OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/New York City, New York/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Oversight Hearing on Construction Safety – October 21, 2026

City Council — Wednesday, October 21, 2026
BodyNew York City, New York
SessionCity Council
DateWednesday, October 21, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 2:32:09

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording.

Speaker 1

0:05

Good morning and welcome to New York City Council hearing on community and housing and building.

0:11

At this time, we are asking everyone to send all electronic devices.

0:15

And at no point in time in this hearing, anyone should approach CDAs.

0:19

If you wish to testify in today's hearing and have a appearance card, please do so with us at the

Unassigned speaker

0:24

back.

Speaker 1

0:25

Chair, you may begin.

Speaker 2

0:27

Thank you, Sergeant, and good morning.

0:29

I'm Councilmember Pierina Sanchez, Chair of the Committee on Housing and Buildings.

0:33

On behalf of the committee and the New York City Council, I'd like to welcome all the members of the public and the administration who have joined us this morning.

0:41

Before I begin, I just want to acknowledge that we are joined by council members Maloney and Riley.

0:47

New York City is home to more than one million buildings and 40,000 active construction sites at any moment.

0:54

The chief agency overseeing this work and the city's construction industry is the Department of Buildings.

0:59

The Department of Buildings plays a critical role in enforcing the rules and regulations that keep the tenants, small businesses, and workers across those one million buildings safe.

1:09

When a new building is constructed or an existing building undergoes renovation work, the public should have confidence that this work is being conducted with the utmost integrity and that the working conditions on construction sites are safe for every person involved.

1:24

Importantly, we have some of the most rigorous construction safety standards in the world, and they are up to date.

1:30

The construction codes we have in effect are just from 2022.

1:35

But our standards only protect the public when the enforcement agency is staffed, resourced, and able to ensure that developers, contractors, and professionals are following the rules.

1:45

So today we'll take a closer look at DOB's ongoing efforts to advance construction safety.

1:51

We've seen recent encouraging trends in the data in fiscal year 2026.

1:55

The mayor's management reports noted a 45% decrease in serious or fatal construction injuries, which is down from 557 to 308.

2:07

Of those serious injuries, falls remained the leading cause over the past two years.

2:12

And while the overall decline signifies can signify real progress, more can be done to identify the persistent causes of both serious injuries and deaths on construction sites.

2:24

Deaths which consistently hover around eight per year.

2:29

And I have to add that while these numbers seems positive, the trends have also zigzagged up and down since 2022 during my tenure as housing chair, and my usual optimism has a little pause.

Unassigned speaker

2:43

In

Speaker 2

2:43

the same way that New York City seeks to prevent all traffic fatalities through the Vision Zero initiative, we should use a similar data-driven approach to eliminate construction-related deaths entirely.

2:54

Recent high profile incidents also highlight the need for continued evaluation of our city's construction safety standards.

3:00

The buckling of two load-bearing columns in the 21st floor of the former Pfizer headquarters in Midtown raised significant concerns about whether corners were cut, which unsafe conditions were first identified, what scope of work was approved, how the city can ensure this never happens again.

3:17

I'm thankful for DOB's swift response to ensure the safety of all of the New Yorkers in the surrounding area.

3:24

But the incident was serious enough to prompt a citywide enforcement blitz from the department, the result of which we will also be wanting to discuss during today's hearing.

3:34

On a related note, we will also receive an implementation update for legislation that we championed here in this committee, local law 79 of 2024, which created a new requirement for proactive enforcement at Department of Buildings.

3:48

Additionally, a recent indictment from the Brooklyn District Attorney's Office raises concerns about the oversight of safety site safety training credentials.

3:57

Last month, the Brooklyn DA charged two individuals and the related company, Red Code Inc., for creating and selling fraudulent site safety cards to construction workers.

4:07

Although the company was authorized to provide site safety trainings, the DA alleged that they sold cards to construction workers who never completed that training.

