The Napa Planning Commission held its final regular meeting of 2022 on December 15, 2022, at 5:30 PM in City Hall Council Chambers. The meeting was brief, with the only substantive agenda item—a conditional use permit for Silicon Valley Bank—moved to the consent calendar and approved without public testimony. Commissioners also reviewed the 2023 meeting calendar, received updates from staff, and reflected on the year’s accomplishments. Consent Calendar - Approved the Planning Commission regular meeting minutes for September 15, 2022 and October 20, 2022. (Commissioner Huether recused himself from the September minutes, noting he was not present at that meeting.) Consent Hearings - Silicon Valley Bank Conditional Use Permit (1300 First Street, Suite 332): The commission moved this item from the public hearing to the consent calendar by a unanimous vote. The permit authorizes a bank use in a downtown commercial zone; no exterior modifications are proposed. The project is exempt from CEQA under Section 15301 (existing facilities). The commission approved the permit on the consent calendar, with one commissioner (apparently in jest) stating “I opposed.” The item was approved and the applicant was wished success. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public spoke during the public comment period for non-agenda items or on the consent hearing item. Administrative Reports - Council Updates: Staff reported that the Lone Oak subdivision was approved by the City Council the previous week by a 4-1 vote (Councilmember Alessio opposed, citing concerns about house size and ADU pad compaction). The condition requiring a compacted ADU pad was removed, but utility hookups remain in place to allow future ADU placement anywhere on the lot. - 2023 Planning Commission Calendar: The proposed 2023 meeting schedule (first and third Thursdays) was presented for review. Commissioners noted that terms for Chair Huether and Commissioner Huether (likely a reference to the same) expire at the end of 2022, but they will continue serving until the council appoints replacements. - Commissioner Applications: Staff reminded that applications for the Planning Commission were due the following day (December 16, 2022). As of the meeting, three complete applications had been received (from Gordon Huether, Bob Massaro, and Alan Delore) and two were in progress (from Miranda Clark and Deanna Aronoff). Comments by Commissioners and Staff - Each commissioner offered reflections on the year. Commissioner Hurtado (likely Huether) thanked colleagues and staff for progress. Commissioner Shotwell appreciated the satisfaction of completing the General Plan update. Vice Chair Massaro noted the team’s cohesion through COVID and praised the chair’s leadership. Commissioner Kelly highlighted the General Plan work as a high point and the importance of setting aside personal agendas. - Chair Huether announced three priorities for the coming year if reappointed: (1) field trips to review completed projects and compare them to approved plans, (2) a deep dive into updating design guidelines with illustrations, and (3) a downtown specific plan workshop to revisit topics such as pedestrian zones (Fußgängerzone). He also noted that after 18–20 years, this would likely be his last term. Key Outcomes - Approved the consent calendar (minutes of September 15 and October 20, 2022). - Approved the Silicon Valley Bank conditional use permit (PL22-0123) as a consent hearing item. - Received and filed the 2023 Planning Commission calendar. - No formal action was taken on commissioner comments; the meeting adjourned with a gavel after the chair’s closing remarks.
Public Meetings - Napa, California
Public Meetings - Napa, CaliforniaThe Napa Planning Commission met on November 17, 2022, at 5:30 PM in City Hall Council Chambers. The meeting covered routine consent calendar items, two major public hearings (Lone Oak Subdivision and Clay Street Care Facility), and commissioner comments. Key actions included recommending approval of the Lone Oak Subdivision with conditions and approving the Clay Street Care Facility use permit. Consent Calendar - Unanimously approved the Planning Commission Regular Meeting Minutes of September 1, 2022. Public Comments & Testimony Lone Oak Subdivision: - Rose Jager (neighbor representative): Urged the commission to include a pedestrian/bike path connecting Grove Avenue to Lone Oak Avenue, citing general plan goals for connectivity and safety. Filed a letter with photo comparisons of similar paths in Napa. - Tom Andrews (neighbor and retired contractor): Opposed a path due to past criminal activity (dumping, encampments) and advocated limiting construction access to Lone Oak Avenue to protect the creek from vibration and potential cave-ins. Supported the project and praised the removal of the path option. - Neil Colwell (neighbor, 2560 Bradford Street): Supported the path for broader community connectivity. Criticized the project for producing only six high-cost homes (estimated $1.5–1.8 million) that are unaffordable to local workers, and argued the plan fails to address housing needs or integrate with the neighborhood. Suggested the commission have authority to require a better plan. - Cindy Deutsch (neighbor, 2375 Lone Oak): Opposed a path due to observed crime (e.g., drunk drivers) and potential creek access issues; noted the property is private and development is inevitable. - Ingrid (neighbor on Grove Avenue): Asked for a path only from Grove to Lone Oak (not to the creek). Inquired about tree removal (especially a 100-year-old redwood) and water availability for new homes and ADUs. Expressed concerns about flood risk and construction access routing. Clay Street Care Facility: - No public comments were made. Discussion Items 7A. Lone Oak Subdivision (2394 Lone Oak Avenue): - Staff presentation by Kevin Payne (consultant) and Michael Allen (city planner). The project proposes subdividing a 2.97-acre infill parcel into six single-family lots (three flag lots). On October 20, 2022, the commission continued the hearing and formed a subcommittee (Vice Chair Masaro and Commissioner Kelly) to address ADU feasibility, architecture, and solar alignment. - Subcommittee report: Vice Chair Masaro and Commissioner Kelly stated the applicant agreed to prepare ADU building pads (graded, compacted, with