OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Sand City, California/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Sand City City Council Meeting - September 16, 2026

City Council — Wednesday, September 16, 2026
BodySand City, California
SessionCity Council
DateWednesday, September 16, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 3:32:23

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it
0:32

I actually went for the data on them.

1:13

Yes, good afternoon, everyone.

1:21

Thank you for joining us here today and welcome to San City's regular city council meeting at Tuesday, September 15th, 2026.

1:31

This meeting is being held virtually and in person and is compliant with AD 2449 signed into law September 13th of 2022, which a man's government section code 54953 by authority for public agencies to continue to hold virtual meetings and remain compliant with the ground app.

1:53

At this time, uh the information is posted on the uh our website uh how to if you'd like to join uh via Zoom also by telephone or here in person.

2:09

So once again, thank you everyone for being here.

2:12

And um with that um members of the public may uh will attend the board meeting and speak to the board when the chair polls for public comment, public comments may be made either in person virtually or email and um um if it was sent in that information should have been to the city clerk, I think Monday morning, which uh which I believe uh the clerk has received a warning to uh public speakers that San City is committed to civility and is mindful of its responsibility to protect the workplace and environment so to ensure civility in its public meetings and the public that the public is encouraged to engage in respectful dialogue that supports freedom of speech and values, diversity of opinion.

3:10

With that, I will uh look to the city clerk.

3:13

Carrie, can he call the role, please?

3:15

Mayor Carbone here, Vice Mayor Diaz here, council member Adams present, council members gotter here, all present.

3:23

Okay, thank you.

3:24

And with that, I'd like to ask uh council member Skedter if she would do us the honors to invit us in the budget late.

3:33

And if you'd like to join us, please speak in clouds the United States of America stands when the issues indivisible thank you.

3:56

With that, uh, we'll go to announcements by the uh mayor, city attorney, and city manager.

4:04

And uh with that, uh there is a mayor's report.

4:08

My report is on the table over there if you'd like um like a copy, and there's also in front of the council a copy.

4:17

Um I can I did a kind of condensed version of my report.

4:22

So um just to touch on a couple items.

4:26

So Monterey Salinas Transit Agency, uh recent regional agency meeting highlighted uh major local governments developments, including Monterey Salinas Transit adopting ordinance 2026 statue one to establish border-facing camera enforcement for transit lanes and uh over at Monterey One Water.

4:52

Uh they uh they it was pretty much common uh household items.

5:00

They had uh had talks spoken on um Monterey One Water Advanced Infrastructure and Chemical Supply Contracts, and over at Ambard, uh they've ratified a new memorandum of understanding with their local union 521 through 2029, and all those can be all this information is in the meeting notes there at the table under the mayor's report.

5:30

Um also uh the Monterey County Mayor's Association bat September 4th and Greenfield to address community initiatives and key state legislative updates.

5:42

Uh they had a um presentation for restorative justice, which uh I I believe we uh we are doing a ordinance for or a resolution for this evening.

5:57

So that's in your packet.

5:59

And um also legislative update.

6:04

Um the Anna Sassons for the California League.

6:08

Um uh she presented on AB 1383 and proposed changes to PEPRA, public employees retirement benefits for format, noting that if an active bill is expected to increase long-term pension costs and liabilities for state and local governments.

6:28

Um and uh that is about it.

6:31

There's a couple handouts uh regarding the Ligate City Conference, uh, the small cities, um, postal cities if anyone would like it.

6:41

And I have a coffee for Debica.

6:44

Uh also uh an upcoming event for Indigenous People's Day and Sand City at the Art Park if anyone would like it.

6:52

Can that information is there also, and with that will alternate up with our city manager.

6:58

Thank you, Mayor.

7:00

Um just wanted to update you on aligning I brought to your attention at previous meetings, which is the D Cell facility, continues to be offline.

7:10

I have had quite a few communications with uh Spencer Bartanian, the uh director of operations for the Central Coast section.

