OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - May 6, 2021

Government Audit and Oversight CommitteeThursday, May 6, 2021
BodySan Francisco, California
SessionGovernment Audit and Oversight Committee
DateThursday, May 6, 2021
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
0:04

Good morning.

0:06

This meeting will come to order.

0:07

Welcome to the May 6th, 2021 regular meeting of the government audit and oversight committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors.

0:16

I am Supervisor Dean Preston, Chair of the Committee.

0:19

I am joined today by Vice Chair Supervisor Connie Chan and Committee Member Supervisor Rafael Mandelman.

0:28

The committee clerk is John Carroll, and I want to thank SFGov TV for staffing this meeting.

0:34

Mr.

0:34

Clerk, do we have any announcements?

0:36

Yes, thank you, Mr.

0:37

Chair.

0:38

In order to protect the public, board members, and city employees during the COVID-19 health emergency, the Board of Supervisors Legislative Chamber and Committee Room are closed.

0:47

This precaution is taken pursuant to all various local, state, and federal orders, declarations, and directives.

0:53

Committee members will attend the meeting through video conference and participate in the meeting to the same extent as if they are physically present.

0:59

Public comment will be available for each item on this agenda.

1:02

Both San Francisco Cable Channel 26 and SFGov SFGOVTV.org are streaming a public comment call-in number across the screen at this time.

1:12

Your opportunity to speak and provide your comments during any of today's public comment periods will be available to you via phone by dialing.

1:19

415 65501.

1:23

Following that, you'll be prompted to uh into the meeting ID, which is 1871 six one four one seven seven.

1:32

Following that, you'll be prompted to press the pound symbol twice to be connected to the meeting.

1:37

When you are connected, you will hear the meeting discussions, but your line will be muted and in listening mode.

1:43

When your item of interest comes up, dial star followed by three to be added to the speaker line.

1:48

A system prompt will then indicate that you have raised your hand.

1:51

Please wait until the system indicates that you've been unmuted and you may then begin your comments.

1:55

Best practices are to call from a quiet location to speak clearly and slowly and to turn down your television, your radio, or your streaming device.

2:04

Everyone must account for potential time delays and speaking discrepancies that we may encounter between live coverage and streaming of the meeting.

2:11

Alternatively, you may submit your written public comment in either of the following ways.

2:15

You may email me.

2:16

My name is John Carroll, and I'm the clerk of the government audit oversight committee.

2:20

My email address is J-O-H-N period C A R R O L at SFGOV.org.

2:29

Alternatively, you can send your written public comment to our office in City Hall.

2:34

Our office is room 244.

2:37

City Hall's addresses one, Dr.

2:39

Carlton B.

2:40

Goodlit Place, San Francisco, California 94102.

2:44

Of course, all this contact information is available on the front page of our agenda for today's meeting as well.

2:49

And Mr.

2:50

Chair, finally, items acted upon today will appear on the Board of Supervisors Agenda of May 18th, 2021, unless otherwise stated thank you, Mr.

3:00

Clerk.

3:01

Please call the first item.

3:03

Agenda item number one is a hearing on the investigation of complaints of substandard living conditions at Plaza East and discussions of proposed plans for the property.

3:12

Members of the public who are interested in providing public comment on this hearing should call for public comment number and I'll repeat it because now is the time to do so.

3:20

415 65501.

3:25

The meeting ID is 187-161-4177.

3:29

Press the pound symbol twice and then press star, followed by three to enter the line to speak.

3:36

A prompt that informs you your line has been unmuted, and that will be your opportunity to provide your comments, Mr.

3:40

Chairman.

3:43

Thank you, Mr.

3:44

Clerk.

3:45

And I received petitions from over 30 of my constituents who live at Plaza East in the Fillmore.

3:56

And today, at their request, uh we are holding this uh this hearing.

4:03

Um I'm pleased to be moving forward with this informational hearing.

4:08

Um to address the current conditions at uh Plaza East and the plans for the property, both in terms of um uh immediate repairs and the in terms of the longer term plans uh for Plaza East.

4:23

So our purpose in having this hearing is to honor the request of residents that this uh be heard and and more attention focused on the plight of residents of Plaza East and also to increase transparency, accountability, um, and make sure that the residents of Plaza East are healthy and safe.

4:47

Um it's also essential, in my opinion, that we recognize and note the significance of housing for the African American community in San Francisco at a time when we have seen so much displacement of African Americans from San Francisco and uh in recent history from uh the Fillmore district.

5:12

Sadly, up till now, Plaza East has too often been a story of government neglect of displacement.

5:22

And now in recent years with the federal government really abandoning and abandoning its role in many ways in public housing.

5:30

The risks and concerns that can be raised with privatization.

5:42

And we'll hear more detail from presenters, but did want to just give some basic information to get us started.

5:48

So it was built in 56.

5:51

It was in 2001, it was rebuilt by McCormick Barron and Salzar, who will be presenting today under Hope 6.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Public Housing█████████████████████████████████33%
Affordable Housing████████████████16%
Public Health████████████12%
Public Comment█████████9%
Housing█████████9%
Electric Service Regulation████████8%
Community Engagement███3%
Housing Authority███3%
Procedural██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - May 6, 2021

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on May 6, 2021, to conduct three agenda items: a hearing on substandard living conditions at Plaza East, a resolution urging utility debt forgiveness and extension of the shut-off moratorium, and a reenactment of emergency hazard pay for grocery and pharmacy workers. The committee heard presentations from city departments, developers, and advocates, and received extensive public testimony.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Plaza East Hearing (Item 1): Multiple residents and advocates expressed frustration with living conditions, management communication, and past displacement. Some supported the current resident council, while others felt it did not represent them. Several callers urged that future redevelopment be led by residents and include affordable housing, not market-rate units. Others called for independent investigation of construction and maintenance negligence.
  • Utility Debt Resolution (Item 2): One caller criticized the city's lack of empirical data on environmental and utility issues, alleging corruption at SFPUC.
  • Hazard Pay Ordinance (Item 3): Supporters (UFCW members and representatives) urged extension, citing ongoing risk and the need to compensate essential workers. Opponents (California Retailers Association, California Grocers Association, and a local grocer) argued the pandemic is abating, the ordinance harms businesses, and it should be allowed to expire.