stubbed utilities) and upgraded electrical panels (320 amp) to facilitate future ADUs. The craftsman elevation was removed, replaced by a modern style. The ranch elevation was modified with lower rooflines and ranch-style porch details. A solar array exhibit was added. The applicant also agreed to use high-definition 40-year shingles and white window trim. - Applicant (Eric Swag, Edenbridge Homes) and architect (Jeff Potts): Emphasized the revised designs and opposition to any pedestrian path, citing trespassing, police calls, property damage, and long-term maintenance burdens on six homeowners. They confirmed 20 of 145 trees on site will be removed (three native, to be mitigated). The applicant argued two construction access points (Lone Oak and Grove) would expedite construction and reduce neighborhood impacts. - Commissioner discussion: Vice Chair Masaro noted the project is not exciting but cannot oppose it; he suggested future projects should involve earlier commission input. Commissioner Kelly supported the architecture changes and ADU preparation but favored a minimal path with fencing; he suggested referring buyers to Napa Sonoma ADU. Commissioner Kelly also raised concerns about the front asphalt. Commissioner Shotwell praised the ADU concept but opposed forcing a path, citing police concerns about it being an attractive nuisance. Chair Hoother supported two-sided construction access and opposed the path, noting potential security risks and minimal connectivity benefit (as staff argued). City planner Michael Allen explained that a path would be difficult due to creek constraints, would not provide regional connectivity, and was opposed by police. - The applicant accepted the conditions included in the draft resolution (ADU grading, stubbed utilities, etc.). 7B. Clay Street Care Facility (2025 Clay Street): - Staff presentation by Ryder Dilley. The applicant requests a use permit for a 10-bed residential care facility for the elderly (RCFE) and allowance of tandem parking. The existing 2,779 sq ft single-family home (damaged by fire in 2020) would be repaired with an 831 sq ft rear addition. Four parking spaces provided (one in garage, one in driveway, two tandem) meet the minimum of three for a 10-bed facility. The facility will have three caregivers during the day and two at night; no residents will have vehicles. - Commissioner questions: Commissioner Kelly asked about age restrictions (60+ confirmed), signage (none proposed), front asphalt paving, and landscaping. Vice Chair Masaro inquired about accessible doors and the possibility of a loading zone. Commissioner Hurtado noted the area’s narrow streets and suggested emergency service access considerations. - Applicant (Chris Music, owner) and architect (Toby Long) confirmed their intent to remove much of the front asphalt and replace it with landscaping to improve aesthetics, though no permit was initially required. They agreed to a condition requiring removal and landscaping. - Commission discussion: All commissioners expressed strong support for the project, noting it returns a fire-damaged property to beneficial use for seniors. Vice Chair Masaro moved to approve with an additional condition that the front pavement be removed and replaced with landscaping (drought-tolerant). The motion carried unanimously. Key Outcomes - Lone Oak Subdivision (PL22-0031): The commission voted unanimously to recommend the City Council adopt a resolution determining the project is exempt from CEQA (Section 15332) and approve the Tentative Subdivision Map, Design Review Permit, and Use Permit, as conditioned (including ADU pad preparation, stubbed utilities, upgraded electrical panel, and architectural modifications). No path was required. Chair Hoother encouraged the applicant to partner with ADU companies for potential buyers. - Clay Street Care Facility (PL22-0091): The commission voted unanimously to adopt a resolution determining the project is exempt from CEQA (Section 15332) and approve the Use Permit for a 10-bed residential care facility for the elderly and tandem parking, with an added condition that the front pavement be removed and replaced with landscaping. - Next Meeting: The next regular meeting is scheduled for December 1, 2022 (agenda not yet set) and December 15, 2022. Commissioner comments included plans for a bus tour of approved projects and residential design guideline updates.
The Napa Planning Commission met on October 20, 2022, at 5:30 PM in City Hall Council Chambers. The meeting included two public hearings: a two-year extension for a four-lot subdivision at 2038 West Lincoln Avenue (approved) and a contested six-lot subdivision at 2394 Lone Oak Avenue (continued with direction for design subcommittee and ADU footprints). The Commission also received a quarterly development report and discussed the recently adopted General Plan. Consent Calendar - Approved the August 4, 2022 and August 18, 2022 Planning Commission minutes unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - West Lincoln Extension (2038 West Lincoln Ave): No public comments were offered. - Lone Oak Subdivision (2394 Lone Oak Ave): Multiple neighbors spoke. - Tom Andrews (2165 Lone Oak Ave) supported the applicant's site plan regarding no pedestrian path, expressed concerns about construction access and fencing at the terminus of Lone Oak Avenue. - Neil Calwell (2560 Bradford St) urged a pedestrian connection between Grove Street and Lone Oak, citing neighborhood desire for connectivity and noting that 25 of 40 neighbors signed a petition supporting a walking path. He argued the large homes (2,900 sq. ft., two-story) are out of scale with existing single-story homes (1,200–1,800 sq. ft.). - Dave Latona (neighbor) confirmed about 25 neighbors favored a pedestrian path and cited concerns about wildlife access. - Jennifer Longstaff (Creekside) supported a walking path and expressed concerns about wildlife (deer, great horned owls) and creek debris. Discussion Items - West Lincoln Parcel Map and Design Review Permit Extension (Item 6A): This item was moved from consent to a public hearing at the request of Commissioner Kelly. Staff (Paul) reported the applicant, Ron (new owner), requested a two-year extension due to pandemic-related staffing shortages. The project subdivides a 0.84-acre parcel into four lots (two existing homes remain, two