Public Meetings - Erie, Pennsylvania

The Erie City Council held a regular meeting at 6:30 p.m., recessed for executive session, and reconvened at 6:54 p.m. The meeting featured a public hearing on a waterfront conditional use application for a 75,000-square-foot light manufacturing facility, followed by public comment on police accountability, ShotSpotter technology, and other community concerns. Council approved several ordinances including historic designations and funding for the ShotSpotter subscription by a 5-1 vote. Consent Calendar - Approval of minutes from the August 5, 2026 City Council meeting and bills for payment on August 21 and 28. (Unanimous) - Presentation from Renee Beckford regarding a repository sale at 739 East 8th Street; no action taken, information will be reviewed and voted on at a future meeting. Public Comments & Testimony Public Hearing: Waterfront Conditional Use (1318 East Lake Road) The hearing considered a proposal by Porter Consulting Engineers on behalf of Enterprise Development Center of Erie County and Nine Ships Company for a new 75,000-square-foot light manufacturing and office facility. Staff liaison Cooper Moore noted both the Design Review Committee and Planning Commission had recommended the project. Presenters Jake Yatsko and Ashley Porter described the site plan, landscaping buffers, lighting, and community outreach including two information sessions and a neighborhood watch meeting. A letter of support from Father Pascaro of St. Ann's Church was noted. Public testimony included: - Jeff Johnson (509 Hess Avenue): Expressed concerns about traffic, semi-truck idling, and wildlife disruption but praised the company’s transparency. He supported the project overall but requested attention to his property. - Fred A Tepfer: Raised concerns about non-native plantings, removal of mature trees, lack of bird-safe glass on large windows, and pedestrian crossing safety. - Bob Strasser (Lower East Side): Strongly supported the project, citing its potential for jobs, local hiring, and economic development. He noted the company’s willingness to work with the community. - Maria Chilevich: Asked whether the facility would include a data center (answered no) and about tax abatements (confirmed project would take advantage of available programs). - Ed Kissle (Erie County Coastal Zone Chairman): Requested an easement for a future trail and asked about water discharge and emissions. Council members questioned project representatives on jobs (currently over 100, aiming to double in 3–5 years), wages (union carpentry, welders, glazers), wildlife mitigation (fence repairs, no threatened species found), and native plant options. Dr. Titus emphasized the need to address wildlife displacement into nearby yards. General Public Comment Members of the public spoke on a range of issues: - Cindy Triver and Charlene Freeman: Described alleged abuse of Jeremiah Russell at Erie County Prison, calling for proof of life and intervention. - Michelle Dovershaw: Criticized proposed residency restrictions for public speakers, lack of transparency on the Community Trust Council, and police harassment of Black residents (citing McKimmer Jackson Jr.). She announced the Justice Recovery Project. - Mike Rentzel: Reported lack of police response to threats against his tenants and property, and requested a meeting with the police chief. - Fredda Tepfer: Urged voter registration (deadline Oct. 19), criticized a zoning hearing board denial letter issue, praised accessibility improvements, and raised concerns about conflicts of interest at Planning Commission. - Maria Chilevich: Criticized rising housing costs, the sports arena, bayfront development, and alleged links between local businesses and organized crime. - Dr. Clayton Bradshaw Middle and Michael Pascalny: Opposed renewal of the ShotSpotter subscription, citing studies showing inaccuracy, wrongful arrests, and disproportionate placement in communities of color. They urged council to reject the appropriation. - Bob Strasser: Defended police, arguing that most incidents could be avoided if citizens follow lawful commands. - Yana Chatfield: Questioned police hiring practices, criticized the PALS program for selectivity, and called for more youth programs and police accountability. - Jay Rodriguez: Opposed data centers, suggested reallocating some police funds to youth and community programs. - Andronny Foster Samuel (Erie High teacher): Spoke on behalf of former student Markeemra Jackson Jr., who was stopped and detained while walking; called for police accountability. Key Outcomes - Historic Designations: Ordinance 45-2026 (Former Foreman block) and Ordinance 46-2026 (William and Mary Spencer House) both passed 6-0. - Winter Supplies Funding: Ordinance 47-2026 appropriating $435,000 from the Liquid Fuels Fund for winter supplies passed 6-0. - ShotSpotter Subscription: Ordinance 48-2026 appropriating $280,000 from contributions for ShotSpotter passed 5-1, with Councilmember Titus voting no. Councilmembers Horton, Brzezinski, and Shaw spoke in favor, citing specific incidents solved with the technology and noting the funds came from businesses, not city taxes. - First Reading Ordinances: Ordinance 16629 (DCNR grant, $10,000), 16630 ($25,000), and 16631 (PHMC grant, $25,000) all passed 6-0 on first reading. - Outdoor Dining Easements: Resolutions authorizing easement agreements with J and M Group Inc. at 1013 and 1015 State Street both passed 6-0. - Waterfront Conditional Use: The public hearing was closed; council will vote on the application at a future meeting after further review. - Council Reports: Council members provided updates on community events, meetings, and public safety; Mayor gave updates on employee activities, Change.org civic dialogue, and the Mayor's Council on Community Safety and Trust.

