Historic and Environmental Preservation Board Meeting – September 1, 2026
Historic and Environmental Preservation Board Meeting – September 1, 2026
The Miami Historic and Environmental Preservation Board (HEP) held its regular meeting on September 1, 2026, to consider 11 agenda items including rescission of a historic designation, new construction, demolitions, and adoption of design guidelines. The board heard public testimony, deliberated on each item, and rendered decisions by roll-call votes. Key outcomes included approval of one rescission, denial of several demolitions, and a deferral for a controversial project in Palm Grove.
Public Comments & Testimony
- Elvis Cruz (631 NE 57th St) spoke on multiple items, urging preservation of historic structures and questioning the process of combining demolition and replacement considerations.
- Nora Schaefer (755 NE 70th St), a pioneer of the Morningside Historic District, opposed new construction in Bayside, arguing it is incompatible with the neighborhood’s 1920s character.
- Anthony Vinciguera (3325 Charles Ave) and Andy Parrish (3940 Main Hwy) testified against a new construction on Charles Avenue, citing non-compliance with Bahamian-style guidelines.
- Eileen Batari (505 NE 76th St) and Elisa Cepeda (531 NE 76th St) opposed demolitions in Palm Grove, emphasizing the importance of preserving contributing structures.
- Shane Graver (1001 NE 72nd St) supported the Bayside project after design improvements.
- Cindy Gage (555 NE 58th St) requested a fence for safety reasons in Morningside, while neighbors like Jeff King (546 NE 57th St) argued it violated historic guidelines.
- Richard Middle (6608 Santona St, Coral Gables) withdrew his demolition application for a Palm Grove property after board feedback.
Discussion Items
- Item 1 – Rescission of Little Havana House (1016 SW 13th Ct): The board debated the legal authority to rescind the designation given demolition-by-neglect provisions. After extensive discussion, the board approved rescission with conditions requiring a covenant to build a duplex incorporating historic elements. Vote: 8-0.
- Item 2 – New Construction on Charles Avenue (3448 Charles Ave): Staff recommended denial due to inconsistency with Bahamian-style guidelines. The board concurred, finding the design failed to address prior direction. Vote: 9-0 to recommend denial.
- Item 3 – New Construction in Bayside (765 NE 70th St): Staff changed its recommendation to approval with conditions after the applicant incorporated feedback (e.g., limestone band, planter). The board approved, with conditions to study a gable roof and extend a vertical accent. Vote: 9-0.
- Item 4 – Demolition in Buena Vista East (151 NE 42nd St): The applicant argued structural unsafety, but board members noted the property was a contributing structure and expressed skepticism about the engineering report. The board denied demolition. Vote: 9-0.
- Item 5 – Chickee Hut in MIMO (7240 Biscayne Blvd): Staff recommended approval; public supported. Approved with standard conditions. Vote: 7-0.
- Item 6 – Demolition and New Construction in Palm Grove (770 NE 5th Ave): Despite a detailed presentation, the board found the proposed three-story building overwhelming and out of context. The applicant requested an indefinite deferral, which was granted. Vote: 8-0.
- Item 7 – Demolition of Contributing Structure in Palm Grove (425 NE 77th St): After hearing from the applicant and public, the applicant withdrew the application, opting to pursue rehabilitation. No vote taken.
- Item 8 – Fence and Gates in Morningside (555 NE 58th St): Staff recommended denial based on guidelines prohibiting front-yard fences. A motion to approve failed 4-3, resulting in de facto denial.
- Item 9 – Asphalt Shingle Roof in Palm Grove (511 NE 65th St): The applicant cited financial hardship. The board approved a one-time exception on hardship grounds, allowing asphalt shingles. Vote: 8-0.
- Item 10 – Palm Grove Historic District Residential Guidelines: Staff presented updated guidelines incorporating community feedback. The board recommended approval to the City Commission. Vote: 7-0.
- Item 11 – 2027 Meeting Calendar: Approved. Vote: 6-1.