new lots). No changes to previously approved entitlements. The extension is the first under Government Code §66452.6 (allowing up to six years). Commission questions focused on the history of extensions and encouragement to build. Public comment was none. The Commission approved the two-year extension unanimously. - Lone Oak Subdivision (Item 7A): Staff (Kevin Payne) presented the proposal to subdivide a 2.97-acre parcel into six single-family lots (three flag lots) at 2394 Lone Oak Avenue. The project includes a public cul-de-sac from Grove Avenue, a private driveway for lots 4–6, and preservation of the Redwood Creek riparian corridor. The applicant (Eric Swag, Eden Bridge Homes) emphasized no work below the creek bank, a 7-foot fence (6 ft + 1 ft lattice), and opposition to a pedestrian path due to previous vandalism, trespassing, and liability for six homeowners. Commissioners expressed concerns: architecture is generic, homes are too large (2,800–2,900 sq. ft.) and out of scale with the neighborhood, lack of ADU provisions, and missed opportunity for pedestrian connectivity. The applicant offered to include junior ADU options and confirmed detached ADUs could fit in rear yards. Public Works Director Tim Wood stated the city would not take ownership or maintenance of a path, citing liability and lack of connection to a larger system. After extensive deliberation, Vice Chair Masaro moved to continue the item with direction to: (1) appoint a two-member design subcommittee (Commissioner Kelly and Vice Chair Masaro) to work with the applicant on architectural improvements, and (2) require the applicant to show on the plans where future ADUs could be placed consistent with city code. The motion carried unanimously. - Quarterly Development Report (Item 8A): Mike Walker presented the Q3 2022 report, noting a decline in project submittals but strong building permits (70 residential permits issued, including 17 ADUs and a chunk of the 171-unit SOCO/Pietro Place development). Commissioners discussed the report and noted the importance of reviewing design guidelines in future meetings. - Commissioner and Staff Comments: Commissioners praised staff for the General Plan adoption (unanimous city council vote on October 18), discussed outdated design guidelines, and welcomed new planner Ryder Dilly. Key Outcomes - West Lincoln Extension (PL22-0066): Approved a two-year extension of the Tentative Parcel Map and Design Review Permit (motion by Commissioner Kelly, second by Commissioner Huether; vote 5-0). - Lone Oak Subdivision (PL22-0031): Continued to a future meeting (date uncertain). The Commission directed staff to form a two-member design subcommittee (Commissioner Kelly and Vice Chair Masaro) to provide architectural feedback. The applicant must return with plans showing feasible ADU footprints on all lots, as endorsed by city staff. The pedestrian path proposal was not advanced; public works and the applicant opposed it. - Administrative Report: Received the Q3 2022 development report; no action required. - General Plan Update: The City Council adopted the 2022 General Plan on October 18, 2022; the Commission acknowledged the completion of the planning process.
The Napa Planning Commission met on September 15, 2022, at 5:30 PM in City Council Chambers. The primary agenda item was a continued public hearing for a Use Permit (PL22-0036) requested by DISH Wireless to install a telecommunications facility at 849 Jackson Street. After extensive public comment, expert testimony, and deliberation, the Commission voted 3-1 to approve the permit with several conditions. The meeting also included routine consent calendar items, a brief public comment period, and administrative reports. Consent Calendar - The consent calendar was approved by a single vote without discussion or items removed. Public Comments & Testimony - Several members of the public spoke in opposition to the proposed cell tower, raising concerns about radio frequency (RF) exposure, proximity to schools, homes, and a CrossFit gym, property value impacts, and the adequacy of FCC guidelines. Speakers included Mark Dalman, Deborah Dalman, Amy Martinson (from Napa Neighborhood Association for Safe Tech), Valerie Wolf, and Lynn Robar. They urged the Commission to deny the permit or require an environmental assessment. Discussion Items - DISH Wireless at 849 Jackson Street (PL22-0036): The project proposes installation of six panel antennas on the roof of an existing light industrial building, screened by architecturally integrated panels, and a ground-mounted equipment cabinet. Staff recommended approval, finding the project exempt from CEQA under Class 3 and consistent with zoning. Commissioners questioned staff about the scope of their authority, the FCC’s role, and the cumulative effects of multiple carriers. The applicant presented an RF expert, Dr. Gerald Bushberg, who testified that exposures would be well below FCC limits and that standards include a 50-fold safety factor. Public comment raised concerns about health effects and the validity of FCC guidelines. After deliberation, the Commission discussed adding conditions: baseline and annual RF measurements, physical safety barriers, and bilingual signage. Chair Huether proposed including a statement that approval is not based on environmental health analysis but on the physical and aesthetic aspects. The motion passed 3-1, with Commissioner Shotwell dissenting. Key Outcomes - Motion to Approve (3-1): The Planning Commission adopted a resolution approving the Use Permit for DISH Wireless at 849 Jackson Street, subject to modified conditions including: - Submission of baseline RF measurements following operation start. - Annual RF measurements for five years (reported to the Commission). - Installation of a physical safety barrier around rooftop equipment. - Signage in English and Spanish. - Reference to the updated RF EME report. - The Commission expressed frustration with federal preemption over RF health concerns and noted the need for a future zoning code update to better regulate telecommunications facilities. Staff introduced a new assistant planner and discussed the handling of late communications; the majority preferred receiving them in real time as staff receives them. - The next regular Planning Commission meeting is scheduled for October 6, 2022.