This caucus session served as a preparatory meeting for the upcoming public hearing and regular council meeting. Council members reviewed agenda items, received updates on budget recommendations from PFM, and discussed waterfront development, property easements, and community benefit agreements. No formal votes were taken. Consent Calendar - Final passage items included an ordinance for historic designation and a budget item appropriating $280,000 from the police budget, with hopes of coverage from community partners. Council clarified the budget line item. - First reading items involved appropriation of funds, with no questions raised. - Old business: Two previously tabled items regarding an easement for McCoy's restaurant were discussed. The easement was originally four feet; McCoy's requested five feet from the building, which engineering confirmed meets ADA requirements for a five-foot pedestrian walkway. Council expressed comfort with the revised easement, and the items were pulled from the table for voting. Public Comments & Testimony - Mr. Kissel addressed the council regarding the Scott Motel waterfront development. He stated that the planning commission had voted on the second hotel deal, and that promised public amenities (seven pocket parks) were not included in the documents. He noted that the city accepted a $5 million grant for the first hotel, but the second hotel received $7.6 million in CRIS funding plus additional loans, with no binding community benefit agreements. He urged council to review the original grant agreement. - Councilor Horton responded, acknowledging the lack of return on investment and expressing concern that promises were not legally binding. Councilor Titus mentioned she attended the planning commission and advocated for benches, a four-way stop, and bird-friendly glass. Discussion Items - PFM Budget Recommendations Presentation: Mayor presented a three-tier plan from PFM to address the city's budget deficit. Short-term actions (already taken) included six position eliminations, community support for public safety, and departmental reviews, reducing the deficit by $3 million. Midterm actions (balance of 2026) include additional position eliminations via retirements and vacant positions, a likely tax increase in 2027, negotiated agreement with Erie Parking Authority, prescription drug/health insurance changes for management, and a potential pension obligation bond to trigger an MMO recalculation. Long-term items include modest annual tax increases, advocacy for local services tax removal, additional hotel tax, contract review, sale of Downing Golf Course, debt restructuring, exploring headcount reductions with unions, and home rule charter to adjust EIT rate. Councilors expressed concerns about the pension bond and tax increases, with Councilor Breneman noting it could be disingenuous given the pension fund's health. Councilor Horton requested PFM also examine the amusement tax collection and skill games legislation. Councilor Titus suggested considering a community benefit agreement for future developments. - Firehouse Historical Review Contract: Contract for environmental and design research to assess firehouses for historical designation, funded by a $50,000 grant, allowing access to additional capital improvement grants. - Ainsworth Field: Council discussed the field's condition (owned by school district) and ongoing efforts to support grant applications through an operating agreement. A support event is scheduled for Friday at 4 p.m. - Celebrate Erie Event: Councilors praised the police, public works, and event staff for a successful event, despite some issues with unprofessional security personnel and youth with nothing to do. Key Outcomes - Agenda items for final passage and first reading are set for the regular meeting. - The two tabled easement items will be voted on in the upcoming public meeting. - The mayor will add feedback on amusement tax and skill games to PFM's September presentation. - Council plans to invite the CRIS Authority for a study session to discuss community benefit agreements and waterfront development commitments. - An executive session was called before the public meeting to discuss updates. Upcoming Hearing - The 7:00 p.m. public hearing concerns a waterfront conditional use property that falls outside the bayfront jurisdiction, so special conditions cannot be imposed. A letter from Jeffrey Johnson about traffic patterns will be included in the record. Council will prepare a resolution for the next meeting.

The Clovis City Council met in regular session on the date noted, with Mayor Mounatua presiding and Councilmembers Ashbeck, Pascal, Bessinger, and Mayor Pro Tem Pierce present. The meeting included two proclamations, public comment, approval of the consent calendar, a budget presentation, council reports, and a closed session. Note: The raw transcript states the meeting was held "Monday, May 18th at 6.01 p.m."; the metadata date of August 5, 2026 is used per instructions. Presentations and Proclamations - National Public Works Week (May 17–23, 2026): Councilmember Bessinger read a proclamation declaring May 17–23, 2026 as National Public Works Week, themed "Rooted in Service, Powered by Community." A staff speaker representing the American Public Works Association, Clovis Public Utilities Department, and other city departments thanked the council and recognized public works employees. Councilmembers praised staff for their service and kindness. Events included a utilities employee appreciation barbecue on Wednesday at noon at the Clovis Corporation Yard and equipment displays at the farmers market on Friday. - Hot Rods Fresno / Central Valley Honor Flight: Councilmember Ashbeck read a proclamation honoring Hot Rods Fresno for raising $30,000 for Central Valley Honor Flight through the Watertower Car Show. Paul Leffler, speaking on behalf