Public Meetings - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

The Bethlehem City Council convened on April 7, 2026, at 7:00 p.m. The meeting began with a recognition of Thomas Rockle, a retiree from the Department of Water and Sewer Resources who served for 36 years. Council approved previous meeting minutes, heard public comments on various issues, discussed budget impacts of rising gas prices, addressed resident complaints about litter and air quality, and voted unanimously on several budget amendments and agreements. Public Comments & Testimony - Brandon Horlick (Church Street resident) expressed concern about litter and trash accumulation along the canal, creek, and Lehigh River, particularly near Sand Island. He asked the city to ensure proper cleanup and maintenance of the natural areas. - George Andrews (resident near Spray Tech, Avenue B) described persistent foul odors from the Spray Tech facility over the past four years. He stated that the odors control his family’s ability to enjoy outdoor activities, and that EPA complaints have not resolved the issue. He asked the council for help. - Isabel Andrews (stay-at-home mom, same Spray Tech issue) stated that Spray Tech has been found not using required scrubbers and that the company has been “kicked out of another place” for similar odors. She suggested the city create an air quality board with stricter rules and proposed adopting stricter air quality standards under Section 116 of the Clean Air Act. - Harry Faber spoke at length about U.S. foreign policy, military spending, and the bombing of universities and medical facilities in Iran, linking these to local impacts. He urged the council to consider anti-imperialist policies and mentioned joining the DSA. - Marty Caratola (813 Law for the Street, Bethlehem) claimed his self-published book was refused by the Bethlehem Public Library while Adolf Hitler’s “Mein Kampf” remains on the shelf. He accused the library director of anti-Semitism and asserted his right to have his book in the library. - Stephen Antalix (Seven Ridge) argued that the Bethlehem Authority should be made independent, similar to Allentown and Easton authorities, to reduce city council workload and improve water management. He cited past financial abuses and illegal timbering due to unclear lines of authority. - Mr. Shire (frequent commenter) criticized inconsistent parking signage around City Hall and the library, calling it an embarrassment. He noted that signs say “no public parking” or “one hour parking” at times when the library is closed, creating confusion. - Brian Nickus (826 Tioga Avenue) thanked council members for speaking to Boy Scout Pack 352 earlier that evening about democracy and government. Discussion Items - Gasoline Budget Impact: Councilman Callahan asked about the city’s gasoline procurement and the effect of rising gas prices ($1 per gallon increase over two weeks). Director of Public Works Michael Alcall and Mr. Evans explained that the city buys gasoline in bulk through state contracts with a lag, so sustained price increases of months would be needed to significantly impact the budget. The city’s annual gasoline expenditure is approximately $1.8 million. Council noted that if high prices persist, budget transfers may be necessary. - Canal Path Litter and Spray Tech Odors: Council discussed follow-up on the two citizen complaints. Mr. Alcall stated that garbage along the canal is difficult to keep clean despite regular emptying of cans and volunteer cleanups. Community connections are evaluating additional needs in areas where unhoused people have relocated. Regarding Spray Tech, Ms. Collins (city staff) explained that DEP controls air quality permits; the city can contact DEP to check on permit status and compliance. Councilwoman Leon encouraged residents to also contact state representatives (Sen. Boscola, Reps. McNeil and Samuelson) to influence DEP funding. Councilman Callahan urged continuous follow-up. - Food Trucks at Lehigh University: Councilman Callahan raised concerns that Lehigh University has placed food trucks on its property (possibly by the cupola plaza), which he claimed are taking business from established restaurants on Fourth Street. Ms. Collins noted that food trucks on private property may be allowed under zoning, but the city does not have a general ordinance for food trucks on public property. Councilwoman Laird noted that the trucks are likely operated by Sodexo under Lehigh’s dining contract. Callahan asked for investigation into permitting. - Council President’s Remarks on Free Speech & Hate Speech: Council President Leon asked the city solicitor to provide guidance to council on the line between free speech and hate speech, following repeated comments that she and other council members find antagonistic. Solicitor indicated she will provide guidance on what is constitutionally protected and what actions council can take. Key Outcomes - Approved previous meeting minutes unanimously. - Adopted Ordinances 8a through 8e (grouped) by a vote of 5-0: These amend the 2026 sewer capital budget, water capital budget, water fund budget, and two general fund budgets (Bills 13-17). - Adopted Ordinance 9a (Bill 18-2026) by a vote of 5-0: Amends the liquid fuels fund budget, reducing it from $2,374,220 to $2,210,833 due to reconciliation with PennDOT allocation, increased snow/ice removal costs, and reduced street overlays. - Adopted Resolution 10a by a vote of 5-0: Authorizes a use permit agreement with The Wicked Botanist for the 2026 Lehigh Valley Spring Wicked Plant Festival on April 26, 2026, on First Street from Polk Street to Eastern Terminus and Founders Way. - Adopted Resolution 10b by a vote of 5-0: Authorizes an agreement with Lehigh Valley Center for Independent Living to conduct a handicap accessibility site survey of city-owned spaces (police department, library, city hall) at a cost of $3,900, to be completed by December 31, 2026. - Adopted Resolution 10c by a vote of 5-0: Authorizes disposal of public records in the Department of Community and Economic Development as per the municipal records manual. - Council directed staff to follow up with DEP on Spray Tech complaints and to investigate the food truck situation at Lehigh University. - The mayor’s State of the City address was announced for April 8, 2026, at 7:00 a.m.

