Public Meetings - Fargo, North Dakota

The Fargo City Commission held its regular meeting on Wednesday, January 8, 2025, at 5:00 PM in the Commission Chambers. The meeting covered a wide range of items including approval of consent agenda items, public hearings on a Renaissance Zone application and a zoning change, discussion on the future of the Fargo Civic Center, and resident comments. The meeting adjourned at 5:52 PM. Consent Calendar - Approved unanimously (5-0) all 32 consent agenda items, including: - Letter of Support for Small Wonders Preschool & Child Care Center. - Second reading and final adoption of ordinances rezoning properties in Hal Addition and Eagle Valley Fifth Addition. - Amendment to Fargo Municipal Code Section 8-0602 regarding starting, stopping, or turning signals. - Second Amendment to Findings of Fact for 909 4th Street North. - Amendment to Municipal Code sections 20-0403(C)(5)(e) and 20-0402(T)(3) to comply with a North Dakota Supreme Court decision. - Four games of chance applications (F5 Project, Fargo Air Museum, St. John Paul II Catholic Schools, and ND Elite Cheer Parents d/b/a NDECP). - Administrative penalties for liquor license violations: $500 fines for Buffalo Wild Wings (42nd St S), Rick’s Bar, Old Broadway, and Rhombus Guys; $750 fine for VFW (second violation). - Nine memoranda of offer for permanent easements (sidewalk) for Improvement District No. BR-25-B1. - Change Order No. 4 for $19,309.41 for Improvement District No. BR-24-B1. - Creation of Improvement District No. BR-25-F. - Negative Final Balancing Change Order No. 1 for -$89,350.42 for Project No. PR-24-F2. - Bid advertisements for Projects TN-24-A and SN-25-A. - Master Service Agreements for Electrical Services (RFP25017). - Items from the FAHR meeting (Sales Tax update, Fire Department budget rollover, broadcast display replacement piggyback purchase). - Contract with Bee Seen Gear for Fire Department service uniforms. - Purchase of Service Agreement with Cass Human Service Zone. - Notice of Grant Award Amendment for Ryan White Part B Program. - Health Savings Account Administrative Services Agreement with WEX. - Resolution approving Plat of Estes Addition. - Mass Transit Agreement with the City of West Fargo for 2025. - Bills in the amount of $8,159,535.58. Public Hearings - Renaissance Zone Application (Item 34): A public hearing was held for MBN Properties, LLC’s application for rehabilitation of the commercial building at 701 Main Avenue. The project involves $850,000 in interior rehabilitation with historic preservation tax credits. The current property value is $954,000. The Renaissance Zone Board unanimously approved the application. The Commission voted 4-1 (Strand nay) to approve the Renaissance Zone application and associated tax exemptions. Commissioner Strand expressed disappointment over the lack of public discourse before the city-owned historic property was sold by the Park District. All other commissioners supported the project for revitalizing a landmark building. - Zoning Change (Item 35): A public hearing was held for a zoning change to repeal and re-establish a C-O Conditional Overlay on Lot 1, Block 1 of The District of Fargo Fifth Addition (3788 55th Avenue South). The change allows the current sign code to regulate electronic messaging signs instead of the 2007 overlay. The Planning Commission recommended approval. The Commission voted 5-0 to approve the zoning change and 5-0 to approve first reading of the rezoning ordinance. Discussion Items - River Drive Shared Use Path Alignment (Item 33): Jeremy Gordon presented the recommended alignment for the path, which will run from Elm Street at 15th Avenue North to the cul-de-sac at Woodcrest Drive. The path is over a mile long with an estimated cost of $1.3 million, funded by federal funds and a local share split with the Fargo Park District. No special assessments are involved. The alignment was moved from 35 feet to 75 feet from rear property lines and lowered 8-9 feet in elevation to address neighbor privacy concerns. The path will be open during daylight hours and closed after dark. The Commission voted 5-0 to approve the alignment. Commissioners noted this is a long-awaited connection that may eventually link to Moorhead and beyond. - 2025 RFQ Process for Fargo Civic Center (Item 36): Mayor Mahoney initiated a discussion on issuing a Request for Qualifications to gather ideas from the public and developers for the future use of the Fargo Civic Center. The goal is to activate the space in the short to medium term. Commissioner Piepkorn opposed, citing a $7.5 million estimated cost for necessary infrastructure upgrades and stating the city is "over the fiscal cliff." Other commissioners supported seeking input to potentially generate revenue or repurpose the asset. The motion to direct staff to draft an RFQ for Commission consideration in late January/early February passed 4-1 (Piepkorn nay). - Liquor Control Board Appointment (Item 37): The Commission approved the appointment of Doyle to the Liquor Control Board with a 5-0 vote. - Property Tax Exemptions for Improvements (Item 38): The Commission approved 18 applications for 5-year property tax exemptions for residential improvements. The list includes properties on 28½ Ave S, 6th Ave N, 35th Ave S, 5th St S, Broadway N, 46th Ave S, Parkview Dr S, 1st St N, Parkview Dr S, 18th St S, 37½ Ave S, Meadowlark Lane, 38th Ave S, 2nd St N, 11th St S, Lilac Lane, 26th Ave N, and 4th St N. Approved 5-0. - Purchase Agreement with Galvanizers, Inc. (Item 41): The Commission approved a purchase agreement for the sale of a 10.84-acre industrial property in West Fargo to Galvanizers, Inc. The purchase price is $1,055,000 with an earnest money deposit of $100,000. The buyer is responsible for all subdivision work and entitlements with West Fargo. Approved 5-0. Key Outcomes - All consent agenda items approved unanimously (5-0). - River Drive Shared Use Path alignment approved unanimously (5-0). - Renaissance Zone application approved 4-1 (Commissioner Strand dissenting). - Zoning change for The District of Fargo Fifth Addition approved 5-0 for both the public hearing and first reading. - Civic Center RFQ process approved 4-1 (Commissioner Piepkorn dissenting). - Liquor Control Board appointment approved unanimously (5-0). - Property tax exemptions approved unanimously (5-0). - Purchase agreement with Galvanizers, Inc. approved unanimously (5-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Resident Comments: Andrew Hennessey spoke during the resident comment period. He noted that despite existing shelters, 50-100 people per night go without shelter in downtown Fargo. He praised Commissioner Strand’s winter warming program at the old police station but pointed out limitations such as no pets allowed and the inability to lie down on cots. Other Highlights - Mayor Mahoney read a proclamation reporting that $687 million in new construction occurred in Fargo in 2024, including 202 single-family homes, 38 twin homes or row houses, and 441 multifamily housing units. Largest projects: airport terminal ($94M), airport parking garage ($38M), downtown NP redevelopment ($49M), and others. - The City recognized bus driver Zachary Armstrong for administering Narcan to a passenger on December 26, 2024—the first time a bus driver used the overdose reversal spray. - Commissioners provided updates on their liaison assignments, including the Fargo Youth Initiative, warming center approaching 50 occupants, fentanyl awareness efforts, and an upcoming Martin Luther King Jr. Awards event on January 20. - Commissioner Piepkorn congratulated the NDSU Bison football team on their 18th national championship. - The meeting included thanks to outgoing staff member Shelley for her service. Meeting dates, times, and statistics are taken from the agenda, minutes, and transcript. Votes are as recorded in the minutes.

