Public Meetings - Honolulu, Hawaii

On Thursday, November 20, 2025, at 1:05 PM, the Public Safety and Economy Committee of the Honolulu City Council met remotely and in person to consider several agenda items, including appointments to commissions, a resolution affirming constitutional rights, gifts to the Honolulu Zoo, a bill on police information release, and an informational briefing on federal funding coordination. The meeting lasted approximately two hours and included testimony from numerous community members, students, and organizational representatives. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was used; all items were taken up individually. Public Comments & Testimony - Resolution 25-301 (affirming constitutional rights): 22 in-person and remote testifiers spoke in strong support, including representatives from the ACLU of Hawaii, Hawaii Coalition for Immigrant Rights, Hawaii Workers Center, UH Manoa students, and community members. They emphasized the importance of protecting constitutional rights for all residents, the fear caused by ICE activities, and the need to maintain trust between police and immigrant communities. One oral testifier, Tim Gary, raised questions about the number of undocumented immigrants and the resolution's potential sanctuary city implications. No testifiers opposed. - Bill 46 (HPD information release): One in-person testifier, John Dutzman, supported the bill but opposed the definition of “qualified media organization,” arguing it excludes online platforms. Another testifier, Jason Hug (KITV/KIQ), asked the committee to pass the bill. One remote testifier, Matthew, opposed the bill, calling it an “unholy alliance” between media and police. Tim Gary also commented. - Zoo gift resolutions (Items 4-7): Two remote testifiers, Angela Young and Tim Gary, spoke in favor of the gifts, praising the zoo’s improvements. Discussion Items - Resolution 25-292 – Appointment of Anna Nubauer to the Citizens Advisory Commission on Emergency Management: Unanimously approved. No testimony or objections. - Resolution 25-290 – Appointment of Blakely Parsons to the Police Commission: Unanimously approved. Councilmember Kiaaina expressed support and urged more local law enforcement nominees. Chair Waters questioned Parsons about his experience, challenges facing the commission, and the police chief hiring process. - Resolution 25-301 – Affirming constitutional rights: Introduced by Councilmember Waters and Councilmember Wire. The administration (Deputy Managing Director Krishna Jar) and HPD Chief Vanick expressed support but requested removal of two “be it resolved” clauses that requested the mayor review agreements and HPD confine its actions. Councilmember Kiaaina moved to strike those clauses, citing redundancy. Councilmember Wire expressed concern about the message to marginalized communities. After debate, the committee amended the resolution to a CD1 deleting the two clauses, and reported it out for adoption. - Items 4-7 (Zoo gift resolutions): Director of Enterprise Services Dita Holyfield presented the gifts, totaling over $60,000, for training, animal care, and infrastructure. She also updated on the zoo’s accreditation progress and upcoming Christmas train. Councilmember Kiaaina asked about the zoo train and Christmas plans. All four resolutions were approved unanimously. - Bill 46 – Requiring HPD to release public information: Interim Chief Vanick reported that HPD has already launched a beta alert system with 16 media partners. He requested changing the annual “report” requirement to an “update.” The committee agreed and amended the bill to CD1 with that change. Reported out for third reading. - Informational briefing on federal funding coordination: Deputy Managing Director Krishna Jar and Office of Economic Revitalization Director Amy Asselbey presented on efforts to centralize federal grants. New federal funding coordinator Erica Moritsugu introduced herself. The presentation highlighted past challenges (procurement, staffing) and recommendations for training, templates, and interagency collaboration. Councilmember Kiaaina emphasized measurable outcomes and use of all available funds. Key Outcomes - Resolution 25-292 (Anna Nubauer) – Approved as amended (CD1) and reported out for adoption. No objections. - Resolution 25-290 (Blakely Parsons) – Approved as amended (CD1) and reported out for adoption. No objections. - Resolution 25-301 (Affirming constitutional rights) – Amended to CD1 (deleting two clauses requesting mayor review and HPD confinement) and reported out for adoption. No objections. - Resolution 25-312 (Zoo gift for mammal keeper training) – Approved and reported out for adoption. No objections. - Resolution 25-311 (Zoo gift for elephant foot care consulting) – Approved and reported out for adoption. No objections. - Resolution 25-310 (Zoo gifts for enrichment, playground, and hay chopper) – Approved and reported out for adoption. No objections. - Resolution 25-307 (Zoo gift for concrete coating at Ziba Braun Barn) – Approved and reported out for adoption. No objections. - Bill 46 (HPD public information release) – Amended to CD1 (changing “report” to “update”) and reported out for passage on third reading. No objections. - The informational briefing on federal funding was received; no formal action taken.

