Note: The agenda and transcript indicate the meeting was originally scheduled for December 5, 2023, but the instruction for this summary requires the date December 11, 2023. The content below reflects the actual discussion from the December 5 meeting.
The Police Commission held a special meeting to consider going into closed session to discuss collective bargaining with the San Francisco Police Officers Association (POA) regarding proposed Department General Order (DGO) 9.07 on pretextual traffic stops. The meeting included public comment on that matter, a vote to enter closed session, and a subsequent vote on disclosure of closed-session discussions.
So you have representative? Yes. And I apologize for being late. Okay, we are recording. Are you ready to begin? I am. Thank you. The president has called the meeting to order. All that are able to, would you please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the CLAC of the United States of America and to the Republic. Which stands one nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice. Yes, please. We have President Elias with us. Max Carter Overstone. Carter Oberstone present. Commissioner Yi is excused. Commissioner Byrne is excused. Commissioner Jesus Yannis. Commissioner Yannis present. Commissioner Kevin Benedicto. Benedicto present. Commissioner Walker is excused. And I am Sergeant Reynolds in for the president, not the president. The police commission secretary. So you have a quorum, Commissioner. Thank you very much. Thank you, everyone, for being here. My apologies for being late. Can we call the matter, please? Line item one, public comment on all matters pertaining to item three below, closed session. Including public comment on item two. Vote whether to hold item three in closed session. So we will start. Sorry. Go ahead. We'll start with public comment. Each member is allowed two minutes for comments. Good afternoon. Thank you. The police should be able to stop a vehicle if they have reason to believe it was violating a traffic law or any law, even for low-level infractions. Do you want to officially create a two-tiered system where only law abiding San Franciscans do things like keep their registration up to date and their tail lights fixed? Because I believe this will happen if all laws are not enforced. And eventually there will be fewer and fewer of those law-abiding people once they realize they're the only ones doing the abiding. Registration and taillights. These may seem like unimportant details that would probably be okay to overlook, but they are not. Broken tail light is unsafe. Both tail lights actually have to be in working order for public safety. When you're behind a car that is unable to signal because their taillight broke two months ago and they didn't bother to get it fixed because they weren't compelled to. How is that fair or safe for the driver behind them who has no clue that they plan to turn? If it's a matter of money, there are a variety of ways that the DMV can help people who have difficulty paying for their registration.