Syracuse Planning Commission Meeting - August 18, 2025
Syracuse Planning Commission Meeting - August 18, 2025
The Syracuse Planning Commission met on August 18, 2025, to consider a range of land use applications including zoning text amendments, subdivisions, special use permits, and site plan reviews. The meeting began with a moment of remembrance for former member Dr. Ruben Cowert. Commissioners approved multiple items, held one application for further review, and took action on two three-mile limit cases.
Consent Calendar
- Minutes of July 28, 2025: Approved unanimously.
Public Comments & Testimony
- Lafayette Hills Estate Project (MASPR-25-13): Kathleen Stribley (316 Monasolo Drive North, Syracuse) spoke in opposition, citing concerns about stormwater pond lining, water table issues, traffic impacts, and segmentation of the project. She noted the project's density and potential impacts on the Valley neighborhood. Another speaker, Jim Calasharino (140 Lafayette Road), expressed concerns about water pressure and traffic congestion. The applicant responded, stating they would line the ponds, work with the city on traffic, and address water pressure.
- Taste of Brooklyn Restaurant (4141 South Salina Street): Multiple speakers spoke in favor, including Councilor Peter Pani Awa (at-large), Bernard Alex (National Action Network), and members of the Minority Entertainment Coalition who highlighted the need for black-owned businesses, job creation, and community investment. Opponents included Kathleen Stribley, Robin Baker (123 Fillmore Ave), and Rhonda Visi (117 Seneca Drive), who cited noise, late-night hours, and past problems with the previous bar. The applicant, Chanel Pickard, expressed willingness to meet with neighbors and address police recommendations.
Discussion Items
- Text Amendments Z-2880 (Rezoning): The commission reviewed updated language for the PID section and other changes. A motion was made to approve the package of text amendments with the exception of Table 2.15G, which would remain unchanged. The motion passed unanimously, sending the amendments to the Common Council.
- Resubdivision R-25-3 (500 Seymour Street): Catholic Charities seeks to subdivide a parcel into two lots: one for a residential building (to be sold) and one for a commercial building (retained). The commission approved the subdivision after a negative SEQRA declaration, with a condition to file within 62 days.
- Special Use Permit SP-25-19 (2000 South Ave): The applicant sought a special use permit for a certificate of use for an existing building with six residential units (four vacant) and a commercial space. The commission approved the permit with five conditions, including no tobacco sales, no window signage, and sidewalk repair.
- Municipal Parking Lot Project (SP-25-22 / MASPR-25-17, 1171 West Fad Street): A 100-space municipal parking lot for police and fire departments. Commissioners added a condition for bicycle parking (one rack per six spaces). Approved with six conditions.
- Lafayette Hills Estate Master Plan (MASPR-25-13, 555 Lafayette Road): A 263-unit first phase of a lifestyle community on the former golf course. After a detailed SEQRA review led by staff, the commission issued a negative declaration and approved the master plan. The project will return for future site plan reviews for each phase.
- South Av Apartments (MASPR-15-16 / R-25-40, 680 South Av): An 8-unit lot combination to create 51 mixed-income units. The commission conducted a SEQRA review and issued a negative declaration but held the application pending a Board of Zoning Appeals decision on a building length variance.
- Icon Lofts (MASPR-25-1-2, 311 Ganant Drive): A 75-unit rehabilitation of a historic building with 73 parking spaces. The commission approved the site plan with four conditions, including landmark preservation approval and coordination with DOT for the I-81 project.
- Taste of Brooklyn Restaurant (4141 South Salina Street): The applicant proposed a restaurant (no alcohol) with hours 6 a.m. to 2:30 a.m. (takeout after 10 p.m.). Police SEPTED recommendations were not fully addressed. After extensive public comment, the commission chose to hold the application to allow the applicant to meet with neighbors, revise the SEPTED response, and reconsider operating hours.
- Three-Mile Limits: Two cases were approved: 3S-25-08 (4774 Cleveland Road / 4848 West Seneca Turnpike, Town of Onondaga) and 3S-25-10 (500-02 Old Liverpool Road, Town of Salina). Both had city engineer approval.