The Fargo City Commission met on December 23, 2024, for a regular meeting following an executive session on a property acquisition. The meeting featured a major unified presentation on homelessness from the FM Coalition and United Way, a public hearing and vote on a proposed camping ban sunset, and a discussion on transitioning the Downtown Engagement Center into a comprehensive Community Service Center. The commission also approved routine consent items, zone changes, a liquor license transfer, the Metropolitan Transportation Plan, and several appointments. Consent Calendar - Approved the Consent Agenda (Items 1-40), which included the first reading of an ordinance on traffic signals, license renewals for alcoholic beverages and live entertainment, gaming site authorizations, several bid awards (including a $543,559.25 three-axle truck and a $395,923.00 dual auto side load truck), grant acceptances (including $136,000.00 from the State Homeland Security Program), engineering contract amendments, intergovernmental agreements (with West Fargo, Cass County, and Oxbow), and bills totaling $16,204,928.77. Public Comments & Testimony - Olivia Fischer (Fargo Resident): Opposed the proposed sunset of the camping resolution, arguing it criminalizes homelessness and urging the commission to prioritize compassion and services over enforcement. She later spoke during the resident comment period, urging commissioners to pass a ceasefire resolution regarding the conflict in Gaza. - Matt Osborne (Downtown Condo Owner): Urged the commission to work collaboratively with state and federal representatives to secure funding for affordable housing and drug treatment, emphasizing that this is a community-wide issue that requires activating citizens. - Rocky Schneider (Downtown Community Partnership): Thanked the city for incremental progress on the camping issue, noted the importance of the 30/60/90-day plan, and urged the activation of riverfront trails to deter encampments and improve public safety. - Deb Frederickson (Fargo Resident): Voiced strong support for the proposed Community Service Center, stating that concentrating services in one facility would be more efficient than the current scattered approach. - Cheryl Bergian (Fargo Resident): Shared a personal family story about a member overcoming homelessness and addiction through a Housing First program in rural Minnesota. She expressed support for the city’s direction on homelessness and recommended allowing metro-area residents from outside Fargo city limits to speak during public comment. Discussion Items - Unified Homelessness Strategy (Item 41): Chandler Esslinger, Executive Director of the FM Coalition to End Homelessness, and Taylor Syvertson, Director of Community Impact for United Way of Cass-Clay, presented a metro-wide plan to address homelessness. They described the current homelessness response system as ‘overwhelmed,’ with shelters at or over capacity and unsheltered homelessness reaching crisis levels. They advocated for an evidence-based ‘Housing First’ strategy and a 30/60/90-day action plan focused on minimizing inflow, managing crisis, and maximizing outflow into permanent housing. They highlighted a 5-to-1 return on investment for prevention and diversion programs. Mayor Mahoney stated the city would transition to a ‘supportive role’ within this broader metro effort, and Commissioner Kolpack praised the collaborative, cross-sector approach. Commissioner Strand asked about relocation services; Esslinger confirmed the system reunifies individuals with family when appropriate but noted the vast majority of people experiencing homelessness are from the local region. - Public Hearings on Zone Changes (Items 42 & 43): The commission held public hearings for two zoning matters. (1) The HAL Addition, which consolidates lots and vacates an alley in the downtown area to allow for mixed-use redevelopment. Commissioner Piepkorn highlighted neighborhood support, the elimination of blight, the potential for lower-cost housing, and alignment with a nearby neighborhood school. The zoning change from DMU/MR-3/LC to DMU was unanimously approved. (2) The Eagle Valley Fifth Addition, which rezones a property from Limited Commercial with a Conditional Overlay to Single-Dwelling Residential (SR-5). Commissioners discussed the loss of potential neighborhood commercial amenities (e.g., coffee shops) but confirmed the change aligns with the 2024 Fargo Growth Plan. The zone change was unanimously approved. - Red Lobster Liquor License Transfer (Item 44): The commission approved the transfer of ownership for the Class “A” Alcoholic Beverage License for Red Lobster, located at 4215 13th Avenue South. Commissioner Piepkorn inquired about the market value of such licenses. - Metro COG Transportation Plan (Item 45): Michael Maddox, Senior Transportation Planner, presented the “Metro 2050” Metropolitan Transportation Plan. The plan sets a 20-25 year vision and introduces a context-sensitive approach to roadway design, balancing congestion relief with safety. The commission discussed the implications of Metro COG becoming a Transportation Management Area (TMA). The commission unanimously adopted a Resolution of Support for the plan. - Sunset of Camping on Public Property Resolution (Item 46): Mayor Mahoney proposed sun-setting the resolution prohibiting camping on public property and rights-of-way on March 23, 2025, a 90-day phased approach intended to provide time for a coordinated effort. He reported that the city is currently aware of 5 active camps, 6 people, 3 dogs, and 1 cat. Commissioner Strand noted the significant reduction in camps (from over 40 down to 5) and emphasized that there have been zero deaths among the unsheltered population during this period. Commissioner Kolpack thanked Team Fargo and community partners. The motion to sunset the resolution on the designated date passed unanimously (5-0). - Transitioning the Downtown Engagement Center to a Community Service Center (Item 47): Mayor Mahoney outlined a framework for a new centralized facility. It would combine the relocated engagement center, Gladys Ray Shelter services, a deflection center (to reduce police workload), and mental health providers (including Southeast Human Services). The preferred relocation area is outside the downtown core to improve efficiency. The estimated budget involves fundraising $2.5 to $3 million from private donors and $2.5 million from the city, potentially sourced from the sale of the current engagement center building and the old Fargo Cass Public Health building. The city is receiving guidance from Bloomberg Associates. Commissioner Piepkorn strongly dissented, stating the city has no additional funds for homelessness, cannot be the lead agency, and insisted all homeless services (including the Salvation Army) must move out of downtown to protect downtown redevelopment. Commissioner Strand supported exploring the framework further and suggested consolidating a list of all city assets for potential use. No formal vote was taken on this discussion item; it served as a framework for future work. - Appointments (Items 48 & 49): The commission unanimously approved appointments to the Renaissance Zone Authority, Historic Preservation Commission, Native American Commission, and the Fargo Youth Initiative, which reached full capacity for the first time in several years. - Extra Item - 2025 Meeting Calendar: The commission voted unanimously to move the January 6, 2025, meeting to Wednesday, January 8, 2025, at 5:00 p.m. due to the NDSU Bison playoff game. - Liaison Commissioner Updates (Item 50): Commissioner Strand promoted the upcoming Martin Luther King Jr. Awards event (Jan. 20). Commissioner Kolpack announced the winners of the City Hall holiday decoration contest, with Planning & Development taking first place. Key Outcomes - Approved Consent Agenda including routine finances, grants, permits, and contracts. - Received and Discussed the Unified Homelessness Strategy, with the city committing to a supportive role alongside the FM Coalition and United Way. - Approved the HAL Addition and Eagle Valley Fifth Addition zoning changes. - Approved the Red Lobster Class “A” Alcoholic Beverage License transfer. - Adopted a Resolution of Support for the Metro COG Metropolitan Transportation Plan (Metro 2050). - Voted (5-0) to Sunset the resolution banning camping on public property on March 23, 2025. - Discussed the framework for the new Community Service Center; no formal action was taken. - Approved appointments to the Renaissance Zone Authority, Historic Preservation Commission, Native American Commission, and Fargo Youth Initiative. - Approved an amendment to the 2025 meeting calendar, moving the January 6 meeting to January 8.