7:20

And um Calam is working closely with the Division of Drinking Water to be able to satisfy these new regulations, permit conditions that were imposed upon them.

7:33

Um and um it looks like they have they have come to an agreement that Division of Drinking Water will issue a letter which will constitute a kind of waiver of those conditions.

7:46

So I will keep you updated, but I don't have a definitive date that the D Cell facility moved back online yet.

7:54

Um and then one of the few other things, MST closures.

8:01

The longest closure that I've been sort of warning you about is happening on Sunday, and it's gonna be essentially they call it a 72-hour closure, but it goes from a 72 cloud 72-hour closure straight into a night closure.

8:16

So it's really more like I don't know, 86 hours something, but it is from Sunday at about 7 p.m.

8:23

until Thursday morning at 7 a.m.

8:25

And that is the section of playa between California and Belmonte that will be closed during that time.

8:32

And they will provide you know detour signage and so on.

8:38

Um they've been pretty good about notifying the public.

8:42

Um they've notified everybody, all the businesses with the shopping center and neighboring impacted residences, although there are not that many in that area.

8:52

Um cities coming right up.

8:56

Um I know you all go to some wonderful educational classes.

8:59

Um I would not be attending, but the administrative services manager order Craig will be.

9:04

Um and just on the general plan update, um, we did have the business round table last Wednesday.

9:13

It's great to see so many different businesses uh come out for that.

9:17

Um, you know, great mix of big and small representatives from Brandon Rock came down from San Jose, Lockheed Sloveny to some of the arts businesses like uh Monterey Glassworks um was out here.

9:32

We got the mails from some of the artisans and artists in town, which is all you know, wonderful input as we move the general plan update forward.

9:41

Um, and then just a few last things, upcoming dates for your calendars.

9:46

The um on the 19th, that's the Saturday at 10 a.m.

9:52

at the end of playa, surf rider, save off shores, and the California Coastal Commission are arranging a beach cleanup.

10:04

Um and then also on the 19th, 11 to 5 p.m.

10:08

is the open studios.

10:09

It's the last weekend.

10:11

And Monterey Glasswork for South California Avenue.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Public Safety██████████████████████22%
Arts And Culture███████████████████19%
Public Engagement███████████████15%
Transportation Safety█████████████13%
Technology and Innovation██████████10%
Procedural█████5%
Engineering And Infrastructure████4%
Water And Wastewater Management████4%
Affordable Housing██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Sand City City Council Meeting - September 16, 2026

The Sand City City Council held a regular meeting on September 16, 2026, at 5:45 PM. The meeting included presentations on the Monterey Regional Airport update and the Automated License Plate Recognition (ALPR) system, as well as action items on a water allocation, adoption of a Vision Zero Safety Action Plan, and selection of a muralist for the Granite Rock batch plant. Public comments addressed concerns about affordable housing parking, ALPR data privacy, and mural design.

Consent Calendar

  • Four consent items were approved unanimously without discussion or public comment.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Luke Kilpatrick, a candidate for city council, requested that Councilmember Kim Scudder be disqualified as a write-in candidate pending a legal opinion on a potential conflict of interest related to the August 18, 2026 decision on moving forward with the election. The city attorney acknowledged receipt and said the review is underway.
  • A resident expressed concerns about the affordable housing project at the Art Park, noting that the proposed mixed-use development had no parking, which he argued is unrealistic given retail failures in Sand City. He urged the council to require parking even if it reduces units.
  • Greg Hotmar (former councilmember) expressed strong support for the ALPR system, citing its effectiveness in solving crimes, and stated confidence that the police chief would not share data with ICE.
  • Patrick (resident) raised concerns about Flock's data management and security, proposing that the city explore local server-based ALPR systems instead of cloud-based ones. He noted Flock's history of sharing data with federal agencies and suggested an RFP for alternative vendors.
  • Brian Clark expressed concerns about Flock monetizing data and called for more local control.
  • Richard Garza, applicant for the water allocation, did not speak. Brian Clark requested that any impact fees for Mr. Garza be waived.
  • Brad Sonders from Sculpture Works initially inquired about the mural item but deferred to the proper agenda item.
  • Multiple residents spoke on the mural: the arts committee chairman defended the selection process and artist Leon Keer; a local artist supported the revised design; Mia (a child resident) expressed her love for the revised mural with an octopus; and another resident argued against micromanaging the artist.
  • Tom Jacobson (online, from the Monterey Tides Hotel) voiced support for the mural.