The Napa Planning Commission held its regular meeting on September 1, 2022, at 5:30 PM in City Hall Council Chambers. The main agenda item was the continued public hearing on the City of Napa's General Plan Update (Napa 2040), including certification of the Final Environmental Impact Report (EIR). After hearing extensive public testimony from 19 speakers and deliberation, the Commission voted 4-1 to recommend that the City Council adopt the General Plan with two key modifications: designating the Foster Road mixed-use area as Greenbelt and removing the Linda Vista Bridge extension from the plan. The recommendation also includes certifying the EIR with a Statement of Overriding Considerations for three significant and unavoidable impacts (air quality, greenhouse gas emissions, and agricultural resources). Consent Calendar - No items were presented for review. Public Comments & Testimony - Nearly all 19 public speakers opposed the Foster Road development and/or the Linda Vista Bridge extension. Specific concerns included seismic safety (earthquake fault lines), traffic congestion, loss of the scenic southern gateway, water scarcity during drought, wildfire evacuation risks, and the bridge's historic infeasibility. - Speakers for the Napa Working Families Coalition (including Tim Frank, G. Anthony Phillips, Danny Bernardini, and Glenn Lovall) urged adoption of policies on prevailing wages, project labor agreements, child care, and rent stabilization, though staff noted these are better addressed outside the General Plan. - Kara Verner of the Napa County Bicycle Coalition requested binding multimodal level-of-service objectives and a 10% mode share target for bicycling and walking by 2035; staff felt existing policies in the bike plan were sufficient. - Carol Barge and others praised the GPAC for designating Napa Oaks as greenbelt, while Eve Reiser and Mary Reed highlighted that 1,210 residential units would bring over 3,000 new residents and 2,000+ cars to an area with narrow roads and limited emergency access. Discussion Items - General Plan Overview: Planner Michael Walker reviewed the document's history, community outreach since 2018, and the three significant and unavoidable EIR impacts. He emphasized that the plan is visionary and does not approve specific projects. - Foster Road Properties: The Foster Road Mixed Use designation (covering 78 acres, with potential for up to 1,210 units plus commercial space) has been in city plans since 1975. Walker noted the land is not needed for the current RHNA cycle (which requires 835 units) but may be considered for future cycles (next cycle target approximately 2,700 units). Commissioners debated the implications of downzoning versus leaving the designation pending a master plan. - Linda Vista Bridge: The bridge (connecting Robinson Lane and Linda Vista) has been in plans since 1966. Staff suggested keeping it as a study corridor for potential emergency, pedestrian, or bicycle use, but Commissioner Masaro, who initially proposed moving it to “long-term,” later supported removal after hearing public testimony. - Commission Deliberation: Commissioners Hurtado, Kelly, Masaro, Shotwell, and Huether each expressed positions. Hurtado supported removing the bridge but not changing Foster Road. Kelly opposed both projects, citing urban sprawl, climate impact, and that market-rate housing would not serve local workforce. Masaro and Shotwell aligned with removal of both. Huether changed his earlier stance, stating he could not support development on Foster Road and would rather see it remain greenbelt. Key Outcomes - Motion: Commissioner Kelly moved to (1) adopt a resolution certifying the Final EIR with a Statement of Overriding Considerations and findings of fact, and (2) adopt a resolution recommending approval of the Napa 2040 General Plan to City Council, with the modifications that the Foster Road Mixed Use designation be changed to Greenbelt and the Linda Vista Bridge be stricken from the plan. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Shotwell. - Vote: The motion passed 4-1. Commissioner Hurtado voted in opposition, stating he supported removing the bridge but not the Foster Road redesignation. - Dissenting Note: Staff will include Commissioner Hurtado's dissenting position in the recommendation to Council. The City Council will hold a final public hearing and make the ultimate decision on certifying the EIR and adopting the General Plan. - Next Steps: The Planning Commission’s recommendation, along with the full record and public comments, will be forwarded to the City Council for action at a future meeting.
The Napa Planning Commission met on August 18, 2022, at 5:30 PM to consider two public hearings: a Use Permit for a Dish Wireless telecommunications facility and the comprehensive City of Napa General Plan Update (Napa 2040). The commission also conducted an annual vacancy rate determination for condominium conversions. The commission voted to continue the Dish Wireless item to a date uncertain and continued the General Plan Update to the September 1, 2022 meeting for further deliberation. Consent Calendar - No items were on the consent calendar. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: One speaker addressed the nuisance of two-cycle engines (leaf blowers, etc.); the chair referred them to City Council. - General Plan Update Public Comments: - Lynn Posner urged preservation of the Foster Road gateway and opposed dense development in that area. - Cindy Deutsch strongly opposed the Linda Vista Avenue extension, citing neighbor opposition, cost, environmental impacts (54-70 trees), and lack of priority. - Maureen Tripp (Slowdown Napa) requested inclusion of a goal to protect residential neighborhoods from high-speed, high-volume traffic. - Glenn Lovall (Napa Working Families Coalition) expressed support for inclusive growth and recommended specific language on workforce development, childcare, anti-displacement measures (rent stabilization), and environmental protection. - Kara Verner (Napa County Bicycle Coalition) requested that the plan include a mode share target (10% bike, 10% walk by 2035) and level-of-service standards for all modes, not just automobiles. - Patty expressed concern that allowing development on agricultural land would open the door to losing the gateway. - Andrew Healy (Browns Valley Action Group) thanked the commission and endorsed the greenbelt designation and remapping of parcels to open space. - Sharon Marks raised concerns about safety on Foster Road and Imola Avenue, and the need for road maintenance and beautification. Discussion Items Dish Wireless at Jackson Street (File No. PL22-0036) - Staff presented a Use Permit to install six panel antennas and a ground-mounted equipment cabinet on an existing industrial building at 849 Jackson Street, screened from view. The project was determined to be CEQA-exempt (Class 3). - The applicant, representing Dish Wireless, stated that Dish will be the fourth wireless carrier in Napa, launching mid-2023, and will improve network capacity and emergency resilience. - Commissioners raised concerns about radio frequency (RF) emissions, particularly after receiving a late RF report indicating that FCC limits may be exceeded within 32 feet (general public) and 8 feet (occupational) of the antennas. They also questioned safety for maintenance workers and firefighters, and noted that previous requests for a technical engineer to be present were not fulfilled. - Chair Huether moved to continue the item to a date uncertain, with the request that the applicant bring an engineer and obtain input from the fire department. - Vote: Unanimous to continue. City of Napa General Plan Update (Napa 2040) - Staff provided a detailed overview of the multi-year process, including GPAC meetings, community workshops, and three prior planning commission meetings