The Fargo City Commission met at 5:00 p.m. on Monday, December 9, 2024, in Commission Chambers at City Hall, with Mayor Mahoney presiding. All five commissioners were present. The meeting covered a 53-item agenda including consent items, public hearings, tax abatements, capital improvement planning, a special assessment deferral, a new homelessness proposal (Operation Safe Fargo), and numerous routine approvals. Consent Calendar - Commissioners unanimously approved the Consent Agenda, which included 39 items such as: an Interest Buydown Agreement with the Bank of North Dakota for three properties; Right-to-Sell agreements for city property west of the landfill; tax abatement recommendations for Park Ridge Apartments; an ordinance amending traffic signal requirements; second reading and final adoption of a 0.25% public safety sales tax; site authorization for Fargo Youth Hockey Association; utility easements; developer agreements; change orders; bid advertisements; budgets and allocations from the Fargo-Moorhead Convention & Visitors Bureau; a mutual aid agreement between Fargo and West Fargo Fire Departments; agreements with Richland County Family Planning; employment policy revisions; plat approvals; firearm disposition agreements; equipment purchases via cooperative agreements; security services bid award; transit cost allocation; change orders; Red River Valley Water Supply Project commitments; and bills totaling $14,319,862.98. Public Comments & Testimony - Victoria Johnson (Families United for Self-Empowerment) opposed placing the Community Integration Facilitator position within city government, arguing it would be more effective in the school district, Global Refugee, or other community organizations. She cited the failed DEI position and urged the commission not to compare Fargo to Grand Forks or Bismarck. - Brian Albertson (City Center Lofts resident and advocate for the Renaissance Zone) spoke in support of the program and asked about potential changes to 5-year vs. 8-year incentives, noting that the program encouraged him to buy a condo. - Kurt Bowman (CFO, County 20 Storage & Transfer) requested tax abatement for six industrial properties, arguing that comparable new construction costs were lower than current assessed values and that the city’s comparisons to recently sold concrete buildings were unfair. - Blake Carlson (representing LH Broadway LLC) requested tax reductions for two downtown properties, noting the combined purchase price was 23% below assessed value. - Austin Morris (Enclave Companies) requested a three-year interest-bearing deferral of special assessments for industrial land, stating it was needed to remain competitive with other communities (e.g., Sioux Falls) where no special assessments apply. - Asher Lorenzen denounced Operation Safe Fargo as punitive and dangerous, claiming it would defund winter warming, sell the Downtown Engagement Center, and impose ID/sobriety requirements that would lead to deaths. - Alison Slavic (Fargo resident) opposed Operation Safe Fargo, citing research on low-barrier shelters and the importance of the Downtown Engagement Center. She urged a Housing First approach and requested an update on the previously approved housing-first plan. - Matt Osborne (downtown condo owner) urged immediate action to get people off the river but stressed the need for mental health and addiction services and affordable housing funding from the state. - Doug Charbonneau (Fargo resident) supported Operation Safe Fargo, arguing that current policies have failed, crime is rising, and law enforcement resources are strained. He cited personal experiences with crimes committed by homeless individuals. - Angie Feckner (Fargo resident and part-time Palm Springs resident) supported Operation Safe Fargo, explaining that 80% of homeless in Palm Springs were from elsewhere and that voluntary bus tickets helped reunite families. She emphasized the need to start somewhere. - Rocky Schneider (Downtown Community Partnership) thanked Commissioner Turnberg for bringing forward a solution but said the proposal needed more refinement. He encouraged collaboration with experts. - Denise Vanderbusch (President, Open Door 65) spoke against a one-size-fits-all approach, noting that many homeless have trauma, mental illness, or PTSD and that some cannot be inside. She invited commissioners to visit her thrift store to hear personal stories. - Olivia Fisher (Fargo resident) criticized Operation Safe Fargo as a waste of time, stating it violates the recently passed camping resolution and disregards best practices. She argued that the proposal does not include any actual mental health or addiction services. - Cheryl Bergian (Fargo resident) spoke against ending the needle exchange program, urging compassion for those with addiction as a chronic disease. - Jessie Azure (likely a resident) provided an update on efforts to help Stand (a facility) find a new location and urged ordinance changes to prevent similar neighborhood impacts. Discussion Items - Community Integration Facilitator (Item 40) – Commissioner Kolpack proposed hiring a facilitator, 100% reimbursed by the state, to coordinate refugee and new American integration. Victoria Johnson spoke against hosting it at city hall. Several commissioners expressed concerns about cost, overlap with DEI, and lack of stakeholder input. A motion to delay two months passed 4-1 (Strand opposed). - Coneflower Farmhouse Renaissance Zone Project (Item 41) – A mixed-use rehabilitation project at 13-15 8th St S with $727,000 in improvements, exceeding investment thresholds. Unanimously approved. - Renaissance Zone Development Plan Update (Item 42) – Staff presented the 2024 plan update, adding two blocks and extending the zone for five more years. Discussion included potential 8-year incentives. Unanimously approved. - MATBUS Route Changes (Item 43) – Permanently eliminating Route 32 and replacing it with additional on-demand service for NDSU students, effective January 6, 2025. Unanimously approved. - Tax Abatements (Items 44-46) – - Item 44: Approved reduction for a misgraded residence (2022-2024). - Item 45: Denied abatements for Sky Logistics/County 20 properties, finding values supported by recent sales. - Item 46: Denied abatement for 406 Broadway but approved reduction for 412 Broadway to $621,000. - 2025 Capital Improvement Plan & Related Projects (Item 47) – Approved the $98 million CIP, 2026 Core Neighborhood and Prairie Dog projects, and updated infrastructure funding policy (caps increased from 2% to 5% annually). Unanimous. - Special Assessment Deferral – Enclave Companies (Item 48) – Requested a three-year interest-bearing deferral for industrial land assessments. Denied 4-1 (Piepkorn dissenting). - Operation Safe Fargo (Item 49) – Commissioner Turnberg proposed immediate measures: emergency shelter, banned camping after May 1, 2025, relocation of Downtown Engagement Center services to Cass County Public Health, and bus tickets for those wishing to leave. Public testimony was sharply divided. The motion failed 3-2 (Turnberg and Piepkorn in favor; Kolpack, Strand, Mahoney opposed). Commissioners Strand and Mahoney indicated a more comprehensive plan from the FM Coalition to End Homelessness would be presented at the December 23 meeting. - Civil Service Commission Appointment (Item 50) – Unanimously appointed Kelsey Roseth. - Property Tax Exemptions for Improvements (Item 51) – Approved 16 applications for five-year exemptions on residential improvements. - Liaison Reports (Item 52) – Commissioner Turnberg reported that the Fargo Public Library is on track for record circulation (nearly 980,000 items through November) and program attendance (over 39,000). Commissioner Kolpack recognized Fire Chief Dirksen for a FEMA commendation for his leadership on the Region 8 Advisory Council. Key Outcomes - Delayed Community Integration Facilitator – Motion to delay hiring for two months passed 4-1 (Strand opposed). - Approved Renaissance Zone Projects – Both the Coneflower Farmhouse project and the five-year plan update were approved unanimously. - Approved MATBUS Route Changes – Permanent elimination of Route 32 and addition of on-demand service, effective January 6, 2025. - Tax Abatement Decisions – - Approved reduction for Kenai Holdings property (parcels at Cattail Cove) for 2022-2024. - Denied abatement for six Sky Logistics/County 20 properties. - Denied abatement for 406 Broadway; approved reduction for 412 Broadway to $621,000. - Approved 2025 CIP and Policy Update – Adopted $98 million capital improvement plan, 2026 reconstruction projects, and increased annual cap escalation from 2% to 5%. - Denied Special Assessment Deferral – Enclave Companies’ request denied 4-1. - Failed Operation Safe Fargo – Motion defeated 3-2; a broader plan is expected December 23. - Appointed Kelsey Roseth to the Civil Service Commission. - Approved 16 property tax exemptions for improvements. - Commended Fire Chief Dirksen for FEMA recognition. - Acknowledged library successes – Record circulation and high program attendance. The meeting adjourned at 7:19 p.m.

