OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Pleasantville, New York/Village Board of Trustees & Boards
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Pleasantville Village Board Meeting - October 29, 2025: Lennar Zoning Presentation and Resolutions

Village Board of Trustees & Boards — Wednesday, October 29, 2025
BodyPleasantville, New York
SessionVillage Board of Trustees & Boards
DateWednesday, October 29, 2025
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 2:25:42

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

0:00

So welcome everybody.

0:03

We don't often get such a party, but glad to have you.

0:05

Thank you for coming.

0:06

We got a bunch of people also watching on Zoom.

0:09

So we'll start a regular meeting, reminding folks that uh the meeting is recorded via Zoo, and the entire recording of it will be available within a few days online at Buzzville-NY.gov.

0:22

So here we go.

0:24

Welcome all.

0:24

The uh village board regular meeting of Monday, October 27.

0:29

Um, as is always the case, we have a work session at seven, a regular session beginning in point.

0:35

Our next regular meeting is on Monday, November 10th.

0:40

So obviously the big matter tonight is a presentation by Lenar about uh their proposal for the site up behind Foxwood.

0:50

As long as I have a captive audience, uh, let me just make a couple of announcements, and one of them I hope uh will engender widespread approval, and that is after months and months and months and months of effort.

1:05

Yemi, Eric, Alyssa, uh Senator Stuart Cousins' office, assemblywoman uh Shimsky's office.

1:14

Today, Governor Hokel signed the legislation.

1:18

You wouldn't think legislation would be needed, but it is to allow us to have a red light camera on the Songmill Parkway at Grant Street.

1:30

That's going to be part of part of the county system.

1:34

They have the right, what is it?

1:35

50, they have the right to put up 50 red light cameras on county-owned highways.

1:40

The reason it required a state state action is that their legislation only permitted them to put them on county-owned highways.

1:48

They accepted the willingness to put it up on this state-owned highway, uh, which not for nothing.

1:54

They're the contracted enforcers for.

1:56

So uh our next effort is to go back to the county and say how soon can we let this happen?

2:01

But within hopefully not too long, uh, the people who come speeding through red lights at Grand Street uh will be caught.

2:10

So good news, long haul.

2:12

Thank thanks to everybody involved.

2:15

Um, I have a few other announcements, none uh perhaps significantly what we're going to do now.

2:22

So, as you all know, um we have an application uh that we have received for a series of zoning changes that would allow the construction of a 102 unit project uh on a site up behind Foxwood.

2:39

Um it's a it's kind of a crazy story about why this site exists in the manner it does.

2:46

And so I just have a couple of slides uh that I think uh are worth buzzing through quickly so people uh realize the kind of interesting story behind this site.

3:03

So here's the map.

3:06

This circle is the approximate site.

3:08

Here is Manville Road, here is Bedford Road, the Methodist Church campus drive.

3:14

This little gray spot is the village-owned tennis courts.

3:18

Uh this is the 254-unit Foxwood condominium.

3:23

Um, this building here is what we used to think of as the Bank of New York site.

3:28

Uh for many years, the backup emergency site for Bank of New York.

3:31

And up at the top of the building, uh, the top of the hill is uh the Savan Engineering Building now owned uh by somebody else.

3:39

Uh, there is a ridge here, so that this is all on one side of the hill.

3:43

On the other side of the hill is uh the Toll Brothers Townhouse Project on Dennis Lane, which was redeveloped seven or eight years ago and had been um

Unassigned speaker

3:56

uh

Speaker 1

3:56

two off spillings.

3:58

So way back when in the 1920s, Hiram Edward Manville, the uh uh the uh keeper of the Johns Manville asbestos fortune, owns something like 500 acres in Pleasantville.

4:15

It was a big grand setting.

4:19

Uh he built this house uh which was 56 rooms.

4:24

It had elaborate gardens and uh uh landscaping and patios and terraces, and there were many other uh outbuildings that existed until the 1940s as Hiram Edward Vanville's estate.

4:41

He died in 1944.

Unassigned speaker

4:44

Uh his wife uh sold the property to General Precision Laboratories, which was uh a company involved in making in in designing at the time high-end technology for sonar radar and the like.

Speaker 1

5:02

1947, here's a New York Times article.

5:06

Laboratory praises country life in Manville, place at Pleasantville.

5:11

Mansion remodeled to permit precision work, stirs inquiries by other concerns, but zoning laws are a stiff barrier.

5:19

So you probably can't see this terribly well.

5:21

But this picture down here is engineers from GPL working in Hiram Edward Manville's dining room in rather grand circumstances.

5:33

Here's what happened thereafter.

