9:23Uh, welcome to the public comment period.
9:26We have uh almost fifty people signed up this evening on a number of different items.
9:32So we're gonna do two minutes a person to make sure everybody has a chance to speak, and I will go ahead and start with uh the first uh Octavia Rani.
9:51I would like to speak from my heart this afternoon on the Civil Rights Act and about the zoning of those thirty stories to Stormy and to Corey.
10:05I am a civil rights activist.
10:07I marched with John Lewis over the Pettish Bridge, and I saw what you did and voted for that project was unconscionable to me as a black person.
10:19You know, blacks didn't have the right to live in 30 stories.
10:27We live in areas that was unsafe, that was habited, but we lived there and we made it work.
10:35What you voted for was a restrictive covenant.
10:39It was a restrictive covenant.
10:41And you are telling black people, I heard what they didn't say, but you're telling black people number one, you are not welcoming these 30 stories.
10:49You don't have the income because we're gonna take it up way beyond 80 percent of the AMI and 80 percent of the AMI give black people the opportunity to live there.
11:01But you voted against it.
11:03That bothered me as a black person, and I don't see why y'all didn't ask those questions to the mayor rally.
11:14I don't understand where you're headed with this.
11:17That is selective housing, and you are talking about God, not in my back God in my backyard.
11:25You gotta be for real.
11:27You gotta be sincere.
11:30And don't get me to talk about God because that's up my alley.
11:34That's not right, and that vote wasn't right.
11:39I expected two blacks to ask that question.
11:44Why black people can't live there?
11:46I heard what they said, but what they didn't say is the question at stake.
11:54Next we have Kevin Kwong.
12:01Hello, mayor and city counselor, city manager, and everyone.
12:06My topic is a very difficult one.
12:08It's about political violence and uh chilling effect on politicians and uh after uh I do some research.
12:16I don't think I have a conclusive answer to that question, but I will encourage politicians to be bold to do not stop in prison meeting to consider their own security after the taking consideration, continue to have the meeting.
12:37The second topic I want to talk about is about uh bus route number two.
12:43Uh also number two number two last Tuesday after the meeting, going off to my friend's home, and a bus driver made two mistakes on the route.
12:55He failed to turn at five point from Greenwood to ease with the meals and need to call the cortex for help on Kinwood.
13:06And after he goes back to East Wickler Meals, he failed to turn on ease with the commune's left turn on Wick Forest Road.
13:16So he makes two mistakes.
13:18Is there a better way to do that?
13:20To improve the services?
13:24Improve the service light, go try and go to install the GPS.
13:29The GPS allow the driver to not need to memorize the role, especially if they are not experienced with it.
13:36And I think that is a pretty important and you should have better training on the driver if they do not remember the route that it is important that they would cause the disruption to the people who work in Walmart and do not oh they miss the bus because the driver is late or something.
13:52Thank you very much.
14:04I'm Byron Laws, District C resident, also former chair of the Human Relations Commission.
14:10I actually just wrote off June of this year after serving three terms, which is six years.
14:15Um I watched the meetings you all held as a special um committee around the boards and commissions to consolidate them.
14:22Um specifically, I'm here to talk about um you all not doing anything with African American Affairs Board.
14:28Um community members brought it up, and you all wouldn't let us do anything as a counsel because it wasn't part of our work plan.
14:35We then put in our work plan July 4th last year.
14:38You all voted for African American Affairs Board here, like you all did, um, except the two new uh people that are on council.
14:46Um last Monday, you all decided to consolidate the Hispanic and Immigrant Affairs Board into HRC, which um clarification it was never part of HRC, it was built out of HRC.
14:57Um, but you all decided not to sit the African American Affairs Board.
15:02Um, as a lifelong resident of District C.
15:05Um, it's really hard to just be be a part of this.
15:09I was a vice chair of my CAC when that got dismantled.
15:13I was um involved in my HRC and became chair because you all asked our president at the time after she had just got approved by us.
15:22So then I hear you all say that we're not organized and moving the work, we move the work, and then you all decide that the work is not important enough to carry on, specifically work um to give African American community members a voice here.
15:36Um I'm a graduate of NLO, there's a council member that's a graduate of NLO, that council member is also an Aggie.
15:42Um I just came from Giho this weekend.
15:46So when I see a council member that looks like me who didn't silence the voice of community in a minority majority district, we got some issues, like real issues.
15:55If y'all are not gonna give black people a voice in this community in this city, and you look like me, get out the way.
16:03And if you all are gonna continue to rig elections here, that are gonna give you power, thank you.
16:24Good evening, Mayor and City Council.
16:27I served as an HRC on the HRC for six years, and also had the opportunity to serve it in leadership roles.
16:36During my time on the commission, every project, every activity we undertook was part of a work plan that was approved by the city council.
16:47Throughout my tenure, the HRC advocated for the Director of Equity Inclusion position.
16:53The HRC conducted research, held community feedback sessions, and made recommendations for the creation of several important boards.
17:02The police advisory board, the Hispanic Affairs Board, the Immigrant Affairs Board.
17:08The HRC introduced National Day of Racial Healing to the City of Raleigh.
17:14The HRC had events with NAMI and did held two food distribution events during COVID.
17:22Over the years, the HRC has participated and supported numerous community events.
17:29During my time on HRC, resolutions were initiatives were from various Raleigh community members.
17:37Members from the Quaker community brought forth the reparative justice resolution.
17:43Members from the African American community brought forward the African American Advisory Board directly to the City Council.
