The San Francisco Police Commission met on October 16, 2024, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included an In Memoriam tribute, public comment, approval of a consent calendar, reports from the Chief and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), commission reports, a presentation on DPA’s DataSF transparency initiative, and a detailed discussion regarding the dissolution of SF SAFE and the status of its former programs. The meeting also included a closed session (Item 11) and a vote on disclosure of that session.
Chief’s Report (Item 4): Chief Bill Scott reported a 32% decrease in all Part 1 serious crimes year-to-date compared to the previous year (about 14,000 fewer crimes). Violent crime was down 14%, property crime down 34%, and car break-ins down 57% (nearly 10,000 fewer incidents). Gun-related homicides were down 38% (18 year-to-date vs. 29 last year), and total homicides were down 42% (25 vs. 43). He also noted:
DPA Director’s Report (Item 5): Acting Executive Director Diana Rosenstein reported that the DPA opened 16 new cases and closed 13. Year-to-date, they have sustained 46 cases, with 118 sustained cases pending before the Chief and 9 pending before the Commission. The Stop Data Audit exit interview is scheduled for October 28.
Commission Reports (Item 6):
Presentation of DPA’s DataSF Charts (Item 7): Nicole Armstrong (Director of Operations) and Eric Ho (IT Director) presented the DPA annual report and a new public data sharing initiative. The data portal, launching Friday, will provide weekly updates on case openings, closures, allegations, findings, and demographics, with interactive dashboards. The DPA also highlighted its award-winning audit work, policy recommendations, and successful internship program (12 field trips, 22 guest speakers in 2023).
Presentation on SF SAFE and Neighborhood Safety Team (Item 8):
President Lyons, like to take roll? Please. Commissioner Clay. Present. Commissioner Walker. Present. Commissioner Benedicto is excused. Commissioner Yanyez. President. Commissioner Yee. Sure. Vice President Carter Oberstone is in route. President Alliance, you have a quorum also with us tonight. We have Chief Scott from the San Francisco Police Department and Acting Executive Director Diana Rosenstein from the Department of Police Accountability. Hello, everyone, and welcome to our October 16th meeting. Sergeant, can you please get us going? Line item one in Memoriam. Sergeant Rennie Nielsen, star number 1882, Richmond Station. Good evening, Captain Manning. Good evening. Madam President, Honorable Commissioners, Chief Scott, Acting Director Rosenstein, members of the public. My name is Chris Canning. I am the Captain and Commanding Officer of Richmond Police Station. It's an honor for me to stand before you tonight to recognize a member of Richmond Station. I'm particularly humbled, given the circumstances, to stand before you and introduce our honoree, Sergeant Rennie Nielsen. Tragically, Sergeant Nielsen recently passed away and here with me to accept Sergeant Nielsen's recognition posthumously as his wife, Jeannie. Jeannie, may I tribe to stand with me, please? Thank you very much. Sergeant Nielsen loved being a police officer. He entered the San Francisco Police Academy in 2006, completed his field training at Mission Station, successfully completed probation at Central Station, and remained there for his permanent assignment. Sergeant Nielsen accepted transfer to Richmond Station in 2014 before he was promoted to sergeant a year later. Sergeant Nielsen served Terravel and Southern Stations as a sergeant before taking a transfer to Richmond Station in 2018, where luckily for us at the Richmond he remained. Accolades of Sergeant Nielsen's work are plentiful in preparing these remarks. There were many. One of the most recent commendations that Sergeant Nielsen received was from a member of the Richmond community who learned that Sergeant Nielsen, while on mobile patrol, observed an elderly resident caught in a bus shelter during a torrential rainstorm. Sergeant Nielsen didn't hesitate. He stopped and gave the grateful resident a ride home a mile or so away. Were it not for an observant citizen who emailed me about Sergeant Nielsen's act of kindness, we never would have known about it. And this was not uncommon for Sergeant Nielsen. He didn't do things to get recognized. He did what he felt was right. Sergeant Nielsen's service wasn't limited to members of the community. He cared deeply about the officers at Richmond Station that he supervised and whom he served. One example was his commitment to fitness. Sergeant Nielsen took it upon himself to organize and update the Richmond Station gym, even with uh his and Jeannie's own personal equipment. It wasn't long before numerous officers at Richmond Station became involved in their own fitness journey. There was an interesting phenomenon that I observed, particularly with officers that worked for Sergeant Nielsen on his shift. When they suffered minor uh work-related injuries on duty, they fought to recover as soon as possible. And that's the kind of leader that Sergeant Nielsen was. If officers weren't at work, they felt that they were missing out.