Public Meetings - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

The Bethlehem City Council met at 7:00 PM on July 21, 2026, to conduct a public hearing on the proposed 2026 Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and Home Investment Partnerships Program (HOME) allocations, to receive public comments on a range of community issues, and to vote on several ordinances and resolutions. Key actions included approving the annual action plans for CDBG and HOME funds, authorizing grant applications for emergency solutions, watershed restoration, and multimodal transportation, and adopting zoning amendments related to property inspections and data centers. Public Hearing: 2026 CDBG & HOME Funding Recommendations - Robert Vidoni, Housing and Community Development Administrator, presented the proposed allocations. The city's 2026 CDBG award is $1,370,309 (a 3% decrease from 2025) and the HOME award is $388,308.10 (a 7% decrease). Of 23 CDBG funding requests, 20 are recommended for funding; of 3 HOME requests, all 3 are recommended. - Vidoni noted that CDBG funds are subject to a 15% cap on public services and a 20% cap on program administration. The recommended public service activities include tenant advocacy ($15,000), emergency sheltering ($50,546), substance abuse treatment ($20,000), housing counseling ($15,000), caregiver services ($10,000), food pantry ($20,000), representative payee services ($50,000), and homebuyer assistance administration ($25,000). Other CDBG recommendations include housing rehabilitation ($100,000–$150,000), facility upgrades, and site cleanup ($50,000). - HOME funds are allocated to program administration (10% cap), the CHODO set-aside (15% mandatory), and the Gateway on Fourth multifamily rental project ($1,488,173.14). - Council members asked questions about new applicants: out of three new CDBG applicants, two received funding. The council expressed appreciation for staff and nonprofit partners. Public Comments & Testimony - Greenway Safety Petition: Chris Ann Drust Lustig presented a petition with 85 signatures from Litzenberger House residents, calling for increased safety on the Bethlehem Greenway following a recent stabbing. They requested the city address homelessness in the area while maintaining the Greenway as a family-friendly space. - Fire Department Study: David Roof expressed frustration that a promised fire department staffing study had not been released, urging its public disclosure given taxpayer funding. - Development Concerns: Janet Barry criticized the approval of multiple apartment projects and a proposed storage unit, arguing the city prioritizes developers over residents and fails to enforce tree replacement under the Tree City USA program. - Visitor Remarks: Gilmark Bariano, a visiting Filipino legislator, praised the council's public participation process and expressed interest in establishing a sister-city relationship with Bethlehem. - Surveillance Cameras: Rooster DeMott spoke against the use of Flock Safety automatic license plate readers (ALPRs), citing privacy concerns, data breaches, and low arrest rates (only three arrests). He urged the council to adopt regulations limiting data retention and usage. - Homelessness and Public Space: Another speaker defended the unhoused population, stating that public spaces belong to everyone and that homelessness is not a crime. - Controversial Comments: Artie Curatola made statements about Jewish leaders and the Middle East, which the council president noted were protected speech but not endorsed. Stephen Antalix and Terry Kloiber echoed concerns about overdevelopment and student rentals. - Welcoming City Ordinance: Sebastian Zavaruka urged the council to adopt a welcoming city ordinance to protect immigrant communities, referencing past kidnappings and recent deaths. Discussion Items - Finance Committee Report: Councilman Cologne reported that the finance committee reviewed a proposal to restructure general fund debt (presentation only) and an ordinance adjusting the capital budget for non-utilities, both forwarded for council action. - Ordinance Bill 19 – Inspection & Sale Amendments: Council discussed changes to property inspection requirements at sale. The ordinance aligns the city's 90-day correction period with the state's 12-month mandate. Debate centered on potential redundancies and costs for landlords, which could lead to higher rents. The ordinance passed 6-0. - Data Center Zoning Ordinance: A communication referred a proposed ordinance to establish regulations for data centers to committee for further review. Key Outcomes - Rescheduled Meeting: The council voted 6-0 to move the August 4, 2026, meeting start time to 5:30 PM due to Musikfest. - Ordinances Passed (all 6-0): - Bill 19 (2026): Amendments to inspection and property transfer rules (12-month correction period). - Bill 20 (2026): Amendment to the 2026 general fund budget. - Bill 21 (2026): Amendment to the 2026 capital budget for non-utilities. - Bill 22 (2026): Zoning ordinance amendments. - Bill 23 (2026): Additional capital budget amendment. - Resolutions Passed (all 6-0): - 10A: Approval of 2026 CDBG and HOME Annual Action Plans for HUD submission. - 10B: Transfer of $141,672 from engineering and streets salary accounts to provide matching funds for the Green Light Go signal modernization program. - 10C: Authorization to apply for up to $1.5 million in Emergency Solutions Grant (ESG) funds. - 10D: Authorization to apply for up to $300,000 for watershed restoration (Stefco Swale rehabilitation). - 10E: Authorization to apply for up to $3 million for multimodal transportation (Stefco Boulevard complete streets). - 10F: Use permit for ArtsQuest Country Fest (August 21-22). - 10G: Use permit for Bradbury Sullivan LGBT Community Center's Lehigh Valley Pride (August 30). - 10H–10J: Certificates of appropriateness for properties at 443 Center Street and others (passed as a group). - Administrative Orders: Approved reappointment of Ian Panco and appointment of Jill Sperandino to the Fine Arts Commission (both 6-0).

