OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/New York City, New York/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Joint Oversight Hearing on Gender-Affirming Care Access and Mental Health for Transgender and Nonbinary Youth, September 23, 2026

City Council — Wednesday, September 23, 2026
BodyNew York City, New York
SessionCity Council
DateWednesday, September 23, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 3:04:09

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording.

Speaker 1

0:00

Substance use joint with joint with women, gender equity and hospitals.

0:04

At this time, I would like to remind everyone to silence all electronic devices.

0:09

Also at this point going forward, no women's approach to theirs.

0:12

No one.

0:13

Chair, we're ready to begin.

Speaker 2

0:20

Good afternoon, and welcome to today's hearing on access to gender affirming care and associated mental health outcomes for transgender and non-binary youth.

Unassigned speaker

0:29

My

Speaker 2

0:29

name is Councilmember Tiffany Kavan.

Unassigned speaker

0:31

My pronouns are she, her.

Speaker 2

0:32

I'm the chair of the New York City Council's Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use.

0:36

Thank you also to Councilmember Narcis, Chair of Hospitals Committee, and Councilmember Faries, Chair of Women and Gender Equity Committee for joining our committee in holding this hearing.

0:47

Before we begin, I'd like to recognize that we are joined by Public Advocate Jumani Williams, Councilmember Harvey Epstein, Councilmember Simkefelder, Councilmember Centus, and Councilmember Ariola on Zoom.

1:05

Today, the committees are convening to discuss access to gender affirming care in New York City and its role in improving health mental health care outcomes for transgender and non-binary youth.

1:14

It's no secret that transgender and non-binary New Yorkers have recently faced a barrage of threats, challenges, and intimidation from the federal government.

1:23

Several institutions in our city have, unfortunately, capitulated to these pressures, and as a city, we are all worse off for it.

1:32

Gender affirming care not only allows individuals to live as their true selves, but it is also strongly associated with improved mental health outcomes for transgender and non-binary people.

1:43

Transgender and non-binary youth, especially are disproportionately burdened by poor mental health outcomes, driven by reduced social support and heightened stigma and discrimination.

1:52

Yet research consistently shows that access to gender-affirming interventions is associated with roughly 60% lower odds of moderate to severe depression, and over 70% lower odds of suicidality in youth.

2:07

70% lower odds of suicidality.

2:43

Today, we will also be hearing three pieces of legislation relating to our oversight topic.

2:48

One, Introduction 949, sponsored by Councilmember Shulman, which would require the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene to create and make available on their website LGBTQI Plus Health and Gender Affirming Care Resources and a Searchable Map of LGBTQI Plus Health Services.

3:04

Resolution 208, sponsored by Councilmember Hanief, which calls on the New York State Legislature to pass and the governor to sign legislation that mandates all medical students in New York State receive anti-biased training.

3:15

And my own legislation, resolution 547, which calls on the New York State Legislature to pass and the governor to sign legislation which establishes a gender-affirming care access program to provide support and increase access to gender affirming care.

3:29

I would like to thank the committee staff who work to prepare for this hearing as well as my own staff.

3:33

And I will now pass the mic to Councilmember.

3:37

Oh, and we're joined by Councilmember Aldwall, and now I will pass it over to co-chair, um, Councilmember Narcis.

Speaker 3

3:44

Hi, good afternoon.

3:46

I am Councilmember Mercedes Narcisse, Chair of Committee on Hospital.

3:51

I'm joined by my colleagues, Councilmember Tiffany Caban, Chair of the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use, and Councilmember Amanda Ferallas, Chair of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity.

4:06

Thank you for joining us today for the for this oversight hearing on access to gender affirming care and associated with mental health outcomes for transgender and non-binary youth.

4:35

This type of care can include social affirmation like adopting gender, affirming hair, clothing, and names, or medical affirmations, such as puberty blockers, hormone therapy, and gender affirming surgeries.

Unassigned speaker

5:00

Transgender and non-binary youth experience significantly higher rates of anxiety, depression, mood disorders, and societal ideations than their cisgender peers, largely due to stigma, discrimination, and social rejection and barriers to care that this individual's experience.

Speaker 3

5:22

Research shows that access to gender affirming care can substantially improve mental health outcome for transgender and non-binary youth.

5:34

Despite local efforts to support, we know that the federal side is not on our side.

5:42

The federal government is taking actions to limit access to gender affirming care.