The Fargo City Commission met on Monday, November 25, 2024, at 4:00 p.m. in the Commission Chambers. The meeting included an executive session (4:07–4:51 p.m.) for negotiation strategy regarding the sale of city property west of the landfill, followed by a public session that adjourned at 6:40 p.m. Commissioners voted on several key items, including a new public safety sales tax, liquor license transfers, the elimination of the virtual call-in option for resident comments, and a motion to end the needle exchange program. Consent Calendar - Approved the consent agenda unanimously, which included 33 items: final adoption of a littering ordinance amendment; property damage settlement for the Water Treatment Plant; games of chance applications (Muscular Dystrophy Association, Pray for Gray); liquor license suspension agreement with Cairo Restaurant; direction to revise municipal code sections on alcohol sales; bid awards for traffic signal bollards, uniform rental services, fire department uniforms, and sanitation projects; numerous change orders, easement memoranda, and grant acceptance; and authorization to revise food and lodging establishment ordinances. Public Comments & Testimony - Virtual Call-in Option (Item 38): Four residents spoke against eliminating the virtual call-in option. KJ Atkinson argued the proposal was based on a factually incorrect premise about COVID, would be classist and discriminatory by only allowing property or business owners to call in, and would violate ADA accommodations. Andrew Nelson called in to say the option is a matter of fairness for residents with work, mobility, or health constraints. Allison Slavik expressed frustration that the agenda order was not followed, preventing her from speaking on this item earlier. Olivia Fischer, calling from her job, criticized commissioners who described the downtown engagement center as a “crap hole” and argued the removal of virtual comment would limit participation. - Winter Warming Update (Item 39): Allison Slavik spoke in support of the winter warming center, emphasizing life-threatening North Dakota winters and criticizing commissioners for derogatory comments about unhoused people and the engagement center. Olivia Fischer also spoke in support, arguing that moving the winter warming center away from downtown is insufficient and that commissioners have shown disdain for the homeless population, citing a commissioner’s comment about needing a handgun for safety. - Needle Exchange Program (Item 40): Asher Lorentzen opposed ending the program, citing CDC research that syringe services are safe, effective, cost-saving, and do not increase drug use or crime. He accused commissioners of neglecting public health advice. - Resident Comments (Item 42): Five downtown residents spoke about safety concerns. Mary Dewald described feeling unsafe due to encampments, public urination, and intimidation. Matt Osborne urged immediate action to find temporary indoor shelter, calling homelessness an emergency. Mariela Kirk reported finding people sleeping in her building entryway, theft, and unsafe river paths. Jordan Iverson described changing her running routes, carrying pepper spray and a handgun, and recounting an incident where a man banged on her window; she has had her condo for sale since April 2023. Michelle Hagen criticized the camping ordinance enforcement, noting garbage and tents not meeting resolution requirements, and urged corrections before spring. Discussion Items - Listing Price for City Property West of Landfill (Executive Session): Following executive session, Commissioner Turnberg moved to set the listing price at $2.65 per square foot for the southeastern two to five acres of City property west of the landfill. The motion passed unanimously. - Citizens Group Request for Ballot Language Consultation (Item 34): Commissioner Strand moved to direct the City Attorney to consult with a citizens group seeking to develop ballot language to change the form of government to a city council system. The motion failed for lack of a second. Commissioner Strand noted he wanted to see results from the upcoming Zencity survey first. - First Reading of Public Safety Sales Tax Ordinance (Item 37): City Attorney Ian McLean explained that voters approved a 0.25% sales tax for public safety on November 5. The ordinance implements the tax from April 1, 2025 to March 30, 2045, estimated to generate over $8.5 million annually (based on 2023 figures) for police and fire operations, equipment, and buildings. Commissioner Kolpack noted transparency in the annual allocation process. The motion to approve first reading passed unanimously. - Virtual Call-in Option for Resident Comments (Item 38): Commissioner Turnberg moved to eliminate the virtual call-in option, calling it a “remnant of COVID” and a “lazy way of avoiding the meetings.” Commissioner Strand proposed an amendment to refer the matter to the Governance Policy Review Committee for further discussion. After debate, the amendment passed 3-2 (Kolpack, Strand, Mahoney aye; Piepkorn, Turnberg nay), thereby tabling the main motion. - Winter Warming Update (Item 39): Fargo Cass Public Health Director Jenn Faul and Assistant City Administrator Brenda Derrig presented an update. Last winter (2023–2024), the program had 8,096 encounters with 698 unique individuals, 86 successful diversions, and an average stay of 8 nights. For the current season, a soft opening at the downtown engagement center housed 41 people Friday, 38 Saturday, and 39 Sunday. The winter warming center will move to 1230 25th Street South (the old police substation) on Tuesday evening, offering seated warming (not cots). Brenda Derrig reported that since September 11, 2024, 41 active and abandoned camps have been removed with no citations or arrests; cleanup used 210 public works staff and 47 police staff over 10 weeks, totaling 520+ staff hours. Discussion included the need for housing first, potential for port-a-potties and trash receptacles, and comparisons to successful programs in Tampa. Commissioners agreed on the goal of housing first but debated funding and partnership models. - Needle Exchange Program (Item 40): Commissioner Turnberg moved to end the needle exchange program immediately, arguing it provides tools for illegal drug use and creates public safety hazards with discarded syringes. Public Health Director Jenn Faul and Prevention Coordinator Robin Lickiss presented data: the program opened in April 2018; since then, hepatitis C rates in Cass County dropped 46% from 2017–2019; 397 lives saved via naloxone this year; 433 referrals to treatment; opioid overdose deaths fell from 31 in 2023 to 17 year-to-date in 2024. Ms. Lickiss noted that comprehensive syringe service programs reduce HIV and hepatitis C transmission by 50%, save $1,300–$3,000 per person per year, and do not increase drug use or crime. The program costs about $100,000 annually, funded by opioid settlement money. Commissioner Kolpack argued the program enables getting people into treatment and saves lives. The motion to end the program failed 2-3 (Piepkorn and Turnberg aye; Kolpack, Strand, Mahoney nay). Key Outcomes - Executive Session – Property Listing Price: Unanimously approved listing price of $2.65/sq ft for SE 2–5 acres west of landfill. - Public Safety Sales Tax Ordinance – First Reading: Passed unanimously; will be implemented by April 1, 2025 if second reading is approved. - Resident Comments Virtual Option: Motion to eliminate was tabled; referred to Governance Policy Review Committee for further discussion. - Liquor License Approvals: Ownership change for Fort Noks (Vault Partners) approved 4-1 (Strand dissenting); transfer for Baymont Inn & Suites approved unanimously. Both included public hearings. - Winter Warming Update: Ongoing; winter warming center opened this weekend; new location at 1230 25th Street South; staff to continue exploring housing-first approaches and potential partnerships. - Needle Exchange Program: Motion to eliminate failed 2-3; program continues with opioid settlement funding. - Consent Agenda: All 33 items approved unanimously. - Citizens Group Request: Motion for city attorney consultation failed for lack of second; group to proceed independently. - Liaison Reports: Commissioner Kolpack reported on Fire Department honors and Churches United funding extension through December 30; encouraged community donations.

