OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/New York City, New York/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

NYC Council Joint Hearing on Office of Community Safety and Violence Reduction (Oct 30, 2026)

City Council — Friday, October 30, 2026
BodyNew York City, New York
SessionCity Council
DateFriday, October 30, 2026
StatusNEW · FILED
Video Record
0:00 / 5:01:39

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording.

Speaker 1

0:09

Hello, good afternoon.

0:11

Welcome to today's New York City Council hearing for the Committee on Public Safety, joint with General Governmental Operations, State and Federal Legislation.

0:22

At this time, please silence all phones.

0:25

If you wish to speak in today's hearing, please fill out an appearance card with one of the sergeants.

0:30

Moving forward, no one is to approach the day.

0:34

Chair, you may begin.

Speaker 2

0:39

Good afternoon, everyone.

0:40

I'm Councilmember Azult Felice, Chair of the Committee on Public Safety.

0:45

Good afternoon, and welcome to today's hearing on the Office of Community Safety.

0:50

At today's hearing, we'll examine the newly created Office of Community Safety and other nonpolice solutions to reduce violence.

0:57

I would like to thank Council Member and Co-Chair Gil Brewer and the Committee of Government Operations for co-chairing today's hearing.

1:04

And I'd also like to acknowledge members who have joined us, including Speaker Julie Menon, Public Advocate Jumani Williams, Council Members Riley, Wong, Morano, Nurse, and Wilson.

1:16

Before I begin my opening statement, I'd like to pass it on to Speaker Julie Menon.

Speaker 3

1:21

Thank you, Chair.

1:22

And I want to welcome everyone to today's committee hearing.

1:26

I'm Julie Menon, Speaker of the New York City Council.

1:28

Let me begin by thanking Chair Feliz and Chair Brewer, chairs of these committees for convening this very important oversight hearing on the Office of Community Safety and Nonpolice Solutions to Reducing Violence.

1:41

We will also be hearing three pieces of legislation that the chairs will discuss shortly.

1:47

A crucial aspect of community safety is establishing and fostering trust between government and the people it serves.

1:54

That trust is earned over time through transparency through ensuring impacted New Yorkers have a seat at the table, and mostly through proven results.

2:03

This past March, the mayor established an Office of Community Safety tasked with developing citywide community safety strategies and to supervise and coordinate the work of mayoral offices that operate in furtherance of community safety, including crime and violence prevention initiatives, victim assistant services, and community mental health services.

2:26

As part of the establishment of OCS, five existing mayoral offices moved under its umbrella.

2:33

The Office of Crime Victim Services, the Office for the Prevention of Hate Crimes, the Office of Community Mental Health, the Office to End Domestic and Gender Based Violence, the Office for Neighborhood Safety and the Prevention of Gun Violence.

2:50

All of them were previously independent offices.

2:53

Some have existed for over a decade.

2:56

So it's important for us to come away from today's hearing with a greater understanding of why the offices were shifted from operating independently to being managed by the new OCS.

3:06

We also want to learn which advocates were consulted before the change was made, and whether those organizations that have been working in these spaces for years are part um of the decision making moving forward.

3:20

Certain providers have contacted us and have uh testified at prior hearings, particularly a hearing we held in the gender equity committee about the move of the office to end domestic and gender-based violence and voiced a concern at our hearing.

3:35

Safe Horizons CEO Liz Roberts

Unassigned speaker

3:37

said

Speaker 3

3:37

that she was concerned that they had not been contacted prior to the restructuring and Sanctuary for Families, specifically said that the move occurred without meaningful collaboration.

3:51

So one of the goals we have today is to understand what can happen moving forward to increase that level of collaboration and make sure that those organizations have a seat at the table.

4:02

Most importantly, um, we want to understand the overarching goal of the office and what approach that it plans on taking moving forward.

4:10

Um we do want to say that the goal of keeping New Yorkers safe is obviously incredibly important.

4:16

We are concerned that compared to 2025, reported rapes have increased nearly 4%.

Unassigned speaker

4:23

Uh,

Speaker 3

4:23

subway felony assaults have climbed by 11%, and hate crimes are up 13%.

4:29

Um these are all questions that we plan on asking, and we look forward to having a really fulsome uh hearing and conversation, and I'll turn it back over to the chair for his opening statement.

4:40

Thank you.

Speaker 2

4:41

Thank you, Speaker.

4:43

Earlier this year, New York City Mayor Mamdani issued executive order number 15, which established the Office of Community Safety known as OCS.