5:35

This is the view.

5:36

This is Bedford Road.

5:38

This is what eventually turned into campus drive.

5:42

This is the site that Foxwood was later built on in three phases in the late 70s.

5:49

Here is the here is the mansion, which continued to be owned and operated by General Precision Laboratories, ultimately acquired by Singer.

5:58

And here is the first piece of a very big building that they built adjacent to it later in the 1980s, expanded.

6:07

Fast forward to 1978, there is the mansion.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Zoning And Land Use█████████████████████████████████████████41%
Community Engagement███████████████15%
Transportation Safety███████████11%
Procedural█████████9%
Affordable Housing████████8%
Economic Development██████6%
Engineering And Infrastructure████4%
Community Events██2%
Historic Preservation█1%
Summary of Proceedings

Pleasantville Village Board of Trustees Regular Meeting - October 29, 2025

The Pleasantville Village Board of Trustees held a regular meeting on October 29, 2025. The primary agenda item was a presentation by Lennar (US Home, LLC) regarding a proposed zoning amendment and the construction of a 102-unit townhouse community on a 20.5-acre site. The board also voted unanimously on the consent calendar. Extensive public comment was heard, and the board outlined the SEQRA review process. Note: The agenda and transcript list the meeting date as October 27, 2025, but the official instruction provided for this summary designates the date as October 29, 2025.

Consent Calendar

  • Res. No. 2025-330: Approved the minutes of the regular meeting held on October 15, 2025.
  • Res. No. 2025-331: Approved budget amendments including $2,894 for Senior Nutrition, $13,700 for Sanitary Sewers, and $24,565 for Engineering Capital (Flood Mapping & Traffic Calming Study).
  • Res. No. 2025-332: Approved payments totaling $563,278.74.
  • Res. No. 2025-333: Authorized the Holiday Tree Lighting ceremony for December 7, 2025, and associated road closures.
  • Res. No. 2025-334: Accepted the resignation of Recreation Assistant Sol Ibarra.
  • Res. No. 2025-335: Authorized a STOP-DWI Patrol/Datamaster agreement with Westchester County ($8,400, 2026-2030).
  • Res. No. 2025-336: Accepted a $150 donation to the Clinton Street Center for Senior Meals.
  • Res. No. 2025-337: Approved a block party and road closure on Sarles Lane.
  • Res. No. 2025-338: Approved the extension of the Snow and Ice Agreement with NYSDOT for 2025-2026.
  • All items were approved unanimously.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • The overwhelming majority of public speakers opposed the Lennar proposal.
  • Tom Rooney (26 Hillview Drive) and Noelle Nikola (44 Hayes Hill Road) expressed strong opposition, arguing that the village is overdeveloped and traffic is already unmanageable. Ms. Nikola stated the “cost of development is borne by the villagers.”
  • Nico (owner, Atlas Physical Therapy, 3 Campus Drive) opposed the plan, stating the building is fully occupied by five small businesses and the project “puts profit above well-being” by eliminating accessible healthcare.
  • Ashley Gray (36 High on the Terrace) noted Lennar is a Fortune 500 company and questioned why Pleasantville must solve the state housing crisis with million-dollar homes.
  • Amanda Chandler (33 Bedford Road) and Liz (181 Sky Top Drive) emphasized severe traffic congestion on Bedford Road and safety concerns for pedestrians and cyclists.
  • Regina Silversmith (Sunnyside Avenue) advocated for affordable senior housing options that allow residents to age in place.
  • Virginia (Foxwood resident) stated Foxwood residents were not properly notified by their HOA and raised concerns about easements.
  • Bill Lenahan (66 Great Oak Lane) asked clarifying questions about Lennar’s contract vendee status and road standards.
  • Christine Ivino (140 Fauche Avenue) requested that any approval include community benefits like a senior or recreation center.
  • Several residents expressed a preference for commercial reuse or leaving the site undeveloped.

Discussion Items

  • Mayor’s Historical Presentation: Mayor Schurman detailed the site’s history, including the Hiram Manville estate, General Precision Laboratories, and its long tenure as a Bank of New York emergency backup facility. He noted the site has a large, mostly vacant building and faces pressure for redevelopment.
  • Lennar Presentation: The applicant proposed rezoning the properties from Campus Office to a PUD to construct 102 fee-simple townhouses (10% affordable, plus 6 workforce units). The plan includes demolishing 175,000 sq. ft. of existing buildings, preserving natural topography, reducing impervious surfaces, and improving stormwater management. Pricing was estimated at $900k–$1.2M for larger units and ~$700k for smaller market-rate units. The preliminary school generation estimate was 42 children.
  • Board Deliberation: Trustees questioned the housing mix and the feasibility of incorporating more affordable or workforce units. Trustee Ealy explored whether the zoning could accommodate different unit types to address local affordability challenges. The board discussed the tension between market realities and community needs.
  • SEQRA Process: Village Attorney Virginia Gray and Planner Susan Fabiate confirmed the board will act as lead agency under the State Environmental Quality Review Act. The planning commission will provide an advisory report. Full traffic, fiscal, and school-impact studies will be required before a public hearing is scheduled.

