Public Meetings - Allegheny County, Pennsylvania

The Allegheny County Council held its regular meeting on Tuesday, August 20, 2024, at 5:00 PM in the Gold Room of the Allegheny County Courthouse. President Patrick Catena presided with 13 members present (Bonaroti, DeMarco, Filiaggi, Futules, Grzybek, Hallam, Klein, Macey, Naccarati-Chapkis, Palmiere, Palmosina, Prizio, Walton). The meeting included proclamations, approval of minutes, appointments, introduction of ordinances and resolutions, motions, contract notifications, and public comment. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approved: Three sets of minutes were approved unanimously: - June 18, 2024 regular meeting (motion 13145-24) - July 2, 2024 regular meeting (motion 13146-24) - July 9, 2024 regular meeting (motion 13147-24) – approved as amended to correct a typographical error on the cover page (the meeting date was listed as July 2 instead of July 9; the minutes themselves were accurate). - Appointments Referred: Three appointments were referred to the Committee on Appointments for review: - James Gezo to Friends of the Park for Harrison Hills (term through August 20, 2027) - Sam Einsidler to Friends of the Park for Hartwood Acres (term through August 20, 2027) - John Fournier, MPA, to serve as County Manager (term effective upon Council approval) - Contract Notifications: Two communications summarizing approved executive actions for June 2024 (13148-24) and July 2024 (13149-24) were received and filed without discussion. Proclamations & Recognitions Twelve proclamations were read into the record, recognizing community events, anniversaries, and service. Notable proclamations included: Whitehall Borough Community Weekend, Chief James "Traz" Matrazzo (28 years), Churchill Borough 90th Anniversary, David Kindig and Kevin Schiele (car industry), MaxMotive, Fire Chief Nicholas Sohyda (25 years), Officer Erick Lakin (31 years), Pittsburgh Brewing Company (160+ years), Pittsburgh Lutheran United Ministries (20th anniversary), Richard and Elsie Ferencz (60th wedding anniversary), Richard V. Piacentini (30 years at Phipps Conservatory), and Wilma Virginia Walters (100th birthday). Several council members asked to be added as co-sponsors to specific proclamations. Discussion Items - Ordinances & Resolutions Introduced: Eight pieces of legislation were introduced and referred to standing committees: - 13151-24: Fire safety information distribution by Health Department to restaurant owners (referred to Health and Human Services) - 13152-24: Voter citizenship verification mechanism for Board of Elections (referred to Government Reform; Councilmember Hallam added as co-sponsor) - 13153-24: Sale of county property on Hollywood Drive, Hampton Township, for $3,300 to Ashley and Kenneth Downing (referred to Economic Development and Job Creation) - 13154-24: Condemnation for Fallen Timber Run Bridge No. 6 replacement in Forward Township (referred to Public Works) - 13155-24: Condemnation for Greensburg Pike Lateral Support Project in Turtle Creek Borough (referred to Public Works) - 13156-24: Condemnation for Beam Run Bridge No. 1 replacement in Jefferson Hills Borough (referred to Public Works) - 13157-24: Ratification of revisions to Health Department rules on housing and community environment (referred to Health and Human Services) - 13158-24: Ratification of year-end transfers per Administrative Code Section 805.03 (referred to Budget and Finance) - Motions Approved: Two motions authorizing public hearings were passed unanimously: - 13159-24: Authorizes the President of Council to conduct three public hearings (October 17, 28, and 30, 2024 at 5:00 PM) in the Gold Room, pursuant to §801.05 of the Administrative Code. - 13160-24: Authorizes a public hearing on Wednesday, September 18, 2024, at 4:30 PM in the Gold Room, pursuant to the Home Rule Charter and Administrative Code. Public Comments & Testimony One member of the public, Chad Ringbloom, spoke during the public comment period on general items. He criticized at-large Councilwoman Bethany Hallam for her social media comments following the attempted assassination of former President Donald Trump in Butler County. He characterized her initial post ("wow, the crime in Butler County is out of control") as mocking the tragedy, and accused her of ties to an account called "Filler Distro" that allegedly made violent comments (e.g., "praying they won't miss next time"). Ringbloom called on the council to hold Hallam accountable with censure, invoking religious language ("the Lord rebuke you"). No council member responded to his comments. Key Outcomes - All three sets of minutes were approved (one as amended). - All three appointments were referred to committee for further review. - Both motions authorizing public hearings were approved unanimously. - Two contract notifications were received and filed. - No votes were taken on the introduced ordinances or resolutions; they were referred to committees for deliberation. - No formal action was taken regarding the public commenter's request for censure.