The Bethlehem City Council met on March 17, 2026, for a full agenda including a public hearing on a liquor license transfer, multiple contract approvals, budget adjustments, and discussion on fire department records management and homelessness. All votes were unanimous (7-0) unless noted. Citations and Recognitions - Assistant Fire Chief Alan S. Berghard was honored with a citation for 30 years of service (starting in 1995, retired 2006). Berghard noted his father also served in the fire department, and this month will be the last time a Berghard is on the department rolls. - A citation for Thomas Spenner was noted but he was not present. Public Hearing: Intermunicipal Liquor License Transfer - Request: Ridham Cowboy Company sought approval to transfer Restaurant Liquor License R0580 from Easton Meat and Produce Corp. (250 Line St., Easton) to 217 Broadway, Bethlehem, for a country-themed restaurant and entertainment venue called "Ridham Cowboy Co." - Details Presented by Attorney Nico Barada: - Seating: 114 on first floor (97 dining + 17 bar seats), plus second floor overflow/private events, and seasonal outdoor patio. - Maximum occupancy rated at 449, but seating will be far lower. - Hours: Mon–Thu 11am–11pm, Fri–Sat 11am–12am, Sun 11am–10pm. - Projected sales: 65% food, 35% alcohol; no take-home alcohol sales. - Employment: 35-40 new jobs (20 full-time, 15-20 part-time, 2-3 admin). - Security: on-site personnel during peak hours, cameras, staff RAMP training. - Opening target: August 2026, pending approvals. - Council Questions: Councilman Cologne confirmed the site was the former firehouse; plans include private event space. Council President asked about peak hours and parking – security will be inside and outside; street parking and nearby garage available. Council expressed support for the investment. - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Resolution 10G approved unanimously (7-0). Consent Calendar / Routine Approvals All items below were approved en bloc by a single 7-0 vote unless specific discussion noted. - Appointments: - Councilmanic reappointments to Bethlehem Human Relations Commission (Valery Noonan, Karen Davison, Marilyn Kelly Cavada) – approved. - Mayoral administrative orders: Appointments/reappointments to Fine Arts Commission (Stephen G. Thompson, Donna McGavro, Carol Parker, Sue Birkenstock, Sharon Brown, James A. DePicho, Adam Urselani, Barbara Fraust, Stephanie Powell Watts) – approved. - Budget Amendments (First Reading): - Ordinance 13-2026: Amend 2026 Sewer Capital Budget. - Ordinance 14-2026: Amend 2026 Water Capital Fund Budget. - Ordinance 15-2026: Amend 2026 Water Fund Budget. - Ordinance 16-2026: Amend 2026 General Fund Budget (grant for fire department special alarm devices, replacing 27 units). - Ordinance 17-2026: Amend 2026 General Fund Budget (grant of $14,975 for EMS equipment for opioid/drug storage on ambulances). - Contracts and Resolutions: - 10A: Appointment of delegates to Northampton County Tax Collection Committee (Lenny Lazarchak primary, Eric Evans alternate). - 10B: Agreement with Preload LLC ($3,480,000) to construct a 1 million gallon concrete water tank on South Mountain, replacing a 100-year-old reservoir; 630-day completion. - 10C: Agreement with Brendan Stanton Inc. ($352,600) for electrical services (lighting, SCADA) for the South Mountain water tank; 630-day completion. - 10D: Agreement with GPE Corporation ($73,095) for analysis and design of pavement restoration on 15th Avenue, Avenue A, and Avenue C; 90-day completion. - 10E: Agreement with Pendon for water main relocation at Hill Hill Bridge. - 10F: Agreement with R3 Construction ($548,189.20) to replace/extend water mains in various locations; 250-day completion. - 10H: Agreement with TL Engineering (dba Elfreth) ($75,645) to design a multi-level steel maintenance building at the golf course; completion by Dec. 31, 2026. - 10I: Adoption of updated City of Bethlehem Emergency Operations Plan (dated March 17, 2026). - 10J: Agreement with Baseline Contracting Inc. ($7,230) for installation of 90 ADA curb ramps; 150-day completion. - 10K: Agreement with Heidelberg Materials Northeast LLC ($1,407.20) for 33 ADA curb ramps, milling and overlays; 120-day completion. - 10L: Use permit agreement with Touchstone Theater for America Dreams and Festival Unbound events (April 11-27) at Rose Garden. - 10M: Use permit agreement with AAUW Bethlehem Branch for 2026 Book Fair (April 23-27) at Earl E. Schaeffer Ice Rink. - 10N: Acceptance of donated outdoor fitness equipment from Bethlehem Aquatic Club at Monocacy Park (adjacent to Memorial Pool). - 10O: Authorization for fire department to create temporary help account for records management system conversion (see Discussion Items). - Certificates of Appropriateness: - 10P: 1506 Calypso Avenue – 4-foot split rail fence with black mesh. - 10Q: 415 Long Street – cellular PVC trim, new front door trim, paint aluminum siding. - (Approved as part of group 10P-10R.) Public Comments & Testimony On Subjects Not Being Voted On (5-minute limit): - Mark Weber: Urged relief from rising gas/diesel taxes; highlighted rising utility costs and asked for a timeline from the mayor on addressing them. Advocated for downloadable water usage apps to help conserve water and prevent costly leaks for residents and businesses. - Amanda Chiles: Spoke on behalf of Bethlehem’s homeless population. Thanked city resources (New Bethany, Small Essentials Cafe, UCC Thrift Store) but stressed urgent need for a year-round emergency shelter and transitional housing. Noted that when the seasonal shelter closes in spring, homeless individuals face harassment, assault, theft, and arson. Presented a petition with signatures collected downtown. Asked the city to make 2026 the year for safe housing. - Mr. Shire (name unclear): Criticized the City Council’s prior approval of a 7-story apartment building in the historic district. Argued that the Historic Architecture Review Board (HARB) only approved the design, not the height, because council had overridden HARB’s rejection of a taller parking garage. Stated that council’s decision on height set a precedent. - Kent F. (Mr. Faber): Spoke against U.S. support for Israel’s war in Iran, citing resignation of Director of National Intelligence Joseph Kent. Called the war illegal and accused the mayor and council of inaction on genocide and imperialism. Urged council to oppose the war. - Marty Curatola: Identified as the chosen Irish tenor for an Allentown parade. Urged council to oppose war in Iran and support for Israel. Called for love and peace, citing his long-standing anti-war stance. Expressed frustration at being called anti-Semitic for his views. On Subjects Being Voted On: - Lou Jimenez (President, Bethlehem Firefighters Local 735): Commented on Resolution 