on the land use plan. Key changes included corrections to parcel-based land use designations, redesignation of 16 acres (Balao Street to Lincoln Avenue) as Industrial Flex, and additions to the climate change and sustainability element (e.g., references to SB 1383, climate emergency resolution). The Final EIR identified three significant unavoidable impacts: air quality, greenhouse gas emissions, and agricultural resources; a Statement of Overriding Considerations was included. - Public testimony focused on Foster Road (long-designated for development but considered a sensitive gateway), the Linda Vista Avenue extension (opposed by neighbors, kept as a study corridor), transportation policies (traffic calming, bike/walk mode share), and climate change. - Commissioners discussed: - Foster Road: Concerns about timing, RHNA numbers, and whether housing would serve local needs. Staff clarified that Foster Road is not needed for the current 6th cycle RHNA (2023-2031) and that a master plan is required before development. - Linda Vista Extension: Staff explained that keeping it as a study corridor allows future evaluation of options (emergency, bike/ped, etc.) without committing to a vehicular bridge. - Transportation: Commissioners supported incorporating public suggestions on traffic calming, mode share targets, and level-of-service for all modes. - Climate: Commissioner Massaro requested adding language on regenerative/resilience and addressing natural gas in new construction and sea-level rise. - The commission voted to continue the item to September 1, 2022, for further discussion and to allow staff to prepare responses to public comments. - Vote: Unanimous to continue. Vacancy Rate Determination (Administrative Report) - Staff presented the annual survey of multifamily rental properties (20+ units) conducted July 20-27, 2022. The vacancy rate was determined to be 2.0% (up from 1.5% in prior years, but still below the 5% threshold). As a result, no condominium conversion use permits may be processed. - Commissioner Kelly asked about the impact of new projects; staff noted that new units fill quickly and are not surveyed until six months after occupancy. - The commission adopted the resolution (motion carried), with one opposing vote. Key Outcomes - Dish Wireless Use Permit: Continued to a date uncertain; applicant to bring an engineer and fire department input at a future hearing. - General Plan Update: Continued to the September 1, 2022 planning commission meeting; staff to incorporate public comments and propose edits. - Vacancy Rate Determination: Approved (2.0% rate confirmed; no condo conversions processed). Vote was 4-1. - Next Meeting: The next regular meeting is scheduled for September 1, 2022.
The Napa Planning Commission convened on Thursday, August 4, 2022 at 5:30 PM in City Council Chambers. The meeting covered a consent calendar, consent hearings, public hearings, and administrative reports. Key items included a second extension for the Keller Apartments, a zoning interpretation request for commercial campgrounds in residential districts, a preliminary review of a major housing development on the former HHS site, and a quarterly development report. The Commission also heard one public comment at the start of the meeting. Public Comments & Testimony - Jim Hinton (3574 Hunter Circle, Napa): Spoke against the long tenure of Commissioner Huether, alleging conflicts of interest due to his art business benefiting from developer-funded art requirements. Called for term limits on the Planning Commission. Consent Calendar - Approved: Planning Commission minutes from July 7, 2022, with a motion and second; all in favor. Consent Hearings (Pulled) - Keller Apartments Extension II (1057 Freeway Drive, File PL22-0048): Pulled from the consent calendar by Commissioner Kelly for discussion. The request was a second two-year extension of a previously approved 24-unit multifamily development and sign permit (originally approved in 2016). Staff recommended approval. After discussion and no public testimony, the Commission voted 5-0 to approve the extension to May 15, 2024. Discussion Items Silverado Trail Zoning Interpretation (Citywide, File PL22-0058) - Staff Report (Michael Allen): The request asked the Commission to determine that a commercial campground is a substantially similar use to "clubs and lodges" or "recreation facilities" listed in NMC Section 17.08.020.B.2 for all residential districts. Staff strongly recommended against this, noting that campgrounds are only explicitly allowed in tourist commercial and agricultural resource districts. Staff emphasized the determination would apply citywide, not just to the applicant's property. - Applicant Presentation (Perry Mead Murray, JB Lemer, Jeremy Sill, Greg Pitts): Presented a conceptual plan for a recreational glamping site on their 13-acre Silverado Trail property, including a pool, grange hall, trails, and about 20-30 tent/trailer units. They argued it was consistent with general plan policies for private recreation and would serve locals and tourists. They believed the use could be a conditional use under existing residential zoning. - Commission Deliberation: Several commissioners expressed support for the project concept but agreed with staff that the proper path is a general plan and zoning amendment, not a broad zoning interpretation. Concerns included precedent setting, potential impact on all residential properties, and consistency with current code. The Commission voted 5-0 to adopt the staff recommendation: determining that commercial campgrounds are not substantially similar to clubs, lodges, or recreation facilities as listed in the code. HHS Housing Preliminary Review (2344 Old Sonoma Road, File PL22-0068) - Preliminary Review Only – No Action: The applicant (Charles Lovman, Heritage Housing Partners) presented a conceptual plan for a 159-unit for-sale mixed-income development on the 8.9-acre former Napa County Health and Human Services site. The project includes preserving three historic buildings (National Register) and features a mix of stacked flats, courtyard condos, single-family homes, and new buildings along the crescent. Unit mix: 50% affordable (15% low-income, 15% moderate, 17% workforce), 50% market rate. Density proposed is 159 units. - Public Testimony: Four speakers (Bill Chadwick, Austin Hall, Carol Barge, Jay Jacobson, plus Michael Holcomb and Greg Pitts) expressed strong support, citing thoughtful design, preservation, and housing diversity. - Commission Feedback: All commissioners praised the project overall but offered design suggestions. Key points: The “Redwood building” (stacked flats on Walnut Street) needs redesign – either more modern/unique or more cohesive with the craftsman style. Requested further detail on solar panels, greywater systems, bike storage, affordable unit phasing, public interface at the crescent, and potential connection to adjacent county property. Commissioners encouraged inclusion of public art. The Commission gave positive feedback and looks forward to a formal application. Quarterly Development Report (Q2 2022) - Staff Report (Mike Walker): Summarized development applications and permits issued in the second quarter of 2022. Notable: 199 residential units at Braden Phase II, renovation permits for Valverde project converting existing facility to SROs and senior units. Commissioner Masaro requested adding trend data for future reports. Key Outcomes - Keller Apartments Extension: Approved unanimously (5-0) to extend approvals to May 15, 2024. - Silverado Trail Zoning Interpretation: Adopted staff recommendation unanimously (5-0) that commercial campgrounds are not substantially similar to the listed conditional uses in residential districts. - HHS Housing Review: No formal action; preliminary feedback only. - Quarterly Report: Received and filed.