of Honor Flight, said the group raised $20,000 the previous year and exceeded expectations by 50%; the contribution will help reduce a waiting list of over 400 veterans. He invited the public to the next Welcome Home event on September 2. Consent Calendar - Items 2–12 were approved by a single motion with no items pulled. The motion carried unanimously (5 ayes). Public Comments & Testimony - Jeanette Georgner, a resident near Clovis High School, requested a formal review of recurring traffic congestion, overflow parking, and emergency access issues around the school. She described overflow parking on residential streets three to four times a week, vehicles encroaching on driveways and intersections, parking near fire hydrants, and lack of enforcement. She noted complaints to Clovis High administration, Clovis Police Department, neighborhood services, the fire marshal, and city engineering had not been resolved, and a police officer stated the school district has jurisdiction over some areas. She also mentioned a 2024 house fire and difficulty with fire apparatus access. The council directed Assistant City Manager Paul Armanderes to coordinate departments and connect with her. - Chris Seites, a Clovis resident and employee of Fresno County Economic Development Corporation, invited the council to the "Bear Breakfast" (Business Expansion, Attraction, Retention) on Tuesday, June 9, from 8:30–10:30 a.m. at the Clovis Veterans Memorial District, expecting about 150 attendees. Discussion Items - 2026-27 City of Clovis Annual Budget / Measure Y / Capital Improvement Program: City staff presented the proposed budget, noting the process began in December 2025 with department updates, followed by a Measure Y oversight committee report in January, a five-year forecast, and a council budget input session in March. Adoption is planned for June 1. Highlights included: - Maintaining and enhancing public safety with 141 sworn officers, construction of an alternate dispatch center, and accelerated fire staffing via a grant. - Continued Measure Y implementation with 21.5 new positions, with 90% of Measure Y focused on public safety. - Capital investments, including $250,000 for recreation center improvements and significant street improvements. - First increase in economic development staff in at least 20 years. - Fiscal stability with a 20% general fund reserve and flexible budgeting for uncertain economic conditions. A councilmember expressed appreciation for the Measure Y reporting structure and branding. The council voted unanimously to continue the budget review to June 1. Councilmember and City Manager Reports - City Manager: Announced the General Plan Advisory Committee meeting the following evening at the Clovis Transit Center, the Memorial Run on Saturday, a Planning Commission meeting on Thursday, May 28 regarding the "info rezone" program, and applications for the next round of Youth Commissioners. - Councilmember Bessinger: Reported on California Health Science University's medical school graduation with 171 graduates (about 130 medical students), the Clovis Flat Track Museum at 309 West Rialto, and Fresno State's veterans education program matriculation. - Councilmember Ashbeck: Asked to recognize the late Fresno County Supervisor Phil Larson and his community service. - Mayor Mounatua: Noted discussions with Cal State and Fresno State about reshaping university pathways for career changers and public safety, thanked Councilmember Bessinger for representing the council at the Lions Club, and praised the Clovis Culinary Center. Closed Session - The council adjourned at 8:44 p.m. to a closed session for one item: conference with real property negotiators regarding property at 260–272 North Minimaba Avenue, Lots 31 and 32. No action was anticipated. Key Outcomes - Approved consent calendar items 2–12 unanimously. - Directed staff to follow up with the resident on Clovis High School parking/traffic issues via Assistant City Manager Paul Armanderes. - Continued the 2026-27 budget to June 1st for adoption; motion carried unanimously. - Received proclamations for National Public Works Week and Hot Rods Fresno/Central Valley Honor Flight. - Moved to closed session on the real property negotiation item.

The Erie City Council held a caucus and regular meeting on July 17, 2026, at 6:30 PM. The meeting included a presentation on the One Bayfront planning process, several resolutions and ordinances, and extensive public comment on police accountability, budget priorities, and council conduct. Councilmember Brzezinski was absent during portions of the meeting, and the mayor was traveling, with Chief of Staff Lori Radder Spicer presenting. Public Comments & Testimony - Michelle Dovishaw criticized the city's transparency regarding the SPCP (Special Police Citizens' Board) and recounted incidents of racial profiling by police, including a traffic stop where a Black man was threatened with being dragged from his car for refusing a search. - Aaron Meisner thanked the Erie Police for their handling of a recent homicide but called for policy changes regarding use of force, referencing the Kevin Sparks case. He also urged the city to adopt policies from Albuquerque's DOJ consent decree, including bans on striking individuals with vehicles and requirements for medical care after force. - Rick Leablani demanded Councilmember Brzezinski's resignation, citing a prior incident of inappropriate comments, and stated that such behavior would not be tolerated in corporate or nonprofit settings. - A landlord (unnamed) described repeated harassment by a neighbor with a Confederate flag, property damage, and police inaction, saying low-income minority tenants were not protected. He was redirected to the District Attorney's office. - Mary Ann McDaniels Calesa raised concerns about foreclosure procedures, alleging that a Pittsburgh law firm