10O (temporary help for fire department). Supported the short-term contractor for the records system transition but urged that it not become a long-term fix. Stated the real solution is increasing the budgeted number of firefighters, which has declined from 108 to 104. Asked that temporary help be limited to the proposed 90-day period and not replace investment in the department. Discussion Items - Fire Department Temporary Help (Resolution 10O) : - Fire Chief Matthew Griffin explained the need to convert records management from Tyler's New World to First Due due to state/federal compliance requirements. The data transfer had errors (e.g., address formatting discrepancies) causing missing data. The temporary position (15-20 hrs/week, 90-day trial) would work under the deputy chief to clean up data, train department personnel, and improve accuracy of key holder/contact information. - Councilman Callahan asked if the system could track calls to Lehigh University off-campus housing to assess usage. Chief Griffin noted difficulty because addresses are not tied to student status. Solicitor is researching billing ordinances for fire/police services. Discussion included complexity of identifying student vs. non-student renters. - Council President emphasized the 90-day window and requested updates if extension needed. Councilwoman Quietek asked about data recovery – Chief believed it can be resolved. Councilwoman Leon clarified that the position is administrative, not a replacement for firefighter staffing. - Outcome: Approved 7-0. - Homelessness Shelter (Councilwoman Quietek inquiry) : - Business Administrator Eric Evans and staff updated on Bethlehem Emergency Shelter (BES). The shelter currently operates six months per year due to zoning restrictions. A capital campaign for a $6 million year-round upgrade has $2 million secured; the city has helped apply for $4.5 million in public funds. Progress is slow due to BES leadership transition. Zoning relief (variance) would be needed unless the facility becomes a public facility. The city is also moving forward on the Packer Avenue project (11 units for families), fully funded. - Parking Authority Sprinkler Issue (Councilman Callahan) : - Reported that a lower-grade pipe than specified was installed in the Walnut Street garage. He sent a memo to the parking authority solicitor three weeks ago but received no response. He will request a subcommittee meeting to address the issue and ensure taxpayers received what was paid for. - Pavement Restoration Study (Councilwoman Quietek) : - Public Works Director Michael Alcal explained that roads like 15th Avenue, Avenue A, and Avenue C were built with only 2 inches of asphalt on dirt. The study will conduct core borings to design a cost-effective reconstruction. Key Outcomes - Liquor License Transfer (10G) : Approved 7-0. - Fire Department Temporary Help (10O) : Approved 7-0, limited to 90-day trial period. - All other resolutions and ordinances (approximately 20 items): Approved 7-0. - Appointments: Both councilmanic and mayoral appointments approved 7-0. - No ordinances for final passage. - Next steps: The temporary help position will be filled and progress reported to council; the parking authority issue will be addressed via subcommittee; the homeless shelter project continues with city support.

The Bethlehem City Council Finance Committee met on March 17, 2026, to review six agenda items: five ordinances for proposed budget adjustments and one resolution for a budget transfer. All items were recommended for approval to the full council. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public were present for comment. Discussion Items - Sewer Capital Fund Adjustment (Item 1): Mr. Boscola presented a proposed adjustment to the sewer capital fund reflecting a year-end reconciliation. The cash balance increased from $6.5 million (as of October 1, 2025) to $6.8 million (as of January 1, 2026), a change of $291,000. Expenditure adjustments included adding $100,000 for collection system capital work, reducing sewer trench restoration by $100,000 (a bill paid in Q4), and increases for aeration tank upgrade and digester replacement. The unassigned future capital needs balance decreased by $208,000 to balance the budget. - Water Capital Fund Adjustment (Item 2): The water capital fund cash balance decreased by approximately $506,000 from October 1 to January 1. The construction fund was spent down entirely from $321,000 to zero. An additional $500,000 capital appropriation from the water fund balance was added. Overall net decrease in available funds was about $327,000, with adjustments including a $400,000 reduction for replace/relocate distribution (bills paid in Q4), increased funding for lead service line replacements and facilities improvements, and reductions in equipment and maintenance line items. - Water Fund Operating Adjustment (Item 3): A transfer of $500,000 from the water fund cash balance to capital appropriation was approved, bringing the water fund cash balance to approximately $15 million. Councilwoman Quietek asked about the need for the transfer given the healthy balance; Mr. Boscola explained that construction costs have risen post-COVID and the fund is used to avoid borrowing. The sewer fund has a similar cash balance in the same magnitude. - Fire Department Grant – PASS Devices (Item 4): Chief Griffin presented a $6,137 grant from the Office of the State Fire Commissioner for 27 new PASS devices (personal alert safety system) to replace obsolete units. These devices help locate downed firefighters. Cost per unit $595. - Fire Department EMS Grant – Med Vault (Item 5): A $14,975 EMS grant to purchase a med vault to secure medications/narcotics in ambulances and organizer equipment for a supervisor's vehicle. Director Fritz confirmed it replaces end-of-life units (approximately 9 years old). - Fire Department Budget Transfer for Temporary Help (Item 6): A $5,000 transfer to create a temporary part-time position (15-20 hours per week for up to 90 days) to assist with the conversion of the records management system ("First Due"). Chief Griffin explained the need for focused, consistent help as shift work and firefighting duties hinder progress. Councilwoman Quietek questioned the sufficiency of $5,000; Mr. Evans noted they have former firefighters/retirees in mind with experience. The position will be posted through HR. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend approval of items 1-5 (water/sewer adjustments and fire grants) to the full council. - The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend approval of item 6 (fire department budget transfer) to the full council. - All six items will be placed on the full council agenda for the same evening (March 17, 2026) with a recommendation for approval.