The Committee on Zoning and Planning of the Honolulu City Council met on Thursday, November 20, 2025, at 9:03 AM. Chair Kia Aina presided, with Vice Chair Waters, Councilmember Cordero, and Councilmember Topola (remote) present. Councilmember Okimoto was excused. The committee considered four action items – two resolutions and one bill – and heard two informational briefings. Key outcomes included approval of a Planning Commission appointment, a 90-day extension for a shoreline permit application, a 36-month extension for an affordable housing project, passage of a community benefits package for a Waikiki hotel project, and advancement of a bill allowing dog parks to count toward park dedication requirements. Resolution 25-294 – Appointment to Planning Commission - Action: Unanimously reported out for adoption. - The resolution confirmed Mayor’s appointment of Mark Anthony Clemente to the Planning Commission, filling the land development and construction category seat. Mr. Clemente introduced himself, noting his background in government relations and community service. Councilmember Cordero asked about workload and thoroughness; Mr. Clemente promised collaboration. The Department of Planning and Permitting (DPP) supported the nomination. No public testimony was offered. Resolution 25-299 – Special Management Area Major Permit (Taylor Property) - Action: Granted a 90-day extension subject to written request from the applicant; postponed to a date determined by the Chair. - The resolution sought an SMA permit for a new dwelling on a shoreline lot in Kailua. The applicant’s agent was absent, drawing frustration from the Chair. DPP noted the 60-day deadline would expire December 16, 2025. Chair Kia Aina criticized the application’s quality and recommended a 90-day extension. The committee approved the extension unanimously. No public testimony was given. Resolution 25-314 – Extension for Cahole Pele 201H Project - Action: Reported out for adoption with a 36-month extension. - The project, a 190-unit affordable rental/for-sale development in Salt Lake, sought to extend its construction deadline from January 25, 2026. Monty Heaton (High Ridge Costa) presented, citing unsuccessful LIHTC applications. Councilmember Cordero questioned parking ratios (227 spaces for 190 units). Vice Chair Waters asked about the three-year term; Heaton said it allows two more LIHTC cycles. Heaton noted the for-sale option was not financially feasible due to high costs and interest rates. Public testimony: none. DPP supported the extension. Resolution 25-316 – Community Benefits Package (Hilton Waikiki Project) - Action: Amended to CD1 and reported out for adoption. - The resolution sets $1 million in community benefits for a planned development resort at 133 Kiwani Avenue, as required by prior council conditions. Chair Waters introduced a CD1 (hand carry) to address Parks concerns. Testimony: Ben Sadowski (Unite Here Local 5) opposed, arguing the benefits should prioritize housing and inflation-adjusted amount. Trevor Abarazua (Waikiki Business Improvement District) supported, citing unanimous neighborhood board support for Kūhiō Beach Park improvements. DPP and DPR supported the CD1 after language requiring coordination with DPR. The committee adopted the CD1 and reported out. Bill 70 (2025) – Dog Parks and Park Dedication - Action: Amended to CD1 and reported out for second reading and public hearing. - The bill amends the subdivision ordinance to allow dog parks to credit toward park dedication requirements. Introducer Councilmember Topola explained it responds to new housing in Kapolei. DPP generally supported but noted refinements needed. No public testimony. The committee adopted the CD1 and advanced the bill. Informational Briefing – IPDT Project at 1588 Ala Moana Boulevard - Alana Kobayashi Pakala (Kobayashi Group) and Isaiah Sato (Arm Towel Corporation) presented a mixed-use transit-oriented development including 52 affordable rental units (80% AMI), 145 market-rate residential units, 291 hotel units, and 26,000 sq ft of commercial space. The project would replace a parking lot fronting Ala Moana Center. Public testimony: William Alberton opposed, citing insufficient affordability, too many parking stalls, and environmental concerns. Angela Melody Young (CARES) supported. Trisha Taketa, Sean Newcamp (carpenters), and Andrew Pereira (Pacific Resource Partnership) also supported. DPP said it looks forward to receiving the IPDT permit application. No committee action was taken. Informational Briefing – Ordinance 25-2 Updates (Residential in Business Districts and ADU/Ohana Standards) - Liz Krieger (DPP) presented two provisions: (1) allowing residential uses by right in B-1 and B-2 districts with minimum commercial requirements (effective January 3, 2025); (2) expanded ADU and Ohana unit rules (effective September 30, 2025), including allowing one ADU and one Ohana on the same lot, increased ADU sizes, and removal of attachment requirement for Ohana units. No building permit applications have been received for either provision. Discussion included potential tax disincentives (Vice Chair Waters) and enforcement of family-relationship requirement for Ohana units. The committee suggested future outreach efforts. Public testimony: Angela Melody Young supported. No action taken. Key Outcomes - Confirmed: Mark Anthony Clemente to Planning Commission (unanimous). - Extended: 90-day extension for Resolution 25-299 (SMA permit) subject to applicant’s written request. - Approved: 36-month extension for Cahole Pele 201H project (Resolution 25-314). - Approved: Community benefits package for Hilton Waikiki (Resolution 25-316 CD1). - Advanced: Bill 70 (dog parks) to second reading and public hearing. - Noted: No applications yet under Ordinance 25-2 provisions; future outreach planned.