Key Outcomes
- Text Amendments Z-2880: Approved and forwarded to Common Council.
- Resubdivision R-25-3: Approved with condition to file within 62 days.
- Special Use Permit SP-25-19: Approved with five conditions.
- Municipal Parking Lot SP-25-22 / MASPR-25-17: Approved with six conditions.
- Lafayette Hills Master Plan MASPR-25-13: Approved after negative SEQRA declaration.
- South Av Apartments: SEQRA negative declaration issued; application held for BZA action.
- Icon Lofts MASPR-25-1-2: Approved with four conditions.
- Taste of Brooklyn Restaurant: Application held for further work by applicant.
- Three-Mile Limits: Both approved.
The meeting adjourned at approximately 9:55 p.m.
Meeting Transcript
Oh, you know, yeah. Uh yes. Yeah. Jennifer. Good evening, everyone, and welcome to this meeting of the Syracuse Planning Commission. Uh, we'll begin our business and our uh public hearings in just a moment. Before we do that, though, I do want to note the passing and acknowledge the many contributions of a former member of this body, um, namely Dr. Ruben Cowert, who passed away last month, served the city for many ye many, many, many years through his work on this body, and I hope that his tireless work will serve as an inspiration to those to the rest of us to look for and take part in meaningful opportunities to serve our community. So thank you for bearing with me as I note that note that um piece of news, and now we will move to our agenda for this evening. Our first order of business is action on the minutes of our meeting in late July, July twenty-eighth. Those minutes have been distributed in advance to the commission members. Move approval of the minutes of July twenty-eighth, twenty twenty-five. Thank you. Second. Aye. Those opposed, please say nay. Any abstentions? Uh, member of the staff will call the applications who in order for our hearings this evening. Just by way of process for those who are not familiar with our um public hearings, as each in the as each application is announced, we ask that the applicant or the representative come forward to the podium in the center of the room, provide their name and address, and then a brief summary of the application. Following questions from the commission members, we will then invite members of the public who wish to speak in favor of the application to come forward to do that, providing their name and address for the record. And we will also provide an opportunity for those who wish to speak in opposition to the application to come forward and do that as well. We ask that all speakers, either for or against to hold their comments to no more than three minutes, uh, so that everyone can have a chance to speak, and also realizing that we have these um chambers for only a limited amount of time this evening, and we want to get through all of our agenda items this evening. So with that, we will turn our attention to the first item on the agenda, which is uh old business. First up is the text amendments to rezone the city of Syracuse zoning ordinance and official map Z-2880. Um just a quick recap summary for the commission members. Um commission made a motion that we would conditionally approve uh the proposed amendments with uh the condition that we work on the PID section um uh um from any concerns that were had, uh namely from uh Sergio's university, and we've done that, and I believe we're at the point now where we are ready to move forward with the exception of um holding on any proposed uh changes to table 2.15 G. Uh so it's two point table 2.15 subsection G, we will hold on any proposed amendments for the time being on that. It'll it'll remain the same as is uh today, but everything else is ready to move forward. Okay, okay. Thank you for the update. We have the uh updated information in front of us and distributed. Um there any questions from the commission members when we took action last time, we advanced a motion and said we would recommend going forward with everything but the PID section. So do you recommend that we now entertain a new motion? Um you might want to modify it because the language in the PAD section is different. Um most of it was posted online, but there were some modifications today. Um most notably the last page of this, and you can modify your motion to I did it so that it's by article section, subsection number. You just do that stuff. Um this was not posted because it's brush. Um you can read it into the record if you want. There's a public review copy here available. And so as the maker, I believe. Just yeah. So everything in purple on there is the substantial revision since last time in the whole document. So they were the blue is what was here last time. The purple is changed, and the red is even additional. Okay, so I'm so can they can the could they make a motion if they choose to uh include all the changes in this handout? Yes. And that would have that would that includes leaving table 2.15 G subsection G it's as is as is now it's corrected in this document. So maybe you can just take it easy and if you choose to just say all the proposed changes in this document. Okay, which will be posted online, and there's public review copy here if anybody wants to look at it.
openpublica.com