The Bethlehem City Council met on February 18, 2026, to address a range of topics including public comments on parking authority issues, historic preservation, public safety, and snow removal. The council voted on several ordinances and resolutions, including a controversial certificate of appropriateness for a seven-story mixed-use building on Walnut Street. Key decisions included approval of budget adjustments, a retired officer's handgun purchase, a fiber optic agreement, and multiple certificates of appropriateness. Consent Calendar - Minutes from the previous meeting were approved unanimously. - Ordinances 8A through 8I, amending various 2026 budgets (General Fund, Water Fund, Community Development Block Grant Fund), were passed 6-0. - Ordinance 12-2026, amending the Non-Utility Capital Fund, was amended (increasing appropriations from $39,025,323 to $41,248,119) and passed 6-0. - Resolution 10A (Hill-to-Hill Bridge expansion) passed 6-0. - Resolution 10C (fiber optic agreement with Greenlight Networks) passed 6-0. - Resolution 10E (COA for 72 East Market Street) passed 6-0. - Resolution 10F (COA for 400 Main Street) passed 6-0. Public Comments & Testimony - Robert Trexinger: Detailed a dispute with the Bethlehem Parking Authority over a parking ticket issued on August 8, 2025. He stated that kiosk software glitches prevented payment, and after a magistrate hearing, he was found not guilty. He criticized BPA for ineptitude and demanded a meeting with the mayor, alleging misconduct by BPA staff. - Girl Scout Troop 8208 (Remy, Beatrice, Viv, Cora, Fiona, Becca): Presented a Bronze Award project on snow and ice shoveling at corners. They requested the city share their educational posters and videos on social media to promote compliance with ordinances. - Harry Faber: Urged council to pass a resolution condemning the rise of fascism, following Lehigh County's similar resolution. He stated, "Condemning fascism is really not that hard." - Alex Miller: Argued for terminating the city's agreement with Flock Safety, citing concerns about civil liberties abuses and ICE collaboration. He urged the city to make "the smart, responsible choice to make Bethlehem a little bit freer." - Martin Romerill: Offered to serve on the Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB), noting a 33% vacancy rate (six of nine seats filled). He cited his experience as a resident of the Northside Historic District since 1975. - Ms. McCall: Expressed concern about understaffing in the fire department, noting that not all calls are medical. She recounted incidents involving propane tanks and carbon monoxide, and emphasized the need for public safety staffing before adding housing. - Stephen Antonics: Criticized council for approving a study of fire/EMS services by the Center for Public Safety and Management, arguing the problem is staffing, not equipment. He urged council to replace dismissed firemen and support the lone council member pushing for proper staffing. - Artie Caratola: Proposed using heaters in snow trucks to melt snow and drain it into sewers. He also made remarks about Jesus and anti-Semitism, clarifying that he loves all people. - Bill Shire: Opposed the proposed seven-story building at 33 West Walnut Street, arguing it would detract from Main Street's historic charm. He stated that growth is not always progress and that the city should focus on affordable housing rather than large apartment buildings. He read a portion of his statement. - Mary Joe: Read the final two paragraphs of Bill Shire's statement, which argued that the building would be "the beginning of the end for Bethlehem as it has been known." - Stephen Antonics (second comment): Opposed resolution 10E, stating that the developer's dollars overrule Article 1714 and that the seven-story building is "ugly" and overpowering, comparing it to a cancer crossing the river. - Artie Caratola (second comment): Opposed the development, urging preservation of historic landmarks and suggesting developers build in other areas. Discussion Items - Fire Department Data Request: Councilman Callahan requested data on the number of fire department calls to Lehigh University, St. Luke's, and Moravian. Fire Chief indicated that five years of data had been provided but aggregating new data would be complex. Callahan proposed a monthly fee for universities to cover fire services. - Parking Authority Issues: Callahan raised concerns about the Bethlehem Parking Authority, including a bid issue on the Walnut Street Garage sprinkler system where piping may not match specifications. He criticized BPA's lack of transparency and responsiveness, and proposed a committee of the whole meeting to discuss dissolving the authority. Mayor Reynolds opposed dissolution, noting the authority's long-term debt and independent operation, but acknowledged some progress. Councilwoman Collins suggested concerns be raised at the parking authority's board meetings. - Snow Removal Enforcement: Councilwoman Daniels asked about property owners not clearing snow. Public Works Director Alcall stated that enforcement is complaint-based due to limited resources. Mayor Reynolds noted the balance between public safety and sensitivity to elderly or disabled homeowners. - HARB Quorum and Legal Standards: Solicitor Stewart clarified that HARB members serve until replaced, and that the board's recommendations are advisory. Council's role in reviewing certificates of appropriateness is limited to architectural features visible from public streets, not height or zoning issues. She also noted that considering the sale of land would be outside the scope of the review. Key Outcomes - Ordinances 8A-8I and 12-2026 (as amended): All passed unanimously (6-0). - Resolution 10B (Retired Officer Handgun Purchase): Passed 5-1, with Councilwoman Quietek voting nay. - Resolution 10D (COA for 33 West Walnut Street): Passed 5-1, with Councilman Callahan voting nay. The resolution approves a seven-story mixed-use building with 107 dwelling units and ground-floor commercial space. - Resolutions 10A, 10C, 10E, 10F: Passed unanimously (6-0). - Committee of the Whole: Council agreed to schedule a future committee of the whole meeting to discuss the Bethlehem Parking Authority, including bid transparency and responsiveness. - Fire Department Study: The previously approved study by the Center for Public Safety and Management will proceed; no further action was taken. - Snow Removal: The city will continue complaint-based enforcement, with no new proactive measures adopted.