The Allegheny County Council met on July 9, 2024, with President Katina presiding and 13 members present. The meeting opened with several proclamations and included a contentious vote rejecting all five appointments to the Juvenile Detention Board of Advisors, approval of a non-controversial resolution supporting a national unity day, and public comment on police, Palestine, and community outreach. Proclamations & Recognitions - Ken Rice (30 years at KDKA TV): Proclamation 13120-24 congratulating the news anchor, who attended and spoke briefly. - William Fisher (100th birthday): Proclamation 13121-24 honoring the former Taylor Allderdice High School principal. Councilmember Klein read the proclamation and noted Fisher was not present. - Louise Stevens (90th birthday): Proclamation 13122-24, sponsored by Councilmember Palmasina. - 2024 Castle Shannon Community Day: Proclamation 13123-24, sponsored by Councilmember Palmery. - Kathy Decker (Golden Life status with Motor Maids): Proclamation 13124-24, sponsored by Councilmember Beikowski. - Linda Fisher (retirement): Proclamation 13125-24, sponsored by Councilmember Prizio. Public Comments & Testimony - On agenda items: None. - On general items: Yas Azuni of Brookline spoke, encouraging council members to read books by Palestinian authors during the upcoming break, to understand the Palestinian struggle, and invited them to visit mosques for Friday prayers. No other public speakers were recorded in the transcript. Discussion Items - Appointments to Juvenile Detention Board of Advisors (Second reading, Committee on Appointment Review): Five appointments were presented without recommendation (13084-24 through 13088-24). Councilmember Filiaggi moved to bundle them and reject all. Several members criticized the administration for a rushed and uncommunicative process, noting the board's revival came as a surprise just before summer break. Councilmember Walton voted no, stating he rejected the council's approach for not including him in discussions. The motion passed 14-1, rejecting: - Dr. Kathy Elliott - Richard Garland - Tiffany Sizemore - Christy Troutman - Michael Williams - Ordinance 13126-24: Amending Administrative Code Article 210 (Assessment Standards) to codify sales data validation for the common level ratio. Referred to the Committee on Assessment Practices. - Resolution 13127-24: Expressing council support for the National Flag Foundation's "Light to Unite" National Day of Unity on July 4, 2026. Sponsored by President Katina. Motion to waive second reading and approve passed by voice vote. - Liaison Reports: - Councilmember (presumably Bob) highlighted the FAR VEST program (Volunteer Emergency Services Training), offering college education or trade training for five years of volunteer fire service. - Another councilmember commended County Treasurer Brussels for transparent communication regarding staffing and job opportunities. Key Outcomes - Rejected Appointments: All five appointments to the Juvenile Detention Board of Advisors were rejected (14-1). - Approved Resolution: The National Unity Day resolution (13127-24) was adopted. - Referred Ordinance: The assessment standards amendment (13126-24) was referred to committee. - No Other Business: The meeting adjourned after public comments.

County Executive Sara Innamorato delivered her second quarterly address, reporting progress on elections, infrastructure, housing, and transit. Council heard extensive public testimony on the climate action plan, passed a bond issuance of up to $445 million, and approved an ordinance extending the climate action plan deadline to July 1, 2025. Consent Calendar - Approved minutes of the June 4, 2024 regular meeting (voice vote, no opposition). - Approved appointments and reappointments on a block vote: Thomas Burgunder and Bobby Fan to the Pittsburgh Regional Transit Board, Gil Barry to the Southwest Pennsylvania Commission, Lisa Freeman, G. Eric French, Juan Garrett, and Anita Prizio to the Allegheny County Conservation District, and corrected term end dates for three Conservation District board members. Public Comments & Testimony - Climate Action Plan (CAP): Twenty community members spoke, overwhelmingly advocating for an inclusive, transparent, and community-led process. Key points: - Helen Gerhardt noted that the RFQ appeared to focus only on county operations, while the ordinance instructs reference to broader plans. She urged a cross-sector approach. - Pamaj Chakmam Nij (Grand Inca, Ongweonwe nation) stressed the need for transparency and inclusion of indigenous voices. - Ed Rand (Pittsburgh Green New Deal) suggested using local resources instead of a consultant. - Paul LeBlanc proposed focusing on abandoned gas wells and principles of people before profit. - Fawn Walker Montgomery (Mon Valley resident) highlighted environmental racism, stating "I can't breathe where I live" and called for a task force representing those most impacted. - Marcia Bandies urged embedding equity metrics and cumulative impact assessments. - Julia Menti (social worker) emphasized accountability measures and periodic public updates. - Ilias Khan (youth advocate) requested extending the deadline and including youth representatives to regain trust. - Leslie Centola (Upstream Pittsburgh) supported extending the deadline to July 2025, arguing that community expertise is essential. - Dana Siler (Citizens Climate Lobby) warned against fossil fuel influence and cited a University of Pittsburgh study showing children living near fracking wells are up to seven times more likely to develop lymphoma. - Alejandro Sanchez criticized fossil fuel lobbying and called for a democratic CAP without corporate influence. - General Public Comment: - Harry Lulder advocated for a Women's Health Care Freedom Act amendment and urged council to take it to the DNC. - Yas Azuni raised concerns about address search security on the county website, providing several ZIP codes, and requested CAPTCHA or other measures. Discussion Items - County Executive's Quarterly Address (Sara Innamorato): - Reported a successful April election with no issues. - Announced a 72% reduction in bridges in poor condition (from 65 in 2014 to 18 now, with 2 under construction). - Launched "500 and 500": a collaborative effort to create 500 deeply affordable housing units in 500 days for people exiting homelessness. A website tracker is live. - Launched Allegheny Go with PRT: all SNAP recipients eligible for half-price bus fare. Enrollment at discountedfares.alleghenycounty.us, with Spanish materials. - Announced four new PRT board members (Emma Schauker, Tia McClenny, Thomas Brogrunder, Bobby Fan). - Reported on the June 4 fire at 2nd Avenue Commons shelter: 94 individuals moved to a Pittsburgh Mercy facility; 94 others rehoused; damage extensive, reopening may take months. - Emphasized the need for permanent housing over shelters, especially after the Supreme Court ruling allowing penalties for sleeping outside—county will not change its approach. - Announced hiring of new directors: Tony McCabb (Facilities), Brittany Pershak (Sustainability), Dr. Julian Vaughn (Health Department), and Melanie Ondike (Grants Manager). - Stated the county will issue an RFQ for a climate action plan consultant, with an advisory group including environmental justice communities. - Noted financial challenges as ARPA funds wind down, previewing upcoming budget discussions. - Q&A with Council: - Councilmember Macy raised concerns about decades-long economic neglect in the Mon Valley (50% below poverty, poor housing, roads). The Executive highlighted $8 million invested in Braddock and agreed to a strategic meeting. - Vice Chair Palmery asked about the climate action plan advisory board; the Executive confirmed it will include community voices and build on existing municipal plans. - Councilmember Klein asked about participatory budgeting; the Executive committed to engaging council before budget