Discussion Items

  • Item 1: Plaza East Hearing – Chair Preston opened with a history of the property and recent developments: a $2.7 million emergency repair loan, withdrawal of the HUD demolition application, and a planned property management transition to John Stewart Company. Presentations were made by:
    • San Francisco Housing Authority (Director Tanya Ladiju) and MBS (Adi Nagraj, Tony Salazar): Described the property's chronic underfunding, deferred maintenance, and plans for short-term repairs and long-term reimagining with resident input. They emphasized the application to HUD was a funding mechanism, not a decision to demolish.
    • Department of Building Inspection (Luis Barahona): Reported 35 housing complaint cases over 15 years, with challenges in tracking violations and communication.
    • Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (Lydia Ely): Detailed the $2.7 million emergency loan conditions, including a scope of work prioritizing life safety, and oversight mechanisms.
    • Housing Rights Committee (Salimon Hyatt): Criticized the lack of genuine tenant participation, arguing that resident councils and listening sessions do not constitute community-led decision-making.
  • Item 2: Utility Debt Resolution – Presented by Supervisor Chan, with data from SFPUC (Michael Himes) showing >16,800 residential and 1,700 commercial CleanPowerSF customers 90+ days delinquent (as of March 29, 2021). LAFCO (Brian Goebel) presented research on the inadequacy of state programs and recommended the resolution urging the Governor and CPUC to extend the moratorium and forgive debt.
  • Item 3: Hazard Pay Reenactment – Presented by Nali G (Chief of Staff for President Walton). The ordinance requires grocery/drug stores with 500+ employees to pay $5/hour extra until June 15, 2021, to align with the state's planned reopening. Supporters argued the pandemic is not over, while opponents cited San Francisco's yellow tier status and economic impacts.

Key Outcomes

  • Item 1: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue the hearing to the regular Government Audit and Oversight Committee meeting on June 17, 2021, for an update on repairs and resident engagement plans.
  • Item 2: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend the resolution to the full Board of Supervisors.
  • Item 3: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward the emergency ordinance reenactment as a committee report to the May 11, 2021 Board of Supervisors meeting.

Meeting Transcript

Good morning. This meeting will come to order. Welcome to the May 6th, 2021 regular meeting of the government audit and oversight committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors. I am Supervisor Dean Preston, Chair of the Committee. I am joined today by Vice Chair Supervisor Connie Chan and Committee Member Supervisor Rafael Mandelman. The committee clerk is John Carroll, and I want to thank SFGov TV for staffing this meeting. Mr. Clerk, do we have any announcements? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. In order to protect the public, board members, and city employees during the COVID-19 health emergency, the Board of Supervisors Legislative Chamber and Committee Room are closed. This precaution is taken pursuant to all various local, state, and federal orders, declarations, and directives. Committee members will attend the meeting through video conference and participate in the meeting to the same extent as if they are physically present. Public comment will be available for each item on this agenda. Both San Francisco Cable Channel 26 and SFGov SFGOVTV.org are streaming a public comment call-in number across the screen at this time. Your opportunity to speak and provide your comments during any of today's public comment periods will be available to you via phone by dialing. 415 65501. Following that, you'll be prompted to uh into the meeting ID, which is 1871 six one four one seven seven. Following that, you'll be prompted to press the pound symbol twice to be connected to the meeting. When you are connected, you will hear the meeting discussions, but your line will be muted and in listening mode. When your item of interest comes up, dial star followed by three to be added to the speaker line. A system prompt will then indicate that you have raised your hand. Please wait until the system indicates that you've been unmuted and you may then begin your comments. Best practices are to call from a quiet location to speak clearly and slowly and to turn down your television, your radio, or your streaming device. Everyone must account for potential time delays and speaking discrepancies that we may encounter between live coverage and streaming of the meeting. Alternatively, you may submit your written public comment in either of the following ways. You may email me. My name is John Carroll, and I'm the clerk of the government audit oversight committee. My email address is J-O-H-N period C A R R O L at SFGOV.org. Alternatively, you can send your written public comment to our office in City Hall. Our office is room 244. City Hall's addresses one, Dr. Carlton B. Goodlit Place, San Francisco, California 94102. Of course, all this contact information is available on the front page of our agenda for today's meeting as well. And Mr. Chair, finally, items acted upon today will appear on the Board of Supervisors Agenda of May 18th, 2021, unless otherwise stated thank you, Mr. Clerk. Please call the first item. Agenda item number one is a hearing on the investigation of complaints of substandard living conditions at Plaza East and discussions of proposed plans for the property. Members of the public who are interested in providing public comment on this hearing should call for public comment number and I'll repeat it because now is the time to do so. 415 65501. The meeting ID is 187-161-4177. Press the pound symbol twice and then press star, followed by three to enter the line to speak. A prompt that informs you your line has been unmuted, and that will be your opportunity to provide your comments, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Clerk. And I received petitions from over 30 of my constituents who live at Plaza East in the Fillmore. And today, at their request, uh we are holding this uh this hearing.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com