4:17

We must ensure that all workers are appropriately trained and continue to improve the city's tools for overseeing the companies that fake safety credentials.

4:28

Excuse me, finally,

Unassigned speaker

4:30

I

Speaker 2

4:30

would be remiss if I didn't end with my continued concerns around staffing within the agency.

4:34

In my time as chair of the Committee on Housing and Buildings, have repeatedly raised concerns about DOB staffing.

4:40

Under the prior administration, DOB eliminated roughly a quarter of its budgeted workforce, including positions tied to inspections and safety oversight.

4:50

And while the council has fought year over year to recover positions, even in the most recent fiscal year, DOB's enforcement division saw a reduction of 16 positions, including seven inspectoral titles.

5:03

So I will continue to push for inspectorial and safety agency, excuse me, and safety capacity that the agency needs.

5:10

I look forward to hearing more about the administration's approach to construction safety, implementation of recent council legislation, and further opportunities to collaborate toward our shared goal of keeping New Yorkers safe.

5:21

I'd like to take this opportunity to thank my team, Deputy Chiefs of Staff, Ben Ratner and Ken Kim Castellanos,

Unassigned speaker

5:28

our

Speaker 2

5:29

District Director Maria José Mares, Gerard Fernandez, Soraya Bonilla, Oriana Jroa Acevedo, Malia Sardinia.

5:36

Welcome to our new fellow and Marcus Connor intern.

5:39

I'd also like to thank the Housing and Buildings Committee staff, senior legislative council Austin Malone, legislative council Billy Eck, senior, not SILIER, senior policy analyst Jose Conde, Senior Policy Analyst Dirk Spencer, data scientists Mohamed Shadid and Noah Slosberg, and finance analyst Carla Naranjo and Spencer Kuhn.

6:02

And with that, thank you all for being here today.

6:04

I'm going to turn it over to our council to administer the oath.

Speaker 3

6:11

Please raise your right hand to your firm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, and to answer all council member questions honestly.

Speaker 4

6:18

I do.

Speaker 3

6:18

Thank you.

6:19

You may begin when ready.

6:21

Thank you.

Unassigned speaker

6:22

Good

Speaker 4

6:23

morning, Chair Sanchez and members of the Committee on Housing and Buildings.

6:26

I am Ahmed Tagani, Commissioner of the New York City Department of Buildings.

6:30

I am joined today by Igal Shamash, First Deputy Commissioner, Guillermo Patino, Deputy Commissioner of Policy and Legal Affairs, and several members of the department's leadership team.

6:41

Thank you for holding this hearing on the critical issue of construction safety.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Engineering And Infrastructure█████████████████████████████████33%
Public Safety████████████████████████████████32%
Construction Safety███████████████15%
Procedural████████8%
Technology and Innovation████4%
Public Engagement████4%
Mental Health Awareness██2%
Licensing and Oversight██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Oversight Hearing on Construction Safety – October 21, 2026

This oversight hearing by the Committee on Housing and Buildings examined the Department of Buildings' (DOB) approach to construction safety, including enforcement, proactive inspections, training, and technology. Chair Pierina Ana Sanchez highlighted a 45% decrease in serious or fatal construction injuries in FY2026 but noted persistent fatalities averaging eight per year. The hearing covered recent high-profile incidents, the implementation of Local Law 79 (proactive inspections), fraudulent site safety training cards, and staffing concerns.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Samuel Eluto (Building Trades Employment Association) urged the Council to amend Local Law 196 to allow employers to verify SST cards by ID ahead of time, citing scaling issues with daily tap checks, and called for expanding the pipeline of construction superintendents.
  • Alex Lay (community resident) testified about unsafe conditions at a Sandu Group development (2501 86th Street), including asbestos found after demolition began and flood zone plan inconsistencies, urging stronger DOB oversight.
  • Rochelle Thompson (senior tenant) raised concerns about landlord harassment, lack of legal representation, and lack of building repair reports, though her testimony was partially ruled off-topic as not directly related to construction safety.
  • Kyle Ems (remote) sought transparency on a $359 million tax exemption for affordable housing preservation, but this was noted as off-topic; Chair Sanchez promised follow-up.