introduction. - Councilmember Klein also asked about 500 and 500 timeline: units are coming online through streamlined housing authority processes, prioritizing shelter users (from 6/year to 20/month). - Discussion on Second Avenue Commons overflow: exploring options, no announcement yet. - Councilmember Klein raised the county housing opportunity fund and eviction prevention; the Executive noted a plan to extend the lawyer of the day program and hopes for state funding. - Councilmember Klein asked about jail population reduction: average daily population in June 2024 was 1,700 (up slightly from last year, down from 2,500 in 2020). Uniforms expected soon; worker stipends under discussion. - Councilmember DeMarco asked about the reopened Schuman Center (now Highland Detention Center); the Executive confirmed community voice will be included in further phases. - Councilmember DeMarco also asked about county plumbers helping city pools; the Executive confirmed county plumbers assisted. - President Katina (via phone) asked about the 911 radio system upgrade; the Executive explained it involves new digital equipment for 400 agencies across 37 towers, part of the bond issuance. - Councilmember Filiagi requested a meeting with new Health Director Dr. Vaughn; the Executive agreed to arrange. - Proclamation: Recognized Glendale Hose Company No. 1 for its 150th anniversary. Chief Scott Cavey thanked council and noted the importance of the radio system upgrade. - Bond Issuance (13109-24): Ordinance authorizing up to $198 million in Series C80 bonds and up to $247 million in Series C81 refunding bonds. The Budget and Finance Committee recommended approval. Passed 14-0. - Amended Grants Budget (13111-24): Resolution amending the 2024 grants budget. Passed 14-0. - Property Sale (13110-24): Sale of Demler Street parcel in North Fayette for $5,500 to Edward Dandar. Passed 14-0. - TIF District Dissolution (13004-24): Dissolving the Mount Nebo Point Tax Increment Financing District. Passed 14-0. - Climate Action Plan Deadline Extension (13118-24): Ordinance introduced by Councilmember Prizio to extend the CAP deadline to July 1, 2025. Motion to waive second reading passed 11-3. Final vote: 12-2 (Macy and DeMarco opposed). Passed. Key Outcomes - Appointments approved: Thomas Burgunder and Bobby Fan to PRT Board; Gil Barry to Southwest PA Commission; Lisa Freeman, G. Eric French, Juan Garrett, and Anita Prizio to Conservation District; corrected term end dates for three Conservation District members. - Bond Issuance approved: Up to $445 million in general obligation bonds for capital projects and refunding (14-0). - Property sale approved: Demler Street parcel for $5,500 (14-0). - TIF District dissolved: Mount Nebo Point TIF dissolved (14-0). - Climate action plan deadline extended: To July 1, 2025 (12-2). - Executive actions for May 2024: Received and filed.

The Allegheny County Council met on June 18, 2024, with 15 members present. The meeting began with the Pledge of Allegiance and a moment of prayer. The council proceeded out of order due to delays, starting with proclamations, then appointments, new business, and public comment. The meeting adjourned to reconvene for executive session on pending litigation. Proclamations and Recognitions - Eaton Park 75th Anniversary (13094-24): Councilmember Fatulis sponsored a proclamation recognizing Eaton Park Hospitality Group's 75th anniversary. He shared personal memories and read the proclamation highlighting the company's growth from a single car hop in 1949 to 56 locations (24 in Allegheny County), employing nearly 10,000 team members. The company has raised nearly $10 million for UPMC Children's Hospital and will award $75,000 grants to food banks. Representatives Jordan Steward (President of Restaurant Division), Courtney Caprera, and Brooks Broadhurst accepted, with Steward expressing pride in the company's community involvement. - Ted Puzak Retirement Board Service (13097-24): Councilmember Macy sponsored a proclamation honoring Ted Puzak for 24 years on the Allegheny County Retirement Board. Puzak, a U.S. Marine Corps veteran, was hospitalized and unable to attend. Walter Samanski accepted on his behalf. - Anary Sheth G - U.S. Presidential Scholar (13095-24): Councilmember Filyagi recognized Anary Sheth G, a North Allegheny senior, as one of 161 Presidential Scholars selected from 3.7 million students. Sheth G's achievements include research at UPMC Hillman Cancer Center, publishing a children's book, and a full scholarship to NJIT. She thanked her family, school district, and the city of Pittsburgh. - Lindsay Downs - Educator of the Year (13096-24): Councilmember Filyagi presented a proclamation to Lindsay Downs, librarian at Sewickley Academy, for receiving the 2024 Alan C. Miller Educator of the Year Award from the News Literacy Project. Downs emphasized the importance of news literacy and critical thinking. She noted that Pennsylvania is not yet one of the states implementing news literacy education. - Additional proclamations were read for Renton Volunteer Fire Department (75th anniversary), Pogo Palooza (20th anniversary), Jeff Scargo (law enforcement service), Earl "Father" Hines (music legacy), Castle Shannon and Clairton Memorial Day celebrations, and Eagle Scout achievements for Brady Ellis, Brena Collery, Samuel Kelly, and Nicholas Jesso. Appointments - The clerk read a list of appointments referred to the Committee on Appointment Review, including nominees to the Pittsburgh Regional Transit Board, Southwest Pennsylvania Commission, Juvenile Detention Board of Advisors, and Allegheny County Conservation District. - Second Reading – Friends of South Park: Nine appointments and reappointments to the Friends of South Park (terms through July 6, 2027) were approved unanimously via a single motion by Councilmember Nakarati Chapkis, with no discussion. New Business – Ordinances and Resolutions - 13108-24: Ordinance amending prior authorization for Department of Public Works actions on temporary occupancy permits, highway occupancy permits, and easements for county projects (referred to Public Works). - 13109-24: Ordinance authorizing up to $198 million in general obligation bonds (Series C80) and up to $247 million in refunding bonds (Series C81) (referred to Budget and Finance). - 13110-24: Ordinance approving sale of Demler Street property in North Fayette for $5,500 to Edward Dander (referred to Economic Development and Job Creation). - 13111-24: Resolution amending the grants and special accounts budget for 2024 (referred to Budget and Finance). Public Comment - Salesha Williams (disability rights coalition): Urged reconsideration of the decision to eliminate the Allegheny County Department of Human Services Office of Behavioral Health Education Specialist position. She argued the decision was based on incomplete analysis and would harm students with disabilities. She requested a one-year delay for a comprehensive review. - Yaf Azuni: Requested the council proclaim June 8th as a day of memory for the 34 U.S. servicemen killed in the 1967 USS Liberty attack by Israel. He also urged the council not to adopt the IHRA definition of anti-Semitism, which he said could label criticism of Israel as anti-Semitic. - Helen Gerhardt (Climate Action Plan and Environmental Justice Coalition): Supported the climate action plan process but urged the Department of Sustainability to hire inclusive service providers, create a community advisory board with real power, and hold accessible public meetings. She submitted documents with 32 organizational signatories. Key Outcomes - All Friends of South Park appointments were approved unanimously. - New ordinances and resolutions were introduced and referred to appropriate committees. - The meeting adjourned to executive session for discussion of pending litigation. Note: No consent calendar was explicitly identified; routine approvals of appointments were handled by unanimous vote.

