Public Meetings - Allegheny County, Pennsylvania

County Council met on March 19, 2024, with 13 members present. The meeting featured Chief Executive Sara Innamorato's first quarterly address, covering her administration's first 78 days, followed by council questions and a lengthy public comment period dominated by criticism of Councilmember Bob Macy's remarks at the March 5 meeting and the council's handling of a ceasefire resolution. Public Comments & Testimony - Michael Brooks (first group, no show) – Did not speak. - Nithin Ragunathan: Called on Councilmember Macy to apologize for racist and xenophobic remarks made on March 5, stating that immigrants in Allegheny County contribute $300 million in taxes and hold $731 million in spending power. He demanded the council censure Macy. - Yas Alzuni (PhD from Purdue, naturalized citizen): Criticized Macy's remarks, noting that no council member has condemned the Islamophobia exhibited that night. Thanked Councilmembers Grisbeck, Hallam, and Prizio for their support of the ceasefire resolution. - Corey Roma (Crafton, District 12): Expressed disappointment and disgust with the council's conduct on March 5, including the removal of a public commenter, illegal search, and denial of legal counsel. Criticized council for limiting public comment to one minute and for allowing “racist, xenophobic, and morally repugnant statements” from Councilman Macy. Called for better representation. - Laura Perkins (human rights organizer at Casa San Jose): Invited Councilmember Macy to meet the immigrant community, stating his remarks imply immigrants are nefarious criminals. Noted the Hispanic population in Allegheny County grew by 80% from 2010 to 2020, while the overall population grew only 2.2%. Rejected the “hidden agenda” charge. - Tanisha Long: Argued that limiting public applause and forcibly removing a commenter criminalized free speech and violated the First Amendment. Condemned Councilman Macy's “dangerous stereotypes about immigrants” and called for an apology. - Kina James (Alliance for Police Accountability, NAACP criminal justice chair): Called Macy's remarks “extremely poor taste and racist,” noting that his own ancestors came with a hidden agenda. Questioned Council President Katina's fairness for saying there were no right or wrong answers after the racist statement. - Derek Housler (District 10, son of Latino immigrants): Condemned Macy's remarks as “racist, xenophobic, and unacceptable,” warning they could hurt growth and migration to the county. Urged Macy to learn about immigrants by visiting local Latino businesses. - Robert Chung (Millvale): Noted that the Tree of Life synagogue terrorist shared conspiracy theories similar to Macy's comments. Called on the council to show strength and integrity by holding colleagues accountable. - Speaker (name not given, Mount Lebanon resident, 47 years in U.S.): Said Macy's words “kill” like the Tree of Life shooter's bullets. Recounting personal experiences of family being attacked, called for an apology. - Brian Knuckles (Wilkinsburg): Criticized Councilmember Bakowski for saying public comment wouldn't change his mind, and Council President Katina for gaslighting. Demanded censure of Bakowski and Macy, and resignations. - Speaker (name not given, Point Breeze): Detailed the consequences of voting against the ceasefire resolution, including continued bombing of civilians, starvation, and deaths of medical personnel. Criticized Macy's racism and noted that Macy called the speaker's wife to apologize but said colleagues advised him not to apologize publicly. Chief Executive's Quarterly Address - Workforce and wages: Raised lowest county wages to $18/hour ($37,000/year) but noted it is still not competitive. Called for continued partnership with council to raise standards. - Department of Human Services (DHS): Sheltered over 1,600 people experiencing homelessness; provided 60,000 home‑delivered meals to seniors; paid over $20 million in child care subsidies for over 10,000 children. Issued solicitation for medication‑assisted treatment in the jail; engaged 40 individuals from 24 organizations on immigrant/refugee services; launched initiative to improve nonprofit contracting. - Transition committee: Most diverse in history, with a Talent Committee (recruiting leaders) and an All‑in Allegheny committee (community engagement). Historic appointments: Solicitor Rosalind Guy McCorkle and Chief Public Defender Lena Bryan Henderson. Hiring process for a new Health Director and Warden includes community input. - All‑in Allegheny survey: Over 19,000 responses from all 130 municipalities; 20% people of color; translated into nine languages; included paper surveys in senior centers and the jail. Highest participation per council district was in Councilman Walton's district (2,355 respondents). An action plan will be unveiled next month. - Economic development: Noted Excelitas moving HQ from Boston to Strip District. Expanded child care access with $500,000 in ARPA funds. Supported LERTA for downtown development. Created a Director of Housing position; Ed Newser to join from City of Bridges Community Land Trust. - Public safety: Over $80 million investment in a unified ultra‑high frequency radio system for first time in county history, covering 400 municipalities. Committed to addressing issues at Allegheny County Jail and Schuman Center for juvenile justice. - Upcoming initiatives: Comprehensive plan (first in 12 years); safe and fair elections; community engagement on housing and public safety. Discussion Items (Council Questions) - Councilman DeMarco: Asked to extend the U.S. Steel Clean Air Fund settlement (expires June 2024) and discussed requiring developers to contribute to a fund for repairing vacant properties. Chief Executive agreed to meet with stakeholders. Also asked about timeline for reopening Schuman Center; administration will provide written update. - Councilman Paul Mary: Highlighted CCAC as an underappreciated asset; asked for a campaign to promote it. Chief Executive noted the governor's proposal for community colleges and ongoing engagement. - Councilmember Hallam: Asked for detailed data on the 1,600 sheltered individuals and the administration's plan for non‑congregate shelter and wraparound services. Chief Executiveresponded that 75% of shelter users are “lower needs” individuals needing affordable housing, and 25% need intensive wraparound services. Also asked about jail reimagining; a public report forthcoming. - Councilmember Nakaretti Chapkis: Praised the community engagement efforts; expressed hope it continues. - Councilmember Grisbeck: Thanked for wage increases and All‑in Allegheny sessions. Raised record high hydrogen sulfide exceedances in air quality. Chief Executive emphasized hiring a new Health Director and working