The Bethlehem City Council Finance Committee met on July 21, 2026, to discuss a proposal to restructure existing general fund debt, consider a budget adjustment for the Green Light Go traffic signal grant program, and receive a mid-year financial report. No public comments were offered. The committee voted unanimously to advance the Green Light Go-related ordinance and resolution to the full city council. Discussion Items - Debt Restructuring Proposal: Director of Budget and Finance Mark Evans and PFM Financial Advisor Scott Shear presented a plan to refinance and restructure approximately $11.7 million of the city's general fund debt. The proposal targets four bond series (2017A, 2017B, 2017E, and 2019) to smooth annual debt service payments, replacing a flat $10.8 million payment with gradual step-downs from $9.4 million in 2027 to under $1 million by 2036. The restructuring would have a present value cost of $811,000 due to extending the repayment term, but would provide annual cash flow relief and budget flexibility. City debt has been reduced from a high of $171 million in 2015 to $77 million currently. The committee took no vote; the proposal will return for a parameters ordinance first reading on August 4, 2026. - Green Light Go Traffic Signal Grant Program: Bureau of Streets Engineering Manager John Alcall presented two related items: an ordinance adjusting the non-utilities capital budget to include a $78,000 project to replace LED display modules and controller components at all 128 traffic signals, funded 80% by state Green Light Go grants and 20% by city match; and a resolution transferring $141,000 in savings from the Streets Engineering budget to fund the city's matching share. The committee voted 3-0 to forward both items to the full council for consideration. - Mid-Year Financial Report: Director Mark Evans provided an update on revenues and expenses through the first half of 2026. Property tax collections are at 96.5% of budget, consistent with prior years. Earned income tax is slightly ahead. Real estate transfer tax is running lower due to timing delays from Northampton County. Investment interest revenue is on track despite lower rates. On the expense side, salaries are within budget, but medical insurance claims are running significantly higher than in recent years, partly due to a $500,000 billing lag from 2025. Weekly claims exceeded $500,000 for several weeks early in the year, though activity has since moderated. The city is monitoring medical costs closely in anticipation of the 2027 budget process. Key Outcomes - Vote on Capital Budget Adjustment (Green Light Go): Motion to move the ordinance to full council passed 3–0. - Vote on General Fund Transfer (Green Light Go): Motion to move the resolution to full council passed 3–0. - Debt Restructuring Next Steps: The committee received the presentation and will consider a parameters ordinance at the August 4 council meeting, with a second reading on August 18 and bond pricing expected after Labor Day. - No votes were taken on the mid-year report; it was informational.

The Bethlehem City Council held a regular meeting on July 7, 2026, starting at approximately 7:00 PM. The meeting included a public hearing on proposed zoning text amendments to clarify short-term rental regulations, expand workforce housing incentives, and limit single-family dwellings to one per lot. Following the hearing, the council conducted general public comment, considered new business, and voted on numerous ordinances and resolutions. Public Hearing: Zoning Text Amendments - Kathy Fletcher, Director of Planning and Zoning, presented a package of six zoning text amendments. Sections 1–4 clarify that short-term rentals (e.g., Airbnbs) are transient lodging (stays under 30 consecutive days) and are only permitted where hotels are allowed. Section 5 expands the workforce housing incentive to the Limited Commercial (CL) district. Section 6 clarifies that only one principal single-family detached dwelling is allowed per lot. The Planning Commission voted 5-0 on June 11, 2026, to recommend approval, and the Lehigh Valley Planning Commission provided a favorable letter on June 29, 2026. - Councilman Laird asked if the amendments strengthen enforcement; Fletcher confirmed they provide clearer legal authority. - Bruce Haynes (63 West Church Street, managing partner of Hotel Bethlehem) expressed full support, stating the amendments help combat illegal Airbnbs in the historic district, reduce litigation costs, and protect housing stock. He noted Hotel Bethlehem’s leisure