The Allegheny County Council met on June 4, 2024, with 14 members present (one absent). The meeting featured a contentious debate and vote on a resolution opposing the sale of U.S. Steel to Nippon Steel, which ultimately failed. Council also passed a resolution urging enactment of a state bill to make post-traumatic stress injury compensable for first responders, approved several appointments, recognized outgoing County Manager Jennifer Liptak and other community figures, and advanced routine legislative items. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: The minutes of the May 7, 2024 regular meeting were approved by voice vote. - Appointments: All appointments were referred to the Committee on Appointment Review and then voted on individually. The following appointments/reappointments were approved by voice votes: - Ed Eichenlob, Dave Bukowitz, James Converse, Carolyn Svicus, Jason Finkey, Tom Woods, and Jake Riley to the Friends of South Park. - Corey Seymour to the Friends of Hartwood Acres. - Richard Snipe to the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review. - Brian Burley to the Minority, Women, and Disadvantaged Business Enterprise Advisory Committee. - Robert Palmasina to the Sports and Exhibition Authority (Councilman Palmasina abstained). - Bridget J. Daly to the Regional Asset District Board. - Christopher Sandveg and Daniel Grisbeck to the Southwestern Pennsylvania Commission (Councilman Grisbeck abstained). Public Comments & Testimony - Michael Suley spoke in support of Councilman DeMarco’s bill to change the property assessment appeal deadline, stating that the current system creates uncertainty. - Harry Liller (during general public comment) proposed a constitutional amendment called the “Women’s Health Care Freedom Act” and urged the council to adopt a resolution or proclamation. He also referenced his earlier proposal for an employee-owned buyout of U.S. Steel. - Yas Azuni spoke about free speech, criticizing Republican efforts to ban TikTok and criminalize phrases related to the Palestinian cause, and expressed support for the Democratic Party’s social safety net. Discussion Items U.S. Steel / Nippon Steel Resolution (Bill 12926-24) Councilman Walton moved to amend the agenda to bring this resolution to the floor, citing council rules that allow items stuck in committee to be brought up. The motion to amend passed 10-4 (with Councilman Klein absent). The resolution would have opposed the sale of U.S. Steel to Nippon Steel. Key speakers and positions: - Councilman DeMarco (opposed the resolution) argued the sale is the best outcome for the region, citing Nippon’s promises to keep U.S. Steel intact, invest $1.4 billion, maintain headquarters in Pittsburgh, and honor labor agreements. He called the deal “absolutely the best deal” and criticized the “catch-or-kill” strategy of Cleveland-Cliffs. - Councilman Grisback (opposed the resolution) echoed DeMarco, noting that Japan is a trusted ally and that Nippon has operated in the U.S. for 40 years. He warned that if Cleveland-Cliffs acquired U.S. Steel, white-collar jobs would leave Pittsburgh. - Councilwoman Filiaci (opposed the resolution) emphasized Nippon’s willingness to address environmental issues and engage with community leaders. - Councilman Walton (supported the resolution) cited national security concerns, the lack of accountability if Nippon fails to deliver, and the history of broken promises at the Mon Valley Works. He stated that the United Steelworkers union opposes the sale and that both U.S. Senators and the President oppose it. - Councilwoman Nakarati Chapkis (position unclear) asked about the status of collective bargaining agreements and noted that her constituents in District 8 (where Edgar Thomson Works is located) have met with Nippon and are encouraged. - Councilman Fatulis (supported the resolution) said he was voting in favor of Councilman Walton because Walton worked at U.S. Steel and knows more, but acknowledged the council’s opinion is unlikely to affect the sale. - Councilman Palmasina (supported the resolution) expressed skepticism about corporate promises and cited his own district’s experience with broken commitments. - President Katina (opposed the resolution) made a motion to table the item to allow more time to talk to union leaders, but the motion to table failed 4-10. He later voted no on the resolution. A member of the public, Harry Liller, briefly spoke in favor of an employee-owned buyout of U.S. Steel. Vote on the resolution: The motion to approve Bill 12926-24 (which would oppose the sale) failed 6-8 (with one absent). The ayes (opposing the sale) were: Betkowski, Bonarotti, Fatulis, Palmery, Palmasina, Walton. The nays (supporting the sale) were: DeMarco, Filiaci, Grisback, Hallam, Macy, Nakarati Chapkis, Pritzio, President Katina. First Responder PTSD Bill (Resolution 13079-24) Councilman Palmasina moved to approve a resolution urging the Pennsylvania General Assembly to enact HB 1632, which would make post-traumatic stress injury compensable for first responders under workers’ compensation. The motion was seconded. Councilman Grisback, a volunteer firefighter, abstained. The resolution passed by voice vote with one abstention. Proclamations & Recognitions - Jennifer Liptak – Recognized for her 26 years of service, including as County Manager. Council members praised her dedication and intelligence. Ms. Liptak spoke about her family’s public service history and her pride in being the first female county manager. - Andy Warhol Museum – Celebrated its 30th anniversary. Representatives noted over 20 million visitors served and highlighted the Pop District initiative for workforce development. - Isaac Bernstein – Recognized as a 2024 Coca-Cola Scholar. He spoke about his service organization “Plates for Pitt” (raising over $44,000 for food insecurity) and his plans to attend Princeton. - McCandless Franklin Park Ambulance Authority and Ross Westview Emergency Medical Services Authority – Both received proclamations for earning national accreditation from the Commission on Accreditation of Ambulance Services, a distinction held by only 182 of 18,000 EMS agencies in the U.S. Representatives emphasized the partnership between the two agencies. Key Outcomes - Resolution opposing U.S. Steel sale to Nippon Steel failed (6-8). The council will not take a formal position against the sale. - Resolution supporting HB 1632 (first responder PTSD) passed (voice vote, one abstention). - Second reading of Ordinance 13056-24 (amending property assessment appeal deadlines) passed 14-0 after a minor amendment to keep the appeal window at 30 days (instead of 60) for change notices. The bill moves the general appeal deadline earlier to provide certainty. - Second reading of Resolution 13057-24 (amending 2024 grants and special accounts budget) passed 14-0. - Second reading of Ordinance 13042-24 (ratifying revisions to Health Department housing regulations) passed 14-0. - New Business: Ordinance 13078-24 (establishing tax neutral assessed values for certain eligible taxpayers) was introduced and referred to the Committee on Assessment Practices. Other Items - President Katina noted a fire at the Second Avenue Commons homeless shelter earlier that day, which was safely evacuated. He thanked first responders and the county administration for their rapid response.