Discussion Items

  • Monterey Regional Airport Update: Chris Morello, Executive Director, presented an overview of the airport's operations, master plan, and $200 million modernization program ("Monterey Metamorphosis"), including a new terminal, taxiway relocation, and sustainability initiatives. No action was taken.
  • Automated License Plate Recognition (ALPR) System Presentation: Police Chief David Honda and Chief Assistant District Attorney Berkeley Brandon presented on the history, legal framework, benefits, and community concerns regarding ALPR cameras. The system has been operational since May 2024 and has assisted in solving numerous cases (e.g., 11 stolen vehicle recoveries, 14 theft cases, 33 hit-and-run collisions, and recent stabbing and armed robbery cases). The district attorney highlighted the technology's role in solving major crimes. Council discussed data retention (currently 30 days), sharing agreements (8 agencies signed), and concerns about Flock's terms of service and data security. A future council meeting will consider contract renewal.
  • Water Allocation for Catalina Lofts (401 Elder Avenue): Staff recommended allocating 0.085 acre-feet of water to satisfy a Monterey Peninsula Water Management District notice of noncompliance. The project had been approved in 2013 for eight residential and seven commercial units; two commercial units were later converted to ADUs, increasing fixture units. A new condition of approval was added to ensure all utility fees are paid. The resolution was approved unanimously.
  • Vision Zero Safety Action Plan Adoption: The Transportation Agency for Monterey County (TAMC) presented the plan, which aims to eliminate traffic fatalities and serious injuries by 2040. Sand City reported zero fatal or serious injury crashes from 2019–2023. The plan includes a safe systems approach, community engagement, and identified emphasis areas (intersections, pedestrians, bicyclists). Council adopted the resolution unanimously after discussion about a stop sign and safety concerns at Tyoga Avenue and the overpass.
  • Mural Selection for Granite Rock Batch Plant: The Arts Committee recommended artist Leon Keer for a large-scale commission mural. Staff presented two revised designs: Design 1 (revised original with toys, local elements like an octopus and truck) and Design 2 (office supply objects). Granite Rock approved Design 1. Public comment included strong support for Design 1 from many residents and arts committee members, while Councilmember Adams reported a poll of 45 residents showing 30 preferred the toys design, 9 the office design, and 7 neither. The council voted to approve Design 1.

Key Outcomes

  • Consent Calendar: Approved unanimously.
  • Water Allocation Resolution: Approved (motion by Councilmember Diaz, second by Councilmember Adams) with an amended condition of approval. Vote: unanimous.
  • Vision Zero Safety Action Plan Resolution: Approved (motion by Councilmember Adams, second by Councilmember Diaz). Vote: unanimous.
  • Mural Selection: Approved Design 1 (revised) as presented by Talking Walls (motion by Councilmember Diaz, second by Councilmember Adams). Vote: majority in favor (one councilmember expressed preference but did not vote against).
  • Future Items: ALPR contract renewal to be discussed in October; staff to follow up on stop sign analysis for Tyoga Avenue; mayor to explore signage for mural artist credits.