business increased 9% in Q4, 12% in Q1, and 20% in the most recent quarter, with advanced bookings up 30%. - Mike Staffer (resident) supported the amendments and urged the council to balance growth with quality of life, citing traffic and congestion concerns. - Stefan Scheidi (Wall Street resident) encouraged a positive vote on the amendments. - The public hearing concluded, and the proposed ordinance was placed on the July 21, 2026 agenda for first reading. Public Comments & Testimony - Deborah Condon (903 Spring Street) spoke in favor of the proposed buffer yard protection amendment (Communication 6R), arguing it would provide equal environmental protection to residents of twin homes and row houses, many of whom are lower-income and minorities. - Artie Curatola (self-described writer/performer) made comments regarding ArtsQuest and Israel; the solicitor intervened to stop statements of attribution. The speaker was eventually asked to sit down. - Dr. Michael Pipestone (1130 West Market Street) supported the buffer yard amendment, citing health benefits of green spaces (reduced urban heat, asthma rates, emergency room visits). - Tammy Rinker (630 15th Avenue) and Siona Broughtlight (412 2nd Avenue) also voiced support for the buffer yard amendment. - Terry Kloiber (Grandview Boulevard) raised concerns about the proposed Bennett Lot development (seven buildings, 410 apartments) and questioned the city’s commitment to quality of life. - Carmela Monaghan (209 Mountain Area Avenue) supported buffer yards and opposed overdevelopment. - Stephen Taleks (737 Ridge) criticized the council’s recent treatment of public speakers, citing a previous meeting where a speaker was cut off at the five-minute limit. - Judith Ross (317 Rock above Perone) spoke in favor of buffers and nature preservation. - Mr. Antalex (spoke twice) addressed the conflict between personal beliefs and official duties, and thanked the council for attention during his earlier comments. Discussion Items - Councilwoman Daniels thanked supporters of the buffer yard amendment and noted it addresses inequity in zoning protections for all residential properties. - Councilman Cologne thanked the administration for sharing the Citizens Traffic Advisory Committee meeting on social media. - Councilman Callahan inquired about a flagpole at Lehigh Little League (a cell tower in disguise) and asked for follow-up for veterans. - Councilman Callahan also noted he had sent a request for a committee meeting to Councilwoman Quitek but had not received a reply; it was clarified the email may have been missed. - New Business guidelines were reiterated: items requiring deep discussion should be submitted via the agenda process or referred to committee. Key Outcomes - Public Hearing concluded: The zoning text amendment ordinance will be placed on the July 21, 2026 agenda for first reading. - Motion to schedule a committee meeting for the buffer yard amendment (Communication 6R) passed 6-0. - Ordinance 19-2026 (amending property sales inspection procedures to align with state law) passed 5-1 (Callahan nay). - Ordinance 20-2026 (General Fund budget adjustment) passed 6-0. - Ordinance 21-2026 (Capital budget for non-utilities) passed 6-0. - Resolution 10A (agreement with Greater Lehigh Valley Chamber of Commerce for marketing, $80,000) passed 6-0. - Resolutions 10B–10G (use permit agreements for ArtsQuest events: Soccer Fest, Sabor Latin Festival, Independence Day, One Earth Reggae Fest; and Chamber block party) passed 6-0. - Resolution 10H (disposal of public records) passed 6-0. - Resolution 10I (agreement with Spillman Farmer for design of 11-unit emergency family shelter at 232-234 West Packer Avenue, $210,000) passed 6-0. - Resolution 10J (transfer of retired officer handgun – Captain Nicholas Leckman) passed 5-1 (Quitek nay). - Resolution 10K (transfer of retired officer handgun – Sergeant John Casella) passed 5-1 (Quitek nay). - Resolution 10L (agreement with Custom Ag Services for water treatment residuals removal, $206,250 per year) passed 6-0. - Resolution 10M (modified parking fines for Musikfest 2026, July 31–August 9) passed 6-0. - Resolutions 10N–10P (certificates of appropriateness for properties at 523 Main Street, 264 East Wall Street, 108-11 Wesley Street) passed 6-0. - Resolution 10Q (certificate of appropriateness for 34 East Third Street) passed 6-0. - Resolution 10R (certificate of appropriateness for 330 East Fourth Street) passed 6-0. - Administrative order: Mayor reappointed Joy Cohen to the Planning Commission (effective through June 2031); passed 6-0.

