OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Pleasantville, New York/Village Board of Trustees & Boards
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Pleasantville Planning Commission and ARB Meeting - December 5, 2025

Village Board of Trustees & Boards — Friday, December 5, 2025
BodyPleasantville, New York
SessionVillage Board of Trustees & Boards
DateFriday, December 5, 2025
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 2:03:21

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording.

Speaker 1

18:46

Okay.

18:48

Right.

18:49

You're ready.

Speaker 2

18:54

Yep.

Speaker 3

19:00

All right.

19:00

We good.

Speaker 1

19:03

Welcome to the Pleasantville Planning Commission and Architectural Review Board meeting.

19:12

Present tonight are commissioners Harry Freedis, David Keller, myself, Russ Klein, Henry Lebanon, and Eric Brotherton, our planning consultant Sarah Brown, and our building inspector, Robert Deus.

19:49

So there is not an application before us.

Speaker 4

20:00

Welcome for which we are grateful.

20:02

Thank you.

20:02

I'm George Marcese.

20:04

I'm the current president of Pleasantville Country Club, which is 72 individual homes.

20:13

A lot of people, even in Pleasantville, does not know it exists, but it's there.

20:18

May I give you a piece of paper?

20:20

Sure.

20:21

Just because I don't know if every if everyone knows what I'll

Unassigned speaker

20:25

be

Speaker 4

20:26

discussing.

20:26

So there's five.

20:28

This has been dismissed report, hasn't it?

20:30

Not what I will be saying now.

20:32

It has.

20:34

Three years ago.

20:35

It's the same location, correct?

20:36

Same location.

20:37

Okay.

20:38

Sorry.

20:39

But but we're talking about uh something different.

20:46

30 grades.

20:48

What I'm here for, as we say in formal, is there are certain things I know we're going to need to do, and I want to not waste your time or my time when we come back with the formal application.

21:07

There isn't a whole lot of protocol information.

21:12

So it would be it will be helpful for me to just outline what we're planning to do or what we'll ask permission to do.

21:22

So the 37 years about the then planning commission and whoever developed Pleasantville Country Club reached an agreement with this declaration.

21:38

The declaration provided that there could only be for the 72 homes, one access egress.

22:04

What we want to do is there is a quote emergency gate, which is permissible.

22:14

What we want to do is make that gate uh so that the 72 homeowners can have a clicker and get out through that entrance.

22:28

We can't do away with the gate because in going back three years ago, there were different things uh attempted, but what happens is if we did away with the gate, all residents in Pleasantville would come in through and use it as a cut through.

22:50

But we're more concerned with the with having uh uh a safety egress.

22:56

I've had uh uh and I'm

Unassigned speaker

22:58

not

Speaker 4

22:59

um I'm I'm sort of talking, not uh making making the case, but uh uh the I've had the fire chief come, he's and they do they you can ask them and they do an analysis.

23:15

We we have the the roads inside Pleasantville Country Club are only 24 feet.

23:24

Uh and when you bring a if you for example, if you bring a fire engine

Unassigned speaker

23:30

in,

Speaker 4

23:31

you can't get you could never get around.

23:33

So you so you depending where you live, you can't get out because uh the gate and and it perhaps you could say, well, sure, but it's an emergency gate.

23:44

Someone, if there's a fire, you you want to wait with your family to get out of there.

23:52

It it's 37 years later, and it's not quite the same instance.

23:58

Now, when we when we get to uh hopefully discussing in detail uh what I will be what I will be asking or a prime purpose here is no matter how we do this, because of our neighbors, there's everyone will say traffic study.

24:22

Three years ago, someone said, Well, what's the use of a traffic study that can be manipulated?

24:28

But I don't see how we're not not you know, you're not gonna want that.

24:32

I've got it lined up to do, but I don't

Unassigned speaker

24:36

know

Speaker 4

24:37

what you need.

24:38

That's one of the prime reasons I'm here because if we know what traffic study we have to have by the time I do of the formal application, you'll have it, and and hopefully it, you know, it's it's what you're looking for.

Unassigned speaker

24:55

Otherwise, we'll we'll be back here again talking about oh, you're gonna need a traffic study, so we waste months and and whatever.

Speaker 4

25:04

Anyway, we and if we do a traffic study, uh it has to be done before school is out, because our closest and biggest neighbor is Pleasantville High School.

25:20

It it's we border with that.

25:23

So to have a to depend, well, depending where we're doing a truck a traffic study is necessary, uh it really has to be done while school's in session, because that's that's the most important reading for the for the safety of the children.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Zoning And Land Use███████████████████████████████████35%
Signage Regulations███████████████████████23%
Engineering And Infrastructure█████████████████17%
Transportation Safety███████████████15%
Public Safety██████6%
Procedural██2%
Public Works█1%
Lighting Regulations█1%
Summary of Proceedings

Pleasantville Planning Commission and ARB Meeting - December 5, 2025

The Pleasantville Planning Commission and Architectural Review Board held a joint meeting on December 5, 2025, at Village Hall. Commissioners reviewed three main items: an informal discussion regarding the Pleasantville Country Club's access request, a new application for a parking area and stairway relocation at 85 Nannahagan Road, and a signage update for Wells Fargo Bank at 44 Washington Avenue. The meeting also included approval of the October 22, 2025, meeting minutes.