Key Outcomes

  • No Vote on Rezoning: The board accepted the application for review but took no action on the Lennar proposal tonight.
  • SEQRA Initiated: The board will circulate its intent to serve as lead agency for environmental review.
  • Data Requests: The applicant was directed to provide comprehensive studies on traffic, fiscal impact, school generation (with comparables), stormwater management, and infrastructure capacity.
  • Consent Agenda Approved: Resolutions 2025-330 through 2025-338 were all approved unanimously.
  • Future Hearing: A formal public hearing on the zoning amendment will be scheduled after the completion of studies and the planning commission’s advisory report.
  • Executive Session: The meeting concluded with a motion to enter executive session for personnel, contractual, and real estate matters.

Meeting Transcript

So welcome everybody. We don't often get such a party, but glad to have you. Thank you for coming. We got a bunch of people also watching on Zoom. So we'll start a regular meeting, reminding folks that uh the meeting is recorded via Zoo, and the entire recording of it will be available within a few days online at Buzzville-NY.gov. So here we go. Welcome all. The uh village board regular meeting of Monday, October 27. Um, as is always the case, we have a work session at seven, a regular session beginning in point. Our next regular meeting is on Monday, November 10th. So obviously the big matter tonight is a presentation by Lenar about uh their proposal for the site up behind Foxwood. As long as I have a captive audience, uh, let me just make a couple of announcements, and one of them I hope uh will engender widespread approval, and that is after months and months and months and months of effort. Yemi, Eric, Alyssa, uh Senator Stuart Cousins' office, assemblywoman uh Shimsky's office. Today, Governor Hokel signed the legislation. You wouldn't think legislation would be needed, but it is to allow us to have a red light camera on the Songmill Parkway at Grant Street. That's going to be part of part of the county system. They have the right, what is it? 50, they have the right to put up 50 red light cameras on county-owned highways. The reason it required a state state action is that their legislation only permitted them to put them on county-owned highways. They accepted the willingness to put it up on this state-owned highway, uh, which not for nothing. They're the contracted enforcers for. So uh our next effort is to go back to the county and say how soon can we let this happen? But within hopefully not too long, uh, the people who come speeding through red lights at Grand Street uh will be caught. So good news, long haul. Thank thanks to everybody involved. Um, I have a few other announcements, none uh perhaps significantly what we're going to do now. So, as you all know, um we have an application uh that we have received for a series of zoning changes that would allow the construction of a 102 unit project uh on a site up behind Foxwood. Um it's a it's kind of a crazy story about why this site exists in the manner it does. And so I just have a couple of slides uh that I think uh are worth buzzing through quickly so people uh realize the kind of interesting story behind this site. So here's the map. This circle is the approximate site. Here is Manville Road, here is Bedford Road, the Methodist Church campus drive. This little gray spot is the village-owned tennis courts. Uh this is the 254-unit Foxwood condominium. Um, this building here is what we used to think of as the Bank of New York site. Uh for many years, the backup emergency site for Bank of New York. And up at the top of the building, uh, the top of the hill is uh the Savan Engineering Building now owned uh by somebody else. Uh, there is a ridge here, so that this is all on one side of the hill. On the other side of the hill is uh the Toll Brothers Townhouse Project on Dennis Lane, which was redeveloped seven or eight years ago and had been um uh two off spillings. So way back when in the 1920s, Hiram Edward Manville, the uh uh the uh keeper of the Johns Manville asbestos fortune, owns something like 500 acres in Pleasantville. It was a big grand setting. Uh he built this house uh which was 56 rooms. It had elaborate gardens and uh uh landscaping and patios and terraces, and there were many other uh outbuildings that existed until the 1940s as Hiram Edward Vanville's estate. He died in 1944. Uh his wife uh sold the property to General Precision Laboratories, which was uh a company involved in making in in designing at the time high-end technology for sonar radar and the like. 1947, here's a New York Times article. Laboratory praises country life in Manville, place at Pleasantville. Mansion remodeled to permit precision work, stirs inquiries by other concerns, but zoning laws are a stiff barrier.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com