17:52The current proposal to eliminate boards or to merge multiple community focused efforts to a single entity is deeply disappointing.
18:04As a volunteer commission, the HRC is not structured to provide adequate attention and voice to the wide range of community issues.
18:15I and other residents of Raleigh look forward to seeing how the new HR Street HRC structure will advocate for important issues for a very diverse city of Raleigh.
18:45Good evening, Council members and my fellow Raleighites.
18:49I'm here tonight to draw your attention to recent lobbying by the billboard industry, and that they are seeking a change to the current UDO ban on electric billboards in Raleigh.
19:01Electric billboards are visual pollution and increased driver distraction.
19:07Digital billboards are designed to get and hold drivers' attention longer than static billboards.
19:16They are designed to pull our eyes off the road away from pedestrians, cyclists, and our fellow drivers.
19:24Just one electric billboard with ability to change ads every eight seconds and running 24 hours a day.
19:33That's over 10,000 flashes of distraction per day on the same stretch of road.
19:40And the billboard industry knows electric billboards are bigger distractions.
19:46And they even use this fact as a selling feature to their clients.
20:03Promoted digital billboards to advertisers because they grab drivers' attention longer.
20:11They quoted an Arbitron outdoor study claiming digital billboards produce 63% longer gaze times.
20:30In their own words, the digital display that grabs attention sooner wins the race.
20:38If the industry itself is selling distraction as a benefit, why would Raleigh knowingly make you Andrew Bennington?
20:58I'm here today to talk about the big branch Creek Greenway Connector, which I think is not news to any of you.
21:17But I'm here tonight, not as an affected homeowner, which I am, but as a taxpayer, which all of us are, and I want everyone here to hear this and you all to consider it carefully, as I know you're going to vote on this issue coming up.
21:30It's my understanding, based on public uh information Freedom of Information Act request that this project, it's about three and a half miles to build a greenway, uh, was funded by a referendum that we all voted on, and it was approved in the order of about 4.5 million.
21:48One segment, a half mile segment, which is behind my house and my neighbors' houses, uh, is less than half a mile.
21:56The Freedom of Information Act request we got from the engineers that have worked on this suggest that that one half mile stretch is going to cost nearly five million dollars.
22:07So a half-mile stretch of this proposed project is going to blow the budget for the entire three and a half mile uh proposed greenway.
22:17So in addition to the number of other environmental, legal, and um safety issues we've raised.
22:26I I bring this issue to the forefront, and this is a result of the fact that the city has no property rights to this land.
22:33It's we hold it in fee simple, we own the entire land.
22:37If it has to be taken from us, it's going to be taken by eminent domain, which is you all know is the city taking private property at your additional expense.
22:46So you're gonna pay for it, and I just want you guys to hear it in front of them.
22:50Thank you very much for listening.
23:14Is this your phone, Andrew?
23:21Did not mean take your time.
23:22I'm probably thank you.
23:27Lila Summer ML Sudden offered me indefinite an indefinite stay at for transition at the CS at 2800.
23:34I was hesitant to move in because the staff was unwelcoming and discouraged to move.
23:38And despite the renovation, there was no AC in the unit.
23:41After about two months later, dropping temps and being exposed to the elements, I reluctantly moved in.
23:48Since I've been there, the elevator has been down for the past 10 months and other repairs neglect to be made.
23:54There are massive water puddles that stand on a slippery cement surface from OACs leaking.
23:59There's a roach infestation and bed bugs in most every room, even if uh festing brand new appliances, those are refrigerators, microwaves, and most times the environment feels unsafe.
24:10As a result of the unworking elevator and slippery pavement, I fell on the stairs and suffered a concussion and multiple injuries.
24:19Just recently, an older woman also almost fell.
24:22As a result of roaches, I cannot use my AC or he or stove or to cook efficiently or to surf efficient.
24:32I have been threatened and harassed, and the Security Guard was hired but left after just one week.
24:36The building considered affordable housing owned by the city and managed by CASA, houses elderly disabled veterans, people with behavioral challenges, abatement has not been offered, and suitable and timely accommodations have not been made.
24:53Residents who live here are on a fixed income and pay off a four-fifths of their fixed income to stay here and deserve better.
25:01So residents and I are requesting a bait main and/or accommodations are and/or alternative housing.
25:09And remember that the promises of tomorrow begin with the practices of today.
25:14Can I just ask you to repeat the name of the building because I missed it when you said that?
25:17You own the building, the studios at 2800 at 2800 Brentwood.
25:22Which is managed by Casa.
25:27Next we have Helen Kerbin.
25:34My name is Helen Kervin and I live in the Anderson Forest neighborhood, where the proposed big branch Greenway Segment 1B, so-called streamside route, would run directly behind non-homes and dangerously close to Big Branch Creek.
25:49For 16 months, our neighbors have provided extensive documented evidence to city staff, parks board, and city council explaining why this route should not be built within feet of the creek.
26:01Yet these facts have been dismissed.
26:04Building a greenway parallel to Big Branch Creek within the 30-foot reparian buffer violates Noose River buffer rules, floodplain standards, the City's own greenway master plan and design guidelines.
26:18This area floods frequently, creating safety risks for users and guaranteeing ongoing costly maintenance.
26:26The public surveys used to justify this route were misleading.
26:30And a greenway within 50 feet of homes will permanently strip away our privacy.
26:35Two facts are impossible to overlook.
26:38Costs and a deed restriction.