The Fargo City Commission held its regular meeting on Tuesday, November 12, 2024, at 5:00 PM in the Commission Chambers, with Mayor Mahoney presiding. Commissioners Kolpack, Turnberg, and Mahoney were present; Commissioner Piepkorn was absent; and Commissioner Strand participated via phone. The meeting covered consent items, a legislative session preview, a continued public hearing for an alcohol license, a construction update, approvals for federal aid transportation projects, and resident comments on homelessness and transgender safety. Consent Calendar - Approved the consent agenda (items 1–35) unanimously. Key items included: - Letter of support for the RKAK Project to the ND Opportunity Fund Consortium. - First reading of an ordinance on littering by contractors. - Final adoption of annexation and rezoning ordinances. - Receipt and filing of an inmate grievance. - Appeal of a district court decision regarding the Windbreak Saloon. - Multiple games of chance raffle applications. - Developer agreement with Lepine Holdings for MLTB Addition. - Stockpile storage agreement with the Fred M. Hector Revocable Trust. - Negative final balancing change orders for projects PR-24-C1 and SR-24-B1. - Change order time extension for project TR-23-A1. - Permanent easements and terminations. - Bid awards: Master Construction Co. ($3,403,624.90) for BR-25-A1 and Border States Paving ($13,300,910.09) for FP-19-A4. - Cleaning services contract with Osgood Cleaning Services. - Items from the FAHR meeting: sales tax update, benefit fair donation, ARPA fund closure, grant awards, police academy overfill, scrap meter liquidation, and commercial real estate advisory agreement. - Environmental health services MOU with West Fargo and Region V LPHU MOU. - Contract with American Lung Association. - Dangerous building amendment at 1011/1013 University Drive North. - Authorization to apply for IIJA grants. - Plat approval for MLTB Addition. - Direction to draft revisions to FMC Section 8-0602. - Task order with Stantec ($83,535) for solid waste permit modification. - Resolutions setting water, sewer, and storm water rates. - Amendments to water and sewer agreements with West Fargo and Cass Rural Water. - Amendment of bond resolution for $98 million Sales Tax and Water Revenue Bond. - Resolutions for Clean Water/Safe Drinking Water Act loan applications. - Change orders for projects WW1707 and WW1701. - Bills in the amount of $15,356,174.81. Public Comments & Testimony - Matt Osborne (downtown condo owner): Expressed urgency for implementing plans to address homelessness, citing 26 tents in encampments along the river. He raised concerns about safety and cleanliness downtown, stating the situation is "getting almost out of control." - Asher Lorentzen: Criticized Commissioner Piepkorn’s past statements about fearing for safety downtown, offering to walk with him. He noted that no portable toilets had been provided for the homeless encampments and asked the city to install at least one. He emphasized the safety needs of homeless individuals, especially with approaching winter. - Zara Crystal (transgender resident): Asked what the city plans to do to protect transgender residents in light of anticipated anti-transgender legislation at state and federal levels. She expressed fear of increased violence and loss of rights. Discussion Items - Presentation on 2025 Legislative Session: - Terry Effertz (Integrity Public Affairs) summarized election results, including the defeat of Measure 4 (property tax measure) and the shift in legislative makeup. She noted $500 property tax relief had 92% participation; expanding it is a likely topic. - Effertz outlined Fargo’s legislative priorities: affordable housing, traffic issues, infrastructure funding (airport, water projects), and cemetery funding. Commissioner Strand added daycare, behavioral health, and homelessness as critical areas needing state support. Mayor Mahoney urged monitoring social issues where Fargo bears a disproportionate burden. - Commissioner Kolpack requested continued monitoring of the homestead tax credit. Commissioner Strand asked for a focus on tax incentives for new home construction (expand to 5 years). Effertz will provide a halftime report and final session recap. - Construction Update: - City Engineer Tom Knakmuhs reported no safety incidents on city projects. Many 2024 projects are complete, including Woodcrest Drive North, 32nd Avenue widening, 1st Avenue South reconstruction, NP Avenue mill/overlay, and shared-use paths. Ongoing projects (storm lift stations, drainage repairs) will finish in 2025. Commissioners praised timely completion. - Federal Aid Transportation Alternatives (2028-2029): - Jeremy Gordon presented four shared-use path projects: extending Drain 27 to 64th Avenue South, connecting to 63rd Street, and extending Drain 53 near Davies. Funding increased due to TMA designation. Commission approved the applications unanimously. - Shared Use Path for 17th Avenue South Reconstruction: - Gordon recommended a 10-foot shared-use path on the north side (removing 41 trees, 6 of which are ash) and leaving the south sidewalk at 4.5 feet (no tree removal). Public input was minimal. Commissioner Strand supported the option, noting safety benefits. Commission approved the recommended alternative unanimously. - Liaison Commissioner Updates: - Commissioner Strand reported on the Fargo Youth Initiative event at City Hall on October 29, with nearly 100 high school students discussing homelessness and mental health. - Commissioner Turnberg noted renovations at Northport Library (still open). - Mayor Mahoney thanked the public for passing the quarter-cent sales tax for public safety (70% approval). Funds will be available in June 2025; a spending plan will be developed transparently over several months. Key Outcomes - Approved consent agenda (items 1–35) unanimously. - Continued public hearing for Fort Noks alcoholic beverage license to November 25, 2024, at 5:15 PM (motion by Kolpack, second by Turnberg; all present voted aye). - Approved federal aid transportation alternative project applications for 2028-2029 (motion by Kolpack, second by Turnberg; all present voted aye). - Approved the recommended shared-use path option for 17th Avenue South (10-foot path north side, 4.5-foot sidewalk south side) (motion by Strand, second by Turnberg; all present voted aye). - Approved appointments to the Growth Initiative Fund Board of Directors and Planning Commission (motion by Kolpack, second by Turnberg; all present voted aye). - Received and filed updates on legislative session, construction, and liaison reports. - Adjourned at 6:03 PM.

