: Chief Russo presented the award to Patrolman Matthew Velud for exemplifying Officer Belton's legacy. Velud expressed honor, stated he is striving to live up to Belton's standard of care, and emphasized that community policing is a mindset rather than just a program.
- 2026 Budget Proposal: Finance Director Lisa Gomersal presented a preliminary budget of $110,112,599, representing a 2.4% increase. She outlined three scenarios for balancing the budget:
- Recommended scenario: Increase property taxes by 1 mil (approx. $100 per $100k home value) in 2026.
- Alternative scenario: No tax increase in 2026, but requiring a nearly 3-mill increase in 2027.
- Local Service Tax (LST) scenario: Increasing LST from $52 to $156 annually to shift burden from residents, enabling property tax increases to remain under one mill per year. She noted that the city has held property tax steady for six years and detailed the usage of the water lease prepayment fund.
- Committee Reports: Councilmembers discussed incoming personnel (Marilyn Pohl, Andre Horton), the Erie Zoo land transfer status, the Port Authority's ship project, and the need for transparency from the District Attorney regarding the Tricello investigation. Dr. Titus stated that a draft ordinance for a police and community committee is under review to ensure legal soundness.
Key Outcomes
- Appointment: Passed a resolution to appoint Carl Anderson to the Erie Planning Commission (term ending Dec 31, 2028) and the Land Bank. Vote: 5 Yes, 2 Nays.
- Bond Authorizations: Adopted Council File Ordinances 16571 and 16572 on first reading to authorize lease rental debt ($12 million and $3.32 million respectively) for water distribution facility improvements. Vote: 7-0.
- Budget Sessions: Scheduled public budget sessions for November 6, 11, 13, and 20, with a final hearing anticipated after the December 3rd City Council meeting.
- Historic Review Commission: Open call for applications to fill three vacancies on the seven-member commission for residents with backgrounds in preservation, history, architecture, or art history.
Meeting Transcript
Roll call for the City Council meeting of Wednesday November 5th, 2025 at 9 a.m. Members Witherspoon, Brzezinski, Flores, Nelson, Schaff, Titus, and Troop. I'd like to ask everyone to please stand for a moment of silence and the pledge of allegiance. One nation under God with liberty and justice hurried. Motion to approve the minutes from the October 15th, 2025 City Council meeting and bills for payment on November 7th and 14th. Members Brzezinski, Flores, Nelson Schaff, Titus Troop, and Witherspoon. Okay, this morning we have a presentation of the Jason Belton Award. Chief. Good morning. Thank you, Council, and especially President Witherspoon. Several years ago, it was your vision to create this award in memory of Jason Belton, the former officer who uh died untimely on the job uh during the COVID uh term. So this morning it's my honor and privilege to present a Jason Belton Community Policing Award, an award that stands as a lasting tribute to Officer Belton's commitment to the Erie community, his dedication to service, his belief that policing is best when it's rooted in trust, compassion, and partnership. Jason was a fixture in the downtown area riding his bicycle, interacting with everyone he came in contact with. We learned that after his uh departure, unfortunately. The Jason Belton Community Policing Award recognizes an officer who goes above and beyond the call of duty to build a meaningful relationship with the citizens we serve. This award honors those who exemplify Officer Belton's legacy through proactive engagement, mentorship, and a genuine desire to make our neighborhoods better and safer. Previous award winners are here today, include Sergeant Mel Soric, Sergeant David Smith, and Patrolman Max Burzel. This year's recipient has demonstrated outstanding initiative in fostering positive community relations, supporting local outreach programs, and embodying the principles, fairness, respect, and integrity in to find true community policing. This year's recipient began his career with the Pittsburgh Police Department before returning to his hometown, where he has served for over seven years. Recently assigned as a full-time saturation unit, he continues on the same path as Jason, riding a bike and making a difference in the downtown. On behalf of the Erie Police Department and the Belton family who are here, it gives me great pride to present the Jason Belton Community Policing Award to Patrolman Matthew Velud. Again, is whenever you're done. What's that? A couple of words. Whenever we're done. Oh, sure. Well, let's hear it from them. Thank you, guys. I'm truly honored to receive this award. Having had the privilege, privilege of knowing Jason before he passed, I saw firsthand how he approached community policing. He set the standard high, treating everyone with genuine care and respect. Every day I strive to live up to the example he set, and I believe we all should. To Jason's family, thank you for being here today. Your strength and compassion reminds us all how great a man Jason was. And his legacy continues to inspire all of us every day. Thank you to the previous award winners for carrying on Jason's example and to the command staff, the saturation unit, and to Deputy Chief Russo. Your guidance and support mean everything. Community policing isn't just a program. Community policing isn't just a program, it's a mindset. It's about knowing the people we serve, understanding their needs, and building trust, one conversation at a time. That connection is what keeps our neighborhood safe and makes this job so meaningful. To all my fellow officers, thank you for the work you do every day, your sacrifices you make, for the compassion you show to this community. This award represents all of us who believe in what community policing truly means. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. I didn't know feeling. Good morning, everyone. I'm very happy to be here. Can you hear me okay?
openpublica.com