5:48

These actions at the federal level present challenges for health in hospital and DOHMH to continue providing the care that people need and deserve in our city.

6:01

As a registered nurse and a chair of a hospital committee, I am committed to ensure that every individual in our city get the care they deserve and needs to get through lives.

6:13

And what we need to do is continue pushing forward and making sure the bigotry around us, the policies that are not on our favors for us to continue addressing them.

6:27

And today we look forward to a hearing from New York City Health and Hospitals and DOHMH about the broader state of gender affirming care access for our youth across the city of New York, including their availability of services at H facilities, DOHMH, and the programs and other city supported efforts.

6:50

We also seek their feedback on legislation before the committee.

6:55

Together, we must work to ensure that transgender and non-binary youth have access to the care they deserve, and that our local hospital and health department can continue to provide such services.

7:10

Before we begin, I'd like to thank committee staff, senior legislative counsel, Ria Ogazarwa, a policy analyst, Manu Butt, as well as a committee brand new, brand new legislative analyst, Raina Lee.

7:26

Welcome for their hard work and preparing for this hearing.

7:31

I also like to thank my staff, um, Frank Shea, Courtney Lee, and of course um Joshina Jalo.

7:41

I would like to recognize that we have been John Whoells like we don't miss anybody.

7:47

You got everybody.

7:48

So I will now turn it over to Chair Ferrari.

Unassigned speaker

7:52

Thank you.

Speaker 4

7:52

Thank you so much.

7:53

Good afternoon, everyone.

7:54

I'm Council Member Amanda Farias, uh pronouns she, her, and I get to chair the Committee on Women and Gender Equity.

8:01

We're excited to join the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Abuse and the Committee on Hospitals and their chairs, Chair Caban and Chair Narcisse for today's oversight hearing on access to gender affirming care and associated mental health outcomes for transgender and non-binary youth.

8:16

As stated by my colleagues, access to gender affirming care is a life-saving medical necessity that dramatically improves the mental health and overall well-being of gender-diverse, transgender, and non-binary children and adolescents.

8:30

Every child deserves to grow up feeling supported in who they are.

8:33

And supporting transgender and non-binary youth means defending their right to health care.

8:39

Currently, access to gender-affirming care for young people is under attack nationwide.

8:44

An analysis by the human rights campaign found that 27 states plus Puerto Rico have successfully passed bans on gender-affirming care for transgender and non-binary youth affecting 48% of transgender youth nationwide.

8:57

A recent survey found that 87% of transgender and non-binary youth and young people whose used hormones to support their gender transition or expression were concerned about losing access to this care.

9:12

These laws interfere with the ability of transgender youth, their families, and their providers to make the health care decisions that are right for them and access the medical care they need and can have devastating consequences.

9:26

It is well documented that transgender and non-binary children experience anxiety and depression at higher rates than their cisgender peers, according to a 2025 survey published by the Trevor Project.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
LGBTQ+█████████████████████████████████████████████64%
Public Health████████████17%
Mental Health Awareness████████12%
Procedural█2%
Homelessness█2%
Pending Litigation█1%
Interagency Coordination█1%
Parks and Recreation█1%
Summary of Proceedings

Joint Oversight Hearing on Gender-Affirming Care Access and Mental Health for Transgender and Nonbinary Youth, September 23, 2026