The Fargo City Commission met on October 28, 2024, at 5:00 PM following a 4:00 PM executive session (4:00–4:52 PM) for attorney consultation regarding pending litigation (Liquid Hospitality, LLC v. City of Fargo). The regular agenda included consent items, public hearings on annexation, rezoning, and a liquor license ownership change, as well as a contentious debate on a winter warming plan for the homeless. The meeting also featured updates on a new fire station, city growth statistics, and other initiatives. Consent Calendar - Approved 33 consent items unanimously, including: - Receive and file an ordinance on contractor littering. - Site authorizations for games of chance (Homeward Animal Shelter, ND Horse Park Foundation). - Raffle applications (Shiloh Masonic Lodge, Sts. Anne & Joachim, Village Family Service Center). - Special assessment deferral agreement with Sanford North. - Reimbursement of $8,160 for irrigation repairs. - Modifications to sanitary sewer service participation policy. - Various change orders and bid awards, including: $1,819,337 to Municipal Pipe Tool Company for Improvement District UR-24-F1; $62,150 to Gast Construction for North Parking Deck repairs; contracts with Valley Green and All Terrain for snow removal (2024–2027). - Contracts for services: Southeast Human Service Center, Liz Hannig (physical activity code), Center Point Tactical, LLC, and amendment with Tyler Technologies. - Resolution approving plat of Timber Parkway Eleventh Addition. - Resolution authorizing $15,000,000 sales tax and water revenue bond/loan for Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) project. - Bills paid totaling $20,842,594.67. Public Comments & Testimony - Tracy Wilkie spoke, referencing President Biden’s first-ever apology for Native American boarding schools and urging the city to continue working with Native American populations. She noted overrepresentation of Native Americans in unhoused populations and the criminal justice system, and called for expanded winter warming services and compassion. Discussion Items Winter Warming Plan (Item 34) Commissioner Strand proposed directing staff to prepare a winter warming plan, citing available ARP funds. A heated debate ensued: - Commissioner Piepkorn opposed, arguing Fargo has become a magnet for homeless from other counties and that taxpayer-funded services are destroying downtown, increasing property taxes, and driving businesses away. He claimed police are not responding and that the downtown engagement center is a “disaster.” - Commissioner Strand countered that the alternative is people freezing to death, referencing a historical case. He stated that most homelessness is due to evictions, and that providing warmth is humane. - Commissioner Kolpack acknowledged complexity but noted staff are actively addressing issues and that a process exists for complaints. - Mayor Mahoney clarified that police do respond and that crime is down; he supported the plan and noted the city is working with Bloomberg Institute for long-term solutions. - Commissioner Turnberg supported the plan, recalling that 40–50 people were warmed nightly last winter. The motion passed 3–2 (Kolpack, Strand, Mahoney in favor; Piepkorn and Turnberg opposed). Annexation (Item 35) Public hearing on annexation of 243.16 acres (west half of Section 4, Township 138N, Range 49W) for the Southwest Pond regional stormwater facility. City staff noted the city owns the land, no development is proposed, and Cass County and Stanley Township were notified. Motion to annex passed unanimously (5–0). First reading of the annexation ordinance also passed unanimously. Rezoning (Item 36) Public hearing for Southwest Fargo Mission Second Addition (4475 40th Avenue South). Proposal to rezone from GC (general commercial with conditional overlay) to MR-3 (multi-dwelling residential with conditional overlay). Planning Commission recommended approval. Motion to approve rezoning and conditional overlay passed unanimously (5–0). First reading of the rezoning ordinance also passed unanimously. Liquor License Ownership Change (Item 37) Application for Class “Z” (full alcohol) license for Fort Noks (Vault Partners LLP) at 52 Broadway North. Two new owners: Cole Jirik and Mr. Lavoy. Mayor split the motion. - Cole Jirik: No background issues; approved unanimously by the Liquor Control Board (4–0). Motion to approve Jirik passed unanimously. - Mr. Lavoy: Chief of Police reported false statements on the application: failure to disclose a 2015 DUI arrest (pleaded to reckless driving) and a 2010 disorderly conduct misdemeanor. Staff offered options to withdraw or file a corrected application, but Lavoy chose to proceed. After discussion, motion to continue the hearing to the next meeting (November 12, 2024) passed unanimously (5–0). Property Tax Exemptions (Item 38) Approved 13 applications for 5-year tax exemptions on building improvements. Motion passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Directed staff to prepare a winter warming plan (3–2 vote). - Approved annexation of 243.16 acres for the Southwest Pond (unanimous). - Approved rezoning for multi-dwelling residential (unanimous). - Approved ownership change for Cole Jirik (unanimous); continued Lavoy portion to November 12, 2024. - Approved 13 property tax exemptions (unanimous). - Approved consent agenda items 1–33 (unanimous). - Received liaison reports and resident comment.

Fargo City Commission Regular Meeting - October 14, 2024\n\nThe Fargo City Commission convened on Monday, October 14, 2024, at 5:00 p.m. in Commission Chambers. All five commissioners were present: Denise Kolpack, Dave Piepkorn, John Strand, Michelle Turnberg, and Mayor Timothy Mahoney. Mayor Mahoney opened with announcements including a decline in apartment vacancy rate to 6.38% in June (down from 6.82% in March), recognition of Indigenous Peoples Day, and a video highlighting city staff efforts for the UND vs. NDSU game day. The meeting adjourned at 6:14 p.m.\n\n Consent Calendar\n- Approved the consent agenda (37 items) unanimously. Key items included:\n - Second reading and final adoption of ordinances rezoning parcels in The Pines at the District Second Addition and The Pines at the District Addition.\n - Fifteen applications for games of chance (raffles, bingo) for various organizations.\n - Gaming site authorization for Friends of the Children Fargo-Moorhead at Crooked Pint Ale House.\n - Renewal of alcoholic beverage and live entertainment licenses through September 30, 2025.\n - 2025 City Commission meeting dates.\n - Contract amendment with Houston Engineering ($29,350.50) and bid awards for multiple projects (e.g., Master Construction Co. Inc. - $136,999; Dakota Underground Co. Inc. - $9,841,796.56).\n - Reimbursements, change orders, creation of Improvement District BR-25-B.\n - FAHR staff meeting items: $4,000 donation from Fargo Police Foundation, interlocal agreement for $66,729 JAG grant, $51,041 budget adjustments, lease amendment with Prairie Public Broadcasting, pause of AMI base meter charge increase.\n - Resolution authorizing up to $57 million in refunding improvement bonds.\n - Grant awards ($51,616 EMPG; Women, Infant and Children grant).\n - Contracts with New Roots Midwest, The Medicine Shoppe, and NDPERS benefit renewals.\n - Direction to draft revisions to Municipal Code sections 12-0105 and 12-0117.\n - License agreement with Park District for biking trail.\n - Second amendment with Sentry Security, amendments with Stantec Consulting ($145,594.50 and $57,000), addendum to lease for County Road No. 20 Lift Station.\n - Change Order No. 6 with PKG Contracting ($998,002), task orders with AE2S ($619,350 and $199,300).\n - Resolution for Clean Water/Safe Drinking Water loan application (Water Supply and Treatment Improvements).\n - Bills totaling $20,191,872.69.\n\n Public Comments & Testimony\n- Olivia Fischer (Fargo resident) expressed deep concern over the Commission's lack of action regarding Palestine, stating that inaction contributes to racism locally and globally. She cited a recent incident of racist comments in City Hall parking lot and criticized the Commission for not doing more beyond an earlier proclamation. She demanded meaningful action.\n\n Discussion Items\n- Construction Update – City Engineer Tom Knakmuhs reported no safety incidents on city projects. Completed projects included 32nd Avenue widening, NP Avenue improvements, First Street, 7th and 9th streets, new development projects (45th Street North, Veterans Industrial Park), asphalt mill/overlay projects, alley paving, and University Drive South Flood Wall. Ongoing projects: Woodcrest Drive North (phase 2 and 3), citywide signal maintenance, pavement marking replacement, drainage repairs (Briarwood area), new developments (Selkirk Second Edition, Dakota Commerce Center North), flood risk management (Lift Station 27, work near Trollwood and Lift Stations 11/57). Photo examples provided.\n\n- Fargo Transportation Plan Final Report – Transportation Division Engineer Jeremy Gordon presented the over-100-page plan, which builds on prior studies (Go2030, MetroCog plan, bike/ pedestrian plans, etc.). Goals: safety, complete streets, multimodal connectivity, grid network, innovation, right-sizing infrastructure. Peer city comparison (Bismarck, Rochester, Des Moines, Fort Collins) showed Fargo in the middle for fatality rates, high for walk score, and 73% of commuters drive alone. The plan introduces new street classification (residential local, industrial commercial, etc.) and driveway access/spacing guidelines. Commissioners discussed speed reduction (especially on principal arterials) and crash analysis; Commissioner Strand noted high-crash locations like 45th Street/32nd Avenue. The plan includes vision zero commitment (joining ND DOT program in 2025) and innovative designs (R-cuts, roundabouts, diverging diamond interchanges). Motion to approve the plan and driveway access/spacing guidelines passed unanimously.