The Community Development Committee of the Bethlehem City Council met on July 7, 2026, for the annual Financial Accountability Incentive Reporting (FAIR) hearing. Chair Hilary Quiet presided, with committee members Justin Amon and Carla Daniels present. Sean Ziller, Deputy Director of Economic Development, presented the 2025 FAIR report, which reviewed tax and non-tax economic development incentives used by the city. The report covered the Local Economic Revitalization Tax Assistance (LERTA), City Revitalization and Improvement Zone (CRIZ), Enterprise Zone Loan Program, Bethlehem Small Business Loan Fund (BSBLF), and Business Infrastructure Development (BID) loan fund. No public comments were received. Discussion Items - LERTA: Ziller reported two active LERTA zones (South Side Affordable Housing LERTA expiring end of 2026 and South Side LERTA 2 expiring end of 2027). In 2025, the city relinquished approximately $1,046,000 in real estate taxes under LERTA abatements. The in-lieu payments collected from the affordable housing LERTA districts total over $907,000 since the fund's establishment. Ziller noted ongoing internal evaluation of a potential new LERTA designation. Councilwoman Quiet requested additional data breaking down which LERTA zone contributed to the in-lieu payments and how many of the 33 active projects involved housing units. - CRIZ: Six projects are active in the CRIZ zone (Greenway Third and New, 510 Flats, 610 Flats, Wilbur Mansion, Wind Creek expansion, and two Lehigh Valley Health Network medical office towers). The total value of tax incentives received in 2024 was approximately $1.78 million, supporting about $40 million in CRIZ debt. Pre-CRIZ property tax assessments were $1.63 million; current assessments are $45.6 million. The zone supported 839 employees (708 full-time) in 2024. Councilwoman Daniels asked about project naming and activity outside Martin Tower. Ziller clarified that most CRIZ acreage is privately held and that the program abates state taxes mostly, with city taxes including business privilege, local services, and amusement taxes. - Enterprise Zone Loan Program: This legacy program is underutilized; the city's enterprise zone designation expired September 30, 2024, though benefits continue for two more years. The city recently issued an RFP for support to renew the designation. Councilman Amon asked about underutilization; Ziller explained that funds are tied up in existing loans, notably the Pi Incubator Facility project from 2013. No new loans are available until repayment occurs. - Bethlehem Small Business Loan Fund (BSBLF): Administered by Rising Tide Community Loan Fund. In 2025, one new small business received a loan valued at $24,412; six other loans remain active. No new Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) dollars were allocated to this fund in 2025. Ziller noted that Rising Tide has new staff and the city is evaluating the program's operation. - Business Infrastructure Development (BID) Loan Fund: No loans were approved in 2025 due to limited remaining legacy funds. Key Outcomes - The committee took no formal votes; the FAIR report was received as informational. - Staff will continue evaluating potential new LERTA designations to address affordable housing and economic development priorities. - The city is pursuing renewal of the Enterprise Zone designation, including a strategy to better deploy the loan fund. - Ziller agreed to provide council with more detailed breakdowns of LERTA in-lieu payments by zone.

The council met on June 16, 2026, but lacked a quorum, so no official actions, motions, or votes were taken. The session was limited to receiving public comment, making informational announcements, and accepting reports. Matters requiring official action were postponed to the July 7, 2026 meeting. Public Comments & Testimony - Artie Curatola (813 Law for Street) criticized U.S. support for Israel, comparing Israeli actions in Gaza to the Holocaust and accusing leaders of genocide. He argued that failing to stop the violence makes citizens complicit. He also alleged that powerful Jewish interests suppress dissent. - Scott Moser (58 Craigie Street, Easton) and Bert Mucklin (1482 Pine Street, Pen Argyl), both in the fire protection trade, alleged that the installing contractor (Anchor Fire Protection) on the Walnut Street parking garage project did not follow bid specifications for fire suppression standpipes and dry pipe sprinklers. They stated the contractor used cheaper schedule 10 pipe instead of schedule 40, omitted pressure gauges, and used roll groove instead of cut groove joints—saving an estimated $205,100 in material, labor, and fabrication. They requested a third-party engineering review and argued that the general contractor (Mohawk Construction) and the Bethlehem Parking Authority were unresponsive. Councilman Callahan later confirmed he had been told by Parking Authority Director Steve Fernstrom that no official substitution form had been filed. - Gaza Burkett Jr. (1903 Hilltop Terrace, lifetime Bethlehem resident) raised three public health concerns: (1) unsafe conditions at a rental property he reported to the Board of Health; (2) potential expansion of the waste landfill near St. Luke’s Anderson campus, which he said could release mycotoxins harmful to immunocompromised individuals; (3) the environmental and health impacts of data centers. He asked the city to investigate. - Bill Shire (1890 Eaton Avenue) continued his critique of the water and sewer bill, arguing that stormwater and recycling fees are effectively property taxes because they are fixed regardless of use. He previewed a future discussion on progressive versus regressive taxation. - Alex Miller (810 Minocase Street) urged the council not to renew the city’s contract with Flock (automatic license plate readers), citing privacy abuses and Flock’s ties to ICE and other problematic entities. He described the government’s role as a test pilot for federal tech grants. - Stephen Antelogs (737 Ridge Avenue) criticized the city’s “student zone” designation, which permits up to five unrelated individuals to be treated as a single family, encouraging investor-owned rentals and displacing single-family homes. He urged the council to revise the definition of “family” to limit student rentals, as other college towns do. Council Member Remarks - Council President Ms. Kuyatec announced that the Community Development Committee will meet on July 7, 2026 at 6 p.m. to discuss the 2026 FAIR (Financial Accountability Incentive Reporting) hearing report. No actions will be taken. - Councilman Mr. Callahan detailed his efforts to investigate the Walnut Street parking garage fire protection issue. He stated that after Councilwoman Crampsy Smith left, she asked him to follow up. He requested documentation from the Parking Authority, was initially told to file a Right-to-Know request, and was later quoted $700 for documents—a charge he called unreasonable. He eventually received the file. He noted that Director Fernstrom initially told him no substitution form had been filed by Anchor Fire Protection, but later directed all further communication through the Parking Authority’s solicitor. Callahan said he will send a formal letter asking for a special subcommittee meeting to examine the matter. - Mayor Reynolds announced upcoming block parties at Madison Park, Clearview, and Bernie Fritz on three consecutive Wednesdays, and a Complete Streets meeting at the Fowler Center on Thursday evening (June 18, 2026) at 6 p.m. Presentations & Recognitions - A citation was presented to Sergeant John Casella for 20 years of service with the Bethlehem Police Department (2007–2026). Casella attended and accepted the citation. - A citation for retired Captain Nicholas Lechman was noted; he was not present and the citation will be mailed. Key Outcomes - No official votes or decisions were made due to lack of quorum. - All agenda items requiring action were deferred to the July 7, 2026 regular meeting. - Council will receive written materials from public commenters and may pursue further review of the parking garage allegations through subcommittees.