4:52

Broadly tasked with developing citywide community safety initiatives.

Unassigned speaker

5:00

OCS is also empowered to supervise and coordinate the work of five existing mayoral offices that operate with similar safety related goals.

Speaker 2

5:05

These offices are the Office for Neighborhood Safety and Prevention of Gun Violence, the Office of Community Mental Health, the Office to End Domestic and Gender Based Violence, the Office for Prevention of Hate Crimes, and the Office for Crime Victim Services.

5:21

The executive order also directs OCS to coordinate citywide mental health crisis response programs, including the BeHerd program, an emergency response initiatives that sends teams of mental health practitioners to certain mental health emergency calls.

5:37

Today's hearing is an opportunity for the council to examine the administration's plan and vision for the newly created Office of Community Safety to better understand what OCS has accomplished since it was since it was established, learn about how OCS plans to coordinate the work of the five offices under its jurisdiction and other city agencies as well, including our New York City Police Department.

6:01

The council also wants to know what changes have been made to existing programs and how OCS will measure whether its efforts are improving safety and connecting New Yorkers with needed services.

6:14

Through today's hearing, the committee seeks a clear understanding of OCS's authority, staffing, budget, and plans for the future.

6:23

Establishing an office is one step.

6:26

We need to know what it is doing, how is it working with the agencies and organizations responsible for delivering services, and what measurable results the city expects to achieve.

6:36

Two specific areas of OCS's work that I plan to closely examine include how we're responding to mental health emergencies and the crisis management system, which operates anti-violence initiatives citywide.

Unassigned speaker

6:51

The

Speaker 2

6:51

committees will also examine how OCS is working with community-based organizations that deliver violence prevention services, notably via the crisis management system, which relies on community members and violence interrupters to mediate conflicts, connect people with services, and help prevent violence.

7:09

We want to understand how OCS is supporting these efforts, how it evaluates their effectiveness, and whether existing programs have the resources and coordination needed to reach the communities they serve.

7:21

Public safety is one of the most important responsibilities of city government, and we have to continue to explore new initiatives, but at the same time we have to make sure that they're effective.

7:30

So I look forward to a conversation on these new initiatives and this new office.

7:34

Finally, the committees will hear related legislation, specifically two bills being heard by the public safety committee.

7:40

Introduction number 414, sponsored by Councilmember Riley, which would require the city to establish a three-digit emergency hotline known as the gun violence intervention hotline to aid individuals seeking assistance with mental health and supportive services and programs related to gun violence intervention.

7:57

And introduction number 667, sponsored by Councilmember Williams, which will require that judges at the oath offer the option to complete community service in lieu of paying civil penalties for violations given for proper disposal of garbage.

Unassigned speaker

8:12

I

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Public Safety█████████████████████████████████████████████54%
Mental Health Awareness█████████11%
Youth Programs██████7%
Gun Violence█████6%
Domestic Violence███3%
Hate Crime Prevention███3%
Public Health███3%
Community Engagement██2%
Procedural██2%
Summary of Proceedings

NYC Council Joint Committee Hearing on the Office of Community Safety and Violence Reduction (October 30, 2026)

The New York City Council Committees on Public Safety and Governmental Operations held a joint oversight hearing on October 30, 2026, to examine the newly established Office of Community Safety (OCS) and non-police violence reduction strategies. The hearing, chaired by Councilmember Oswald J. Feliz (Public Safety) and Councilmember Gale A. Brewer (Government Operations), included testimony on three proposed local laws: Int. 0403 to create a Department of Community Safety, Int. 0414 to establish a gun violence intervention hotline, and Int. 0667 regarding community service for littering violations. The meeting featured opening statements from Speaker Julie Menon, Public Advocate Jumani Williams, and bill sponsors, followed by a detailed panel with OCS Commissioner Dr. Aisha Delaney Brumsey and her team, and concluded with extensive public testimony.

Consent Calendar

  • No items were approved under a consent calendar. The oversight item (T2026-2701) was "Filed" by the committee, and all three introduced bills were "Laid Over," meaning no vote was taken and they remain under consideration for future action.

Public Comments & Testimony

Approximately 60 individuals registered to testify in person and via Zoom. The overwhelming majority expressed support for the creation of a permanent Department of Community Safety while offering significant input on its structure.

