Public Meetings - Allegheny County, Pennsylvania

The Allegheny County Council convened on October 24, 2023, at 10:15 AM for a regular meeting. The session began with several ceremonial proclamations, followed by routine approvals, introduction of new ordinances, and public comments on varied topics. Council members also unanimously passed a resolution condemning the October 7 Hamas attack on Israel after hearing statements from two members. Proclamations - Officer Mark Prunitsky (Allegheny County Police) was recognized for heroic actions on October 9, 2023, at Pittsburgh International Airport, where he used an AED and CPR to resuscitate a 43-year-old man who had suffered a medical emergency. Officer Prunitsky expressed gratitude for his training and commitment to serving Allegheny County. - Donald Alexander (Carnegie Elementary teacher) received recognition for earning the 2023 AFT Pennsylvania Community Outreach Award. He helped create a free store and chillroom at Carnegie Elementary to provide clothing, food, and necessities to students, inspired by Giselle Fetterman's free store in Braddock. - WTAE-TV Channel 4 was honored for its 65th anniversary of broadcasting (since September 1958). The station was praised for community programs such as Project Bundle Up, Project Hunger, and Race for the Cure. - 2023 Real Men Wear Pink of Pittsburgh candidates were congratulated for raising $83,383 for breast cancer research through the American Cancer Society campaign. Councilmember DeMarco noted he had personally known two women who died from breast cancer. - Plum EMS received a proclamation for being awarded the 2023 National EMS Award of Excellence by the National Association of EMTs and American College of Emergency Physicians. Key statistics: Plum EMS reduced lights-and-siren use on 911 calls from 48% to less than 7% and during patient transport from 26% to 3%, without negative clinical outcomes. The agency also conducted COVID-19 vaccinations and provided free cribs through Cribs for Kids. - Andre Acey (Plum EMS) was recognized for earning the Pennsylvania EMS Provider Foundation Star of Life Award, noted for 24 years of service, including prior Marine Corps service and leading the child passenger safety program. Consent Calendar - Bill 12821-23 (Resolution amending the 2023 grants budget) was approved unanimously (14-0) upon recommendation from the Budget and Finance Committee. - Bill 12820-23 (Ordinance accepting donated walkthrough metal detectors from PSSI Stadium LLC for use in magisterial district courts) was approved unanimously (14-0) upon recommendation from the Public Works Committee. Reports & Announcements - Board of Elections Update (President Katina): Preparations for the November 7 general election are proceeding well, with strong poll worker recruitment and a good return rate for mail-in ballots. Voters with questions about missing ballots were urged to contact the Elections Division. Discussion Items - Resolution 12839-23 (Condemning Hamas attack): Councilmember DeMarco introduced a resolution condemning the October 7, 2023, unprovoked terrorist attack by Hamas against Israel, supporting justice and safety for both Israeli and Palestinian people, and offering condolences. The resolution mirrored language passed unanimously by the Pennsylvania General Assembly. After a motion to waive second reading passed, the resolution was debated. Councilmember Bennett thanked DeMarco for specifying Hamas (not all Palestine). Councilmember Klein delivered an extended statement drawing parallels to the Tree of Life synagogue massacre (fifth anniversary on October 27), quoting Primo Levi and urging a commitment to social justice and peace, saying "Let's stop the madness… and instead wage peace." The resolution then passed unanimously on a voice vote. Key Outcomes - Two routine bills passed unanimously (14-0): the grants budget amendment and the metal detector donation ordinance. - Condemnation resolution (12839-23) passed unanimously on a voice vote; all council members present were added as co-sponsors. - New ordinances introduced and referred to committees: - 12838-23: Amends County Code to prohibit distribution of certain single-use plastic bags (referred to Sustainability and Green Initiatives). - 12840-23: Resolution authorizing up to $35 million in revenue bonds for Duquesne University (referred to Economic Development and Housing). Public Comments - Jennifer Pusiteri: Complained that during a recent appeal hearing, the board chair repeatedly interrupted her and did not allow her to finish her statement, while two attorneys for absent property owners were not interrupted. She cited the Pennsylvania Sunshine Act and urged council to ensure all speakers receive fair and respectful treatment. - Juliette Savant: Urged passage of Ordinance 12534-22 to establish a bipartisan commission for county council redistricting, arguing the current process lacks transparency and is not rule of law. She asked council to show commitment to good governance. - Darcy Zotter: A former U.S. diplomat, she echoed Savant's call for a fair, transparent, and accountable redistricting process, stating it is unacceptable for Allegheny County in 2023 to lack such a system. - Jacob Poole: Delivered a lengthy personal account alleging he was a victim of child trafficking from Eastern Europe and that Pittsburgh lacks anti-slavery laws. He stated he is isolated and has been unable to get help from authorities. - Jeff Cohen: Opposed the proposed single-use plastics ban, asking council to wait 12 months to see how the City of Pittsburgh's ban works before extending it countywide. He argued it would burden small businesses with higher costs for replacement bags and contribute to inflation.