This public hearing of the Allegheny County Council was held on May 22, 2024, to discuss property reassessment practices, including the common level ratio (CLR), the need for a countywide reassessment, and potential legislation for regular assessments. The hearing featured presentations from county officials, experts from Lackawanna County, Tyler Technologies, and the International Association of Assessing Officers (IAAO), followed by public testimony. The meeting began at 10:15 AM and was scheduled to wrap up by 7:30 PM. Presentations - Fargas Day, Chairman of the Allegheny County Board of Viewers: Argued that reassessment is necessary because the CLR is imprecise and manipulable. He proposed a computer system to constantly update valuations using data from multiple departments. He noted that commercial properties are not included in CLR data, which unfairly penalizes them. He also highlighted the hardship on seniors facing tax increases, stating that as a hearing officer he could only follow the law and not consider personal circumstances. - Patrick Tobin, Director of Lackawanna County’s Office of Assessments and Appeals: Described their ongoing reassessment (base year 1968) with Tyler Technologies, a 4-year process costing approximately $5.1 million. He emphasized public education and relief measures, including a two-year reassessment relief initiative that defers payment of increases interest-free. - Paul Miller, Tyler Technologies: Discussed reassessment methodologies, costs (approx. $50-65 per parcel in recent contracts), and the challenges of labor and public acceptance. He noted that Pennsylvania is one of the last base-year states and advocated for cyclical reassessment over trigger-based systems, citing the predictability of a calendar-based cycle. - Shannon Hiss and Justin Elmers, IAAO: Presented technical standards, including the importance of physical inspections every 4-6 years, timely sales verification (within 6-8 weeks of recording), and statistical measures like coefficient of dispersion (COD) and price-related differential (PRD). They emphasized data accuracy and public trust. Public Comments & Testimony - Mike Sulley (27 years in assessment business): Supported reassessment but stressed the need for a chief assessor with experience. He noted that in 2012, the appeals process was done first, then values implemented, and that only about 7,500 appeals were filed this year out of 600,000 properties, indicating an unfair system. - Dana O’Connor (Lawrenceville resident): Supported frequent reassessments for fairness, noting that neighborhoods like Lawrenceville and the Strip District have drastically changed since 2012. - Jack Billings (Squirrel Hill): Offered three suggestions for the legislation: strike the ban on computer-assisted mass appraisal, clarify the chief assessor liability clause, and consider annual cycles instead of COD trigger. He cited a quote of $219,000 per year for annual assessments from the firm Value Base. - Nicholas Ritzia (downtown resident): Supported regular assessments and land value tax, linking to public safety funding. He shared an anecdote about waiting on hold with emergency services, arguing that lost revenue from inequitable assessments harms essential services. - Christopher Beam (Bloomfield): Shared personal stories of inequity, including friends who pay six times more in taxes despite similar home values. He argued that regular reassessments are essential for fairness. - David Fats (Pro Housing Pittsburgh): Endorsed the ordinance for equitable housing, stating that the current system taxes new homeowners and younger, less wealthy residents disproportionately. - Lisa Schwartz: Raised concerns about data accuracy, noting that exterior inspections in 2012 missed interior details. She warned that Allegheny County is losing population to neighboring counties with lower property tax rates, and that reassessment could drive more people out. - John Aikey (via comment): Noted that until the 1970s, Allegheny County had regular assessments, and urged the council to mandate frequent assessments to close loopholes. Discussion Items - Councilmembers debated the merits of trigger-based (COD) vs. cyclical reassessment. Councilmember Hallam explained her bill using Vermont’s COD model, but Councilmember Klein noted that Vermont is moving away from COD to a cyclical system effective January 1, 2025. - Councilmember DeMarco questioned the inclusion of commercial properties in CLR and the impact on seniors. He highlighted that Allegheny County has 1,224,825 residents, with 20.4% (249,865) over 65, and that reassessment could tax unrealized capital gains. - Councilmember Grisbeck pointed out that areas like Carrick are overpaying now and would benefit from reassessment, while Councilmember DeMarco countered that wealth is only realized upon sale, not on paper. - Councilmember Howell asked about cost and timeline for a potential reassessment. Paul Miller estimated 5 years for Allegheny County due to scale and labor challenges, with costs around $50-65 per parcel currently, but likely higher in the future. - The IAAO recommended physical inspections every 4-6 years and timely sales verification, and noted that digital tools like aerial imagery can reduce costs. Key Outcomes - No formal votes were taken. The hearing was informational. - Councilmembers indicated they would consider the testimony and presentations in future deliberations. President Katina noted that the next public hearing will start with public comments. - The proposed ordinance (Hallam’s bill) remains under consideration. Councilmember Filiaggi, chair of the special committee on assessment practices, indicated that technological updates and a repository for data are already being worked on. - The overall sentiment among presenters and many public speakers was in favor of regular, predictable reassessments to improve equity and transparency, with concerns about cost, public education, and protection for fixed-income homeowners.

