The San Francisco Police Commission met on February 8, 2023, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included discussions on overdue policy revisions, a surveillance camera policy update, public safety reports, and budget presentations for the SFPD and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA). The commission voted to approve the SFPD’s proposed budget for fiscal years 2024-2025 and held a closed session.
All right, the chair has called the meeting to order. If you could please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. Pledge of allegiance. To the Republic for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible liberty and justice for all. Please. Commissioner Walker. Commissioner Benedict. Present. Commissioner Yanias. President. Commissioner Vern. Here. Commissioner Yi is in route. And Vice President Carter Overstone, you have a quorum. Also here with us tonight, we have Chief William Scott who was appearing virtually, as well as Assistant Chief David Lazar and Executive Director Paul Henderson from the Department of Police Accountability. Great. Welcome everyone. For members of the public, just want to advise on a couple changes to the agenda. So item five, the MOU with the district attorney's office is going to be taken off the agenda today. And the commission to consider, and the chief will give an update on the status of the negotiations during his chief's report. Chief Scott will be joining us remotely for a portion of today's meeting. And so we're going to take a couple of items out of order that Chief Scott's going to speak on so that he can speak on them first because he is on the East Coast. So with that, we are going to start with item number six, please. Line item six discussion of deadlines per DGO 3.01 written communication system for revision of DGO 8.10 guidelines of First Amendment activity, 6.18 warrant arrests, and 9.03 mandatory blood test for drivers under the influence at the request of the commission discussion. Thank you. So I asked for this item to be placed on the agenda a few weeks ago, and just wanted to provide some background and context on this issue. So it was a few months ago now that Director Henderson highlighted for the commission that there were 26 DGOs that had been started the revision process but had been stalled, despite the department having received uh recommendations from DPA. In response to that, and I should say some of these some of these DGOs were most were stalled for over a year, some even over two years. First, President Elias assigned to each commissioner each one of these DGOs, such so that each commissioner had personal responsibility to shepherd the DGO through the revision process and ensure that timelines were being met. Secondly, um last year, DGO 3.01 became effective. And what DGO 3.01 does is that it it sets it sets out an explicit step-by-step process for how DGOs are to be revised. It sets strict timelines for each step along the process. Now, while the timelines are strict, they are not completely inflexible. The DGO does allow for either DPA or the department to seek an extension of time if they feel they're not able to meet a deadline, and they just have to describe explain why there's good cause to receive an extension. Back when we had our original meeting many months ago to discuss the 26 stall DGOs, many of us were, including myself, many of us were very critical of Chief Scott for the unexplained delay. Because it's ultimately our responsibility as the oversight body to ensure that policy revision is happening on time. And so when we have instances, as in as in the case of DGO 810, uh, where deadlines are not being met, it's the commission's responsibility to inquire into why that is, especially when there's there's been no request or no timely request for an extension of time. Um and then I should also say, in addition to 810, Commissioner Benedicto had, I think, similar issues and asked for some other DGOs to also be placed on the agenda. So we'll have an opportunity to discuss those two. Um if it's all right, Commissioner, I'll start with 810 and then you can take it away. All right. Um Sergeant, could you put the uh the graphic up? All right, so um I just wanted to so as part of this inquiry into DGO 810, I asked for the department and DPA to provide the commission with the relevant emails uh that took place between between them as it relates to the revision of the DGO. And this just highlight this just outlines the timeline of those emails. So on October 27th, DPA requested certain documents from the department that it needed to uh make its phase one recommendation grid. Um there was no response as far as I can tell to that email. On November 3rd, DPA sent the department its phase one recommendation grid. That act under 3.01 triggered a December 6th deadline for the department to respond to that recommendation grid. Um on November 22nd, uh there was a follow-up email from DPA because it had not received any response to this point.