with EPA to hold polluters accountable. - Councilmember Filiagi: Excited about UHF radio system. Asked that the comprehensive plan address the volunteer‑driven emergency services crisis. Chief Executive agreed to convene a table and include it in the plan. - Council President Katina: Thanked the administration for UHF radio system; stressed need to solve the Schuman Center juvenile justice crisis. Key Outcomes - Appointments: Three appointments approved by voice vote after committee recommendations: Donna Gardner to Friends of the Park (Boyce Park), Russell Giancola to Accountability Conduct and Ethics Commission, and Maria Swartz to Friends of the Park (Boyce Park). - Ordinance 12951‑24: Extended county real estate tax discount deadline from March 31 to April 30, 2024, and gross face period from May 1 to May 31, 2024. Approved 13‑0. - Resolution 12954‑24: Amended grants and special accounts budget for 2024. Approved 13‑0. - Motion on litigation invoices: Authorized payment of $6,219 for professional services related to Schuman Center litigation. Approved 13‑0. - Notification of contracts: Communication summarizing approved executive actions for February 2024 received and filed. - New business referred: Ordinance 12978‑24 (Health Dept. housing regulation revisions) to Health and Human Services Committee; Resolution 12979‑24 (Wilkinsburg TIF district) to Economic Development and Job Creation Committee. - Board of Elections meeting: Scheduled for March 20 at 11:30 a.m. to vote on five mail‑in ballot drop‑off locations (not drop boxes). Public Comment on Past Ceasefire Resolution and Council Conduct - The overwhelming theme of public comment was condemnation of Councilmember Bob Macy's remarks at the March 5 meeting, where he stated immigrants might have “come here legally… but may have came with a hidden agenda.” Speakers called the remarks racist, xenophobic, and dangerous, demanding an apology and censure. Several speakers also criticized the council for limiting public comment to one minute, removing a person for clapping, and failing to condemn Macy's statement. Speakers from Casa San Jose, the Alliance for Police Accountability, and individual residents emphasized that immigrants contribute significantly to the county and are not a threat. One speaker reported that Macy called his wife to apologize but said colleagues advised him not to apologize publicly. Council President Katina did not allow a response during the meeting, but noted that a resolution for discussion could be placed on a future agenda.

Allegheny County Council held its regular meeting on March 5, 2024, with 14 members present and one absent. The meeting opened with proclamations, moved to shorten public comment to one minute after 279 people signed up, heard hours of testimony dominated by the ceasefire resolution, referred new ordinances to committees, and concluded by voting down the ceasefire resolution. No written agenda or minutes were included in the source material. Consent Calendar - Council proclaimed the week of March 3–9, 2024 as Women in Construction Week (Proclamation 12948-24). Sherry Thomas, president of the Pittsburgh chapter of the National Association of Women in Construction, and Amanda Kraft accepted. Thomas said the 2024 theme is “keys to the future” and promoted Camp NAWIC, a free week-long camp for girls in grades 8–12, to be held June 24–28, 2024. - Council read a proclamation (12949-24) recognizing John Burnett’s 42-year television career and his community service. Procedural Motion: Public Comment Time Limit - Council considered Motion 12950-24, setting time limits for public comment at the March 5, 2024 meeting. President Katina said 279 individuals had signed up, all agenda-item comments pertained to the ceasefire motion, and three minutes each would create roughly 14 hours of testimony. He proposed shortening the limit to one minute as the fairest way to hear the most speakers. Councilman Betkowski said “the first casualty of war is the truth” and that no testimony would change minds. The motion passed 12–2, with Councilmembers Grisbeck and Hallum voting no and one member absent. Public Comments & Testimony - Hundreds of residents spoke under strict rules: one minute per speaker, no applause or heckling, no ceding time, and names called from posted lists. Speakers who were not present when called forfeited their turn; non-residents who had not signed up 24 hours in advance were not permitted to speak. Two recesses were taken to manage overflow rooms and audio issues. - The overwhelming majority of public comment addressed the ceasefire motion. Supporters—including Palestinian Americans, Jews, union members, health care workers, students, clergy, and local officials—urged an immediate and permanent ceasefire. They argued that more than 30,000 Palestinians, including over 12,000 or 13,000 children, had been killed; that hospitals, schools, and universities were destroyed; that Gaza faced starvation and displacement of about two million people; that U.S. tax dollars funded the campaign; and that County Council had already taken a position on Israel/Palestine with its October 24 resolution. Several said a ceasefire was necessary to free the remaining Israeli hostages and cited previous releases through negotiated pauses. Multiple Jewish speakers said opposing Israeli policy was not anti-Semitic and that Jewish safety required ending the killing. - Opponents—including representatives of the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh, synagogues, Jewish communal groups, Holocaust survivor descendants, and other residents—urged Council to vote no. They argued that Hamas broke the existing ceasefire on October 7, committed rape and murder, still held hostages, repeatedly rejected ceasefire offers, used Palestinian civilians as human shields, and that the resolution omitted Hamas and falsely equated hostages with convicted Palestinian prisoners. They called the measure outside County Council’s purview, symbolically ineffective, divisive, and harmful to the local Jewish community. Some also contended the ICJ did not find Israel guilty of genocide. One opponent quoted a former Jerusalem mayor’s “spare me your sermons and I will fix your sewers” to urge local focus. - Councilmember Hallam later stated that public commenters had shown up 138 to 71 in favor of the ceasefire, and she said this was the second consecutive meeting with overwhelming public support. New Business and Ordinance Referrals - Unfinished business 12915-24, amending the Administrative Code regarding the Chief Assessment Officer position to ensure continuity, was read and referred back to the Committee on Assessment Practices. - 12951-24, extending the county real estate tax discount deadline from March 31, 2024 to April 30, 2024, and the May 1, 2024 deadline