Discussion Items

  • Construction Safety Statistics & Trends: DOB reported 266 construction-related injuries (as of Sept 2026) and 4 fatalities year-to-date. Falls remain the leading cause. Chair Sanchez noted persistent fatality numbers (6-10 per year since FY2022) and called for a Vision Zero-style approach.
  • Pfizer Headquarters Partial Collapse (July 2026): DOB conducted an enforcement sweep of 180 sites, issuing 71 violations and 19 stop work orders. The investigation is ongoing with law enforcement; no structural concerns found in sweeps.
  • Local Law 79 (2024) Implementation: DOB’s proactive inspection program grew to 33% of all enforcement inspections (54,226 proactive in FY2026 as of Sept), resulting in 14,161 violations at 13,092 unique locations since Jan 2025. Predictive analytics are used to target high-risk buildings.
  • Fraudulent Site Safety Training Cards (Red Code Inc.): DOB revoked the company’s status after a Brooklyn DA indictment; 2,000 active SST cards invalidated. SBS launched a free remediation program with multilingual outreach (Bengali).
  • Staffing & Inspector Capacity: DOB has 609 active inspectors (430 dedicated to construction enforcement), with an 8% vacancy rate. Enforcement inspectors average 5-7 inspections per day. Chair Sanchez noted a reduction of 16 enforcement positions in FY2026.
  • Smaller Sites & Worker Falls: Of eight FY2026 fatalities, only two required a construction superintendent. Falls caused 163 of 320 injuries (2025). DOB’s fall prevention campaign included a December sweep with 50 stop work orders.
  • Sidewalk Sheds & Scaffolding: Shed count dropped from ~8,000 to 6,861 since January (15% decrease). New 90-day permits and upcoming civil penalties for sheds over 180 days aim to reduce prolonged sidewalk obstructions. New designs displayed at 280 Broadway.
  • After-Hours Work Variances: DOB noted limited enforcement capacity for after-hours violations, relying on coordinated inspections and community reports.
  • Safety Logs: DOB reviewed safety logs at 32,004 sites in FY2026, issuing 260 summonses for missing or falsified logs. Digital logs are now permitted.
  • Mayor’s Committee on Construction Safety: Invitations sent for a November 2026 launch, focusing on root causes of injuries, enforcement gaps, and technology. Chair Sanchez invited to participate.
  • AECR Task Force: Parallel code reform task force to streamline development without compromising safety.

Key Outcomes

  • No votes were taken; the hearing was informational.
  • DOB committed to follow up on several data requests: breakdown of inspection types, stop work order enforcement metrics, after-hour variance numbers, and site classification data.
  • DOB will provide a written response to Councilmember Zhuang’s concerns on flood zone approvals and developer compliance.
  • Chair Sanchez will participate in the Mayor’s Committee on Construction Safety.
  • The committee will continue oversight on proactive inspection implementation and SST card verification improvements.