Meeting Transcript

I actually went for the data on them. Yes, good afternoon, everyone. Thank you for joining us here today and welcome to San City's regular city council meeting at Tuesday, September 15th, 2026. This meeting is being held virtually and in person and is compliant with AD 2449 signed into law September 13th of 2022, which a man's government section code 54953 by authority for public agencies to continue to hold virtual meetings and remain compliant with the ground app. At this time, uh the information is posted on the uh our website uh how to if you'd like to join uh via Zoom also by telephone or here in person. So once again, thank you everyone for being here. And um with that um members of the public may uh will attend the board meeting and speak to the board when the chair polls for public comment, public comments may be made either in person virtually or email and um um if it was sent in that information should have been to the city clerk, I think Monday morning, which uh which I believe uh the clerk has received a warning to uh public speakers that San City is committed to civility and is mindful of its responsibility to protect the workplace and environment so to ensure civility in its public meetings and the public that the public is encouraged to engage in respectful dialogue that supports freedom of speech and values, diversity of opinion. With that, I will uh look to the city clerk. Carrie, can he call the role, please? Mayor Carbone here, Vice Mayor Diaz here, council member Adams present, council members gotter here, all present. Okay, thank you. And with that, I'd like to ask uh council member Skedter if she would do us the honors to invit us in the budget late. And if you'd like to join us, please speak in clouds the United States of America stands when the issues indivisible thank you. With that, uh, we'll go to announcements by the uh mayor, city attorney, and city manager. And uh with that, uh there is a mayor's report. My report is on the table over there if you'd like um like a copy, and there's also in front of the council a copy. Um I can I did a kind of condensed version of my report. So um just to touch on a couple items. So Monterey Salinas Transit Agency, uh recent regional agency meeting highlighted uh major local governments developments, including Monterey Salinas Transit adopting ordinance 2026 statue one to establish border-facing camera enforcement for transit lanes and uh over at Monterey One Water. Uh they uh they it was pretty much common uh household items. They had uh had talks spoken on um Monterey One Water Advanced Infrastructure and Chemical Supply Contracts, and over at Ambard, uh they've ratified a new memorandum of understanding with their local union 521 through 2029, and all those can be all this information is in the meeting notes there at the table under the mayor's report. Um also uh the Monterey County Mayor's Association bat September 4th and Greenfield to address community initiatives and key state legislative updates. Uh they had a um presentation for restorative justice, which uh I I believe we uh we are doing a ordinance for or a resolution for this evening. So that's in your packet. And um also legislative update. Um the Anna Sassons for the California League. Um uh she presented on AB 1383 and proposed changes to PEPRA, public employees retirement benefits for format, noting that if an active bill is expected to increase long-term pension costs and liabilities for state and local governments. Um and uh that is about it. There's a couple handouts uh regarding the Ligate City Conference, uh, the small cities, um, postal cities if anyone would like it. And I have a coffee for Debica. Uh also uh an upcoming event for Indigenous People's Day and Sand City at the Art Park if anyone would like it. Can that information is there also, and with that will alternate up with our city manager. Thank you, Mayor. Um just wanted to update you on aligning I brought to your attention at previous meetings, which is the D Cell facility, continues to be offline. I have had quite a few communications with uh Spencer Bartanian, the uh director of operations for the Central Coast section. And um Calam is working closely with the Division of Drinking Water to be able to satisfy these new regulations, permit conditions that were imposed upon them. Um and um it looks like they have they have come to an agreement that Division of Drinking Water will issue a letter which will constitute a kind of waiver of those conditions. So I will keep you updated, but I don't have a definitive date that the D Cell facility moved back online yet. Um and then one of the few other things, MST closures. The longest closure that I've been sort of warning you about is happening on Sunday, and it's gonna be essentially they call it a 72-hour closure, but it goes from a 72 cloud 72-hour closure straight into a night closure. So it's really more like I don't know, 86 hours something, but it is from Sunday at about 7 p.m. until Thursday morning at 7 a.m. And that is the section of playa between California and Belmonte that will be closed during that time. And they will provide you know detour signage and so on. Um they've been pretty good about notifying the public. Um they've notified everybody, all the businesses with the shopping center and neighboring impacted residences, although there are not that many in that area. Um cities coming right up. Um I know you all go to some wonderful educational classes. Um I would not be attending, but the administrative services manager order Craig will be. Um and just on the general plan update, um, we did have the business round table last Wednesday.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com