  • Community-Based Organizations (Support with Conditions): Groups like the Center for Anti-Violence Education, the People's Plan, the Muslim Community Network, the Rise Project, the Legal Aid Society, the NYCLU, and the NAACP Legal Defense Fund urged the council to ensure legislation (Int. 0403) focused on establishing the department in law rather than prescribing specific operational details like safety patrols or borough offices. They argued for a community-driven planning process.
  • School and Youth Safety Advocates: Organizations such as the Dignity in Schools Campaign, Girls for Gender Equity, and the YAYA Network called for OCS's mission to explicitly include school safety, youth mental health, restorative justice, and a transition away from school-based policing and surveillance.
  • Hate Violence Prevention Testimony: The Jewish Community Relations Council (JCRC), the Arab American Association of New York, the Anti-Violence Project, and the Wagner College Holocaust Center detailed the success of community-based hate crime prevention (PATH initiative) and requested sustained investment.
  • Personal and Constituent Testimony: Speakers including Conrad Blackburn (Bronx Defenders), Christina Sparrich, and Ruth Lohencron shared personal stories of police escalation during mental health crises, emphasizing the need for civilian-led, peer-based crisis response and the passage of Daniel's Law to remove police from crisis response.
  • Opposition: One speaker, Christopher Leon Johnson, opposed the bills, arguing for increased police presence and questioning the effectiveness of Cure Violence programs.

Discussion Items

  • Oversight of the Office of Community Safety (OCS): Commissioner Brumsey testified that OCS operates on a $271 million budget, with $67 million in new resources, and oversees five offices with about 100 staff. Council members scrutinized the high vacancy rate (25.3%) in the Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence (NGBV) and the initial staffing (3 employees) of the Office for the Prevention of Hate Crimes (OPHC).
  • Mental Health Crisis Response (BHERD Program): Major focus was placed on BHERD. OCS reported responding to 8,524 out of 10,945 eligible calls in FY26, a fraction of the 150,000 total mental health 911 calls. Council members raised concerns about the lack of 24/7 service, the reliance on EMS, and the absence of comprehensive data tracking repeat calls or long-term outcomes for individuals served. Chair Brewer highlighted the lack of appropriate facilities ("somewhere to go") for patients after crisis stabilization.
  • Violence Prevention and CMS: OCS reported a 16% decline in shooting incidents year-over-year and that the Crisis Management System (CMS) conducted 14,232 mediations. Councilmember Morano challenged OCS to identify specific public safety improvements directly attributable to the creation of OCS rather than pre-existing programs. Discussion also covered the transfer of CMS contracts from DYCD to OCS and ensuring timely payments to community providers.
  • Coordination with NYPD: Public Advocate Williams questioned the depth of OCS's integration, noting the lack of regular high-level meetings with the Police Commissioner and non-attendance at CompStat meetings. OCS stated that operational coordination happens daily but acknowledged a need for stronger strategic partnership.
  • Legislation:
    • Int 0403 (Department of Community Safety): Councilmember Resler stated the bill has 34 co-sponsors. OCS expressed support for its goal and committed to working with the council on amendments. Public testimony was largely supportive but requested the bill avoid prescriptive details.
    • Int 0414 (Gun Violence Intervention Hotline): Councilmember Riley provided emotional testimony about a recent youth shooting (15-year-old Javis Frimpong) to urge action. OCS supported the intent but noted federal authorization is required for a new three-digit number and suggested leveraging existing resources like 988 and the Hope Hotline.
    • Int 0667 (Community Service for Littering): Mentioned in Chair Feliz's opening, this bill received minimal substantive discussion during the hearing.

Key Outcomes

  • Hearing Held: The committees successfully held the hearing and received testimony on the oversight and all three bills.
  • Bills Laid Over: Int. 0403, Int. 0414, and Int. 0667 were all laid over by the committees, indicating further negotiation and revision before a potential vote.
  • Continued Oversight and Directives: Council members expressed a strong intent to continue scrutinizing OCS, particularly regarding operational metrics, BHERD expansion, and coordination with NYPD. OCS committed to providing the council with a breakdown of its personnel vs. programmatic budget. Chair Feliz formally requested that OCS consider establishing a field headquarters in a community highly impacted by violence, such as the Bronx.