\n\n- Public Hearing – Special Assessment List (Continued from 9/30/24) – The hearing covered 22 improvement districts. Staff explained the reason for continuation: a North Dakota Supreme Court ruling (Sept 17, 2024) required the Special Assessment Commission to determine benefit in dollars independent of cost. The Commission met Oct 3 and Oct 8, estimated present/ future benefits, and staff verified benefits exceeded costs for all parcels. No public speakers. The motion to approve the assessment list passed unanimously. Commissioner Kolpack clarified that the city often subsidizes assessments (e.g., 50% for mill and overlay, 85% city-funded for local reconstruction).\n\n- Lead Service Line Replacement Loan Resolution – Brenda Derrig and Troy Hall presented a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law. Fargo has under 2,300 known lead service lines (mostly on private side). Proposed loan: $35 million with 66% loan forgiveness ($23 million grant) and 0.5% interest. The resolution authorizes applying for the loan without obligation to borrow. Presentation included 30+ years of tap water lead testing (best results in last four years due to new membrane plant), sampling protocols, corrosion control measures, and financial modeling. Community benefits include reduced lead exposure, improved home values, construction jobs, and water system improvement. Motion to approve the resolution passed unanimously. Commissioner Kolpack commended staff for proactive data collection.\n\n- Camping Ordinance and Resolution Implementation Update – Assistant City Administrator Brenda Derrig and Fargo Cass Public Health Director Jenn Faul reported on five weeks of implementation (since Sept 9, 2024). Key stats: mobile outreach team averages 265 transports/month downtown; HART team diverts 81 dispatch calls/month; 1,090 engagements/month; 142 businesses visited since May; Gladys Ray Shelter served 103 unique individuals in September; Engagement Center served 495 unique individuals (80/day average), with 19,602 total encounters year-to-date. Camp outreach has moved from downtown northward; no arrests or fines to date; 164 staff hours spent on camp cleanups. The city uses Fargo One app for reporting. Housing First initiative focuses on connecting individuals to services, using $4,000 donation and carryover funds, working with partners (Churches United, Housing Authority, YWCA, F5 Project, etc.) to master lease apartments. Commissioner Strand asked about winter warming plans (funds available, exploring locations) and amenities like porta-potties (not yet, but garbage cans provided). He also raised concerns about Churches United’s financial difficulties (20-30% staff layoffs). The city is coordinating with others to continue services.\n\n- Liaison Commissioner Assignment Updates – Commissioners reported on boards/committees. Commissioner Kolpack announced Impact Fargo 2024 (Oct 29, all-day youth event at City Hall) and Fargo Youth Initiative applications open through Nov 15. Commissioner Strand suggested more systematic youth engagement on boards. Mayor Mahoney recognized efforts.\n\n Key Outcomes\n- Unanimous approval (5-0) of the consent agenda (37 items).\n- Unanimous approval (5-0) of the Fargo Transportation Plan final report and driveway access/spacing guidelines.\n- Unanimous approval (5-0) of the special assessment list for 22 improvement districts.\n- Unanimous approval (5-0) of the resolution to apply for a $35 million loan (66% forgiveness) for lead service line replacement.\n- No formal vote on the camping update; it was received as information. No arrests or fines reported in first five weeks.\n- Resident comment made no call for action, but public record of concern.

The Fargo City Commission met on Monday, September 30, 2024, at 5:00 PM in the Commission Chambers. The meeting lasted until 7:13 PM. Key actions included approval of a $116,750 Flock Safety technology purchase (4–1), adoption of the 2025 Final Budget with a 4.5% COLA and no new mill increase (3–2), and continuation of a special assessment hearing to October 14 due to a North Dakota Supreme Court ruling. Several public hearings were held on zoning, Renaissance Zone rehabilitation, special assessments, and budget amendments. Public comments addressed Flock Safety concerns, budget priorities, homeless services, and community programs. Consent Calendar - Approved unanimously (Items 1–38): including second readings of rezoning ordinances for Harwood's 4th Addition and Legacy I Eighth Addition; renewal of alcoholic beverage and live entertainment licenses; games of chance applications; consent to construction with JBJ Properties; conduit lease with VAL-ED Joint Venture; variance and waiver for Riverside Cemetery; encroachment agreement with Oak Grove Lutheran School; deferral of special assessments for A & T Land Co.; negative final balancing change order (-$192,930.10); MOUs with Park District for shared use paths; change order and time extension for BN-23-E1 ($4,614.50); reimbursement to St. Mary's Cathedral ($12,587.17); creation of Improvement District BR-25-A; contract and bond for BR-23-G3; bid awards for snow removal; FAHR staff meeting items; letter of support for FAA waiver; joint fire training MOU; master service agreement with AdShark; agreements with Clay County Public Health and various service providers; grant awards from ND HHS; letter of support for EPA 319 Grant; amendment to consulting agreement with czb, LLC; exempt purchase from Butler Machinery ($144,701.97); task order with HDR Engineering ($179,130); amendment to task order with AE2S ($96,850); bills totaling $14,155,780.13. Public Comments & Testimony - Ron Gilmore (Fargo resident) opposed the Flock Safety purchase, calling it an intrusion on First and Fourth Amendment rights and expressing concerns about potential errors and police stops. - Tim Nasheim (resident in Improvement District PN-23A) requested that curb/gutter and sidewalk repairs within the asphalt wear course project be separated and assessed at appropriate rates. - Whitney Johnson (Chair of Native American Commission) spoke against proposed cuts to Indigenous Association and Youth Works, emphasizing the importance of these services to the Native community, especially on Truth and Reconciliation Day. - Summer Sturlugson (Fargo resident) advocated for funding the Downtown Engagement Center (DEC), stating it diverts people from a broken system and helps connect homeless individuals to resources. - Ron Gilmore (again) criticized the commission for known funding shortfalls and urged cutting "fat" rather than essential services. - Melanie Heitkamp (Executive Director of Youth Works) described the emergency shelter's role in keeping police officers on the street and urged continued funding ($41,200 from the city). - Kimberly Kemppanion (Fargo resident) warned that defunding the DEC would worsen homeless visibility and violate Resolution 4 of the camping ordinance. - Asher Lorentzen (resident) criticized the city for providing port-a-potties for fishermen but not for homeless neighbors, and accused the commission of prioritizing fears over dignity. - Olivia Fischer (resident via conference call) denounced the commission's silence on the Gaza genocide and called on them to denounce the violence. Discussion Items - Flock Safety Technology (Item 39): Police Captain Bill Ahfeldt presented the system, noting 42 documented successes since June 3, 2024, including stolen vehicle recovery, warrant arrests, and suspect identification. Data is retained 30 days and not used for facial recognition or speed enforcement. The purchase ($116,750) is from seized assets. Commissioner Piepkorn opposed, citing financial uncertainty and desire for regional cost-sharing. Commissioner Strand supported the technology. Motion passed 4–1 (Piepkorn nay). - The Pines at the District Rezoning (Item 40): Planning Director Donald Kress explained the zone change to MR-3 with Conditional Overlay for two subdivisions owned by Bethany on 42nd. Planning Commission recommended approval. Unanimous vote. - Renaissance Zone Project (Item 41): Director Cole Kritzfeld presented rehabilitation at 315 Main Avenue ($900,000 investment, 5 residential units). Scoring was 49/90, but staff recommended approval. Renaissance Zone Authority approved 8/28. Unanimous vote. - Special Assessments – BID, Utilities, Skyway, Snow Removal (Item 42): Steve Sprague detailed BID increase to $760,000, Skyway to $160,000, snow removal for two properties, and unpaid utilities (193 properties list). Unanimous approval. - Sidewalk Special Assessments (Items 43–44): Two projects totaling $1.2 million, affecting 250 parcels. Interest rate 5.08% including 0.75% net. Unanimous approval. - Improvement District Assessments (Item 45): Due to a September 17, 2024 ND Supreme Court ruling, public hearing was held but final action continued to October 14, 2024, to allow Special Assessment Commission to confirm benefit. Tim Nasheim spoke on District PN-23A. Motion to accept list pending benefit confirmation carried unanimously. - 2025 Final Budget and Tax Levies (Item 46): Mayor Mahoney presented balanced budget with 4.5% COLA, no mill increase, $12 million increase (11%) driven by transit deficit ($3.5M), police station bonding, and compensation. Commissioner Strand proposed amendment to add three RIFs and eliminate Office of Strategic Planning & Research – failed for lack of second. His second amendment to remove non-legacy funding for arts partnerships, land trust, MLK/Juneteenth events – also failed for lack of second. After public comment, motion to approve budget as presented passed 3–2 (Kolpack, Strand, Mahoney aye; Piepkorn, Turnberg nay). - Liaison Commissioner Updates (Item 47): Commissioners reported on board/committee assignments. Mayor noted Fire Station 8 ribbon cutting October 23, 2024, and new fire academy. Key Outcomes - Flock Safety Purchase: Approved (4–1). Funds from seized assets; system installed June 3, 2024. - The Pines Rezoning: Approved unanimously (5–0). - Renaissance Zone Project (315 Main Ave): Approved unanimously (5–0). - Special Assessments (BID, utilities, skyway, snow removal): Approved unanimously (5–0). - Sidewalk Assessments (SR-23-A & SR-23-B): Approved unanimously (5–0). - Improvement District Assessments: Accepted as presented with benefit confirmation pending; action continued to October 14, 2024 at 5:15 PM. - 2025 Final Budget: Approved (3–2). The budget is balanced with a 4.5% COLA and no new mills. The commission will begin work on 2026 budget immediately. - Public Input Opportunity: All public hearings were held; speakers exercised their rights.