The Bethlehem City Council held a regular meeting on February 4, 2026, beginning at approximately 7:00 PM. The meeting covered public comments on various topics, several communications and resolutions, and passage of multiple ordinances and resolutions. Councilwoman Laird was congratulated on the expansion of her family and will miss upcoming meetings. Consent Calendar - The council approved minutes and scheduled a public hearing for an intermunicipal liquor license transfer (Resolution 10E). - All ordinances and resolutions were voted on individually; no consent agenda was used. Public Comments & Testimony - Mike Garcia (South Side resident): Expressed concerns about immigration, respect for all opinions, opposition to transgender issues being promoted to children, criticism of the mayor's closed-door policy, and frustration with homelessness allowed at City Hall. He called for respect and understanding. - Alex Miller (80 Minocasi Street): Urged the council to end the city's contract with Flock Safety, citing issues with data sharing, lack of oversight, security vulnerabilities, and cooperation with ICE. He provided examples of Flock's camera data being exposed and used for mass surveillance, and expressed concern about ICE activity in the region. - Will Weber (66 West Elizabeth Avenue): Raised utility affordability concerns, recounting a story of a resident with a $420 electric bill. He urged the council to prioritize water smart meters with a protective app for consumers, referencing a successful program in Fairmont, West Virginia, and warned against installing meters without consumer protections. - Harry Faber: Spoke against injustice, ICE, and inaction by local government. He urged Bethlehem to be a leader in opposing fascism and called for legislation preventing local law enforcement from sharing information with ICE. He echoed support for Alex Miller's comments. - Bill Shire (1898 Avenue): Commented on snow removal inefficiencies, suggested more proactive snow hauling, criticized the planned seven-story parking garage ("the big white box") on Main Street as harming historic character, and expressed support for immigrants who are willing to work and follow laws. He also requested more public financial reporting from the Parking Authority. - Stephen Antalix (737 Ridge): Spoke on two occasions. In non-voting comment, he criticized the council's budget decisions that prioritized revenue over public safety, specifically the vote to not replace dismissed firemen and the hiring of code enforcement officers. He asked new council members how they would have voted on the firefighter issue. In voting comment, he opposed a resolution that would deny retired police officers the ability to purchase their duty firearms, arguing it was a tradition and an unfair burden. Discussion Items - Flock Safety Contract: Councilmember Callahan asked Police Chief Michelle Kott about the city's use of Flock. Chief Kott confirmed the city only uses Flock automated license plate readers, not cameras, and that the city owns and controls the data, which is not shared. The data is retained for approximately 90 days. Councilmember Callahan also noted attending a meeting of 400 concerned residents about immigration enforcement and the recent purchase of warehouses in Berks County. - Snow Removal and Water Main Breaks: Mayor reported that the city declared a snow emergency for the first time in five years (since February 2021). Public Works Director Michael Alcall and his team were thanked for their efforts. Water main breaks increased due to extreme cold, and crews worked overtime. - Firefighter Staffing: Councilmember Callahan expressed determination to find funding for four additional firefighters, citing forced overtime and overwork. He referenced a study to be conducted. The Business Administrator Eric Evans explained that each fund is self-sustaining and money cannot be transferred across funds without proper justification (Maximus study). The mayor confirmed that user fee revenue must stay within its fund. - Golf Course Profit: Councilmember noted a $700,000 profit above budget projections. Mr. Evans explained the funds stay in the golf course fund and are designated for the repair/replacement of a structurally unsafe barn at the recycling center. - Communications: Several items were presented: - 6A: Tree inventory contract with Arbor Pro Inc. ($96,750). - 6B: Purchase of duty weapon by retired police officer (Lieutenant Michael Deluzio). - 6C: Fire and EMS study by Center for Public Safety Management, LLC ($82,740). - 6D: Land surveying for Greenway parcels ($6,300). - 6E: Liquor license transfer from Easton to 217 Broadway, Bethlehem; public hearing scheduled for March 17, 2026. - Committee Reports: Finance committee met earlier and advanced 10 proposed budget adjustments (9A-9J) to the council for first reading. All were considered routine. Key Outcomes - Ordinance 8A (Uniform Construction Code): Passed 6-0, adopting the 2021 Pennsylvania Uniform Construction Code. - Ordinances 9A-9J (Budget adjustments for general fund, water fund, CDBG fund, and non-utility capital fund): Passed 6-0 as a group after discussion. - Resolution 10A (Tree inventory contract with Arbor Pro): Passed 6-0. - Resolution 10B (Police duty weapon transfer to retired officer): Passed 5-1, with Councilmember Quietek voting no. - Resolution 10C (Fire and EMS study contract): Passed 6-0. - Resolution 10D (Land surveying contract for Greenway): Passed 6-0. - Resolution 10E (Human resources records disposal): Passed 6-0. - Public Hearing Scheduled: For the liquor license transfer on Tuesday, March 17, 2026 at 7:00 PM.