26:40This half-mile streamside route is projected to cost more than the entire 4.5 million budget for the full three and a half-mile project and irresponsible use of taxpayer funds.
26:52The city will have to violate a 39-year-old scenic preservation deed prohibiting Greenway construction and pursue eminent domain against non-homeowners.
27:02Ignoring these realities would be a costly mistake for the community, the environment, and the city's long-term interests.
27:19Thank you so much for your consideration.
27:30Okay, she's not here.
27:43For the past two years, I have bore witness to Palestinian children that look like they're sleeping, but in actuality, their bodies are so small that when the bombs go off around them, the blowblock, the blowbacks liquefy their insides, making them look like they're sleeping, and that there is a possibility to save them.
28:02And yesterday, I witnessed Trump in Israel joke with Bibi that he sent all the bombs.
28:09He didn't know that existed, and that BB used them well.
28:12And that Merriam, his biggest donor of six mil $60 million to his campaign, was at his White House more than any other person telling him to keep sending more money, more bombs to Israel, and that he admits that it will get him in trouble, but that Mary Am most likely loves Israel more than she loves the USA.
28:34While we're in a full government shutdown, our national parks are left exposed, our military was stressed about whether or not they were going to be paid to pay their mortgage, to pay for food.
28:46Israel got paid through a loophole.
28:49So while they're still getting money, our people starve.
28:54But I would like to point out that we are supplying money to a government that has universal health care, free college, and for every baby they have, they get a paycheck every year until that child is 18.
29:08Meanwhile, America, we're crippled with debt everywhere.
29:13And we have the money to send to a country that is not in debt like we are, and send our tax dollars to a country that has free socialist programs while we are not allowed to have them.
29:31Meanwhile, I have 10 seconds.
29:34Meanwhile, I would like us to demand Deborah Ross present an arms embargo on this country.
30:03Good evening, Mayor and Council members.
30:04My name is Rashawn King.
30:06I'm here today to talk about the big branch greenway trail connector.
30:09The big branch greenway is a vital project that will impact not just one section of Raleigh but the entire region.
30:15The importance of this trail has been expressed highly by citizens Raleigh through community engagement.
30:20The Greenway has been emphasized and embedded in the 2020 walkable midway plan and the Vision Zero plan as well.
30:26The development of this greenway will bring more than 10,000 residents within a 10-mile walking radius closer to this greenway.
30:33But it also will bring residents outside of Raleigh's jurisdiction to be able to enjoy this remarkable trail and the city trail connectivity throughout the city of Raleigh.
30:41I advocate for this project because of the substantial connection that we'll provide for residents who will be able to utilize this trail for transportation, recreation, leisure, and health and wellness.
30:52But more so for the kids, for the kids, and for the parents who will be able to be able to use this route for safe routes to school and safe routes to playgrounds.
31:11And I can truly say that almost every greenway and trail that Raleigh has built has made a substantial and a positive impact on people's lives.
31:18I am a cancer survivor, and greenways and trails have saved my life.
31:22When I bought leukemia at age of 17 years old, had 24 hours to live.
32:09Two years ago, uh when everything started over in uh Palestine and the genocide began.
32:16We came here week after week demanding a resolution for a ceasefire.
32:21Uh week after week, we finally uh the pressure built up where that vote was taken, and of course, unfortunately, it failed.
32:28Um I just wanted to say after everything that's happened, we finally have reached a peace quote unquote peace deal, um, which is obviously riddled with corruption and everything else, but we'll get to that.
32:39Umetheless, we've seen proven time and time again that the genocide was in fact real, the starvation, uh hundreds of thousands at this point are probably the actual death toll in Palestine as far as dead Palestinians, mostly uh women and children.
32:55Um those of you who voted who are still on this council who voted against that ceasefire resolution will forever have to live with that and will forever be on the wrong side of history.
33:05Now, uh with this corrupt peace deal, of course, what it really is is a real estate grab for Donald Trump.
33:11He wants to be he's gonna be the head of the peace board.
33:14And make no mistake, there will be no peace.
33:16The infrastructure is completely destroyed in Gaza, just about, and everything else, and it will probably take decades upon decades to even try to rebuild it if if they are if they even can at this point.
33:28So what I would encourage the city to do from now on is is not to take your eye off the ball.
33:33Look into everything that uh any ties to Israel as far as city investments, uh companies you deal with and everything else, and consider uh divesting from anything that's connected to Israel, which is a terror state, an apartheid state and a racist state.
33:48Thank you very much.
33:51Uh Michael Porvoznick.
33:59Good evening, Mayor, Council, staff.
34:02This evening I'm here to urge you to continue development of the big branch greenway following your staff's recommended alignment.
34:09This greenway is more than a recreational path.
34:12It's a vital piece of Raleigh's active transportation network.
34:15It connects thousands of residents to the broader greenway system and provides safe direct access to Kawanis Park and Our Lady of Lords Elementary School.
34:24For families and children, this means a secure way to travel, play, and learn without relying on a car.
34:31Suggesting that pedestrians and cyclists use Anderson Drive and Six Forks Road instead is not just unrealistic, it's dangerous.
34:39These are high traffic corridors with limited pedestrian infrastructure, and we've seen this before up on Mine Creek Trail, where it ends, and Greenway users are asked to use Six Forks Sidewalk to continue north.
34:54If you tried to bike from the proposed Greenway area to Whole Foods today, you'd be putting your life on the line.