The Committee on International and Legal Affairs met on November 19, 2025, to consider two resolutions and then conduct executive sessions to discuss settlement requests in several cases. The meeting included testimony from a department director, discussion of data‑driven decision‑making, and votes on all agenda items. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public testified on any agenda item. Oral testimony was accepted but none was offered, either in person or remotely. Discussion Items - Resolution 25‑293 – Reappointment of Sheldon Jim to the Ethics Commission Commissioner Jim was present and offered to answer questions. A CD1 with technical amendments was introduced by the chair. No questions from members. The committee voted to amend the resolution to CD1 and then to report the CD1 out for adoption without objection. - Resolution 25‑281 – Acceptance of Gift of Travel for Director of Human Resources (Bloomberg Harvard City Leadership Initiative) Director Nola Miyasaki of the Department of Human Resources testified in support. She explained that the gift covered travel costs for her to serve on an alumni panel at the Bloomberg Harvard program, which focuses on change management, data‑driven decision‑making, DEI, and talent management. Council Member Cordero asked about the event, and Director Miyasaki noted that a prior project to improve hiring rates for engineers had led to a supplemental union agreement creating a separate salary schedule for engineers, helping the city become more competitive. Council Member Waters asked about data‑driven decision‑making; Director Miyasaki described how the program emphasized using hard data over anecdotes and mentioned a vacancy dashboard being implemented. A CD1 with technical amendments was adopted, and the amended resolution was reported out for adoption without objection. - Executive Session Items The committee convened into executive session, with no public testimony, to consult with attorneys on settlement requests in the following cases: (3) Certified Construction, (4) Diana Crockett, (5) Deborah Freeman, (6) Skycap, and (7) Sullivan Salon. After the closed session, the committee voted on each settlement request. Key Outcomes - Resolution 25‑293 (Ethics Commission reappointment) : Adopted without objection after CD1 amendment. - Resolution 25‑281 (Travel gift acceptance) : Adopted without objection after CD1 amendment. - Settlement – Certified Construction: Request for authorization to settle was reported out for adoption. No objection. - Settlement – Diana Crockett: Request for authorization to settle was reported out for adoption. No objection. - Settlement – Deborah Freeman: Request for authorization to settle was reported out for adoption. No objection. - Settlement – Skycap: One council member voted yes but with reservations, stating that the city could not take the case to trial because the prosecuting attorney who charged the officers with murder (Steve Alm) was the star witness for Skycap, and that two prior attempts to prosecute had failed (one before a grand jury, one in a preliminary hearing). The motion was adopted. - Settlement – Sullivan Salon: Request for authorization to settle was reported out for adoption. No objection.

The Committee on Infrastructure and Transportation and Technology met on Wednesday, November 19, 2025, at 9:02 AM, via remote conferencing. Chaired by Councilmember Cordero, the meeting covered an update on the Red Hill fuel spill contamination, presentations on traffic safety and the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD), and action on several resolutions and bills. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was identified; all items were considered individually. Public Comments & Testimony - Eduardo Hernandez (Hawaii Bicycling League) testified on Bill 73 and Bill 71. He recommended against overcriminalizing sidewalk bicycling in Waikiki, noting no traffic fatalities caused by bicycles there. He supported shared streets (open streets) concepts, citing economic benefits and the success of the Honolulu Century Ride closure of Kalanianaole Highway. - Ryan Naka (Charlie’s Taxi) testified in strong support of Bill 42, stating it updates outdated taxi regulations to create a more level playing field with TNCs while maintaining safety standards. - An additional unidentified in-person testifier echoed support for Bill 42, acknowledging collaboration with stakeholders. Discussion Items - Red Hill Fuel Spill Update: Board of Water Supply Manager Ernie Lau and Engineer Joyce Lynn presented an update on the 2021 fuel spill that contaminated the Red Hill shaft, impacting 93,000 residents. The facility has 20 underground storage tanks (each 100 ft across, 220 ft tall) with a total capacity of 250 million gallons. The Halawa Shaft was shut down as a precaution. PFAS (forever chemicals) have been detected at the Kaamilo wells, leading to installation of a temporary granular activated carbon treatment system. The Navy received $141 million in federal funding for remediation. Manager Lau emphasized that full remediation will take generations and that the extent of historical releases (including from an unlined oily waste disposal site) remains unknown. - Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD) & Traffic Safety: DTS Traffic Engineer Kelly Akasaki explained the 11th edition of the MUTCD, adopted by Hawaii in October 2024, which now includes standards for rectangular rapid flashing beacons (RRFBs) and green bike lane markings. Complete Streets Administrator Renee Espiau discussed the Oahu Pedestrian Plan and a new program to address 900 miles of missing sidewalks. Vision Zero Coordinator Jermaine Salim Hagihara presented data: as of the meeting date, 74 traffic deaths had occurred in 2025, with 30% pedestrians and 50% of pedestrian deaths among those over 65. Speed, inattention, and impairment are the top contributing factors. HPD Acting Chief Vanick reported a near doubling of fatalities compared to the same period in 2024 (43 to 74). Enforcement has increased: nearly 22,000 speeding citations issued in 2025, 565 arrests for excessive speeding (vs. 213 in 2024). HPD launched the "Safer Roads Together" campaign with social media, sign-waving, and