Meeting Transcript

Good morning and welcome to New York City Council hearing on community and housing and building. At this time, we are asking everyone to send all electronic devices. And at no point in time in this hearing, anyone should approach CDAs. If you wish to testify in today's hearing and have a appearance card, please do so with us at the back. Chair, you may begin. Thank you, Sergeant, and good morning. I'm Councilmember Pierina Sanchez, Chair of the Committee on Housing and Buildings. On behalf of the committee and the New York City Council, I'd like to welcome all the members of the public and the administration who have joined us this morning. Before I begin, I just want to acknowledge that we are joined by council members Maloney and Riley. New York City is home to more than one million buildings and 40,000 active construction sites at any moment. The chief agency overseeing this work and the city's construction industry is the Department of Buildings. The Department of Buildings plays a critical role in enforcing the rules and regulations that keep the tenants, small businesses, and workers across those one million buildings safe. When a new building is constructed or an existing building undergoes renovation work, the public should have confidence that this work is being conducted with the utmost integrity and that the working conditions on construction sites are safe for every person involved. Importantly, we have some of the most rigorous construction safety standards in the world, and they are up to date. The construction codes we have in effect are just from 2022. But our standards only protect the public when the enforcement agency is staffed, resourced, and able to ensure that developers, contractors, and professionals are following the rules. So today we'll take a closer look at DOB's ongoing efforts to advance construction safety. We've seen recent encouraging trends in the data in fiscal year 2026. The mayor's management reports noted a 45% decrease in serious or fatal construction injuries, which is down from 557 to 308. Of those serious injuries, falls remained the leading cause over the past two years. And while the overall decline signifies can signify real progress, more can be done to identify the persistent causes of both serious injuries and deaths on construction sites. Deaths which consistently hover around eight per year. And I have to add that while these numbers seems positive, the trends have also zigzagged up and down since 2022 during my tenure as housing chair, and my usual optimism has a little pause. In the same way that New York City seeks to prevent all traffic fatalities through the Vision Zero initiative, we should use a similar data-driven approach to eliminate construction-related deaths entirely. Recent high profile incidents also highlight the need for continued evaluation of our city's construction safety standards. The buckling of two load-bearing columns in the 21st floor of the former Pfizer headquarters in Midtown raised significant concerns about whether corners were cut, which unsafe conditions were first identified, what scope of work was approved, how the city can ensure this never happens again. I'm thankful for DOB's swift response to ensure the safety of all of the New Yorkers in the surrounding area. But the incident was serious enough to prompt a citywide enforcement blitz from the department, the result of which we will also be wanting to discuss during today's hearing. On a related note, we will also receive an implementation update for legislation that we championed here in this committee, local law 79 of 2024, which created a new requirement for proactive enforcement at Department of Buildings. Additionally, a recent indictment from the Brooklyn District Attorney's Office raises concerns about the oversight of safety site safety training credentials. Last month, the Brooklyn DA charged two individuals and the related company, Red Code Inc., for creating and selling fraudulent site safety cards to construction workers. Although the company was authorized to provide site safety trainings, the DA alleged that they sold cards to construction workers who never completed that training. We must ensure that all workers are appropriately trained and continue to improve the city's tools for overseeing the companies that fake safety credentials. Excuse me, finally, I would be remiss if I didn't end with my continued concerns around staffing within the agency. In my time as chair of the Committee on Housing and Buildings, have repeatedly raised concerns about DOB staffing. Under the prior administration, DOB eliminated roughly a quarter of its budgeted workforce, including positions tied to inspections and safety oversight. And while the council has fought year over year to recover positions, even in the most recent fiscal year, DOB's enforcement division saw a reduction of 16 positions, including seven inspectoral titles. So I will continue to push for inspectorial and safety agency, excuse me, and safety capacity that the agency needs. I look forward to hearing more about the administration's approach to construction safety, implementation of recent council legislation, and further opportunities to collaborate toward our shared goal of keeping New Yorkers safe. I'd like to take this opportunity to thank my team, Deputy Chiefs of Staff, Ben Ratner and Ken Kim Castellanos, our District Director Maria José Mares, Gerard Fernandez, Soraya Bonilla, Oriana Jroa Acevedo, Malia Sardinia. Welcome to our new fellow and Marcus Connor intern. I'd also like to thank the Housing and Buildings Committee staff, senior legislative council Austin Malone, legislative council Billy Eck, senior, not SILIER, senior policy analyst Jose Conde, Senior Policy Analyst Dirk Spencer, data scientists Mohamed Shadid and Noah Slosberg, and finance analyst Carla Naranjo and Spencer Kuhn. And with that, thank you all for being here today. I'm going to turn it over to our council to administer the oath.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com