This was the second night of the Allegheny County Council's public hearings on the proposed 2024 budget, required by the Administrative Code and Home Rule Charter. The council heard from the Treasurer’s Office, Sheriff’s Office, District Attorney’s Office, Controller’s Office, the Fifth Judicial District (President Judge), and Pittsburgh Regional Transit, following public testimony. Public Comments & Testimony - Lisa Pennington, a family law attorney of 25 years, testified that the family division is failing constituents due to underfunding. She reported: support hearings take four months for 3,000 new filings per year; divorces require 30–45 days because only one employee grants them; custody hearings face six-month waits; and the PFA court has five staff handling 5,200 filings with a vacant attorney supervisor position. She also stated she was contacted by court administration and told to "stand down" after mentioning her intention to testify. Discussion Items - Treasurer John Weinstein presented his last budget (retiring after 32 years, along with his top deputies). The Treasurer’s Office requested $9.2 million (8.6% increase) and $1.689 million in capital for IT upgrades. Real estate tax collection remains at 99%. Investment earnings are up 82% from 2022. He expressed a goal to unify tax collection with the City of Pittsburgh and school districts. - Sheriff’s Office: Sheriff Krause and Deputy Chief Kearney presented. The office has 206 employees and requested eight new positions (sergeant, six deputies for the Community Intensive Supervision Program, and one special counsel). Accomplishments included transporting 15,000 incarcerated individuals, serving over 20,000 legal papers, clearing 3,500 warrants, and conducting 100+ Megan’s Law checks. Body cameras were implemented for accountability. A facility dog joined the canine unit. Project Dump for safe medication disposal served 5,000 people at 10 events this year. - District Attorney’s Office: Rebecca Spangler presented a brief written submission. They requested five attorney IIIs, six attorney IVs, six staff, and two paralegals (19 new positions). They acquired a digital evidence software and a new case management system using grant funding (total $700,000). Spangler noted difficulty filling existing positions. - Controller’s Office: Corey O’Connor presented. Budget request $8.6 million. New positions include a construction manager, asset manager, and process improvement specialist. The office processed over 136,000 payments and $330 million in wages. Hotel audits recovered $432,824 owed to the county. They are exploring paying poll workers and jurors via debit cards. - Fifth Judicial District (President Judge Clark): He reported that the family division is struggling to fill existing positions, not from lack of budget. He detailed the juvenile detention crisis: 152 juveniles on electronic monitoring (78.3% with violent felony/firearms charges), 392 bracelet-tampering incidents since 2022, 102 outstanding juvenile warrants (72.5% violent), and 23 juveniles charged as adults for new crimes including seven homicides. Since the Shuman Center closed, over 300 juveniles who met detention criteria were released home, resulting in at least five deaths (four shot, one overdose). He urged council to address the lack of detention capacity. - Pittsburgh Regional Transit (CEO Katharine Eagan Kelleman): Operating budget $535 million, with a 4% increase request from the county. Ridership is at 62–64% of pre-COVID weekdays (weekends at 82%). Fares have not increased since 2010–11. The agency faces manpower issues (96% of transit agencies have hiring problems); they are working on a Bus Line Redesign. They have implemented affordable fare programs and a zero-emission fleet transition. COVID-19 claimed seven employees; a vaccine mandate was implemented and later lifted. Key Outcomes - The hearing was informational; no votes were taken. Council members asked questions and received commitments for follow-up data: a breakdown of DA’s prosecutions, sliding scale for electronic monitoring fees, updates on the Carnegie station project, and analysis of the 15 Charles Street route in Northview Heights. - President Judge Clark will retire on December 23, 2023. - The budget process continues with council deliberation.

On October 17, 2023, the Allegheny County Council held the first of two required public hearings on the 2024 budget. The hearing featured presentations from the Community College of Allegheny County (CCAC) and the county administration. No tax increase was proposed for 2024. Community College of Allegheny County (CCAC) Presentation - Dr. Bullock, CCAC President, and Jim Flynn, Vice President, presented the college's budget and impact. CCAC contributes approximately $1.3 billion annually to the regional economy. For every dollar spent on a student, the return is $2.50; students earning an associate degree gain an additional $11,000 per year. - 68% of CCAC students are part-time; 37% are ethnic minorities; 85% of graduates live and work in the region. - CCAC's 2023-24 operating budget is $107.25 million, with a capital budget of $32.3 million. The county's current appropriation is $31.1 million (including $800,000 for the workforce training center), representing 28.5% of CCAC's total revenues. - CCAC's fully loaded tuition and fees are $163.50 per credit—the lowest among Pennsylvania's 15 community colleges (average $207). The in-county rate for 15 credits is $1,890 per semester. - The college requests a $4.6 million increase (14.4%) from the county for 2024, which would raise the county's share to 33.3%. The funds would support reading and writing centers at each campus, nursing lab upgrades, aviation program scholarships, early registration incentives, and other student services. - New student enrollment increased 11.4% for fall 2023. The college is preparing for the "enrollment cliff" by expanding partnerships, improving retention, and offering evening/weekend programs. County Administration Presentation - County Manager Jennifer LipTac presented the 2024 comprehensive fiscal plan. The operating budget is $1.054 billion, with no tax increase recommended—the 12th consecutive year without a property tax increase. - The county's unassigned fund balance is $56.1 million (7% of operations), up from $5.7 million in 2012. The county's bond ratings are the highest in 40 years (Moody's Aa3, S&P AA-). - Key revenue sources: property taxes (largest), state aid (18.67%), and department earnings. The county saved $279 million by moving to self-insured health plans; employee premiums are 3.25% of base salary. - ARPA funds have been used strategically: $20 million for the Allegheny County Childcare Matters pilot program (supporting families between 200-300% of federal poverty guidelines), $35 million for the health lab, and $11 million for 911 radio upgrades. A major communications system upgrade (analog to digital) is ongoing. - The capital budget is $116 million, with $69.9 million in new bonds anticipated for 2024. Debt service is being managed to avoid spikes. Council Discussion and Questions - Council members praised the presentations and highlighted the county's fiscal discipline, including the use of Marcellus Shale royalties (over $20 million for parks) and the new airport terminal project. - Councilwoman Hallam asked about the $4.6 million CCAC request and student bus pass program. CCAC currently purchased 100 passes for a pilot; full unlimited access would require a new student fee. - Councilman Paul Mary asked about the $50 early registration credit and the top two new requests from CCAC; Mr. Flynn cited reading/writing centers and aviation program support. - Councilman Palmasina questioned CCAC about the "enrollment cliff" and transfer rates to four-year institutions. - Councilman Klein thanked the administration for supporting the Local Government Academy. - Councilman Sam requested a long-term analysis of one-time funds (ARPA, refinancing savings) that will not be available after 2024. Key Outcomes - No votes were taken; this was a public hearing to gather information for the 2024 budget process. - The county administration confirmed no tax increase for 2024. - CCAC's request for a $4.6 million increase will be considered by council during budget deliberations. - The county's ARPA funds must be committed by the end of 2024; about 50% has been spent to date. - The next public hearing is expected to cover other county agencies and departments.