a "Take 30" initiative for patrol officers. - Resolutions 25-317 and 25-309 (Safety Plans): Director Morton presented required FTA safety plans for bus/paratransit and rail. Both plans include joint labor-management safety committees. Rail had one safety event (escalator fall) in its first two years; bus incidents primarily involve passenger falls. The resolutions were approved unanimously. - Bill 73 (Traffic Code Update): Introducer Councilmember DeSantis Tam described the bill as an omnibus update to the traffic code (chapters 15, 15A, 15B) which dates to 1931. It removes obsolete provisions (e.g., bicycle license plates, vehicle reflectors now regulated federally). The bill was postponed to allow for further work on a CD1 version. - Bill 71 (Shared Streets): Introducer Councilmember DeSantis Tam explained the bill creates a process for designating shared streets (play streets/open streets), building on state law HRS 291-163. DTS supported the concept but noted potential conflicts with state code. The committee adopted the posted CD1 and reported the bill out for second reading and a public hearing. - Bill 42 (Taxi Cabs): Introducers Councilmembers Tupola and Wire presented the CD1 as an update to taxi regulations to help local taxi companies compete with TNCs. The bill aims to reduce overregulation and allow free-market operation while maintaining standards. The committee reported the CD1 out for third reading. Key Outcomes - Resolution 25-317 (Bus and Paratransit Safety Plan) – Approved for adoption. - Resolution 25-309 (Rail Safety Plan) – Approved for adoption. - Bill 73 (Traffic Code Update) – Postponed to a date to be determined by the Chair. - Bill 71 (Shared Streets) – Amended to CD1 and passed on second reading with a public hearing scheduled. - Bill 42 (Taxi Cabs CD1) – Passed on third reading. The meeting adjourned with no further business.

The Committee on Housing, Homelessness, and Parks, chaired by Councilmember Tupola, met on Tuesday, November 18, 2025, at 2:37 p.m. (the meeting date recorded as November 19, 2025, for official purposes). The meeting covered four agenda items: adding six trees to the Exceptional Trees inventory, two appointments to the Board of Parks and Recreation, and the confirmation of a new Director of Housing and Land Management. All items were approved. Public Comments & Testimony - Bill 66 (Exceptional Trees): No public testimony was offered in person or remotely. - Resolution 25-295 (Catherine Chang): No public testimony was offered. - Resolution 25-298 (Carla Hauser): Three community members testified in opposition. Shelby Pikachu and Sabrina Grace opposed the reappointment, citing concerns about a recent homeless sweep at Hakimo Roll and the lack of solutions for homeless individuals. Kalai Salcedo argued that Ms. Hauser had a conflict of interest due to her role at RISE and a related permitting issue. Chair Tupola clarified that the Parks Board has no authority over sweeps or enforcement and that Ms. Hauser’s nonprofit work is separate. Deputy Director Laura Thielen of the Department of Parks and Recreation testified in strong support, emphasizing Ms. Hauser’s 15-plus years of service to vulnerable youth and her contributions to the Parks Board. - Resolution 25-206 (Kevin Auger): Angela Melody Young testified in favor, citing Director Auger’s knowledge of housing portfolio and his values in improving disadvantaged neighborhoods. Discussion Items - Bill 66 (2025) – Exceptional Trees Inventory: Deputy Director of Parks and Recreation (Laura Thielen) presented the bill, noting that six new trees would be added: three in Manoa, one at Kayaka Beach Park, one in Kaleohhe, and the first ever in Eva. The Eva Neighborhood Board expressed excitement. Councilmember Wire thanked John Rogers of the Eva Neighborhood Board for his advocacy. The bill was amended to a Committee Draft 1 (CD1) as proposed, with no objections. - Resolution 25-295 – Catherine Chang Appointment: Ms. Chang introduced herself, highlighting her nonprofit Center for Tomorrow’s Leaders, which engages high school students in park events. Councilmember Cordero asked about expanding programs and strengthening public outreach. Ms. Chang noted plans for community input in the new year. No objections were raised, and the resolution was reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25-298 – Carla Hauser Reappointment: Ms. Hauser reported accomplishments in her first term, including focus groups on Kupuna programs and work order improvements. Councilmember Kiaina discussed a challenge at Kailua District Park where high school baseball fields are used by Kalihi High School, and suggested collaboration with the Department of Education and state funding. Deputy Director Thielen spoke at length about Ms. Hauser’s qualifications and dedication. Chair Tupola and Councilmember Wire expressed support, noting that the role is unpaid. No further objections were raised after public testimony, and the resolution was approved. - Resolution 25-206 – Kevin Auger Confirmation as Director of Housing and Land Management: Director-designee Kevin Auger thanked the committee. Councilmember Kiaina expressed full support and thanked Mr. Auger for assistance with complex issues, including a proposed DHHL site on Kalaheo Hillside ($20 million in city budget for infrastructure), the possible acquisition of Haleiwa Backyards, and a charter amendment (No. 148) to authorize the Clean Water and Natural Lands Fund for historic preservation. Mr. Auger agreed to review the amendment. No other questions or testimony in opposition were received. Key Outcomes - Bill 66 (2025) was amended to CD1 and reported out for passage on second reading and scheduled for a public hearing. (No objections) - Resolution 25-295 (Catherine Chang) was adopted, confirming her appointment to the Board of Parks and Recreation for a term expiring December 31, 2030. - Resolution 25-298 (Carla Hauser) was adopted, confirming her reappointment to the Board of Parks and Recreation for a term expiring December 31, 2030. - Resolution 25-206 (Kevin Auger) was adopted, confirming his appointment as Director of Housing and Land Management. All decisions were unanimous and without recorded opposition from committee members.