to May 31, 2024, was referred to Business, Budget, and Finance. - 12952-24, requiring a complete streets plan by December 31, 2024, was referred to the Committee on Economic Development. - 12953-24, creating a new Chapter 572 on litter enforcement, was referred to Sustainability and Green Initiatives. - 12954-24, amending the 2024 grants and special accounts budget, submission 1-24, was referred to Budget and Finance. Ceasefire Resolution 1295-24 - Council took up Motion 1295-24, sponsored by Councilmembers Hallam, Pritzio, and Grisbeck, urging the U.S. federal government to work cooperatively toward an immediate de-escalation and ceasefire in Israel and Palestine and the release of all hostages. - During discussion, Councilman Bonarotti called the situation tragic and said a diplomatic solution was needed, but he abstained. Councilman DeMarco said Council lacked geopolitical expertise and noted Hamas had rejected ceasefire offers. Councilman Fatulis said he wanted world peace but would not support a resolution naming one country or religion. Councilman Macy cited local issues and said any vote would draw accusations of genocide or anti-Semitism. Councilwoman Nakarati Chapkis said her district was divided, she was horrified by civilian deaths, and she abstained. Councilman Klein said the Jewish community’s fear of anti-Semitism was real and that the crisis called for real action, not symbolic gestures. Councilwoman Filiachi and Councilman Palmasina said they felt the pain of the issue but made no further comments. - Councilman Grisbeck spoke at length in support, saying the motion called for a bilateral ceasefire, release of hostages, and humanitarian aid; that Council had previously weighed in on foreign policy; and that the resolution was not anti-Semitic. Councilwoman Hallum apologized for a since-deleted October 7 social media post, said she had since researched the conflict, called the situation genocide, and said abstaining was cowardly. Councilwoman Pritzio said she refused to be complicit in the humanitarian catastrophe and supported the motion. President Katina said democracy was in action, acknowledged the divisiveness, and urged residents to keep talking to each other. Key Outcomes - Motion 12950-24 passed 12–2. - Ceasefire Motion 1295-24 failed: 3 yes, 9 no, 2 abstentions, 1 absent. Councilmembers Grisbeck, Hallum, and Pritzio voted yes; Bonarotti and Nakarati Chapkis abstained; Councilmember Walton was absent. - The Chief Assessment Officer ordinance was referred back to committee; four new ordinances/resolutions were referred to their respective committees. - The meeting adjourned after the vote, with audience members chanting “cease fire now.”

The Allegheny County Council met on February 20, 2024, with all 15 members present. The meeting included proclamations, approval of minutes, and second readings of multiple ordinances. A large portion of the meeting was dedicated to public comment, primarily concerning a proposed ceasefire resolution for Gaza, which was not on the agenda but drew extensive testimony. The council passed four bills: two reforming the property assessment appeals board, one establishing a volunteer firefighter tax credit, and one enacting a downtown tax abatement (LERTA) to address commercial property value declines. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes of the February 6, 2024 regular meeting (motion carried unanimously). Public Comments & Testimony - Merle Pusy (Assistant Fire Chief, West Welling Volunteer Fire Department) expressed strong support for the proposed volunteer firefighter tax incentive, citing a drastic drop in volunteers and the need for recruitment incentives. He noted the proposal is already generating interest. - John Sylvestri (former solicitor for the Board of Assessment, 1978–1998) spoke in favor of three bills to improve the assessment appeals process, emphasizing that technology could reduce decision times from 60+ days to 30 days and that board members need training in uniform appraisal standards. - Over 90 members of the public registered to speak, nearly all addressing the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The majority called on the council to introduce and approve a resolution demanding an immediate and permanent ceasefire in Gaza. Speakers included Palestinian Americans who lost family members, Jewish residents citing Holocaust lessons, union representatives (e.g., UE, AFT), and students. They argued the U.S. funds the conflict and a local resolution could pressure federal officials. A smaller number of speakers opposed such a resolution, stating it is beyond the council's purview, would legitimize Hamas, and could increase anti-Semitism locally. Discussion Items - Assessment Appeals Reform (12917-24 & 12918-24): Councilmember Filiaggi introduced these bills from the Assessment Practices Committee. 12917-24 requires uniform training (9 hours every two years) for board members and hearing officers in appraisal standards and tax exemptions. 12918-24 mandates that appeals decisions be issued within 60 days (down from five months) and allows a single hearing officer with one reviewer. Councilmember Walton questioned the specifics of training and his lack of committee appointments. After discussion, bills passed as noted below. - Volunteer Service Tax Credit (12916-24): Councilmember Palmasina moved approval. This ordinance creates a real property tax incentive program for volunteer service providers (e.g., volunteer firefighters). Councilmembers Macy and Grisbeck abstained due to potential personal benefit. Passed. - Downtown LERTA (12939-24): Councilmember Bikowski presented this resolution providing a 10-year temporary tax exemption for improvements to commercial/industrial property in deteriorated areas of downtown Pittsburgh, under LERTA law. Councilmember Hallum spoke against it as a "band-aid" and called for a countywide reassessment and land value tax. Councilmember Klein and others supported it as necessary to counter falling commercial assessments, office vacancies, and to spur housing conversion. Passed. Key Outcomes - 12917-24 (Assessment board training) passed: 14 yes, 1 no (Walton). - 12918-24 (Appeals timeline) passed: 14 yes, 0 no, 1 abstention (Walton initially abstained, later stated no; recorded as abstention). - 12916-24 (Volunteer tax credit) passed: 13 yes, 0 no, 2 abstentions (Macy, Grisbeck). - 12939-24 (Downtown LERTA) passed: 14 yes, 1 no (Hallum). - 12915-24 (Continuity of Chief Assessment Officer) was held by sponsor Councilmember Katina to the March 5 meeting. - No formal ceasefire resolution was introduced or voted on, but the council heard extensive public testimony on the matter. Council President Katina reminded attendees to remain respectful and noted the council is not expert in geopolitics.

