OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Radnor Township Board of Commissioners Meeting – October 27, 2025

Board of Commissioners & BoardsMonday, October 27, 2025
BodyRadnor Township, Pennsylvania
SessionBoard of Commissioners & Boards
DateMonday, October 27, 2025
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 2:11:57

Transcript — Verbatim
0:00

Welcome everyone to the Board of Commissioners meeting for Monday, October 27, 2025, and to call the meeting to order.

0:09

I apologize for being late.

0:11

Would everyone join me at the Pledge of Allegiance?

0:33

Thank you.

0:34

I want to give notice that we did have an executive session on October 17th virtually.

0:41

And we had an executive session prior to this meeting, both to discuss real estate and legal matters.

0:49

We have several presentations tonight.

0:52

First, we're going to have the Shade Tree Committee telling us about some of their recommendations for maintenance of trees in the right of way.

1:00

Mr.

1:01

Foster, do you want to start us off or Mr.

1:03

Gibbons?

1:06

Okay.

1:06

Yeah, this is just an introduction.

1:07

We have uh Mr.

1:08

Gibbons, the chair of the uh Shade Tree Commission.

1:11

Um, but the presentation will be given by uh Frank Parris, one of the members of Shade Tree.

1:16

He has uh always handled our bare root tree program.

1:20

So he was an integral part in us developing um this uh recommendation that you're about to see.

1:25

Mr.

1:25

Paris.

1:26

Okay, thank you.

1:27

Thank you, Mr.

1:27

Paris.

1:28

Uh thank you for letting me speak.

1:30

Um it's going to be short, I hope.

1:34

Um, but first I wanted to talk about something that happened uh a couple weeks ago, and that is Delaware County did an ass commissioned an assessment of the county's tree canopy for the period 2010 to 2022.

1:47

Their findings for the whole county.

1:49

Could you speak a little more into the mic either or give it a tap, make sure it's working?

1:53

Yep, it is.

1:54

Just so just sort of bring it over to you and speak louder.

1:56

They're having trouble hearing you in the back.

1:58

Okay, sorry about that.

2:00

But anyway, Delaware County uh commissioned an uh an assessment that was conducted by the University of Vermont about the tree cover in uh Delaware County.

2:10

Some of their findings were for specifically for Radner, which I think we can be very, very proud of, is that 50 percent, 2% of our township is covered by canopy.

2:19

And this is kind of significant because I personally did a uh tree canopy study five years ago and it was 52 percent.

2:26

So in the last five years, it appears, you know, margin of error, we pretty much maintained our canopy within within the township.

2:34

Um for as far as us compared to the other townships, um we had the second largest tree canopy with 4500 acres covered by trees within the township.

2:46

Um we're about 8,000 acres, obviously.

2:50

Uh but over that 12-year period, Radner had the second lowest change in canopy.

2:56

While we did lose 70 acres over the 12 years, um that was only one percent, you know, of what we have.

3:04

Um the loss, of course, we've had uh loss due to disease, age and development.

3:11

But I think the the proud thing for for me as a township resident is it's offset by our shade tree ordinance, because we review with all the developers.

3:20

Uh we've got tree planting programs, the shade tree um uh the bare root program has planted about 1200 trees over the last five years.

3:29

And um we've had a lot of other giveaways, not only with us, but also with the Radina Conservancy.

3:36

So all this is to say we got all this stuff, how are we going to maintain it?

3:41

There was a segue.

3:43

Um the current situation is the township uh maintains the trees in the parks and in the right of way.

3:52

Uh they maintain the trees in the right of way if they're hazardous, dead, fallen, or lost large branches.

4:01

And we've had a lot of that, you know, during during October and December, uh September.

4:06

Um deemed necessary by our arbors, the township will remove the tree, all the debris, and grind the stump.

4:15

What the township does not do, it doesn't treat unhealthy trees with chemicals or whatever, uh, remove vines from trees, which can kill them, or prune them for aesthetic reasons, or remove a healthy tree at a residence request.

4:28

So that's kind of like where we are.