Key Outcomes
- Approvals: Rescission of Little Havana House (Item 1) with covenant; Bayside new construction (Item 3) with conditions; Chickee hut (Item 5); Palm Grove roof (Item 9) on hardship; 2027 calendar (Item 11); Palm Grove guidelines (Item 10).
- Denials: Charles Avenue new construction (Item 2); Buena Vista East demolition (Item 4); Morningside fence (Item 8).
- Deferral: Palm Grove demolition/new construction (Item 6) deferred indefinitely.
- Withdrawal: Palm Grove demolition (Item 7) withdrawn.
- All votes were recorded as roll calls; decisions are final unless appealed within 15 or 60 days as applicable.
Meeting Transcript
Be clearing up the lot as well as registering it with the city of Miami because it is now vacant and is no longer a structure on here and it's not being occupied. A lot like this is a hazardous to our neighborhood. It attracts illegal dumping, it attracts trash, stray animals, and it devalues the property values of the houses around us. As a reminder, if you so happen to own a vacant lot, it is to be registered with the city of Miami. By doing so, you can go on to our website under co-compliance. It will provide you all the steps that are needed to take. Scammers target consumers searching for company contact information online by purchasing fraudulent ads that look legitimate. When individuals click these ads or call the displayed numbers, they are unknowingly connected with scammers and share personal information. Victims often only realize they have been scammed weeks later. To protect yourself from online search scams, follow these tips. One, always use the phone number on your FPL bill instead of searching for contact information online. Two, check the URL for misspellings or extra characters. Three, look for the padlock icon, which indicates a secure connection. It happens more than you would think because scams are getting more elaborate. It can be difficult to tell what is a scam. These scammers know how to confuse you and take your information. Scammers are aggressively targeting utility company customers across Florida using sophisticated tactics to pocket quick cash. And it can happen to anyone. Even if the caller ID displays FPL's phone number and name. FPL will never call you and demand something immediately. An FPL employee will never call you and make you feel pressured to provide personal information. FPL will never demand immediate payment through an app like Zell or Venmo, a prepaid card or wire transfer to avoid service disconnection. FPL will never ask for personal information, such as account numbers or your social security number. We have heard of scammers that threaten to turn off power to your home or business within an hour if payment isn't made immediately, and they may even claim a truck is on the way. It's important to remember FPL would never do that. FPL does have energy experts who complete home energy surveys, but FPL will never solicit a customer by phone to offer home energy surveys. To spot a scam, you should know the process for late payments. FPL tries to be as flexible as possible, giving customers 21 days after the bill issue date to make a payment. If we do not receive payment past the 21 days, the balance is considered late, and a final notice is sent showing the amount due and a secondary due date. If payment is still not received, FPL will contact you by email regarding the payment. Shutting off someone's electricity is always our last resort. Although an FPL employee or contractor may knock on your door to inform you about projects in your area, such as undergrounding power lines, they will not try to sell you a product. Always ask to see the FPL employee or contractor's photo identification badge. If you have a scheduled appointment, ask for the work request number prior to letting a worker in your home. Contact the FPL Care Center or law enforcement if you think you have been a victim of a scam. It is rare that an FPL employee or contractor requires access inside your home or business. However, it's possible that an FPL employer contractor will require access to the meter on your property without an appointment or notice. In this case, ask to see their badge and call the number on your FPL bill if you wish to confirm the appointment. So what do you do if you think you have been scammed? The first thing you should do is contact your local police department to report the scam. It is also important that you report the suspected scam or fraud to FPL. Go online to FPL.com slash protect for more information. Click the link to report a scam. We know it can be difficult to tell when someone's trying to scam you. If you ever feel concerned, just hang up the phone or ask the person to leave. If you feel unsafe, call 911 and ask for help. You can find more information about how to protect yourself from scams on fpl.com slash protect. Comme substance danger and soti na fatois. J'étais la paire contaminée at Souscre. Pollution affecte santé ecosystem, de F des plant, Bit AC La Vie Aquatique.
openpublica.com