used outdated deeds and that low-income homeowners were being intimidated. Councilor Horton explained that foreclosures are a county matter beyond the city's jurisdiction. - Rye Witherow questioned the council's responsiveness, noting that over 200 signatories on an ICE petition received no response from most councilors, and urged creation of a transparency policy. - Caleb Brechtston criticized the council's response to public comment at the previous meeting, called for action on the Kevin Sparks case, and opposed the city's pursuit of defense manufacturing contracts. - Dr. Clayton Bratt John Middle analyzed the 2026 city budget, noting the police department consumes nearly 40% of the general fund ($43.5M out of $112.6M) and argued for reallocating funds to social safety nets and arts programs. - Anthony Hazen warned that rising taxes and fees are making rental housing unaffordable and driving population decline. - Samantha Vodo condemned Councilmember Brzezinski's comments to a reporter and urged council members to speak up against inappropriate behavior. - Abigail Hanson read from The Serviceberry by Robin Wall Kimmerer, arguing that Lake Erie and the bayfront should remain public assets, not privatized for commercial development. - Michael Butskolny criticized the mayor's attendance at a defense innovation summit, linking it to genocide in Gaza, and questioned the role of Infinite Erie in promoting shipbuilding. - Dan Norrin called for addressing litter, potholes, and infrastructure, and suggested cutting the police budget. - A speaker (name not given) asked for clarification on Councilmember Brzezinski's absence and censure status, and urged the city to have Erie Waterworks claim a $14 billion PFAS settlement. - Cindy Triver challenged the Erie Police Department's training and policies, noting that the department lacks a use-of-force continuum and that 93% of departments nationwide have duty-to-intervene policies, while Erie's is lacking. She highlighted settlements in 11 of 15 notable incidents involving women, disabled persons, and Black individuals. - Dr. Donna (name possibly) sounded an alarm about toxic male culture and patriarchy in leadership and law enforcement. - Dan Brayman filed a formal complaint regarding the city's status as a welcoming city, citing the Kevin Sparks case and the use of deadly force tactics. - Deontay Coley questioned the absence of Councilmember Brzezinski and expressed concern about the upcoming crisis of gambling addiction when skill game machines are outlawed, predicting increased crime and substance abuse. - Julio Regis criticized inefficiencies at 8 Great Tuesdays events and urged the council to remove problematic individuals from organizations. - Jared Stascheski asked about Councilmember Brzezinski's censure and encouraged Erie Waterworks to claim PFAS settlement funds. Discussion Items - One Bayfront Update: Chief of Staff Lori Radder Spicer presented the community-driven planning process for the waterfront, covering the study area from Cranberry Street to the Erie Land Lighthouse, bounded by Third Street. The project timeline includes a virtual open house and survey (700+ responses), with a goal to produce a final plan by end of 2026. Council members emphasized the need for ongoing community engagement and accessibility. - Fire Engine Roof Replacement: The council discussed a change order for roof replacement at Fire Engine 10, originally approved for Engine 11. The cost increased from $76,250 to $87,936, with a further $1,967 for additional work, totaling $89,903. The change was due to different roof conditions. - Winter Maintenance Contract: The city renewed a PennDOT agreement for winter maintenance of 125 miles of state routes within Erie, with annual reimbursement between $400,000 and $500,000. - Public Safety Facility Phase II: A resolution authorized a $720,000 contract with HHSDR for design services for Phase II of the public safety facility. Councilmember Brzezinski voted no. - Historic Designation: The council approved the designation of the former William and Mary Spencer House at 519 West 6th Street as a historic building. - Council Conduct: Council President Titus addressed rules of decorum and the limits of censure, noting that only a motion and vote can censure a member for a single meeting. She stated that ordinances on Article 112 (rules of decorum) and a Citizens Review Board are under review with the solicitor, with care to comply with state preemption laws. Key Outcomes - Ordinances Passed: - Ordinance 42-2026: Appropriated $189,868 for the Insurance Fraud Prevention Authority grant. Passed 5-0-1 (Brzezinski abstained). - Ordinance 43-2026: Appropriated $405,899 for the Auto Theft Prevention Authority grant. Passed 6-0. - Ordinance 44-2026: Appropriated $500,000 for the Erie Center for Arts and Technology (ECAT) upgrades via RACP grant. Passed 6-0. - Resolutions Passed: - Historic designation for 519 West 6th Street. Passed 6-0. - Change order for Fire Engine 10 roof replacement (total $89,903). Passed 6-0. - New Business Resolutions: - Winter maintenance agreement with PennDOT approved (moved on consent). - Contract with HHSDR for Phase II design services ($720,000) approved 5-1 (Brzezinski opposed). - Appointments: Sarah Morrison and Janae Alexander were appointed to CAFE (announced for transparency). - Committee Reports: Councilors reported on various liaison meetings, including the Housing Authority, Blighted Property Review Board, Parking Authority, and Airport Authority. Councilor Shaw highlighted the upcoming America's Saturday festival and a community rebuild house project. Councilor Poll noted a blighted property redevelopment on West 7th Street. - Next Steps: The One Bayfront virtual open house closes July 17; parks plan comment period ends July 21. The council will continue reviewing ordinances on police accountability and decorum.