The Allegheny County Council convened on October 10, 2023, with 12 members present at roll call. The meeting featured a presentation of the 2024 comprehensive fiscal plan by County Executive Fitzgerald, who highlighted a proposed budget with no millage increase, a growing fund balance, and investments in infrastructure, parks, and air quality. Council approved several legislative items and heard public testimony on redistricting reform, CCAC funding, and a complaint against a council member. Public Comments & Testimony - Juliet Zavon and Deborah Fayok urged the council to pass redistricting reform ordinance 12534-22, which has been stalled in committee for two years. They argued that allowing council members to draw their own districts creates a conflict of interest and undermines good governance. - Donald Breitbarth (speaking for a CCAC colleague) described the welding and HVAC programs at CCAC's West Hill Center, noting over 90% job placement rates. He requested increased county funding to offset student lab fees and keep equipment up to date. - Ann George (CCAC North Campus Nursing Lab coordinator) stated that the nursing lab space has not been updated since 1999. She asked for substantial investment to add simulation mannequins and technology to train 21st-century registered nurses. - Arden Zynga (CCAC culinary instructor and 1977 graduate) thanked the council for past support and highlighted the new Center for Education, Innovation, and Training. He urged continued funding for culinary and workforce programs. - Joseph Klepik criticized Councilwoman Hallam for what he characterized as disrespectful comments toward Judge Housey and former warden Orlando Harper, and requested the council explore censure or removal. Discussion Items - 2024 Comprehensive Fiscal Plan Presentation: County Executive Fitzgerald presented his 12th and final budget, emphasizing no tax increase and a low property tax rate ($388/year for the average home, unchanged since 2012). He reported a fund balance growth from $5.9 million to over $53 million, a bond rating upgrade, a historically low 3% unemployment rate, and an 80% reduction in hazardous air pollutants. He also noted achievements in bridge repairs (from 72 poor-rated bridges to 5), park investments (23 million annual visits), and air service growth (from 36 to 61 destinations). The budget includes continued support for CCAC ($126/credit, lowest in the state) and the airport's terminal modernization program. - Q&A on the Budget: Councilwoman Hallam questioned why jail fatalities remain high despite $100 million annual spending. The County Executive disputed the characterization, noting one fatality in the jail since September and no suicides in three years. Another council member asked about federal infrastructure and Inflation Reduction Act funding; the Executive stated that the budget includes already-appropriated money and that future funds will require pursuing grants. - Appointment Approval (12805-23): The council voted 14–1 to confirm Lasans Heard Montgomery to the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review. - Park Restoration Ordinance (12775-23): The council voted 15–0 to authorize Land Reclamation Group LLC to enter county property for a stream restoration project at Pearson Run in Boyce Park. - New Business Referrals: Several ordinances and resolutions were introduced and referred to committees, including a bill to ensure continuity in the Chief Assessment Officer position, acceptance of metal detectors for the court system, a grant budget amendment, and a motion to publish RFPs for IT solutions. Key Outcomes - Motion to amend the agenda to include all budget bills passed 14–1 (one no vote, Councilwoman Hallam). - Appointment of Lasans Heard Montgomery passed 14–1. - Ordinance 12775-23 (Boyce Park restoration) passed 15–0. - Proclamations recognizing SHACOG's 50th anniversary and the Pittsburgh-Matanza Sister Cities Partnership's 30th anniversary were read into the record. - Notification of executive actions for September 2023 was filed unanimously. - The meeting adjourned after public comments; no further business was scheduled.