The Allegheny County Council convened on May 21, 2024, at 10:15 AM with 13 members present. The meeting featured multiple proclamations, public comments on property tax reassessment, approval of committee appointments, a new motion related to litigation, and public testimony on coroner procedures and mental health policy. Proclamations & Recognitions - Older Americans Month (May 2024): Councilmember DeMarco sponsored a proclamation recognizing the District Attorney's Office for its work with seniors. Julie Capone, senior prosecutor in the elder abuse unit, accepted on behalf of DA Stephen Zappala, highlighting Project Lifesaver, the fraud squad (preventing over $35 million in losses since 2015), and the senior justice advocate program. - Matthew Brown, CEM: Councilmember Nakarati Chapkiss presented a proclamation congratulating Matthew Brown for maintaining his Certified Emergency Manager designation, held by only 2,363 professionals worldwide. Brown thanked council and highlighted the work of Allegheny County Emergency Services. - Alekia Borgata – 2024 Coca-Cola Scholar: Council President Katina recognized Alekia Borgata, a South Fayette High School senior, as one of 150 scholars selected from over 103,000 applicants, receiving a $20,000 scholarship. Borgata spoke about her nonprofit "Women Welfare" and plans to study pre-med. - Teen Mental Health Awareness Day (May 23, 2024): Councilmember Hallam sponsored a proclamation declaring May 23, 2024 as Teen Mental Health Awareness Day. Statistics cited: 31.71% of Allegheny County students reported poor mental health in the past month; 56% of LGBTQIA+ youth who wanted mental health care could not get it. Three youth advocates spoke: Layla King (sophomore at Pittsburgh Kappa), Dorini Marutu (junior at South Fayette, PA Youth Advocacy), and Janaya Coleman (senior at PA Reach Cyber Charter School), emphasizing the need for supportive environments and destigmatization. - Linden Garden Club 100th Anniversary: Councilmember Klein presented a proclamation honoring the club, founded in 1924. A representative thanked council and noted the club's support for various organizations including Tree Pittsburgh, Phipps, and the Parks Conservancy. - Additional proclamations read into the record (without ceremony): 32nd Phalandaffa celebration, recognition of first responders from Plum Borough for Rustic Ridge tragedy, Paul H. Wayne for 40 years with Boy Scouts, and Bishop Marvin C. Moreland Day. Public Comments on Agenda Items - Resident of Brookline (ISUNY): Expressed support for property tax reassessment, stating she prefers to pay library, property, and school taxes. She advocated for incremental increases over a multi-year period rather than sudden jumps, and asked for tax funds to be used for parks and pools. - Corey Dickey (read by councilmember): In a written statement, urged council to implement regular, frequent, fair property reassessments, arguing that infrequent reassessments disproportionately harm disenfranchised residents and exacerbate racial inequality in Pittsburgh. Approval of Minutes - Motion to approve minutes of April 24, 2024 regular meeting. Passed without objection. Committee on Appointment Review – Second Reading - Councilmember Nakarati Chapkiss moved to approve 12 appointments to the MWDVE Advisory Committee (terms expiring December 31, 2028). All appointments were approved unanimously. Liaison Reports - Councilmember Palmer reported attending CCAC's commencement ceremony on May 15, 2024, where approximately 2,200 students graduated. He praised the college and urged council to refer students to CCAC. New Business – Ordinances & Resolutions - 13056-24: Ordinance to amend Administrative Code Section 5-210.09 regarding property assessment appeal filings (sponsored by DeMarco, Macy, Katina, Philiaggi). Referred to Committee on Assessment Practices. - 13057-24: Resolution to amend the grants and special accounts budget for 2024 (submission 03-24). Referred to Committee on Budget and Finance. Motion for Litigation Expenses - 13058-24: Motion authorizing payment of invoices for extraordinary professional services related to litigation involving Allegheny County Council (the Schumann lawsuit). After a brief executive session, council voted: 11 yes, 1 no (Councilmember Walton), 3 absent. Motion carried. Public Comments on General Items - Stephanie Waters: Representing her deceased brother Kevin Kavlovich, she requested a meeting with council to address concerns with the county coroner's office. She proposed three action points: improved family communication (contact within 48 hours, updates at primary and final autopsy), protocol changes (histology at time of autopsy, right to request grand rounds and access minutes), and creation of an oversight committee. She noted her brother's case involved viral meningitis and that his fluids/tissues were sent to the CDC. - Ruth Johnston (possibly last speaker): Invited council to a one-day workshop on July 30, 2024 in Butler, PA, about assisted outpatient treatment (AOT) for severe mental illness. She explained that a 2018 state law allows counties to opt into AOT, which permits involuntary commitment to a medical team without requiring a "clear and present danger" standard. She shared a personal family story and urged council to consider the program.