35:02Once built, this greenway will offer safe access to jobs, grocery stores, and restaurants, making it a critical link for daily life, not just weekend recreation.
35:11To quote George Costanza, we live in a society.
35:16And in a society, we make choices that reflect our shared values.
35:21Sometimes sacrifices must be made by the few for the good of the many.
35:25This is one of those moments.
35:27The safety of our children, our neighbors, and our most vulnerable road users depends on this connection.
35:33Let's not treat greenways as optional luxuries.
35:36They are essential infrastructure, just like roads.
35:40Ensure Raleigh remains a city that values safety, sustainability, and connection for everyone.
35:46Please move forward with the big branch greenway as proposed.
35:50And I urge you to not give in to hyperbole about costs and environmental factors.
35:55Trust the engineers that your staff has hired to design this greenway and move forward as proposed.
36:31I um am here also to speak to the support for the big branch uh trail.
36:39And there's so many things that have already been mentioned about the greatness of our trails, but this isn't the first greenway trail that's been built, and I have heard stories from not directly, but from a former council member who sat here and listened to all sorts of complaints about the House Creek Trail when it was being built.
37:03And the reality is that after the neighbors complained and they said, you know, we don't want this trail, the trail was built, and those same neighbors came back and they said, um, could could we please have access to that trail?
37:18So it really I think the trails are so valuable uh for so many reasons, but just in favor of them.
37:51Uh my name's Chip Thrasher.
37:53I serve on BPAC bike ped.
37:55Um I just want to express my support for the Active Mobility Plan and the downtown mobility study from earlier today.
38:03Obviously, we spent some time at BPAC talking about it.
38:06Staff has done a great job, tool design.
38:09Um, and I think I'm really excited for how we're going to move forward as a city.
38:13And actually, as a part of that, I also want to express my support for big branch Greenway recommended alignment by Park Sport.
38:50Hi, my name is Colin.
38:51Um I wanted to support my I wanted to uh voice my support for the big branch green greenway and uh emphasize the need for better greenways in our city and uh the need for better safe routes.
39:04If you've ever been to the area that is being served by this greenway, you'll know that it is very um high high-speed traffic.
39:11Um you're not going to see many people outside of cars.
39:13So I think a greenway in this area is going to do give dividends to this community.
39:19Um I think greenways provide a lot more than just recreation.
39:23They provide safe passage to um different areas in the city, uh allow for better economic activity and to provide uh independence for children that are able to get to school that way.
39:35Um I'm a pharmacist in the area.
39:38I work at Joseph's pharmacy.
39:40Um I do a lot more than just dispense drugs.
39:44I uh give wellness recommendations to people, and I feel like a lot of times when people tell me what they're doing at home, uh you know they might walk on the side of a highway, they might walk up and down the block.
39:56I think there's a lot more that more enrichment that is able to be had on a greenway.
40:01And I know biking has changed my life, and I know that a lot of people that have I've gotten into it has changed their life as well.
40:09So I like to um voice my support for better greenways in this way as well, and to provide better exercise opportunities and better better ways to get around for the general public.
40:23Uh next, Cody Stokes.
41:11Good afternoon, members of the board, city officials, and colleagues.
41:15My name is Natalie Brown, and I'm a bus operator who proudly serves the city.
41:19Every day, my co-workers and I perform one of the most essential yet often overlooked public services.
41:25We transport thousands of residents safely to work, school appointments, and home again.
41:29We do this with professionalism and pride.
41:33However, I stand before you today because the working environment for operators has become increasingly difficult and at times unsafe.
41:40Many of us feel unsupported and disrespected by those in positions of leadership who should be advocating for us.
41:47There have been repeated instances of intimidation, rebel mistreatment, and misuse of authority by our assistant general manager.
41:56Operators have reported walking away from conversations feeling demeanor, threatened, or silence.
42:02This kind of behavior undermines morale, erodes trust, and creates a hostile workplace culture.
42:07Leadership should empower employees, not intimidate them.
42:12Beyond workplace culture, safety remains our most urgent concern.
42:15Recently, a fellow operator experienced harassment and assault while performing her duties.
42:19When she defended herself, she was handcuffed and treated as the aggressor.
42:23Incidents like this expose the gaps in our safety protocols and inconsistent treatment of transit workers when they are victims of violence.
42:30Operators deserve to know, I'm sorry, yeah, that they when they are assaulted, their agency in their city will stand behind them, not turn against them.
42:41We ask for clear, consistent policies that one, protect transit employees from retaliation with reporting harassment, ensure accountability and professional professional conduct from management at all levels, establish stronger coordination with law enforcement to safeguard operators' rights during on job incidents.
42:58We are not seeking special privileges, we are seeking fairness, respect, and the right to a safe workplace.
43:03The same principles this city is sent to all public service.
43:07Bus operators are the face of this transit system.
43:10We are the ones greeting passengers every morning, helping singles bore, and ensuring our communities stay connected.
43:52Okay, James Longhouse.
43:53Um James Limehouse, as you have to see my uniform.
43:57Uh go real Will Raleigh employee.
44:00Um as you say um I might say um R ATP dev employee.
44:08But um this is the name that they see when I walk out.
44:13That's who I represent.
44:16And you know, the problem with security, it affects everyone.
44:22And one of when one of our employees or a fellow employees have problems, um, let you say the bus operators, the mechanic shop, um, utility, whatever.
44:34We are all affected.
44:35Janitorial, down the grounds, the maintenance.
44:39But we all need security.