4:31

And uh at the Shade Tree Commission, we we uh discussed this, uh, worked with uh public works, and we came up with this recommendation, which is essentially the township should continue to main the right of way right-of-way trees, and also the parks.

4:46

I should have mentioned that.

4:48

Um but we wanted to uh suggest the residents have some sort of skin in the game and have some sort of financial responsibility for their maintenance.

4:57

That can take many forms, but we are recommending that they do get that skin in the game.

5:02

Um we could do a char a reasonable flat fee for any sort of tree maintenance done under the direction of public works, and consistent with uh the flat fees we already charge for people that can't plant a tree and they give us money in lieu of planting a tree.

5:19

Um this is our ordinance, which you guys all know, but I think this recommendation is consistent with what we've been doing under the current uh shade tree ordinance.

5:31

Um the issues that we considered uh is the benefits, of course.

5:39

Uh they provide cooling, uh flood control, well-being for the community.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Tree Management█████████████████17%
Engineering And Infrastructure███████████████15%
Public Safety██████████10%
Parks and Recreation██████████10%
Public Engagement████████8%
Procedural███████7%
Technology and Innovation██████6%
Budget Equity Analysis█████5%
Personnel Matters████4%
Summary of Proceedings

Radnor Township Board of Commissioners Meeting – October 27, 2025

The Board of Commissioners met on Monday, October 27, 2025, at 6:30 PM in the Radnorshire Room. The meeting included presentations from the Shade Tree Commission and departmental budget requests for 2026, public comment on a sign code issue, and action on several agenda items. Executive sessions were held on October 17 and prior to the meeting for real estate and legal matters.

Consent Calendar

  • Approved the meeting minutes of October 13, 2025.
  • Accepted the Chief Monthly Report for October 2025.
  • Approved Staff Traffic Committee Meeting Minutes of September 17, 2025.
  • Adopted Resolution 2025-152 authorizing transfer of $95,344.14 from the Liquid Fuels Fund to the General Fund for road salt reimbursement.
  • Adopted Resolution 2025-155 adopting the 2026 Township Manager’s Recommended Budget as the Preliminary Recommended Comprehensive Budget.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • David Mackey (non-resident, business owner in Wayne) described his difficulty relocating his business sign after moving locations. He stated his sign had been approved at two prior locations, but on the third relocation, the Design Review Board approved it subject to a zoning review, and the township code interpretation (square footage based on building width) now requires him to go before the Zoning Hearing Board. He asked the commissioners to consider his situation.
  • Mark Danick, attorney for Joe Schumacher (607 South Valley Forge), requested that the stormwater project designed for that property be completed in 2026, as it is listed in the upcoming bond issue.

Discussion Items

  • Shade Tree Commission Presentation – Frank Parris presented the commission’s findings and recommendations: Delaware County’s tree canopy study shows Radnor has 50.2% canopy cover (down from 52% five years ago) and lost 70 acres (1%) over 12 years. The Commission recommended that residents share financial responsibility for maintenance of trees in the right-of-way, possibly via a flat fee (e.g., $300–400 per removal), to offset maintenance costs (about $200,000 per year). Commissioners questioned the feasibility, safety implications, and burden on homeowners; some expressed concern that shifting costs could create public hazards. No vote was taken; the presentation was informational.
  • 2026 Budget Presentations: Staffing Requests – Department heads presented staffing needs:
    • Police Department (Chief & Lieutenant): Requested 3 new officers – one for patrol (balancing platoons at 8 officers each), one detective (to distribute workload and reduce on-call burden), and one training/quartermaster officer (to manage increasing training demands, active shooter drills, and extra duty details). Annual cost per officer was discussed, with potential offsets from overtime savings under review.
    • Public Works (Ricky Foster): Requested 3 additional staff – one for sewer maintenance (safety concerns with two-person rule, increased response to PUC fines), one fleet maintenance small-engine specialist (to handle growing vehicle/equipment demands and safe garage operations), and one parks maintenance worker (to meet increased use and trail system expansion).
    • Parks and Recreation (Director Tammy Cohen): Requested a Park Operations Coordinator to handle administrative support for park projects, contractual services, community engagement, and succession planning. Noted that the parks maintenance staff had decreased from 18 to 13 despite added facilities.
  • Capital Overview (Township Manager White): Presented a summary of capital types (infrastructure, fleet, buildings, parks), reviewed bonded projects from 2016, 2019, 2024, and the 2022 stormwater bonds, and outlined an unfunded capital project list (84+ projects). He proposed developing a Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) policy to prioritize and fund projects, using a mix of taxes, bonds, grants, and fees, to strengthen the township’s financial position.