The Bethlehem City Council Finance Committee held its first meeting of 2026 on February 3, 2026, to review and recommend approval of ten budgetary and grant-related items. The meeting, chaired by a committee member, featured presentations from department heads including the police chief, fire chief, health director, community and economic development director, water and sewer director, and the budget and finance director. All items were voted on as a group and recommended for approval to the full City Council. Discussion Items - Item 1: Year-End Adjustment and Carryover for 0901 Accounts – Mr. Evans explained that the adjustment reconciles actual usage from 9/30/2025 balances for three accounts: community recovery, homeless initiative, and affordable housing. Additionally, a separate downtown initiative account (0901-95012) had $150,000 added in September from accumulated savings, earmarked for Moravian University's World Heritage site coordinator. The funds were not spent by year-end, so the item moves the $150,000 into the 2026 budget. - Item 2: Carryover for Office Furniture – Funds to purchase office furniture for public works facilities (conference rooms) and the police department. Police Chief noted the furniture is for the records room and traffic bureau, with renovation ongoing. The total includes $35,000 for police furnishings. - Item 3: JAG Grant Rollover – A Justice Assistance Grant balance from 2025 is transferred to 2026. Chief noted the federal government has not released the 2025 or 2026 JAG grants yet; the 2024 grant funds must be spent by 2028. - Item 4: FM Global Insurance Grant – $5,000 grant to the fire department for IT upgrades, specifically to replace mobile data terminals with iPads and mounts, which are cheaper and more capable. The department is currently in the testing phase. - Item 5: Pipeline Emergency Response (PER) Grant – $55,455 from FEMA for combustible gas monitoring equipment used in pipeline and rail emergencies. This is a recurring grant but not awarded in consecutive years. - Item 6: Health Department Grants – Two items: a new maternal health initiative grant from the Pennsylvania Department of Health (new account created for temporary help and other costs), and a rollover of a workforce development grant for a communication plan and community health needs assessment. - Items 7 & 9: Emergency Solutions Grant (ESG) Amendments – Ms. Collins (CED) explained that the city administers ESG funds as a pass-through for seven nonprofits (homelessness prevention, street outreach, emergency shelter, rapid rehousing). An additional $150,000 was added at year-end for encampment clearing efforts, bringing the FY24 total to $559,000. A new FY25 ESG award of $400,000 is also being added. Item 7 is a $20,000 portion going to the health bureau (transferred to general fund). - Item 8: Water and Sewer Staffing Adjustment – A new maintenance support position in the water fund is created, offset by not filling a retired account clerk position in the sewer fund, making it head-count neutral. - Item 10: Non-Utility Capital Budget Adjustments – Ms. Lasarchik presented the annual reconciliation, adjusting $2 million in capital projects based on actual 12/31/2025 balances versus the 9/30/2025 estimates. Major adjustments included $777,000 for Friendship Park (not completed as expected) and $600,000 from police vehicle savings transferred to escrow. Controller Mr. Yasso noted that one small adjustment ($5,825 for East Broad Street corridor improvement) could not be verified through expenditure reports, but Ms. Lasarchik explained it related to a matching grant calculation (85% grant, 15% match) that was originally based on funding rather than total project cost. Key Outcomes - The committee unanimously voted (3-0) to consider all ten agenda items as a group. - A subsequent motion to recommend approval of all ten items to the full City Council passed (3-0). - The referenced legislative items will be placed on that evening's City Council agenda.

The Bethlehem City Council held its regular meeting on January 21, 2026. The meeting included citations honoring retiring members, public comments on various issues, a discussion on potential fees for university services and non-profit contributions, approval of multiple contracts and resolutions, and updates on the Bethlehem Co-op and greenway project. Citations and Roll Call - Council approved a citation honoring Lynn Rothman for her decade of service on the Environmental Advisory Council (EAC), including leadership on solar ordinance amendments and the climate action plan. - A citation for Charles Scripp for 30 years of service at the wastewater treatment plant was noted (absent). - Roll call: All seven council members present. Consent Calendar (Routine Approvals) - Approval of minutes from previous meeting (no discussion, passed). - Councilmanic appointments to Environmental Advisory Council: Megan Lysowski, Vibor Kumar, Mandy Tolino, and Steven Olzewski as chair. Approved 7-0. - Certificates of appropriateness for properties at 55 East Church St, 441 Linden St, and 443 Center St. Approved 7-0. Public Comments and Testimony - Keith Dow requested the city encourage Wind Creek to restore lighting on the steel stacks at the Bethlehem Steel site, calling it a cultural and heritage obligation. - Mark Weber spoke in support of downloadable water apps for smart meters, emphasizing early leak detection and financial relief for residents. He expressed concern about the lack of a timeline but voiced trust in council. - Mr. Shire complimented the city's snow removal efforts, noting improvements in clearing snow from around parked cars. - Mr. O'Hare criticized the Bethlehem Co-op for not opening after five years despite $3.105 million in public funds. He asked council to investigate and consider alternative uses for the space. - Hans Alex Stephen raised concerns about fire department staffing, citing a firefighter working a 15-hour shift and potential safety risks. He criticized council president's votes on firefighter replacement versus code enforcement hires, urging new council members to prioritize public safety. Discussion Items - Fire Department Calls to Universities and Non-Profit Contributions: Councilman Callahan requested data on fire calls to Lehigh University and off-campus student housing, suggesting a $50 fee per student. Fire Chief noted challenges in tracking off-campus calls but agreed to provide campus data. Mayor discussed the legal distinction between fees for services and illegal taxes, and mentioned state-level efforts to raise the local services tax (LST) from $52 to potentially $75-$100. Solicitor confirmed that municipalities can charge non-resident accident response fees (fire service recovery). Councilman Cologne requested historical minutes from 2012 regarding a PILOT (payment in lieu of taxes) resolution. - Steel Stacks Lighting: Council discussed broken lighting at Wind Creek (Sands). Mayor stated there is no contractual obligation for decorative lighting, but the city continues to push Wind Creek to honor community promises. Councilman Callahan noted that a local electrical firm fixed lights at minimal cost. Solicitor will review easement documents. - Snow Emergency Planning: Councilman Callahan asked about declaring a snow emergency for an upcoming storm. Mayor said no emergency has been declared in four years but the administration is monitoring conditions. - Bethlehem Co-op Update: In response to public comment, Mayor reported that the co-op is 97-98% complete, working to secure a refrigeration unit deposit, and that city staff meet regularly with the board. He stated the city has offered advice but cannot mandate actions. - New Street Greenway: Mayor announced a $250,000 DCNR grant for greenway construction near Comfort Suites. Project expected to proceed after hotel construction. - Lease Agreement with Bethlehem Tempo LLC (10I): Discussion focused on ensuring public access to the drop-off area for non-hotel guests and inclusion of bike racks. Councilwoman Laird requested a supplemental letter to clarify public use. Mayor and solicitor agreed that current lease does not prohibit public drop-off. Resolution passed 7-0. Key Outcomes - Resolution 10A: Approved contract with Lehigh Valley with Love Media for information officer services ($18,000/year, 2026-2029). Passed 7-0. - Resolution 10B: Approved agreement with CHA Consulting for engineering services at wastewater treatment plant ($66,700). Passed 6-0 with one abstention (council member recused). - Resolution 10C: Approved agreement with Collabo Planning and Design for choice neighborhoods grant application (up to $40,000). Passed 7-0. - Resolution 10D: Approved agreement with Colliers Engineering for boiler/efficiency study ($59,900). Passed 7-0. - Resolution 10E: Approved software support contract with Emerson Power and Water Solutions ($66,225.30/year, three years). Passed 7-0. - Resolution 10F: Approved wastewater rate study with Gannett Fleming ($19,000). Study will inform future sewer rate adjustments. Passed 7-0. - Resolution 10G & 10H: Approved intergovernmental agreements with Hanover Township and Fountain Hill for yard waste facility use (2026). Passed 7-0 each. - Resolution 10I: Approved 50-year lease with Bethlehem Tempo LLC for hotel driveway/drop-off area ($100,000 first 25 years, $4,000/year thereafter). Council added condition for public access and bike racks. Passed 7-0. - Resolution 10J: Approved contract with Michael Baker International for HUD funding technical assistance ($112,409, with renewal options). Passed 7-0. - Ordinance 8A: Final passage of 2026 general fund budget amendment. Passed 7-0. - Ordinance 9A: Adoption of 2021 Pennsylvania Uniform Construction Code. Passed 7-0. Next Steps - Council will hold ethics training on February 24, 2026. - Council President will hold "president hours" one hour before each regular council meeting. - Data on fire calls to universities to be compiled; legal research on cost recovery and PILOT to be continued. - Council to receive historical minutes on previous PILOT resolution from 2012.