The Erie City Council convened on Wednesday, July 1, 2026, at 9 a.m. for a regularly scheduled meeting. The session included a presentation on a proposed workforce housing development, public hearings on two historic landmark designations, lengthy public comment periods addressing police brutality, media conduct, and systemic racism, and the passage of several ordinances and resolutions. Three council members were absent for portions of the meeting, leaving four members to vote. The meeting was adjourned at 12:26 p.m. Consent Calendar - Minutes and Bills: Approved minutes from the June 17, 2026, City Council meeting and bills for payment on July 3 and July 10, 2026. (Motion carried unanimously.) Public Comments & Testimony - Post Office Closure: Nick Pilato urged the council to draft a letter to senators and congressmen to reopen the South Erie post office, which has been closed since October. He also requested that mail sorting be returned to Erie, rather than being transported to Pittsburgh. - Media Conduct: Scott McDowell, corporate news director of Lily Broadcasting, reported that a reporter was verbally harassed after the last council meeting by a council member. He called for a code of conduct and expressed disappointment that the council member was not present. He stated that reporters will now record all interactions. - Police Brutality and Systemic Racism: Multiple speakers condemned the police treatment of Kevin Sparks, a Black man struck by a police SUV, tackled, and punched. Speakers included Michelle Dovishaw, Malcolm Pooleum, Jerry Roberts, Michael Pascal, Danielle Randall, Bishop John Crosby (uncle of Kevin Sparks), Aaron Meisner, Deontay Cooley, and others. They called for adoption of the Department of Justice excessive force policy, a civilian review board, firing of the involved officer, and systemic reform. Several speakers noted that July 2, 2026, marks the one-year anniversary of Marcello Woodard's death. - Housing and Climate: Susanna Faulkner urged proactive climate adaptation (cooling stations) and supported the rental ordinance. She expressed concern that workforce housing could lead to gentrification and displacement, referencing Pittsburgh's experience. - ECR SSA Concerns: Aaron Meisner and others questioned the funding and administration of the Erie County Re-entry Support Services Agency (ECR SSA), suggesting the program may not be sustainable. - Council Member Conduct: Multiple speakers, including Deanna Chatfield (age 17), criticized the absence and alleged misconduct of a council member, calling for accountability. Discussion Items - BEST Workforce Housing Presentation: Dr. Marcia Farrell, executive director of BEST, presented a conceptual plan for workforce housing at 6th and Parade Street. The proposal includes a 42-unit building (with possible commercial space) at 6th and Parade, and a 10-12 unit building at 6th and Wallace, totaling about 52 units. The project is in preliminary stages, requires rezoning from R2 to higher density, and would use LITEC funding. Council members expressed support, with Councilor Horton noting the historical context of the neighborhood and the responsibility of developers to rebuild after demolitions. BEST board chair Father Stephen Simon affirmed the project timeline of 18 months. - Historic Designation Public Hearings: - Foreman Block (1013-1015 State Street): Matthew Falcone, cultural resource manager, presented the nomination. The Historic Review Commission and Planning Commission recommended approval. No public testimony was offered. - William and Mary Spencer House (519 West 6th Street): Falcone presented the nomination. Councilor Horton requested additional information on whether the Spencer family had ties to slavery or the Civil War, citing the need for transparency. The public hearing was closed, and the resolution to designate was tabled by a vote of 4-0 pending further research. - America 250 Resolution: Councilor Poll sponsored a resolution commemorating the 250th anniversary of the United States. Councilor Horton and Councilor Shaw expressed opposition due to the nation's history of slavery and ongoing racial injustice. Councilor Titus initially voted no but changed to yes to ensure passage. The resolution passed 3-1. Key Outcomes - Ordinance 39-2026 (CDBG Funds): Appropriated $4,237.21 for a CDBG project. Passed 4-0. - Ordinance 40-2026 (Rental Registration Amendment): Amended Article 330 of the city code to update rental registration requirements. Passed 4-0. - Ordinance 41-2026 (Rental Housing Enforcement): Updated policies for noncompliance enforcement, ensuring landlord-tenant rights under federal, state, and local laws. Passed 4-0. - First Reading Ordinances: Appropriated funds for the 2026 Insurance Fraud Prevention Authority grant ($189,868), 2026-2027 Auto Theft Prevention Authority grant ($405,899), and upgrades to the Erie Center for Arts and Technology ($500,000). All passed 4-0. - ECR SSA Funding Resolution: Authorized an agreement with Erie County Re-entry Support Services Agency, allocating $65,000 in CDBG funds from FY24. Passed 4-0. - Spencer House Designation Tabled: Council voted 4-0 to table the resolution to designate the Spencer House as a historic building, pending additional historical research requested by Councilor Horton. - Council Liaison Changes: Council President Dr. Titus announced that she removed a council member from all liaison positions following the previous meeting's decorum issues, and reassigned them to herself. She stated that the action was taken privately to avoid perception of retaliation. - Mayor's Report: Mayor Devlin acknowledged the community's concerns, confirmed that the involved officer has not been suspended, and committed to reviewing the use-of-force policy against the DOJ model. She stated that the investigation into the Kevin Sparks incident is ongoing and that a report will be released, including any discipline or policy changes, but not all evidence. She also noted that the SPCP (Strengthening Police and Community Partnerships) board is being reconvened to determine the best tool for community oversight.