44:41Not just downtown, but all of our facilities.
44:45They're wide open to the public.
44:47At any time, you know, people walking up on our facility at the garage, in in the shop, you know, that's that's unacceptable.
44:57And we've talked about this many a times.
45:00Well, it's time for something to be done.
45:03You know, because we deserve more than people standing around with the arm fold, not seeing us.
45:15We deserve to be seen, heard, and respected.
45:32My name is Jeffrey Hooks.
45:34I'm a professional bus operator for Go Raleigh slash Rappy Dev.
45:39I am here because I want to talk about safety.
45:45Last week we had an incident happening at work at nighttime.
45:50And it hurts my heart, you know, to hear what we had to do.
45:55But at night, my fellow some of my fellow co-workers, um, they got off work and their windows smashed out.
46:03I'm like, mm, you know, that's not normal.
46:06And then I follow one of them, they said, uh, I had to pay my own for my own window to be fixed, I don't I don't know what to do.
46:15So I asked, did it come to take care of it?
46:18They said no, we got foul on our own insurance.
46:24And um, for the safety part, when we get off work, we want to go home to our families.
46:33Families is very important to all of us.
46:36Some of this, we are some of the drivers, we are the breadwinner of our family.
46:42We want the safety for us as drivers.
46:49Our verse, our voice need to be heard clearly.
46:54It is very unacceptable for Rapp P Dev to treat us like that.
47:01They go home their families.
47:02We want to go to home our families too.
47:15My name is Archibald Gresham, and I'm here because of what's going on.
47:23Without the buses, don't nothing go.
47:27And if y'all want us to do continue to do this, then make it safe for us.
47:34We out here every day.
47:36We only get two days off a year.
47:40And y'all worried about the money.
47:43I heard one of these young men here, I'm not gonna mention your names, found five thousand dollars last year in November to do a transit service at Apex.
47:54What is that helping us?
47:58What are y'all gonna focus on us?
48:01We riding around with broken windows.
48:11You got security down there.
48:13They're not allowed to do anything because of what?
48:16When they first came, they were doing a great job.
48:19Now they're not allowed to get on the bus.
48:22So how's it security?
48:25You don't got no fences at our facility.
48:29I park my car there, I come back and it's broken windows.
48:35And the thing is, now you got a parking ride at the garage, so they can ride back to us and follow us to our car.
48:43Y'all know who we riding.
48:48Y'all want us to move it?
49:01Good evening, everyone.
49:02My name is Michael General.
49:04I stand before you guys as a professional bus operator.
49:08Yes, I came from a big city.
49:11Yes, I seen public aggression.
49:14But as our city grow, I've never seen disaggression at one of our main hogs, which is go Raleigh Station.
49:22If any of you guys ever been down there four or five in the morning, it's the liking of a third world country now.
49:29Every corner of Go Raleigh Station has feces, urine all over the place.
49:39You know, RATP dev was hired to manage us, and I don't think they, I don't think they're put in a position to protect us.
49:47So it's getting to a point now where we're getting up three, four, five in the morning, and I'm telling everybody to rest is sure the same way you come to work, get home to your family by any means necessary.
50:00And I don't know how that's gonna look for a lot of us.
50:01But when you operating as a public servant in a poverty stricken city, I don't think it's fair for me to be driving up the road moving passengers and getting cussed out and threatened.
50:16And we told to stay in our seat shut up and drive at what point do you take your seatbelt off when someone is approaching you know we had an operator who was stabbed in the seat four o'clock in the morning guy run off nothing happens.
50:32This was a 62 year operator getting ready to retire.
50:36He haven't returned back to work yet.
50:39He haven't returned back to work yet.
50:42We need on-site counseling capital police when they deal with any incident is two officers RPD when they deal with any incident it's two police officers our supervisors when they deal with an incident sometimes they are by themselves and one thing I said I'm not gonna do is leave any our female supervisor alone to deal with our passenger thank you Clifton Hill try to do this as fast as possible so bear with me.
51:35My name is Clifton Hill Financial Secretary HU 1328 my roots run deep in the state my grandmother's from Bath my mother's from Little Washington and Williamston.
51:45My father's from Harlem and I was raised in Jamaica Queens I seen so many sides of America working class the political to personal struggles I've been in transportation for 27 years New York, Jersey and North Carolina more than half my life serving the public I have seen how much operators give and how little protection they get I rep that's why I joined our union we was founded in 1892 we represent over 2000 members across U.S.
52:13and Canada we fight for safe fair and reliable transit the governor even spoke at our last AFL CIO convention which represents 15 million workers you support us we support you.
52:25Local 1328 represents the bus operators who move this city through storms holidays and COVID when others stayed home we were called the central but never treated like it.
52:35Local 1328 represents the bus operators and we face daily threats being cursed at spit on and even assaulted and when we defend ourselves we are treated like the problem how did we become the enemy our passengers have weapons our officers have weapons invest and all we have is a standwell and a will to get home safe we need rail safety we need transit police units that build relationships with operators in the community relations over intimidation maybe then when I say good morning I can get a good morning back because we are not treated like that downtown.
53:10All right we need fair investigations when operators defend themselves and the end to lowest big contracts that cut safety and benefits to save a DOM.
53:19Our next contract is coming and at this time we're coming for fairness transparency and respect.
53:24We are getting tired and ready to stand together.