The Napa Planning Commission met on July 7, 2022, at 5:30 PM at City Hall, Council Chambers, to consider several items including a requested third extension for the Napa Creek Condominiums project, an Outdoor Dining Ordinance amendment, and a preliminary review of the General Plan update. The meeting was the first without COVID-era plastic barriers in two years, as noted by Chair Huether. Consent Calendar - Planning Commission Minutes – May 19, 2022: Approved unanimously. Commissioners Huether and Myers abstained as they were absent from that meeting. Consent Hearings - Outdoor Dining Ordinance Amendment (PL21-0139): Approved without discussion as part of the consent hearings. The item, a citywide amendment to Napa Municipal Code Section 17.52.340, was forwarded to the City Council with a recommendation for adoption. Public Comments & Testimony - Non-agenda public comment: None. - Napa Creek Condominiums: No public testimony was offered. - General Plan Preliminary Review: Patrick Band, speaking as an individual, commended the commission’s request for early document review and asked about the anticipated adoption timeline by Council and the role of the implementation plan. Staff responded that Council adoption is targeted for September/October 2022 and that the implementation plan is an appendix that will be updated continuously. Discussion Items - Napa Creek Condominiums Tentative Map Extension III (PL22-0045): Staff Planner Michael Allen presented the request for a third and final two-year extension of approvals originally granted in 2011 for a 48-unit for-sale condominium project at 1701 D Street Alley (APNs 002-071-010, -011). The project is in the MFR-142 and RM; AH; FP-10 zoning districts. Staff noted that the current owner, who acquired the property a few years ago, has obtained prior extensions; this is the last local extension allowed by the Subdivision Map Act (total of six years). The project previously received a Mitigated Negative Declaration (CEQA) and will pay an alternative equivalent affordable housing fee (over $250,000) instead of providing seven on-site affordable units, as approved by City Council in 2018. A pedestrian easement originally crossing the property was modified at Public Works’ request to improve ADA accessibility along D Street Alley. Chair Huether recused himself, stating a business relationship with the Manny Brothers, the project sponsor. The commission voted 3-0 (Huether recused) to adopt the resolution approving the extension, with clarifying discussion that the two-year extension begins August 1, 2022, and that timely building permit issuance is essential. - General Plan Preliminary Review (PL22-0058 Administrative Report): Staff provided a preview of the General Plan update adoption process, highlighting redline edits to the Climate Element based on public comments. Staff emphasized that upcoming adoption hearings (tentatively August 18 and a second meeting) will focus on goals and policies, not line-by-line editing. Commissioners discussed several policies: - Commissioner Kelly questioned the wording of Climate Change Policy 1-2 (removing “me”) and sought clarification on drive-through caps (policy 2-1) and fueling station limits (policy 2-1). He also asked about requiring net-zero energy for city buildings (policy 8-2) and suggested including tree-lined medians for heat island reduction and traffic calming. - Vice Chair Massaro and Commissioner Shotwell supported keeping the net-zero energy language broad (not tied to a specific certification like LEED) to remain relevant over the 20-year horizon. - Commissioner Myers requested early distribution of the full adoption package (about 320 pages of goals and policies) at least two weeks in advance to allow thorough review, noting a personal travel conflict in mid-August. Staff agreed to adjust the schedule to accommodate commissioners. - Silverado Trail Zoning Interpretation (PL22-0058): Continued to the August 4, 2022 meeting at the applicant’s request. Motion passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Napa Creek Condos: Resolution approving the third and final two-year extension adopted (3-0). Approval includes extension of the Tentative Map, Design Review Permit, three Use Permits, and two Variances through August 1, 2024. The CEQA Mitigated Negative Declaration remains applicable. - Outdoor Dining Ordinance Amendment: Forwarded to City Council for adoption. - Silverado Trail Item: Continued to August 4, 2022. - General Plan Update: Target for first adoption hearing is August 18, 2022, with a follow-up meeting for formal recommendation. City Council adoption expected September/October. - Administrative items: The July 21, 2022 Planning Commission meeting was canceled. Next regular meeting is August 4, 2022. - Staff announcements: Ricky Caperton (formerly of Clovis and Fresno) will begin as Planning Manager on July 11, 2022. Molly has been promoted to Deputy City Manager. Bond Mendez has left the department for a position in Rancho Cucamonga. The Housing Element update website (NapaHousingElement.com) is live, and a “Housing Week” outreach campaign is scheduled for the last week of July 2022.