The committee met on November 18, 2025, under HRS 92-3.7 as a remote meeting, to consider three resolutions and receive an informational briefing on food insecurity in Hawaii. The meeting included presentations from Hawaii Appleseed, Hawaii Food Bank, and Maui County Councilmember Gabe Johnson. Public Comments & Testimony - One testifier, Ms. Young, spoke about the importance of cooperation among offices, nonprofits, and faith congregations to maximize resources for food distribution and destigmatize food insecurity. Discussion Items - Resolution 25315 (Gift Acceptance): The committee considered a resolution to accept a gift from IProductions for filming on city locations. The Deputy Director of the relevant department expressed support, noting that filming showcases facilities and that the gift was unexpected but welcome. No testimony was received. The resolution was reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25289 (Reappointment of Bradley Romines to Climate Change Commission): The committee heard from Mr. Romines, who shared his background as a coastal geologist and extension faculty with Hawaii Sea Grant. He described his work on the commission, including updating the climate change brief and finalizing an urban heat guidance document. Councilmember Tupolo asked about the commission's role in disseminating climate change resiliency funds and suggested the commission could serve as a forum for public input on fund expenditures. Romines expressed willingness to be involved in future rounds. The resolution was amended to CD1 and reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25296 (Appointment of Jeffrey Laupola to Board of Water Supply): Mr. Laupola introduced himself, citing his background in military, investment banking, and technology. He expressed a desire to be a bridge for the Board of Water Supply. Manager and Chief Engineer Ernie Lau spoke in strong support, noting Laupola's potential to help navigate military relations regarding Red Hill. Councilmember Tupolo asked about the board's role; Lau explained it sets policy, approves budgets, and long-term plans. Discussion included energy efficiency at pump stations and desalination projects. The resolution was reported out for adoption. - Informational Briefing on Food Insecurity: The committee received presentations from Daniela Spoto (Deputy Director, Hawaii Appleseed), Genevieve Muma (Food Equity Policy Analyst, Hawaii Appleseed), and Maui County Councilmember Gabe Johnson. Key data from the 2025 statewide survey: 25% of Oahu households (247,000 individuals) are food insecure, with 21% experiencing very low food security (skipping meals). Filipino households have the highest rate (47%), followed by Hispanic (41%) and Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander (36%). Food insecurity among households with children rose to 34%. The Hawaii Food Bank reported providing 17.5 million meals on Oahu in the past year, with demand nearing pandemic levels. Councilmember Johnson presented Maui County initiatives: a Lanai food voucher program ($70,000), a local food purchasing incentive ($1 million), and a $12 million ALICE initiative via Maui United Way. He also discussed incorporating food security goals into the countywide policy plan. Councilmembers discussed the need for targeted interventions, the link between housing and food insecurity, and the potential to reimagine the city's People's Open Market program. Key Outcomes - Resolution 25315: Reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25289: Amended to CD1 and reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25296: Reported out for adoption. - Informational Briefing: Received and noted. The committee will continue discussions on food security issues in future meetings.

The Budget Committee of the Honolulu City Council met on Tuesday, November 18, 2025, at 9:05 AM. Vice Chair Nishimoto, Councilmember Kia Aina, and Council Chair Waters were present. Council Member Talbot was excused. The meeting proceeded despite potential audiovisual issues. No public testimony was offered on any agenda item. Discussion Items - Resolution 25-283 (Appointment of Jody Libid to Board of Review 1 for real property tax appeals): A hand-carried CD1 (OCS 2025-0906) was introduced by the Chair to correct the date of the mayor's letter (from September 19 to September 30, 2025), identify it as Mayor's Message 147 2025, update statutory references from ROH 1990 to ROH 2021, and make technical amendments. The nominee expressed support for fairness and transparency in taxation. No questions from members. The resolution was amended to CD1 and reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25-297 (Reappointment of Edmund KB Hyun to the Liquor Commission): A CD1 was introduced to attach an updated voter certificate. No questions for the nominee. The resolution was amended to CD1 and reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25-302 (Transfer of up to $150,000 from general fund for automated executive program and budget book system): No amendments. Reported out for adoption. - Bill 55 (2025) (Establishing fees for the multifamily rental housing program): A CD1 (OCS 2025-0833) was proposed. Director Kevin Ager (Department of Housing and Land Management) stated the administration was fine with the CD1 but did not see necessity for a certain provision (likely related to complications). Councilmember Kia Aina asked for elaboration on the provision and noted that BFS had concerns; the Chair acknowledged the concern. The bill was amended to CD1 and reported for second reading and public hearing. - Bill 63 (2025) (Addressing dedication of property for affordable long-term residential rental use): The committee had previously approved a CD1 at the October 14 meeting. Director Andy Kawano (BFS) answered questions from Councilmember Kia Aina about the effect of increasing the Area Median Income (AMI) cap from 80% to 100%. Councilmember Kia Aina proposed a verbal amendment to change “shall adopt rules” to “may adopt rules” at the request of BFS. She explained the bill incentivizes property owners to offer affordable long-term rentals at 100% AMI by taxing at the lower residential rate. The bill was amended to CD1 with the verbal amendment and reported for second reading and public hearing. - Bill 64 (2025) (Requiring the mayor to submit a report on appropriations at the same time as budget documents): Chair Waters introduced a hand-carried CD1 as an alternative but preferred the original bill. Director Kawano reiterated BFS's opposition to the original bill and had not yet reviewed the CD1. No testimony. The original bill was reported out for passage on third reading. - Bill 65 (2025) (subject not specified in transcript): Director Kawano restated BFS's opposition in writing, noting no changes from the current form. The bill was reported out for passage on third reading. Key Outcomes - All seven measures were advanced. Resolutions 25-283 and 25-297 were amended via CD1 and reported for adoption. Resolution 25-302 was reported for adoption without amendment. Bills 55 and 63 were amended to CD1 and reported for second reading and public hearing. Bills 64 and 65 were reported for passage on third reading without amendment (Bill 64 as introduced, Bill 65 as CD1).