The Allegheny County Council held its regular meeting on September 26, 2023, with 15 members present. The meeting opened with a tribute to labor leader Tom Conway, followed by several proclamations, public testimony on a contentious proposal to use the former Schumann Center for juvenile detention, and a series of unanimous approvals. A major debate centered on a motion to authorize a lawsuit against the county executive and courts over the use of county property for the Schumann Center, which passed after a procedural dispute. The council also heard public comments on veteran housing, benzene monitoring at the Clairton Coke Works, and funding for the Community College of Allegheny County. Consent Calendar - Approval of minutes from the July 5, 2023 regular meeting (unanimous). - Proclamations: Recognizing William T. Hillgrove (50+ years in sports broadcasting), Wilkinsburg Athletic Association youth football and cheerleading (proclaiming September 14, 2023 as Wilkinsburg Athletic Association Day), Dr. Leon Haley (50+ years of service), and Cameron Aziz (Boy Scouts lifesaving award). - Second‑reading ordinances and resolutions passed unanimously (15‑0): - 12791‑23: Amendment to grants and special accounts budget for 2023. - 12793‑23: Ratification of year‑end transfers. - 12792‑23: Local Economic Revitalization Tax Assistance (LERTA) program for deteriorated areas in Pittsburgh. - 12789‑23: Acceptance of donated fire hose from Seville Volunteer Fire Company. - 12790‑23: Acceptance of donated fall‑protection harnesses and lanyards from U.S. Steel Corporation. - 12784‑23: Condemnation of temporary construction easement for Bailey’s Run Walk Reconstruction Project. - 12785‑23: Condemnation of permanent right‑of‑way and temporary easement for Douglas Run Bridge replacement. - Appointment of Michelle Payanzo to the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review (15‑0). - Motion 12814‑23: Authorization of three‑year contract with Henderson Brothers Inc. for insurance placement (passed 13‑0 with two abstentions). Public Comments & Testimony Comments on Agenda Items (Schumann Center) - President Judge Kim Berkeley Clark (Fifth Judicial District) opposed the motion regarding the Schumann Center, arguing that the county lacks detention beds for youth charged with serious violent or gun offenses, leading to tragic outcomes. She stated that Adelphi (the proposed private provider) operates on a program‑funded basis (payment determined by license capacity, not number of children detained), eliminating financial incentive to detain, and that Allegheny County judges are not corrupt. She cited two incidents: a youth released due to no bed later charged as an adult for a shooting, and a youth who died after removing his electronic monitor. - Brad Kerensky (private citizen, former chief legal counsel for the county executive) argued that the county charter requires council approval for any use of county property, and that circumventing council sets a bad precedent for future administrations. - Sam Schmidt implored council to vote against privatization, citing Adelphi’s history of physical and sexual abuse and existing class‑action lawsuits, stating that detention does not reform children. - Tanisha Long argued that judges are corrupt and the system disproportionately incarcerates Black boys (90–100% in the county jail). She urged council to follow the charter and not sell children to a company with a history of abuse. - Carl Redwood (Hill District) stated that privatization of the Schumann Center will not make communities safer and that youth are already being held in county jail. General Public Comments - Kent Bay (Project Love Coalition) requested support for providing housing to veterans in crisis, and highlighted a fatal incident involving a veteran named William Hardison who was killed during an eviction by multiple law enforcement officers. - Lisa Graves Marcucci presented monitoring data on benzene emissions from the Clairton Coke Works, noting that U.S. Steel’s fence‑line monitoring over six months showed an average benzene concentration of 33.3 micrograms per cubic meter – ten times the proposed federal action level and California’s long‑term health threshold (3 µg/m³). She stated that 97% of Allegheny County’s benzene emissions come from that facility, and urged support for EPA’s proposed fence‑line monitoring rule. - Scott Cornish, Sujana Kanjila, and Cheryl Friedman (faculty members of the Community College of Allegheny County) appealed for increased county funding, citing needs for facility upgrades (e.g., ventilation at South Campus, disintegrating studio at North Campus), adequate space for the honors program, and support for the aviation program to address the national pilot shortage. Discussion Items - Appointment of Timothy Maury to the Accountability, Conduct and Ethics (ACE) Commission (12756‑23): The Committee on Appointment Review returned the appointment without recommendation. Council debated allegations of a previous conflict of interest in his prior service on the commission. After a roll‑call vote was interrupted by a procedural dispute (Councilman Walton refused to vote without explanation, leading to a brief recess and ruling that he was out of order), the appointment failed 4 ayes, 10 nays, with one member not casting a vote. - Motion 12813‑23 (Suit against County Executive and Courts): Councilmember Hallam introduced a motion to direct the council solicitor to file a declaratory‑judgment lawsuit over the use of the former Schumann Center site. She argued that the county executive and the courts conspired to supersede council’s charter authority over county property. Councilmember DeMarco questioned whether inter‑governmental uses require council approval, noting that other government entities (e.g., elections office) use county property without council votes. After a motion to end debate passed 9–6, the main motion passed 9 ayes, 4 nays, with two abstentions. Several members expressed concerns about premature action and insufficient due diligence. Key Outcomes - Motion to sue (12813‑23) passed (9 ayes, 4 nays, 2 abstentions). Council will seek a declaratory judgment regarding conditional use of county‑owned property at the former Schumann Center. - Timothy Maury appointment to ACE Commission rejected (4 ayes, 10 nays, 1 not voting). - All other appointments (Sully, French, Kramer, Douglas, Payanzo) were approved, with Sully passing 12‑3, and French, Kramer, Douglas passing with one dissenting vote each. - All second‑reading ordinances and resolutions passed unanimously (15‑0). - Public comments on veteran housing, benzene monitoring, and CCAC funding were heard and noted; no immediate council action was taken.