The Allegheny County Council met on February 6, 2024, at 10:15 AM. Roll call showed 14 members present. The meeting began with the Pledge of Allegiance, a moment of silence, and the reading of seven proclamations into the record. Council then heard public comment on agenda items, approved minutes, considered multiple appointments (including the County Solicitor and Jail Oversight Board members), and introduced new business items. Public comment on general items addressed volunteer firefighter tax credits, ethics, and child trafficking. Public Comments & Testimony - George Genosco (Munhall resident, former County Solicitor) spoke in strong support of confirming Rosalind Guy McCorkle as County Solicitor, citing her 30-year legal career, leadership, problem-solving skills, and ability to provide continuity in the Law Department. He urged council to confirm her. - Corey Roma (Crafton Borough resident) urged approval of Mohammed Ali Nasir, Barbara Griffin, and Rob Perkins to the Jail Oversight Board, emphasizing the need for diverse experiences and formerly incarcerated voices. He also supported a motion encouraging less restrictive zoning practices and the motion urging passage of HB 1972 (PIAA reform), while opposing the motion against the sale of U.S. Steel to Nippon, arguing the situation is different from past mergers and that Nippon’s investments would benefit the Mon Valley. - Miracle Jones (employee of One Hood Media) spoke in favor of approving Muhammad Ali Nasir to the Jail Oversight Board, highlighting his personal experience with the criminal justice system and his advocacy work. She also asked council to approve the County Solicitor appointment. - Jaseri X (Co-founder/CEO of One Hood Media, East Liberty resident) supported the appointment of Muhammad Ali Nasir, drawing parallels to Martin Luther King Jr.’s letter from jail, and argued Nasir’s humanity and rehabilitation focus make him ideal for the board. - Josh Thieler (Pittsburgh resident) supported Nasir’s nomination, describing him as a “bridge” between the jail and the community, noting the Allegheny County Jail’s high rate of forced incidents and lacking healthcare. He said Nasir stands in the gaps of knowledge and compassion. - Tanisha Long supported Nasir’s confirmation, stating the Jail Oversight Board lacks people of color with lived experience of incarceration. She also recommended Rob Perkins and Barbara Griffin, and criticized a judge on the board who had never toured the jail. She argued community member spots should reflect the community. - Brandon Schmidt (Fire Chief, Rainbow Volunteer Fire Company, White Oak, with 22 years of service) spoke against the proposed $500 tax credit for volunteer firefighters, calling it insufficient to recruit or retain members. He suggested using the $2 million budget for more effective solutions and urged council to consult firefighters. - Jeremy Kazaz spoke about ethics codes, urging council to uphold the public trust and avoid any appearance of corruption, referencing past political scandals. - Jacob Poole (also known as Zoltan Levin) testified about child trafficking and forced labor in the Pittsburgh area, claiming he was a victim. He said no organizations have supported him and that the issue is a hidden reality. Discussion Items - Proclamations: Seven proclamations were read into the record without discussion, recognizing individuals and organizations (including Christopher Lochner, Bower Hill Volunteer Fire Dept., Joe Schwann, Grace Memorial Presbyterian Church, National School Counseling Week, and Eagle Scout Alex Barker). - Approval of Minutes: Motion to approve minutes of January 23, 2024, regular meeting was made, seconded, and passed by voice vote. - Appointments – Referrals: All appointments (Donna Gardner, Russell Giancola, Maria Schwartz) were referred to the Committee on Appointment Review without discussion. - Unfinished Business – Appointments from Committee: - Barbara Griffin to Jail Oversight Board: Voice vote, motion carried. - Mohammed Ali Nasir to Jail Oversight Board: Voice vote, motion carried. - Rob Perkins to Jail Oversight Board: Voice vote, motion carried. - Mark Forrester reappointment to Housing Authority: Roll call vote – 13 yes, 0 no, 1 abstention (Councilmember Philiagi), 1 absent. Motion carried. - Mandy Steele to Housing Authority: Voice vote, motion carried. - Kyle Chintalapali to Redevelopment Authority: Voice vote, motion carried. - Rosalind Guy McCorkle as County Solicitor: Voice vote, motion carried. - New Business: - 12939-24: Resolution for a program of temporary tax exemptions for improvements on commercial/industrial property in Pittsburgh (LERTA). Referred to Economic Development and Job Creation committee. - 12926-24: Motion opposing sale of U.S. Steel to Nippon (sponsors Walton, Pritzio, Palmery). Referred to Economic Development and Job Creation committee. - 12940-24: Motion encouraging local municipalities to adopt less restrictive zoning practices (sponsors Grisbeck, Pritzio, Hallum). Referred to Housing and Homelessness committee. - 12941-24: Motion urging expeditious passage of HB 1972 to overhaul the PIAA (sponsors Palmery, Macy, Pritzio, Hallum, Betkowski, Grisbeck). Councilmember Palmery spoke, criticizing the WPIAL and PIAA for allowing small schools to compete against large schools. Motion was seconded, discussed, additional co-sponsors added (Futolas, Klein), and passed by voice vote. Key Outcomes - County Solicitor Confirmed: Rosalind Guy McCorkle was confirmed as County Solicitor by voice vote. - Jail Oversight Board Appointments Approved: Barbara Griffin, Mohammed Ali Nasir, and Rob Perkins were all confirmed by voice votes. - Housing Authority Reappointment Approved: Mark Forrester was reappointed (13-0-1, with one abstention). - Other Appointments Approved: Mandy Steele (Housing Authority) and Kyle Chintalapali (Redevelopment Authority) were approved by voice votes. - PIAA Reform Motion Passed: The motion urging passage of HB 1972 (overhauling PIAA structure and classification) passed by voice vote after discussion. - Items Referred: The resolution on tax exemptions, motion on U.S. Steel sale, and motion on zoning were referred to respective committees for further consideration. - No Action on Volunteer Firefighter Tax Credit: Public comment highlighted opposition; the proposal remains pending.