The Erie City Council met on July 1, 2026, for a caucus and public meeting that included final passage of three ordinances, a presentation on workforce housing, public hearings on historic designations, and extensive public comment. The most charged topic was an incident of police violence against Kevin Sparks, with multiple speakers demanding systemic reforms, adoption of a national use‑of‑force policy, and creation of a civilian review board. Council also debated and passed a resolution commemorating America’s 250th anniversary, tabled a historic designation for the Spencer House pending additional historical context, and approved the reallocation of CDBG funds to the Erie County Re‑entry Support Services Agency. Consent Calendar - Approved minutes from June 17, 2026, and bills for payment on July 3 and July 10, 2026. Public Comments & Testimony - Nick Pilato: Asked council to draft a letter to federal representatives urging reopening of the South Erie Post Office and return of mail sorting to Erie. He cited the closure’s impact on elderly and veterans. - Scott McDowell (Erie News Now): Condemned the conduct of a council member who sexually harassed a reporter after the previous meeting, calling for a code of conduct and recording of interactions. He expressed disappointment that the council member was absent. - Michelle Dovishaw: Questioned the timing of CDBG funding for ECRSSA, noting the county had not decided where to place the program. She urged the public to hold officials accountable. - Multiple BIPOC speakers (Malcolm William, Bishop John Crosby, Deontay Courley, and others): Expressed outrage at the video of Kevin Sparks being struck by a police vehicle, tackled, and repeatedly punched while on the ground. They described the incident as attempted murder, called for the officer’s firing, and demanded policy changes, including a civilian review board and adoption of the Department of Justice use‑of‑force policy. Speakers highlighted a long history of racial profiling and policing as an occupying force in Black neighborhoods. - Susanna Faulkner: Urged the city to move from reactive to proactive climate planning, support the rental ordinance, address police violence via policy reform, and hold elected officials accountable for misconduct. She also called for greater engagement with impacted communities. - Aaron Meisner: Questioned the ECRSSA program’s sustainability after a recent interview showed funding uncertainty. He urged adoption of a model use‑of‑force policy and asked for transparency in housing inspections. - Danielle Randall (mother of three Black boys): Described teaching her sons how to stay safe from police and argued that the officers in the Sparks video abandoned their training and should face termination and charges. - Julia Jacobs: Emphasized intersectionality, noting the lack of queer community support for Black-led protests, and called for systemic reform to policing and housing. - Deona Chatfield (17‑year‑old wrestler): Condemned the council member’s comments toward the reporter, calling them part of a culture of disrespect that enables sexual assault. Discussion Items - Presentation by BEST (Dr. Marcia Farrell & Rev. Stephen Simon): Proposed workforce housing at 6th and Parade (42 units) and 6th and Wallace (10‑12 units) on BEST‑owned land, with possible commercial space. Concept includes affordable and workforce units. Zoning changes needed. Council members expressed support, with Councilor Horton emphasizing responsible land ownership and transparency about the board’s composition. The mayor clarified that workforce housing is for lower‑wage workers, not luxury units. - Public Hearing – Foreman Block Historic Designation: Matthew Falcone presented the nomination for 1013–1015 State Street, noting HRC and Planning Commission support. No testimony from the public. Council had no questions. - Public Hearing – William & Mary Spencer House: Falcone presented the nomination for 519 West 6th Street. Council member Horton requested additional information about the Spencer family’s potential involvement in slavery before voting. Councilor Titus suggested tabling the related resolution to allow time for research. The public hearing was closed. - America 250 Resolution: Council debated the resolution commemorating the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence. Councilor Horton and Councilor Titus expressed opposition, citing the country’s history of racism and slavery, and noted they could not in good faith celebrate. Councilor Poll and Councilor Shaw spoke in favor of recognizing community contributions. After Horton agreed not to let it fail, the resolution passed 3‑1 (Horton, Poll, Shaw yes; Titus no). - ECRSSA Funding Resolution: Councilor Titus explained the resolution only reallocates FY2024 CDBG funds ($65,000) and does not guarantee future funding. Councilor Horton supported it as a reallocation, noting he had opposed the original day‑reporting center. The resolution passed 4‑0. - Liaison Reports & Caucus Discussion: Council reported on meetings of the Owen E. Pension Board, Port Authority, Housing Authority, and the SPCP. Council President Titus announced that due to conduct concerns, she had removed Councilor Brzezinski from all liaison positions. Mayor Devlin discussed efforts to relaunch the Strengthening Police and Community Partnerships (SPCP) board, the ongoing investigation into the Sparks incident, and plans to release a report. She also noted the officer involved has not been suspended but suggested reassignment could be considered. Key Outcomes - Final passage of ordinances: - Official Ordinance 39‑2026: Appropriated $4,237.21 in CDBG program income (passed 4‑0). - Official Ordinance 40‑2026: Amended the landlord/rental ordinance (Article 330) to allow a four‑year inspection cycle for properties that pass two clean inspections, and moved fee deadlines to July (passed 4‑0). - Official Ordinance 41‑2026: Updated enforcement of noncompliance policies (passed 4‑0). - First reading approved: - Ordinance 16621 (Insurance Fraud Prevention Authority grant, $189,868) - Ordinance 16622 (Auto Theft Prevention Authority grant, $405,899) - Ordinance 16623 (ECAT upgrades, $500,000) - Resolution on America 250: Passed 3‑1. - Resolution on ECRSSA funding: Passed 4‑0. - Resolution on Spencer House historic designation: Tabled 4‑0 pending further research on the family’s history. - Mayor’s announcement: The administration intends to issue a 90‑day notice to BIU to end the rental inspection portion of their contract, effective October 1, 2026. No council vote required. - Code of conduct: Council President Titus removed Councilor Brzezinski from all liaison positions due to inappropriate conduct. A proposed amendment to the code of decorum was circulated to council members. - Next steps: The police chief will meet with command staff to discuss the Sparks incident; a full report on the investigation and any disciplinary actions will be released. Council will review a model use‑of‑force policy and consider changes to the city’s current policy.