The New York City Council Committees on Mental Health and Substance Use (Chair Tiffany L. Cabán), Hospitals (Chair Mercedes Narcisse), and Women and Gender Equity (Chair Amanda Farias) held a joint oversight hearing on Wednesday, September 23, 2026, at 1:00 PM in Council Chambers. The hearing examined access to gender-affirming care and its associated mental health outcomes for transgender and non-binary (TGNB) youth. The committees heard testimony from administration officials, advocates, healthcare providers, parents, and community members, and considered three pieces of related legislation.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Manhattan Borough President Brad Hoylman-Sigal expressed strong support for the oversight and legislative package. He discussed the SHIELD Law 2.0 and expressed alarm over hospital capitulations to federal subpoenas, urging the city to maintain its status as a safe haven.
  • Youth Advocates and Community Members (Nat Mogay, Tatiana Cruz, Ocean D. Waves, Filament Kind, Zev Frank, Ellis Jablonsky, Signes Pavo, Bianca Garcia, JJ Cleo Mizrahi, Suhaili Mendez) unanimously supported all three bills, emphasizing that gender-affirming care is life-saving suicide prevention. They detailed significant barriers to care including housing insecurity, cost, lack of culturally competent providers, and the psychological impact of provider capitulations. Several speakers shared personal stories of struggling to find care, having to educate their own providers, or experiencing the disruption of care by private hospitals.
  • Parents (Raina Bien, Kristen Clifford, Angelica Jadunandan) testified about their children losing care at private hospitals, having their medical records subpoenaed by the federal government, and the immense difficulty finding ongoing care, particularly for younger children needing puberty blockers. They expressed urgent support for expanded city services and the legislative package, with Ms. Clifford urging the city to attract and support more gender-affirming care practitioners.
  • Ren Galloway, Ali Forney Center, supported the legislation and urged the council to consider compounding barriers to care such as homelessness, immigration status, and access to sustainable mental health support.
  • Kimberly Blair, Girls for Gender Equity, supported the legislation, highlighting that an estimated one in five TGNCNBI youth report attempting suicide and that supportive environments cut attempt rates by over half.
  • Judith Goldiner, Legal Aid Society, supported the legislation but raised concerns that a public provider map could create risks for providers and patients.
  • NYCLU supported the legislation, recommending the definition of gender-affirming care in Res 547 be expanded to include mental health care and to explicitly exclude non-consensual surgeries on intersex individuals.
  • Andy Bowen, Queer Budget Center, supported the legislation and urged the city to use its contractual leverage over hospitals to compel continuation of gender-affirming care.

Discussion Items

  • Oversight of Gender-Affirming Care Access and Mental Health Outcomes (T2026-2350): Councilmembers Cabán, Narcisse, Farias, and Wilson questioned administration witnesses (Director Taylor Brown, Assistant Commissioner Marnie Davidoff, Dr. Andrew Wallach, Dr. Omar Fital) on the evidence base for care, city efforts, and gaps in the system. The administration affirmed that access to gender-affirming care is a suicide prevention strategy, citing studies including a 72% increase in suicide attempts in states with anti-trans laws and a 2023 NYC Youth Risk Behavior Survey showing TGNB youth reported suicidal ideation at rates of 28-45% compared to 16% for cisgender peers. They outlined a $15 million, three-year investment to support providers, launch a dedicated call/chat line, and fund research. NYC Health + Hospitals confirmed they have not changed their scope of practice and are expanding capacity to meet increased demand via their existing Pride Health Centers and telehealth services, inviting patients to call 1-844-NYC-4-NYC.
  • Int 0949-2026 (Councilmember Shulman): This bill would require the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DOHMH) to create and maintain a website with LGBTQI+ health resources and a searchable map of services. DOHMH expressed general support for the bill but noted operational details to discuss. Multiple public speakers supported the intent but flagged significant privacy and safety concerns for providers listed on a public map given the current political climate.
  • Res 0208-2026 (Councilmember Hanif): This resolution calls on New York State to mandate anti-bias training for all medical students. The resolution received broad support from all testifiers.
  • Res 0547-2026 / 0547-A (Councilmember Cabán): This resolution calls on New York State to establish a gender-affirming care access program. The committee proposed and accepted an amendment to the resolution. Speakers were broadly supportive, with NYCLU recommending the definition of care be expanded to fully align with state law.

Key Outcomes

  • T2026-2350: This Oversight was Hearing Held by Committee. This Oversight was Filed by Committee.
  • Int 0949-2026: This Introduction was Hearing Held by Committee. This Introduction was Laid Over by Committee.
  • Res 0208-2026: This Resolution was Hearing Held by Committee. This Resolution was Laid Over by Committee.
  • Res 0547-2026: This Resolution was Hearing Held by Committee. This Resolution was Amendment Proposed by Committee. This Resolution was Amended by Committee.
  • Res 0547-2026-A: This Resolution was Laid Over by Committee.
  • The public record was held open for 72 hours following the hearing to accept additional written testimony.