53:26We want partnership justice safety good benefits and money we deserve ATU local 1328 we're not asking for favors we're asking for respect protection and fairness because we move this Robert Drakeford Robert Good evening ladies and gentlemen my name is Robert Drakeford I'm operatorslash trainer I've been doing this for about four years and seven months and it is ridiculous downtown it's just like a circus I've trained new drivers who have left because they get down there and they see what goes on and they don't feel safe right now I can't understand why it's like that you go to Durham and this is Raleigh is the capital you go to Durham Transit Center they help you don't see this they sit down there they party they smoke they drink um they do everything and it's out of control and we just need to get this under control so that we can move the city again this is Raleigh this is the capital it shouldn't look like this thank you.
55:01I'm here to speak in favor of the big branch greenway.
55:05We all know that greenways are very important to our city here.
55:10They connect our neighborhoods.
55:13They give us safe places to walk and cycle.
55:16They support our health.
55:18And they provide an alternative to driving that is safe and accessible for nearly everyone.
55:24And they're widely loved by both residents and visitors to Raleigh.
55:28However, we need to speak out for them now, and especially now.
55:32The city's Master Greenway Plan identifies the big branch tributary corridor as a key connection.
55:38It links the Crabtree Creek Greenway to North Hills and eventually Millbrook Road and beyond.
55:46So this is a critical piece of long planned infrastructure for a more connected Raleigh, and it could connect people from North Raleigh to downtown where they can work and recreate without getting on our already congested roads.
56:02Unfortunately, there's a very small group of residents, seven in total, that have been working to stop this greenway from being built near their homes.
56:12To address privacy concerns, the city has generously agreed to put up a privacy fence.
56:19I've heard some of these homeowners tonight say, well, this greenway will flood.
56:23Well, I'm an avid cyclist.
56:25I can tell you a lot of greenways are built near streams, and a lot of them flood.
56:29And walkers and cyclists are usually uh not interested in walking in the rain and flooded conditions.
56:37And the city has an excellent website that tells you when the greenways are flooded and people stay away from them during those times when they're unsafe.
56:45Um they actually make very good use of the floodplain, which it's much better use of the floodplain where people can enjoy and use the floodplain rather than having homes there that get flooded.
56:57It's much better to have a greenway flooded than a home.
57:40Uh I'd like to speak in strong support of the big branch greenway connector.
57:45Uh I live and work in the area where segment one is proposed.
57:48Uh when my partner and I bought our first home last year, proximity to Crabtree Creek Greenway was a major selling point for us.
57:56Uh three to four days a week.
57:57I go for a run on the greenway, and much of my commute takes place on the greenway.
58:02So I say all of this not as an occasional user, but someone who relies on and deeply values Raleigh's Greenway system.
58:10Uh I truly believe it is one of the city's greatest assets.
58:14Well, I'm very fortunate that my commute lines up with the Greenway.
58:17Most people are not as lucky.
58:19In order to drop off their kids at school, go to work, or run errands, they often have no choice but to drive.
58:25The big branch greenway connector can change that.
58:29By linking to North Hills and bridging the belt line, this project has the potential to transform a trail that's mainly recreation, recreational into a real transportation option.
58:40In my mind, there are two things that are really important when considering which route this greenway should take.
58:46Uh the first is safety, with 40,000 Americans dying in car crashes every year.
58:51Conflict points between cars and people need to be reduced.
58:54Every greenway or every driveway that the greenway crosses is a potential hazard.
59:00The second thing to consider is convenience.
59:02It doesn't matter how safe a greenway is if it doesn't go where people want to go, or it takes too long for them to get there.
59:10Uh adding half a mile or increasing the steepness by a few degrees may seem like a minor inconvenience, but it can be the difference between someone walking or biking or jumping in their car.
59:21So as you consider the route for this connection, I encourage you to please think about the people that will be using the screenway and to design something that is safe, direct, and truly useful.
59:47Brian McGuinness, good evening, everybody.
59:49Thank you so much for your time and your energy.
59:51I just wanted to speak to you the spark that's inside of you all to move you to be in these positions and to listen to all of us.
1:00:00I know it's a long time, but I just want to, you know, revere you for that action that you're taking and that responsibility you are taking.
1:00:05Um I'm here to speak about Israel-Palestine.
1:00:08And oh we talk about that.
1:00:11Well, how to relate it to North Carolina, we have spent 430 We have funded Israel with 432 million dollars.
1:00:19Uh America has given Israel 32 billion dollars since October 2024, 23.
1:00:25And those monies could very well be used better utilized in my opinion.
1:00:29I think most Americans' opinions uh for infrastructure, education, subsidizing uh home um child care.
1:00:37Um every many things that are here in our states.
1:00:41So that's a way to relate this the genocide and this horrible humanitarian situation in Palestine.
1:00:48And um I also want to just take I I recognize that you guys are all very busy with many, many a multitude of issues.
1:00:54So I just want to speak to you real quick to catch you off with a side of the Palestine information that you won't hear on the Western media that you know there's 17 Palestinians who have been killed since the ceasefire is started.
1:01:06Um settler violence in the West Bank has been going on for decades and it's not ceasing, it's only getting larger and larger.
1:01:13I myself was encountered by some Israeli uh settlers uh August 2024, and a military guy shot a you know a smoke canister thing right right by my face.
1:01:24Um the violence is really real.
1:01:26Um the uh the Western media isn't covering it.
1:01:30Uh Trump is speaking as if you know he's in charge of these people and their lands, and it's taking such a colonial uh you know overtaking type of tone that it's despicable.
1:01:42But many people are following what many people are backing it.
