OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/San Francisco, California/Police Commission
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - October 21, 2026

Police Commission — Wednesday, October 21, 2026
BodySan Francisco, California
SessionPolice Commission
DateWednesday, October 21, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 1:13:05

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

0:00

Why is it that no commissioner on this board commented or inquired into SFPD lying about when officers issued dispersal orders at Stutt Alley when I have brought this to your attention at every commission meeting since this information became public?

0:14

Why do we still not know how many officers were present during that 22-minute active enforcement window at Transmarch?

0:19

How can a dead ankle monitor escalate into Edwin Michael Adams, a father, being killed by being tackled into a bus stop?

0:28

How can the department this commission overseas so casually claim that the vile assault of Kevon Gibson was within the bounds of reasonable force?

0:36

Is there such a deficit in reasonable policy in this department, let alone the city's governance, that these acts of grave brutality can stand?

0:45

We all heard speakers last week talk about how a police force is only as effective as the trust community's place in it.

0:52

How does the exponential expansion of surveillance programs, not to mention passing that miserable DGO last week, curtail the potential for abuse or foster any sense of trust in either SFPD or its oversight committee?

Unassigned speaker

1:05

Well,

Speaker 1

1:05

I understand that the Board of Supervisors still needs to vote to enact this DGO.

1:09

The fact that only one person on this board voted against this measure speaks to either bureaucratic impotence or an eagerness to legalize and sanction abuses by the very department this commission is supposed to monitor.

Speaker 2

1:28

Um I wanted to play this video again.

Unassigned speaker

1:32

I need the other part of it.

Unassigned speaker

1:35

So if you can help me,

Speaker 2

1:38

what do I do?

1:39

Just put the mic down here, or are you gonna turn it up?

Speaker 3

1:41

You don't need to put the mic down.

1:42

You don't once you hit play, it'll you'll hear the sound.

Unassigned speaker

1:45

So

Speaker 2

1:45

just do it now.

Speaker 3

1:46

Yes.

Speaker 4

2:01

My baby.

Speaker 2

2:04

My son's there as lifeless.

2:06

These are the other unsolved homicides.

Speaker 5

2:11

Since 2004, San Francisco has experienced an unprecedented number of homicides.

Speaker 2

2:17

This is our documentary, and I'm only showing three minutes of

Unassigned speaker

2:21

it.

Speaker 2

2:34

Just showing what mothers and fathers had to go through marching for their children and trying to get justice.

Speaker 5

2:54

Living in neighborhoods of scarcity and neglect, must deal with their personal tragedies while at the same time facing the crime and violence of the unsafe neighborhoods that surround them every day.

Speaker 2

3:39

I'll show the other half later.

Unassigned speaker

3:41

Thank you.

Speaker 6

3:53

Good evening.

3:55

Thank you for letting me address the committee.

3:58

I have been a resident in the city for 20 years, 17 years in the exact same location.

4:03

I live below the castro at church and market.

4:08

I had no problems up until five or six years ago.

4:11

I then was arrested illegally three times, 5150 four times illegally.

4:18

I have a letter from Mr.

4:19

Henderson that is basically a falsified government document.

4:25

I would have liked to have been much better prepared, but I heard you're going to be here tonight, sir.

4:29

I thought I would come down.

4:31

You have an employee by the name of Ellen Delees.

4:35

I've had a case open for 1,100 days.

4:38

I have seven different cases.

4:53

I have all the records.

4:55

I will probably be back.

4:56

I'm a little nervous.

Unassigned speaker

5:00

I have sent the receipts for what Ms.

Speaker 6

5:02

Cahill had alleged for Mr.

5:05

Henderson to the mayor first.

5:08

He denied

Unassigned speaker

5:09

them.

Speaker 6

5:09

I sent them to Mrs.

5:12

Cahill.

5:13

She didn't want them.

5:14

I sent them to the retired, I'm sorry, the chairman of the committee.

5:20

My name is John Savoya.

Speaker 7

5:22

I'm a sex offender

Speaker 6

5:23

from 30 years ago.

5:25

I was profiled by the police in the mission and in Park County.

