Frederick Historic Preservation Commission Meeting - November 14, 2024
STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE
Frederick Historic Preservation Commission Meeting - November 14, 2024
The Historic Preservation Commission (HPC) met on November 14, 2024, at 6:00 PM at City Hall to hear cases, discuss proposed projects, and conduct a workshop. The meeting included a public hearing, approval of minutes, administrative reports, consent items, and four regular cases. The commission also recognized Christina Martinkosky as the first Division Manager of Historic Preservation Planning.
Consent Calendar
- HPC24-778 (522 Klineharts Alley) – Rehabilitation approval for Derrick and Molly Harrigan, agent Robert Johnston. The commission approved the consent item unanimously.
Public Comments & Testimony
- On HPC24-759 (200 E Patrick Street): A member of the public, identified as Totoff, spoke in opposition to the current site plan, supporting staff comments regarding the mitigation for the historic Byerly Tannery. He urged the incorporation of the smokestack into the design and requested a more meaningful interpretation of the site's industrial heritage.
Discussion Items
- HPC24-702 (127 E 6th Street) – Continuance: Staff announced that this demolition case was automatically continued to the December 12, 2024 hearing due to public notice requirements. No action was taken.
- HPC24-779 (10 N Carroll Street) – Amendment (Crabby Bunch, LLC): The commission considered a modification to allow a new wood service door and wood soffit to be finished with a clear stain (rather than solid opaque), plus new hardware. Staff noted the elements are recessed under cover and recommended approval. The commission agreed, finding the location protected from the elements, and approved the application unanimously.
- HPC24-759 (200 E Patrick Street) – Level II Review (Frederick Conference Center Hotel): Staff presented a detailed report on materials, landscaping, and lighting. A major point of discussion was the extensive artistic uplighting proposal. Staff recommended conditions including removal of uplighting on upper stories of the south elevation and an 80% reduction overall. After discussion, the applicant agreed to remove the lighting plan from the current application and resubmit it separately. The commission then voted to approve the remainder of the Level II application with that condition, unanimous.
- HPC24-764 (132 W Church Street) – Demolition: Partial demolition of a non-historic rear stoop. Staff found the removal would not affect the historic integrity of the contributing resource. The commission approved the application unanimously.
- HPC24-769 (132 W Church Street) – Rehabilitation: Rehabilitation of a non-historic rear addition. Staff recommended approval, noting the rear location and non-historic nature. The commission approved the application unanimously.
Key Outcomes
- All regular cases (HPC24-779, HPC24-759, HPC24-764, HPC24-769) were approved, with HPC24-759 having the lighting plan removed for future review.
- Administrative Approval Report for October 2024 (30 cases reviewed and approved) was noted.
- The commission amended the hearing agenda to hear HPC24-779 first, consistent with staff request for interpretive assistance.
- Workshop cases (HPC24-477, HPC24-685, HPC24-744) were discussed and applicants were directed to resubmit updated materials by December 2, 2024 for the December 12 hearing.
Meeting Transcript
Tansi Creighton, uh Commissioner Paul Fitzgerald, myself, Commissioner Robert Van Renz, Commissioner Ann Hart, and Historic Preservation Planners Christina Martin Koske and Sarah Hoffaditz, and Assistant City Attorney Ira Sanon. Well, everyone who has business before the Commission this evening or wishes to be heard for public uh public testimony, please rise and be sworn in. Do you solemnly swear or affirm that the responses given and statements made in this hearing before the Historic Preservation Commission will be the whole truth and nothing but the truth? If so, answer I do. Thank you very much. It is the purpose of the historic historic preservation commission to safeguard the historical and cultural heritage of the City of Frederick by preserving sites, structures, or districts that reflect elements of the cultural, social, economic, political, archaeological, or architectural history, to stabilize and improve property values of such sites, structures or districts, to foster civic beauty, to strengthen the local economy, and to promote the preservation and appreciation of such sites, structures, and districts for the educational welfare of the residents of the City of Frederick. In order to be eligible to vote on an application, a commissioner must have made the required site visit and attended any and all meetings at which such an application was discussed. In the event that a commissioner is absent from any such meeting, the commissioner may satisfy the attendance requirement by reviewing the record of that meeting. It is presumed if a commissioner makes no statement at this time that they have done so and are prepared to vote on the agenda this evening. That being said, are there any commissioners with statements of eligibility? All right, seeing none, uh let's move on. Uh any announcements this evening. Excuse me. Yes, I have two announcements. The first HPC 24-702 at 127 East 6th Street, appeal to meet public notice requirements. No action will be taken tonight. The project is automatically scheduled for the December 12th hearing. Second. Uh to accommodate requested interpretive assistance. I'm asking the commission to amend the order of the hearing agenda so that HPC 24-779 at 10 North Carroll Street be the first item on the regular cases to be heard following the consent agenda. All right, we do actually have a third announcement this evening from uh our director for planning, Gabriel Gabriel Collard. If you would come forward, please. Good evening. Thank you very much for having me. Uh, my name is Gabrielle Collard, and I'm the Deputy Director for the Planning Department. And I just wanted to join you this evening to um give a very warm welcome and congratulations to Christina Martinkowski, who has now been uh pointed to our role of division manager of historic preservation planning. She is the first ever division manager of historic preservation planning for the city of Frederick, as this is an entirely new position, uh one that is very strategically designed to uh not only promote the goals of historic preservation planning and give it the resources that it really does deserve in the city, um, but also to further our long-range planning goals and to separate some of our functions uh that have been kind of lumped together, um, and this is a a step in a more efficient direction, um, and hopefully one that gives the historic preservation planning staff the resources it needs to support you all to your fullest. So very exciting. So, congratulations, Christina. And I would also like to thank Brandon uh who has been working very hard uh over the past many years with our historic preservation planning staff. He will now be resuming his full-time role as the community planning and urban design manager, uh, so focusing on some of our long-range efforts, but um, he has done a wonderful job supporting Christina and Sarah and all of our preservation planners in the past. So thank you, Brandon. I look forward to um continuing to work with all of you and to see um how how we can move forward in a much more progressive and exciting way, and I'm excited about it. So thank you very much for your time this evening and uh thank you. Thank you. All right, moving on to approval of minutes. Uh minutes from the October 24th, 2024 hearing and workshop. Commissioners, any additions or corrections to be made to those minutes. Mr. Chairman, I move to approve the hearing minutes and the workshop minutes for the October 24, 2024 HPC hearing. I will second. All right. Any further discussion? Hearing none, all in favor, please raise your hand. All right, that uh passes unanimously. Thank you very much. Moving on to HPC business administrative approval reports. Yes, I would like to enter the entire administrative approval report into the record and note that 30 cases were reviewed and approved in the month of November, October, excuse me. Um finally, uh circling back to the announcement I made earlier regarding um modifying the agenda so that HPC 24-779 at 10 North Carroll Street can move forward to be the first item on the regular cases to be heard agenda following the consent agenda. Um HPC business, the commission can make such a motion.
openpublica.com