The Erie City Council met on June 19, 2026, for a caucus and regular meeting. The caucus covered proposed changes to landlord-tenant ordinances, the Bayfront master plan, and the parking authority. The regular meeting featured a record 58 public speakers, most addressing a transphobic comment made by a council member at the prior meeting. Council passed several ordinances and a resolution recognizing Juneteenth. Consent Calendar - Approved minutes of the June 9, 2026 meeting and bills under dates of June 19 and 26, 2026 (unanimous). Public Comments & Testimony - 58 individuals spoke, the highest number in three and a half years. The overwhelming majority condemned a council member (Ed Brzezinski) for intentionally misgendering Council President Titus at the previous meeting. Speakers called for his resignation, censure, removal from liaison assignments, and the creation of a formal decorum policy. Many expressed that the incident harmed LGBTQ+ residents, especially youth, and that silence from other council members was complicity. - Several speakers addressed the proposed rental inspection ordinance changes. Some landlord representatives opposed the fee increases and moving inspections in-house, arguing it would raise costs and that the city should work with the existing third-party inspector (BIU). Others supported stronger oversight, citing tenant safety concerns. - Additional speakers raised issues of police accountability, accessibility, Juneteenth, and redevelopment authority property damage. Discussion Items - Landlord and Rental Ordinance Amendments (Article 330): The administration and solicitor presented proposed changes: adding definitions from the Tenant Bill of Rights, reducing the inspection cycle from four years to two years for properties with positive inspections, increasing fees from $40 to $55, and requiring the Housing Authority to submit inspection reports to the city. The ordinance does not address the future of the BIU contract. Council clarified that changes would not take effect until 2027. - Enforcement of Noncompliance (Article 1503.5): Proposed amendment allowing notice of violations by regular mail in addition to certified mail, to aid in reaching unresponsive owners. - Parking Authority: Council members expressed frustration with the Parking Authority's lack of response to requests for a study session. The mayor's solicitor sent a letter and is working on a draft MOU. Councilor Horton urged preparing a court filing. - Bayfront Master Plan: The mayor announced a new planning process called "One Bayfront," led by consultant WSP, funded by Erie Insurance and Erie Community Foundation. A public survey and open house (June 25) are the first steps, with a final blueprint expected by end of 2026. - PFM Audit: The consultant is in town for management audits; department heads were cooperative. A full report is expected within a month. - ERCS SSA Program: The program will be moved from probation to the public defender's office. Council will discuss at the next caucus; some members expressed frustration over the time spent on a $65,000 item given a $12 million deficit. - Juneteenth Presentation: Councilman Troop gave a presentation on Juneteenth events in Erie, including a block party, panel discussion, and cruise. Council passed a resolution recognizing Juneteenth. Key Outcomes - Votes on Final Passage (all 7-0): - Ordinance 33-2026: Appropriating $254,061 for ESG26 projects. - Ordinance 34-2026: Appropriating $797,014.86 for HOME26 projects. - Ordinance 35-2026: Appropriating $2,909,512 ($2,914,512 with program income) for CDBG24 projects. - Ordinance 36-2026: Historic designation for Erie Label Temple (1701-1707 State St.). - Ordinance 37-2026: Historic designation for Erie Maennerchor Club (1607 State St.). - Ordinance 38-2026: Historic designation for South Erie Iron Works Building (1919 Peach St.). - Votes on First Reading (all 7-0): - Ordinance 16618: Appropriating $4,237.21 program income for CDBG24 projects. - Ordinance 16619: Amending Article 330 (landlord and rental) – fee increases, inspection frequency, definitions. - Ordinance 16620: Amending Article 1503.5 (enforcement of noncompliance) – allowing regular mail for notices. - Resolution: Recognized Juneteenth (June 19) as a day of historical significance; passed 7-0. - Appointments: Mayor announced reappointment of Sean Dugan to the Housing Authority and appointment of Andrea Carr to the Parking Authority (no council vote required). - Public Comment: Council President Titus acknowledged the record turnout and committed to focusing on integrity and accountability. Mayor Devlin apologized for not intervening immediately during the prior incident and pledged to work with the apartment association on inspection checklists. Note: The meeting date in the title follows the provided timestamp (2026-06-19), but the transcript indicates the roll call was on Wednesday, June 17, 2026. This discrepancy is unresolved.

A largely procedural meeting was overtaken by an unprecedented public response to a transphobic comment made by a council member at the previous meeting. 58 speakers, the most in recent memory, addressed the council over nearly four hours, calling for accountability, a decorum policy, and the resignation or censure of the offending councilor. The council also passed several routine appropriations, advanced a rental inspection ordinance on first reading, and unanimously adopted a Juneteenth resolution. Consent Calendar - Approval of the minutes from the June 9, 2026 meeting. - Approval of bills dated June 19 and June 26, 2026. (All passed unanimously, 7-0) Public Comments & Testimony - Rental Inspection Ordinances: Several landlords and members of the Apartment Association of Northwest PA spoke against the proposed changes to the rental registration and inspection program. They argued that moving inspections in-house would be costly, that the ordinances were rushed, and that the city should first negotiate improvements with the current third-party inspector (BIU). They requested more collaboration and a comprehensive plan. Some speakers supported the changes, citing poor housing conditions and the need for stronger enforcement. - Transphobic Incident (Majority of Speakers): A large majority of the 58 speakers condemned the actions of a council member who had intentionally misgendered Council President Dr. Titus at the previous meeting. Speakers described the act as bigoted, disrespectful, and harmful to the LGBTQ+ community. Many called for the council member’s resignation, a formal censure, removal from liaison assignments, and the creation of a clear code of decorum. Several