The meeting opened with the pledge of allegiance, roll call, and approval of the previous meeting's minutes. Public comments covered a wide range of issues including landfill cleanup, weed enforcement, curbing damage from UGI utility work, concerns about Flock Safety surveillance cameras, calls for stronger natural resource protections, critiques of GDP-driven growth, and opposition to the Northampton County Drug Task Force. During new business, council members discussed the 10th Avenue curbing issue, the Flock contract renewal, affordable housing strategies (including the Martin Tower site), the Walnut Street Garage odor incident, and the 40&10 Parks Plan. Several resolutions were passed, including the award of a design contract for three parks, renewal of the drug task force agreement, and various use permits. Consent Calendar - Approval of minutes (no comments). - Several resolutions were grouped and passed without discussion: 10B through 10E, 10L and 10M (use permits for various events); 10G through 10I (certificates of appropriateness); 10N through 10Q (certificates of appropriateness). Public Comments & Testimony - Larry Kirk – Thanked the city for finally cleaning up the New Bethlehem Landfill after seven months; praised code officer William Santiago. - Sue Greathouse – Requested code enforcement for neighbors' overgrown weeds, including poisonous plants dangerous to pets. - Jessica Unger – Explained that the curbing in front of her home was deemed acceptable by the city in 2022, then damaged by UGI utility work in 2022–2024. She stated that residents were promised repairs that never happened and are now being held financially responsible. She urged the council to hold UGI accountable. - Stephanie Zabo – Echoed the curbing issue, noting that UGI and its subcontractor promised repairs. She criticized the city for inconsistent enforcement and for threatening fines, while other streets (e.g., Spring Street) were not required to replace curbing. She asked for a fair resolution and for the city to work with residents and UGI. - Alex Miller – Expressed strong opposition to the city's use of Flock Safety surveillance technology. He cited recent reports of sales employees accessing cameras without authorization, cities covering cameras with trash bags, and police searches of ALPR data without warrants. He urged the council not to renew the contract, which expires around July 2026 at $41,000 per year. - Deanna Rodriguez – Urged the council to adopt ordinances protecting natural resources (trees, water, green space) before data centers and overdevelopment consume them. She noted that Bethlehem's tree canopy provides $1.79 million in annual ecosystem services and removes pollution equivalent to 3,808 cars per year. She called for proactive regulation. - Harry Faber – Used the “parable of the river” to argue that the city should address root causes of social problems rather than simply rescuing downstream victims. He criticized GDP growth as a measure of well-being and opposed the drug task force, citing historical abuses. He also urged the council to reject the drug task force resolution. - Bill Shire – Questioned the nature of the stormwater user fee, arguing it is effectively a property tax but called a fee to avoid political backlash. He suggested folding it into the property tax. - Artie Curatoli – Made lengthy remarks about alleged anti-Semitism in the city, claiming that Jewish people control media and institutions. He also quoted Adolf Hitler, leading to tension. Council President Leon reminded him of rules against personal insults, but allowed him to finish. - Terry – Thanked the city for installing a blinking speed limit sign on her street after she submitted a petition with 75% of neighbors. She requested additional blinking stop signs and encouraged others to follow the same process. - Stephen Antalix – Expressed concerns about the planned Linden Street two-way conversion, warning that it would cause traffic congestion and safety issues on Center Street. He argued that the council did not consider the impact on Center Street traffic. - Michael Pipestone – A medical physician, he apologized for an earlier outburst and asked the council to consider the impact of allowing Nazi propaganda during public comment. He praised the neighborhood bakery At Lehigh and the improved stop sign at 12th and Market. He urged the city to focus on community-owned businesses rather than data centers and private equity. - Kwame (Boy Scout) – Approached the podium but was told public comment time was over; council members offered to answer questions after the meeting. Discussion Items - 10th Avenue Curbing – Councilman Kuyatec asked Public Works Director Alcall about UGI's responsibility for damage. Alcall said the city has reached out to UGI and will help residents enforce promises. Councilman Callahan requested that enforcement letters be paused while the matter is investigated. The administration noted that the curbing was already deteriorated before UGI's work. - Flock Safety Cameras – Councilwoman Laird asked about the contract renewal (July 2026, $41,000/year). Deputy Chief Michels confirmed the contract is up for renewal. Councilwoman Laird requested a copy of the contract terms, privacy provisions, and use policies before renewal. - Walnut Street Garage Odor – Councilman Callahan reported that a fire department response was due to an odor in the sprinkler room. He raised concerns about the garage construction, alleging that the contractor substituted cheaper materials than specified (e.g., Formica instead of granite countertops, inferior piping). He requested a committee meeting to investigate. The city solicitor