The Allegheny County Council met on January 23, 2024, to conduct a regular meeting. The agenda included proclamations, approval of minutes, appointments, new business ordinances, motions, and public comments. Key discussions involved a cost-of-living adjustment for council staff, leave policy updates, payment of litigation invoices, renewal of the council solicitor contract, and a motion regarding the proposed sale of U.S. Steel to Nippon Steel. The meeting featured both unanimous approvals and split votes. Consent Calendar - Minutes of the December 19, 2023, regular meeting were approved by unanimous voice vote. - Minutes of the January 2, 2024, regular meeting were approved by unanimous voice vote. - The following proclamations were read into the record without objection: congratulating Gerald and Carol Zeman on their 60th wedding anniversary; welcoming Shenyun Performing Arts to Allegheny County; recognizing Eagle Scout Hunter Fitzpatrick Mayor; and recognizing Eagle Scout Edward Mackenzie Vicente Khan. Public Comments & Testimony - Jacob Poole testified about his experience as a survivor of child trafficking from Eastern Europe, describing forced labor conditions in Allegheny County and Westmoreland County. He claimed to have been part of a large-scale trafficking operation using charitable foundations. He stated that he represents the 30% of the region that is first- or second-generation immigrants, though he noted his story is one of exploitation. - Katie Granaccia testified as a lifelong Pittsburgh resident, expressing gratitude for the council’s work and the region’s beauty. She also mentioned co-facilitating a local mental health and sobriety recovery program. She briefly commented on the importance of diversity, referencing Councilman Walton’s earlier remarks. Discussion Items - Presentation of Appointments: The agenda was amended to add the nomination of Rosalind Guy McCorcle for County Solicitor, which was referred to the Appointment Review Committee. Other appointments to the Jail Oversight Board, Housing Authority, and Redevelopment Authority were also referred. - Liaison Reports: Councilwoman Nakarati-Chapkis reported on the Friends of Boyce Park Committee’s 2023 activities, including a photo contest and a new social media presence. Councilwoman Filiagi reported on a bipartisan speaking engagement at Chatham University’s Pennsylvania Center for Women in Politics. - New Business – Ordinances: Four ordinances were introduced and referred to committees: one amending the Chief Assessment Officer duties for continuity; one creating a Volunteer Service Tax Credit Program; two establishing uniform training requirements and an expedited appeals process for the Property Assessment Appeals Board. - New Business – Motions: - Cost of Living Adjustment (12920-24): Councilman Palmer moved a 4% cost-of-living increase for council staff for 2024. Councilman Walton expressed concerns about the lack of diversity on council staff, but the motion passed 13-0 (two members absent). - Updated Leave Policies (12921-24): A motion to update annual, sick, and parental leave policies for council staff passed 13-0 despite a brief procedural exchange between President Katina and Councilman Walton. - Payment of Litigation Invoices (12922-24): The council authorized payment of $12,933 in total for extraordinary legal services: $8,332.50 for the minimum wage litigation and $4,600.50 for the Schumann bill litigation. Councilman Walton voted no, arguing the council should have appealed the minimum wage decision. Councilwoman Hallam noted that the executive branch would reimburse the $8,332.50. The motion passed 12-1. - Renewal of Council Solicitor Contract (12923-24): The council renewed the contract of Frederick Frank and his firm for two years. Councilman Walton voted no, citing poor legal advice on the minimum wage litigation. Councilman DeMarco raised concerns about potential conflicts of interest, but supported the renewal. The motion passed 12-1. - Renewal of Dreamscape Video Productions Contract (12924-24): The council renewed the video streaming and recording services contract for two years. The motion passed unanimously, 13-0. - Motion on U.S. Steel Sale (12926-24): Councilman Walton introduced a motion opposing the sale of U.S. Steel to Nippon Steel, arguing it would harm workers and the region. Councilman DeMarco countered that the sale would bring $14.9 billion in investment and keep the headquarters in Pittsburgh. Councilman Futolis, an original co-sponsor, withdrew his support and moved to hold the motion for further discussion. The motion to hold passed 12-1, with Councilman Walton voting no. Key Outcomes - Minutes approved: Both sets of minutes were approved unanimously. - Appointments referred: All nominations, including the new County Solicitor nominee, were referred to the Appointment Review Committee. - Cost of living adjustment: Approved (13-0) for 4% increase for council staff. - Leave policies: Updated policies approved (13-0). - Litigation invoices: Payment authorized (12-1). - Solicitor contract: Renewed for two years (12-1). - Dreamscape contract: Renewed for two years (13-0). - U.S. Steel motion: Held for future discussion (12-1). Next Steps: The held motion on U.S. Steel will be further considered after additional information is gathered. The ordinances and appointments will be reviewed by the respective committees.