The Committee on Health and Human Services held a public hearing to explore the crisis of medical debt and the need for universal, single-payer healthcare. Three expert presenters provided extensive data and personal narratives, followed by testimony from numerous residents and healthcare professionals. Council members expressed strong support and pledged to pursue further action, including exploring a county referendum and researching local medical debt impacts. Public Comments & Testimony - Dr. Judy Albert (co-founder, Western PA Coalition for Single Payer Health Care) detailed the scale of medical debt: 100 million Americans affected, premiums up 200% since 1999 while wages rose only 47%, and cancer patients 2.5 times more likely to declare bankruptcy. She argued that private insurance profits ($200 billion in overhead) should instead fund a public system like Medicare, which has only 2-3% overhead. - Ed Gristar (former union rep, PA Staff Nurses) emphasized the need for a county referendum to pressure Congress, citing successful referendums in Wisconsin and Illinois that passed with large majorities. He urged the council to reduce obstacles for non-binding referendums and to research medical debt demographics in Allegheny County. - Dr. Claire Cohen (child psychiatrist) shared personal and clinical experiences: she negotiated a $4,000 hospital bill down to $1,000 for her daughter; reported that U.S. infant mortality for Black women is 69.9 per 100,000 (ranking 85th globally); and noted that for-profit insurers earned $40.2 billion in profits in first half of 2023. She argued that health insurance companies increase profits by denying care and purging patients through high costs. - Dr. Kate Neely (family doctor) told the story of a patient who died of colon cancer after avoiding a diagnostic colonoscopy due to fear of out-of-pocket costs, and described urgent care patients turning away because of outstanding balances. - John Rice (resident) cited statistics: 18 million Google results for "medical debt horror stories"; U.S. spends twice as much on healthcare as peer nations but ranks last in access/quality; medical bills are the 1 cause of bankruptcy. - David Hughes (resident) criticized privatization of Medicare (half now Medicare Advantage) and described his $8 bill for emergency care in Mexico vs. astronomical U.S. costs. - Dr. Anthony Fiorilla (semi-retired physician) recounted a friend who died at 51 from a heart attack after avoiding care because he had no insurance and feared $30,000+ costs. - Emily DeFari (resident): described women in labor without prenatal care due to insurance gaps; her mother's rehab delayed by Medicare Advantage plan; a relative's $2,000 surprise bill for reproductive care. - Carl Redwood (activist): cited a Commonwealth Fund report noting medical debt affects people of color, women, and low-income families; called for linking short-term fixes to single-payer; noted 36% of UPMC employees have medical debt to UPMC (51% for those earning under $20/hr). - Sandra Fox (Churchill Borough resident): paid $520.76 for an EpiPen due to a Medicare Part D deductible; argued for free care at point of service funded by progressive taxes. - Teresa Chalich (registered nurse): concerned about the Medicaid "purge" in Pennsylvania (estimated 90,000–184,000 lost coverage); called for seamless Medicare for All to prevent debt. - Sam Schmidt (resident): echoed the statistic that 51% of UPMC low-wage workers have medical debt; called for single-payer. - Dr. Thomas Brockmeyer (retired orthopedic surgeon, multiple myeloma patient): his monthly Revlimid cost Medicare nearly $16,000, with his co-pays $5,800/month; argued only 2–3 of his 25 cousins could afford such care; endorsed improved Medicare for All. - Lorraine Starsky (retired nurse): pointed out that the end of the public health emergency means free COVID tests are no longer available, burdening low-income families; cited Philadelphia's free test distribution as a model and urged Allegheny County to fund similar programs. - Councilmember Barb Warwick (City of Pittsburgh): noted the city's $1 million ARPA-funded medical debt buyback through RIP Medical Debt; questioned why UPMC doesn't simply waive its own patients' debt; shared personal family medical costs ($3,000 ambulance bill, $900 ER visit for a dog bite that required no treatment). Discussion Items - Councilmember Hallam asked about negotiating medical debt; presenters confirmed it's possible but difficult for individuals. - Councilmember Hallam pressed for legally binding, enforceable actions beyond resolutions, suggesting mandates like zero employee insurance contributions. Presenters emphasized that the ultimate solution is national single-payer, but local steps like publicizing medical debt data and supporting worker organizing could help. - Council President Katina and Councilmember Palmasino expressed gratitude and acknowledged the severity of the issue, noting specific county programs (Aging services, higher life expectancy at home) and the need to amplify voices. - Councilmember Macy shared his personal experience of being dropped from Medicaid after starting a new job and struggling with insurance, noting that mental health care is also a challenge. He emphasized that council members are not immune to these problems. - Councilmember Klein (Chair) stated that the committee has a moral obligation to create a platform for these issues and pledged that the hearing will not be forgotten. Key Outcomes - No formal votes were taken. The committee committed to taking the testimonies to heart and exploring next steps. - Presenters requested that the council: (1) reduce obstacles for a non-binding county referendum on a universal national health system; (2) research the impact of medical debt on Allegheny County residents (by municipality, race, age, sex); (3) encourage and support similar resolutions from other municipalities; (4) consider building a database of local elected officials backing Medicare for All, as suggested by the late Senator Jim Furlow. - Council members indicated openness to these proposals and agreed to stay in contact with the presenters for further guidance. - Chair Klein closed by thanking all participants and affirming that the council will not disappoint in following up.