The Allegheny County Council meeting on May 7, 2024, was called to order at 10:00 AM by President Katina. Thirteen members were initially present, later increasing to fifteen. The meeting featured multiple proclamations, extensive public testimony, and several legislative actions. Proclamations and Certificates - National Nurses Week (13036-24): The council proclaimed May 6–12, 2024 as National Nurses Week. Dennis Bielonda, executive director of Kane Living Centers, introduced nursing staff who reported that in 2023, 11 LPNs graduated (seven from the centers' own aides), and 100 nurse aides were trained through a partnership with CCAC. In 2024, 18 new students are in the LPN program. Holly Marin, deputy warden of health services at the county jail, also spoke. Dr. Bullock from CCAC noted a 94% pass rate (120 of 126) on the recent RN exam. Lauren Brungo, chief nursing officer of the Allegheny County Health Department, and a representative from DHS also expressed gratitude. - Pittsburgh Today Live 20th Anniversary (13037-24): Councilmember Macy presented a proclamation honoring KDKA's "Pittsburgh Today Live" for its 20th anniversary. Hosts Heather Abraham and David Highfill accepted, noting the show's role in providing community connection during the pandemic. - Other proclamations read into the record: 13038-24 (WIC Program 50th anniversary), 13039-24 (Eagle Scout Jacob Townsend Lowe), and 13040-24 (Magisterial District Judge Xander Orenstein). Public Comments & Testimony On Agenda Items: - Brian Knuckles: Scheduled to speak, but no testimony recorded in the transcript. On General Items: - Michael Barone: Former Allegheny County jail correctional officer, speaking on behalf of 11 officers terminated in December 2021 for refusing the COVID-19 vaccine mandate. He argued the mandate violated the Nuremberg Code and HIPAA, criticized the county for not making them whole, and demanded accountability. - Sabrina Maines: A mother sharing her daughter's recovery from schizophrenia, contrasted the support her child received with the lack of care for children in Gaza. Urged council to call for a ceasefire. - Zia Manes: Brief statement: "Cease fire, divest from Israel, and free Palestine." - Elizabeth Arafat: Read a letter from her sister-in-law in Rafah, describing the terror of raising a newborn during war. Urged council to remember Palestinian mothers when voting against ceasefire. - Aaron Broad: A history teacher and mother, quoting Julia Ward Howe's 1870 Mother's Day Proclamation. Called on council to foster peace in Gaza. - Joanna Collins: A mother of five, shared the story of Nabila, a Gazan mother whose three children were killed. Criticized U.S. funding of weapons and urged support for a ceasefire resolution. - Tanisha Law: Expressed solidarity with Palestinians but primarily criticized Councilmember Filiaggi for remarks at a prior meeting comparing Manny (a formerly incarcerated community activist) to Bob Macy, calling the comments offensive and undermining rehabilitative justice. Demanded an apology. - Carly Barube: A mother and midwife, described conditions for 50,000 pregnant women in Gaza. Then criticized Councilmember Filiaggi for comparing her criminal record (a summary offense akin to a traffic violation) to Macy's racist remarks. Reported that since the prior meeting, her group served 256 unhoused and returning neighbors. - Fawn Walker Montgomery: Listed but did not speak. Discussion Items - Odor Investigation Update: President Katina reported that the county, with the Pennsylvania Public Utilities Commission, has ruled out certain sources for the mysterious odor in the Mon Valley and South Hills. Encouraged residents to call 911 if they smell it. - New Business Motion (13043-24): Councilmember Macy introduced a motion urging the Pennsylvania General Assembly to pass HB 1825 and SB 25, which would expand nurse practitioner practice. He cited healthcare access shortages. The motion was referred to the Health and Human Services Committee for further vetting. - Ordinance (13042-24): Ratification of revisions to the Allegheny County Health Department's housing and community development rules (Article 6). Referred to Health and Human Services. - Notification of Contracts (13044-24): April 2024 summary of approved executive actions. Motion to receive and file was approved. Key Outcomes - Approval of Minutes (13041-24): Minutes of the April 9, 2024 regular meeting were approved by voice vote. - Appointments Referred: Seven appointments (13029-24 through 13035-24) were presented and referred to the Committee on Appointment Review. - Motion Referred: Motion 13043-24 was sent to the Health and Human Services Committee. - Ordinance Referred: Ordinance 13042-24 was sent to the Health and Human Services Committee. - Contract Notification Received: Communication 13044-24 was received and filed. - Adjournment and Executive Session: The meeting adjourned following public comments, and council moved to an executive session to discuss professional services.

The Allegheny County Council convened on April 24, 2024, with all 15 members present and Council President Katina presiding. The meeting opened with an apology from Councilmember Macy for a March 5, 2024 statement that he said harmed some people. The agenda included seven proclamations, extensive public comment, a series of county board and authority appointments, two second-reading votes, and new business on property reassessment. Proclamations & Recognitions - National Therapy Animal Day (April 30, 2024) — Proclamation sponsored by Councilmember Katina and all members. Ms. Hanson, a licensed counselor and small-business owner serving older adults, people with disabilities, and children with special needs, spoke about her plans to train a therapy dog for her clients. - 2024 Pennsylvania Big Brother of the Year — Jared Latchaw — Sponsored by Councilmembers DeMarco and Bonarotti. Latchaw and his 'little brother' Jamari, matched for six years through Big Brothers Big Sisters of Pennsylvania, both spoke about the impact of the mentorship. - 2024 Pennsylvania Big Sister of the Year — Lindsay Literini — Sponsored by Councilmembers DeMarco and Fatulis. Literini, a former Big Brothers Big Sisters staff member, and her 'little sister' Sarah, matched for eight years, spoke; Sarah credited Literini with helping her get to college. Council also remembered the late former Councilman Tom Baker, a longtime BBBS mentor. - Women's Law Project — 50th Anniversary — Sponsored by Councilmember Katina and all councilmembers. A representative noted the organization's founding in 1974 and its 2024 court victory overturning a 1985 Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision that had upheld a Medicaid ban on abortion, reinvigorating the state Equal Rights Amendment. - Boom Concepts — 10th Anniversary — Sponsored by Councilmember Hallam and all councilmembers. The Garfield-based creative hub for Black, brown, queer, and femme artists has curated more