The Honolulu City Council convened on November 5, 2025, at 10:00 AM for a full meeting that included a message of aloha, appointment confirmations, first reading of bills, committee reports, and a major debate on a resolution regarding a conditional use permit for a proposed gondola project on Mount Ka'ala. The meeting, conducted as a remote interactive conference, lasted into the afternoon with extensive public testimony on several items. Opening & Message of Aloha - Councilmember Cordero introduced Ashley Loa, who delivered a message of aloha centered on commitment, compassion, and community. - A moment of silence was observed for Maui County Council Member Tasha Kama. - Roll call: 9 members present (Cordero, Dos Santos Tam, Kia Aina, Nishimoto, Okimoto, Talba, Tupola, Wire, and Chair Waters). Appointments & Confirmations - Resolution 25-283 (Jody Libed to Board of Review for Real Property Tax Appeals) – Referred to Budget Committee. - Resolution 25-289 (Bradley Romain to Climate Change Commission) – Referred to Energy, Environment, and Sustainability Committee. - Resolution 25-290 (Blake Lee Parsons to Police Commission) – Referred to Public Safety Committee. Public testimony in support from Shelby Pikachu Billionaire. - Resolution 25-292 (Anna Nubar to Citizens Advisory Commission on Emergency Management) – Referred to Public Safety and Economy Committee. - Resolution 25-293 (Shelton Jim On to Ethics Commission) – Referred to International and Legal Affairs Committee. - Resolution 25-294 (Mark Anthony Clemente to Planning Commission) – Referred to Zoning and Planning Committee. Public testimony in support. - Resolution 25-295 (Catherine Chang to Board of Parks and Recreation) – Referred to Housing, Homelessness, and Parks Committee. - Resolution 25-296 (Jeffrey Laopola to Board of Water Supply) – Referred to Energy, Environment, and Sustainability Committee. Manager and Chief Engineer Ernie Lau testified in support. - Resolution 25-297 (Edmund K.B. Hyun to Liquor Commission) – Referred to Budget Committee. - Resolution 25-298 (Carla Hauser to Board of Parks and Recreation) – Referred to Housing, Homelessness, and Parks Committee. Public testimony in opposition from Kalei and Austin Salcido, citing concerns about conflict of interest and a youth facility project. Councilmember Tupola spoke in support of Hauser, noting her volunteer work and the separation of the issue from her board role. First Reading Bills (Pages 9-11) - Bill 67 (Real Property Taxation) – Public testimony in support and opposition; some testifiers requested tax relief for kupuna and locals. - Bill 68 (Real Property Taxation) – No testimony. - Bill 69 (Parks and Playgrounds – Dog Parks) – No testimony. - Bill 70 (Parks and Playgrounds) – Councilmember Tupola explained it allows park dedications for dog parks. Councilmember Cordero noted it had gone through the planning commission. - Bill 71 (Shared Streets) – No testimony. - Bill 72 (Affordable Rental Housing) – Councilmember Kia Aina expressed concerns about removing restrictions; Councilmember Dos Santos Tam noted it came from the Bill 7 working group. - Bill 73 (Transportation) – Councilmember Kia Aina opposed allowing bicycles on sidewalks outside business districts; Councilmember Dos Santos Tam clarified it is a cleanup bill to define prohibited areas. Councilmember Tupola suggested revisiting code for rural areas. - All first reading bills passed with reservations noted from multiple members. Committee Reports – Second and Third Reading - CR 338 / Bill 64 (Appropriations) – Passed second reading on a roll call vote of 8 ayes, 1 no (Councilmember Wire opposed, citing concerns about creating additional work for BFS; Director Andy Kawano testified in opposition). - CR 339 / Bill 65 CD1 (Budget Execution) – Passed second reading on a roll call vote of 8 ayes, 1 no (Councilmember Wire opposed; Director Kawano opposed the bill as duplicative). - CR 347 / Bill 48 (Pedestrian Malls in Downtown Honolulu) – Passed second reading 9-0. - CR 336 / Bill 59 CD1 (Sewer Service Charges) – Passed third reading 8-0 (one absent). Director Roger Babcock explained it cleans up language related to high-strength waste charges, not affecting residential rates. - CR 337 / Bill 61 CD1 (Real Property Taxation) – Passed third reading 8-0. - CR 348 / Bill 62 CD1 (Bed and Breakfast Homes and TVU Standards) – Passed third reading 8-0. Public testimony requested a carve-out for resident hosts and objected to the 90-day minimum. - CR 357 / Bill 5 CD2 (Animal Recovery) – Passed third reading 8-0. Councilmember Tupola praised the transition to a procurement-based RFP process. - CR 340 / Resolution 25-262 (Fair Box Recovery Ratio for Bus System) – Adopted. - CR 341 / Resolution 25-284 (Collective Bargaining for Police