The Napa Planning Commission held a regular meeting on May 19, 2022, at 5:30 PM in City Hall Council Chambers, 955 School Street, Napa, CA. Vice Chair Bob Massaro presided due to the absence of Chair Gordon Huether and Commissioner Alexander Myers. Commissioners present: Paul Kelley, Beverly Shotwell, and Bob Massaro. The meeting covered approval of previous minutes, a consent hearing that became a public hearing on a parcel map extension, and a discussion on the Draft General Plan Implementation Program. Consent Calendar - Planning Commission Minutes (April 21, 2022): Approved unanimously by a single vote. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public spoke on non-agenda items. Consent Hearings (Became Public Hearing) - Milliken Creek Parcel Map Extension II (File No. PL22-0020): A request for a second two-year extension of a previously approved Tentative Parcel Map and Design Review Permit for a 4-lot subdivision on an 11.60-acre site west of Silverado Trail. The item was pulled from the consent calendar at the request of neighbor Judy Buffington (1913 Silverado Trail). - Speaker Position: Judy Buffington expressed concerns about potential fill in the floodplain (based on past flood control meetings) and traffic safety on Silverado Trail. She noted she had not commented on the original project. - Applicant Response: Scott Cleinwill (KG Planning Partners) explained that fill would be required for future home pads but the extension only extends the map, not authorizes construction. Fill would comply with city codes and floodplain regulations; the project was reviewed by Public Works and found consistent with floodplain requirements (no fill in the floodway). - Commission Discussion: Commissioners noted the project's history and constraints, confirmed that the four-lot density is appropriate, and that the extension is warranted. Staff clarified that the Subdivision Map Act allows three extensions total; this is the second. - Vote: Motion by Commissioner Kelly, second by Commissioner Shotwell to adopt a resolution approving the second extension and determining that the environmental effects were adequately analyzed by the 2018 Mitigated Negative Declaration. Approved unanimously (3-0). Discussion Items - Administrative Report – Draft General Plan Appendix A: Implementation Strategies: Staff presented the draft implementation program, which categorizes policies by approach (zoning, capital improvements, plans, environmental initiatives, city administration), assigns responsibility codes, and provides timelines (ongoing, 0–5 years, 6–10, 11–20). The commission was asked for feedback. - Commissioner Feedback: - Commissioner Kelly expressed disappointment that the document lacks strong action language (e.g., “shall” and “will”) and reads more like a responsibility matrix than a committed implementation plan. He noted the Planning Commission and City Council are only cited as responsible for item A-1-e (development review) and suggested adding a column identifying which items require commission/council review. - Commissioner Shotwell found the timelines reasonable given budgetary and staffing constraints but agreed that stronger language would be helpful. She expects to be more comfortable after seeing revisions to the General Plan itself. - Vice Chair Massaro supported adding a statement of commitment at the beginning of the appendix, and suggested adding review bodies (e.g., CHC, Planning Commission, City Council) as a column. He also questioned prioritization, asking why land use items are urgent (0–2 years) while housing is later; staff explained that zoning must be consistent with the General Plan by law, and the housing element update is a separate process. - Staff Response: Staff acknowledged the feedback and committed to: - Revising the General Plan’s goals and policies to include more definitive language (not wholesale “shall”/“will” but stronger action words). - Adding a statement of commitment to the implementation appendix. - Adding a column for approving/review bodies (e.g., Planning Commission, City Council). - Correcting a typo: “CA state of California” should have “CA” capitalized. - No formal action was taken; the item was for discussion only. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Approved. - Milliken Creek Extension: Approved unanimously (3-0). - General Plan Implementation: No vote; staff will incorporate commissioner feedback into the next draft. The next regular Planning Commission meeting is scheduled for June 16, 2022 (the June 2 meeting was canceled).