Key Outcomes

  • Consent Agenda: Approved unanimously.
  • 3A – Appointment of Melissa Zaffin to the Environmental Advisory Council (partial term ending Dec. 31, 2027): Approved unanimously.
  • 3B – Ordinance 2025-09 (Tree clearing permit amendments): Adopted unanimously. The ordinance amends Section 263-8 to clarify when a clearing permit is required and establishes additional requirements for tree removal.
  • 3C – Resolution 2025-153 (Granicus engagement platform): Tabled after a motion and second, pending further presentation and commissioner questions about the platform’s value and controls.
  • 3D – Ordinance 2025-10 (Portnoff as special counsel for delinquent collections): Tabled due to ongoing negotiations.

The meeting adjourned after reports of board liaisons and no further business.

Meeting Transcript

Welcome everyone to the Board of Commissioners meeting for Monday, October 27, 2025, and to call the meeting to order. I apologize for being late. Would everyone join me at the Pledge of Allegiance? Thank you. I want to give notice that we did have an executive session on October 17th virtually. And we had an executive session prior to this meeting, both to discuss real estate and legal matters. We have several presentations tonight. First, we're going to have the Shade Tree Committee telling us about some of their recommendations for maintenance of trees in the right of way. Mr. Foster, do you want to start us off or Mr. Gibbons? Okay. Yeah, this is just an introduction. We have uh Mr. Gibbons, the chair of the uh Shade Tree Commission. Um, but the presentation will be given by uh Frank Parris, one of the members of Shade Tree. He has uh always handled our bare root tree program. So he was an integral part in us developing um this uh recommendation that you're about to see. Mr. Paris. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Paris. Uh thank you for letting me speak. Um it's going to be short, I hope. Um, but first I wanted to talk about something that happened uh a couple weeks ago, and that is Delaware County did an ass commissioned an assessment of the county's tree canopy for the period 2010 to 2022. Their findings for the whole county. Could you speak a little more into the mic either or give it a tap, make sure it's working? Yep, it is. Just so just sort of bring it over to you and speak louder. They're having trouble hearing you in the back. Okay, sorry about that. But anyway, Delaware County uh commissioned an uh an assessment that was conducted by the University of Vermont about the tree cover in uh Delaware County. Some of their findings were for specifically for Radner, which I think we can be very, very proud of, is that 50 percent, 2% of our township is covered by canopy. And this is kind of significant because I personally did a uh tree canopy study five years ago and it was 52 percent. So in the last five years, it appears, you know, margin of error, we pretty much maintained our canopy within within the township. Um for as far as us compared to the other townships, um we had the second largest tree canopy with 4500 acres covered by trees within the township. Um we're about 8,000 acres, obviously. Uh but over that 12-year period, Radner had the second lowest change in canopy. While we did lose 70 acres over the 12 years, um that was only one percent, you know, of what we have. Um the loss, of course, we've had uh loss due to disease, age and development. But I think the the proud thing for for me as a township resident is it's offset by our shade tree ordinance, because we review with all the developers. Uh we've got tree planting programs, the shade tree um uh the bare root program has planted about 1200 trees over the last five years. And um we've had a lot of other giveaways, not only with us, but also with the Radina Conservancy. So all this is to say we got all this stuff, how are we going to maintain it? There was a segue. Um the current situation is the township uh maintains the trees in the parks and in the right of way. Uh they maintain the trees in the right of way if they're hazardous, dead, fallen, or lost large branches. And we've had a lot of that, you know, during during October and December, uh September. Um deemed necessary by our arbors, the township will remove the tree, all the debris, and grind the stump.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com