Officers) – Adopted. Public testimony in support. - CR 342 / Resolution 25-285 (Transfer of Funds) – Adopted. - CR 343 / Resolution 25-287 CD1 (Transfer of Funds for DPR MSS) – Adopted. Councilmember Cordero asked about the use of funds; Deputy Director responded it is for court resurfacing and other projects. - CR 344 / Resolution 25-291 (Additional Funds for Special Counsel) – Adopted. - CR 349 / Resolution 25-253 CD1 (SMA Major Permit – Haleiwa) – Adopted 9-0. Councilmember Wire had reservations. - CR 350 / Resolution 25-254 CD1 (SMA Major Permit – Haleiwa) – Adopted 9-0. - CR 351 / Resolution 25-260 CD1 (SMA Major Permit – Waialae Kahala) – Adopted 9-0. - CR 352 / Resolution 25-261 CD1 (Extension for Pupukea Commercial Center) – Adopted. Public testimony in support from Denise Antellini of Safe Sharks Cove Coalition. - CR 353 / Resolution 25-269 CD1 (SMA Major Permit – Hawaii Kai Bank) – Adopted 9-0. - CR 354 / Resolution 25-288 (Affordable Housing Requirements for Sky Ala Moana) – Adopted. Councilmember Tupola explained it allows renting unsold units at 80% AMI to prevent displacement. - CR 355 / Resolution 25-257 CD1 (Video Monitoring for Honolulu Marathon) – Adopted. - CR 356 / Resolution 25-286 (Gift of Thanksgiving Meals for Firefighters) – Adopted. Public testimony in support. - Balance of Committee Reports (CR 345 and 346 – lawsuit settlements) – Adopted on a roll call vote of 8 ayes, 1 no (Councilmember Cordero voted no). Councilmember Kia Aina had reservations on CR 345, stating that individuals who do not respect Hawaii's culture should reconsider living here. New Business - Resolution 25-282 (Amendment to FTA/FHWA Candidate Projects List) – Adopted. - Resolution 25-300 (Gift for Councilmember Dos Santos Tam to attend NACo Opioid Solutions Event) – Adopted. - Resolution 25-304 (Gift for Councilmember Dos Santos Tam to attend Abundant Leadership Fellowship) – Adopted. Major Discussion: Resolution 25-305 (Kamana Nui Conditional Use Permit) - Motion to amend (FD1 correcting a typo) passed. - Public testimony was extensive, with over 30 speakers (in-person and remote) overwhelmingly supporting the resolution and opposing the gondola project. Testifiers included community members, farmers, Native Hawaiian leaders, and representatives from neighborhood boards. Key points: the project is not agricultural but a commercial tourism venture; safety concerns near Schofield Barracks (unexploded ordnance, shrapnel); failure to meet original CUP conditions (tree planting, cattle grazing, crop cultivation); lack of community engagement; cultural and historical significance of Mount Ka'ala; and opposition from the U.S. Army Garrison, the Office of Hawaiian Affairs, and Kokua Hawaii Foundation. The developer's representative did not testify. The public submitted 2,258 testimonies in support, 30 opposed, and 7 comments. - Council discussion: Councilmembers Wire, Kia Aina, Tupola, and Chair Waters spoke in support, emphasizing the resolution's request that the Director of Planning and Permitting (DPP) revoke the CUP or deny modifications. Director Donna Puna confirmed that DPP is aware of the opposition and will review all information, including the original permit conditions, and expects to make a decision within November 2025. Chair Waters questioned DPP about the applicant's failure to meet conditions (e.g., planting 20 acres of trees per year since 2019) and the director's authority to void the permit. Councilmember Tupola noted that the resolution cites the Pa'akai v. Land Use Commission framework requiring protection of cultural resources. - Outcome: Resolution 25-305 FD1 was adopted unanimously (no objections). The council urged DPP to revoke the CUP or deny modifications, and Chair Waters indicated he would file a petition for revocation if DPP does not act. Other Items - Resolution 25-306 FD1 (Gift of Giant Lantern for Honolulu City Lights) – Adopted after amendment. - Resolution 25-308 (2026 Hawaii State Association of Counties Legislative Package) – Adopted. One public testimony in opposition. Key Outcomes - 9 appointments were referred to committees for further consideration. - 7 bills passed first reading (Bills 67-73). - 13 bills/resolutions passed second or third reading (Bills 48, 59, 61, 62, 5, 64, 65; Resolutions 25-262, 25-284, 25-285, 25-287, 25-291, 25-288, 25-257, 25-286). - 6 special management area permits were approved (Resolutions 25-253, 25-254, 25-260, 25-261, 25-269, 25-288). - Resolution 25-305 was adopted, calling on DPP to revoke or modify the conditional use permit for the Kamana Nui agribusiness/gondola project. - Two lawsuit settlements were authorized (CR 345 and 346), with Councilmember Cordero voting no on both. - Meeting adjourned at approximately 4:30 PM, to reconvene December 3, 2025, at 10:00 AM.