The Fargo City Commission met on Monday, September 16, 2024, at 5:00 PM in Commission Chambers. All five commissioners were present: Mayor Mahoney, Commissioners Kolpack, Piepkorn, Strand, and Turnberg. The meeting began with the Pledge of Allegiance and roll call. It included approvals of a consent agenda, regular agenda items, three public hearings on zoning changes and a public hearing on the 2025 Preliminary Budget, followed by a vote on budget-related position eliminations. The meeting adjourned at 6:26 PM. Consent Calendar - Approved unanimously (5-0) the consent agenda (items 1-20, excluding item 16 moved to regular agenda). Items included: Agreement for Special Improvements with ARD Properties LLC (Improvement District No. BN-24-B1); games of chance applications for Carl Ben Eielson PTA and New Life Center; Final Balancing Change Order No. 2 ($0.00) for Project UR-24-H1; Memorandum of Offer for easements with Tones LLC; Change Order No. 1 ($284,983.47) for Improvement District BN-23-F1; Change Order No. 2 ($2,475.00) for Improvement District BN-23-J1; creation of Improvement District FP-19-A (Southwest Regional Pond Phase 2); Facilities Management Policies; resolutions authorizing Taxable Annual Appropriation Bonds Series 2024F and 2024G; FAHR staff items including a $99,200 WIC grant amendment, a plat application to West Fargo, an RFP for advisory services and commercial realtors for landfill-adjacent property, an amendment with KLJ Engineering ($42,375.00) for City Hall Deck Repairs Phase 2, and interim compensation for City Administrator Michael Redlinger (net $0.00 impact to City); contracts for Fire Station No. 5 Renovation (general, electrical, mechanical); grant agreement for TB Care Coordination Services; vacating findings for 1710 1st Avenue South; amended findings for 909 4th Street North; funding approval and HOME Investment Partnerships Agreement with HUD; consent to rename the Badges of Unity Fund to the Fargo Police Foundation; quitclaim deed with the Park District for South Ridge First Addition; bid award to Northern Truck Equipment ($195,525.00) for a hook and hoist refuse truck; and bills totaling $15,098,132.58. Regular Agenda Items - Item 16: Resolution approving Plat of College Third Addition – Moved from consent agenda at Commissioner Strand's request. Planning Director Donald Cress presented a minor subdivision at 1038 25th Street North to create a second lot for a single-family residence on an SR3-zoned lot. Public comment: Paula Strom Sow (resident of 1122 25th Street North) expressed concerns about parking congestio, green space, and behavior of current renters. Discussion: Commissioner Piepkorn noted parking is not allowed in alleys; Commissioner Strand stated that parking issues are citywide but housing needs take precedence. Motion to approve carried 5-0 (Kolpack, Piepkorn, Strand, Turnberg, Mahoney aye). - Item 21: Appointments to Civil Service Commission and Fargo Dome Authority – Approved 5-0. - Item 27: Application for Property Tax Exemption – For improvements at 1416 West Gateway Circle South (5 years). Approved 5-0. Public Hearings (commenced at approximately 5:15 PM) - Item 22: Legacy I Eighth Addition (6155 24th Street South) – Recommended by Planning Commission on 6/4/24. Zoning change from GO (General Office) with C-O (Conditional Overlay) to GO with C-O and SR-5 (Single-Dwelling Residential), plus plat. No public speakers. Motion to approve rezoning and plat carried 5-0. Subsequently, first reading of the rezoning ordinance was approved 5-0. - Item 23: Legacy I Eighth Addition (same property) – Recommended by Planning Commission on 8/6/24. Zoning change from GO with C-O to MR-3 (Multi-Dwelling Residential) with PUD (Planned Unit Development) overlay, and approval of the PUD Master Land Use Plan. Developer Brandon Rayborn (Rayline Realty) presented a proposed 51-unit apartment building with half-story underground parking and a residential protection buffer. Commissioner Piepkorn noted no opposition from neighbors. Commissioner Strand asked about incentives; Rayborn stated no incentives were used. Motion to approve rezoning and PUD plan carried 5-0. First reading of ordinance approved 5-0. - Item 24: Harwood's 4th Addition (806 7th Street North) – Recommended by Planning Commission on 7/2/24. Zoning change from MR-3 to SR-5 and plat for a twin home development on a 7,000 sq ft lot. No public speakers. Motion to approve carried 5-0. First reading of ordinance approved 5-0. - Item 25: Public hearing on the 2025 Preliminary Budget and recommended tax levies – Mayor noted no increase in mill levy for the airport authority. Approximately eight residents spoke (Connie Hamre, Glenn Knudson, Brad Shaffer, Jonathan Adams, Hassan Iber, Charles King, Sekou Sirleaf, Matuor Alier, and others). Positions varied: Several speakers expressed opposition to property tax increases and called for spending reductions, with some singling out the DEI position as wasteful; others, particularly members of the community of color, voiced strong support for retaining the DEI position, arguing it provides essential representation for people of color, veterans, and people with disabilities. The mayor and commissioners acknowledged the comments; final budget hearing scheduled in two weeks. Discussion Items - Item 26: Recommendation for budget-related position eliminations – City Administrator recommended elimination of 6.2 positions (3 occupied, 3.2 vacant) to meet expenditure reduction targets, including the DEI Director position. Commissioner Strand expressed dissatisfaction, stating he wanted broader cuts across departments before supporting employee COLAs. Commissioner Kolpack supported the recommendation, noting it followed the process and that every department made cuts. Mayor Mahoney indicated ongoing review. Motion by Commissioner Piepkorn, second by Turnberg. Roll call vote: Ayes – Kolpack, Piepkorn, Turnberg, Mahoney; Nay – Strand. Motion carried 4-1. This action eliminated the DEI position. Key Outcomes - Consent agenda approved 5-0. - Plat of College Third Addition approved 5-0. - Appointments to boards approved 5-0. - Property tax exemption approved 5-0. - Legacy I Eighth Addition zone changes and plats (Items 22 and 23) both approved 5-0. - Harwood's 4th Addition zone change and plat approved 5-0. - Budget-related position eliminations approved 4-1, eliminating the DEI position. - Final budget hearing set for two weeks (date not specified but implied as the next meeting). - Commissioner Strand reported that the Airport Authority changed meeting schedule to the second Tuesday of each month.