The Allegheny County Council met on September 12, 2023, at 10:00 AM. The meeting included proclamations, unanimous approvals of several ordinances, a heated debate on diversity in council staffing, liaison reports, and public comment on CCAC funding, redistricting, and juvenile detention privatization. Consent Calendar (Unanimous Approvals) - 12786-23: Ordinance authorizing Allegheny County Budokai to continue using a structure in South Park for martial arts – passed 12-0. - 12787-23: Ordinance authorizing Mon Valley Express Drum and Bugle Corps to continue using a South Park structure – passed 14-0. - 12788-23: Ordinance authorizing South Park Theater Incorporated to continue using real property in South Park for theater activities – passed 14-0. - 12801-23: Motion authorizing public hearings on October 17 and 19, 2023 – passed by voice vote. - 12804-23: Notification of contracts for August 2023 – received and filed. Discussion Items - Appointment: 12798-23 (Michelle Pianzo to Board of Property Assessment Appeals) was introduced and referred to the Committee on Appointment Review. - Unfinished Business – 12718-23 (Allegheny League of Municipalities contract): This bill was added to the agenda via a motion to comply with the Sunshine Act. It passed 9-3, with Councilmembers Hallam, Macy, and Walton voting no. - Liaison Reports: - President Katina reported on a Board of Elections meeting regarding a special election for a vacant state house seat, noting that polls are fully staffed with 20 backup workers and that director voiced everything is prepared. - Councilmember Macy reported that the Fire Vest Board approved two new CCAC curriculums (CDL driver and emergency medical technicians) and highlighted incentives for volunteer firefighters, including free college education. - Diversity on Council Staff: Councilmember Palmary raised a point of personal privilege, expressing frustration that the Executive Committee decided not to post for a researcher position. He stated that in nearly eight years on council, there is no diversity on council staff and accused the body of engaging in activities that “border on racism.” Councilmember Hallam countered that when she was chair, no diverse candidates were hired in four years despite numerous EEOC complaints and a lawsuit. Councilmember Dewar argued that the delay in hiring was to evaluate staffing needs. The discussion became heated and was eventually ruled out of order by the President. - Councilmember Bennett’s Statement on Shelter Closures: During personal privilege, Councilmember Bennett expressed concern that after assurances from the administration, the Smithfield Street shelter closed and now the Second Street shelter is closing, leaving inadequate shelter for the unhoused population in downtown. She noted tents and tent villages and reported concerns from constituents and businesses. - Councilmember Klein’s Response to Public Comment on Redistricting: In response to public commenter Marie Norman’s support for an independent redistricting bill, Councilmember Klein noted that he did not draw his own district and that the map was a collaborative effort led by Councilmember Dewar. Councilmember Dewar added that Councilmember Betkowski never attended any reapportionment committee meetings. Public Comments & Testimony - Marie Norman (Squirrel Hill): Expressed strong support for Bill 12534-22 (independent redistricting commission). She argued that codified rules are needed to prevent future gerrymandering. - Donald Breitbarth (CCAC academic advisor, District 11): Thanked council for the $2.8 million funding increase to CCAC, bringing the county's share to 26% (from 22%) and reducing the student share to 36%. He detailed how the funds are used for tutoring, mental health support, placement testing, bus passes, and Microsoft Office licenses. He asked for continued support in the upcoming budget. - Hannah Thomas (Plum Borough, District 8): A CCAC student and teacher, she advocated for reading and writing labs at every campus to support the most vulnerable students. - Rebecca DuPont (CCAC professor, North Campus): Pushed for cloud computing at CCAC to provide equitable access to software and hardware. She noted it supports both transfer students and workforce training initiatives. - Robert Koch (CCAC automotive instructor, West Hills Campus): Highlighted the need for funding to keep trade programs (automotive, HVAC, etc.) updated with technology, especially for electric/hybrid vehicles. He invited council to an event on October 6, 2023. - Tanisha Long (Pittsburgh): Expressed concern over potential privatization of the Shuman Center juvenile detention facility. She cited a Pittsburgh Institute for Nonprofit Journalism article about Adelphoi contracting, noting that Adelphoi faces multiple lawsuits for sexual abuse and assault of minors. She urged council to hold public hearings and involve community partners like the Abolitionist Law Center and Juvenile Law Center. Key Outcomes - 12718-23 (Allegheny League of Municipalities contract): Passed 9-3 with three members absent. - 12786-23, 12787-23, 12788-23: All passed unanimously with 12-14 votes in favor. - 12802-23 (Payment of litigation invoices, Fitzgerald v. Allegheny County): Passed 13-2, with Councilmembers Fatullis and Walton voting no. The invoices totaled $8,070.50. - Liaison Reports: - The special election (to fill a vacant state house seat) is prepared; all polls staffed with 20 additional poll workers on standby. - The Fire Vest Board approved two new CCAC curriculums: CDL driver and emergency medical technician training, with an incentive of free college education for volunteer firefighters. - Personnel/Diversity Discussion: Councilmember Palmary raised concerns about the lack of diversity on council staff and criticized the executive committee's decision not to post the researcher position. An exchange occurred with other members, with some objecting to the characterization of racism. The discussion was ended by the president. - Shelter Closures: Councilmember Bennett put on record her disappointment with the closure of the Smithfield Street and Second Street shelters, stating that the administration had previously assured the council that adequate shelter space existed. - Appointment Referred: 12798-23 (Michelle Pianzo) referred to appointment review committee. - Proclamations: - September 2023 declared Love Your Library Month in Allegheny County; the Jack Buncher Foundation will match donations. - A proclamation congratulating George and Barbara Morgan on their 60th wedding anniversary. Note - The meeting included a moment of silence and roll call with 11 members initially present, later increasing to 14.