5:33

Very serious.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Police Oversight█████████████████████████████████████████41%
Procedural████████████████████████24%
Public Safety████████████████████20%
Public Comment████████████12%
Crime Statistics██2%
Sexual Assault Prevention█1%
Summary of Proceedings

San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - October 21, 2026

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, October 21, 2026, to hear public testimony, receive departmental reports, and vote on revised general orders. The meeting covered the consent calendar, the Chief's crime trends report, the DPA Director's quarterly report, the adoption of several revised Department General Orders, and a closed session followed by a disclosure vote.

Consent Calendar

  • The Commission voted 3-2 to receive and file the semi-annual Sexual Assault Evidence Kit report covering January 1 through June 30, 2026. Commissioners Lowe and Laias voted no, saying they wanted a full SVU presentation before accepting the report. Commissioner Tackey requested a full SVU presentation before the end of the year, and Chief Liu agreed to arrange it.
  • Public speakers Ivy Lee (Director, Mayor's Office for Victims' Rights) and Lila Carrillo (Director, SHARP) expressed support for Chief Liu's collaboration and asked for a full hearing on recommendations from prior sexual assault investigation discussions.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • A commenter criticized the Commission and SFPD over dispersal-order details at Stutt Alley, unanswered officer-count questions from Trans March, the death of Edwin Michael Adams, the assault of Kevon Gibson, surveillance expansion, and a previously passed DGO, expressing distrust in SFPD and its oversight.
  • A public commenter identifying himself as John Savoya alleged illegal arrests, unlawful 5150 holds, a falsified government document, and no DPA responses on seven cases; he also said DPA's average cost to finish a case is $11,000 and that CAD reports can be falsified.
  • Jessica Pesco expressed support for the Commission, said police should be held to the same standard as sheriffs, hoped for a pay increase, and urged on-scene evidence collection and more staffing.
  • A commenter raised concerns about the upcoming Trans March town hall, including delay in scheduling and the use of police headquarters as an intimidating venue, and cited inadequate SFPD training, including missing youth training and insufficient LGBTQ training at Trans March.
  • A commenter described the ongoing trauma of homicide survivors, including her personal loss, and the role of community support and the healing circle.
  • A District 10-focused commenter acknowledged citywide decreases in property, violent, and gun crime and noted homicides at 22 year to date, but argued District 10 needs consistent, measurable progress and said a 2023 safety plan with shared metrics, quarterly reports, hotspot patrols, and multi-agency response did not appear implemented by October 2026.

Chief's Report

  • Chief Liu reported that a Trans March community engagement meeting will be held Tuesday, November 24 at 6 p.m. at police headquarters, and invited commissioners to the Medal of Valor Awards on November 4.
  • Crime statistics: part one crime is down 17 percent year to date compared with 2025, violent crime is down 10 percent, property crime is down 19 percent, and homicides are at 22 year to date, matching 22 in 2025. He detailed an October 16 homicide on the 1100 block of Wisconsin with a juvenile arrested October 17, an October 13 non-fatal shooting, and an October 15 arrest in an October 1 Bayview homicide.
  • Regarding the Board of Supervisors sexual assault hearing, Chief Liu said closure rates around half the national average are matters of concern, and described commitments to stronger supervisory controls, regular meetings with advocates, improved audit processes, and a timeline for action items.
  • Chief Liu highlighted SFPD's partnership with the Police Activities League (PAL), which serves nearly 1,200 youth each year through more than 100 volunteer coaches and mentors, including an October 13 food delivery to St. Anthony's dining room.
  • Commissioners Lowe and President Clay commended the Chief's presentation and the Department's approach at the hearing.

DPA Director's Report

  • DPA Director Henderson reported completion of the Q3 2026 report: complaints rose from 263 in Q2 to 307 in Q3, an increase of more than 17 percent; comparing Q3 2024 (175) with Q3 2026 (307) yields an increase of about 75 percent.
  • DPA launched a redesigned weekly activity report with graphics, automatic translation into 15 languages, print capability, and automated data flows.
  • During the reporting week, DPA opened 17 new cases and closed 21; the most common allegation was failure to take required action or neglect of duty.
  • Director Henderson announced upcoming station visits and DPA's presentation at the NACOL conference on November 8. Commissioner Laias asked whether Trans March complaints were mostly in Q2 or Q3; Henderson declined to guess.