noted that the parking authority is a commonwealth agency and not under council oversight, but Councilman Callahan pressed for transparency. - Martin Tower / Affordable Housing – Councilman Callahan argued that the city should pursue the Martin Tower site (zoned for 1,000 units) which could generate $5 million in new revenue for affordable housing. He criticized the administration for not engaging with the developer due to a personal dispute. Director Collins responded that the project is not economically feasible without incentives and that the city is focused on other strategies (e.g., gateway project, ADUs, choice neighborhoods). - 40&10 Parks Plan – The council debated Resolution 10A to award a design contract for three parks (Bernie Fritz, Clearview, Madison). Councilwoman Daniels expressed concern about equity, noting that Madison Park (on the South Side) appeared to receive less investment than the two North Side parks. She wanted to postpone the vote. Other council members explained that the resolution could not be amended; it was either pass or fail. After discussion, the resolution passed 7-0. Councilwoman Laird asked that the Parks and Recreation Committee review the preliminary designs. - Drug Task Force – Councilwoman Kuyatec voted against renewal, citing concerns about civil liberties and disproportionate impact on communities of color. The resolution passed 6-1. Key Outcomes - Minutes approved without objection. - Resolution 10A (Parks design contract with HRG, $324,925.98) – Passed 7-0. - Resolution 10K (Northampton County Drug Task Force agreement) – Passed 6-1 (Councilwoman Kuyatec voted no). - Resolutions 10B–10E, 10L–10M (use permits for events) – Passed 6-0 (Councilman Callahan absent for roll call). - Resolutions 10F (Interceptor capital improvements agreement) – Passed 6-0. - Resolutions 10G–10I and 10N–10Q (certificates of appropriateness) – Passed 7-0. - Resolution 10J (BEDCO agreement) – Passed 7-0. - Other communications – A public hearing was scheduled for July 7, 2026 to consider zoning ordinance amendments regarding short-term rentals and hotels. - Future meetings – Council President Leon announced she will be absent for health reasons; Vice President Laird will chair the next meetings.

The Bethlehem City Council held a regular meeting on May 12, 2026, which featured a training presentation from an attorney with the Pennsylvania State Ethics Commission on the State Ethics Act. The presentation covered conflict of interest, nepotism, use of office, gifts, statements of financial interests, and enforcement. No public comments were made, and the meeting adjourned after council thanked the presenter. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public provided comments during the public comment period. Discussion Items - Ethics Training Presentation: An attorney from the Pennsylvania State Ethics Commission delivered a detailed presentation on the State Ethics Act. Key points included: - Conflict of Interest: Using public office for private pecuniary benefit (including mitigation of loss) is prohibited. Example: a township supervisor who sold a car from his lot to the township; despite losing money, the commission and Commonwealth Court ruled mitigation of loss is a financial gain. - Exceptions: De minimis economic impact (up to $500) and class/subclass actions (e.g., a county commissioner voting to change zoning for solar panel leases benefited all similarly situated landowners). - Nepotism: Public officials cannot use their position to benefit immediate family members (spouse, parent, child, sibling). Example: working behind the scenes to change an anti-nepotism policy and then abstaining from the vote still constitutes use of office. - Use of Government Assets: Using government equipment or subscriptions for private business is a violation. Example: a PennDOT surveyor used agency equipment and GPS subscription for his private surveying business, resulting in $62,000 restitution. - Gifts and Improper Influence: Accepting gifts (e.g., event tickets, cash) in connection with official actions can lead to violations if a vote follows. Example: a school director received Eagles tickets and an envelope of cash from a vendor; if he later votes for that vendor's contract, it becomes an ethics violation. - Honoraria: Public officials cannot accept payment for speaking engagements on matters related to their official duties. - Revolving Door: For one year after leaving public employment, former officials cannot represent a person or business before their former agency for compensation. - Advice of Counsel: The commission offers written advice for future conduct, which protects against later investigations. - Investigations: Initiated by sworn complaints; preliminary inquiry (60 days) then investigative complaint (180 days). Confidential until final public order. Penalties include restitution (to the local municipality) and possible treble damages. Criminal prosecution referred to district attorney or attorney general. - Statements of Financial Interests: Must be filed by May 1 each year. Failure to file or backdating can lead to civil penalties (e.g., $250 fine, court costs, contempt of court). Online filing is recommended to avoid deficiencies. - Council members had no questions or comments following the presentation. Key Outcomes - The council received the ethics training from the State Ethics Commission. - No votes or decisions were taken; the meeting was adjourned after council thanked the presenter and the acting audiovisual support (Council Vice President Laird). - The presenter shared contact information for the commission (staffed 8 a.m. to 5 p.m.) for future questions.