The Allegheny County Council met on August 29, 2023, at 10:15 AM. The meeting included a moment of silence, a statement on the Plum tragedy, several proclamations, extensive public testimony on a proposed climate action plan ordinance, and a vote to approve that ordinance. Public comment also addressed a proposed homeless shelter in Carrick and opposition to the federal EATS Act. Consent Calendar - Approval of the minutes from the August 15, 2023 regular meeting was moved and seconded; passed unanimously. - Proclamations were approved en bloc (12781-23 through 12783-23) recognizing Jason Brule, Willa A. Neal, and George and Mary Batico. Public Comments & Testimony Climate Action Plan (Bill 12695-23): - Tom Pike (Forest Hills) voiced strong support for the ordinance, stating it would bring Allegheny County in step with Pittsburgh and other municipalities. He noted that the county's air quality is among the worst in the country, with 52 unhealthy air days in 2021. - Sam Schmidt (concerned mother and resident) urged immediate action, emphasizing that the plan must be enforceable, specific, measurable, and time-bound, and based on IPCC data. She highlighted poor air quality in the Mon Valley. - Matt Mahalek (Director, Breathe Project) supported the ordinance, stating that air quality and climate issues are intertwined. He noted that the Mon Valley's air is worse than 93% of the country and that Allegheny County is in the top 1% for cancer risk from point source air toxics. He cited a 42% drop in ER visits for heart problems after the Shenango Coke Works closure. - Angela Wiley (Children's librarian, Communitopia board member) supported the plan, emphasizing the need for equitable responses to climate change that prioritize underserved communities. - Deborah Smith (Resident, climate reality leader, Mount Lebanon Environmental Sustainability Board) supported the bill, noting that Pittsburgh created a plan 15 years ago and that the county faces over $15 billion in climate adaptation costs by 2040. She stated that 20% of county residents live at or below poverty. - Naomi Swerglow thanked council members and highlighted educational institutions. - Ilias Kahn (Swissvale) urged the council to pass the ordinance, arguing it would address environmental racism, protect seniors, and help rural communities. - Christine Graziano (Squirrel Hill North resident) supported the ordinance, noting the urgency of climate action and referencing Hurricane Idalia and Maui wildfires. - Patricia DeMarco (Resident, concerned mother) supported the plan, emphasizing the need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 50% by 2030 and 100% by 2050, and criticizing carbon capture and blue hydrogen. - Melanie Meade (Clairton resident, near USX Clairton Coke Works) urged passage, stating that children in Clairton do not know what environmental justice is and are suffering from health issues due to pollution. - Juan Lingo (Homewood resident) endorsed the plan, noting milder winters and the impact of Canadian wildfire smoke. - Meredith Feldy (Oakland, constituent of Councilman Walton) expressed strong support, saying both Pennsylvania and Pittsburgh already have climate action plans. - John Detweiler (77-year resident, in Mr. Klein's district) supported the bill but warned against hucksters and profiteers, and called for a transparent, open planning process. - Thomas Allen (Lawrenceville, constituent of Councilwoman Bennett) supported the plan, stating that Allegheny County's food system alone emits 3.7 million tons of CO2 annually, more than entire countries like Puerto Rico or Niger. - Lucina de Barbero supported the plan, emphasizing the need to distinguish investments that reduce emissions. - Phoebe Reeves (O'Hara Township, constituent of Councilwoman Prizio) supported the ordinance, stating that emissions are waste and cost money through heat, asthma, landslides, and flooding. - Diane Peterson, Emily Donato, James Logue were not present. - Robert Axon (Engineer) advocated dividing the plan into local pollution and global climate change parts, stressing the need for innovations. - Reverend Jeffrey Thomas (Lawrenceville, constituent of Councilwoman Bennett) supported the bill on the basis of faith, stating that humans are caretakers of the earth. - Ray Roberts (constituent of Councilman Walton) urged passage, citing IPCC reports, extreme rainfall, and the urgency of climate action. Other Public Comments: - Shannon Dickerson (Pittsburgh) spoke against the federal EATS Act (HR 4417/S 2019), arguing it would give DC power over local communities, undermine state agricultural committees, and hurt minority, women, and veteran-owned businesses. - Donna McManus (President, CAREC Community Council) raised safety concerns about a proposed homeless shelter at 2230 Brownsville Road in Carrick, noting it sits between two Pittsburgh public schools. She cited issues like public urination, drug use, and understaffed police. - Laura Doyle (Secretary, CARE Community Council) objected to the lack of community notification for the shelter RFP, stating that 60 homeless people listed Carrick as last address and that the community was blindsided. - Michelle Trafficante (Lifelong resident) opposed the shelter location near an elementary school, citing problems from a previous shelter on Smithfield Street. - Ron Giardini (Carrick resident) expressed frustration with the concentration of social services in the city and argued that suburban council members should understand the burden on Pittsburgh neighborhoods. - Eileen Papau (Former volunteer at Bethlehem Haven) urged a more comprehensive approach, including job skills and partnership with Habitat for Humanity, rather than just warehousing the homeless. - Rhonda Luffy Graham (Carrick resident, family history since Civil War) asked the council to reconsider the RFP and to walk the community. - John Hanarhan (North Side resident, Vice President of Fine View Citizens Council) supported emergency housing and noted that his neighborhood is doing its part. Discussion Items - Plum Tragedy Statement: Councilwoman Nakara Chapkis delivered a statement honoring six victims of a tragedy in Plum, thanking first responders and many volunteer fire departments and organizations. - Proclamation for Ray McCutcheon: Council President Katina presented a proclamation recognizing Coraopolis Borough Manager Ray McCutcheon for the 2023 Distinguished Service Award. McCutcheon thanked the council, noting his 12 years of service and deep roots in the community. - Climate Action Plan Ordinance (Bill 12695-23): Councilwoman Prizio, sponsor, moved for approval. Councilman Walton spoke in favor, citing WHO statistics on climate change health impacts, NASA data on July 2023 being the hottest month on record, and risks to health and agriculture. Council President Katina noted that the committee on sustainability was created only recently. The ordinance passed unanimously 15-0. - Liaison Report: Councilman Macy reported that the Southwestern Pennsylvania Commission (SPC) voted unanimously to be a single point of contact for regional climate planning, emphasizing collaboration. - New Business: Several ordinances were introduced and referred to committees, including acquisition of easements for road and bridge projects, and continuation of use of structures in South Park by Budokai, Mon Valley Express Drum and Bugle Corps, and South Park Theater. Also, a resolution opposing the EATS Act (HR 4417/S 2019) was introduced and passed by voice vote. Councilman DeMarco expressed opposition to the EATS Act due to overly broad language that could affect animal protection and environmental laws. - Public Comment on General Items: Multiple speakers opposed the proposed homeless shelter in Carrick, citing safety, lack of community notification, and the concentration of services in southern neighborhoods. Council member noted that the shelter proposal came from the administration, not the council, and called for better communication. Key Outcomes - Climate Action Plan Ordinance (12695-23): Approved by a vote of 15-0. The ordinance requires the Allegheny County Department of Sustainability to develop a climate action plan by July 1, 2024. - Resolution Opposing EATS Act (12794-23): Approved by voice vote. The resolution urges the U.S. Congress to defeat HR 4417 and S 2019, which would limit state and local agricultural regulations. - All other new business items were referred to appropriate committees for further consideration.