The meeting was called to order by Chairwoman Pat Catina at 10:15 AM on January 2, 2024. The primary agenda items included the certification of election results and administration of oaths of office for seven returning and newly elected council members, followed by the election of the Council President. The meeting also included two proclamations. No public comment was offered. Certificates of Election and Oaths of Office Council approved and administered oaths for the following members (each certificate filed under a separate communication number, e.g., 12892‑24 through 12900‑24, and 12891‑24 for a proclamation): - Samuel DeMarco (At‑Large, third term): Took the oath administered by Judge Beamer. In remarks, DeMarco thanked voters, pledged to support the incoming administration when proposals benefit the county, and emphasized collaboration. - Bethany Hallam (At‑Large, second term): Sworn in by Judge Beamer. Hallam reflected on her first term, stating she never backed down from what is righteous. She cited troubling statistics from the past four years: at least 22 deaths in the Allegheny County jail, nearly 3,000 overdose deaths, and thousands of residents experiencing homelessness. She pledged to continue fighting for incarcerated people, overdose prevention centers, and unhoused individuals. She called on colleagues to remain authentic and fight for equity. - Suzanne Filiagi (District 2, first elected term – previously appointed): Sworn in by Judge Beamer. Filiagi thanked her family and expressed a desire to work collaboratively with all council members as a bridge to residents and a check on authority. She identified as a minority‑party member and called for participation and cooperation. - Dan Grisbeck (District 5, first term): Sworn in by Judge Sweeney. Grisbeck thanked campaign volunteers, organized labor, and the local environmental movement. He promised to work for clean air, sustainable jobs, basic needs, and dignity for all. - John F. Palmary (District 6, re‑elected): Sworn in by Judge Reagan. Palmary emphasized making county council relevant and attentive to citizen needs. He thanked his wife and campaign team, and noted the recent loss of his son. He reaffirmed his commitment to serve rather than be self‑serving. - Nick Futulis (District 7, fifth term): Sworn in by Judge (unnamed). Futulis noted his 16 years of service. He highlighted homelessness, affordable housing, and senior housing as key priorities, and urged treating people with dignity rather than using temporary shelters. - DeWitt Walton (District 10, re‑elected): Sworn in by Magistrate Petit. Walton thanked residents for an overwhelming re‑election margin. He called for equity, justice, diversity, and inclusion, and criticized the lack of any African American staff on county council. He demanded the hiring of a person of color and urged consideration of a woman of color for county solicitor. He pledged to stand firm for justice. - Paul Klein (District 11, third term): Sworn in by Judge Catherine Hans Greco. Klein highlighted the importance of compromise and consensus, and called for government committed to human flourishing rather than division. - David Bonarotti (District 13, first term): Sworn in by Judge (unnamed). Bonarotti kept remarks brief, thanking family and constituents, and pledging to learn, listen, and serve. Election of Council President Councilmember Palmary nominated incumbent President Pat Catina for re‑election. Councilmember Walton nominated himself. A roll‑call vote resulted in: - 13 votes for Pat Catina (Betkowski, Bonarotti, Catina himself, Filiagi, Futulis, Grisbeck, Klein, Macy, Nacarati‑Chapkiss, Palmary, Palmasina, Prizio, Hallam) - 2 votes for DeWitt Walton (DeMarco, Walton) Catina was declared elected President. In his acceptance remarks, Catina thanked the council and outlined challenges ahead: the 2025 budget, effects of systematic assessment appeal errors, use of the former Schumann Center site, the county jail, and the need to overhaul the ethics code. He expressed optimism for a collegial relationship with the new county administration. Proclamations Two proclamations were introduced by Councilmember Catina: - Recognizing Maggie Forbes’ dedication to the Andrew Carnegie Free Library and Music Hall, proclaiming December 27, 2023 as Maggie Forbes Day. - Recognizing Dr. Felix J. Urace for earning the 2023 National Earl Room Award. Key Outcomes - All certificates of election were approved and oaths administered, seating all 15 council members. - Pat Catina was re‑elected Council President by a vote of 13‑2. - Two proclamations were approved. - No public comment was heard, and the meeting adjourned by motion.

The Allegheny County Council held a regular meeting on December 19, 2023, at 10:00 AM. The meeting featured County Executive Rich Fitzgerald's final quarterly address, tributes from council members, a proclamation honoring his 12 years of service, and legislative action on several ordinances. Key outcomes included the passage of a reapportionment reform bill, approval of a property sale, and a vote on reproductive rights legislation, while a bill to replace Columbus Day with Indigenous People's Day failed. Quarterly Address & Tributes - County Executive Rich Fitzgerald delivered his final quarterly address, recognizing department directors and deputy directors who served under his administration. He highlighted achievements including: increasing the county's fund balance by over 1,500% (from $5 million to over $50.5 million), the highest bond rating in 40 years, no tax increases for 12 years, an 80% reduction in air pollutants, 11% reduction in carbon emissions, 20% reduction in water usage, over 80 miles of paved roads, reduction of jail population from about 2,700 to 1,600, and over 2,000 expungements through Project Reset. - Multiple council members (Councilmen Walton, Dewar, Fatulas, Macy, and others) offered personal remarks praising Fitzgerald's leadership, collaboration, and focus on job creation and economic development. - Councilmembers Katina, DeMarco, Bekkowski, and others sponsored a proclamation recognizing and honoring Fitzgerald for his contributions. The proclamation was read aloud and formally presented. Public Comments & Testimony - Marilyn Jenkin: Encouraged council to adopt standards for future redistricting processes to safeguard against gerrymandering. - Ruth Quint (League of Women Voters of Greater Pittsburgh): Expressed support for Bill 12534-22 (reapportionment reform), arguing it would codify a transparent and independent process and reduce political manipulation. - Elaine Kramer (Mount Lebanon): Spoke in favor of the same reapportionment bill, recalling that council supported fair redistricting in 2017 and urging