1:01:45Uh I just want to just speak those things.
1:01:47Thank you for your time.
1:01:57Good evening, Donna Bailey.
1:01:59Um, the approval of Z-12 was a huge disappointment to many of the residents in Raleigh's neighborhoods.
1:02:06What is most disappointing is that there was a workable compromise that would have respected all parties.
1:02:13Raleigh needs to do better managing growth.
1:02:16We all know that affordable housing is the number one issue in Raleigh.
1:02:21If this developer builds the proposed 900 apartments, their financial contribution from this massive project will be $1,300 per unit for affordable housing.
1:02:35I think that's an embarrassment.
1:02:38For a project, $1,300, you guys gotta do better.
1:02:43You all have the power to demand more to be done.
1:02:48If you continue at this level, we will be losing more affordable housing every year.
1:02:53Mayor Cowell, you mentioned Atlanta the other night and all the tall buildings around the belt line.
1:02:59Chat GPT says that none of the buildings around there are more than 18 stories.
1:03:04That might be wrong.
1:03:05I don't know, but that's what Chat GPT.
1:03:08On a more positive note, I'm glad you disbanded the community engagement board.
1:03:12As a past member, I can attest that this board did not improve community engagement.
1:03:17I would like to recommend that the funds and personnel be directed to the CACs, which does support real community engagement.
1:03:26If the CACs had not held a joint meeting after the staff report, the public would not have had a chance to review it.
1:03:33There is a big gap in the public getting information in the rezoning process.
1:03:38As we saw with Z-21, even with the two developer-led meetings, we were not privileged to hear all the information.
1:03:47That is where CACs are so helpful.
1:03:49We heard the cases before the planning commission, and negotiations often resulted in a better plan.
1:03:55One way to fix this is to have the staff report at the second meeting.
1:04:17I just wanted to take a moment to thank um the Gore Raleigh employees.
1:04:21They came, I know that they left.
1:04:22But as a community um, as we all are committee members here and use public transmit at times, we stand with you and I implore the council and the mayoral office to look into the legitimate grievances that they have and take immediate action to ensure the safety of our essential Raleigh City workers.
1:04:42We also need more resources for the acorns program to ensure that we reach to the root cause of issues that we have and not just criminalize those suffering with mental health issues or other health crises.
1:04:55And reaching into that, we need more affordable housing.
1:05:00I'm hoping that the new mayor that we have will help us get there instead of just working with the land developers to have more high rises.
1:05:07Trying to get one community fridge in Raleigh where food insecurity and homelessness are exponentially rising should not be as hard as it has been.
1:05:17I would like to revisit with the council if we can to try to do something at Morris Square Cafe.
1:05:23Also, I just want to say, as a middle school teacher, my students have read Medicine back this month in honor of what our indigenous communities have gone through right here in Raleigh as well.
1:05:37And hearing these stories, they themselves have felt the similarities being Palestinians, being Syrians, Lebanese, Yemen, and from other places and people that have been colonized in the past to see that the struggle of all indigenous people and reflect on how food is used as a weapon, how land is ravaged instead of protected, and how they are dehumanized and how there's biases in word choice, and you see that in print as a person with journalism background.
1:06:06I just want to say I stand in our community and grieving with everyone for the over 250 journalists that have been targeted and as well as you Jared Harbour.
1:06:33I am here to well, I came here today to speak on the big branch greenway in support of the Creekside Alignment on the connector.
1:06:43You know, Greenways, greenways really are the best, I think.
1:06:48I think most of us know that.
1:06:50And um in a city that doesn't have some great natural resource like a large river, a mountain, an ocean, our greenways have been that sort of regional draw that brings people from all over who come to experience the extensive and large greenway network that we have.
1:07:09It also is whether people are willing to acknowledge it or not.
1:07:13A transportation network, and a lot of people use it to get from point A to point B for work, for school, and even for just rec you know recreation to go to a different restaurant or something like that.
1:07:25And I was in the work session, um, which uh by the way, I'd love to hear about the new uh active mobility plan.
1:07:32Uh councilmember Jones had a question specifically about how we're going to how is that um the the big jump of 50 uh 50 miles in five years going to connect residents in Briar Creek.
1:07:46Staff said, well, we're going to create those connections in that area and that lead them to the greenway.
1:07:52Well, if that greenway is not connected and not complete, bringing people to downtown, they're gonna basically reach a dead end and not be able to get anywhere.
1:08:02Um it's really important to see that these connections actually happen.
1:08:08Uh as I'm running out of time, uh I did not know about all the grievances that the Go Raleigh bus drivers had.
1:08:15That's news to me, and I grew up being told that you say thank you when you exit the bus.
1:08:22And I feel like at a leadership level, we need to be saying thank you.
1:08:31Thank you for those comments.
1:08:47Polite nods immediately followed by votes against the will of the community by previous council is the reason why those of you who know me haven't seen me in a while, because political theater sucks.
1:08:59But tonight I'm back, not for me, but for my neighbors.
1:09:03This is about survival.
1:09:05For Southeast Raleigh for small businesses like the Black Farmers Hub on Cross Street, this is a matter of life and death.
1:09:12The Black Farmers Hub is more than a market.
1:09:14It's the heartbeat of Southeast Raleigh, feeding our community with culture, connection, and fresh locally grown produce.
1:09:22They recently received a notice from Total Pay, which is the system that processes EBT and WIC benefits, warning that during the government shutdown, transactions would be suspended.