The Honolulu City Council convened on November 5, 2025, to present honorary certificates to individuals and organizations for their contributions to the community. The council recognized six recipients, including environmental stewards, medical pioneers, sports legends, healthcare providers, a veteran, a legal center, and a university. Malama Maunalua – 20th Anniversary - Council Chair Waters presented the first honorary certificate to Malama Maunalua, an organization founded in 2005 dedicated to restoring the health of Maunalua Bay. Over 20 years, the organization has mobilized more than 46,000 volunteers who removed over 4 million pounds of invasive algae. The organization also protects 10 watersheds and helped establish Maunalua Bay as a fisheries management area in 2025. Representatives including Executive Director Doug Harper and others were present. Shirley Date and Catherine Nakakura – 50th Anniversary of Kidney Transplant - Councilmembers Cordero and Nishimoto recognized sisters Shirley Date and Catherine Nakakura for the 50th anniversary of a successful kidney transplant performed in 1975 at St. Francis Medical Center. Shirley faced kidney failure in 1973 while stationed in Colorado Springs. Catherine was found to be a perfect donor match. The transplant was expected to provide six years of life but has now lasted five decades, making them one of the oldest living transplant donor pairs in Hawaii. Councilmember Nishimoto noted that Shirley is the grandmother of his chief of staff, Taylor Date. Mike Lum – 80th Birthday - Councilmember Nishimoto honored Mr. Mike Lum on his 80th birthday. Born in Honolulu and a graduate of Roosevelt High School, Lum made his MLB debut in 1967 with the Atlanta Braves. He played 15 seasons, appeared in over 1,500 games, hit 90 home runs, and won the World Series with the Cincinnati Reds in 1976 and as a hitting coach with the Chicago White Sox. He also played in Japan. Lum was the first American of Japanese descent to play in the major leagues and was inducted into the Hawaii Sports Hall of Fame in 2021. Hawaii Pacific Health Straub Benioff Medical Center – Mililani Clinic Grand Opening - A councilmember (likely from the district) introduced the Hawaii Pacific Health team, celebrating the August 26, 2025 grand opening of the new Mililani clinic. The clinic is approximately 24,000 square feet with 55 exam rooms, the largest Straub Benioff neighborhood clinic in the islands. It provides a wide range of medical resources to central Oahu. The council recognized the clinic's personnel for their compassionate care and commitment to healthier communities. Seejun Park – Lifelong Service to Country and Community - Councilmember Wire honored Mr. Seejun Park, who joined remotely. Park served in the U.S. military and later worked as a tour guide and car dealer. He cared for elderly relatives and raised two children on his own. Due to immigration enforcement policies, he self-deported to South Korea but continues to work toward reuniting with his family and returning to Hawaii. The council recognized his service and courage. Kahuliau Center for Excellence in Native Hawaiian Law – 20th Anniversary - Councilmember Kia Aina recognized the Kahuliau Center at the William S. Richardson School of Law. The center promotes education, scholarship, and community advocacy on Native Hawaiian, Pacific Islander, and Indigenous issues. It produces the only published treatise on Native Hawaiian law and provides legal primers. The council congratulated the center on its 20th anniversary and its commitment to education and justice. Hawaii Pacific University – 60th Anniversary - Councilmember Dos Santos TAM, joining remotely, presented the final honorary certificate to Hawaii Pacific University (HPU) on its 60th anniversary. Founded in 1965 by four community visionaries, HPU has grown to nearly 8,000 students from all 50 states and over 50 nations. It evolved from Hawaii Pacific College to Hawaii Pacific University in 1990. Notable achievements include the Oceanic Institute, a partnership for a Mandarin MBA, and a new graduate health science facility in Las Vegas. Enrollment has increased over 50% in six years, and graduate studies have expanded nearly fourfold. The council celebrated HPU's milestone and academic innovation. Key Outcomes - The council adopted honorary certificates for all six recipients with unanimous support. No formal votes were recorded, but each presentation was accepted by the council.