Pleasantville Country Club - 110 Nannahagan Road - Informal Discussion

  • George Marcese, president of the Pleasantville Country Club (72 homes), requested informal guidance on amending the 37-year-old site plan to allow residents to use an existing emergency gate for egress via a clicker system. He argued the current single-access egress on a 24-foot road is unsafe, citing a fire department assessment and the risk on Nannahagan Road between the club and Broadway. He also noted recent stop signs installed by the village and potential cooperation with the adjacent high school to address parent pick-up traffic using the club's parking lot.
  • Commissioners raised concerns about the original resolution's strictness on access, the need for a traffic study (especially during school hours), and whether the change would add or reduce traffic. Commissioner Harry Freedis suggested that the applicant prepare a comprehensive case addressing why the original conditions are no longer relevant and include a turnaround for the school pickup area.
  • The applicant agreed to commission a traffic study and return with a formal application.

85 Nannahagan Road - Gianna Marzella - Parking Area Extension and Stairway Relocation

  • Philip Holub, architect, presented a new application to rebuild a failing retaining wall, relocate a stairway from the road edge to a safer location behind the garage, and widen the existing 21-foot driveway to 25.5 feet to improve vehicle circulation and pedestrian access. The work is within the village right-of-way, currently encroaching 421 square feet, increasing to 454 square feet.
  • Commissioners expressed concern that a 25.5-foot width could physically accommodate three cars, potentially creating a parking lot appearance in a high-end neighborhood. They suggested keeping the width at 21 feet but adding a defined pedestrian walkway (4 feet wide with a 1-foot curb) demarcated by a low wall or curb to prevent third-car parking. They also requested sight-distance verification by the village engineer.
  • The applicant agreed to revise the plans to include a walkway and curb, and to present a simplified, colorized drawing at the next meeting on December 10, 2025. No public hearing was set, pending completeness.

44 Washington Avenue - Wells Fargo Bank - Exterior Changes and Signage

  • Matt Clift, installer for Wells Fargo, presented a refresh package including a large red pan sign (non-illuminated, with lit white channel letters) spanning the entire storefront facade, plus various directional, parking, and entry signs in new white-and-yellow brand colors. A new ground sign (33 by 25 inches) was also proposed.
  • Commissioners found the red pan sign overly wide (93 and 5/8 inches) and recommended shortening it to align with the building's main entrance lobby perimeter, leaving the rightmost window bays uncovered. They also requested removal of the proposed ground sign, viewing it as unnecessary. The applicant agreed to take these revisions to the client.
  • The commission voted unanimously to approve the signage application with the conditions that the main sign be reduced in length as described and the ground sign be eliminated. The building inspector was authorized to proceed upon receipt of revised drawings.

Key Outcomes

  • Pleasantville Country Club: No formal application yet; applicant to prepare a traffic study and return for further discussion.
  • 85 Nannahagan Road: Applicant to revise plans per commission guidance (21-foot driveway with 4-foot walkway and curb) and present at the December 10, 2025 meeting. Village engineer will review sight lines.
  • 44 Washington Avenue: Wells Fargo signage application approved unanimously (all in favor) with two revisions: reduce main sign length to align with lobby entry and remove ground sign. Revised drawings to be submitted to the building department.
  • Minutes of October 22, 2025: Approved unanimously with edits.
  • Meeting adjourned. Next regular meeting scheduled for December 10, 2025.

Meeting Transcript

Okay. Right. You're ready. Yep. All right. We good. Welcome to the Pleasantville Planning Commission and Architectural Review Board meeting. Present tonight are commissioners Harry Freedis, David Keller, myself, Russ Klein, Henry Lebanon, and Eric Brotherton, our planning consultant Sarah Brown, and our building inspector, Robert Deus. So there is not an application before us. Welcome for which we are grateful. Thank you. I'm George Marcese. I'm the current president of Pleasantville Country Club, which is 72 individual homes. A lot of people, even in Pleasantville, does not know it exists, but it's there. May I give you a piece of paper? Sure. Just because I don't know if every if everyone knows what I'll be discussing. So there's five. This has been dismissed report, hasn't it? Not what I will be saying now. It has. Three years ago. It's the same location, correct? Same location. Okay. Sorry. But but we're talking about uh something different. 30 grades. What I'm here for, as we say in formal, is there are certain things I know we're going to need to do, and I want to not waste your time or my time when we come back with the formal application. There isn't a whole lot of protocol information. So it would be it will be helpful for me to just outline what we're planning to do or what we'll ask permission to do. So the 37 years about the then planning commission and whoever developed Pleasantville Country Club reached an agreement with this declaration. The declaration provided that there could only be for the 72 homes, one access egress. What we want to do is there is a quote emergency gate, which is permissible. What we want to do is make that gate uh so that the 72 homeowners can have a clicker and get out through that entrance. We can't do away with the gate because in going back three years ago, there were different things uh attempted, but what happens is if we did away with the gate, all residents in Pleasantville would come in through and use it as a cut through. But we're more concerned with the with having uh uh a safety egress. I've had uh uh and I'm not um I'm I'm sort of talking, not uh making making the case, but uh uh the I've had the fire chief come, he's and they do they you can ask them and they do an analysis. We we have the the roads inside Pleasantville Country Club are only 24 feet. Uh and when you bring a if you for example, if you bring a fire engine in, you can't get you could never get around. So you so you depending where you live, you can't get out because uh the gate and and it perhaps you could say, well, sure, but it's an emergency gate. Someone, if there's a fire, you you want to wait with your family to get out of there. It it's 37 years later, and it's not quite the same instance. Now, when we when we get to uh hopefully discussing in detail uh what I will be what I will be asking or a prime purpose here is no matter how we do this, because of our neighbors, there's everyone will say traffic study.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com