1:09:33So just imagine the panic that ensued.
1:09:36But thankfully, some divine intervention occurred and the system was up and running shortly thereafter.
1:09:40But what if it hadn't?
1:09:42In Southeast Raleigh, where rezoning after rezoning is driving out legacy residents, where the BRT rezoning that nobody asked for will worsen this food desert and where affordability is already out of reach, losing access to EBT benefits would be catastrophic.
1:10:00The Black Farmers Hub isn't just a business, it's a lifeline.
1:10:04It feeds families who cannot easily access fresh fruits and vegetables because food lion is too far.
1:10:11So when that warning came, I emailed counsel immediately.
1:10:14But when no one even acknowledged in my email, the message was clear.
1:10:18This community is still on its own.
1:10:21Here's what I'm asking for, and please don't say this is out of your jurisdiction.
1:10:25Council, you have power.
1:10:27I'm asking you to use it.
1:10:29I'm asking you to create a local contingency plan to protect small businesses and families when federal systems fail.
1:10:39This store is going to collapse.
1:10:43If you guys don't do something, please.
1:10:45Southeast Raleigh cannot afford another crisis, and this council cannot afford to stay silent.
1:11:15Good evening, everybody.
1:11:17My name is Tania Hubbard.
1:11:18I'm from the Alcohol Drug Council in North Carolina, and this is my colleague Ashley.
1:11:25In 2023, North Carolina recorded its highest overdose rate since 2010, with an estimated of 4,042 deaths, about 12 deaths per day, more than double the rate of any vehicle fatalities.
1:11:39Fentanyl related deaths rose by 23 percent from 2022 to 2023, and 80 percent of the overdose deaths involve multiple substance multiple substances.
1:11:50At least 50 percent of people with an SUD disorder have a co-occurring mental illness.
1:11:57Only 50 percent of individuals in North Carolina have access to the care that they need for SUD and mental health issues.
1:12:04Starting October 1st, 2025, the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services implemented reimbursement rate reductions for Medicaid providers due to a $319 million shortfall in the state budget.
1:12:18Access to mental health and substance use disorder services has remained a critical challenge in Raleigh and in Wake County.
1:12:25Vulnerable populations, including individuals experiencing homelessness, face systemic barriers such as fragmented care, transportation issues, and financial constraints.
1:12:39We seek partnership and funding support, expand capacity and multilingual services, mental health, and SUD issues.
1:12:46Develop a no-wrongdoor navigation model for Raleigh residents, and launch community care coordination pilot integrating mental health, SUD and social services.
1:12:57Alcohol and Drug Council of North Carolina serves as a central hub for behavioral health navigation, offering helpline and digital access.
1:13:04We have a 24-7 confidential helpline connecting individuals to treatment, recovery housing, and crisis services.
1:13:12We have an online resource directory for mental health and substance use providers.
1:13:26If you have a written statement too, that would be helpful just to know all the and thanks for your emails too.
1:13:38My name is Will Hooker.
1:13:39I'm a landscape architect and an emeritus professor for MC State, where I taught landscape design for over 35 years.
1:13:47There is an issue concerning Dix Park, which I believe is short-sighted, very ill-advised, and which would represent an extremely bad precedent for the future of Dix Park.
1:13:58Some want to put condominiums in the park.
1:14:02Central Park in New York City is the best urban park in the U.S.
1:14:07and one of the best in the world.
1:14:10And it is a model for what for what Dick's Park could become.
1:14:14Central Park was started in the 1850s, and since its inception, there's been pressure for more commercialization.
1:14:22Thankfully, this has been thwarted.
1:14:28Allowing Central Park to be what it was intended to be, a place to offer a retreat from noise, pollution, and overcrowding.
1:14:35This is also what Dix Park should be.
1:14:37And with Raleigh being one of the fastest growing cities in the country, every square foot of land is precious.
1:14:45One of the problems of concern here relative to the park is symbolic ownership.
1:14:54And that is when people live near something, they feel like they own it.
1:15:00And this would be a problem with people trying to come to the park to use the park on any land that is near these condominiums, because they would be invading it.
1:15:13This this would be a major travesty and would make the park unattractive for most of us normal folks.
1:15:20Please, please do not allow condominiums to be built in the park.
1:15:24Thank you very much.
1:15:57Um I'm here to request the city look into emotional intelligence assessments and training for the city staff.
1:16:04To not point fingers at any particular person or department, I think it's something that should be done across all city departments.
1:16:16The long story short was after I had a chance to speak with them, she he said they threatened to hit him.
1:16:35Now, as a parent coach, you know that's very triggering to me.
1:16:38Now I'm not here to proclaim that wisdom is some angelic child.
1:16:45All the things a mentally healthy child should be and do.
1:16:49So this seems a really like a really harsh punishment for him trying to reenact a scene from Bluey where bingo is trying to get water from a water fountain and she overflows it to drink from it.
1:16:59If you know, you know.
1:17:01Now this might alarm you and even seem dangerous, but the fountain was outside.
1:17:06Again, this is a very b abbreviated version of the story.
1:17:10I'm not going to blow up this individual, but I will say that if they the if they did that to wisdom, not believing he would say anything to me, then who else are they talking to like that?
1:17:20No child should be threatened with any get you, especially in our parks.
1:17:25Of all places, they should of all places, they should be yet another safe space to be in.
1:17:46Thank you, and good night.
1:17:52That concludes our public comment for this evening.
1:17:55Thank you all for coming out.