The Bethlehem City Council met on May 5, 2026, at 7:00 PM in Town Hall. The meeting included extensive public comments on a long-standing garbage issue at 1953 Eaton Avenue, a discussion on police training at the Steel City Gun Club, traffic safety concerns, and the approval of a controversial certificate of appropriateness allowing full demolition of four buildings at 327 South New Street. Several resolutions were passed, and a council meeting was rescheduled due to the primary election. Public Comments & Testimony - John Bardino, Mark Sager, Daniel Fritzzi, Mike Albanese, and Larry Kirk (residents of Eaton Avenue and Union Boulevard) spoke about a garbage pile at 1953 Eaton Avenue that has been accumulating for six months. They expressed frustration with the city's code enforcement process, stating that citations were slow to be issued, a magistrate hearing had not been scheduled, and they felt ignored by the code officer. They described health and safety risks from vermin and blowing trash. - Mark Ozaneck (resident of Reddington Road) complained about nighttime shooting at the Steel City Gun Club, reporting that on April 30 and May 1, gunfire continued past 10:00 PM, disturbing children and residents. He urged the council to restrict police training to end by 9:00 PM. - Dan Skinner (Delwood Street) requested speed deterrent devices on his street near Elmwood Park due to increased speeding, noting many children in the area. - Isabel thanked the council for updates on a spray tech issue and asked for guidance on organizing community cleanups at Sand Island. - Terry Coyber (Grandview Boulevard) presented a petition signed by 46 of 61 households requesting a traffic study for speed humps and flashing stop signs at Glendale and Florence Avenues, citing frequent stop sign violations and pedestrian risks. - Mary Jo McCool (Grandview Boulevard) echoed speeding concerns on Grandview, Broad Street, and Hanover Avenue, criticizing the administration for perceived apathy and urging immediate action before a fatality occurs. - Bill Shire (Eaton Avenue) read quotes from Ronald Reagan in support of immigration, then later commented on the 327 South New Street demolition, arguing that council prioritizes developers over historic preservation. - Stephen Antalix (Richard Street) criticized the council for allowing variances that he said damage the character of single-family neighborhoods, citing the commercialization of South Side. Discussion Items - 1953 Eaton Avenue Garbage Issue – Mayor Reynolds and Ms. Collins (Recycling Bureau) explained that a single trash enforcement officer handles 650–700 complaints annually. The property owner was first warned, then cited in March 2026, but the magistrate had not yet scheduled a hearing. A second $500 citation was issued on May 5 after a cleanup promise was broken. Council members discussed potential solutions including health department involvement, condemnation, liens, and a possible single-hauler system. The mayor noted that legal limits on fines and collections (as low as 14–19% of fines collected) hinder enforcement. The property is a rental with owner-tenant family ties. - 723 Broadway Affordable Housing – Council member Callahan asked why a city-renovated home completed in late 2024 was still not for sale. The mayor confirmed that Community Action Lehigh Valley is responsible for final repairs, and there have been staffing turnovers in their housing division. An update will be provided to council. - Steel City Gun Club and Police Training – Police Officer Adel explained that the department has an agreement for daytime and some nighttime qualifications. Night training is rare but sometimes necessary. He said the April 30 incident may have been a two-day qualification class. There is no formal community notification for after-hours training, but dispatch is alerted. Council expressed concern about noise and disruptions. - Traffic Safety – Council discussed the Citizens Traffic Advisory Committee, which meets the first Tuesday of each month at 8:30 AM. Mayor Reynolds noted that a Complete Streets Plan will address physical infrastructure to slow traffic. - 327 South New Street Demolition – This item was removed from a group of certificates of appropriateness due to controversy. The HCC had recommended full demolition including an historic Italianate facade at 321-323 South New Street, replacing a 2021 COA that required preserving that facade. Council members debated the delay since 2021, structural integrity claims, and economic hardship arguments. The HCC unanimously approved the new COA. Council voted 4–3 to approve. Key Outcomes - Meeting Rescheduled – The second council meeting in May was moved from Tuesday, May 19, 2026 (primary election day) to Wednesday, May 20, 2026, at 7:00 PM. (Vote 7–0) - Appointments – Lynn Olinov appointed to the Redevelopment Authority (vote 7–0); Christopher Kern appointed to the Bethlehem Revitalization and Improvement Authority (vote 7–0). - Use Permit Agreements – Approved for Mom Market 2026 (May 17, Aug 23, Oct 25), Sangria Fest (May 16), Live on the Greenway (May 24, 31, June 7, 14), and Live in the Garden Concert Series (Saturdays May 9–June 27). All passed 7–0 on a group motion. - Public Records Disposal – Authorized disposal of records from Water & Sewer Resources (vote 7–0). - Certificates of Appropriateness – Three standard COAs passed 7–0 (15 E 4th St signage, 25 W 3rd St signs, 306 S New St ventilation louvers). - 327 South New Street COA – Approved demolition of all four structures and removal of required facade preservation, allowing a new seven-story mixed-use building. Vote: 4–3 (Raymond, Callahan, Cologne, Quitek in favor; Daniels, Laird, Leon opposed).