The Allegheny County Council met on August 15, 2023, with 13 members initially present (later 14 for a roll call vote). The meeting featured multiple proclamations honoring individuals and organizations, approval of prior meeting minutes, referral of appointments, introduction of a public hearing on medical debt, and public comments on ADA accessibility and healthcare costs. Proclamations - Alekia Dota Penene (Pine Richland Eden Hall Upper Elementary student) was recognized for winning the statewide One Water Poster Contest, sponsored by Councilmember Filadie. Councilmember Palmasina offered a boat ride. Alekia spoke about water conservation and the importance of clean water. - Gateway Clipper Fleet celebrated its 65th anniversary, sponsored by Councilmembers Palmasina and Macy. Representatives highlighted the fleet's history, its role in river tourism, and its impact on the region. - Presley's Place at Pittsburgh International Airport recognized for its fourth anniversary, sponsored by Councilmember Katina. - Battle of Homestead recognized for its 131st anniversary, sponsored by Councilmembers Pritzio and Klein. - Castle Shannon Community Day celebrated the 2023 event, sponsored by Councilmember Palmery. - Western Pennsylvania Slovak Day recognized for its centennial, sponsored by Councilmember Macy. - Sean Trainer recognized on his retirement from the City of Pittsburgh, sponsored by Councilmember Palmasina. - Minerva Bakery recognized for its 100th anniversary, sponsored by Councilmember Macy. - John Vento honored on his 100th birthday, sponsored by Councilmembers Katina, Palmasina, Fatulis, and the County Treasurer. - Ethan Conley recognized for achieving Eagle Scout rank, sponsored by Councilmember Macy. Public Comments & Testimony - Bernadette Mossy (resident of Mount Lebanon/Scott Township area) raised concerns about the lack of ADA-accessible curb cuts on Bower Hill Road in Scott Township. She stated that the road was resurfaced without updating corners as required by state law, and that Scott Township did not respond to her calls. She noted that the issue affects mothers with strollers and elderly individuals, and requested county assistance. Councilmember DeMarco offered to follow up with her. - Ed Griffar and George Wax Munski (United Electrical Workers regional director) spoke in support of the upcoming public hearing on medical debt. Griffar cited statistics: 100 million people with medical debt, 41% of adults affected, medical debt is the leading cause of bankruptcy, and 17% of adults with medical debt declare bankruptcy. He noted that 119,000 people in Allegheny County are on Medicaid and that 15 million people were recently cut from Medicaid nationally. They urged the council to use the hearing to raise awareness and push for healthcare reform. Discussion Items - Public Hearing on Medical Debt (Bill 12776-23): Councilmember Pritzio presented a motion to hold a public hearing on Monday, September 18, 2023, at 6:00 p.m. in the Gold Room of the Allegheny County Courthouse to discuss medical debt. The motion was seconded and approved via roll call with 14 votes in favor; one member (President Katina) was noted as absent (despite being recorded as 'Yes' earlier in the roll). - Bill 12777-23 was withdrawn from the agenda. - Resolution on Jail Warden Search (Bill 12778-23): A motion expressing the sense of council regarding the search and hiring processes for a new Allegheny County jail warden, sponsored by Councilmember Katina, was referred to the Committee on Public Safety. Key Outcomes - Approved minutes of the regular meetings on May 23, June 6, June 20, and July 11, 2023, by voice vote. - Appointments referred to the Committee on Appointment Review: Michael Soley (Board of Property Assessments, Appeals and Review), Timothy Mowray (Accountability Conduct and Ethics Commission), G. Eric French (Allegheny County Conservation District Board), Jenna R. Kramer (Allegheny County Conservation District Board), and Holly A. Douglas (Minority Women and Disadvantaged Business Enterprise Board). - Ordinance authorizing land reclamation group LLC to complete a stream restoration project at Pearson Run in Boyce Park referred to the Committee on Parks. - Public hearing on medical debt authorized for September 18, 2023 (14-0 vote, with one absent). - Bill 12777-23 withdrawn. - Resolution on jail warden search referred to Public Safety Committee. - Notifications and contracts for July 2023 were received and filed. - Meeting adjourned after public comments.