than 50 exhibitions, paid out over $216,000 in artist fees, and produced over 200 events. Founders DS Kinsel and J. Thomas Agnew thanked the Council. - Additional proclamations — Declared April 28, 2024 as Workers' Memorial Day; April 2024 as Arab American Heritage Month; and April 2024 as Autism Acceptance Month. Public Comments on Appointments & Reassessment - Opposition to Councilmember Robert Macy's SPC reappointment — Multiple speakers opposed Macy's appointment to the Southwestern Pennsylvania Commission (SPC). Ms. Azuni, a Muslim resident, said she had faced a defamation campaign since Macy's March 5 'Islamophobic comments' and reported threatening letters received by area mosques. Ali Assad of the South Hills criticized the Council's failure to pass a ceasefire resolution, spoke of his Palestinian grandmother's legacy, and warned, 'We're either gonna move you with our talk or we'll remove you.' Another speaker cited a petition with over 200 signatures; Corey Roma of Crafton Borough presented a petition signed by over 240 constituents and organizations including Casa San Jose and Sunrise Movement Pittsburgh (speakers cited both 200 and 240 figures). Brian Knuckles of Wilkinsburg argued for a 'progressive vision' for transportation, called the Council's response to public participation disappointing, and said 'decorum' had been treated as more important than democracy. Other speakers cited Macy's record, including a 2012 DUI, transphobic remarks, and a comment about whether unhoused people were 'grateful enough' to deserve shelter; several called his apology 'too little, too late.' - Reassessment advocacy — A speaker from Scott Township (listed as Mike Stall) spoke in favor of the chief assessor legislation, calling reassessment 'ugly' and 'like a military operation,' and urged Council to vote yes so the next chief assessor has professional credentials and countywide reassessment experience. - Friends of South Park — Carolyn Savagas, a retired financial advisor and South Park volunteer, opposed the reappointment of Sharon Adams to the Friends of South Park, describing conflicts with county park staff and fellow volunteers, and urged Council to consider two new nominees instead. Consent Calendar & Minutes - Minutes of the March 19, 2024 regular Council meeting were approved by voice vote. Appointments & Key Votes - Sharon Adams, Friends of the Park for South Park — Councilmember Griffin said he would vote no, citing reports that Adams directed county employees and had terse relationships with board members. Roll call: Ayes 2 (Fatulis, Palmery), Noes 13. Motion failed. - Daniel Connolly, Airport Authority — Approved by voice vote. - Darren Kelly, Allegheny County Sanitary Authority (reappointment) — Approved by voice vote. - Paul Klein, Allegheny County Sanitary Authority (reappointment) — Councilmember Kowski urged rejection, saying suburban ratepayers were left without a voice on the board. Roll call: Ayes 13, Noes 1 (Betkowski), Abstention 1 (Klein). Motion passed. - Diamante Walker, Redevelopment Authority — Approved by voice vote. - Dusty Elias Kirk and Monica Malik, Regional Asset District Board — Approved by voice votes. - Jesse Durennet, Southwestern Pennsylvania Commission — Approved by voice vote. - Robert Macy, Southwestern Pennsylvania Commission (reappointment) — The Committee on Appointment Review negatively recommended Macy. In debate, Councilmembers Fatulis and DeMarco argued for forgiveness, second chances, and Macy's record; DeMarco noted the crowd outburst that interrupted Macy's March 5 remarks. Councilmember Philiagi called County Executive Sarah Innamorato the 'fresh face' behind the nomination and urged tolerance and mercy. Councilmembers Grisbeck, Hallum, and Klein opposed, with Hallum citing a pattern of transphobic, homophobic, and misogynistic remarks, and Klein calling the apology 'transactional in nature.' A point of order clarified that voting for oneself is not illegal but may violate the County Ethics Code; Macy changed his vote to an abstention, and Walton also abstained. Roll call: Ayes 5 (Bonarotti, DeMarco, Filiagi, Fatulis, Palmery), Noes 8 (Betkowski, Grisbeck, Hallum, Klein, Nakaretti Chapkas, Palmasina, Pritzio, Katina), Abstentions 2 (Macy, Walton). Motion failed. - Jamila DuCard, Regional Asset District; Dora Walmsley, Redevelopment Authority; Diamante Walker and Kyle Chittilopoli, multiple development authorities; Michael A. Gable, Professional Services Review Committee — All approved by voice votes. - Jennifer M. Liptak, Retirement Board (reappointment) — Roll call: Ayes 13, Noes 2 (Hallum, Katina). Motion passed. Discussion Items & Second Readings - Bill 12915-24 (Chief Assessment Officer continuity) — Amends Administrative Code Article 209 to establish a mechanism for continuity in the Chief Assessment Officer position. The Committee on Assessment Practices met April 18, 2024, and moved the bill with a neutral recommendation; Councilmember Filiagi noted no amendments were introduced. Roll call: Ayes 14, Noes 1 (Walton). Bill passed. - Resolution 12999-24 (Grants and special accounts budget amendment, Submission 02-24) — The Budget and Finance Committee met April 18, 2024, and affirmatively recommended the resolution. Roll call: 15-0. Passed. Liaison Reports - Councilmember DeMarco reported on the April 23, 2024 primary election: turnout was 32% among Democrats and just under 27% among Republicans; all mail-in and absentee ballots submitted before election day were processed; 6,870 poll workers served. Councilmember Fatulis described mail-in ballots arriving late for his family; DeMarco noted state law deadlines (registration 14 days prior, mail ballot requests 7 days prior). Councilmember Walton raised concerns that in 2020 no mail-in ballot drop-off sites were located in African American communities; DeMarco reported six drop-off sites operated over two weekends (four days total) with fewer than 2,800 ballots returned, versus about 28,000 in 2020, noting the pandemic context. New Business - Ordinance 13027-24 (periodic countywide reassessments) — Sponsored by Councilmember Hallam; referred to the Committee on Assessment Practices. - Motion 13028-24 (public hearing on property reassessment) — Sponsored by Councilmember Katina, authorizing a public hearing on Wednesday, May 22, 2024, at 5:00 p.m. in the Gold Room of the Allegheny County Courthouse, to gather expert testimony on a possible court-ordered countywide reassessment. Roll call: 15-0. Motion passed. Key Outcomes - Councilmember Robert Macy's reappointment to the SPC was rejected (5-8-2); his earlier apology did not change the outcome. - Sharon Adams's appointment to Friends of South Park was rejected (2-13). - All other presented appointments were approved, including Paul Klein (13-1-1) and Jennifer Liptak (13-2). - Bill 12915-24 and Resolution 12999-24 passed on second reading. - A public hearing on a possible countywide reassessment was scheduled for May 22, 2024, at 5:00 p.m.