The City of Bethlehem Parks and Public Spaces Committee held an informational meeting on May 5, 2026, to receive a presentation from the administration on the "40 Parks in 10 Years" (40&10) plan. The presentation covered the planning process, community engagement, criteria for park selection, and the first three parks to be improved: Bernie Fritz, Madison, and Clearview. No votes or formal decisions were taken; the meeting was for discussion and information sharing. Key dates mentioned include the ribbon cutting for Friendship Park on May 17, 2026, and the next council agenda item for the design and engineering contract. Discussion Items - Overview of Park System and Philosophy: Mayor Reynolds and staff emphasized that parks are shared public goods designed for all residents, not just the wealthy. They highlighted recent successes like Friendship Park (ribbon cutting in 12 days) and Dutco Park (completion within a month) as examples of community-driven projects. - Community Engagement Process: Kathy and Corey from the administration described a year-long process involving a steering committee, three virtual public meetings, 15 pop-up events, and a survey. Key community values identified were maintenance and care (number one), accessibility/connectivity, and nature-based experiences. - Park Typology and Network: Parks were classified into three types: regional (10+ acres, destination parks like Monocacy and Sand Island), anchor (medium-sized, neighborhood destinations like the new Friendship Park), and community (small, walkable parks like Dutco). The plan aims to create a network within four geographic areas (northeast, central, south, west) to ensure a variety of amenities are accessible within short distances. - First Three Parks (Phase 1): The first parks selected are Bernie Fritz (northeast), Madison Park (south), and Clearview Park (west). Selection was based on community feedback, environmental justice criteria, ADA access needs, safety, and potential impact. All three are anchor parks with proposed improvements including splash pads, updated play equipment, sports courts, and water refill stations. Feasibility will be determined during engineering and design. - Timeline and Funding: The administration explained that using general fund dollars (approved by council in the prior budget) allows a faster 24-month cycle from announcement to completion, compared to 36+ months for grant-funded projects. The contract for design and engineering for the first three parks is expected to be on the next council agenda. Construction is targeted for summer/fall 2027 with completion by end of that year. - Future Planning: The city plans to apply for a DCNR grant to create master plans for three regional parks: Sand Island (2027), Sauken Park, and Menacasi Park. These are separate from the 40&10 anchor park investments. - Programming and Maintenance: Emphasis was placed on increasing structured programming (e.g., movies in the park, summer park programs) and balancing maintenance needs. The community's top concern was maintenance, and staff are exploring efficiency measures such as adjusting mowing schedules and reducing leaf collection in certain areas. - Council Member Comments and Concerns: - Councilwoman Laird thanked the team and asked about park-specific plans in the final report. She also inquired about potential park removal from inventory; staff confirmed none are being considered. - Councilman Daniels expressed support for the plan but raised equity concerns regarding the South Side, noting that parks like Yasko have not seen significant capital improvements and that Madison Park currently has broken equipment. He requested immediate attention to a broken slide and a dangerous swing at Madison. Staff acknowledged the issues and committed to following up. - Councilwoman Kwatec praised the maintenance data and asked about the RFP structure for the first three parks (single firm vs. multiple). The administration indicated they likely will hire one firm for design/engineering, with construction contract decisions pending capacity. - Councilwoman Liao highlighted the importance of cooling stations and splash pads, noting tears of joy at prior committee meetings, and urged continued commitment from future councils to see the 10-year plan through. - Councilwoman (Chair) Laird noted payroll plaza is included in the park count (43 total) and asked about reducing maintenance burdens through no-mow areas and not clearing all paths. Staff responded that such decisions require legal review and community acceptance. Key Outcomes - The meeting was informational; no votes or formal motions were made. - The design and engineering contract for the first three parks (Bernie Fritz, Madison, Clearview) will be presented to the full council at the next meeting. - Community pop-up events for feedback on designs will be held at Bernie Fritz on July 29, 2026 (Bernie Fritz Night), and at Madison and Clearview in June/July (dates to be announced). - Staff will inspect the broken slide and dangerous swing at Madison Park and report back on potential temporary repairs. - The administration will continue to explore programming increases (e.g., at Yasko Pool) and sustainable maintenance practices.