consistency. - Susan Thornton Lara: Described her qualifications (25+ years in assessment, certified Pennsylvania evaluator) for appointment to the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review. - Jacob Poole: Claimed he was trafficked from Eastern Europe as a child and forced into labor in Allegheny County; he urged council to investigate. - Rachel Nunes (Executive Director, Thomas Merton Center): Criticized communication failures in the city-county Code Blue cold weather shelter plan, noting that unhoused individuals were not adequately informed and that pets were not allowed. She called for improved outreach and compassion. Discussion Items & Legislative Actions - Consent Calendar / Minutes: Approved minutes from November 14, November 28, and December 5, 2023 meetings by voice vote. - Appointment: Upon motion to waive rule (passed 12-2), council approved the appointment of Susan Thornton Lara to the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review for a term 2024-2026 by a roll call vote of 12-1. - Property Sale (Bill 12868-23): Approved sale of a parcel at Glen Avenue, Wilkinsburg, to Neil Straub for $400. Passed 14-0. - Indigenous People's Day vs. Columbus Day (Bill 12480-23): Proposed replacing Columbus Day with Indigenous People's Day. After debate, an amendment to also recognize Italian heritage was withdrawn. Councilmembers expressed concerns about erasing Italian American heritage. The bill failed on roll call (2 yes, 12 no). Several council members pledged to work on a separate Indigenous People's Day in November. - Reapportionment Reform (Bill 12534-22): Sponsored by Councilmember Dewar, the bill creates a uniform, independent commission for redistricting. An amendment to remove two administrative consultant positions and rely on council staff was adopted (13-0, 1 abstention). The amended bill passed 14-0. - Campaign Finance Enforcement (Bill 12812-23): Proposed giving the Ethics Commission authority to review campaign finance reports. Some council members expressed concerns about potential weaponization. The bill failed on a tied roll call (7 yes, 7 no). - Right of Choice Reproductive Rights (Bill 12741-23): Amends the Health and Sanitation code to protect reproductive rights in anticipation of potential state/federal changes. Passed 10-4 after debate about county authority. - Ethics Commission Overhaul (Bill 12888-23, New Business): Councilmember Dewar introduced a comprehensive bill to repeal and replace the Ethics Commission code. He noted it is a starting point for future discussion. Council members suggested forming a committee to gather input from former commissioners. The bill was referred to the Government Reform Committee. - Contracts: Approved a communication summarizing approved executive actions for November 2023 by voice vote. Key Outcomes - Passed: - Appointment of Susan Thornton Lara to Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review (12-1). - Sale of property at Glen Avenue, Wilkinsburg (14-0). - Reapportionment Reform ordinance (14-0 after amendment). - Right of Choice reproductive rights ordinance (10-4). - Approval of minutes and contract summary (voice votes). - Failed: - Indigenous People's Day ordinance (2-12). - Campaign finance enforcement ordinance (7-7). - Referred: Ethics Commission overhaul bill to Government Reform Committee for further study. - Next Steps: Council will work on a new bill for Indigenous People's Day in November; ethics reform will be taken up in the new session with input from former commissioners and stakeholders.

The Allegheny County Council met on December 5, 2023, to adopt the 2024 operating budget, vote on jail oversight and incarcerated welfare fund ordinances, discuss homelessness response, and hear public testimony on jail conditions, air quality, and other community concerns. The meeting included multiple proclamations honoring community members, a debate on amendments to the budget, and a vote on a routine public works ordinance. Proclamations & Certificates - Rory A. Cooper: Honored for receiving the National Medal of Technology and Innovation. Councilmember Pritzio read the proclamation; Dr. Cooper expressed gratitude. - Michael E. Lamb: Recognized for his service as Pittsburgh City Controller. Councilmember Dewar presented the proclamation; Lamb thanked council and offered advice on public service. - Councilmember Tom Dewar: Recognized for his service to District 5. Councilmembers highlighted his legislative achievements and commitment. - Councilmember Olivia Bennett: Recognized for her service to District 13. Councilmembers praised her advocacy and community work. - Additional proclamations read into the record: Michelle Stowell, Nino Petricelli Sr., Joseph Colosimo Jr., and Nicholas Sasilski. Public Comments & Testimony - Donald Breitbarth (CCAC AFT faculty): Urged support for increased CCAC funding, citing a $1.3 billion economic impact and that the county is below the mandated 33% contribution. Thanked council for last year's $2.8 million increase. - Mohammed Ali Nasir (One Hood Media): Supported the Incarcerated Individuals Welfare Fund and changing jail uniforms from red, arguing red causes negative psychological effects. Urged paying incarcerated workers, stating 225 people work eight hours daily for free. - Tanisha Long (former detainee): Criticized jail conditions, free labor, and red uniforms. Noted that 95% of detainees are not convicted and demanded the budget be passed with amendments for jail reforms. - Dr. Phoebe Cook (biologist, search and rescue): Criticized the Code Blue activation threshold of 26°F, arguing hypothermia can occur at higher temperatures, especially with dampness or contact with cold ground. - Tom Bailey: Cited his wife's respiratory issues due to air pollution from U.S. Steel Clairton Coke Works. Called for suspension of the operating permit until compliance is confirmed, noting increased hazardous air pollutants from 165 tons (2020) to 234 tons (2021). - Cindy Meckle (Glassport resident): Described health impacts from benzene exposure and lack of weekend enforcement. Accused U.S. Steel of planning to abandon the plant while polluting. - David Meckle (Glassport resident, retired Marine): Presented particulate matter samples from his home. Stated he cannot engage in strenuous outdoor activity due to poor air quality. Urged council to enforce clean air standards. - Jacob Poole: Alleged he was a victim of child trafficking from Eastern Europe, brought to the U.S. through the Heinz Foundation. Described ongoing isolation and lack of legal status. Discussion Items - Budget Debate (Ordinance 12856-23): Councilmember Palmasina moved approval of the 2024 operating budget. Councilmember DeMarco attempted to amend the agenda to strip