The Bethlehem City Council held its annual reorganization meeting on January 6, 2026, to swear in new and returning members, elect council officers, and conduct final business of the outgoing council. The meeting included farewell citations for outgoing council members Grace Cramsey Smith (six years of service) and Kira Wilhelm (four years), a public comment period, approval of minutes, passage of ordinances and resolutions, and the election of a new council president and vice president. Farewell to Outgoing Council Members - Councilwoman Grace Cramsey Smith was honored for her service from 2019 to 2026, including as vice president, chair of public works and finance, and membership on multiple committees. Council members praised her dedication, advocacy (e.g., pet shop/puppy mill ordinance, LERTA work), and support during personal challenges. In her remarks, she urged future council to prioritize independent thinking, mutual respect, and recognition of council as an equal branch of government, cautioning against "one-man rule" and destructive mannerisms. - Councilwoman Kira Wilhelm was recognized for her service from 2022 to 2026, including chairing the Human Resources and Environmental Committee. Colleagues noted her careful research, effective communication, and constituent service. In her farewell, she thanked supporters and staff, gave advice to new and returning members (e.g., keep values clear, don't be afraid to agree or disagree), and expressed gratitude for the learning experience. Public Comments & Testimony - Pastor Timothy Smith offered a prayer for the city, asking for wisdom, unity, humility, and justice for leaders, particularly for the unhoused. - Mark Will Weber (66 West Elizabeth Avenue) advocated for protective water apps (e.g., Aquahawk, WaterSmart) to alert residents of leaks, criticizing the city's current monitoring as insufficient. He cited Fairmont, West Virginia, as an example and claimed the city water director's statements about monitoring were misleading. - Stephen Antalix (77 Ridge Avenue) criticized the outgoing council, giving grades (no A's, two B's, three C's, two F's), alleging that public input is ignored, and citing inadequate firefighter funding and poor preservation decisions. He also shared personal reflections on attending synagogue. - Mark Will Weber (second comment) thanked council for their service and acknowledged the heat they take, wishing them a happy 2026. Discussion Items - Old Business – Elevator Issues at Wallace Street Garage: Councilwoman Leon reported that Mayor claimed union workers were at fault for elevator failures, but union officials provided evidence that the general contractor ignored warnings from union workers, resulting in five inspection violations. She requested a public apology to union workers and follow-up to ensure violations are corrected. - Council President’s Annual Report: Outgoing President Cologne presented the 2025 annual report, highlighting Bethlehem's first full year as a UNESCO World Heritage site, the reopening of the Walnut Street Garage (517 spots, $27M), completion of the Greenway Trail gap, progress on Friendship Park, the 40/10 parks plan, Complete Streets plan (Broad Street redevelopment starting 2026), Linden Street two-way traffic restoration (expected March 2026), and affordable housing projects (Gateway on Fourth, new emergency shelter, Pembroke Marvine Village). Statistics: 24 regular meetings, 11 committee meetings, 20 hours of budget hearings, 57 ordinances passed, 188 resolutions passed. Key Outcomes - Approval of Minutes: Minutes from December 16, 2025, council meeting were approved (7-0). - Ordinance 9A (2026 Budget Amendment): Authorized transfer of $20,000 from revenue account to expense account for a grant writer for the Choice Neighborhood Implementation Grant application (joint with Bethlehem Housing Authority). Passed 7-0. - Resolution 10A (St. Luke’s Drug Testing Contract): Approved a three-year contract (Jan 1, 2026 – Dec 31, 2028) with St. Luke’s Hospital Occupational Medicine for DOT-regulated drug and alcohol testing at $7,000/year, with three renewal options. Passed 7-0. - Resolution 10B (Certificate of Appropriateness): Granted for 13 and 15 East Third Street to modify the existing sign band and storefronts. Passed 7-0. - Swearing-In of Officials: - George Yasso was sworn in as City Controller. - Justin Amon, Joe Daniels, Hillary Quaytech, and Rachel Leon were sworn in as City Council members. - Election of Council Officers: - President: Rachel Leon was elected 7-0. - Vice President: Colleen Laird was elected 4-3 over Hillary Quaytech. - Adjournment: The meeting concluded with a benediction (Shehecheyanu prayer) by Rabbi Michael Singer.