speakers noted that the silence from other council members in the moment was complicit. A few speakers expressed support for the council member or urged unity, but the overwhelming sentiment was for accountability. - Other Issues: A few speakers raised concerns about park construction, police conduct, accessibility, and the importance of Juneteenth. Discussion Items - Ordinance 16619 (First Reading) – Rental Registration Amendments: The council heard a first reading of an ordinance amending Article 330 of the city code. The solicitor explained that changes include: moving definitions from a previous tenant bill of rights ordinance, reducing the inspection cycle for properties with good inspections from four years to two years, adjusting fees ($55, $100, $150), and requiring housing authorities and similar entities to submit annual inspection reports to the city’s Building Code Official (BCO) for equivalence review. The council clarified that this ordinance does not change the current contract with BIU or immediately implement in-house inspections. It passed 7-0 on first reading. - Ordinance 16620 (First Reading) – Enforcement of Non-Compliance: An ordinance updating policies and procedures for enforcing rental housing codes, with changes to notice delivery (adding regular mail as an option). Passed 7-0 on first reading. - Juneteenth Resolution: Councilman Troop sponsored a resolution recognizing June 19 as Juneteenth. Councilman Horton gave an impassioned speech linking the struggle for Black liberation to the LGBTQ+ community, noting that the council member’s remarks particularly harm black queer and trans people. The resolution passed unanimously (7-0). - Council President’s Remarks: Dr. Titus addressed the public, stating they felt embarrassed, humiliated, and angry after the incident but chose to focus on action. They reaffirmed commitment to reviewing council rules and procedures, and called for truth-telling and accountability. Key Outcomes - Votes: All consent calendar items and the final passage of five HUD appropriations (ESG, HOME, CDBG) and three historic designation ordinances were approved 7-0. - First Reading: Two rental inspection ordinances (16619 and 16620) were adopted on first reading 7-0. - Resolution: The Juneteenth resolution passed unanimously 7-0. - No Formal Action on Misconduct: No motion for censure, resignation, or removal was made during the meeting. Council President Titus indicated plans to review council rules and decorum policies. - Meeting Duration: The meeting began at 6:30 p.m. and concluded after 10:00 p.m., with a record 58 public speakers.

This study session, held on June 13, 2026, was dedicated to the presentation and discussion of the Comprehensive Recreation, Parks, and Open Space Plan, titled "Erie Outside." The plan, developed over more than a year by the city and consultant Design Workshop, outlines a roadmap for the future of Erie's parks, recreation, and public spaces, grounded in fiscal realities and community input. City council members and staff asked questions, offered comments, and discussed priorities, equity, and implementation. Discussion Items - Presentation Overview: Brenna Laffy from Design Workshop presented the plan's background, community engagement process, and key findings. The plan is organized around four themes: Stewardship & Maintenance, Access Belonging & Connectivity, Active & Vibrant Places, and Nature & Resilience. - Community Engagement: 613 survey respondents, 200 youth worksheets, 29 pop-up events, 100+ attendees at an open house, 4 focus groups, and 20+ stakeholder one-on-one meetings. The city intentionally went to where people were, rather than expecting them to come to meetings. - Park System Data: 50 parks, 350 acres, estimated $17-20 million in deferred maintenance. Only 3% of city land is dedicated to parks, compared to national median of 15%. Operating expenditure is $26 per resident vs. peer city average of $99 and national of $126. Staffing is 20.5 full-time equivalent positions vs. peer city average of 70+. - Access & Equity: 87% of residents have a park within a 10-minute walk (76% for city-owned parks). However, when considering quality, only 53% have a quality park within a 10-minute walk. An equity analysis showed that areas with higher poverty, less tree cover, and more brownfields also have lower park quality, particularly on the east side. - Prioritization Framework: Parks were scored on equity, quality, level of service, nature/resilience, and feasibility. Six parks were identified as Tier 1 for reinvestment, with 14 in Tier 2, 15 in Tier 3, and 17 in Tier 4. The plan is a flexible tool, not a rigid prescription. - Council Questions & Comments: - Councilmember Horton asked about converting underused lawn areas to native plants and reducing concrete (heat islands). Staff confirmed the plan includes converting underused lawns to natural landscapes. - Councilmember Horton also noted the lack of a centralized recreation facility (like Mill Creek) and suggested reimagining parks for athletics. The plan includes evaluating feasibility for indoor recreation facilities. - Councilmember Brzezinski questioned whether the plan recommends reducing the number of parks (e.g., repurposing some). Staff replied that the data can inform such decisions, but the plan does not prescribe removal. - Councilmember Titus highlighted that brownfield locations align with equity gaps, making the data useful for decision-making. - Councilmember Troop praised the plan and expressed optimism about Erie's future, noting that centralized athletic facilities could attract tourism, as Visit Erie and the Sports Commission indicated no tournaments locate in the city due to inadequate facilities. - Councilmember Flores (via comment) suggested using schools for youth engagement, as teens had many ideas about park usage. - Another councilmember (unidentified) emphasized the need for signage and proper conduct in parks. - Big Ideas Discussed: Reconnecting Erie to the waterfront, mobile recreation programs, a signature winter experience (e.g., ice skating ribbon), and cultural/historical trails with guided experiences. Key Outcomes - Public Comment Period: The draft plan will be published online for public comment from June 22 to July 21, 2026. - Adoption Timeline: Anticipated adoption by city council in August 2026. - Next Steps: The plan is a roadmap; implementation will require prioritization, partnerships, and diversified funding. An early implementation grant has been applied for to research park histories and cultural relevance. - No Votes Taken: This was a study session; no formal votes or decisions were made.