Meeting Transcript

Hello, good afternoon. Welcome to today's New York City Council hearing for the Committee on Public Safety, joint with General Governmental Operations, State and Federal Legislation. At this time, please silence all phones. If you wish to speak in today's hearing, please fill out an appearance card with one of the sergeants. Moving forward, no one is to approach the day. Chair, you may begin. Good afternoon, everyone. I'm Councilmember Azult Felice, Chair of the Committee on Public Safety. Good afternoon, and welcome to today's hearing on the Office of Community Safety. At today's hearing, we'll examine the newly created Office of Community Safety and other nonpolice solutions to reduce violence. I would like to thank Council Member and Co-Chair Gil Brewer and the Committee of Government Operations for co-chairing today's hearing. And I'd also like to acknowledge members who have joined us, including Speaker Julie Menon, Public Advocate Jumani Williams, Council Members Riley, Wong, Morano, Nurse, and Wilson. Before I begin my opening statement, I'd like to pass it on to Speaker Julie Menon. Thank you, Chair. And I want to welcome everyone to today's committee hearing. I'm Julie Menon, Speaker of the New York City Council. Let me begin by thanking Chair Feliz and Chair Brewer, chairs of these committees for convening this very important oversight hearing on the Office of Community Safety and Nonpolice Solutions to Reducing Violence. We will also be hearing three pieces of legislation that the chairs will discuss shortly. A crucial aspect of community safety is establishing and fostering trust between government and the people it serves. That trust is earned over time through transparency through ensuring impacted New Yorkers have a seat at the table, and mostly through proven results. This past March, the mayor established an Office of Community Safety tasked with developing citywide community safety strategies and to supervise and coordinate the work of mayoral offices that operate in furtherance of community safety, including crime and violence prevention initiatives, victim assistant services, and community mental health services. As part of the establishment of OCS, five existing mayoral offices moved under its umbrella. The Office of Crime Victim Services, the Office for the Prevention of Hate Crimes, the Office of Community Mental Health, the Office to End Domestic and Gender Based Violence, the Office for Neighborhood Safety and the Prevention of Gun Violence. All of them were previously independent offices. Some have existed for over a decade. So it's important for us to come away from today's hearing with a greater understanding of why the offices were shifted from operating independently to being managed by the new OCS. We also want to learn which advocates were consulted before the change was made, and whether those organizations that have been working in these spaces for years are part um of the decision making moving forward. Certain providers have contacted us and have uh testified at prior hearings, particularly a hearing we held in the gender equity committee about the move of the office to end domestic and gender-based violence and voiced a concern at our hearing. Safe Horizons CEO Liz Roberts said that she was concerned that they had not been contacted prior to the restructuring and Sanctuary for Families, specifically said that the move occurred without meaningful collaboration. So one of the goals we have today is to understand what can happen moving forward to increase that level of collaboration and make sure that those organizations have a seat at the table. Most importantly, um, we want to understand the overarching goal of the office and what approach that it plans on taking moving forward. Um we do want to say that the goal of keeping New Yorkers safe is obviously incredibly important. We are concerned that compared to 2025, reported rapes have increased nearly 4%. Uh, subway felony assaults have climbed by 11%, and hate crimes are up 13%. Um these are all questions that we plan on asking, and we look forward to having a really fulsome uh hearing and conversation, and I'll turn it back over to the chair for his opening statement. Thank you. Thank you, Speaker. Earlier this year, New York City Mayor Mamdani issued executive order number 15, which established the Office of Community Safety known as OCS. Broadly tasked with developing citywide community safety initiatives. OCS is also empowered to supervise and coordinate the work of five existing mayoral offices that operate with similar safety related goals. These offices are the Office for Neighborhood Safety and Prevention of Gun Violence, the Office of Community Mental Health, the Office to End Domestic and Gender Based Violence, the Office for Prevention of Hate Crimes, and the Office for Crime Victim Services. The executive order also directs OCS to coordinate citywide mental health crisis response programs, including the BeHerd program, an emergency response initiatives that sends teams of mental health practitioners to certain mental health emergency calls. Today's hearing is an opportunity for the council to examine the administration's plan and vision for the newly created Office of Community Safety to better understand what OCS has accomplished since it was since it was established, learn about how OCS plans to coordinate the work of the five offices under its jurisdiction and other city agencies as well, including our New York City Police Department. The council also wants to know what changes have been made to existing programs and how OCS will measure whether its efforts are improving safety and connecting New Yorkers with needed services. Through today's hearing, the committee seeks a clear understanding of OCS's authority, staffing, budget, and plans for the future. Establishing an office is one step. We need to know what it is doing, how is it working with the agencies and organizations responsible for delivering services, and what measurable results the city expects to achieve.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com