This meeting of the San Francisco Police Commission on February 21, 2024, featured discussions and actions on several key items, including a presentation on Automated License Plate Recognition (ALPR) cameras, a Department of Police Accountability (DPA) audit of SFPD's misconduct handling, and a vote on Department General Order (DGO) 9.07 restricting pretext stops. The commission also heard public comments, received the Chief's report, and the DPA Director's report, and held a closed session.
Chief Scott reported crime statistics: shooting victims down 14% year-to-date, homicides down from 7 to 3, firearm recoveries at 115, with zero ghost gun recoveries. He detailed incidents including non-fatal shootings, a carjacking, elder abuse, and a pursuit from South San Francisco. The chief also addressed questions about autonomous vehicles: SFPD does not routinely receive video from autonomous vehicle companies, and the city lacks jurisdiction to restrict them on narrow one-way roads. He noted a pro-Palestine ceasefire demonstration with an estimated 500 participants that did not result in injuries or arrests.
Executive Director Henderson reported 89 cases opened, 96 closed, 305 pending. 12 cases sustained, 1 mediated. 32 cases past 270-day period (22 tolled). 10 cases awaiting disposition from commission, 96 from chief's office. Allegations: 26% for conduct unbecoming an officer. Highest allegations from Southern and Mission stations.
Lieutenant Springer presented two cases: one from 2017 where an officer-in-training fired one shot through a patrol car window, killing a suspect who ran toward the vehicle. The board found proper conduct except for seat belt violation. The second case involved an off-duty officer's accidental discharge of a firearm at home (no injuries). The board found improper conduct for unsafe firearm handling. No in-custody deaths were presented.
Assistant Chief Lazar presented a plan to fund 400 ALPR cameras via a $15.3 million BSCC grant for organized retail theft prevention. Installation costs: $335,000; operating costs: $1.2 million/year for 3 years (total $3.935 million). Cameras will be placed at high-traffic intersections, covering about 1.5% of the city's 6,399 intersections. Usage will comply with Section 19B of the Administrative Code: only for stolen vehicles, AMBER Alerts, criminal investigations, and emergencies. No facial recognition, no traffic enforcement, no data sharing for immigration. Data retained for 1 year (5 years if evidence). Training anticipated within 60-90 days. The department hopes to launch in first half of 2024.
Audit Director Flaherty presented the final audit with 31 recommendations. Key findings: SFPD does not track key dates to ensure investigations are completed within the one-year statute of limitations; lacks consistent approach for bias-related misconduct; fails to comply with public reporting requirements (e.g., Administrative Code Chapter 96); and station captains did not follow policy to identify trends and develop prevention plans. SFPD concurred or partially concurred with 26 recommendations, did not concur with recommendations on setting time frames for chief's hearings and clarifying implicit bias handling. Commissioner Elias emphasized the need for follow-up and reporting. Commissioner Benedicto noted that permissive access for DPA to SFPD's benchmark system could address many data issues.
Vice President Carter Oberstone moved to adopt the DGO, noting it deprioritizes nine vehicle code infractions that have no public safety benefit (e.g., license plate and registration tag stops, where arrests occur in less than 1% of cases). He stated the policy was developed through extensive public input including over a dozen town halls, a working group, and hundreds of comments. Commissioner Benedicto seconded, adding that the policy is about prioritization, not banning enforcement, and that 25% of officers' time is spent on low-value stops. Commissioner Walker expressed concerns about state preemption, the POA's threat of litigation, and whether the policy would reduce racial disparities (citing LA's camera-based approach). Commissioner Byrne requested going into closed session for legal advice. Commissioner Yee questioned why the vote was scheduled before closed session. After public comment, the commission voted 4-3 to adopt DGO 9.07 (yes: Carter Oberstone, Benedicto, Yanyez, Elias; no: Walker, Byrne, Yee). The motion included a 90-day training period (with possible 30-day extension).
Vice President Carter Stone like to take roll. Please. Commissioner Walker. Present. Commissioner Benedicto. Present. Commissioner Yanyez. Commissioner Yanyez, are you present? Yeah, someone. Commissioner Byrne. Here. Commissioner Yee. Here. Uh Vice President Carter Overstone, you have a quorum. Commission uh President Alliance is in route. Also with us tonight, we have Chief Scott from the San Francisco Police Department and Executive Director Paul Henderson from the Department of Police Accountability. Sergeant, could you call the first item, please? Line item one, general public comment. At this time, the public is now welcome to address the commission for up to two minutes on items that do not appear on tonight's agenda but are within the subject matter jurisdiction of the police commission. Under police commission rules of order during public comment, neither police or DPA personnel nor commissioners are required to respond to questions by the public, but may provide a brief response. Alternatively, you may submit public comment in either of the following ways. Email the Secretary of the Police Commission at SAPD.commission at sfgov.org, or written comments may be sent via U.S. Postal Service to the public safety building located at 1245 Third Street, San Francisco, California, 94158. If you would like to make public comment, please approach the podium. Good evening, Commissioners. My name is Charlotte, and I'm a lifelong resident of San Francisco. And I have some sentiments to express regarding this Commission's years-long meddling in the ability of San Francisco Police Department to enforce the law against people who make amoral choices that violate the peace and rights of our bodies, our property, and our environment. Far too many DGOs are oriented toward impeding law enforcement, ostensibly to help us, but the consequences are clear. A demoralized and undermined police force in a city abused and beleaguered by rampant crime and filth. On March 5th, San Francisco voters are faced with a choice of either ushering in invasive high-tech to help police fight crime or continue in the vein of a hobbled police force. I place full fault fault squarely on the commission for putting us in this voter's dilemma. You've done a major disservice to the people of San Francisco with your holier than thou vision of the anointed. Hi, my name's Ashley Westinger. And with that, I'd like to discuss the special patrol police that I expanded in the uh neighborhood due to the fact that we nobody really had a patrol in the area. We're a high-profile shopping area. We have the Palace of Fine Arts. And could everybody please look at me when I'm talking? Because I really mean I came down here from my husband's sick. I took the time out, and I would like you to get off your phones and listen to what I have to say. You have this uh patrol police has been a hundred and sixty-eight years in this city. And now all of you are going to end it. That's not acceptable because let me tell you what they mean to us. They are family. They're friends. They're there when you pick the phone up. There's a lot of old people living in the marina. One of which, for example, is a 68, 87-year-old woman who is living alone, whose lights went off. And she called Alan Bard, and within two minutes he was in the house because she thought somebody had broken into. He went up at a 10-foot ladder and found out that it was a fuse that was broken. There's people that go away.