This final regular meeting of 2025 featured public testimony on multiple issues, an extended discussion on the clearing of a homeless encampment, and the adoption of the 2026 city budget by a 5‑2 vote. Council also approved several use‑permit resolutions unanimously. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes from the December 2, 2025 council meeting without discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - Angela Mitchell (430 Cherokee St.) raised concerns about lead in pipes for dialysis and cancer patients, asked for remote public comment options, and described alleged abuse and denial of dialysis treatment at St. Luke’s Hospital. - Evelyn Leon (East Fifth St.) thanked council members for their service and praised the leadership of Council President Colón and Vice President Leon. - Michael Liberto announced his candidacy for mayor, emphasizing second chances and community resilience. - Mark Will Weber (66 West Elizabeth Ave.) provided a list of over 100 cities that offer free water‑consumption apps (e.g., EyeOnWater, AquaHawk, WaterSmart) and urged Bethlehem to adopt a similar system. - Artie Curatola (813 Lafayette St.) discussed being banned from ArtsQuest and other venues, claiming anti‑Semitic accusations, and offered to speak to homeless individuals about wealth building. - Lou Jimenez (Local 735 president) argued that firefighter staffing decisions should not be deferred to collective bargaining, citing the NFPA standards and requesting a permanently assigned company officer at the Northwest Fire Station (currently covered by a roving officer). He noted the city recognizes NFPA standards for training but avoids them for staffing. - Terry Michel (56 East Gep St.) raised parking‑ticket inconsistencies and expressed opposition to any plan to convert Linden and Center streets to two‑way traffic, citing accident risks. - Dominic Trabasi criticized the clearing of a homeless encampment on Norfolk Southern property, arguing it forced relocation without guaranteeing safe alternatives and called for addressing housing needs. - Cheyenne Cahun (Easton) condemned the eviction, urging council to recognize housing as a human right and to act with compassion. - Lee (Bethlehem resident) described the scene of the December 15 clearing (16‑degree weather, no resources provided by the city or police), stating that only two volunteers helped move possessions hours later. - Valerie Noonan corroborated Lee’s account, noting that three volunteers arrived at 7:45 AM, helped one person move belongings two miles, and that six people’s items were moved in seven trips by a single pickup truck after 5 PM. - Steven Antonalix (737 Ridge) accused council of voting 5‑2 against restoring fire staff (four firefighters) for political reasons, calling some members “lapdogs” of the mayor. - Ms. Daniels expressed frustration that the fire department has not grown with the city, noting 32 new hires in three years but continued understaffing and reliance on overtime. - Kyle Dalton (Bethlehem firefighter) thanked council for their service. - Sebastian Zavaruka (811 Elm St.) echoed concerns about the encampment clearing, stating that displaced individuals have moved to other unsafe locations, some on city property. Discussion Items Homeless Encampment Clearing (Sand Island / Hill‑to‑Hill Bridge) - Mayor Reynolds, Miss Wenrick (Community Connections), and Miss Collins provided a detailed update: - 92 unique individuals were counted in the impacted areas over several months; 85% were successfully connected to at least one service (case management, drug/alcohol treatment, mental health, medical care). - Three “care events” were held at Sand Island to offer comprehensive services. - On December 15, the remaining 12 individuals were assisted: one was connected to Victory House shelter, two obtained single‑room occupancy units, and others received storage help or medical care. - The Mincy Trail area (estimated 5‑8 individuals) remains to be cleared later in the week (Dec. 18 or 19). - The city owns about 0.25 acres east of the Fahy Bridge; that small area was also posted due to safety concerns. - Council asked about regional solutions; Mayor Reynolds emphasized the need for county leadership, noting that 95% of Lehigh Valley land is in suburbs that contribute little to homelessness services. - Councilwoman Leon asked about housing options outside Bethlehem; some individuals were placed in Allentown or other locations. - Councilwoman Laird asked about environmental review of Norfolk Southern’s planned clearing; Mayor Reynolds stated the city has no jurisdiction over private‑property trees but is engaged on waterway impacts. - Public comments from Lee and Noonan contradicted the city’s account, stating no resources were provided on‑site and that volunteers handled all moving. City staff maintained that services were offered and that grant restrictions limited what could be done for those without a planned shelter destination. Water Bureau Technology & Customer Apps - Councilwoman Laird asked about providing a consumption‑monitoring app for smart meters. Director Boscola noted the city is vetting compatible platforms but emphasized the priority is expanding bill‑pay options (paperless, auto‑pay). He estimated a new platform could be ready by 2026 or 2027. Councilwoman Cramsey Smith pressed for a timeline, expressing disappointment. Fire Department Staffing - Councilwoman Cramsey Smith asked about using overtime to ensure a permanently assigned officer at the Northwest Fire Station. Chief Griffin confirmed that the station has lacked an assigned officer for about 20 years, though the chief has authority to authorize overtime. The mayor noted that overtime is funded from salary savings from mid‑year retirements. Councilwoman Cramsey Smith argued that with 32 new firefighters (less than three years’ experience), the need for on‑site supervision is critical. - Councilwoman Cramsey Smith also objected to a memo from the DCED director that she said falsely accused her of trying to cut nonprofit funding; she clarified her budget amendment would have used a small portion of the Community Recovery Fund temporarily and would have been reimbursed. Key Outcomes - 2026 Budget Adoption: All 11 budget ordinances (General Fund, Water, Sewer, Golf Course, Liquid Fuels, Capital Budgets, CDBG, Stormwater, and 2026 tax rate) passed 5‑2. Council members Callahan and Cramsey Smith voted “nay” on all items, citing inadequate fire department funding. Councilman Callahan noted that $331,000 (0.3% of the budget) would have funded four firefighters for the year, costing the average household $11.42. - Resolutions: Three use‑permit agreements (ArtsQuest for Peeps Fest fireworks, Touchstone Theatre for Parham Park, and K.O. Fulford Associates for East Allen well operation) and a certificate of appropriateness for an elevator addition at 38‑44 East Market St. were all approved 7‑0. - Next Meeting: The first meeting of 2026 will be a reorganization meeting on Monday, January 5, at 7 PM, where outgoing council members will be recognized and new members sworn in. - Directives: Council President Colón asked the administration to keep council updated on regional homelessness efforts and on the fire‑staffing RFP process. Councilwoman Laird requested a first‑quarter committee meeting to discuss water‑technology improvements.