Meeting Transcript

Substance use joint with joint with women, gender equity and hospitals. At this time, I would like to remind everyone to silence all electronic devices. Also at this point going forward, no women's approach to theirs. No one. Chair, we're ready to begin. Good afternoon, and welcome to today's hearing on access to gender affirming care and associated mental health outcomes for transgender and non-binary youth. My name is Councilmember Tiffany Kavan. My pronouns are she, her. I'm the chair of the New York City Council's Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use. Thank you also to Councilmember Narcis, Chair of Hospitals Committee, and Councilmember Faries, Chair of Women and Gender Equity Committee for joining our committee in holding this hearing. Before we begin, I'd like to recognize that we are joined by Public Advocate Jumani Williams, Councilmember Harvey Epstein, Councilmember Simkefelder, Councilmember Centus, and Councilmember Ariola on Zoom. Today, the committees are convening to discuss access to gender affirming care in New York City and its role in improving health mental health care outcomes for transgender and non-binary youth. It's no secret that transgender and non-binary New Yorkers have recently faced a barrage of threats, challenges, and intimidation from the federal government. Several institutions in our city have, unfortunately, capitulated to these pressures, and as a city, we are all worse off for it. Gender affirming care not only allows individuals to live as their true selves, but it is also strongly associated with improved mental health outcomes for transgender and non-binary people. Transgender and non-binary youth, especially are disproportionately burdened by poor mental health outcomes, driven by reduced social support and heightened stigma and discrimination. Yet research consistently shows that access to gender-affirming interventions is associated with roughly 60% lower odds of moderate to severe depression, and over 70% lower odds of suicidality in youth. 70% lower odds of suicidality. Today, we will also be hearing three pieces of legislation relating to our oversight topic. One, Introduction 949, sponsored by Councilmember Shulman, which would require the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene to create and make available on their website LGBTQI Plus Health and Gender Affirming Care Resources and a Searchable Map of LGBTQI Plus Health Services. Resolution 208, sponsored by Councilmember Hanief, which calls on the New York State Legislature to pass and the governor to sign legislation that mandates all medical students in New York State receive anti-biased training. And my own legislation, resolution 547, which calls on the New York State Legislature to pass and the governor to sign legislation which establishes a gender-affirming care access program to provide support and increase access to gender affirming care. I would like to thank the committee staff who work to prepare for this hearing as well as my own staff. And I will now pass the mic to Councilmember. Oh, and we're joined by Councilmember Aldwall, and now I will pass it over to co-chair, um, Councilmember Narcis. Hi, good afternoon. I am Councilmember Mercedes Narcisse, Chair of Committee on Hospital. I'm joined by my colleagues, Councilmember Tiffany Caban, Chair of the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use, and Councilmember Amanda Ferallas, Chair of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity. Thank you for joining us today for the for this oversight hearing on access to gender affirming care and associated with mental health outcomes for transgender and non-binary youth. This type of care can include social affirmation like adopting gender, affirming hair, clothing, and names, or medical affirmations, such as puberty blockers, hormone therapy, and gender affirming surgeries. Transgender and non-binary youth experience significantly higher rates of anxiety, depression, mood disorders, and societal ideations than their cisgender peers, largely due to stigma, discrimination, and social rejection and barriers to care that this individual's experience. Research shows that access to gender affirming care can substantially improve mental health outcome for transgender and non-binary youth. Despite local efforts to support, we know that the federal side is not on our side. The federal government is taking actions to limit access to gender affirming care. These actions at the federal level present challenges for health in hospital and DOHMH to continue providing the care that people need and deserve in our city. As a registered nurse and a chair of a hospital committee, I am committed to ensure that every individual in our city get the care they deserve and needs to get through lives. And what we need to do is continue pushing forward and making sure the bigotry around us, the policies that are not on our favors for us to continue addressing them. And today we look forward to a hearing from New York City Health and Hospitals and DOHMH about the broader state of gender affirming care access for our youth across the city of New York, including their availability of services at H facilities, DOHMH, and the programs and other city supported efforts. We also seek their feedback on legislation before the committee. Together, we must work to ensure that transgender and non-binary youth have access to the care they deserve, and that our local hospital and health department can continue to provide such services. Before we begin, I'd like to thank committee staff, senior legislative counsel, Ria Ogazarwa, a policy analyst, Manu Butt, as well as a committee brand new, brand new legislative analyst, Raina Lee. Welcome for their hard work and preparing for this hearing. I also like to thank my staff, um, Frank Shea, Courtney Lee, and of course um Joshina Jalo. I would like to recognize that we have been John Whoells like we don't miss anybody. You got everybody. So I will now turn it over to Chair Ferrari. Thank you. Thank you so much. Good afternoon, everyone.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com