Discussion Items

  • DGO 3.01 Department Written Directives: Staff said the order went to meet and confer on June 10, the process concluded the week of October 5, and no amendments were added. The Commission adopted the revised DGO with a December 7 effective date on a 4-1 vote, with Commissioner Laias dissenting.
  • DGO 6.05 Death Cases: The order went to meet and confer on June 17; an amendment requiring a field supervisor to authorize leaving a death scene was approved. The Commission adopted the revised DGO with a December 7 effective date on a 5-0 vote.
  • DGO 5.14 Interagency Operations: Captain Mason described the revision as a streamlining of the interagency form and protocol. The Commission voted 5-0 to advance the revised order to meet and confer with affected bargaining units.
  • DGO 8.11 Investigations of Officer-Involved Shootings and Firearm Discharges: Lieutenant Lisa Springer said the order was last updated in September 2005 and that 26 public comments led to additional revisions. Proposed updates addressed the District Attorney's Office MOU, Cal DOJ involvement, interview procedures, and San Mateo County authority over airport OIS incidents. After DPA Director Henderson raised concerns about DPA notification and access at SFO, the Commission approved the order 5-0 with amendments, including revised OIS/OID definitions, language that an involved and able-bodied member shall not have their firearm removed until range staff provide a replacement, and DPA language allowing DPA to seek access from appropriate San Mateo County authorities for OIS at SFO.

Closed Session

  • The Commission held a closed session under agenda Item 12 and, after returning to open session, voted to disclose the discussion held in closed session. No substantive details of the closed session were provided in open session.

Key Outcomes

  • Adopted DGO 3.01 (4-1), DGO 6.05 (5-0), and DGO 8.11 (5-0, as amended); advanced DGO 5.14 to meet and confer (5-0).
  • Received and filed the sexual assault evidence kit report on a 3-2 vote despite two no votes requesting an SVU presentation first.
  • Directed that an SVU presentation to the Commission be scheduled before the end of 2026.
  • Set the Trans March community engagement meeting for Tuesday, November 24 at 6 p.m. at police headquarters.
  • Voted to disclose closed-session discussion.

Meeting Transcript

Why is it that no commissioner on this board commented or inquired into SFPD lying about when officers issued dispersal orders at Stutt Alley when I have brought this to your attention at every commission meeting since this information became public? Why do we still not know how many officers were present during that 22-minute active enforcement window at Transmarch? How can a dead ankle monitor escalate into Edwin Michael Adams, a father, being killed by being tackled into a bus stop? How can the department this commission overseas so casually claim that the vile assault of Kevon Gibson was within the bounds of reasonable force? Is there such a deficit in reasonable policy in this department, let alone the city's governance, that these acts of grave brutality can stand? We all heard speakers last week talk about how a police force is only as effective as the trust community's place in it. How does the exponential expansion of surveillance programs, not to mention passing that miserable DGO last week, curtail the potential for abuse or foster any sense of trust in either SFPD or its oversight committee? Well, I understand that the Board of Supervisors still needs to vote to enact this DGO. The fact that only one person on this board voted against this measure speaks to either bureaucratic impotence or an eagerness to legalize and sanction abuses by the very department this commission is supposed to monitor. Um I wanted to play this video again. I need the other part of it. So if you can help me, what do I do? Just put the mic down here, or are you gonna turn it up? You don't need to put the mic down. You don't once you hit play, it'll you'll hear the sound. So just do it now. Yes. My baby. My son's there as lifeless. These are the other unsolved homicides. Since 2004, San Francisco has experienced an unprecedented number of homicides. This is our documentary, and I'm only showing three minutes of it. Just showing what mothers and fathers had to go through marching for their children and trying to get justice. Living in neighborhoods of scarcity and neglect, must deal with their personal tragedies while at the same time facing the crime and violence of the unsafe neighborhoods that surround them every day. I'll show the other half later. Thank you. Good evening. Thank you for letting me address the committee. I have been a resident in the city for 20 years, 17 years in the exact same location. I live below the castro at church and market. I had no problems up until five or six years ago. I then was arrested illegally three times, 5150 four times illegally. I have a letter from Mr. Henderson that is basically a falsified government document. I would have liked to have been much better prepared, but I heard you're going to be here tonight, sir. I thought I would come down. You have an employee by the name of Ellen Delees. I've had a case open for 1,100 days. I have seven different cases. I have all the records. I will probably be back. I'm a little nervous. I have sent the receipts for what Ms. Cahill had alleged for Mr. Henderson to the mayor first. He denied

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com