The Napa Planning Commission convened on April 21, 2022 at 5:30 p.m. in City Hall Council Chambers. All five commissioners were present. The meeting covered routine consent items, a quarterly development report, a three-element draft General Plan discussion (Natural Resources Conservation, Safety & Noise, and Economic Development), and a presentation on the Draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for the General Plan. Public comment was taken on the General Plan and EIR. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes from the March 28, 2022 City Council and Planning Commission Special Joint Meeting. - Approved the minutes from the April 7, 2022 Planning Commission Regular Meeting. Public Comments & Testimony - Chuck Shineman (Napa resident): Requested additional time for public review of the Draft EIR, noting it is an 800-page document. He questioned the dismissal of the higher density alternative, suggesting it could reduce vehicle miles traveled (VMT) from long commutes. He also expressed concern about economic development language that seemed to encourage jobs at 75% of Area Median Income (AMI), which he felt was too low. - Austin Hall (Napa resident, Napa County Landmarks): Urged the city to hire a qualified historic preservation specialist to review projects earlier, preventing delays. He noted that Napa has lost many historic buildings and features and that new construction should be compatible with historic resources. - Jay Jacobson (Napa resident): Encouraged the Commission to use strong, directive language (e.g., "shall" instead of "encourage") in the General Plan to protect culture, economy, and land use. He emphasized the need to backstop planning decisions. - Glenn Lovall (Napa-Solano Central Labor Council, Community Benefits Coalition): Expressed support for sustainable and equitable growth. He highlighted the importance of high labor standards, transit-oriented development, VMT reduction, and expanded housing options with clear metrics. He pledged continued engagement. - Jorge Aviñar Romero (Cement Masons business agent, former Napa resident): Supported higher wages for union workers and encouraged the General Plan to address this. Discussion Items Quarterly Development Report (Q1 2022) - Staff reported over 40 total project applications in Q1 2022. Notable: 7 parcel maps under SB9 (new housing law effective Jan 1, 2022), 90 residential building permits (mostly for SOCO Apartments/Pietro Place), 25 single-family permits (primarily in Vista Grove and Foothill Estate subdivisions), and 3 ADU permits. Commissioners asked about typical SB9 unit counts (1-2 units) and expressed satisfaction with the pace. Draft General Plan – Natural Resources Conservation Element - Commissioners reviewed goals/policies to protect water, vegetation, wildlife, open space, and air. - Commissioner Hurtado questioned air quality impacts from the Sire Quarry (county jurisdiction, strict air permits). He also asked about NRC policies 6-1 and 6-2 (green building practices) and NRC 9-3 (water quality report accessibility). - Commissioner Shotwell noted a typo (missing word "is") and asked about the status of the Napa County Groundwater Sustainability Plan (draft available in 2021, adoption anticipated early 2022). She questioned redundancy in goal language and who is responsible for educational outreach on climate risks. - Commissioner Kelly suggested that more flexible use of the term "sustainable" could benefit the element, and noted potential for land exchanges with the county to optimize urban growth boundaries. - Vice Chair Massaro proposed adding a definition of sustainability (e.g., “preserving the capability of the environment to support human life”). He criticized referencing an outdated Napa Green Building Code, noting it defaults to state minimums. He urged stronger language on air quality cooperation with the county and clarified “LID” (low impact development). - Chair Huether found the element well-written and comprehensive. He questioned the distinction between parks and open space (e.g., Oxbow Preserve) and noted the map shows limited green space, suggesting opportunities for future riverfront parks. Draft General Plan – Safety & Noise Element - Commissioners discussed seismic hazards, flooding, wildfire, emergency preparedness, and noise. - Commissioner Shotwell noted a timeline reference ("since construction began in 2000") should be more current. She pointed out a formatting/hyphen issue in "noise-sensitive land uses". She asked to remove policy SN 5-6 (extending Linda Vista Avenue) due to environmental/neighborhood concerns. Staff said they are evaluating public comments on that issue. - Commissioner Kelly observed that Table 8-3 (noise exposure) appeared mislabeled as “solid waste information system facilities”. He recommended adopting higher fire-resistant construction (Wildland-Urban Interface codes) citywide. He suggested adding a section on pandemics/disease outbreak and urged continued mapping of seismic faults. - Commissioner Hurtado emphasized the need for better community education on evacuation routes, especially for non-English speakers, noting that communication improvements only came after the 2017 fires. - Vice Chair Massaro stressed that earthquake preparedness is the weakest area. He called for language on hardening existing buildings, especially unreinforced masonry (URM) structures downtown, and suggested revisiting the city's URM ordinance. He cited personal experience with earthquakes and the 2014 Napa quake. - Chair Huether commented on noise, noting that I-29 and Silverado Trail noise affects quality of life. He wished the city could gain control over the state-owned fairgrounds for potential mixed-use development, but acknowledged no policy currently addresses this. Draft General Plan – Economic Development Element - Commissioners praised the element’s link to housing, transportation, and equity. - Commissioner Hurtado acknowledged the GPAC’s work and highlighted the importance of preserving industrial uses and providing workforce housing. He noted ED 1-10 (accommodating workers with housing difficulties) is crucial. - Commissioner Shotwell identified a few typos (e.g., “as new supply becomes available” should be “became”). She asked about the Syar/Synodome redevelopment site status (still in planning, mixed ownership). She supported streamlined permitting (ED 1-9) and family-friendly downtown amenities (e.g., ice skating rink on former Safeway lot). - Vice Chair Massaro praised guiding principle 4 (diverse housing). He requested language consistency (use “Latinx” throughout) and suggested adding employer-sponsored housing. He noted that ED 1-4 mentions possible code amendments and asked for clarification on “portal” in ED 7-2 (web or physical). He supported workforce training for adults, not just youth. - Chair Huether questioned whether the description of the city’s cultural diversity and thriving arts scene was more aspirational than current reality. He emphasized that economic development funds other priorities like parks and housing. He supported policies that commit funding to arts and culture. Draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for General Plan - Staff presented the program EIR, which analyzes citywide impacts of the General Plan. Only air quality and greenhouse gas emissions are found to be significant and unavoidable. Two alternatives (no project, higher infill) were examined; the proposed update is environmentally superior. - Public comment period originally ending April 25, 2022, has been extended to May 6, 2022. Staff will respond to all comments. - Commissioner Kelly questioned how a program EIR’s “less than significant” conclusions apply to specific projects. Staff and legal counsel explained that future site-specific review (e.g., biological, cultural resources) will still occur, and the program EIR streamlines but does not eliminate project-level CEQA analysis. He expressed concern about water supply being labeled “less than significant” given potential population growth. Staff noted increased efficiency and potential future closed-loop water recycling. - Vice Chair Massaro appreciated the 2-week extension and indicated he would submit written comments. Chair Huether praised the collaborative effort. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar approved unanimously. - Public comment closed on all items by vote. - No formal votes taken on General Plan elements or EIR; the session was deliberative. Commissioners provided numerous specific suggestions for staff to consider in finalizing the draft General Plan and EIR. - EIR comment period extended to Friday, May 6, 2022, announced at the meeting. - Next regular Planning Commission meeting (May 5, 2022) cancelled. The next meeting will be May 19, 2022, focusing on the General Plan implementation plan (Appendix A).