two items (jail worker pay and uniform funding) but the motion to waive the 48-hour rule failed (6-9). Debate centered on $1 million for incarcerated worker wages and $500,000 for new uniforms. Supporters argued the payments address involuntary servitude; opponents called the funds a "slush fund," questioned legal implications for county employee status, and argued the new administration should decide. Councilmember Walton supported compensation but opposed uniform changes. - Jail Oversight Board Ordinance (12854-23): Codified the Jail Oversight Board and authorized solicitor retention and fund expenditures. Passed 11-4. - Incarcerated Individuals Welfare Fund Ordinance (12853-23): Established a fund for revenues from incarcerated individuals. Passed 11-4. - Public Works Ordinance (12855-23): Authorized temporary permits, easements, and real estate acquisitions for 2024-2025. Councilmember Bennett proposed an amendment to limit delegation to emergent situations and require notice to council. The amendment failed (2-13). The original ordinance passed (14-1). - Homelessness Response: Council President Katina questioned County Manager Jen Liptak and DHS Director Aaron Dalton about why unhoused individuals were turned away on cold nights. Dalton explained the previous Code Blue protocol relied on city activation; they have since adopted a 26°F temperature threshold and will open additional shelters and a drop-in center by December 15. Councilmember Hallam pressed about lack of no-barrier shelter capacity; Dalton acknowledged the system is functionally full and emphasized the need for affordable housing to move people out of shelters. Councilmembers expressed concern but thanked staff for their work. - Shuman Center Update: President Katina reported that council's declaratory judgment action is ongoing but not delaying construction. The first pod is expected to open by April 29, 2024. Key Outcomes - Operating Budget (12856-23): Approved 10-5. Includes $1 million for incarcerated worker wages and $500,000 for new jail uniforms. - Jail Oversight Board (12854-23): Passed 11-4. - Incarcerated Individuals Welfare Fund (12853-23): Passed 11-4. - Public Works Ordinance (12855-23): Passed 14-1. - Budget Transfer Committee (new business): Re-established unanimously (14-0). - Amendment to Public Works Ordinance: Failed 2-13.

The Allegheny County Council met on November 28, 2023, with 14 members present. The meeting included proclamations, approval of three fiscal year 2024 budget ordinances, a charter-related administrative code amendment, referrals of property conveyances, and public comments on transit service, a plastic bag ban, and homeless campsite legislation. The Council also recognized County Solicitor George Chanosco for his 45 years of service. Proclamations & Certificates - Certificates of recognition for the 2023 Shining Star Gala Awardees (sponsored by Councilmember Filadie). - Proclamation honoring Frances S. Butts on her 100th birthday (sponsored by Councilmember Walton). - Proclamation honoring Denise White on her 70th birthday (sponsored by Councilmember Walton). Consent Calendar - No items were placed on a consent calendar; all actions were taken individually. Public Comments & Testimony - Annette Kroll (Bridgeville resident) expressed frustration with Pittsburgh Regional Transit (PRT) service, citing bus route cuts, drivers skipping stops, and a three-hour delay due to a driver returning to the garage. She criticized the PRT CEO and board, and opposed the upcoming plastic bag ban, calling it a tax on non-drivers and people with disabilities. - Rachel Nunes (Executive Director, Thomas Merton Center) urged the Council to act on establishing serviced homeless campsites, warning that prolonged cold exposure leads to hypothermia, frostbite, and other health crises. She stated that people will die if the city does not provide heated tents and called for an end to camp evictions. - Sam Schmidt (Bellevue resident and outreach worker) supported City Council’s proposed zoning amendment (2023-2197) to create temporary city-maintained homeless shelters with heated tents and services. He noted that outreach workers are already seeing hospitalizations and that the long-term solution is affordable housing, but immediate shelter is needed to save lives. Discussion Items - Budget and Finance Committee Reports (Second Reading): - Ordinance 12852-23 establishing the 2024 real property tax levy (sponsored by Councilmember Palmasina). The committee met on November 21 and recommended approval. Passed unanimously (14-0). - Resolution 12857-23 adopting the 2024 capital budget (sponsored by Councilmember Palmasina). Passed unanimously (14-0). - Resolution 12858-23 adopting the 2024 grants budget, special accounts budget, and agency fund budget (sponsored by Councilmember Palmasina). Passed unanimously (14-0). - Liaison Report: Council President Katina reported that the Board of Elections met on November 28 at 10:00 AM and certified the 2023 general election results, including write-in results posted on the website. He noted that over 1,000 mail-in ballots arrived after the 8:00 PM deadline and were not counted, urging voters to submit mail-in ballots early. - New Business – Ordinance 12867-23: An ordinance amending the Administrative Code to eliminate reference to the prohibition on council members receiving salaries, aligning with the voter-approved charter change from a stipend to a salary. Councilmember Dewar moved to waive the second reading. The waiver passed 13-1 (Ms. Hallam voted no). The ordinance itself then passed 13-1 (Ms. Hallam voted no). - New Business – Referrals: - Ordinance 12868-23: Approving the sale of a county parcel (Glen Avenue, Wilkinsburg) to Mr. Neil Straub for $400, referred to the Committee on Economic Development and Housing. - Ordinance 12869-23: Authorizing a land exchange (0.88-acre county parcel in White Oak Park for a 0.89-acre parcel from A. Keith Staso Revocable Trust), referred to the Committee on Parks. - Resolution 12870-23: Providing a temporary property tax exemption for improvements to commercial/industrial property in deteriorated areas of Pittsburgh under the Local Economic Revitalization Tax Assistance Act, referred to the Committee on Economic Development and Housing. Key Outcomes - Votes: - Three fiscal year 2024 budget bills passed unanimously (14-0). - Ordinance 12867-23 (administrative code amendment) passed 13-1. - Directives: - Council President Katina indicated he would follow up with Annette Kroll on PRT concerns. - Public comments on homeless campsites were received; no immediate action was taken. - Recognition: County Solicitor George Chanosco was recognized for 45 years of service, with his last day on December 1, 2023.